3 ms·

I don't know about Ireland, but in the US the home ownership rate is higher than it was at any point in the 20th century. So however bad the situation is it doe

I don't know about Ireland, but in the US the home ownership rate is higher than it was at any point in the 20th century. So however bad the situation is it doesn't seem to actually prevent people from buying a house.

b112 4y ago
In the 90s, I didn't know anyone in their 20s, who didn't have a roommate(or two!), or were married. No one I knew, could afford an entire apartment to themselves! I find it weird that people complain about not being able to rent their own entire apartment, but are in their 20s. It wasn't a thing 30 years ago! As one advances in their career, eg in their 30s, then income tends to rise, due to experience, and better paying jobs. San Fran is an outlier here. Literally the most expensive area on the planet, with loads of money floating around. Of course rent is crazy expensive.
- bandrami 4y ago
  Anecdote is always dangerous, but 100% same here; I had housemates in the 1990s and this was entirely normal in the city I was in (DC). Come to think of it the only time before I got married I lived alone was when I rented a friend's basement for a couple of years basically as a favor to him.
- Aeolun 4y ago
  In the 90s I didn’t have a house, I was in diapers. In my experience growing up, everyone I knew could afford to buy a house on a single salary when 28-30, so that’s what I expect for myself. Anything other than that is a regression.
  - b112 4y ago
    So, you're saying that when interest rates first dropped mega-low, people could afford a house? But... that's what caused the current problem, some say. Rates too low, for a decade, causing a housing bubble. It sounds to me like what you recall, was an aberration. EDIT: Don't get me wrong. I think the bar to home ownership should be lower. But at the same time, I think it hasn't been low, for 50+ years.
    - bandrami 4y ago
      People forget about the old interest rates. I have a credit card with a lower rate than my parents' mortgage back in the 80s.
    - Aeolun 4y ago
      In 1995, the average income in the Netherlands was €33000, and an average house (not any house, anecdotally my parents bought it for less) could be bought for €93750 at an interest rate of 7.71%. 3 times annual salary seems reasonsble to me.
  - bandrami 4y ago
    > everyone I knew could afford to buy a house on a single salary when 28-30 Did you grow up in 1958? Because that's the last time that was true.
    - robocat 4y ago
      Depends on where they were. For example #15: Clarksville, Tennessee: Median home value: $172,700, Median household income: $58,853 https://www.businessinsider.com/best-places-to-buy-a-home-united-states-affordable-2023-3#15-clarksville-tennessee-1 https://www.businessinsider.com/best-places-to-buy-a-home-un...
      - bandrami 4y ago
        Meaning median individual income is ~$29K, which is not enough to afford a $172K house on one salary.
- jnwatson 4y ago
  When I graduated as a software engineer in 1998 making $45k, I could have easily bought a house in the DFW area.
  - satvikpendem 4y ago
    There are parts of the US where houses are similarly cheap even today, problem is, no one wants to live there. People want to simultaneously live in very popular cities but also not want to pay a high rent. Both can't be true at once. ...Or can it? The solution then is to build more housing; YIMBYism, go to local government meetings and vote for YIMBYist candidates. After all, all of the NIMBY people who bought their house decades ago are there, day after day. There really is no way around this.
- matwood 4y ago
  Yeah, late 90s/00s I was an exception that I had my own apartment. All my friends had roommates. A couple really industrious ones bought a house and then had 2-3 roommates so they could afford it.
lambic2 4y ago
right but I'm guessing a huge percentage is baby boomers or Gen X'ers who bought a house 10 or more years ago. I'm curious to see a graph of home ownership rate history for people between 25 and 39 years old, I'm guessing it is lower now than 30 years ago.
- bandrami 4y ago
  A majority of millennials are homeowners. It's maybe two or three points behind where the boomers were at their age.
  - capableweb 4y ago
    The only numbers I could find about this disagree with you: > Just 47.9% of U.S. millennials owned homes in 2020, according to Apartment List analysis of census data. At age 30, millennial home ownership hit 42%, compared with 48% for Gen Xers and 51% for baby boomers. https://archive.is/P5EKj#selection-3963.136-3971.67 https://archive.is/P5EKj#selection-3963.136-3971.67 - Bloomberg: Don’t Blame Avocado Toast. Here’s Why Millennials Don’t Own Homes Maybe you have access to more recent numbers that show that the majority of millennials are homeowners?
- disgruntledphd2 4y ago
  It's like 20 points lower for Irish millennials vs gen X re home ownership rates.

b112 4y ago

In the 90s, I didn't know anyone in their 20s, who didn't have a roommate(or two!), or were married. No one I knew, could afford an entire apartment to themselves! I find it weird that people complain about not being able to rent their own entire apartment, but are in their 20s. It wasn't a thing 30 years ago! As one advances in their career, eg in their 30s, then income tends to rise, due to experience, and better paying jobs. San Fran is an outlier here. Literally the most expensive area on the planet, with loads of money floating around. Of course rent is crazy expensive.

bandrami 4y ago
Anecdote is always dangerous, but 100% same here; I had housemates in the 1990s and this was entirely normal in the city I was in (DC). Come to think of it the only time before I got married I lived alone was when I rented a friend's basement for a couple of years basically as a favor to him.
Aeolun 4y ago
In the 90s I didn’t have a house, I was in diapers. In my experience growing up, everyone I knew could afford to buy a house on a single salary when 28-30, so that’s what I expect for myself. Anything other than that is a regression.
- b112 4y ago
  So, you're saying that when interest rates first dropped mega-low, people could afford a house? But... that's what caused the current problem, some say. Rates too low, for a decade, causing a housing bubble. It sounds to me like what you recall, was an aberration. EDIT: Don't get me wrong. I think the bar to home ownership should be lower. But at the same time, I think it hasn't been low, for 50+ years.
  - bandrami 4y ago
    People forget about the old interest rates. I have a credit card with a lower rate than my parents' mortgage back in the 80s.
  - Aeolun 4y ago
    In 1995, the average income in the Netherlands was €33000, and an average house (not any house, anecdotally my parents bought it for less) could be bought for €93750 at an interest rate of 7.71%. 3 times annual salary seems reasonsble to me.
- bandrami 4y ago
  > everyone I knew could afford to buy a house on a single salary when 28-30 Did you grow up in 1958? Because that's the last time that was true.
  - robocat 4y ago
    Depends on where they were. For example #15: Clarksville, Tennessee: Median home value: $172,700, Median household income: $58,853 https://www.businessinsider.com/best-places-to-buy-a-home-united-states-affordable-2023-3#15-clarksville-tennessee-1 https://www.businessinsider.com/best-places-to-buy-a-home-un...
    - bandrami 4y ago
      Meaning median individual income is ~$29K, which is not enough to afford a $172K house on one salary.
jnwatson 4y ago
When I graduated as a software engineer in 1998 making $45k, I could have easily bought a house in the DFW area.
- satvikpendem 4y ago
  There are parts of the US where houses are similarly cheap even today, problem is, no one wants to live there. People want to simultaneously live in very popular cities but also not want to pay a high rent. Both can't be true at once. ...Or can it? The solution then is to build more housing; YIMBYism, go to local government meetings and vote for YIMBYist candidates. After all, all of the NIMBY people who bought their house decades ago are there, day after day. There really is no way around this.
matwood 4y ago
Yeah, late 90s/00s I was an exception that I had my own apartment. All my friends had roommates. A couple really industrious ones bought a house and then had 2-3 roommates so they could afford it.

lambic2 4y ago

right but I'm guessing a huge percentage is baby boomers or Gen X'ers who bought a house 10 or more years ago. I'm curious to see a graph of home ownership rate history for people between 25 and 39 years old, I'm guessing it is lower now than 30 years ago.

bandrami 4y ago
A majority of millennials are homeowners. It's maybe two or three points behind where the boomers were at their age.
- capableweb 4y ago
  The only numbers I could find about this disagree with you: > Just 47.9% of U.S. millennials owned homes in 2020, according to Apartment List analysis of census data. At age 30, millennial home ownership hit 42%, compared with 48% for Gen Xers and 51% for baby boomers. https://archive.is/P5EKj#selection-3963.136-3971.67 https://archive.is/P5EKj#selection-3963.136-3971.67 - Bloomberg: Don’t Blame Avocado Toast. Here’s Why Millennials Don’t Own Homes Maybe you have access to more recent numbers that show that the majority of millennials are homeowners?
disgruntledphd2 4y ago
It's like 20 points lower for Irish millennials vs gen X re home ownership rates.