11 ms·
Heat pump sales outpaced gas furnace sales in the US in 2022
- davidw 4y agoI have been asking about this locally, here in Oregon, and it seems that in the US we're likely to get some financial incentives. But nothing seems sure yet. Anyone here happen to know anything?
- mkozlows 4y agoThere are incentives in the IRA, but (except for ground-source, which is a straight up 30% uncapped tax rebate), they're limited by income and capped to certain dollar amounts.
- ben7799 4y agoWe have had them here in Massachusetts for a while. $10,000-15,000 rebate depending on what the house requires.
- jdeibele 4y agohttps://www.energytrust.org/residential/incentives/furnace-and-heat-pump https://www.energytrust.org/residential/incentives/furnace-a... Some of the incentives may be limited if you have too much income. I was able to get the latest Ecobee thermostat for $90 instead of the list price of $250. Fortunately or unfortunately, I started reading about how 3rd party thermostats can't talk to multi-stage furnaces or air handlers except in very blunt increments. Maybe as blunt as on or off. Each manufacturer has their own, undocumented protocol for doing fine adjustments. I tried running the fan all the time (now I do 10 minutes every hour) and it was quite expensive for that month. Anyway, I'm hesitating about putting in the nice Ecobee thermostat because it could conceivably cost quite a bit more in electricity.
- rainsford 4y agoOregon seems like a perfect use-case for heat pumps. It has a lot of renewable energy and relatively mild winter temperatures (at least near the coast where most of the people live), two things that make heat pumps a lot greener of a solution than natural gas heating.
- MrFoof 4y agoIn 2008 I moved into my first apartment with a proper air-to-water heat pump. Granted, the place clearly also had a smart architect, and was built to very high efficiency standards (was rated LEED Platinum). It was installed in a small void between a living room and the bedroom, adjoining an exterior wall. Had an access panel. You’d only barely hear it initially start up. Because of its location, the total length of the ventilation ducting was maybe 1.5m, so air didn’t really change temp before it was delivered to its destination. Nowadays I rent a floor in an old Victorian home converted into a duplex, still running a boiler (single loop for both floors) going to radiators and convectors. Real noise from the basement from the pump, banging of pipes, and the air quality monitors clearly show VOCs rising — sometimes to really crazy levels (250+, sometimes 400-600!) if upstairs cranked the heat to hell and back. Where I live now has mediocre insulation at best, and an uninsulated three-seasons room on the 2nd floor that might as well just be open to the outside air. In 2017 when I left, my electric bill was only about $45/mo (1BR, all electric appliances, though elec was half the price back then), and that included in-line water heating (with 3gal tanks for the bath and kitchen). Meanwhile, my landlord currently pays about $7000/year in fuel oil to heat this duplex and its water. Granted, it’s far from an apples-to-apples comparison as where I lived for ~9 years was ultra-modern construction with no corners cut, and I didn’t share heat/hot water with neighbors that have a far more demanding “standard of comfort”. If only I lived here, might only be $2000/year since my standard of comfort is a lot lower than upstairs, but it really shows the difference that construction, insulation, maintenance, HVAC system choices, and just lowering your standards a bit makes. House across the street just sold. Had vents and forced air, but still a boiler. New residents haven’t moved in yet, but they IMMEDIATELY removed a fairly new boiler, plus the 375 gallon fuel tank. Putting in a heat pumps and a hybrid water heater. Don’t blame them for both the long-term savings, plus reclaiming floor space in the basement.
- kibwen 4y agoYes, the question of furnace vs. heat pump should always be deferred until after your insulation is up to snuff.
- Overtonwindow 4y agoSomething that readers may not know is that they are now heat pumps on hot water heaters. An added benefit is that the fan on the heat pump will exhaust cold air. That might be a benefit for some folks!
- nimajneb 4y agoCan you clarify what you mean? There's only ~2 fans in my system, the one on the heat pump outside (looks like an AC unit) and the one in the air handler in the basement. To me sitting in my dining room this system is no different than any other forced air system.
- ars 4y agoThe air for a hot water heat pump could be entirely indoor air, the entire unit is located inside. Unlike an A/C which is split, with the compressor located outside.
- mikeyouse 4y agoHe's saying that instead of a gas or electric hot water heater - you can now buy a heatpump version. It works the same as a normal heat pump, but it takes ambient air in your basement or garage or wherever, and then moves that heat into the water which provides a slight cooling and dehumidifying effect for your indoor climate. They make a lot of sense in the US South. https://www.energy.gov/energysaver/heat-pump-water-heaters https://www.energy.gov/energysaver/heat-pump-water-heaters
- bombcar 4y agoTo be precise the heat pump water heaters are electric - they just use latent heat in the air around them as much as they can, but they'll fall back to electric when that isn't enough. They also cease working when the power is off, of course.
- ars 4y agoThey exist, but are really only good in the southern part of the US. In the north the incoming water is cold which really slows down the hot water creation (recovery) rate, and that cold exhaust then needs to be warmed up by the heat. If you have low usage (i.e. less than 40 gallon/day of hot water) you could get away with it, but that's two showers - so if your usage is more than 2 showers per day I would avoid them. But in the south they are a much better choice, since the recovery rate is much better and the cold air helps with A/C.
- supernova87a 4y agoI don't know if anyone else is following this as an issue, and maybe in the grand scheme of our housing "demographics" it's a small thing. But if you live in a medium or large sized condo or apartment building, it is extremely hard to get legacy systems like gas furnaces or hot water boilers replaced by a new technology like this. Not because of lack of desire, but because it involves incredible amounts of: -- legal questions on whether you're allowed to do such things as an entity (will the owners agree to do it) -- who will pay for the new costs of the thing itself, as well as the ongoing maintenance, any changes to insurance costs, etc. (how will current people who have to pay shoulder the costs of future benefits) -- (sometimes) how to divide up or give up space from existing ownership stakes to fit the new hardware into what was never expected to be modified in the building ever again -- electrical, plumbing, power, heat, requirements that may change the performance or costs of your building (how will you swap a 300 pound furnace with 1200 pounds of condenser units and not have the roof collapse?) Technical feasibility not matching the policy goals. And then on top of this all, the local city wants their say to block or make it very expensive for you to do all this. (yet at the same time their city councils are charging forward in requiring the phase out of natural gas while not fully understanding the inability or cost to real people of not having the ability to affordably implement those mandates) For some kinds of buildings, this is a very big problem stopping people from being able to change things. There needs to be some enabling legislation to cut out these roadblocks, or somehow make things easier. Contractors know this so well they apply probably a 10x discount factor in the number of calls they receive to the number of projects that actually proceed to being started. Single family / single owner homes have a much easier time just getting it done. And new build. It can be really very difficult to displace existing technology, for very real and legitimate reasons.
- rcme 4y agoHeat pumps have the same footprint as, and can replace, AC condensers. So if you already have central air, you should be able to retrofit a heat pump. You might need a new air handler, however.
- supernova87a 4y ago
- lnsru 4y ago[flagged]
- favsq 4y ago[flagged]
- throwway120385 4y agoI wouldn't go so far as to call it green fascism, but where I live right now we have to fire up our generators regularly and sometimes the power will go out for several days during winter storms. So forcing us to switch to electricity is risking the lives of some of my neighbors because it's not a reliable source of heat for us. If we're going to be required to do this, they should require the public utility to maintain the lines to the degree that they can survive the frequent windstorms and snowstorms that happen here.
- lnsru 4y agoIt would be ok having sane timeline for heat pumps conversion for coming decade. But now it’s fascism just telling, that no gas furnaces anymore starting next year. There is no plan, there is no strategy. Just pure ideological nonsense. Close nuclear power plants, ban gas furnaces. Bun coal and run heat pumps on coal power. Great plan! Edit: and yeah, I just lost €100k tonight. That’s rough sum for house insulation, ventilation system and heat pump installation.
- mikeyouse 4y agoThere are plenty of supplemental heat heat-pumps that have a gas burner for very cold days or extended power outages.
- throwway120385 4y agoBut they will no longer be up to code as of this year.
- mrguyorama 4y agoWhat systems don't need electricity? Growing up, my oil fired furnace still needed electricity to spark it and pump it. Blowers don't run on oil. If you live in a place that gets cold, you should probably have enough insulation that occasional power loss isn't life threatening. In fact, we once lost power all of christmas morning, before we had even turned up the heat for the day. We snuggled in a bed for a while. Just keep blankets and jackets around. The human body produces about 100w of heat at rest. Usually food and water become bigger problems first.
- jmcphers 4y agoI very nearly bought a heat pump for my house to replace (or augment) my natural gas furnace, but was dissuaded by the salesperson. He who pointed out that, while heat pumps are miracles of efficiency, the electricity in my area is primarily generated by burning fossil fuels such as coal and natural gas. Due to transmission losses, it is cheaper, efficient, and greener to combust natural gas for warmth directly than to burn it at a power plant, feed the power into the grid, and use grid power to run a heat pump. Of course, running a heat pump allows you to take advantage of greener power sources when they become available, but his claim was that in a lot of places they don't really benefit the environment right now. Anyone have any numbers to back this up or refute it?
- dzhiurgis 4y agoI would just use heat pump for convenience alone. Not having monoxide and NOx risks around the house is another one.
- cjrp 4y ago> Due to transmission losses, it is cheaper, efficient, and greener to combust natural gas for warmth directly than to burn it at a power plant, feed the power into the grid, and use grid power to run a heat pump. That would certainly be true for a classic electric (element) heater, but I thought the point of heat pumps was that they’re not generating heat just… pumping it.
- benj111 4y agoI'm not convinced either a heat pump has a cop of ~4. A thermal power plant is ~50% efficient and transmission isn't losing 50% of the energy. This also ignores any greening of the grid, present and future. And the fact that a furnace/boiler isn't 100% efficient.
- groestl 4y ago> A thermal power plant is ~50% efficient For electricity alone, I'd want to add. With heat coupling and district heating, thermal power plants can reach ~90% efficiency.
- randito 4y agoLot of discussion here => Heat pumps of the 1800s are becoming the technology of the future. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34397715 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34397715
- avodonosov 4y agoHow significant is Earth cooling speedup due to heat pumps? Is this practice ecological? (I assume they pump the heat from under ground?)
- kibwen 4y agoSome heat pumps use underground pipes (and those units have a great advantage in avoiding the efficiency loss due to extreme temperatures), however they're much more expensive to install, so the vast majority of heat pumps are air-based, same as any traditional air conditioner you've ever used. As for whether ground-based heat pumps would cool the Earth's crust, the answer is no (in any measurable sense). Consider that heat pumps are used for both heating in winter and cooling in summer, so in a temperate climate you're just as likely to put as much heat into the ground (in summertime) as you extract from the ground (in wintertime).
- avodonosov 4y agoThank you
- avodonosov 4y agoThat's an interesting question, whether heating and cooling by humanity are really balanced. People living in cold climates (northern countries and areas) mostly heat. People in hot climates (Africa, India and such) mostly cool.
- TheGigaChad 4y ago[dead]
- the-alchemist 4y agoThere's an amazing video on heat pump from Technology Connections: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7J52mDjZzto https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7J52mDjZzto
- nfriedly 4y agoThat's the right one to start on, but he's posted a few followups with updates and more information: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLv0jwu7G_DFVIot1ubOZdR-KC-LFdOVqi https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLv0jwu7G_DFVIot1ubOZd...
- jandrese 4y agoI recently learned from an NPR piece that only about 13% of US households have a heat pump. This floored me. One because in my mid Atlantic area nearly every house has a heat pump. When house shopping many years ago we never saw a listing that didn't have one. The other is that if you have central air then it seems like you should have a heat pump. You're basically just running the heat pump backwards to provide heat instead of air conditioning, but apparently the vast majority of central air installs are only set up to do cooling? This makes no sense to me. Even if you area gets too cold to be efficiently warmed by a heat pump in the winter you can still use it for several months out of the year and switch to gas only when you need to. It's not like gas is especially cheap.
- imglorp 4y agoMisaligned incentives. A traditional furnace is a bunch of sheet metal, a burner, a fan, and a thermostat and that's it. Sold for thousands, it seems like enormous, criminal markup. Of course they'll keep selling that and price it less than heat pumps, which have an actual complex closed loop coolant system in addition to what a furnace has.
- toomuchtodo 4y agohttps://www.rewiringamerica.org/ira-fact-sheets https://www.rewiringamerica.org/ira-fact-sheets Progress is being made. > The 25C and 25D tax credits incentivize household electrification by lowering the total cost of qualified electrification upgrades. 25C provides a capped 30 percent tax credit for heat pumps, heat pump water heaters (HPWHs), qualifying electrical panel upgrades, select weatherization measures, and energy audits. For the first time, air source heat pumps for space heating/cooling and HPWHs will be eligible for a tax credit of up to $2,000 per year, and electrical panel upgrades installed in conjunction with a heat pump or HPWH will be eligible for a tax credit of up to $600.
- vanilla_nut 4y agoThere are a lot of US households on places like New England and the Midwest where historically very very few houses have central air and most have a furnace running on oil, propane, or natural gas. The upgrade path is hard there: do you accept the multiple thousands of dollars to install a heat pump on top of your existing heating solution? For the couple of fringe months where a heat pump can actually heat your house, and the extra cost of cooling in the summer (money many don't have)? It probably makes a lot of sense to just switch to a heat pump if you live in the south these days and give up any backup heating system entirely. But it is worth noting that only in the past 5 years or so did we finally get heat pumps that didn't totally suck at 0C. Until then, it made sense for even a lot of Southern households to stick with backup furnace + central air, assuming they already sunk money into the backup furnace for the 5 days a year they actually need it.
- surfmike 4y agoIf only someone made a good thermostat for them. Nest and Ecobee integration doesn't work very well since they need to go through a two-stage controller interface.
- rthomas6 4y agoI am using an Ecobee thermostat with a heat pump and it is working, for both heating and cooling. Is it doing something inefficient or wrong? What am I missing out on? Edit: Ecobee says they support heat pumps. https://support.ecobee.com/s/articles/What-types-of-HVAC-systems-are-ecobee-thermostats-compatible-with https://support.ecobee.com/s/articles/What-types-of-HVAC-sys...
- surfmike 4y agoWhich heat pump do you have? I’m on a Mitsubishi which requires a bridge unit which has its issues.
- nfriedly 4y agoI use a Nest thermostat with a 2-stage ground sourced heat pump (a.k.a. geothermal) that also has backup resistive heating. It works perfectly fine. It will run a single stage most of the time, or both stages if it's trying to change the temperature by more than a couple of degrees. I have mine set to treat the resistive heating as emergency backup, but I believe I could also configure it to treat it as a third stage and run it automatically.
- surfmike 4y agoI keep reading that, at least for air source heat pumps, it cuts into a lot of the efficiency advantages if it’s cycling a lot. Better to run at a low stage for a long time as opposed to a higher stage on and off. Maybe I should just try and see what how it works for me though.
- cpncrunch 4y agoComfortnet works pretty well, and I can control it via an app.
- jonatron 4y agoI'm in the UK, and got an air-to-air heat pump (more commonly known as air conditioning). It made sense because of extremely high electricity prices, and I have an insulated house without gas, electric only. There's a lot of houses / flats similar to mine, that could switch from resistive to heat pump heating. Unfortunately, the government are focusing on very expensive retrofitting of air-to-water heat pumps in older uninsulated houses, which doesn't make a lot of sense.
- jansan 4y agoI was not aware until recently that most air conditionings can produce heat really efficiently. For hot water, efficiency is quite low, so using a simple air conditioning for room heating combined with an electric boiler for shower water would achieve a lot at quite reasonable price.
- jonatron 4y agoIt's air to air, so it's for heating air only. I still use resistive heating for hot water.
- kemiller 4y agoI tried to get a heat pump but asinine local regs require five full feet of setback from property line to the edge of the external condenser. I'm not willing to spend $15k upgrading my connection just to get electric resistive heat, so I had to get a new gas furnace instead. Also, why are heat pumps so hideously expensive? I was quoted $35k, not including the electrical upgrades. A plain AC is half that but it's virtually the same mechanical equipment.
- toomuchtodo 4y agoThat price is ridiculous. I just had a combo high efficiency 4 ton heat pump with backup natural gas furnace in an Illinois property for $17k.
- dashundchen 4y agoUnless your house is ridiculously large I think you were given a sky high quote because the contractor didn't want to the job. I paid less that half of that for a full ground source geo heat system a few years ago. Heat pumps are typically more complicated to install and size properly. You can throw an oversized gas furnace in any house for fat profits and no real HVAC design. Contractors that aren't wanting for business can give you ludacris estimates for jobs they're not interested in. If you take it, great, they make a lot of money, if not they can schedule someone else or push you into an easier job for them. I ran into this with a concrete job I needed done recently. The contractors were all booked a year or more out, and were quoting $20k+ for a normal concrete driveway. I found a paver installer who seemed much less busy, was able to do a full paver job for way under the slab pourers!
- 4y ago
- lizknope 4y agoMy unit has both a heat pump and gas furnace. Of course the heat pump is used for cooling in the summer. In the winter the thermostat is set to use the heat pump for heating until it is below 40F. Below that and it switches to natural gas. The company that installed it and maintains it said that was the best crossover point for efficiency and cost. I didn't look at any specific cold weather heat pumps that are still efficient below freezing.
- cpncrunch 4y agoAll heat pumps are generally still efficient at well below freezing, and will have a COP (efficiency) above 1 even at -15C. The problem is that they don't generate a huge amount of heat at those ambient temperatures, so you need a backup source of heat. A heat pump should be able to keep your house at room temperature when the outside temp is around freezing, but it will take a long time to heat up your house if you let the temperature drop overnight. 40F seems unusually high for your aux heat set point, unless you have expensive electricity and cheap gas.
- api 4y agoOur gas furnace has a few years left then we will be getting one. It's kind of a no-brainer.
- ltbarcly3 4y agoIf we could get a mini split installed in every house in the country it would save around 1 trillion dollars of energy costs over the next 20 years. That's just the savings in kwh of electricity, it also means less energy produced, less carbon, less grid capacity needed, less production facilities, etc etc.
- cmrdporcupine 4y agoI tried to get a quote on a heat pump here (Ontario, Canada) last week because the gov't has incentives up to $5000 on them right now. My gas furnace doesn't need replacing (9 years old) but the AC does. So I figured I'd ask them to quote on a hybrid configuration in a way where the furnace could maybe be swapped out later when it hit EOL, and in the meantime just be used for very cold temps. Problems: Gov't incentive only applies to a full replacement, existing gas furnace would have to be ripped out. Seemed wasteful. High pressure sales guy wouldn't give me a straight answer on pricing, or even proper spec sheets, but sounded easily like $25,000 CAD would be about the price for a system. And that was on a "medium range" system. That's gotta be at least 2 times more than a new gas furnace + AC. Maybe 3x. I'm on a rural property, and have the space to do excavation for ground source heatpump, which I suspect would get me an even more efficient system. Sales guy was clueless about them, but it also seems like nobody around here really does them.. still? (My parents have such a system in Alberta, for over 10 years) Also kind of suspect that gov't incentives just get turned into price increases by the suppliers. Unfortunately just very frustrating. I'd love to do the right thing here, but it seems at this point that pricing still favours natural gas heating. At least for renovations/replacements? Guess I'll wait for the furnace to die.
- systemvoltage 4y agoAll this focus about environmentalism and efficiency lately is making me think that we're not even daring to look at the supply side of this equation. We should have basically infinite energy situation figured out by now. The fact that we haven't and we're squirming about how to automatically turn off my garage lights is an indictment of our failure as a society. Power generation technology is stagnated to the point where fusion is only 4 years away for over 40 years now. Wind and Solar keeps the population delusional as they feel proud to wear insulated clothes indoors. Poor and middle class struggles are ignored. But, the virtue signaling Berkeley folks will surely tell you how their $1.3M 900 sq ft home is heated using heat pumps. I feel extreme dissappointment in our inability to engineer things everytime I see a Nike shoe box with greenwashing labels. We should aim a lot higher. Like 1000000x higher and solve the problem of energy once in for all. But, something tells me that we will have protests in the year 2200 for engulfing the last 20% of the sun with a dyson sphere. There will be folks trying to campaign for "Leave the sun alone".
- thraway3837 4y agoCan someone please speak about their experience with the cost of running a heat pump for the same amount of time as a gas furnace or AC? I’m still confused about why a heat pump is so much more efficient, since the only change from a typical AC and compressor setup is the two-way valve that allows the system to reverse and a different refrigerant. Would it still not use the same power hungry compressors as before? I always thought the most expensive part of running an AC was the compressor. In terms of Gas, does it actually run cheaper than the per-therm Gas costs?
- datatrashfire 4y agoIt's not that it's more energy efficient than AC per se, just that running it in reverse to move heat into your house is much more energy efficient than using electricity to generate heat compared to electric resistance heat. Relative to gas, it's going to be competitive when the ambient outdoor temperature is > 40 degree Fahrenheit, but probably more expensive depending on utility rates where you live.
- thraway3837 4y agoIf I rephrase what you said to make sure I understand it correctly: Cooling costs would be the same as AC units and heating would be cheaper or same depending on the cost of Gas. Would that be correct?
- Schroedingersat 4y agoGenerally. Depends a bit on climate, choice of heat pump, and relative energy costs. A ground loop can make cooling cheaper too, as can upgrading to newer more efficient compressors.
- thraway3837 4y agoThank you! Also sounds like heat pumps come with multi or infinite stages akin to a CVT to be able to run at any speed for the heating or cooling demands. Rather than legacy units that are only On or Off. Down in the comments, sounds like MA has good incentives, but not seeing other states. CA is banning new gas installations, so I assume heat pumps are the only way for new developments
- mylittlebrain 4y agoI wonder if a dual-fuel system can optimize the use of heat-pumps and gas heating. Could a control system also use the current price of each fuel to determine the mixture. https://www.goodmanmfg.com/resources/hvac-learning-center/hvac-101/precise-energy-efficient-heating-with-dual-fuel-technology https://www.goodmanmfg.com/resources/hvac-learning-center/hv...
- dukeofdoom 4y agoForced air Furnaces cause health issues when the filter isn't changed very often, or there is dust in the ducts. Best form of heating is under floor radiant heating.
- rgmerk 4y agoUnderfloor heating is awesome but it’s also very expensive, particularly if you’re also in a climate that also needs cooling.
- medion 4y agoI wish the mini DIY heat pump was more widely adopted by manufacturers! Mitsubishi and Mrcool make split systems that do not require installers. Having to hire trades to gas them etc is such a pain - small rooms, once you add up the unit and install cost, you may as well just buy a $60 heater off Amazon and swallow the poor efficiency.
- xupybd 4y agoWith American electric prices maybe but here in NZ the installation pays for itself quickly.
- seattle_spring 4y agoSo has any wackadoodle chimed in here yet to claim this is the result of "the woke/radical left" coming to take their God-given gas furnace away, similar to their claims about gas stoves[1]? [1] https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2023/jan/11/republicans-culture-war-gas-stoves-biden-administration https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2023/jan/11/republicans-...
- iancmceachern 4y agoI think this probably has a lot to do with the general trend to go electric. We used to have gas ranges, gas clothes dryers, I think hvac is no different now that split units and heat pumps are getting better, easier to install and cheaper