7 ms·
Managers exploit loyal workers over less committed colleagues
- quantified 4y ago> Company loyalty is a double-edged sword, according to a new study. I'm not sure what the second edge is? When is loyalty meaningfully rewarded?
- suoduandao2 4y agowhen it's layoff season.
- toomuchtodo 4y agoHow’d that work at Google? Loyalty is zero guarantee of safety during any sort of reduction in force. You’re just a line in a spreadsheet. Also, you can have the best working relationship with your manager and if they don’t have enough juice, you’re still out. Tips: Robust emergency fund, keep your network warm, work enough to keep your employer reasonably happy, show up every day like it might be your last. (technologist for 22 years)
- gruez 4y agoLoyalty isn't rewarded per se, but someone who is committed to their work/team/company is going to be lower on the layoffs list than someone who's doing rest and vest while doing the bare minimum.
- toomuchtodo 4y agoProve your assertion. You are attributing logical, rational behavior to orgs and their participants that rarely are those traits. I have personally attempted to defend directs from layoffs, and that quickly turned into me making calls to other orgs so they could land safely elsewhere, facts and value be damned. I support rational decisioning (“here is the evidence this person delivers value, is committed to the org’s success, and should be factored into retention”), it’s just rare imho. YMMV. Perhaps I’ve just been unlucky in my journey. If that is the case, n=1, build your assumptions off of competing data.
- gruez 4y ago> Prove your assertion. You are attributing logical, rational behavior to orgs and their participants that rarely are those traits. I have personally attempted to defend directs from layoffs, and that quickly turned into me making calls to other orgs so they could land safely elsewhere, facts and value be damned. And what am I supposed to do if my experience was the exact opposite to yours? Do you want me to dig up emails and/or other company documents that show there was "logical, rational behavior" in my organization?
- toomuchtodo 4y agoNah, I’m just saying that our experiences are going to wildly differ and my recommendation is to plan for the worst. Please don’t take my comments as anything other than that, and I absolutely did not intend it as a personal attack. If you’ve worked at amazing (logical, rational) orgs that value commitment and will take care of folks in return, I am genuinely happy for you. Envious even. It is more rare than you would think. Regardless, workers must protect themselves. If you’d like to discuss further, contact info in my profile.
- vkou 4y agoLayoffs in large firms are typically handled in complete secrecy by third-party consultants, and 'loyalty' isn't an input they plug into their formulas. The decisionmakers that, at the end of the day, approve the recommendations of the consultants are usually incredibly removed from any actual work that gets done. I'm talking about people with 300+ reports. They have no fucking idea whether or not you are 'loyal'. The people who have an idea of that find out that you got laid off at the same time that you do. Likewise, when an entire department gets gutted (with no internal transfers available), nobody with any influence over that decision is going to care that you were busting your ass for the firm's bottom line every Saturday.
- gruez 4y ago> and 'loyalty' isn't an input they plug into their formulas. >They have no fucking idea whether or not you are 'loyal'. My comment literally says >Loyalty isn't rewarded per se What metrics do you think the "third-party consultants" are using?
- vkou 4y ago> What metrics do you think the "third-party consultants" are using? Closing their eyes, and throwing darts at the historical record of your three-point "NI/Meets/Exceeds" score, where you are on the org chart, and whether you're being paid more than your peers. If there was any method to their madness, you wouldn't be seeing people with strong performance histories getting canned (In divisions that haven't been shut down).
- not_the_fda 4y agoI have never seen that happen. I have seen people who were loyal and worked for the same company for 20 years be thrown to the curb like trash, and they were not poor performers. You are just a number on a spreadsheet, and if you have been there awhile its an expensive number, you are probably older with a larger salary and higher healthcare costs.
- noncoml 4y ago> You’re just a line in a spreadsheet. Spot on. IT workers need to realise this and start acting accordingly. You are no more important to an exec of a tech company than a barista is to Starbuck’s exec. Unionise and stop being jerks during technical interviews.
- prepend 4y agoOr even better, use your skills to start your own company. I’ve never seen a unionized software company make good software. And I’ve seen lots of different types of software. I don’t think programmers are interchangeable cogs and there’s so much variance and diversity across people, I wouldn’t want to work for a company that paid me the same as everyone else and fired based on seniority.
- noncoml 4y ago> I wouldn’t want to work for a company that paid me the same as everyone else and fired based on seniority. Are you insinuating that pay and layoffs are done based on merit today? Because that’s totally not my experience after a couple of decades in the industry. And I’m leaving myself out of the sample. Not sure if you ever attended a meeting with just directors and above. If you do you will hear only one word used for engineers: “Resource”. Also great software, made by the megacorps, has to do as much with the engineers as McDonald’s burger have to do with the person flipping the patties. It’s just lies we tell to ourselves.
- CapstanRoller 4y ago>I’ve never seen a unionized software company make good software. This is a non-sequitur. Are you misunderstanding how unions work? It's not that a particular company should unionize, but rather the software developers at every company. The union's role is to advocate for the interests of software developers in the industry as a whole, not oversee particular software development projects.
- adhesive_wombat 4y agoNot everyone works for massive tech companies. If you work for a FAANG or MANTA or whatever it is, then sure, you're probably viewed as another cog in the machine.
- dsfyu404ed 4y agoIf your whole department or project is being let go loyalty and personal relationships doesn't matter. If your department or project is one of the ones told to manage out poor performers more aggressively or to cut X% of headcount being someone your manager can count on is going to make you substantially less likely to be one of the people managed out or cut. Sure, they might bring in consultants like it's Office Space but those consultants ask everyone what they think of their team members and keep score and in that scenario it's still better to be the person everyone likes and/or respects with more than the absolute bare minimum work output.
- watwut 4y agoThe layoffs I have seen just were not that thought out. First people to go were the most paid ones, regardless of performance anyway.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- treis 4y ago>how’d that work at Google How do you know it didn't?
- s1artibartfast 4y agoDo you realize you shifted the gold post from having benefit to providing a bulletproof guarantee? Nothing in life is guaranteed.
- j-bos 4y agoMaybe the commentor is refering to net benefit, rather than gross.
- s1artibartfast 4y agoPerhaps, this whole topic becomes a lot more nuanced if people want to talk about net benefit, and situational benefit, and honestly a lot more interesting. E.g.How and when do you decide to pull out the stops and put in a lot of extra work for your company or boss? That's the kind of stuff make or break careers and build lasting reputation.
- Waterluvian 4y agoLayoff season is not about keeping the loyal employees, it’s about keeping the necessary ones. Loyalty isn’t really valuable to the company when retention isn’t a concern.
- jiriknesl 4y agoAs a CEO who had to do some lay-offs, I would terminate loyal workers who care about the company the last, even if I had to change their focus. At a certain size when you know all people in the company, a CEO always know which 15 % of people will be let go first and which 15 % will the company keep even if the business is losing money every month.
- CapstanRoller 4y agoHow do you identify, evaluate, and rank loyalty? Please be specific about your process.
- monkeyshelli 4y ago"I like him/her and don't like this other him/her"..
- jiriknesl 4y agoMy company is small enough to know everyone personally. For larger companies, honestly, it’s a difficult question.
- CapstanRoller 4y ago>My company is small enough to know everyone personally. OK, so how do you identify, evaluate, and rank loyalty? If there's an objective mechanism for it, you shouldn't need to personally know everyone. What I'm hearing is that you go by "feel" (aka the sum of all your biases) and make decisions based on that. How is this remotely objective, fair, or scalable?
- willcipriano 4y agoSo you get to stay at a failing company as a reward?
- suoduandao2 4y agospeaking from my own experience, I got to leave on my own terms instead of worrying about making rent for any amount of time.
- roenxi 4y agoIn theory maybe promotions and bonuses were being handed out they should tend towards the more loyal workers. But I would advise against working overtime as a strategy to get rewards, it usually doesn't work in my experience.
- Aeolun 4y agoI think you can work only a little bit of highly visible overtime and get most of the benefits without all the hours. If you’re known never to work overtime, the few times you do (without complaining) it’ll highlight your efforts.
- crazygringo 4y agoIn theory, with promotions. In practice, they've decided to bring in an external candidate to fill the role at the higher level. But you're the best person to bring them up to speed because you know so much with all the extra projects you've taken on!
- quantified 4y agoYes, all the projects that you were hoping to be able to work on as a reward are out of reach because you're too valuable to the ones you're on.
- rhtgrg 4y agoThese days the expectation around promotions is that you've already been working at the next level for 1-2 years and are due for a correction in title and compensation. Basically, you have to let the company exploit you while crossing your fingers regarding the light at the end of the tunnel, which might just be the ditch light of the layoff train.
- vlunkr 4y agoI work for a small company, and I do believe loyalty is rewarded here. Raises, bonuses, freedom to move between projects, etc. I’m sure it’s a different story when you’re working with an army of devs. It’s a numbers game, everyone is easier to replace in that situation.
- pgwhalen 4y ago> When is loyalty meaningfully rewarded? At the risk of being overly obvious, a company might do things like increase your compensation (especially backward looking discretionary comp), give you more opportunities suited to your interests, or consider others for layoffs before you. Of course, none of these things are guarantees, and it's entirely rational to assume they will never happen and go about your professional life accordingly. But that doesn't mean they don't happen at some companies for some people.
- karaterobot 4y agoI think the easy take is that companies never reciprocate loyalty, but I have had people go to bat to keep me at a job during a round of layoffs, because they liked working with me and trusted me. I agree that you shouldn't be a company man, but I think the easy take is too simple to describe how people actually work.
- zabzonk 4y ago> it doesn’t mean we should just abandon work commitments or dodge uncompensated overtime. it's not dodging! if you won't pay me for my work, i'm not going to do the work!
- eggsmediumrare 4y agoIt's crazy how many people don't understand this
- xyzelement 4y agoIt depends on the job and company. I've worked with folks w your mindset who'd bail at 5 when their team stayed till 7. Then 5 years out, their team mates were making an extra 200k a year because they got bonuses and raises in return. So in their case it was short term uncompensated overtime , long term well compensated.
- zabzonk 4y ago5 years is short term? do the maths. anyway, few people stay with a company that exploits them for 5 years.
- xyzelement 4y agoI feel like you mentally inverted every thing in my post and then replied to that.
- zabzonk 4y agoI feel otherwise, but please expand a bit.
- xyzelement 4y agoAlright. Two guys working in a great company. One had the attitude of "no uncomped OT" and leaves at 5. The other guy works till 7. At the end of the year guy 2 gets an extra 40k comp raise vs guy 1. In 5 years that's a 200k difference. So by avoiding "uncomped OT" guy 1 fucked himself out of a ton of comp. OBVIOUSLY this depends on the company and there's no guarantees. I've been lucky enough to work on companies that were like this and this every man for himself short term thinking was poison. YMMV.
- yalogin 4y agoLoyalty also makes you earn less compared to their peers. I am exhibit A for that:)
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- henry2023 4y agoBe loyal to your wife. People organizations are higher order entities who could not care less about you. Building a relationship of loyalty with them is just not something you should do.
- fwsgonzo 4y agoIndeed. It's crazy the amount of stories I've seen on Reddit this past decade from people who are warning others about the dangers of treating a company as family etc., after they themselves were discarded at a whim. It's always the same story, and they sometimes profess how unexpected it was, and how important they were (or how many projects they lead) in the company.
- Gigachad 4y agoThere is a middle ground. On one side you have working massive unpaid overtime and stressing out, and on the other side you have WFH bludgers who spend 90% of their time on YouTube and reddit knowing they will get away with it. Then there is actually doing the work you are paid for and putting a good effort in but not letting it extend unreasonably beyond hours and not letting it stress you out. It’s actually far more rewarding to do this where you actually care about the work you do and feel some pride in it vs completely disassociating.
- eecc 4y agoIf I ever did that, it'd be J2 or some training. YouTube and Reddit have vampired way to much time from my life already.
- pigsty 4y ago> on the other side you have WFH bludgers who spend 90% of their time on YouTube and reddit knowing they will get away with it. If they’re getting away with it, that’s a problem with the company not distributing their workloads properly. 90% of work hours wasted should be immediately obvious.
- Aunche 4y ago
- jeffrallen 4y ago> Participants handing out the unpaid work in Stanley’s study were compensated $12 an hour. Isn't that a kick in the nuts for poor John?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- analog31 4y agoMy knee jerk impression is that the study could be explained by defining loyalty as willingness to accept unpaid work.
- maxk42 4y agoIt's not "unpaid work" if you're classified as an exempt employee, which is never explicitly addressed in the article. That's why you get a certain salary regardless of sick leave, holidays, etc - you are being paid to apply your professional skill to a task, not conduct menial labor for a certain number of hours. I would never work unpaid overtime when I was working as a retail clerk. That's why they had a time card system which I had to punch in and punch out of. If a customer kept me late by even 15 minutes, I'd be compensated for all of that time. Now later in my career I'm an exempt professional, and I don't mind crunching when it's crunch time. That's part of why my salary is so much higher now: I understand that I have a job to execute at any cost. If a deadline is in danger of being missed I will put in the extra hours necessary to achieve success regardless of being asked to or not. That's why managers award me crucial projects and that's the kind of employee I would lean on when I have a crucial project of my own to manage. That's also the first employee to be put up for promotion and the last one to be expendable during hard times. This isn't the least bit surprising.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- ary 4y agoDid anyone think otherwise and need to have it explained? Having been on both sides of the employment equation a few times now I can say confidently that people act on their values and respond to incentives without regard to where they sit on an org chart. This too doesn't require a study to confirm. Perhaps I'm naive and the point of publishing this is to drum up engagement from the aggrieved employed. Be you an employer or employee the hardest thing to be in business is ethical. Convincing (or paying) people to care is incredibly hard, as is convincing (or paying) people to learn. It gets a lot easier when you find a way to tie either of those things to their values, and honestly most people, rationally, value themselves above all else. Is it any wonder people give up and begin exploiting one another? This article reads like someone found the Gervais Principle [1] and viewed it as full of low-hanging fruit for a study. [1] https://www.ribbonfarm.com/2009/10/07/the-gervais-principle-or-the-office-according-to-the-office/ https://www.ribbonfarm.com/2009/10/07/the-gervais-principle-...
- doctor_eval 4y agoSo loyalty is treated as a weakness, rather than a strength. What a shitty world we've built for ourselves.
- pessimizer 4y agoLoyalty has always been treated as a weakness and a strength. Your loyalty is my strength.
- alex7734 4y agoThe problem is that loyalty is one of those words that is so emotionally charged that doesn't really mean anything concrete anymore. If you define loyalty as ignoring short term potential self-interest by leaving/betraying/not-doing-overtime in favor of the long term value you will receive from the relationship, then, even if you may be betrayed in return anyway, it's not really weakness - you just made a mistake. If you know you're getting a bad deal, and you predict it's not going to get better in the long term, and you stay anyway, you're not "loyal", you're weak.
- whack 4y ago> We value people who are loyal. We think about them in positive terms. They get awarded often. It's not just the negative side If the managers also award loyal workers in various ways, it would hardly be exploitative. As a manager, if something absolutely needs to get done outside of normal work hours, of course I would lean towards asking the person most likely to say yes. And of course I would also give that person a larger end-of-year salary increase, bonus, or fast-tracked promotion to recognize their efforts and commitment. It seems odd for the study to focus purely on the additional work the loyal workers are doing, and ignore the various ways in which they would be rewarded for it.
- klabb3 4y agoYeah, it’s obvious as a last resort for judging employees. If you know nothing about the work itself, all you can confidently assess is responsiveness and agreeableness. But beware of the incentives this can create. When managers reward looking busy and sacrificial rituals, you also end up with short-termism. A team can tread water for years, being constantly “rescued” by “heroes” when a fire starts. This may not be the best people to promote. Wanting to be helpful and being helpful are not the same things. In software and product development, the best performing teams, in my experience, are small. They have a well defined area of responsibility and a strong culture of ownership. It takes time and commitment to build that up, but when it’s in a good state, it runs on its own like a well maintained clockwork. Not only is this much more relaxing and fun to work with, it also performs so much better in the long run, and requires very little hands-on management.
- matheusmoreira 4y agoDoesn't seem so obvious to me. The story of the dedicated employee who's often overlooked despite their efforts is as old as humanity.
- swagasaurus-rex 4y agoThe prodigal son
- m348e912 4y agoFormer manager here, I definitely leaned on the guys/ladies on the team I could count on over "less committed team members". The ones I could count on were eager and willing to step up when needed and I very much appreciated it. In this case, they were salary and worked more hours than some of their counter parts. I did my best to reward them with promotion opportunities and supporting them as much as I could in their career.
- spoonfeeder006 4y agoWhat about giving them bonuses as well?
- m348e912 4y agoThey would be awarded higher bonuses at review time. I had limited ability to do much out of cycle.
- jdbernard 4y agoAs a manger myself, I try to be careful about what I ask for this reason. I can easily ask a lot from a team member, but I often don't have the ability to really reward them beyond a set limit. If I'm not in a position to adequately reward them for that extra effort then I'm not going to ask for it. Our position straddles the fence. We have to support the company and our team members. Ideally we do that by keeping incentives and compensation aligned. But corporations are usually structured to have a predictable limit on the ways we can compensate employees, but rarely any limits on what we can expect from employees. We should be careful there to be fair.
- adave 4y agoSo all they got was appreciation and measly pay increase, guess you were playing favorites which only human.
- WesleyLivesay 4y agoSucks being dependable.
- osigurdson 4y agoIt seems pretty obvious. The ones most willing to do the work end up doing it.
- Animats 4y agoA more effective cure: pay for overtime.
- ssss11 4y agoIt’s the path of least resistance for the manager. The easy route.
- mesarvagya 4y agoIMO being loyal is like being sweet, which will attract ants of all sort and suck all juices out of you. Sometimes, being bitter (saying NO) is an art.
- akomtu 4y agoIf you think about it, the kind of corporate loyalty we are talking about is a lot closer to gambling than generosity. Just like gambling, it's the belief that the corporate one-armed bandit remembers your contributions of time and work, and will surely reward you for that.
- Nevermark 4y agoThis is why I think companies that have real follow through in terms of taking care of layed off workers exit compensation and next job assistance are doing the”right” thing for everyone. We all win when loyalty can be counted on to go both ways. Companies that can count on extra employee efforts win. Employees that know their employer is not gaming them, and won’t dump them cold, and will advance their responsibilities and compensation as fast as they can, also win. When there is a strong reputation both ways, everyone becomes a motivated partner for everyone else.
- happytoexplain 4y agoGenerally yes, but this specific example is imbalanced, in my opinion. The trade here is employees going above and beyond in return for employers simply behaving in a way that I would expect any decent person to: "not gaming them", "won't dump them cold", "advance their responsibilities and compensation as fast as they can" (that last one I read as "as fast as responsible company management permits").
- hanoz 4y agoThe willing horse gets the whip.
- adave 4y agoSqueaky wheel get the oil.
- grensley 4y agoJust remember, in capitalism: if you aren't exploited you aren't valuable. Your goal as a worker is to right size that exploitation.
- ochronus 4y agoThere's a big divide in (tech) management based on how managers see their roles. On one end of the spectrum are folks who feel their only job is to make things happen, pronto. This is what gets you rewards, pats on the back, promotions etc. On the other end of the spectrum are folks who don't care about delivery and think that the only happy team is where everything is allowed. The truth lies somewhere in between. Sometimes the hardest part of my job as a manager is to stop my engineers from overtime/extra work, even if the project is late. I want to build a healthy, sustainable environment, not only because it's the right thing to do, but also because this is how the whole company becomes sustainable eventually. Anything else simply hides the sub-optimal things in the system (e.g. unrealistic planning culture). I wouldn't be doing a good job if I let messed up planning go unseen and hide it by pushing folks to overwork themselves. My job is not to micro-optimize but think about the system.
- kappuchino 4y agoRelated: Stop loss behaviour Imagine two people bidding for a dollar bill. You start at 1 cent. Someone else bids 2 cent, etc. etc. Now apart from who bids the most wins, the investment is gone when you don't win the bid. Until 99 cents all is sane, since you believe you can make a "win". At one dollar you still break even. After that, you would bid to reduce loss. How fare will you take that? This example can be transferred to workplace situations(this is why it is related), relationships ... especially wars. Imagine how much was already destroyed and how many were killed ... no, surrender is not an option. Humans sometimes justify any bid blindly on the one dollar just for minimizing loss. Yet, most times it is better to get out early. You - as I - will learn that the hard way, because its incredibly difficult to identify in real life when and how you are involved in a stop loss situation. But once you identify its stop loss: Get out.
- ochronus 4y agoSo true! See also: sunk-cost fallacy
- precompute 4y agoMost managers don't know shit about management, they're only rewarding people that act like managers, irrespective of the role. There will always be more BS artists than honest, skilled people. A lot of people can afford to be this callous because thanks to the digital realm, in their view, their cap for the maslow's hierarchy pyramid is firmly in their grasp. This is similar to how practicing cruelty often makes managers more effective. Also similar to how the primary role of an executive is the mismanagement of company funds for personal gains.
- swagasaurus-rex 4y agoJust because a manager can be cruel, it does not make them more effective. A manager relies on their subordinates to get things done. Breaking trust in this relationship happens often unfortunately and will over time inversely impact the actual getting things done part. Certain high-profile companies can burn through "expendable" labor. That's because everybody wants to work there for certain reasons.
- SergeAx 4y agoIt is okay to be loyal to anyone or anything as far as that loyalty is rewarded. Yes, any manager would be more willing to put extra burden to loyal workers, but if at the same time they are equally willing to give those workers a raise or promotion — it seems okay in my book. Also, workers willing to do extra work will be last to laid off.