6 ms·
Switzerland Weighs Full or Partial Credit Suisse Nationalization
- moneywoes 4y agoShades of SVB
- mtremsal 4y agoI don’t think that’s fair. CS is a GSIB. We can wipe shareholders, but (unlike SVB) it’s a lot less clear what can be done with bond holders without threatening the stability of the global financial system. Probably the central bank will have to buy the bonds at a bargain and hold them to maturity.
- lordnacho 4y agoLiterally changing the law in order to allow bypassing a shareholder vote? I get that it's an emergency, but I think people ought to find this hard to accept. At the same time it's a warning about size: CS has grown so big and so integral to the Swiss economy that the tail wags the dog. Let something grow to this size and it falls outside of the control of ordinary democracy. When bad things happen to an essential institution you end up doing things that are against your own principles. People will rightly be asking how the government ends up paying for it when things go wrong but shareholders get paid when they go right.
- sandworm101 4y ago>> ... government ends up paying for it when things go wrong but shareholders get paid when they go right. A sizable percentage of the population sees this as a valid role for government. Every time the stock market dips a little, or home prices flatten off, people scream for the government to do something. Dumping government money into private entities to protect "shareholder value" is why stocks have risen so dramatically in the last 15 years. An entire generation has grown up thinking this is not only normal but that the party should never stop. The goal at every publicly-traded company is to become dominant enough to qualify for such protection (ie be just slightly more important than Lehman Bros was).
- palata 4y ago> A sizable percentage of the population sees this as valid role for government Interested in any source here.
- redox99 4y ago"sizable percentage" is so vague that it's probably easy to back up that claim
- prox 4y agoI am assuming that in Europe it’s not that rare nor weird, while in the US I can almost hear the doomsday bells ringing.
- consp 4y agoHasn't happened a lot since the privatisation movement in the 90s but it's not unprecedented. Most recent example is however South America (Argentina, railways) I guess.
- izacus 4y agoEveryone in US would be sprinting to nationalize the big banks if that would pose any threat to national wealth or allow other countries (china!) to be more influential.
- paganel 4y agoSince the famous “it’s the economy, stupid!” each and every US President has taken upon himself to support said economy and to make it thrive, because that’s what was getting the electorate’s votes. That has mostly meant trying to support the stock market/share prices, but under the current ideological circumstances it wouldn’t surprise me if the US Government were to help other sections of the economy, like housing.
- mannerheim 4y ago'Toute nation a le gouvernement qu'elle mérite.'
- pfortuny 4y agoThis is nitpicking but it is not the government who pays, it is the taxpayers and in the end, every citizen. I think the distinction matters in this case.
- lkbm 4y agoHow is that a distinction at all? What would it mean for the government, but not the taxpayers, to pay?
- r00fus 4y agoGovernment can force others to pay like corporations or other countries (by threats).
- pfortuny 4y agoI am just clarifying that the government does not own money. It just manages it. There was a famous intervention by the previous speaker of the house (Pelosi) saying “we are giving them our money”… That is why I started by saying “nitpicking” but in the end, it is the State’s money (or the taxpayers’, which is equivalent), not the Government. The government has no momey, it cannot pay anyone (in a Republic, mind you).
- dermesser 4y agoThis is false, and doubly so in this case. There is no taxpayer money involved that would go missing elsewhere. Central bank money - which is free - is what props up the deal.
- AbrahamParangi 4y agoWell, you could make the argument that the base state of business is that your profits are taxed but your losses are your own. There are exceptions (plenty of them!) to this rule, but it is the base dynamic.
- bagacrap 4y agoLast time I checked, the govt taxed basically all economic transactions, so the govt does get paid when things go right. Meanwhile if CS blows up and the country enters a recession, tax dollars will be lost. Intervening may be cheaper than the alternative.
- ClumsyPilot 4y agoThe argument is not about government intervention per se, but about hypocrisy -> it's somehow okay for Government to bail out banks, but not students/school meals for kids/any other cause for the common man
- PKop 4y ago"Sovereign is he who decides on the exception.” - Carl Schmitt [0] This is just revealing who is in charge. The state with some mix of banking and corporate interests. Certainly it is not the people, nor is the law as written sovereign. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/State_of_exception https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/State_of_exception
- Youden 4y agoIn Switzerland, perhaps more than any other place, it truly is the people who are in charge: - There is no "he". Switzerland has no single person in a position of power above all others. Even the "head" of government is a council of 7 from a variety of political parties. - Any alterations to the law can be (and are) challenged by referendum. - Changes to the constitution can be (and are) put forward by the people and voted on by the people. The people have a say on everything from whether cows should keep their horns [0] to whether the country should spend several billion buying new fighter jets [1]. [0]: https://www.swissinfo.ch/eng/politics/november-25-vote_are-cows-with-horns-worth-a-bonus-for-the-swiss-/44564548 https://www.swissinfo.ch/eng/politics/november-25-vote_are-c... [1]: https://www.swissinfo.ch/eng/fighter-jet-challenge-called-off-to-avoid--democratic-farce-/47913906 https://www.swissinfo.ch/eng/fighter-jet-challenge-called-of...
- PKop 4y agoI understand all this. I'm specifically refuting the "truly" qualifier. Nominally, and in various day to day issues, they may be given some degree of say yes. I would argue this is only in so far as they are delegated or granted this by actual power. And I did not mean to imply that power can only ever reside in one unitary leader. It is almost certainly always distributed to one degree or another, even in absolute monarchy. But, crisis times reveal where majority of the de facto rather than de jure power resides in reality, despite our assumptions, and I don't think it is ever in the hands of the collective masses more than some minority groups/institutions. I'm not a believer in populism, think rather the Italian school/elite theorists[0] were right who describe how power is most often wielded by a minority, whether individual or oligarchic group(s) mostly because it is much easier to organize on the small group level, and the public is always more disorganized and less aware about inner workings of the system which over time enables factions to consolidate power away from the disorganized broad masses. The demos can here and there express their will for a time, for example by supporting some elite leader or faction/party, but ruling/governing over the long term is nearly impossible for the masses to direct political outcomes. Once set up the insiders have an asymmetry they can leverage in all sorts of ways. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elite_theory https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elite_theory Good book giving broad overview of some of these political ideas and thinkers including Mosca,Pareto,Michels,Schmitt,Jouvenel, Burnham,Francis, Gottfried: https://www.imperiumpress.org/shop/populist-delusion/ https://www.imperiumpress.org/shop/populist-delusion/ The people are given a say on all sorts of things until circumstances arise where the people and laws are against the interests of real power, and then these nominal structures are simply ignored. >perhaps more than any other place I'll grant that this relative comparison may be true. It's only a matter of time until entropy degrades this special situation and bureaucratic and institutional inertia consolidate power into the hands of insider elites like every other instance. >Any alterations to the law They are breaking the law right now, the people's will and the law are irrelevant here in terms of actually preventing this action. Machiavelli would say the people do have to be placated and their interests served to a large degree else you will end up with civil war, so they aren't "powerless", and they need to grant legitimacy of the system that rules over them (for things to work well), but they are not in charge.
- mpol 4y agoIn Europe we used to have a dual system with a capitalist and a socialist part. Companies are capitalist and try to grow. The socialist governement tries to put limits to what is allowed. But now we have more neoliberal governments and the market can often do what it wants. People voted for more liberal politic parties. Governments loosened the rules and the trimmed down on inspectors. And now shareholders and the CEO can just earn money almost without limits.
- sschueller 4y agoAt this point I believe this would be the best solution. It would prevent mass layoffs and prevent UBS getting put into a critical situation because of the bad CS assets. For the tax payer it sucks but if we are bailing them out, then the bank should be ours. If something is too big to fail it should be nationalized or broken up.
- NomDePlum 4y agoThe bank is worthless though? If anything it's an additional obligation to the taxpayer that they have to underwrite. Really puzzles me the logic of underpinning a market economy to the extent it's no longer functioning. No lessons learned from 2008 whatsoever.
- sschueller 4y agoIt isn't worthless, it has 13% liquidity unlike for example Lehman Brothers in 2008 which had less than 3%. Biggest issues is the trust which is gone. CS has actually been on a turn around since last year. New leadership and new goal including significantly reducing investment banking.
- NomDePlum 4y agoIs anyone else likely to buy them, or can they continue to operate if not nationalised? Losing trust as a financial institution is, and probably should be fatal, if it justified.
- H8crilA 4y agoIf it is exactly worthless (meaning the equity is worth $0, but everything below equity in the capital stack can still be serviced) then the government is getting it at a fair price while doing something good along the way. For all the valid criticism of the handling of the 2008 crisis (e.g. moral hazard, unfairness vs the people that had their property foreclosed) it is worth to point out that the US government at large has made profit on the bailouts. Most of the assets recovered and were later either sold or expired, all together at a nice profit. I.e. the US government has successfully "bought the dip" from "panic sellers".
- abc03 4y agoCurrently in my view the only solution. The solution with UBS is not supported by the people. The Swiss National Bank (SNB) has basically unlimited money power. Credit Suisse is not technically insolvent like Silicon Valley Bank but lacks trust in the market. The risk is too high that the contagion spreads to UBS and only defers the problem to a later date (what will we do with UBS). SNB should have already reacted much earlier and they are partly responsible for the problem (along with management and the biggest shareholder and their CHF 50B line but which they asked to be secured). It's high time to send a powerful message before Monday. And for the SNB it's easy to buy all bonds in the market at a distressed level and make a hefty return. This is better than to invest their currency reserves in the stock market. Edit: Added last two sentences.
- sschueller 4y agoI 100% agree and I hope it goes into this direction. The state also has more power to push back on fines that are incoming from other states regarding tax evasion etc. which UBS would have to deal with putting it into a bad situation.
- curiousgal 4y ago> buy all bonds in the market at a distressed level and make a hefty return. How? They can't sell the bonds. And holding the bonds to maturity is questionable since CS may likely default. If it doesn't default, it would be thanks to a lifeline thrown by...SNB. So yeah, no idea what you're on about there.
- abc03 4y agoWhy sell it? The SNB doesn't need to sell them and yes they can hold them to maturity. They can also give a larger credit line to CS and CS can buy back all the bonds from investor that want it. At CHF 100B it's a CHF 50B - 20B capital injection.
- weard_beard 4y agoThe derivatives and trading arm is what’s of concern here. Bonds and rates are a paper covering for trillions in swaps: bad bets that need to be repaid. These swaps may involve the solvency of US institutions. That’s why this isn’t so straight forward.
- Arubis 4y agohttps://archive.is/paeOV https://archive.is/paeOV
- calr 4y agoWhen a company is nationalized what typically happens to the shareholders? Are they wiped, do they get paid out, or does some of their ownership carry over to the new entity (rights to a special dividend or something)?
- nwellnhof 4y agoThe article talks about "full or partial" nationalization. I have no idea how a full nationalization would look like, but typically, a company is only partially nationalized. The state takes a large equity stake, diluting the ownership of previous shareholders.
- naveen99 4y agoCurrent Shareholders are a rounding error, as bond holders with over $60 billion at risk are at risk of being bailed in as shareholders.
- elzbardico 4y agoAs the bank seems to be toast, the fair market price of their shares should be very close to zero. The shareholders are already fucked.
- arbuge 4y agoThey would likely be wiped out in this scenario. Note that long term shareholders have already been pretty much wiped out. CS was worth almost $300B before the GFC, and down 70x to around $8B Friday. Apparently UBS was uncomfortable offering more than $1B for it today, so already down a further 8x since then.
- bkor 4y agoCredit Suisse was involved in loads and loads of scandals. Joe Blogs summarized loads of them in a video: https://youtu.be/tAJRqpDqjLU?t=325 https://youtu.be/tAJRqpDqjLU?t=325 It's insane that this questionable bank which continuously says "problems have been addressed" scandal after scandal is now being saved. Public losses, private profit.
- abc03 4y agoUnfortunately other banks, too. Not something to mention specifically in this case. We must admit that banks have gone too big and need to be split up in the future.
- swarnie 4y agoI'd struggle to mention a bank which hasn't done some seriously questionable stuff just in the last 15 years, this is nothing unique.
- VWWHFSfQ 4y agodoes that change anything with regard to this particular bank
- swarnie 4y agoOnly in the context of OPs comment. If we withhold help purely based on evidence of shady dealings then JPM, HSBC, DB, Well Fargo, Goldman and a whole butch of others should be liquidated by Monday lunch time in solidarity. Personally i hate the barter system so i suggest we find a different judgement metric.
- BaseballPhysics 4y agoHonestly, the only way you could say that with a straight face is if you haven't been paying attention to CS over the past year. Archegos and Greensill alone are astounding, and those blew up in just the past 6-9 months!
- 4y ago
- elzbardico 4y agoPlease, if someone is working on a time machine, I need a ride back to 2007 to take care of some urgent issues.
- woeirua 4y agoThe just solution here is to let CS fail, and jail the executives if they find evidence of fraud or other crimes. Make the depositors and bond holders whole to prevent contagion.
- oblvious-earth 4y agoIn practice wouldn't this just mean part nationalizing the bank so you can keep paying the salaries of all the various bank tellers, IT staff, and accountants to allow the depositors and bond holders to withdraw their money. Given the retail bank is highly profitable wouldn't it make sense to then keep the whole thing going and figure out how to re-privatize it at a later date?
- cm2187 4y agoNot the least because on paper at least it looks healthy. It has capital and liquidity ratios in line with other major banks. It has a profitability problems but had started laying off thousand of staff already, so that was more a share price problem than credit risk problem. But bank runs don't look at financials.
- david927 4y agoBut if you make depositors whole, we'll have to switch to banks as custodial accounts. These private companies can't make huge profits off of deposits in good times and be, essentially, insured by tax payers in bad times.
- akira2501 4y ago> we'll have to switch to banks as custodial accounts. Isn't that effectively what Glass-Steagall, a law passed after one of our previous massive failures, mandated? > These private companies can't make huge profits off of deposits in good times If they were, then why were interest rates so low? Either way, I figure the river of low interest government money was what made them so profitable, and now that this tap is turned off, the reason they're immediately failing. > insured by tax payers in bad times. If deposits equated to profits, then what is the current source of "stress?"
- jb1991 4y agoBlackRock won't be happy to hear they can't buy it now.
- RandomLensman 4y agoIt has to be possible to orderly wind down a GSIB. If that is just not possible then they perhaps cannot be fully private institutions.
- sampa 4y agoanother reminder that bitcoin is a ponzi scheme oh, wait.. wrong thread.
- irrational 4y agoThat was a hard title to parse. I read “full or partial credit” in the school sense. Maybe leave out “full or partial”?
- bvan 4y agoCS had been circling the drain for long time. The Swiss government must have been asleep at the switch.
- bayesian_horse 4y agoI don't know much about Switzerland but their flag is a big plus.
- germandiago 4y agoThis should not happen. Never.