8 ms·
UK backs Rolls-Royce project to build a nuclear reactor on the moon
- stephc_int13 4y ago"The UKSA will now provide £2.9 million (around $3.52 million) of funding for the project." A nuclear reactor on the moon? I don't get it. Meta spent north of $30 Billions to build a "metaverse" that I would not even consider to be alpha-level quality, and some people at Rolls-Royce think they can build a nuclear reactor for how much?
- ianai 4y agoThey’re just adding money to the pot, from my read of it.
- dogma1138 4y agoFAANG spending isn’t the norm, the total program cost of the Mars 2020 rover was $2.7 billion. Meta spent $30 billion on something that looks like SecondLife on the Wii… But also this ain’t the total cost just how much money the UK government is funding the project for right now.
- fosk 4y agoIt’s really mind boggling how much money Meta spent on this thing.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- midoridensha 4y agoAny time someone complains about the government buying $600 toilet seats as an example of how the government wastes money, just point them to the MetaVerse.
- blitzar 4y ago$600 for a virtual toilet seat.
- zoklet-enjoyer 4y agoDid they seriously spend that much money on it??? How???
- dogma1138 4y agoI don’t know if that’s how much they spent on it or was that how much they “spent” on it. But the cumulative cost of Reality Labs was apparently indeed $36B over 3 years.
- 2143 4y agoAnd let's not forget India's Mars mission (orbiter, not a rover) was even cheaper at "just" $75 million [1]. [1] https://www.forbes.com/sites/saritharai/2013/11/07/how-indias-isro-launched-its-mars-mission-at-cut-rate-costs/?sh=4ce856bf18b7 https://www.forbes.com/sites/saritharai/2013/11/07/how-india...
- vkou 4y ago1. Meta had to have spent vastly less than $30 billion on their "metaverse". That's ~80,000 person-years of senior SWEs. 2. Literally half the companies who have video games as their core competency would have been able to build way more for way less.
- __turbobrew__ 4y agoImagine if we put effort into humanities and science instead of trying to get people to buy stuff they don’t need.
- helsinkiandrew 4y agoThey’re already building small modular nuclear reactors for power stations and submarines. This is just for the work to make it work in a lunar environment
- fnord77 4y agodumb question maybe, but with out an atmosphere, isn't there virtually unlimited solar potential on the moon? why is a nuclear reactor needed?
- panick21_ 4y agoIn addition to what others have said, in the places where the water is and the energy is needed, there is no sun. So you need to first go to a place where there is sun, then beam energy into a crator.
- dogma1138 4y agoBecause you have a cycle of ~14 days of darkness and light on the moon so solar will need a backup. Batteries are an option but 14 days worth of storage for a lunar base is probably asking a bit too much. Also nuclear provides another benefit on the moon - heat which you’ll definitely need during those 14 days of darkness.
- textninja 4y agoAnother benefit might be protection from asteroids and meteorites if built underground.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- ianai 4y agoIs there somewhere someone’s done the numbers on bootstrapping industry off world? Like what would make most sense very first, etc. It strikes me that at some point it makes a lot more sense to build the stuff to build more stuff out there.
- mLuby 4y agoNASA did a study in the 1980's. For something more recent, I suggest checking out Dr. Casey Handmer. https://ntrs.nasa.gov/api/citations/19830007081/downloads/19830007081.pdf https://ntrs.nasa.gov/api/citations/19830007081/downloads/19...
- ianai 4y agoWow awesome thank you!
- mLuby 4y agoIt's a super-specific niche that I'm very interested in but sadly has very little activity, so I'm happy to spread the word. ISRU "in-situ resource utilization" gets a bit more press more and then. Isaac Arthur also has some good episodes (video/podcasts) on the subject of bootstrapping off-Earth industries like on the Moon or asteroids or Mars.
- credit_guy 4y agoThere's a problem with nuclear power on the Moon. How do you get rid of the heat? Here on Earth, we just use water, of which we have plenty. But on Moon water is extremely scarce. It would make the sci-fi novel Dune look like an oasis. When we'll have some type of an economy on the Moon, it's very likely that water will be more expensive than gold. One thing is absolutely certain: we will not be able to afford to vaporize water and let the steam vent. So, any nuclear reactor on the Moon will need to have some complex array of pipes where steam is circulated through some radiators, then condensed and recirculated. Or, who knows, maybe we'll do this cooling with liquid metals. Among the more abundant metals on the Moon, tin could be a good candidate; there was an experimental reactor at the Oak Ridge National Lab in the 60's that used liquid tin as a coolant.
- krasin 4y agoHeat will be an asset, not a problem: the Moon sub-surface temperature is around -20C ([1]), which means there's an easy way to dissipate power. And if we have any humans living on the moon, that heat will very much be appreciated around all livable areas. https://space.stackexchange.com/questions/19906/constant-lunar-sub-surface-temperature https://space.stackexchange.com/questions/19906/constant-lun...
- m4rtink 4y agoInteresting!l, havent ever thought about that! What is the heat conductivity though ? If it is low, you might have to sink too many heat transfer channels, not to mention with possibly ending up with a hot "bubble" that would no longer provide a temperature gradient.
- krasin 4y agoUnder the layer of regolith, Moon crust is mostly basalt ([1]), which has about 1.6 W/mK thermal conductivity ([2]). Not great, not terrible. We all know how cold it is to stand on a stone floor - unlike wood or plastics, it keeps sucking that heat off. 1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Internal_structure_of_the_Moon https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Internal_structure_of_the_Moon 2. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_thermal_conductivities https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_thermal_conductivities
- specialist 4y agoWill this future moonbase be before or after the UK rejoins the EU?
- mixdup 4y agoWe can't even reliably build them for anything approaching a sane cost on Earth. I hope they're going to build a bankruptcy court up there, too
- kube-system 4y agoThe cost on earth is mostly due to the regulatory environment. The moon doesn’t yet have the same regulatory environment.
- FridayoLeary 4y agoThe current nuclear station program in the UK seems to be struggling to keep up. I'm not sure how we will cope on the moon. Also, wasting money on a vanity project. As for extra terrestrial law, research online reveals there to be a highly developed and powerful judicial system throught the whole galaxy. i have no doubt it is can hear lunar bankruptcy cases too.
- throwayyy479087 4y agoReactor going pop on the moon is a science experiment, not an biological tragedy. Big fan of this idea.
- jimbokun 4y agoWe can and we have, then we stopped.
- SillyUsername 4y agoIt's probably off the back of this work. https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-51233444 https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-51233444 I do think this is running before we can stand. We can't even launch our own rockets/space craft https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/science-environment-64218883 https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/science-environment-64218883
- textninja 4y agoChatGPT had fun with this one. Pretty soon YouTube will be replaced with ITube and we’ll have blockbusters on demand. > In the pulse-pounding sci-fi blockbuster, Lunar Armageddon, the British government enlists Rolls-Royce to construct a series of nuclear reactors on the moon as the last hope for saving Earth from an imminent energy crisis. When legendary pinstriping artist Mark "Marksman" Court is recruited for his unique skills, he joins forces with the fearless commander, Emily "Em" Walker, to assemble an elite team of astronauts and experts. As they race against time to complete the high-stakes mission, Court and Em must navigate political intrigue and life-threatening challenges on the treacherous lunar landscape.
- textninja 4y agoI wonder which endgame is more probable: satellite, or space ship? We have people perfectly willing to shroud earth in sulphur to “protect” us from the sun, so who’s to say those same types won’t repurpose the moon into a luxury spacecraft and take it on a joyride to distant stars?
- salad-tycoon 4y agoIf I am to take your reply seriously, you mean colonize the moon with ultra rich people and then turn it into an arc ship to settle a new world? I mean, billionaires don’t strike me as the kind of people who would want to barely scrape by with limited access to air, water, food, sex, security, shelter until they finally perished cold and alone in the nothing.
- textninja 4y ago> If I am to take your reply seriously, you mean colonize the moon with ultra rich people and then turn it into an arc ship to settle a new world Yes, I said it in a jokey way but I’m actually seriously speculating about that as a distant future scenario, though I’d include their servants, clones, entertainers, staff, recruits, and progeny in that, along with probably a DNA bank of every person, animal, and strand of bacteria on earth. > with limited access to air, water, food, sex, security, shelter until they finally perished cold and alone in the nothing Who said anything about that? I mean, they’d be “limited”, yes, in the strictly mathematical sense that these things are finite, but they need not lack in abundance. I did say luxury space craft, didn’t I? I’m not talking about heated seats here, I’m talking nuclear powered underground cities…
- textninja 4y agoAlso, just a side point but I don’t think billionaires value comfort as much as you think. If that was the case they probably would have stopped somewhere in the tens of millions.
- kjellsbells 4y agoIs it me, or is the UK government launching an unusually large number of boondoggles lately? Nuclear reactors on the moon. Attempts to become a major player in battery technology. It feels to my jaundiced eye like the UK is trying just a little too hard to remind the world that they still matter. Some Brexit insecurity might explain this, perhaps, but that was over five years ago.
- switch007 4y agoLocal elections in May and general election (likely) next year. And we’ve just had the Budget I think there’s plenty of Brexit insecurity still lol The Tory party has a trashed reputation currently so they’re trying to reclaim some ground
- rozal 4y agoUSA has secretly gotten ahead of the quantum race. Part of their disclosure plan is it work with allies on multiple needs. With fusion on the horizon, we will need batteries. With electromagnetic craft, moon trips will be easy.
- whatshisface 4y agoSecretly? QC companies have been shouting every tiny bit of progress from the rooftops, usually before it gets made.
- rozal 4y agoThat’s because the military already had it. They are just now getting bits and pieces.
- panick21_ 4y agoFusion isn't on the horizon. And batteries are needed for EVs and Solar/Wind. And electromagnetic craft are a terrible way to get to the moon.
- 4y ago
- pffft8888 4y agoReminds me of the first episode of Space 1999 where nuclear explosions on the moon push it out of orbit (not implying there will be explosions, just a nostaligic memory brought up by this news) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y6BXaGEuqxo&t=2314s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y6BXaGEuqxo&t=2314s
- ClapperHeid 4y agoNow there was a series which really required "willing suspension of disbelief" of even a child's scientific understanding!
- double2helix 4y ago$3.5 million sounds like a drop in a bucket for a nuclear reactor.
- deepsun 4y agoOnly if you care about nuclear contamination of the surrounding environment.
- buran77 4y ago> The new boost to Rolls-Royce’s research pot follows a previous $303,495 (£249,000) study funded by the U.K. Space Agency in 2022 Wish them all the best, really. But I'm really curious what the study actually provided/concluded in terms of the stated goal of using the money to research the development of such a reactor. Because unless the British are so much more efficient than the EU for example, this kind of money just bought a short conversation with McKinsey. P.S. I think it bought a press release [0]. [0] https://www.rolls-royce.com/media/our-stories/discover/2023/uk-space-agency-backs-rolls-royce-nuclear-power-for-moon-exploration.aspx https://www.rolls-royce.com/media/our-stories/discover/2023/...
- ocimbote 4y agoA small conversation with McKinsey can go a long way in terms of influencing public policy.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- LightBug1 4y agoProbably nonsense. A press release to feed the Brexit part of our politics and population that we're still relevant in terms of global influence and technology.
- wongarsu 4y agoThe US army used a miniature nuclear reactor to power Camp Century in Greenland in the 60s [1]. Obviously that base had some important differences to a moon base (like being surrounded by water ice and atmosphere) and technology has advanced a bit since then, but I wonder how much you would have to change the design to make it a viable moon base. 1: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Camp_Century https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Camp_Century
- jodrellblank 4y agoThe US Navy made a nuclear reactor to power an Antarctic base and it was so expensive and failure prone they went back to diesel. https://theconversation.com/remembering-antarcticas-nuclear-past-with-nukey-poo-99934 https://theconversation.com/remembering-antarcticas-nuclear-...
- loeg 4y ago(1961)
- jodrellblank 4y agoIf you're marking the date implying the technology has improved since then, I'm going to need some convincing. List of cancelled nuclear reators in the US on Wikipedia[1] says "By the end of the 1970s it became clear that nuclear power would not grow nearly as dramatically as once believed. [...] Eventually, more than 120 reactor orders were ultimately cancelled and the construction of new reactors ground to a halt." "Of the 253 nuclear power reactors originally ordered in the United States from 1953 to 2008, 48 percent were cancelled, 11 percent were prematurely shut down, 14 percent experienced at least a one-year-or-more outage, and 27 percent are operating without having a year-plus outage. Thus, only about one fourth of those ordered, or about half of those completed, are still operating and have proved relatively reliable" "As many as 30 new reactors were planned by 2009. As of February 2021, only two new reactors are still under construction, both at Vogtle. The project has announced significant delays and budget overruns. Most of the other new builds and the equally extensive list of upgrades to existing reactors have been shelved" And the story is similar in the UK. (NB. that's not saying "one outage in a year" it's saying "an outage lasting at least a year".) Nuclear power has not had the 70 years of intense funding, competition, year on year improvement that computing has had. There's fewer nuclear plants now in the UK and USA than there were in the heyday. Yes civilian nuclear tech and military tech will have improved somewhat, but the idea that we just wait 70 years of not running nuclear reactors in remote hostile places and now suddenly we'll be much better at it doesn't sound very plausible. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_cancelled_nuclear_reactors_in_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_cancelled_nuclear_reac...
- stevenjgarner 4y agoAmongst other things, it would provide for powering installations on the dark side of the moon where there is no solar power.
- coding123 4y agoThe "Dark side of moon" gets sunlight. That's just what we call it because it never faces us.
- stevenjgarner 4y agoYou're right of course. Bad choice of words. I was meaning the the moon's "Permanently Shadowed Regions" [1] [1] https://moon.nasa.gov/resources/97/the-moons-permanently-shadowed-regions/ https://moon.nasa.gov/resources/97/the-moons-permanently-sha...
- Maursault 4y agoWhile solar obviously would not work there, is there any compelling reason to need nuclear power in those permadark locations?
- m348e912 4y agoIt's not that reactors are needed in the permadark regions, it's just they they tend to be very cold and it should be easier to dissipate heat from the reactor.
- slobotron 4y agoI thought that it's hard to radiate-away heat in vacuum?
- generalizations 4y agoDump the heat into the ground.
- nickpeterson 4y agoThey’ve gone full wallstreetbets. They’re going to the moon boys.
- speed_spread 4y agoFlylady, Fly!
- nickdothutton 4y agoIt will be interesting to see a modern design, rather that the something based on 1930s physics, 1940s construction methods, built in the 1950s and put into use in the 1960s like some of these military reactors they used for remote bases.
- aynyc 4y agoNo matter the design, it’ll be built by lowest bidders around the world. /s
- throwaway4aday 4y agoAny evidence that high bidders do a better job?
- simonh 4y agoClearly you have never heard of cost plus contracts.
- wongarsu 4y ago"Rolls-Royce plan to have a reactor ready to send to the Moon by 2029". With that deadline I would expect something closer to a proven submarine reactor adapted for an environment without abundant water and fewer convenient ways to get rid of heat.
- bayesian_horse 4y agoI'd think a similar design, or at least at a similar scale, would get ruled out by the necessary shielding. That would be quite a lot of mass to land on the moon. Some innovation is in order. Mass reduction and radiation safety are among the highest design priorities I'd say.
- imglorp 4y agoIn flight, it can be shielded with water and polyethylene, which would be needed anyway by colonists. On the surface, as someone else noted, you want good ground contact for heat dissipation so you might as well throw it into a hole and bury it, dirt being plentiful.
- mkl95 4y ago> The new boost to Rolls-Royce’s research pot follows a previous $303,495 (£249,000) study funded by the U.K. Space Agency in 2022 > helping to create jobs across our £16 billion space tech sector If the space tech sector is £16bn, why is it news that some corporation (£13bn+ revenue) earned a 249k grant? It reads like a Monty Python script.
- dazc 4y agoIt's just a press release
- bmgxyz 4y agoI think this means that a previous iteration of this effort had a value of £249,000. The article is mainly about the current iteration, which has some other total value that is presumably larger. It isn't clear how much the current iteration is worth, at least from the article alone. In general I agree that this might not be significant, unless the total value of the current contract is large or there are notable research or engineering results.
- wongarsu 4y agoSpecifically, this new stage of the project has £2.9 million of new funding, according to the linked press release. Still feels like pocket change, I wonder how much they can really do with that little
- convolvatron 4y agoare there any fissionable materials that can be refined on the moon?
- jandrese 4y agoThe weight of the fuel is the least of the concerns with this scheme.
- convolvatron 4y agobut getting into an accident and spraying it all over during liftoff is something of a concern
- bayesian_horse 4y agoI'd still like to know how they plan for a potential explosion of the space craft carrying the fuel inside the atmosphere. They better have a good story on that. Even if the rocket breaks up and the fuel reaches ground in perfectly sealed containers, that still doesn't mean the danger is over.
- throwaway4aday 4y agoI imagine step one is to launch from the coast heading out over the ocean. If Starship is fully operational by then it would be the obvious choice and depending on the reactor design there might be enough weight capacity to build in some extra shielding. I also wonder if the fuel can be shipped separate from the reactor.
- philipkglass 4y agoThe fuel doesn't become dangerously radioactive until after the reactor powers up for the first time. The uranium fuel is only about as toxic as something like barium or lead until the chain reaction starts generating fission products. This is in fact safer to launch than past space missions such as Pioneer, Voyager, and Cassini. Those used radiothermal generators that were far more radioactive and hazardous than a fresh reactor core.
- credit_guy 4y agoThe same plan as for all the countless cases when they sent radioisotopes in space. Perseverance and Curiosity each have 4.5 kg of Plutonium-238 on board. Did that worry you?
- bayesian_horse 4y agoYes. And the lunar reactor will require more power and thus more fuel.
- philipkglass 4y agoThe plutonium 238 fuel in RTGs has a half life of 87.7 years: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plutonium-238 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plutonium-238 Uranium 235, the fuel used in reactors, has a half life of 703.8 million years: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uranium-235 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uranium-235 This means that plutonium 238 is roughly 8 million times as radiotoxic as uranium 235, gram for gram. If this mini-reactor carries 4.5 tonnes of fuel it will be 0.012% as dangerous at launch as the power source for the Curiosity rover.
- zabzonk 4y agoThis article does not cover what I consider to be two key issues: - how to boost the mass of something like a shielded nuclear reactor to the moon? - how to extract the heat energy from the reactor? turbines (more mass)?
- jandrese 4y agoMaybe reduce the shielding requirement by burying it in regolith with only the heat exchangers exposed?
- thinkingemote 4y agoalso wondering the same. Most nuclear reactors including those in submarines (which rolls royce make) are basically steam engines.
- TheRealPomax 4y agoIf we had those answers already, there wouldn't be a project to fund to find out those answers.
- kurthr 4y agoWhen all you have is a hammer, nothing looks like low cost continuous solar power with direct conversion to electricity at the poles.
- Reason077 4y agoI guess they aren't planning to build the moon-base at the poles, which could provide access to continuous solar power nearby. The rest of the moon has long (+/- 14 day) lunar nights, and getting enough batteries or whatever to the moon to last that long is likely to be impractical/expensive.
- kurthr 4y agoBecause it's too cold there? Probably too much water ice on the poles to be interesting. https://www.nytimes.com/2020/10/26/science/moon-ice-water.html https://www.nytimes.com/2020/10/26/science/moon-ice-water.ht... oops https://web.archive.org/web/20201101003308/https://www.nytimes.com/2020/10/26/science/moon-ice-water.html https://web.archive.org/web/20201101003308/https://www.nytim...
- nonethewiser 4y ago… but why Rolls Royce? Also interesting that they didn’t pick a US nuclear company. This is obviously a boon to the contract winner. These decisions always have a political aspect to it. What does this signal? Edit: wow, massive oversight. I thought this was NASA. Nevermind! Still, the Rolls Royce choice isn’t obvious to me.
- cdot2 4y agoAlong with making fancy cars, Rolls Royce is a significant aerospace engineering company well known for their jet engines. https://www.rolls-royce.com/ https://www.rolls-royce.com/
- 8ytecoder 4y agoCar brand is owned by BMV. RR now is primarily known as a defence contractor and jet engine manufacturer (and other powerplants). To answer your original question, Rolls Royce is a major job provider in the UK. This is probably an attempt to revive it in addition to building it. A lot of these are job programs first. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rolls-Royce_Motor_Cars https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rolls-Royce_Motor_Cars
- nonethewiser 4y agoStill, I would be surprised if the US government commissioned a reactor from Pratt and Whitney.
- guiriduro 4y agoMore relevant for this case is that they are also involved in Submarine propulsion, which usually means nuclear. So I would guess that they have significant experience.
- fogforthought93 4y agoThis reads like a madlib, it can't be serious. Who's embezzling money here?
- FredPret 4y agoFirst my pocket computer hugely outperforms my 90’s desktop, space rockets get privatized and much cheaper, there’s probably an actual AI online, and now we’re putting a nuclear reactor on the moon. Awesome! (I hope)
- Reptur 4y agoCan we build them for earth too? We need to quit oil yesterday.
- philipkglass 4y agoThe largest terrestrial consumer of oil is road transport (cars and trucks). https://www.statista.com/statistics/307194/top-oil-consuming-sectors-worldwide/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/307194/top-oil-consuming... You can't put a nuclear reactor in a car. You can charge an electric car's battery using nuclear electricity, of course. But if you're just charging a terrestrial battery then nuclear power's attractive attributes for the Moon (like continuing to produce during a 14 day period of darkness) are less salient. Electricity sources like wind and solar power are likely to charge up the car's battery at lower cost.
- Reptur 4y agoYou can't put a nuclear reactor in a car. You can charge an electric car's battery using nuclear electricity, of course. But if you're just charging a terrestrial battery then nuclear power's attractive attributes for the Moon (like continuing to produce during a 14 day period of darkness) are less salient. Electricity sources like wind and solar power are likely to charge up the car's battery at lower cost. You don't need batteries if the energy is readily available throughout the route. Examples: 1. Buses that use capacitors https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Capacitor_electric_vehicle https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Capacitor_electric_vehicle 2. Trains / Bullet Trains / Trolleys that could have that energy along their line. Car dependency could be rapidly reduced if we truly wanted.
- CiaranMcNulty 4y agoYeah car and road-centric culture holds a lot of this stuff back. In any urban area an efficient metro underground/elevated/tram metro system could take up a huge percentage of journeys. If high-speed electrified rail links exist between cities, they can become much more attractive than long car trips. On-demand transit can fill a lot of gaps in rural areas (e.g. on-demand bus routing)
- ravagat 4y agoThat's cool