6 ms·
Not sure what the purpose of the question is. If you don't want to do the take home test, tell the company just that. You aren't going to hurt anyone's feeling
by paxys 4y ago
Not sure what the purpose of the question is.
If you don't want to do the take home test, tell the company just that. You aren't going to hurt anyone's feelings. You don't have to be overly polite about it or think of excuses. No one there is going to care.
They will just move on and hire someone else. You can move on and apply somewhere else. That's all.
- sokoloff 4y agoExactly, this seems like a total non-problem. "No thanks. <send>"
- jodrellblank 4y agoThe purpose of the question is to avoid triggering "they will just move on and hire someone else". As you well know. (and evidenced by "I will also state that they can check out some of the previous code I have written on my GitHub." where the candidate still wants the company to keep considering them after declining the test.)
- tensor 4y agoWhether or not you think a take home test is appropriate, it would be unethical of the company to let some candidates skip it. Every candidate should be evaluated the same way.
- JohnFen 4y agoI don't really think that it would be unethical for a company to not have a uniform evaluation like that. It would be unwise, but not unethical.
- rrobukef 4y agoWhy would this be? The goal of the test is to have a minimal baseline. Considering outside proof of this baseline is not unethical. If maybe it shouldn't be used to rank candidates, but you'd probably do this anyway for the final consideration.
- JohnFen 4y ago> The goal of the test is to have a minimal baseline. How do you know that's the goal of the test?
- lukas099 4y agoEven if it's not specifically that, if the company thinks you are the best available candidate (by whatever criteria they have) despite your not taking the test, I don't see how it's unethical for them to hire you.
- SkyBelow 4y agoWhy would it be ethical that every candidate has to go through the entire evaluation process? It would be possible that a candidate can demonstrate mastery of skill enough that they don't need to go through the same evaluation as one unable to demonstrate the same mastery. A take home test for those who don't commit code to github doesn't seem unethical. Much like how most candidates likely don't even get the chance to take the take home test because they were already eliminated.
- nebulousthree 4y agoPerhaps your reaction to the test is part of the test too. If you do it, you'll be evaluated on your technical performance, and if you refuse you've simply answered another question they might have about you, albeit a non-technical one. Completing the test might signal compliance, which might be exactly what they're filtering for.
- DonsDiscountGas 4y agoRight and if 90% of the candidates decline and the ultimate hire ends up being less than ideal, the company will (or they should) re-evaluate whether it's a good idea.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- lapcat 4y ago> Whether or not you think a take home test is appropriate, it would be unethical of the company to let some candidates skip it. Every candidate should be evaluated the same way. Ask yourself how the company founders and initial employees got their jobs. Almost certainly not by going through their ex post facto, arbitrarily selected in-house hiring process. Was that unethical? IMO there's actually nothing wrong with hiring the first qualified applicant who shows up, and then calling off the search. Is there an ethical obligation to hire "the best possible candidate", and why? See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Satisficing https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Satisficing Is it unethical to recruit an outside person you already know is good, and not offer an open position for everyone? It it unethical to go with an internal candidate and not offer an open position for everyone? Companies tend to waste way too much time, effort, and money on hiring. It's premature optimization, the root of all evil. Uniformity is not the same as ethics. Otherwise, we'd be ethically obligated to eliminate special parking stalls for the disabled. Moreover, there's nothing inherently ethical about any given company's uniform hiring criteria. Any given set of criteria may "discriminate" in favor of certain traits and against other traits. How do you judge the ethics of the criteria themselves, in comparison to other possible uniform criteria?
- tensor 4y ago> Ask yourself how the company founders and initial employees got their jobs. For founders this is a perk of being a founder. You are welcome to found your own company if you wish. > Is it unethical to recruit an outside person you already know is good, and not offer an open position for everyone? Yes, it can be. Especially in larger organizations that have policies around diversity and equal opportunity, it is in fact a requirement to have a large enough and representative pool of candidates.
- lapcat 4y ago> For founders this is a perk of being a founder. Yes, but that didn't answer my question about ethics. > You are welcome to found your own company if you wish. I did! > Especially in larger organizations that have policies around diversity and equal opportunity, it is in fact a requirement to have a large enough and representative pool of candidates. How often do tech companies get a "representative" pool of candidates? But this actually goes to the other issue I raised: > there's nothing inherently ethical about any given company's uniform hiring criteria. Any given set of criteria may "discriminate" in favor of certain traits and against other traits. In particular, take-home exams that take many hours to complete tend to discriminate against certain kinds of candidates, those who don't have a lot of free time outside of work, family, etc. It's important to note that these tests are primarily used by tech companies as a screening device, not as the method for making the final hiring decision, which tends to be more subjective. They don't simply add up test scores and choose the highest scorer. Moreover, the tech industry seems to be obsessed with tests, but they're an outlier. Tons of other industries use more informal methods of hiring and don't give tests at all, much less take-home tests. Do you think they're all unethical?
- EdgeExplorer 4y agoIt's also a legal minefield if you only use the test on some candidates. https://www.eeoc.gov/laws/guidance/employment-tests-and-selection-procedures https://www.eeoc.gov/laws/guidance/employment-tests-and-sele...
- paxys 4y agoI'd hope that every adult understands that unless you have any extra leverage in a situation you aren't going to get special treatment. "I know that every other candidate for the job successfully did this exercise but I found it too difficult to even set up. Can you hire me over all of them?" What do you think the company's response will be?
- slindsey 4y agoAnd I hope that every company understands that unless you offer a sane hiring practice, you aren't going to get the best developers. "Every other candidate was desperate and rejected a thousand times so they're happy to waste their time on your pointless exercise that you won't even look at." The good candidates are busy getting hired by companies that understand how to evaluate their work based on interviews, references, and several other things that don't waste their time.
- awesomeMilou 4y agoDepending on the company and current economic situation, they might just have to swallow. With the layoffs right now, employers have the upper hand and candidates are well advised to just comply and do the test. But there were also reports on HN that before the layoff wave, they'd get 2-3 applications per year for a senior position. It is of course any employers right to continue applying the same hiring standards as eg. FAANG/Big Tech would. But if I were the employer, a better strategy in such a situation would be to just swallow that I can't pick and choose if I have nothing to offer for leverage :) I'm sure you're smart enough to realize that what I'm hinting at is that the job market is a _market_ and that employees don't have to put up with every bullshit depending on the market conditions.
- sshine 4y agoI landed a job doing embedded Rust, and the company had been looking for someone to fill the role for 6 months with only one qualified applicant who bailed, and external contractors with C/C++ experience only. They surely were bad at looking, since neither they nor the recruiter consulted the local Rust meetup group. But there are starved companies looking for specialists out there even in an employers market.
- JohnFen 4y agoI don't think it's reasonable to expect that result, no matter how polite the applicant is. Every company has their own process for vetting applicants, and it's vanishingly rare that you can decide not to follow their process and still be considered for the position. I don't do these sorts of tests, personally (I even had one that they expected would take a full 40 hour workweek to complete!). If I'm presented with one, I know that in declining to do it, I am disqualifying myself for the position. It's just life. We all decide what our limits are, and in deciding those limits, we exclude some possibilities.
- ozim 4y agoWorst part is that this person wrote he already failed the test and now is looking for some shortcut.
- sshine 4y agoThey didn't fail the test yet. They spent longer time than preferred. And yes, they're looking for a shortcut. There is no way around fulfilling the task. Not revealing the time spent poses risk of impostor syndrome, risk of actually landing a very stressful job. Refusing to solve the task indicates that they would rather post-pone finding out, and rather risk rejection if it means not being challenged on their solving speed disqualifying them, because they think that it too likely would disqualify them.
- coffeebeqn 4y agoIn a fantasy land that might be the case but being one of 10-1000 people in the early funnel, you as an applicant have zero leverage. No one has a vested interest in moving you forward when you go against their process. Heck, they’re probably happy to whittle down the pool because you had an “attitude” or some other nonsense reason. Personally I prefer a take home over a full day technical whitebording on-site which is my idea of hell. But unfortunately many companies do both in the same loop instead of one or the other
- newZWhoDis 4y agoMaybe some people need to hear this though? About a month ago I had this happen: -Explained full interview process during the phase 1 call (15 min call, round table, and lastly a take-home code challenge) -they were cool with all this -they get to the end of phase II, after an hour long call with a bunch of people, and passed it/went great -they then surprised us by refusing phase III/the take home test As an employer I try to set expectations early, they acknowledged it and then proceeded to get upset when we did what we said we were going to do.
- jrootabega 4y agoWere they actually upset? Maybe the impression that things went great was really just that the candidate was diplomatic, and they were just waiting for the next excuse to exit the process. I've had phone interviews with some really bad interviewers that should have been a sign that the company may not have been a good place to work.
- darkerside 4y agoThis seems most likely. Also, why would you do a round table before a take home? Do you not value the time of your people?
- marcosdumay 4y agoMaybe because they respect the candidate's time.
- darkerside 4y agoThen you don't do an exam at all
- newZWhoDis 4y agoThey were pretty rude when they declined. I mean they made it through Phase 2 and sorta 2.5 where we confirm salary and they accepted. Everything seemed on track until the test was mentioned. If they ghosted us after the round table interview then sure, but why come back and accept a salary just to bail at the last step?
- eternalban 4y agoIt will take OP more than 3 hours to compose and post question, read all the top rated answers and comments, reach a decision, and finally write a thoughtful email. Possibly OP wanted moral support in their self-deception as to the actual issue. It is clearly not OP's valuable time that is the issue. My advice: Your first step as a candidate when given an assignment (with specific time constraints that you feel are mis-estimated), is to guestimate what you think it will take. Remember, this is exactly what happens at work with task estimation. Are you going to 'politely quit' if your manager gives you a task that can't be done in a certain time window? "I reviewed the task and my estimate is that this will take a few more hours than specified. I would like clarification if the time limit is an informative hard limit." One benefit of asking for estimate confirmation (specially for people like me who tend to go for more general solutions) is that you may actually get useful feedback. If you get a firm 'yes' from a competent team then it means they are looking for absolute simplicity in solution, and your weekend project of pimping your take home task is not only a wasted effort, it may actually take you off the list. Whatever response you get back it will be informative, sometimes even shedding light on what sort of organization you are applying to join.
- ryandrake 4y ago> It will take OP more than 3 hours to compose and post question, read all the top rated answers and comments, reach a decision, and finally write a thoughtful email. What? I like sokoloff's response[1]. It takes 3 seconds. 1: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35183583 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35183583
- thewebcount 4y ago>Not sure what the purpose of the question is. > >If you don't want to do the take home test, tell the company just that. Just a guess, but perhaps they're trying to provide some constructive feedback to the company to let them know that the time estimate they're giving to their candidates is potentially way off. (That said, maybe it's not way off for people with more experience, but the candidate doesn't get that.) It's probably futile, but I can understand the urge. If they company doesn't know a problem exists, they can't fix it (if it is an actual problem).