11 ms·
> As a professional...why not do this? Because your clients do not allow you to share their data with third parties?
by amelius 4y ago
> As a professional...why not do this?
Because your clients do not allow you to share their data with third parties?
- as300 4y agoWhat's the difference between entering in an anonymized patient history into ChatGPT and, say, googling their symptoms?
- mliker 4y agoif you enter an entire patient history, it could easily be an identifier of the person whereas Google queries have a smaller max limit number of tokens
- msikora 4y agoCan OpenAI get HIPAA certification? Perhaps offer a product that has it?
- gigel82 4y agoI've heard the Azure OpenAI service has HIPAA certification; they don't have GPT-4 yet, though.
- Godel_unicode 4y agoThe pdf on this page has the services that are under audit scope, check the table in appendix A; OpenAI is in scope for HIPAA BAA.
- pmoriarty 4y agoData that has ostensibly been "anonymized" can often be deanonymized.
- Gene_Parmesan 4y agoEspecially when the system we're discussing is literally the most advanced AI model we're aware of.
- woodson 4y agoAnonymization doesn’t just mean “leave their names out”. An entire patient's medical history is in itself personal identifiable information. Instead of googling for “headache”, they now have stored a copy of every medical detail in your life.
- dragonwriter 4y agoIf it is de-identified per HIPAA, little. OTOH, the more patient info you are putting in, the less likely it is actually legally deidentified.
- parentheses 4y agoThe data moat effect is greater with OpenAIs products.
- MagicMoonlight 4y agoWhat we really need is a model that you can run on your own hardware on site. I could never use this for business because they're reading everything you send through it, but let me run it on my own server and it would be unbelievably useful. Imagine being able to ask your workplace server if it has noticed any unusual traffic, or to write a report on sales with nice graphs. It would be so useful.
- jahewson 4y ago“on site”? Medical records are in the cloud already.
- szundi 4y agoWhat is “the cloud” - that’s the question
- gffrd 4y agoAs taken from the cover page of the July, 2018 edition of AARP Weekly.
- MisterBastahrd 4y agoYes. But they aren't being shared with third party AIs. Sharing personal medical information with OpenAI is a good way to get both your medical org to get ground into dust under a massive class action lawsuit, not to mention huge fines from the government.
- sebzim4500 4y agoWhy do you think sharing the data with OpenAI is legally any different than storing it on AWS/Azure/GCP/Whatever else they are using?
- unusualmonkey 4y agoGCP respects hipaa (google 'gcp hipaa baa'). Does OpenAPI?
- majkinetor 4y agoWhich will disappear soon enough, once it is able to run on premise.
- hanoz 4y agoI'd be furious if I found out some professional I'd commissioned had taken a document based on my own personal data, and poured over it themselves looking for errors at the tune of hundreds of dollars per hour, instead of sumbitting it to ChatGPT.
- paulryanrogers 4y agoThen why submit it to a professional human at all? If ChatGPT is prone to massive errors humans have to pour over the input anyway. If ChatGPT can make subtle, rare errors then again humans may need to be involved if the stakes are high enough to commission someone.
- msikora 4y agoAs a second opinion advisory role this seems reasonable... And also things are going to improve with time.
- glenstein 4y ago>If ChatGPT can make subtle, rare errors Yeah, I think the issues presented will relate to uniquely tricky errors, or entirely new categories of errors we have to understand the nature of. In addition to subtle and rare, I think elaborately hallucinated and justified errors, errors that become justified and reasoned for with increasing sophistication, is going to be a category of error we'll have to deal with. Consider the case of making fake but very plausible sounding citations to research papers, and how much further AI might be able to go to backfill in it's evidence and reasons. Anyway, I just mean to suggest we will have to contend with a few new genres of errors
- seydor 4y agoI assume that health providers will use servers that are guaranteed not to share data with openAi
- tippytippytango 4y agoThis is the biggest thing holding gpt back. Everyone with meaningful data has their hands tied behind their back. So many ideas and the answer is “we can’t put that data in gpt” very frustrating.
- geysersam 4y agoSounds like an easy problem to solve if this is actually the case. OpenAI just has to promise they won't store the data. Perhaps they'll add a privacy premium for the extra effort, but so what?
- null_shift 4y agoAnyone that actually cares about the privacy of their data isn’t going to be satisfied with just a “promise”.
- geysersam 4y agoA legal binding agreement, whatever.
- Gene_Parmesan 4y agoStill not enough. Seriously. Once information is out there it cannot be clawed back, but legal agreements are easily broken. I worked as a lawyer for six years; there are extremely strict ethical and legal restrictions around sharing privileged information.
- Jensson 4y ago> I worked as a lawyer for six years; there are extremely strict ethical and legal restrictions around sharing privileged information. But Microsoft already got all the needed paperwork done to do these things, it isn't like this is some unsolved problem.
- sebzim4500 4y ago
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- fatihcelikbas 4y agoHow about open-source models like Flan-T5? What stops you from using them in your own cloud account or better on-prem?
- TeeMassive 4y agoYou mean like the cloud?
- pas 4y agoIt'll be a routine question, and everyone will just nod to give consent.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- ShadowBanThis01 4y agoAnd yet boatloads of people are willing to hand their phone number over to OpenAI.
- jnwatson 4y agoThen you really shouldn’t use Google Docs, or Photoshop Online, or host your emails in the cloud.
- faeriechangling 4y agoThese services now have privacy and legally complaint options nowadays, and decisions to use them get board approval. OpenAI just simply does not offer the same thing at this time. You’re stuck using Facebook’s model for the moment which is much inferior.
- thiht 4y agoYou’re saying it like you found a loophole or something but it’s not a gotcha. Yes, if you manipulate sensitive data you shouldn’t use Google Docs or Photoshop online (I’m not imaginative enough to think of a case where you would put sensitive data in Photoshop online though, but if you do, don’t) or host your emails in the cloud. I’ve worked in a moderate size company where everything was self hosted and it’s never been an issue
- selfhoster11 4y agoGoogle Docs and Photoshop Online have offline alternatives (and if you ask me, native MS Office is still the golden standard for interoperability of editable documents), and I use neither in my work or personal life. Email is harder, but I do run my own email server. For mostly network related reasons, it is easier to run it as a cloud VM, but there's nothing about the email protocol itself that needs you to use a centralised service or host it in a particular network location.
- jfoster 4y agoMS Office is just one login away from storing documents in the cloud. I bet tons of users have their documents stored in OneDrive without realizing it. https://support.microsoft.com/en-us/office/save-documents-online-8ba1f596-6bc9-4e35-99d4-e27a40037789 https://support.microsoft.com/en-us/office/save-documents-on...
- Sharlin 4y ago
- sshumaker 4y agoJust use the Azure hosted solution, which has all of Azure's stronger guarantees around compliance. I'm sure it will update with GPT-4 pricing shortly. https://azure.microsoft.com/en-us/products/cognitive-services/openai-service https://azure.microsoft.com/en-us/products/cognitive-service... (disclaimer: I work for Microsoft but not on the Azure team)
- ndm000 4y agoAgreed. The same data privacy argument was used by people not wanting their data in the cloud. When an LLM provider is trusted with a company’s data, the argument will no longer be valid.
- alfor 4y agodo you use gmail?
- jstummbillig 4y agoIn these particular circles the idea of privacy at a technical and ideological level is very strong, but in a world where the biggest companies make their money by people freely sharing data every chance they get, I doubt that most would object to an affordable way to better their chances of survival or winning a court case.
- textninja 4y agoBiggest roadblock right here. Need a private version for sure.
- netsroht 4y agoThat's why more research should be poured into homomorphic encryption where you could send encrypted data to the API, OpenAI would then run computation on the encrypted data and we would only decrypt on the output locally. I would never send unencrypted PII to such an API, regardless of their privacy policy.
- rawoke083600 4y agoIs that any different then sending you patient down the hall to get an MRI from a 3rd-party-practise operating inside the hospital ? (honest question, I don't know ?)