3 ms·
Why do people act like the tax's is greater than the cash flow, like it's some unthinkable crime to pay tax.
by cyanydeez 4y ago
Why do people act like the tax's is greater than the cash flow, like it's some unthinkable crime to pay tax.
- samclearman 4y agoIn this case, the way it works is: 1. You exercise your options, for a paper gain of millions of dollars 2. However, you can't actually sell the shares (there are likely contractual restrictions on selling them, and even if not, there's not a liquid market) 3. So you have to pay millions of dollars of taxes even though your cash flow is zero. And before you say "but they're ISOs", there's no such thing as ISO's under AMT so it doesn't help at all.
- chii 4y ago> for a paper gain of millions of dollars which is why this part should never have been taxed. Until there's a sale of those shares, the price is merely an estimate and thus is not and should not be considered the FMV.
- samclearman 4y agoNot sure what you mean by "should" here, but the IRS definitely considers it to be a gain that you have to pay taxes on, regardless of whether you can sell the shares.
- zamnos 4y agoYes that's exactly the problem. Why does it seem okay for the IRS to demand a million dollars from someone who has no way to pay that? Like, doesn't that seem like something is wrong/broken somewhere? There's a cottage industry of loan sharks who will lend people money so they can pay, but how about instead the IRS not take money from people who don't yet, and may not ever, actually have the money to pay, until they, y'know, have the ability to pay off that tax bill.
- Keyframe 4y agoWould I own tax then on the classic car I bought 20 years ago which is now worth 10x the buying price and I can actually sell it for that, even though if I won't sell it?
- refurb 4y agoNo, because the IRS has special rules about exercised options being recognized as income in the year they were exercised.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- georgeecollins 4y agoA tax deferred is a tax avoided. I can take any financial gain and turn it into a "paper profit". So those have to be taxed. PS: I feel for these employees. My question is: Did they have the same access to the secondary market as the founder?
- chii 4y ago> I can take any financial gain and turn it into a "paper profit" if you did, you would not have access to make use of those "paper profits" for consumption - it would remain an investment. This makes taxing it egregious imho.
- seattle_spring 4y agoBecause in this case they're going to be taxed on money they can't, and possibly won't ever, be able to access. It's like being required to pay tax on lottery winnings before you get a chance to enter the lottery.
- polishdude20 4y agoWhy is that even treated as income then? That's like the government asking for more taxes from me because I have the potential to make money in the future if I'm lucky.
- akhosravian 4y agoBecause shares in a company represents something of value. Just because a company’s shares are privately held doesn’t make them worthless. The IRS has ways to estimate valuations of privately held companies. The problem unique to folks likely to be reading here is the exponential growth that can happen in early stage start ups. The options might’ve represented 100k in value when they were granted, but grown to 1m in value by the time they vested. If you exercise you owe ~300k in taxes. Even if you have that cash the exercised shares could become worth 0 and you’ll just be out the money.
- liketochill 4y agoIf they become worth zero do you not have a capital loss to deduct from future income? So you would gradually recover the tax paid when you got the now worthless shares in the form of future taxes you don’t have to pay.
- akhosravian 4y agoYou would have a capital loss to carry forward, and this is part of why the current rules aren’t great for people who aren’t already wealthy. If the tax bill is a big chunk of your net worth it makes it hard to take advantage of what might be a great opportunity.
- 4y ago
- alvah 4y agomainly because the tax is greater than the cash flow?
- refurb 4y agoThe tax is greater than the cash flow because stock you can't sell provides $0 in cash flow.