13 ms·
"Who owns private home security footage" I do. DIY on-site only system. Pretty simple really - stop using third party vendors for data storage. They're cheap
by giantg2 4y ago
"Who owns private home security footage"
I do. DIY on-site only system.
Pretty simple really - stop using third party vendors for data storage. They're cheap and easy because your data is usually the product. Sure, you would still be forced to comply with warrants/subpoenas if they think you have data, but that's basically unescapable.
- anonu 4y agoIs there a home solution as easy as Nest or Ring and which offers the same feature set?
- gresrun 4y agoUniFi Protect[0] is a decent on-prem solution and has all the main features of Nest/Ring. Certainly expensive though, minimal system for a doorbell cam is $199 for the camera[1] + $199 for the smallest NVR[2]. [0]: https://ui.com/camera-security https://ui.com/camera-security [1]: https://store.ui.com/collections/unifi-protect-cameras/products/uvc-g4-doorbell https://store.ui.com/collections/unifi-protect-cameras/produ... [2]: https://store.ui.com/collections/unifi-protect/products/unifi-cloudkey-plus https://store.ui.com/collections/unifi-protect/products/unif...
- schwank 4y agoI use UniFi devices throughout my home but the cameras (G3 specifically) are buggy and frequently disconnect, and don't auto reconnect. Basically useless. Over the year end holidays I was traveling and set one up to monitor my front yard. There was actually an incident while I was gone and I remoted in to find the camera offline, totally missed it when it should have had perfect perspective. The police asked me for video and in this case I would have shared it, but alas could not. Sucks as I have the CloudKey box for video storage, but its very undependable in my experience.
- Axsuul 4y agoWould you not recommend UniFi then? Will you be migrating to another system?
- zrail 4y agoI have a smallish Protect system (UNVR, four G4 Pros, one doorbell, two G3 Instants). The positives are that it pretty much just works. The mobile app is excellent, the web app on the UNVR is fine, and it has full spousal approval factor. I have had very few issues with the system, primarily just the doorbell was unreliable until I upgraded the transformer and put an access point right next to it. I had an issue with the NVR right before it went out of warranty and I fixed it by replacing the internal USB drive with an SSD. The negatives are that it's more costly than other options, Ubiquiti has had perennial stock problems over the last few years, and you're locked into their ecosystem. The NVR won't work with generic cameras and you can't run the software on your own hardware. It's also possible that, if you have their remote access proxy set up (required for mobile app), you could be subject to the same warrant issues as with Ring.
- schwank 4y agoThe Access Points, PoE switch, and firewall work fine. My only dissatisfaction has been the G3 camera. As others have stated its a big investment so not moving off the ecosystem today. However when its time to upgrade everything I will certainly shop around.
- zrail 4y agoThis has not been my experience with mostly G4 pro hardwired PoE cameras. I have their G4 doorbell and did have similar problems until I upgraded its transformer and pointed an access point directly at it. Been smooth sailing ever since.
- arrosenberg 4y agoThis has been my experience. In a year of use I've had 0 problems with PoE cameras and maybe 2-3 disconnects on the doorbell over wifi.
- alistairSH 4y agoAren't most of those PoE (the doorbell being the exception - appears powered by regular doorbell power supply)? So, you have to run cables to each camera. Not an easy undertaking for most.
- sirwally 4y agoas easy as plug and play? not really. blueiris(windows) & securityspy(macOS) offer similar features, but it takes a bit of setup to add the cams via RTSP/ONVIF, configure storage and retention, configure monitoring schedules/alerts etc..
- WaitWaitWha 4y ago> as easy This is a very subjective area. As I noted you can get all kinds of NVRs with notification and cameras, others have mentioned Ubiquiti, Roku is also getting into the home automation field, and of course there are open source solutions like Home Assistant.
- giantg2 4y ago"Is there a home solution as easy as Nest or Ring and which offers the same feature set?" I highly doubt it, for the fact that many of the features are incompatible with the goal of privacy and convenience. There are plenty of on-site options that offer the bulk of the benefits, like self contained NVR systems. Once you want things like texts, web access, etc then it gets tricky. Those typically aren't offered in a secure and easy way.
- bobleeswagger 4y agoFrigate takes 5 minutes to setup and try. There's really no excuse these days but these companies will keep walling-up their gardens.
- jjeaff 4y agoI use frigate and like it. But it did take me a few hours to figure out all the right config file settings for my 3 cameras and then figure out how to configure storage settings and the like. And that's not counting the fact that I already have experience with docker and Linux systems and already had a running server with docker containers launched from a docker compose file. In other words, frigate is not for the 99%.
- hapticmonkey 4y agoApple HomeKit’s secure video is end to end encrypted and very easy to set up. You need compatible devices though.
- wjamesg 4y agoI agree, but it’s not so evident or easy for the average person. Who wants to deal with managing storage? Cloud will typically win for the masses, who are typically not thinking about privacy and may not know the difference between a SSD and HDD
- WaitWaitWha 4y agoI agree many are not willing, but I disagree that it is not "easy for the average person". One can walk into a local supermarket on any planet(e.g., Walkmart, Sam's Club, Carrefour, Aldi, Tesco, Auchan) and likely be able to pick up a self-managed NVR with cameras. If it was not relatively easy, I do not believe these companies would carry them. You are right, many are not willing.
- bcrosby95 4y agoI've long wondered why something like a general computing device maintenance service hasn't become a thing. I guess cloud storage stepped in and removed the need. When my AC unit broke I didn't need to know the finer decisions surrounding which unit to choose. I have weekly visits from the pool guy for a pool and gardener for the landscaping. A yearly termite check and AC/furnace maintenance. And so on.
- swatcoder 4y agoYour pool, landscaping, and traditional appliances are all fairly mature and stable in a way that lets local workers learn basic, repurposeable maintenance skills that last a long time and cover a large number of clients. We won’t have that for home compute appliances until hardware/interface innovation slows down, and that’d actually been trending in the other direction for a while now. It will stabilize, even while innovation happens at other layers, but core stability plays a huge role in what you have in mind here. Cloud stuff basically hid that that stuff on the other side of a pipe for a while, but has its own drawbacks and we’re likely seeing the start of a turn away from it.
- rlyshw 4y ago
- uoaei 4y agoThe allure of convenience makes a lot of people blind to what's going on outside their small bubble of awareness. I see it a lot in the boomers around me.
- JohnFen 4y agoThat's hardly something boomers are more prone to than anybody else.
- uoaei 4y agoI disagree. How your life proceeds for the first 5-10 years of your life has a strong influence on your general outlook on life. Obviously it is not a 1:1 correlation, but it is by now a widely accepted trusim that children born into famine come out with much different perspectives on life than those born into surplus. The strong economic growth during the postwar period created a culture with a truly utopian outlook on how technology is applied to improving lives. There was not the recognition there is today that it is possible (indeed, common) to consume resources at an unsustainable, destructive, rate, nor to comprehend the magnitudes and qualities of the effects that our consumption and pollution could have on the quality of life of future generations. Peopple born in the last 40 years have weathered the effects of Reaganomics on the economies of the world. People born in the past 10-20 years have felt the ramifications of a massive recession during the early years of their lives. All the above-mentioned people are by now old enough to know who is to blame for those massive failures. This has apparently engendered a more cynical, or at least skeptical, perspective on how the future might proceed based on our current trajectory, compared to the more techno-utopian visions of the mainstream boomer mindset.
- JohnFen 4y agoAnd yet, people younger than the boomer set trade convenience for privacy and such all the time. Just look at social media use alone. From what I can see, all generations are equally likely to trade some amount of personal freedom for convenience. The exact things they're willing to trade may or may not be different, but the principle seems a constant.
- teawrecks 4y agoI agree, but still, I don't think it was appropriate for the judge to approve this warrant. Just because person X is suspected of a crime doesn't justify a search/seizure from person Y who just happens to be nearby at the time. Imagine a police officer legally searching your car just because the car next to you was suspected of a crime. It's just not reasonable. I hope the EFF or someone can help push back on this.
- kshacker 4y agoAre these examples even comparable? A camera can provide direct evidence.
- JohnFen 4y agoI think they're comparable. Both are the police searching the private property of an innocent bystander.
- bell-cot 4y agoAnalogy - if it was 1950, a robber fled on foot through a residential neighborhood, and he no longer had the wad of stolen money when the police finally got grabbed him - would it be reasonable for the police to search in the shrubbery, groundhog holes, loose dirt, sandboxes, etc. of the private property in that residential neighborhood for the stolen money? Does your answer change if, instead of stolen money, the police are looking for the robber's weapon, or the victim's empty wallet, or some other "we have good reason to suspect that he ditched it somewhere around here" evidence?
- JohnFen 4y ago> would it be reasonable for the police to search Yes. And my answer would not change for the other case. It's also reasonable for the property owner to demand that the police get a warrant first. I'm not arguing about whether or not these powers are OK. I'm just arguing that, in my view, both of the situations the OP mentioned are equivalent in that they're both searches of private property.
- wara23arish 4y agoHave any links related to what you’re using and what to recommend?
- scrappyjoe 4y agoWhen I went through this vueville had enough info for me to build an intuition for what to look for on Amazon. https://www.vueville.com/home-security/cctv/ip-cameras/ultimate-ip-camera-buying-guide/ https://www.vueville.com/home-security/cctv/ip-cameras/ultim...
- jszymborski 4y agoReolink cameras are pretty affordable, can be accessed with ONVIF, and you can just put them on a VLAN/Firewall that has no internet access if you're afraid that it's phoning home. I have a Synology NAS and their free security camera software is pretty easy to set-up and use with ONVIF cameras.
- ortusdux 4y agoPOE cameras paired with either an NVR or custom server. I prefer wired cameras and local storage.
- giantg2 4y agoNo actual links, but ReoLink PoE cameras, a miniPC, PoE switch, Zoneminder, 2TB SSD, external enclosure, and backup UPS.
- liotier 4y agoA more contemporary alternative to ZoneMinder would be Shinobi: https://shinobi.video/ https://shinobi.video/
- tastysandwich 4y agoHow have you found Shinobi versus Zoneminder? I've been using ZoneMinder for years. It's a bit clunky but once it's set up it works fairly well, but I'd be open to switching to something better.
- Ralo 4y agoI host my own on-site and have had my security footage requested by police 4 different times. It's never a subpoena or demanding. Just some detectives will stop by and say they want to know which direction a vehicle went. They come inside, give me a USB stick and we copy it over. I'm sure I could tell them to kick rocks, and they would have to write up a subpoena but there's no reason to do that.
- iotku 4y ago>I'm sure I could tell them to kick rocks, and they would have to write up a subpoena but there's no reason to do that Would they have the right to subpoena you though? Over mere suspicion that they think a vehicle at some point drove a certain direction? Sure if it was a case involving me personally I'd probably be cooperative, but I don't fancy the idea of just letting LEOs just waltz into my property to "just to take a look"
- Ralo 4y agoLegally, I'm not sure. I could say they aren't working, or they're fake etc. My neighbor has fake cameras and he gets asked too but they just leave it at that and never press it.
- giancarlostoro 4y agoYeah I have zero issue doing this, it costs me nothing, and if it helps keep others accountable for their actions even better.
- hsbauauvhabzb 4y agoI’m not saying don’t help the police but I think it’s worth acknowledging that point of view when applied en made is how we end up with policies attempting to back door encryption etc. I think making sure some decision basis should be applied (there was a break in, commotion, and a car speed chase which ended here is much different to ‘we just wanna see if this car drove past’)
- koheripbal 4y agoI use Blue Iris. Cheap and easy.
- dheera 4y agoI use Unifi's security cameras at home, they store all data on your own disks on-site. Owning footage is only half the story, privacy is also a big issue for me, I don't want images of my home being sent to corporations even if I own all rights to it. The only downside I can think of is that a really advanced thief might know to pull the hard drives and walk with them, but I suspect most residential thieves aren't that smart or wouldn't know what disk to pull from my rack. The other downside for less techy people is that without the cloud it's not that simple to view your home from a remote location. I just VPN into my home network and view it, but it took some effort to set that up, especially with dynamic DNS and all.
- dahart 4y agoHave you tried TailScale for the remote access part?
- jjav 4y ago> I do. DIY on-site only system. Agreed, that's the only way to build a secure system. I have some outdoor cameras but they are on a physically separate network and can't talk to anything. Also, they are on ethernet but because they also support wifi I physically cut the antenna connections because I'm not about to trust the manufacturer of the camera to not try to exfiltrate something. But sadly this is, while not difficult, too much for the non-techie person to do. So people just buy Ring cameras with all the associated privacy problems. The worst is that while my system is secure, many of the surrounding neighbors have ring cameras outside so I can't protect from those!
- ClumsyPilot 4y ago> physically cut the antenna connections because I'm not about to trust the manufacturer of the camera to not try to exfiltrate something This is not normal - there is no other industry where the customer routinely expects to be defrauded, and everyone to get away with it.
- loeg 4y agoWell, there's crypto.
- throwawaylinux 4y agoIs a pyramid scheme really an industry though?
- ClumsyPilot 4y agoDid someome say Housing?
- loeg 4y agoYou can't live in a bitcoin. Unlike housing, or land, which clearly have some value, the inherent value of crypto is $0. All prices are purely speculative.
- rtkwe 4y agoIn this case even that might not have solved the issue because the cops got a warrant for EVERY camera on the person's account including those inside the house that couldn't reasonably show evidence of the thing they were investigating.
- r3trohack3r 4y ago> EVERY camera on the person's account including those inside the house that couldn't reasonably show evidence of the thing they were investigating. Armchairing it here - these broad warrants are probably carry over from the days where you'd issue a single warrant for "the tapes" since every camera in the system recorded onto a single shared medium. Like GP, I have a personal offline system with remote backups that I control. The footage all goes onto a single shared HDD for all the cameras like the old "tape" days. A warrant would likely ask for that HDD - not the footage from a specific camera.
- rtkwe 4y agoThat doesn't really change that even though you're completely uninvolved in the investigation as a target suddenly you've got cops examining the recordings of the interior of your house. Exterior recordings are at least often of nominally publicly viewable areas barring things like fences. Either way though I'm not that inclined to give the cops a pass for being lazy about the warrant writing just because it's the old way, warrants should be minimally invasive, particularly so for people NOT INVOLVED in the crime under investigation.
- JohnFen 4y agoThe main advantage to having this data yourself rather than being held by a third party is that you have a chance to push back if you have it yourself. If you get a subpoena that you believe is overly broad, you can take the matter before a judge and argue your case. As I understand it, this can be quite effective in narrowing the scope. It's not perfect, of course, but it's better than having no say whatsoever.
- StrangeATractor 4y agoDo you have outdoor cameras? What did you do for weatherproofing?
- hot_gril 4y ago> stop using third party vendors for data storage No. I need a system that detects motion during scheduled times (ideally only humans) and buzzes my phone instantly, giving me a live view and saving a recording around that time. And most of all, it has to be reliable enough that I don't question whether it's working. Anyone who says this is easy is underestimating it. Something on-prem could do all that, but nobody sells it, and most DIY systems don't have those features (does yours?). So here I am with the Ring.
- wyager 4y agoYou can do all that locally with Frigate, FYI
- hot_gril 4y agoYeah, Frigate is pretty cool, but here are the moving parts: https://docs.frigate.video/frigate/hardware/ https://docs.frigate.video/frigate/hardware/ and https://docs.frigate.video/guides/ha_notifications/ https://docs.frigate.video/guides/ha_notifications/ . I don't trust that to all work without maintenance.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- tohnjitor 4y agoUnifi Protect can do that on-prem. Remote access is optional.
- Salgat 4y agoUbiquiti does that. I have motion detection alerts disabled but human motion detection enabled depending on the camera. You can also set regions in the view that it ignores for motion detection.
- hot_gril 4y agoTech-savvy people say great things about Ubiquiti wifi, but my experience was that it's way more annoying to deal with than the AirPorts I was replacing. So I have doubts about relying on their security solution to "just work," but maybe I'll give it a try. And sure I'm tech-savvy, but I also don't want to deal with things. The real test is at my parents' house, where I don't live but I manage some of their stuff remotely / occasionally in person. I can't babysit whatever gets installed, and they don't understand computers. Like, whenever their internet was having problems, they'd only know how to reboot the router; eventually they automated this task with a lamp timer. But they were fine managing the Ring once I set it up.
- SkyBelow 4y ago>Sure, you would still be forced to comply with warrants/subpoenas if they think you have data, but that's basically unescapable. Isn't there the standard work around that companies do of having scheduled deletion. As long as the deletion is scheduled and not in response to a legal request, what is gone is gone and not a crime. If you receive a warrant you might have to stop further deletion, but what they want is likely already gone.
- slowhand09 4y agoI have a ring doorbell and I detest it. But my wife wants it. Since you have your own system, would you be willing to share links to info on a "roll your own" system?
- pkulak 4y agoNot OP, but I _love_ talking about this stuff, so you're stuck with me. :D I'm a big fan of this project: https://frigate.video/ https://frigate.video/ It's open source, and you can hook it up to a Coral (or some other things, I think) to get crazy-fast classifications. But CPU is fine for only a few cameras. Once you get something like that setup, it's just a matter of finding cameras that support RTSP. You get them setup however you like (but preferably wired, with PoE), point Frigate at the RTSP stream, and that's it. Now you've got home security footage that never leaves your house. You can set up a VPN to watch the feeds from elsewhere. Frigate supports MQTT as well, so you can hook it into Home Assistant to get notifications, and even pipe person events into something like Double Take to get face detection: https://github.com/jakowenko/double-take https://github.com/jakowenko/double-take EDIT: Oh, and the most important part is to have your security cameras on a totally separate network that doesn't have access to your internal network or the internet. The best cameras are from China, and you don't want to give them any opportunities.
- _rs 4y agoOne of my problems is finding reputable good quality cameras that are ideally dumb and just provide an RTSP stream. Of course, I'll throw them on their own VLAN and isolate them from the internet, but I want something with good image quality and ideally doesn't require an app or Windows to setup Another issue is finding all of these projects and choosing the right ones that'll receive long term support and making sure the pipeline (Camera -> NVR -> Frigate -> ? -> Home Assistant?) doesn't break and stays up to date. A lot of moving parts, and last time I looked it was hard to find a good NVR with Linux support that also has a decent web app (and even better if it has a native mobile app)
- pkulak 4y ago
- ChrisMarshallNY 4y agoI have a pretty decent outdoor camera system, because I actually wrote some ONVIF software, and got them for testing. I will not use an external server. The cameras are in an internal DMZ, and no ports are open. I have a Synology server, recording the video. But the convenience (and well-written apps) for Ring and Nest cameras is hard to argue with. People don't care about this kind of thing, if they can pull up video of their dog taking a dump in the living room, while they are sitting at a bar with you.
- jojobas 4y agoIt's the convenience of a farm feeding trough versus having to search for food in the forest.
- ChrisMarshallNY 4y agoStealing that!
- Johnny555 4y ago> I do. DIY on-site only system The police can still subpoena that footage and if they do, you can’t legally destroy it. If you’ve got the money, you can fight the subpoena and you can be sure that they can’t bypass you and get the footage while your fighting it, but you better preserve it and don’t let it age out if your NVR in case you lose the fight.
- pixl97 4y agoThis is how laws have worked for centuries at this point in the US. At least with this method you have the option of fighting it and the data isn't secretly used behind your back. Also you can force them to clearly define what data they need, like front porch, rather than as much as they can get.
- Johnny555 4y agoYes, as I said if you have the money (a big if and whether you win or lose, you can’t recover that money ) you can fight it, but can you really say you “own” your data if you can be forced to give it up?
- compiler-guy 4y agoOf course. Just like I own my car but if I violate certain laws it may be confiscated. If "can't be forced to give it up by normal legal processes" is your standard for what it means to own something, there is very little in the world that you do actually own. So little, in fact that the concept doesn't mean much at all.
- Johnny555 4y agoBut you can have your video footage taken without you having violated any laws or even have any relation at all to the reason they want the footage, the cops can say "We think there's something we want to see on your camera feed, now give it to us", and as long as they have reasonable suspicion that there's footage related to an investigation, they'll get it.
- asveikau 4y agoIf they get a warrant like the story in this article you'll still have to hand it over. The fact that it's not on a popular cloud camera provider may make it harder for them to discover what it is they need to request, but they can still do it and you could still be compelled to comply. In that case I would kind of rather they go to a megacorp vs. me needing to get a lawyer and figure out how to respond. But generally I agree that it's sketchy for a third party to hold the data.
- ocdtrekkie 4y agoI strongly disagree. If they have to serve you a warrant for the data, you know they've requested it. This is rarely true if they can serve a warrant to a cloud provider for your data. Since the likelihood is footage from your home is to investigate you or your family, knowledge of the data demand in itself is potentially invaluable, as you can begin forming a defense.
- lazide 4y agoAlso, not that anyone would do it, but 'oops, it caught on fire' is much more doable when it's all under your control and they don't even know what you have, rather than in some audited cloud providers backend. Which has pros and cons.
- egberts1 4y agoYou claim 24-hour deletion policy for liability reason. Cannot chase what you don't have.
- giantg2 4y agoYou shouldn't really need a lawyer. The megacorp will just hand over all the data, in which case you could too to avoid the legal fees. The benefit is like you said, less likely they go to you since they don't know you have anything, vs them seeing a map of all the Ring users.
- asveikau 4y agoThat's what I'm saying, if they want footage on my hard drive they need to approach me and i need a lawyer, if they go after Ring then I don't need to incur costs and life stress of dealing with that bullshit. That's all assuming the cops understand I'm not involved or committing crimes. As indicated in your sibling comment, that may not be the case and having my own representation would be needed. It's shitty situations all around frankly.
- redeeman 4y ago> but that's basically unescapable. or you destroy the evidence.. sure, the regime may come after you, but they cant get what they want
- Jenda_ 4y ago> Sure, you would still be forced to comply with warrants/subpoenas if they think you have data, but that's basically unescapable. Can you claim protection against self-incrimination?
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 4y agoMuch easier for the party seeking footage to subpoena a large, third party repository than to subpoena individual citizens. The mere existence of large repositories of recorded footage invites parties to subpoena them. No need to locate individuals with useful footage and deal with each separately. Just go to Ring. Same with third party email providers. The use of third parties for email makes warrants and subpoenas much more convenient. Just go to Google. These are one stop shops for getting peoples' data. Why store private data on removable media disconnected from the internet. Put it on social media or in the cloud so it's easier for law enforcement to get a copy. They can subpoena the social media or cloud provider. It's better if people do not know when the third party is giving their data to law enforcement.