29 ms·
Who owns private home security footage, and who can get access to it?
- lionkor 4y agoI dont want to be that guy, but who didnt know this would eb possible and would happen?
- altairprime 4y agoJudges can do absolutely anything, once, if someone decides not to object at the time. Recall campaigns for judges exist in a lot of American jurisdictions. Such is warranted here. If it’s recognized that rubber-stamping Ring requests can and has lead to a recall being presented to voters, judges will in general take more care to consider the request in the future.
- shapefrog 4y ago> They amount to a large and unregulated web of eyes on American communities — which can provide law enforcement valuable information in the event of a crime, but also create a 24/7 recording operation that even the owners of the cameras aren’t fully aware they’ve helped to build. They drew this conclusion from a court order being served upon people who had selected "record everything" when they set up their surveillence camera?
- barbazoo 4y agoBecause no one understands how those features they're paying for work. People want everything to be convenient and "cheap". Ring isn't cheap, it just appears so if you look at it per month. That's why we end up with that privacy nightmare that's Ring. People with different priorities buy different hardware that's more complicated to set up and more expensive but keeps the sensitive data local.
- shapefrog 4y ago> Because no one understands how those features they're paying for work In my experience they know exactly how they work, they want to record everything that happens in the street infront of their house - that is litterally what happens. Is ring etc really much more of a privacy nightmare than any other cctv? Given the wide spread use, it is easier for police to do a blanket request, but back in ye olde days the officer would stand there, look around and see all the cameras and go make requests where they saw one. End result is identical, its the same thing with a few extra steps.
- barbazoo 4y agoIt's a set of hurdles that I think wouldn't hurt. Plus more reasonable retention periods to limit the impact on the people around them. I think that would be positive. At least that way police have to intentionally select which cameras to pursue instead of just asking Ring for data on an entire neighborhood what I assume is happening now.
- JohnFen 4y agoThose extra steps can often make all the difference in the world in terms of privacy protection. I object to every public place being monitored by CCTV. I would have less of an objection to every public place having a uniformed officer instead. If nothing else, at least then it would be obvious when you're being watched, so you wouldn't have to be on guard every moment.
- ROTMetro 4y agoThat would be a great augmented reality app. Show a virtual officer standing everywhere there are cameras.
- BeetleB 4y ago> Because no one understands how those features they're paying for work. Everyone I know who owns a Ring does. They don't care. Convenience always wins. People who put privacy and related rights above convenience are the exception.
- yborg 4y agoI don't understand what you find confusing about this. If a court can order that all camera footage from a citizen be provided to law enforcement at any time for any reason (in the case cited the individual wasn't a suspect, he just happened to have an external camera that might have shown an actual suspect) then you have a surveillance infrastructure. The citizen in question got tired of doing the police's job for them as they widened their dragnet, so they just demanded his entire account from Ring, which included cameras inside his home. Which Ring provided without hesitation, and the best part is that they paid for this "service".
- dangoor 4y agoThis is why the only cameras I've bought have been ones that support HomeKit Secure Video, which is end-to-end encrypted: https://www.digitaltrends.com/home/why-you-should-use-homekit-secure-video/ https://www.digitaltrends.com/home/why-you-should-use-homeki... It limits the choices, and they tend to be a bit pricier, but the tradeoff seemed reasonable.
- shapefrog 4y agoYou could still be served a court order to hand over the footage, it is just a couple of steps harder than the one stop shop that is Ring / Amazon.
- barbazoo 4y agoAs long as it's within the retention period of the video data. It's nuts for Ring to store the data for 180 days. If I had exterior cameras, I'd store the data for maybe a week?! However long I'd need to backup important snippets in case something happens, like a theft.
- shapefrog 4y ago> If I had exterior cameras, I'd store the data for maybe a week? Annecdata - but people I know who have cctv around their home store for as long as possible, limited only by the storage size availiable - every motion from a car / person / tree blowing through the trees - years of recordings. People are selecting 180 days on Ring as the retention period (if they could select longer they probably would), the default is 60 days.
- theloco 4y agoI use iSpy. Its free and open source and you can connect as many IP cameras to it you want. Need cloud backup? Save the videos to google drive. Need text notifications? Theres apis for that.
- bityard 4y agoIt claims to be open source but it seems to be only in name. The web site says you can use it for free for personal use, but such a claim makes it NOT open source by definition. (Source-available at best.) I had to dig really hard to find a link to github (https://github.com/ispysoftware/iSpy https://github.com/ispysoftware/iSpy) but I get the impression from the README and lack of activity that this repo was superceded by another product from the same company, and that appears to be what the main website is marketing for download/payment. And according to the license file, some rather important bits of it are not open source at all.
- schwartzworld 4y agoRelevant podcast: https://citationsneeded.libsyn.com/episode-97-porch-pirate-panic-and-the-paranoid-racism-of-snitch-apps https://citationsneeded.libsyn.com/episode-97-porch-pirate-p...
- austinkhale 4y agoI've been using UniFi cameras for a couple of years now, writing to a local SSD (~ 40 days of storage), stored in a UDMPro. The initial outlay is a bit more expensive but the setup is rock solid, provides tons of network analytics, has smart lights paired next to the cameras, and continues to work even when my ISP has issues. I've _voluntarily_ given footage to the police a couple of times but it feels much better when the entire system is within my control, sitting in my office.
- noodlesUK 4y agoI'm curious. Do you currently have Unifi remote access [1] enabled, or is any remote access done through a VPN that you control? I suspect that if a law enforcement agency were sufficiently determined, they could convince Ubiquiti to give them access to your system if you had remote access turned on. Whether this is realistic depends on your threat model. [1] https://help.ui.com/hc/en-us/articles/115012240067-UniFi-Network-Remote-Access-Requirements https://help.ui.com/hc/en-us/articles/115012240067-UniFi-Net...
- jaywalk 4y agoWith a security-minded setup, Ubiquiti would not be able to grant remote access. Whether they actually have a security-minded setup or not is the question. As a user of their stuff, I have remote access disabled. I can access everything I need through Home Assistant, which is completely controlled by me.
- nmilo 4y agoCouldn't the police in theory get a warrant for the footage on your SSDs? The problem with Ring is that they give data to police without warrants, but in this case the problem seems to be the over-invasion of privacy of the warrant system.
- pc86 4y agoIANAL but the short answer is yes. Slightly longest answer is probably, but they'd have to convince a judge that this camera has something worthwhile compared to any other cameras on that street. Somewhat paradoxically the more of your neighbors have things like Ring the "safer" you are from something like this.
- MPSimmons 4y agoThis is obviously horrible. But I'm curious, since I have an internal-only camera system - is this materially different than if the police subpoenaed his recordings directly?
- henryfjordan 4y agoThe biggest difference is that he was not the subject of the warrant, Ring was, so he didn't risk any issues about non-compliance with the warrant or anything. Ring gave him a chance to challenge the warrant but decided not to. He might've just had to write Ring a letter, though he says in the article he thought he'd need a lawyer. If he was the subject of the warrant directly then he'd need to deal with the court directly, probably requiring the help of a lawyer. Ring deals with warrants all the time though, so they are probably a good resource for challenging these kinds of things.
- fitblipper 4y agoRing doorbells providing this information to law enforcement quickly and easily is working as intended and is part of the reason it exists at all. Amazon has even used police to sell the doorbells arguing it provides better security [1]. It is great that the people who had their video data provided to law enforcement were notified after the fact in this situation. I wonder how many people never find out due to national security letters not allowing it. [1]https://www.vice.com/en/article/mb88za/amazon-requires-police-to-shill-surveillance-cameras-in-secret-agreement https://www.vice.com/en/article/mb88za/amazon-requires-polic...
- IncandescentGas 4y ago> I wonder how many people never find out due to national security letters not allowing it. There's an annoying thought. Amazon could be providing a live feed of every ring device directly to an aggregated intelligence data center, while being legally prevented from revealing that fact by a national security letter. Seems inevitable, and anybody buying a ring device should assume it as likely. Imagine the boon of having indexed facial, gait and voice recognition feeds recorded and stored for eternity covering a significant portion of residential and business locations.
- mywittyname 4y agoPresumably this evidence will eventually come to light through court proceedings. I'm not talking like one huge case, but through thousands of inconsequential small cases where an effort is not made to hide the data origin.
- JohnFen 4y ago> Presumably this evidence will eventually come to light through court proceedings. Probably not. Great effort is made to hide the use if NSLs. Instead, they engage in "parallel construction" -- reverse engineering a different way of getting the evidence they've collected, so they can use the evidence in court without revealing the NSL.
- aleksandrh 4y agoPolice: We suspect your neighbor committed a crime... You: Okay Police: ...so we're going to need all the footage from inside your home You: Wait wha— Judge: Sure, I'll sign a warrant for this. That sounds perfectly reasonable.
- mattkrause 4y agoAnd so you move to quash some or all of that request!
- hooverd 4y agoSimple as...?
- henryfjordan 4y agoMore like: Police: Hey can we get a warrant for all the Ring cameras on this street. Oh and we know for a fact that there's a guy with more exterior cameras who has refused to share footage with us. Judge: Sure, I'll sign that warrant. Nobody would be dumb enough to put Ring cameras in their house. Guy who is that dumb: I'm not going to fight the warrant even though I got a letter saying I can totally prevent my interior cameras from being included in the data Ring turns over.
- bob1029 4y agoThis kind of outcome is precisely why I removed all cameras and other smart capabilities from my home on the day I moved in. I've never once seen someone in my friend & family circle achieve some positive outcome in their own household by having more surveillance around it. The only thing I observe is increased anxiety when squirrels or FedEx trigger push notifications to phones.
- JohnFen 4y agoI recently had my place broken into and was the first thing I did was to hand the cops a memory stick with the relevant footage from my cameras on it. My system isn't managed by any companies, so nobody can be all sneaky about getting footage. But I could still provide that footage to the cops when needed. It's the best of both worlds. I should note that I have no cameras that can see any public space. They only record my private areas. I have too much respect for my neighbors to invade their privacy.
- ambicapter 4y agoDid anything come out of you handing over that footage?
- JohnFen 4y agoIt's still under active investigation. The police won't update me about progress until/unless they need to.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- squokko 4y agoDid you get your stuff back?
- JohnFen 4y agoIt's unlikely I will. But the alarm chased them off, so they took very little. I lost about $300 of stuff.
- squarefoot 4y agoNot sure if I'll be setting up CCTV at the new home this year or later, but for sure it'll be ZoneMinder based and everything, especially cameras, will be firewalled and behind their physical subnet. See: https://zoneminder.com/ https://zoneminder.com/
- anonym29 4y agoI wonder what happens if you have a DIY, FOSS, local setup with full disk encryption on the footage storage drive, and you simply refuse to give up your password for the footage. At least in some states¹ in the USA, police cannot compel you to give up a password². ¹ https://www.reuters.com/business/legal/us-supreme-court-nixes-appeal-over-forced-password-disclosure-2021-05-17/ https://www.reuters.com/business/legal/us-supreme-court-nixe... ² https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28955830 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28955830
- dfxm12 4y agoDouble check with a lawyer, but a web search suggests that at least in some jurisdictions, you can be held in civil contempt, for which you may be incarcerated for up to 18 months. https://goldsteinmehta.com/blog/limits-on-federal-civil-contempt#:~:text=The%20penalty%20for%20refusing%20to,no%20longer%20be%20held%20indefinitely https://goldsteinmehta.com/blog/limits-on-federal-civil-cont....
- anonym29 4y agoAbsolutely. Even so, it used to be the case that judges could detain people this way indefinitely. Outside of the US, many countries offer no such legal protection at all, refusing to give up a password is itself a crime, in some cases with penalties exceeding the original charges. People should absolutely familiarize themselves with the laws surrounding this in their jurisdiction even if they're doing nothing wrong - legitimately forgetting a password and defiantly refusing to share it are often treated the same way by the criminal justice system.
- JohnFen 4y agoIn my state, you could be put in jail until you give up the password.
- lrvick 4y agoThis is exactly why security footage will never be available in decrypted form except on hardware I own.
- JohnFen 4y agoThis. My security system incudes video, but that video stays with me. It's not being managed by any third party service. If the police want it, they have to ask me for it directly -- they can't go to some company and bypass my protections.
- bluGill 4y agoIf the courts find out you have the data they can demand you decrypt it, and send you to prison if you do not.
- nobody9999 4y ago>If the courts find out you have the data they can demand you decrypt it, and send you to prison if you do not. If the courts decide there's anything (physical or digital) law enforcement wants/needs, you have to turn it over or face jail[0][3] and/or fines. That's nothing new. Nor is it likely to change anytime soon. However, not being able to comply (e.g., you don't actually have such data) is a defense for contempt of court. As such, short-term retention policies and secure deletion methods would be preferred. Perhaps also with a 'canary'[2] as well, that will delete all data if some key/setting/file isn't updated within a specific period of time. Unless one has been ordered by the court (or some law on the books to retain data), this is perfectly legal. [0] Not prison. Contempt of court[1] means jail, not prison. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Contempt_of_court#United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Contempt_of_court#United_State... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Warrant_canary https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Warrant_canary -- Not exactly this (as it affects the retention/deletion of personal data rather than informing others of government involvement), but a similar idea. [3] https://www.merriam-webster.com/words-at-play/jail-vs-prison-difference https://www.merriam-webster.com/words-at-play/jail-vs-prison... Edit: Corrected punctuation.
- 4y ago
- caseysoftware 4y agoEffectively anyone. Third Party Doctrine says that once you give your data to someone else, you lose most of your rights to privacy, control, etc. It's why law enforcement doesn't NEED a warrant to go after so many things like cell phone records, bank account info, and so much more. The fact that so many companies want a warrant is usually a courtesy, not a requirement. Check out the book "Habeas Data" for the (US) legal reasoning on it. And to be clear, I think Third Party Doctrine should be wiped out and I should be able to say "you can't use, sell, share, etc my data without EXPLICIT PRIOR permission from me." Ref: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Third-party_doctrine https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Third-party_doctrine
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- anonymouse008 4y agoI wish the 2nd amendment movement had a sister group with the same vigor for the 4th amendment. What you proposed is the sensible legislation that we need to ensure our longevity as a “free society” One could almost say that aggressive opposition to this exposes a true tyrant.
- giantg2 4y agoInterestingly enough that group does tends to advocate for 4th amendment protections, at least within limited scope. Although those same concepts and case law could be applied to other areas. So it's possible to piggyback off of it. Some examples are red flag laws which use the civil system to avoid the protections of the criminal system for the government to seize property (beyond a reasonable doubt, right to representation, ex parte protections, etc). Police stopping, questioning, and sometimes seizing guns (property) without any crime being committed and with some of those guns (property) being destroyed. There is of course pushback on things related to data reporting such as registries (Ring is essentially a registry that allowed police to contact the individual in this article), new credit card merchant codes, and data abuses of carry permit information (disclosing names and addresses of gun owner which is basically a map for thieves).
- tptacek 4y agoIt seems worth calling out that if Larkin had "owned" the footage in the sense the article means, perhaps by recording it onto magnetic tape like a convenience store, he'd still be required to furnish it to the police. Deliberately destroying that tape, even in advance of the receipt of a warrant, can be actionable depending on your state's tampering and obstruction statutes. So my take would be that it's not so much the "cloud" part of this problem as it is the "it's now convenient to have lots more cameras" part of it.
- donmcronald 4y agoI wonder how it works (technically) for things like Amazon's Blink cameras that advertise local storage. They're absolutely trash because the local storage mode is (deceptively) crippled, but as far as I can tell they actually store the video locally. Is Amazon allowed to reach into your network and take the video they want?
- ethbr0 4y agoThat's the difference between the government compelling speech (1st Amendment) and serving warrants with due process (5th/14th Amendment). IANAL, so not sure on recent case law, but last I knew (~2010 Apple encryption case?) the government couldn't compel a private company to change their existing architecture to expose data in unencrypted and/or physically/legally-accessible fashion. If they already have data security implementation gaps or a tap-susceptible architecture, then it's a different matter. The government serves them a warrant, and they have to comply. But if Amazon being compelled to reach into a network and retrieve video stored locally is a threat model, that should be mitigated by a tight firewall and non-updating devices... Half of the IoT privacy gaps are because people don't run network security barriers anymore, and then are shocked when companies abuse them.
- WaitWaitWha 4y agoI have a slight different take on this. To me the concern is not a proper subpoena duces tecum to Larkin, but the lack of specificity that can be ignored going to the cloud provider.
- 4y ago
- giantg2 4y ago"Who owns private home security footage" I do. DIY on-site only system. Pretty simple really - stop using third party vendors for data storage. They're cheap and easy because your data is usually the product. Sure, you would still be forced to comply with warrants/subpoenas if they think you have data, but that's basically unescapable.
- anonu 4y agoIs there a home solution as easy as Nest or Ring and which offers the same feature set?
- gresrun 4y agoUniFi Protect[0] is a decent on-prem solution and has all the main features of Nest/Ring. Certainly expensive though, minimal system for a doorbell cam is $199 for the camera[1] + $199 for the smallest NVR[2]. [0]: https://ui.com/camera-security https://ui.com/camera-security [1]: https://store.ui.com/collections/unifi-protect-cameras/products/uvc-g4-doorbell https://store.ui.com/collections/unifi-protect-cameras/produ... [2]: https://store.ui.com/collections/unifi-protect/products/unifi-cloudkey-plus https://store.ui.com/collections/unifi-protect/products/unif...
- schwank 4y agoI use UniFi devices throughout my home but the cameras (G3 specifically) are buggy and frequently disconnect, and don't auto reconnect. Basically useless. Over the year end holidays I was traveling and set one up to monitor my front yard. There was actually an incident while I was gone and I remoted in to find the camera offline, totally missed it when it should have had perfect perspective. The police asked me for video and in this case I would have shared it, but alas could not. Sucks as I have the CloudKey box for video storage, but its very undependable in my experience.
- Axsuul 4y agoWould you not recommend UniFi then? Will you be migrating to another system?
- WaitWaitWha 4y agoIf this is a concern for you, consider Home Assistant[0]. Near dummy proof (I am prime example), can bet set up to have zero third-party involvement. My properties are not locked into any ecosystem and I am able to do everything the closed commercial gardens offer. [0]: https://www.home-assistant.io/ https://www.home-assistant.io/
- originalcopying 4y agoI say that if I have the footage, then under (non-existing) regulations of digital assets I own them along with anybody who also has their "own copy". The problem with this notion of ownership is that it's not compatible with the idea of trading assets in a typical traditional market like all that existed before the internet was built
- yabones 4y agoIf you're willing to put an afternoon's work into it, you can easily and inexpensively build a home surveillance system with ZoneMinder that stores all data securely and safely on-prem. The cops can still take it, but it requires a few warrants to do so. Shameless plug -> https://nbailey.ca/post/nvr/ https://nbailey.ca/post/nvr/ But it's also important to only record what you absolutely must. I think putting CCTV cameras inside your house is insane, and putting up cameras in any "private" outdoor area should likewise be avoided. Once the data exists, somebody will want it eventually.
- giantg2 4y agoNot to mention your name doesn't show up in a registry (Ring client list), so they might not even ask you for video if they don't go door to door.
- rytis 4y agoDo you have any recommendations what cameras to use? Rather simple set of requirements, but I really struggle to find anything suitable: compatible with zoneminder/motioneye, poe, no cloud nonsense, outdoor weatherproof, preferably non-chinese, reasonably priced. Don't need NVR. Was eyeing hikvision, but there seems to be mixed feelings about them.
- orangepurple 4y agohttps://docs.frigate.video/frigate/hardware https://docs.frigate.video/frigate/hardware
- thesh4d0w 4y agoWyze v3 with https://github.com/gtxaspec/wz_mini_hacks https://github.com/gtxaspec/wz_mini_hacks
- mitemte 4y agoSensor size, relative to megapixels is the most important factor for quality, especially at night. Here’s a good starting point: https://ipcamtalk.com/threads/best-current-recommended-cameras.58076/post-580392 https://ipcamtalk.com/threads/best-current-recommended-camer...
- syntaxing 4y agoI currently run frigate with Docker and the setup is pretty straightforward if you know how to modify YAMLs. Got rid of all my eufy stuff after the scandal. It’s so nice to have an on premise system since you can set a camera VLAN to have no internet access. The tensorflow lite based detections is miles ahead of motion based detection too.
- oaththrowaway 4y agoI'm also running Frigate and I've helped 2 other people set it up. Pretty slick if you have a Coral
- deviantbit 4y ago"that concerns privacy advocates and Democratic lawmakers..." https://www.cnn.com/2020/05/27/politics/house-vote-fisa/index.html https://www.cnn.com/2020/05/27/politics/house-vote-fisa/inde... Snicker. I love when people the media spreads false information. Democrats have been all about monitoring your every move, just as Republicans. I hate politics. How about we all become Libertarians please. Less government, less in our business. Why would anyone put camera's in their home? This is lunacy. Outside, I can understand.
- mixmastamyk 4y ago> Why would anyone put camera's in their home? This is lunacy. Outside, I can understand. I thought so too at first glance. But the article explains, that they only come on when the security system is turned on. i.e. when one leaves the house. I could see investigating a burglary when at work, for example. Would not send it to the cloud, but can see the logic otherwise.
- duck0duck 4y agoIn my current work I develop software on this area. Kind of CCTV from scratch in .NET. We archive high performance using static FFmpeg libraries. Right now, because of currency exchange, I'm looking for a new job. ely at duck dot com
- wara23arish 4y agoHas anyone set up a home security system using HomeAssistant?
- nixpulvis 4y agoWe need a comprehensive, people first, data ownership bill drafted and pushing to law ASAP. I know a lot of work has/is being done on this front, but I'm even someone who cares and I have trouble following it all. It seems corporations and private/government interest are running the show completely. Am I wrong?
- nixpulvis 4y agoAllow me to expand and spitball here just a little bit. 1. Technology companies as data creators should have the responsibility of clearly denoting the ownership of the data they create. 2. Data created as a product or derivative of something a user owns should be given the option to be owned by the same user. 3. Rights for data owned by a user should be akin to physical ownership and stewardship, including limited scope of warrant by law enforcement, etc. (Why would we limit the ability for a police officer to search your home, but not the video footage you installed of the same?) 4. Technical implementation including but not limited to advanced cryptography should NEVER be disallowed or restricted by the owners of data.
- concordDance 4y agoSeems like the judge signed an overly broad warrant.
- didgetmaster 4y agoEveryone seems to be accepting at face value the government's claim that they were investigating a real crime in the neighborhood and not specifically targeting this guy and using this as a lame excuse to spy on him. Given all the instances of government agencies abusing their power to target political enemies of the current administration; I wonder how reasonable such an assumption really is.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- mulmen 4y agoWho owns it? The homeowner. Who can access it? Anyone with an internet connection that can reach shodan.io.
- mcbits 4y agoIs there any sort of encryption scheme that would make it possible to generate a key on-demand to decrypt only the data that was encrypted within some arbitrary interval of time? The idea being if 100 terabytes of someone's private life history is seized, a judge could order the decryption of only the parts likely to contain material evidence. The closest thing that comes to mind is to use a unique AES key for every chunk of 5 minutes or so, and then encrypt those keys with an asymmetric cipher with the private key secured off-site somewhere, which could selectively decrypt some of the AES keys. But that could be an inconveniently long list of keys for, say, 10 video feeds over several days.
- rex_gallorum2 4y agoNobody seems to be asking whether/why you need cameras in the first place. The last thing I want is surveillance cameras in my living space, and the fact that other people have street facing cameras casting suspicion on people lawfully using public spaces really unnerves me. These companies are encouraging fear and paranoia to sell their products, and there is no guarantee using said products will deter criminals, or ensure that they are caught and punished even if you have clear video evidence. This whole camera craze is built on a bunch of hot air. Ditch the cameras and stop living in fear.
- encryptluks2 4y agoI used to think the same thing until I caught a 40 year old man stalking my teen daughter and continually trying to peer into her bedroom windows on camera. So while it feels good to be ignorant, it doesn't make everything go away. Also, the people commiting crime seem the most concerned with people having cameras. Hmm, wonder why.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- rex_gallorum2 4y agoThe irony is that you wouldn't know if your neighbors were using their own cameras to observe your daughter. Or you for that matter.
- BeetleB 4y agoYour use case would have been fine with external cameras, right? I believe that was the intent of the GP's question: Why have indoor cameras?
- rex_gallorum2 4y agoThe indoor camera thing is pretty freaky. Setting them up to keep an eye on things when you are gone would probably be a good idea - but all the time?
- scubadude 4y agoWhat I can't work out is why people put security cameras inside their house? What do you possibly stand to achieve from doing that?
- JohnFen 4y agoI think I accidentally answered your question here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35075366 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35075366
- scubadude 4y agoThank you for being considerate of your neighbours and the general public!
- JohnFen 4y agoI'm one of those privacy freaks who rails against ubiquitous surveillance. There's no chance I'd be OK with imposing surveillance on unconsenting others except in areas that are clearly my private property. Any legitimate guests are aware that the cameras are there. I should add, though, that my cameras only cover the the external doors and windows. There are no cameras, say, in the bathroom, covering my bed, etc. My surveillance goal is simply to record anyone entering and leaving while I'm not home.
- krupan 4y agoSeveral people questioning why you'd have cameras inside your home. I have a story. A few years back I started discovering wet spots on the carpet around my house. It was pretty clearly urine. None if my kids would fess up to it, and they seemed sincere. I set up some cameras and eventually caught a sleepwalker. At least one of my kids would stand up, walk around the house for a bit, and take a leak like he thought he was in the bathroom, and have zero memory of it! It was kind of hilarious. Got the kid to a sleep doctor and cleaned (and eventually replaced) the carpet. Got rid of the cameras. It would have been embarrassing at least if anyone got that footage. Glad it was all local storage.
- lotsofpulp 4y agoWhat did the sleep doctor say? I used to sleep so deep that if I needed to go to the bathroom, in my dreams, a toilet will appear. Even in the middle of a jungle. Peed in a trash can one time. My solution was to just not drink anything in the hours before going to sleep.
- krupan 4y agoBasically just told the kid to stop staying up so late reading Harry Potter. He said to try a regular sleep schedule with an early bedtime first, and if that didn’t work to come back and there was some medication we could try. The regular sleep schedule seemed to fix it
- Zetice 4y agoYou can challenge a subpoena right? Like, he could hire a lawyer and contest the scope of this? Not saying it's not wildly inconvenient, but he could if he wanted to.
- titoCA321 4y agoFind a lawyer that's willing to do that for you. Then show up to court and complete all the legal paperwork. How many do you think are going to do that? How much do you think it's going to cost?
- test6554 4y agoI use ring cameras. I gave some initial consideration to the privacy concerns before going all in. I decided I'm fine with it. I positioned the cameras specifically knowing that whatever they record could be made public at some point. I consent to Amazon or Ring sharing the footage with police and 70% or so of my neighbors all do the same. If my footage can help catch a burglar or vandal in my neighborhood I've made the whole community a bit better. But I already live in a very safe area. All I've caught so far are some possums, cats, squirrels, and wasps. But I also see when packages get delivered, etc. If I'm ever not OK with it I can just replace the cameras with any PoE alternative. My house is wired to be flexible.
- lancesells 4y agoI'm wondering how many people here have cameras and have had something go wrong where the camera made the difference? I think for most neighborhoods and people they seem needless, but perhaps I'm a bit too naive.
- rconti 4y agoI'm sort of the "I'd rather not know" camp. I've lived in my house for 8 years now. I'm sure in that time the area has been prowled. Somebody has probably walked into my fenced backyard to see if I left a window open in the summer, or tried my front door to see if it's unlocked, or scoped out my cars for catalytic converters. But, I've never had a crime issue. Not a single package stolen, ever. Why work myself into a tizzy about everything that "seems strange"? Don't get me wrong, I'm sure if something did happen, I'd wish I had footage. And maybe I'd go out and buy cameras. But then, I've watched my brother-in-law's Ring footage of his catalytic converter being stolen from his Prius. On 3 separate occasions. Gotten angry, thought about what I'd do if I happened upon these scumbags. And yet, that's all the footage does; makes you angrier.
- rconti 4y agoFrom my skimming, the article doesn't explain why the police knew to ask for the footage. Did he volunteer it to them initially, or to someone else? Is he part of a ring neighborhood thing? (They have a function to offer to share footage with your neighbors). Or did the police simply throw out the dragnet and look to see if Ring had any customers in the area? I suspect it's one of the first two options. In such a case, you're better off not offering your information to begin with (unfortunately), and you'd likely be okay with a Ring as long as you didn't advertise its existence online. You'd be better off still with a non-cloud solution that, while subject to subpoena-or-something, flies under the radar even more.
- JohnFen 4y agoRing doorbells are very distinctive and easy to see from the street, especially at night. It's possible they just drove down the street looking for the houses that have them.
- j45 4y agoThe cloud is always someone else's computer. If you put something in someone else's desk drawer, is it really yours alone to access? Self hosting has become much easier than 10-20 years ago.
- jimt1234 4y ago> [Larkin] still doesn’t understand how a judge could have signed off on a warrant asking for footage from a camera inside his home... > Privacy advocates point out that the police don’t have unfettered authority in demanding footage: They need to get a warrant from a judge... Sounds like these "privacy advocates" are extremely naive; most judges will sign anything the police put on their desks.
- xvilka 4y agoSomeone should make a company that modifies existing "smart" appliances or "things" to cut them off the grid. A bit like OpenWRT does to routers or other FOSS firmwares. I am sure it will be a lucrative business given how omnipresent cloud crap these days.
- zizee 4y agoIt was terribly dangerous to let your thoughts wander when you were in any public place or within range of a telescreen. The smallest thing could give you away. A nervous tic, an unconscious look of anxiety, a habit of muttering to yourself – anything that carried with it the suggestion of abnormality, of having something to hide. In any case, to wear an improper expression on your face (to look incredulous when a victory was announced, for example) was itself a punishable offence. ... You had to live – did live, from habit that became instinct – in the assumption that every sound you made was overheard, and, except in darkness, every moment scrutinized. 1984, George Orwell
- nicolas_t 4y agoOff topic, I have a synology NAS, what is a good camera that only communicates within my lan and doesn't reach out to any servers on internet? We need to setup a camera for insurance purpose in my mum's house in France after multiple burglaries but I absolutely do not want to give access to a third party.
- villgax 4y agoSo much for freedom
- kavalg 4y agoSome time ago police asked for data from my cameras. They did not present a subpoena, but were very open and clear about the purpose (a car has been stolen on the street next to the building) and the time span (2 AM - 3AM). We looked at the footage together, found nothing and they went away. I could have very well told them that they need a subpoena, but that could easily backfire. I could also have told them that the system is out of order, or even destroy the footage if I had something to hide. You can't do any of the latter if you data is uploaded to a cloud provider. Unfortunately DIY security cameras are usually based on old hardware and lack the AI goodies of new systems (e.g. semantic event detection).
- egberts1 4y agoThis is why a Raspberry Pi serves as a private server to my private video stream. You can battery-back it with a cheap UPS to cover this video server, the Power-over-Ethernet switch via Cat-6 cabling to your private video cameras. No more hassle. No more monthly fee. And free access from your cellphone.