13 ms·
Bee and butterfly numbers are falling, even in undisturbed forests
- lproven 4y ago6 upvotes and no comments for the single most important story on HN for the year so far. To quote a poster: A smiling bee says, "When we go, we're taking you with us!" The ongoing human-caused insect apocalypse signals that the same is coming for humanity. Most flowering dicotyledonous plants don't make fruits or seeds without pollinating insects. There goes many human crops. There go the forests that catch and slowly release rainwater to irrigate those crops. There goes much of on-land CO₂ absorbtion and capture. Here comes the big dustbowl, there goes the West Antarctic Ice Sheet, goodbye to every coastal town and city in the world.
- dtx1 4y ago> But what about the poor SUV drivers? And all this green stuff is gonna make us poor! That's basically been the reaction of the boomer generation I heard when talking about the looming eco disaster. When getting decent bicycle infrastructure in cities is impossible because half the population does not only doesn't care but actively opposes any change we can forget about changing any of this. It's going to happen. The question then becomes: What can we do to deal with that? How can we replace the polinators?
- lproven 4y agoI don't think we will, TBH. I am colossally pessimistic but at the rate we are going, I think we are heading for between 4-7⁰ C of warming this century, 5-10m of sea level rise, the extinction of 95%+ of species, and a small remnant of humanity, maybe a few million people, living at the poles, after the collapse of our technological civilisation. We're not going to have time to invent magic mini flying robots to do pollination when the bees are all dead.
- dtx1 4y agoThats unrealistic. Sure, some countries are going to become unlivable for humans, afghanistan, pakistan etc. but large parts of now permafrost will become habitable in exchange. And there are also many plants that dont rely on polinators.
- urfullofsht 4y ago[dead]
- galangalalgol 4y agoLatitude isn't as good as altitude for avoiding warming. They'll all be perched on the tops of mountain ranges hoping for rain.
- nerdponx 4y ago> 6 upvotes and no comments for the single most important story on HN for the year so far. I have nothing to say. I feel powerless and robbed of my own future by my parents' generation. Forget the dustbowl, if we can't pollinate crops, we will all either starve or kill each other long before the rest of the ecosystem collapses.
- birdyrooster 4y agoWe mechanically pollinate plants all the time, it’s not the end of our ability to feed ourselves. I think people are ignorant to and are overestimating how difficult it is to make pollen blow in the air or transfer using mechanical means.
- stuven 4y ago... how much are you willing to stake on that assumption?
- birdyrooster 4y agoWhat other options are working? Geopolitics isn’t changing anytime soon.
- dumpsterlid 4y ago[dead]
- pseudolus 4y agoThere have been stories documenting how the decline of bee populations has necessitated the introduction of hand-pollination. [0] Hand-pollination seems both tedious and difficult to scale. Mechanical pollination might be viable in some environments but basically it amounts to extensively paying for something that historically has been free. [0] https://www.globalcitizen.org/en/content/life-without-bees-hand-human-pollination-rural-chi/ https://www.globalcitizen.org/en/content/life-without-bees-h...
- 4y ago
- stinos 4y agoMost flowering dicotyledonous plants don't make fruits or seeds without pollinating insects Is it really 'most' (I honestly don't know, I've never considered only looking at dicotyledonous plants)? In any case: I'm very well aware of how dramatic the decline is, but imo there are more than enough 'if all the bees die we die as well' memes out there and perhaps it's a pet peeve of mine but that's a correlation at best and it ignores so many nuances it's not funny anymore (not that it ever was, but you get the point). It's HN so let's not ignore all other pollinators (wasps, flies, butterflies, moths, beetles, bats, spiders, birds, ... in no particular order - and of which I know many people actually go like 'erm, what, bats?'), nor that there's also wind pollation, and also not the fact that there's a bunch of crops whos yield doesn't depend on pollinators at all and another bunch who'd see dercreased yield without pollinators but not quite zero.
- eimrine 4y ago>> Most flowering dicotyledonous plants don't make fruits or seeds without pollinating insects > Is it really 'most' (I honestly don't know, I've never considered only looking at dicotyledonous plants)? Flowering plants is way smaller domain than dicos plants and flowers use insects (or lucky burst of wind) as the only way to make a new organism, I mean a new DNA.
- lproven 4y ago> Flowering plants is way smaller domain than dicos plants It's the other way round. Dicots are a sub-domain of angiosperms (flowering plants). There are lots and lots of flowering plants. All (bar a rounding error) make seeds. Some of the seeds have 1 seed leaf (cotyledon), so are called monocotyledonous plants: monocots. The others have 2 cotyledons: dicotyledonous plants, or dicots. Some monocots use insect pollination and some make edible fruit. Bananas and coconuts are monocots. All cereals (except some false cereals like buckwheat) are monocots, but all are wind-pollinated. Hand-wavey generalisation: most monocots are wind-pollinated, and don't need insects. Many dicots use wind pollination, but most of the ones that make fruit we can eat are insect-pollinated. Some plants are self-fertile and don't need to be pollinated at all (e.g. dandelions). Some can be bred to be that way. If insects disappear it doesn't mean all fruit will. But OTOH it's not just about pollination. Insects do much more than that. They are also vital in decay, in the soil, in turning dead plants back into soil. No insects means much slower decay, means soil that's much less fertile, means plants grow much more poorly, means more crop failures.
- ourlordcaffeine 4y agoWell surely conifer forests will be fine as they are wind pollinated
- rowanG077 4y agoHuh I thought we don't know why they are dieing yet.
- lproven 4y agoIt's a question of which causes are the more important ones. For example, the rise in Varroa mites is probably a secondary effect caused by insecticides, but which insecticides? Colony collapse disorder is a thing, but nobody is 100% sure what is causing it yet. So the scientists say "we don't know". Which is true... but it is very clear who is causing it. It's us. Humans. It doesn't really matter if it's the chemicals that we make in the millions of tonnes specifically to kill insects, or the ones we make in the billions of tonnes to do other things which happen to kill insects, or the ones we accidentally create as byproducts which happen to kill insects, or whether it's because we're destroying the wilderness that they need to survive, or it's something we don't know yet. E.g. vultures in India are doing very badly. It's humans, but it's by accident. Some Indian religions practice "air burial". They let vultures eat the bodies. Dying people often feel unwell. They take painkillers. Paracetamol is cheap. India is poor. People take a lot of paracetamol and then some of them die. Paracetamol is toxic to vultures. It's still humans, but it's indirect and accidental, but it's 100% our fault.
- macinjosh 4y agoIt is a fallacy to say scientists don't know what is causing it but they/we know its humans for sure! Huh? What?! That don't make no damn sense. You got to know something before you know it, you know? In your vulture example we know why the vultures died so we can tie it to a human behavior. We don't know why the bees die or what the deal is with the mites so we can't tie it to human behavior. You are still making a leap of faith, no matter how logical or likely it seems or in fact is.
- rowanG077 4y agoWhile I agree that it's probably likely that humans are the cause I disagree with you outright stating humans are. I can still see some non-human probable causes like an undiscovered disease in or multiple species.
- Maken 4y agoTo be fair, I do not think many people here (or anywhere) is qualified enough to have an informed opinion in the matter. In fact, the lack of entomologists (a boring, unexciting field of study for most of us) may be the cause of how seemly late the complete wipe-out of all insect life is being reported. Last time this happened, it was killing the birds and people noticed it much much earlier.
- belorn 4y agoThere are a few scary solutions if it ever came to the point where insect population would start to seriously harm pollination for forests and human crops. We can always start engineering and breeding insects that are more resistant to global warming. What we will never know for certain is what the long term effect will be if we start to do this.
- tptacek 4y agoHuman crops are generally pollinated by livestock bees, not feral pollinators. If we depended principally on natural produce, most of us would have starved to death long ago. Forget about the bees; just think about the Haber-Bosch process.
- goatlover 4y agoIt has more votes now that it's been posted several hours, but why would it be more important story than recent AI advances on a hacker news site?
- avgcorrection 4y agoWhat you are witnessing is simply resignation.
- EGreg 4y agoThis is far more pressing than the climate crisis, but people don’t seem to prioritize it: One third of all arable farmland has become desertified in the last couple decades as people are in a race to the bottom (just as USA was in the Great Depression leading to the dust bowl) Biodiversity has plummeted as species go extinct, only to be replaced by farms and monocultures Insect populations are plummeting Forests are being decimated The boomer through millenial generations think they’re smarter than previous ones but they are in fact like an irresponsible kid living on an ecological credit card, that their children will have to pay. Child mortality was solved but humanity was slow to adjust their birth rates to compensate for it.
- pc86 4y agoI'm curious how you can view this as separate from climate change and not inextricably linked.
- EGreg 4y agoIt may not have anything to do with the greenhouse gas effect and emission of fossil fuels. The desertification has to do with farmers planting too much and extracting all nutrients from the soil - same as happened in the 1930s which didnt have to do with cars and cows and methane in the atmosphere. The overfishing - same thing The collapse of insect populations is highly unlikely due to the slight aberage temperature changes or carbon concentrations in the atmosphere. It may be due to wireless radio signals, or light pollution, or pesticides and GMO plants. The collapse of kelp forests or bleaching of coral reefs also has less to do with acidification of the oceans, and more with local pollution and ecosystem collapse. The extinction of some species is due to hunting. And so on. You could say the anthopocene is behind all these things — but that is not the same as saying that climate change is CAUSING these things. If A (human activity) is causing B and C, and nearly all we talk about is C, then it is valid to say that B is more pressing, and that we should focus on A causing B. The response that “C is linked to B” is not enough because C doesn’t cause B and talking about C doesn’t do anything to stop B.
- pohl 4y ago
- dathinab 4y ago> undisturbed forests there are no really undisturbed forests rain and winds brings contamination into the most remote corners of the world for example the Aral Sea has not dust but salt storm, to top it of they are highly toxic due to extrem over use of pesticides upstream and toxines from there have been fund as far away as in snow in Sweden (probably further away too, I just don't remember). another example dust from the Sahara somewhat frequently get carried as far as Germany and climate warming affects remote regions too
- cwkoss 4y agoSahara dust feeds the Amazon rainforest https://www.nasa.gov/content/goddard/nasa-satellite-reveals-how-much-saharan-dust-feeds-amazon-s-plants/ https://www.nasa.gov/content/goddard/nasa-satellite-reveals-...
- snozolli 4y agoFive times between 2007 and 2022, researchers surveyed the insects in three forested areas in the Oconee National Forest in northern Georgia. That's it? Just one forest in a single US state?
- pc86 4y agoNot to mention the fact that this "undisturbed" forest is barely an hour away from the third-fastest growing metro area in the country.
- snowwrestler 4y agoHow many forests have you surveyed over the past 15 years? The tricky thing about science is that it only gets done by actually doing things…
- goatlover 4y agoYeah, but if that's used to draw a more general conclusion about populations in other forested areas, that's not good science, or journalism (more likely).
- snozolli 4y agoHow many forests have you surveyed over the past 15 years? What's the point of this question? I can't be skeptical unless I've personally conducted the same research? The tricky thing about science is that it only gets done by actually doing things… Doubling down on the snark. Why? What do you imagine this adds to the conversation? I have no problem with the study, but I do have a problem with the headline, barring the citation of similar studies in other areas. At least the other guy who replied mentioned studies in other areas. Your comment added nothing of value whatsoever.
- pb7 4y agoDoesn’t matter because he’s not the one making grand assertions. It’s ok to criticize research, especially when it’s limited.
- 4y ago
- jmclnx 4y agoI cannot disagree with this. When I was young not a day went by were I did not see some butterflies in the summer and autumn. Even in the small City where I grew up. Now that I think of it, I have not even seen a butterfly in many years, this includes hiking it the woods. What a shame, well with global warming and the powers that be still doubling down on fossil fuels, a big correction is probably on its way, similar to this story posted here earlier about tree roots. We had 50+ years to do something about climate change, as usual profits came first. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35054175 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35054175 (edit, fixed the link, paste issue)
- jimbob45 4y agoSaw six butterflies last night while walking in a highly developed area. I’ll probably see six more tonight. Are anecdotes really how we want to measure this?
- BitwiseFool 4y ago>"Are anecdotes really how we want to measure this?" Anecdotes aren't always bad, or even inappropriate. We're on an internet forum having a casual discussion so my expectations for intellectual rigor are quite low.
- snowwrestler 4y agoNo, anecdotes are unreliable. It would be better to do a systematic study, and publish the results in a scientific journal like Current Biology. Then maybe to help get the word out, publish a summary on a website like Science.
- mistrial9 4y agobackground on political action in the USA and elsewhere https://thebreakthrough.org/articles/the-death-of-environmentalism https://thebreakthrough.org/articles/the-death-of-environmen...
- xnx 4y agoLoss of biodiversity follows directly from and is a much bigger deal than typical "climate change" headline
- aeternum 4y agoWhy has massive biodiversity losses at multiple previous points in earth's history always resulted in an even larger subsequent explosion of biodiversity?
- xnx 4y agoI lament we've been given this amazing Eden filled with boundless flora and fauna -the complexity and beauty of which we can barely comprehend- and we're trading it in for parking lots and shiny baubles.
- EForEndeavour 4y ago"You know what I love most about Mars? They still dream. We gave up. They're an entire culture dedicated to a common goal, working together as one to turn a lifeless rock into a garden. We had a garden and we paved it." — Franklin Degraaf, The Expanse S1E3 https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Quotes/TheExpanse https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Quotes/TheExpanse
- goatlover 4y agoHowever, the Martian dream dies the moment they find out there are other worlds with biospheres not named Earth that they can migrate to. Particularly one named Laconia. The problem with Mars in the Expanse is they never got around to terraforming the surface. That and the military culture. In the books, Holden says that not a single blade of grass grows outdoors on the surface. But Earth, despite its pollution and massive population, still grows tons of things that don't grow anywhere else. It's hard to understand just how fertile our planet remains. Bobby is dazzled sitting by the polluted harbor, hearing a sea gall flying overhead. Mars only has underground zoos and farms.
- 4y ago
- olivermuty 4y agoThe squashed bug studies along highways worries me almost even more. Where are all the insects going? I have been driving for exactly 21 years now. My first car I remember the drudge of cold soaking it through the summer to get off the layers of bugs. I don’t see more than the odd bug on my current car through the summer. It is anecdotal, but it tracks the science and feels very real when it is so observeable personally too.
- kyleyeats 4y agoIt's cars. You killed them all!
- aeternum 4y agoIt's the pesticides. Consider the world from the POV of an insect. Even if you're a bee, your metabolism is similar to other insect pests. There are huge fields of dense crops with plenty of pollen but if you partake, you die.
- galangalalgol 4y agoI've read much of this is improved aerodynamics of cars that prevents the collisions.
- lamontcg 4y agoLooking at the massive front grill of a modern truck or SUV I very much doubt this.
- cryptonector 4y agoIn Texas you can have three beehives in your backyard. And if you have a few acres you can have pretty much as many as you can sustain. I've beehives. It's super fun to care for my bees!
- LatteLazy 4y agoIt's almost as if we have spent 50 years ignoring and accelerating climate change...
- throw_pm23 4y agoDrop in insect and butterfly numbers has nothing to do with climate change. It is due to pesticides being pumped in unprecedented quantities into nature and monoculture agriculture.
- AlexandrB 4y agoIt doesn't have "nothing" to do with climate change. Climate change probably contributes to habitat loss as weather becomes less favourable for some species in areas where they could probably survive before. Pesticide use the is cost you pay for cheap food, meat heavy diets, and other benefits of living in "western" society. Sure we could grow food without pesticides, but it would cost more. It might also require more land - which would probably also impact insect populations.
- avgcorrection 4y agoWhy just fifty years?
- LatteLazy 4y agoBefore 50 years ago, it was at least debatable whether everyone knew. Now everyone knows. And has for at least a generation. You fuck things up without realizing, then you get to be surprised they're fucked up. You spend 50 years doing it knowingly, you don't get to act shocked when insects numbers are plummeting and once per century forest fires are happening every year and France gets zero rain for all of Feb... Welcome to the new normal. The one we all knowingly ordered.
- anonymouskimmer 4y agoI had read about the company Beemunity a while back. https://scitechdaily.com/beemmunity-pollen-sized-technology-protects-bees-from-deadly-insecticides/ https://scitechdaily.com/beemmunity-pollen-sized-technology-... > An early version of the technology – which detoxified a widely-used group of insecticides called organophosphates – is described in a new study, “Pollen-Inspired Enzymatic Microparticles to Reduce Organophosphate Toxicity in Managed Pollinators,” published on May 20, 2021, in Nature Food. The antidote delivery method has now been adapted to effectively protect bees from all insecticides, and has inspired a new company, Beemmunity, based in New York state. The company (I think it's the same company) currently makes flower pots to attract and feed native bees, and they make food bricks that help boost bee immunity and robustness. Still a small company, and frequently out of stock. You can click through the "health action" drop downs on their lickbrick page to see what each of the ingredients do. https://www.beemmunity.co/lickbrick https://www.beemmunity.co/lickbrick
- twiddling 4y agoBut hey we have got a lot of brown marmorated stink bugs now!
- craig_s_bell 4y agoDon't forget their (slightly less dopey) cousins, the boxelder bugs.
- ROTMetro 4y agoWhen we moved to the mountains my son really wanted to see a porcupine. I talked to an oldtimer forrester friend and he said that in the 60s/70s they sprayed to kill all the underbrush to make logging easier and that that changed the fauna quite a bit and that was when porcupine's became uncommon. I thought it sad we thought we were hiking through natural forests but they had been heavily changed by an expedited business practice from a few decades in the last century. We saw everything from otters and beavers to lynx, grizzlies and cougars in our journeys, but never a porcupine.
- cityofdelusion 4y agoInteresting. I live in the city and I see porcupines just walking the dog. Usually they're up in oak trees. They seem well adapted to city life since they just need to live in and eat tree tops.
- macinjosh 4y agoEnvironmentalists are like capitalists in that they always want the numbers going up. Growth, growth! Wherein reality, nature ebbs and flows.
- eggsmediumrare 4y agoIt's only been ebbing lately.
- CatWChainsaw 4y agoDid that sound a lot better in your head or something?
- tracker1 4y agoI really don't consider myself an environmentalist in the most typical sense. I think that people should probably get a little bit closer to natural processes and away from industrial franken-foods. The push against repairability is pretty bad. The levels of pollution are disheartening to say the least. Two instances in travel stick out to me. Going into/through LA in the mid 00's and finding the smog unbearable and driving on the I-10 through west TX and into Louisianna there was this thick layer of gas fumes that was simply hard to even keep my eyes open. These are two visible, pungent cases and you don't need to be an environmentalist to feel that this is a problem. I'm also not inherently against GMO plants/food... I will say that some of these have been problematic, like 20x the histamine response in modern wheat vs. older strains. The increased use of soy and legume proteins that are not complete/good, and the lack of understanding of how problematic they along with the vegan/vegetarian cult-like culture have been. Not to mention the massive negative impact of refined seed oils on human physiology and hormone production. There are a lot of choices made in the past century or so that have been done out of convenience and at the time ignorance of longer-term impacts. We should largely know better at this point. I don't like the tendency to lay global climate change to blame for it all, or that humans are even the leading cause of those changes... climate changes and has throughout time. But I can absolutely find that covering a significant portion of the planet in chemical pesticides that kill off insects to the point that it's of serious concern, and making no efforts to move towards something that is sustainable is irresponsible at best. I can also feel that continuing to come up with more chemical processes to make a better non-stick pan, vs. just learning to clean/maintain steel and cast-iron pans is problematic. Yeah I like amazon... I like that I can get apples year round... I like that I can do a lot of things. But I'm at least trying to make better choices at least part of the time... and advocating for others to do the same.
- kornhole 4y agoI know its a drop in the bucket, but I hope this can inspire more drops in the bucket. I tend my yard with plenty of plants that make food and habitat for bees and butterflies. This includes native milkweed for the monarchs, carrots, fennel, and parsley for the swallowtails, and many other flowering plants for the bees. Chemical warfare is completely banned from my property. All kinds of insects are here and in balance providing food for the rest of the ecosystem.
- gE6n9m 4y agoThis is the way. I'm going to do the same even though I only have a balcony. I was thinking of building a fountain for birds too to help them cool down and bath in the dreadful hot days. That's the least I can do.
- eggsmediumrare 4y agoSame. Milkweed and goldenrod are really beautiful plants.
- avgcorrection 4y ago> I know its a drop in the bucket No. It’s a hobby. If I set up my own email server, I’m not fighting the Gmail Dominance. I’m pursuing a hobby.
- algoatecorn 4y agoAre you saying that intermittent pollinator gardens don't serve to bolster the ecological network? Because that would be wrong. Every bit helps and even small gardens have a large impact.
- ricardobeat 4y agoIf 10 million people set up their own e-mail servers, yes, you're fighting GMail. It starts somewhere.
- ddejohn 4y agohttps://www.theonion.com/how-bad-for-the-environment-can-throwing-away-one-plast-1819571260 https://www.theonion.com/how-bad-for-the-environment-can-thr...
- pphysch 4y ago"undisturbed forests" don't mean much to pollinators if 100% of surrounding basins and meadows have been turned into toxic farms/ranches
- DeadMouseFive 4y agoBecause of glyphosate and similar chemicals. Petrochemical society will be the death of us all.
- alyx 4y agoMaybe they are just moving to beyond-the-ice-wall.
- college_physics 4y agoIts hard to have a rational response to the steady trickle of warnings. We know that things are not going well on many fronts. We also know that we are locked-in along an unsustainable path that is extremely difficult to change given that people are not equipped mentally, socially, politically, economically to do the right things. We also know that the negative effects will not be the kind of in-your-face "wake up" call that will panic people into some sort of action. Species don't make a lot of noise when they disappear. Its just silence. Not that panic reactions could change anything. Changing course into a sustainable economy would require massive, coordinated and persistent changes over decades. So we must resign to a steady degradation of the environment across the planet, the loss of many beautiful things, the creation of fragile human monocultures, recurrent epidemics and ecosystem disasters and just hope that some deus-ex-machina will grant us at some point a way out - despite us not deserving it.
- vivekd 4y agoDoesn't the article suggest the opposite. If populations are declining in untouched forests far from human activity, wouldn't that be evidence that human activity is not the cause of population decline
- bagels 4y agoIt only suggests that local effects are not responsible. That leaves as some of the possibilities: climate change, air pollution, other chemicals that still make it in to 'untouched' forests.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- vkou 4y agoIt could be evidence that the impact of human activity - say, pesticides - isn't localized to the particular field that you spray with them.
- college_physics 4y agoMicroplastics have been found everywhere, from high mountains, to antarctica and deep ocean sediments. I am not claiming thats the vector responsible in this case but the human footprint is now everywhere.
- resuresu 4y agoAll i can say is im glad im not having kids. They have no future, just look at the state of the world now, in another 20 years when kids today grow up their will be even less opportunities and and even worse environment.