9 ms·
5k-year-old tavern with food still inside discovered in iraq
- ftrobro 4y agoI wonder why the tavern was abandoned with food in it in 2700 BC when the city itself was inhabitated far longer and according to Wikipedia might have been "the largest city in the world from c. 2075 to 2030 BC".
- ggeorgovassilis 4y agoThe article mentions that the city was surrounded by "fertile lands", so maybe there was no need for scavenging?
- Kye 4y agoAncient times must have had some equivalent to urban explorers. edit: Bing Chat says... >> "That’s an interesting question. I couldn’t find any direct evidence of ancient urban explorers, but there were many ancient explorers who traveled to different lands and cultures for various reasons123. Some of them may have explored urban areas as well, but they didn’t leave any records of their adventures." >> "One possible exception is Xuan Zang (602-664), a Chinese Buddhist monk who traveled to India and visited many ancient cities and temples along the way. He wrote a detailed account of his journey, which is considered a valuable source of information on the history and culture of India and Central Asia1."
- ralfd 4y agoHe looks like a backpacker tourist: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Xuanzang https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Xuanzang
- thesuitonym 4y agoIn hindsight, it's completely obvious, like of course it would be this way, but it's still amazing how ancient people were exactly the same as people are today.
- notahacker 4y agoI was going to say "but backpackers never wore clothes that wild", but then I remembered backpacking in India!
- speed_spread 4y agoThat's not really urbex though. Not sure ancient times had closed down industrial and commercial sites like the ones we have now.
- forgotusername6 4y agoBuilding falls or burns down perhaps? The ruins cover the site and people just rebuild on top of it. There's a site in the UK from slightly later (1000BC) that had food still found in containers but that was the result of a fire https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Must_Farm_Bronze_Age_settlement?wprov=sfla1 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Must_Farm_Bronze_Age_settlemen...
- ftrobro 4y agoI was mainly wondering why noone else claimed the tavern or demolished it to make room for a new building considering that the city was probably growing between 2700 BC and 2075 BC. Looking at the photo it seems the tavern was found in the top soil layer with nothing above it. But perhaps the photo looks like that because there have been several excavations since 1887. Or maybe the photo just shows some random building...
- anonu 4y agoIt's hard for humans to fathom timelines beyond our life span. But over the course of 100s or 1000s of years, cities can be abandoned and population migrates. Think about the Detroit suburbs in recent years where entire neighborhoods were abandoned. https://www.gettyimages.com/photos/abandoned-houses-in-detroit https://www.gettyimages.com/photos/abandoned-houses-in-detro...
- hackernewds 4y agoThis seems like the impending future for San Francisco
- Mountain_Skies 4y agoThat looks like the City of Detroit, not its suburbs, though I'm sure some of them do suffer some decay, in general Detroit's suburbs are pretty healthy.
- jghn 4y agoThe definition of 'suburb' has been changing over time. I can't speak to Detroit but for instance with Boston the original 'suburbs' would now be described as "the city of Boston, not its suburbs". Likewise the town I grew up in as a kid (mumble) years ago, I would have been laughed at for calling it a 'suburb' of Boston as it was too far out of the city. Now Wikipedia calls it a suburb of Boston.
- gs17 4y agoI can speak to Detroit, and it's the same. The areas south of 8 Mile but not downtown would by definition be "suburbs" (and structurally resemble the outside of the city), but I'm used to people reserving the term for outside city limits. Now that I'm in Nashville, "suburbs" seem to usually still be inside the city, so I'm guessing it changes as cities grow/decay.
- Infernal 4y agoNashville has experienced really rapid growth too over the last 20 years, and I think it takes a while for naming conventions to catch up. Given by the fact that what people call suburbs appear to you (as I'm assuming, a relative newcomer) to be "inside the city". My own hometown has experienced rapid growth over the same time span as Nashville, and has annexed large portions of what were commonly known as the suburbs. So there has been a literal change from what used to be suburbs to now be within city limits, in the course of a generation.
- notahacker 4y agoPlenty of abandoned taverns in inhabited cities in the modern world. Owners die or suffer financial or social death, businesses become too unprofitable to run in parts of cities where the land also isn't worth much, structures start looking alarmingly unstable and aren't worth repairing etc etc. And regardless of how long bits of the food are preserved for future archaeologists, a couple of days after the tavern's closed most of it isn't really edible any more...
- pbhjpbhj 4y agoYou'd expect scavengers to get the food: rodents, insects, etc.? Buildings that fall into disrepair tend to be scavenged by humans for materials too. Much moreso anywhere there's wealth disparity or resource shortages.
- AlotOfReading 4y agoYou'd be surprised. It depends heavily on the prevailing social mores. Besides, much of what archaeologists recover is the stuff that survived, not the 99% that didn't.
- giantg2 4y agoNotice that they didn't find any beer or wine. It seems the important stuff got scavenged.
- einherjae 4y agoPresumably just the eras equivalent of Hákarl or Surströmming was left, alongside the pizza-with-pineapple equivalent and Dr. Pepper-equivalent.
- nick123567 4y agoIn archaeological terms, they could be discovering stuff like microscopic grain husks embedded into the clay of the containers. Though they could have found whole chicken skeletons or fossilized garlic or something else too... I searched for a moment but couldn't find more details from this dig about the food specifically.
- 4y ago
- oh_sigh 4y agoOne can think of a million reasons, but we will never know. Maybe the owner died and the kids didn't want to take it over and boarded it up. Maybe someone was murdered there or everyone got food poisoning and it was closed up because people were superstitious.
- arp242 4y agoI used to live across an abandoned building that was falling apart; one day I forced the door to have a look inside (the place was already beyond salvage) and there was all sorts of stuff inside; some furniture, bunch of magazines and newspapers, empty bottles. Today's refuse, tomorrow's archaeology. Lots of boring mundane stuff gets interesting hundreds of years in the future. Or the owner burned the place down after a tourist from a faraway land sold him a polly sea for some inn sewer ants.
- jcutrell 4y agoI was thinking exactly this. It’s not surprised it would be abandoned, but the story makes it sound like it was suddenly abandoned. The simplest explanation to me is likely the untimely death of the proprietor, but even that doesn’t seem like a sufficient answer.
- pram 4y agoIIRC there’s a lot of totally abandoned places around there (like Babylon) because the Tigris and Euphrates changed course quite a bit? So what might have been a riverside city soon was just sitting in the middle of the desert. Kinda like the fishing towns around the Aral Sea.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- mothsonasloth 4y agoAnother piece of evidence that Mesopotamia was the cradle of civilisation.
- speed_spread 4y agoCivilization might be much older than that but the traces in Mesopotamia are the oldest ones we could find.
- rbanffy 4y agoI find the concept of pre-human civilisations fascinating. For how long would we be able to find our own civilisation’s remains and what would they look like in a million years, or a 100 million?
- speed_spread 4y agoI would expect plastic and radioactive waste to be our longest lived tell-tale markers, along with stuff we've left on the moon, if anybody ever makes it there again.
- rbanffy 4y agoMillions of years from now, even the devices we left on the moon will be under regolith or mowed down by incoming micrometeorites. You are probably right that the most obvious signs will look like mineral deposits. Plastic will be back to oil by then.
- ETH_start 4y agoNo way a civilization would ever die out in a scenario where a significant fraction of terrestrial vertebrate species survive. Civilizations are much hardier than any terrestrial animal life more complex than insects.
- rbanffy 4y ago
- 2rsf 4y ago> They also found a domestic dwelling that contained a toilet A toilet?
- apeescape 4y agoA toilet is a place where people go take a shit or piss.
- credit_guy 4y agoBefore the invention of flushing toilets, the place where people were going to shit or piss was generally outside the house, also known as an "outhouse". A "domestic dwelling that contained a toilet and a kitchen" does sound unusual.
- prmoustache 4y agoHell no. People have never been ok to stump on someone else shit and feces have been used in the past as construction material and fertilizer. There are still old dry toilets in my grandparents old farm. Basically a cabin with a toilet seat made of wood on top of a big hole. Wood chips and saw dust was kept in a bucket for the user to cover his shit with. Mixed with compost the end result was used as fertilizer.
- somedangedname 4y ago>...a cabin with a toilet seat made of wood on top of a big hole. In Australian slang this is called a 'long drop' after a particular style of judicial hanging. And yes, there are spiders.
- speed_spread 4y agoI would have guessed long dropbears instead of spiders.
- HeyLaughingBoy 4y ago
- DeathArrow 4y agoAnd on the table a Big Mac with fries, looking as fresh as on its first day.
- euroderf 4y agoI was expecting ever-fresh spam & twinkies.
- nunodonato 4y agohow can food last for 5k years? doesn't it decompose during such a long period?
- indy 4y agoThe article didn't imply that the food was still edible.
- nunodonato 4y agoI wasn't implying that either. But how can you recognize organic food after 5k years? In my compost bin it lasts only a few weeks :)
- ceejayoz 4y agoComposting is a process specifically intended to break down organics. A closed tavern in the desert isn't likely to have the same conditions, and I'd imagine the remnants of the fish are largely bones and scales of the sort you wouldn't put in home compost.
- myth_drannon 4y agoYou can't compost food in the desert, it's to dry.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- RugnirViking 4y agothey mentioned they found the "remains" of fish, presumably liquefied along with possibly some bones
- lm28469 4y agoDepends on the conditions, see mummies for examples. Don't expect fresh looking food though, it probably amounts to super dry rock looking objects
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- epberry 4y agoThe archaeology content on HN is some of my favorite. I think what this find is getting at is more evidence that Sumerian civilization was more egalitarian than we may have thought if we projected our understanding of feudal civilizations all the way back.
- kupopuffs 4y agoInteresting. I've always seen feudalism as the response to civilization/empires collapsing (e.g. europe in the dark ages, Japan), and Mesopotamia was a thriving civilization
- TechBro8615 4y agoFeudalism was not entirely new to the Middle Ages - it was partially derived from the Ancient Roman system of Patronage [0] between a Patron and Client. So this kind of hierarchical social structure predates the civilizational collapses that led to the Middle Ages. Of course, Mesopotamia predates Ancient Rome, so perhaps it was even more egalitarian. Although slavery has existed since pretty much day one of civilization. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Patronage_in_ancient_Rome https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Patronage_in_ancient_Rome
- ztrww 4y agosuch a system more or less existed in every premodern society. Some sort of a patron-сlient to system is absolutely inevitable in any complex non egalitarian society unless there is a strong state that can protect the rights of individuals.
- ElfinTrousers 4y agoThese finds that teach us about everyday life are interesting to me because they remind us that people are people. I remember looking at an exhibit of Babylonian seal cylinders, which were a kind of tool that a Babylonian would use to sign a document written on a wet clay tablet. It suddenly occurred to me that what I was looking at was not a work of art intended to be displayed and enjoyed just for its aesthetic value: it was the everyday tool of an ordinary clerk who lived and died thousands of years ago. I pictured this ancient Babylonian at the office, rolling the cylinder over wet tablets, looking forward to quitting time when he could go home, maybe stop for a beer on the way, play with the kids, kiss his wife. All of which would also be normal behavior for a white-collar worker alive today.
- imwillofficial 4y agoWe missed it the first time around, quick, let’s bomb it!
- imwillofficial 4y agoTough crowd
- tdiff 4y agoWhy aren't inner wall orthogonal to outer walls?
- kyteland 4y agoI believe what you're calling the "outer wall" is just the edge of the excavation grid, not a wall in the original city. The grid plan used by the archeologists won't necessarily align to the city plan.
- jollyllama 4y agoGreat, it used to be a nice, chill place to grab a drink and some food but now it'll be swamped with tourists.
- throwaway1777 4y agoDid you even read the article? It’s an archaeological site… not an operating tavern…
- surge 4y agoDid you even read the comment? That was obvious humor. "It used to be" - 5k years ago "now it'll be swamped with tourists" - today now that its a famous dig site, people will come to look. All of it parodying a common refrain from locals when ever a cool local spot gets media attention on the news or some national TV show. Much like dissecting a frog, explaining humor kills the joke. To OP: I liked the joke.
- soperj 4y agoIt's interesting seeing a joke as a top comment and someone downvoted for not getting the joke. I feel as though the voting would have been the opposite on this site years ago.
- Aicy 4y agoYep, as much as I enjoy the occasional humour I don't want HN to become reddit.
- surge 4y agoThey were down voted for the way they remarked on it. "Did you even read the article", berating the OP for missing something obvious (and also apparent just from the headline, not just the article). People make jokes sometimes on here, its not all serious business, I don't think it would have been different years ago. You should get down voted for being a bit rude and simultaneously hypocritical because your criticism is also based on also missing something fairly obvious. The OP didn't deserve that comment, and the commenter should be corrected and have it pointed out they're actually the one making the embarrassing mistake.
- photochemsyn 4y agoInternet Archive Scholar has some interesting results for "Lagash", it's a nice resource. See this from 1956: https://archive.org/details/sim_transactions-of-the-american-philosophical-society_1956-09_46_0/page/211/mode/1up?view=theater https://archive.org/details/sim_transactions-of-the-american... > "This is the dream contained in the famous Cylinder A of Gudea (published in TCL VIII), the ensi of the Sumerian city of Lagash, whose floruit falls about the very beginning of the second millennium B.C. Gudea, ruler of Lagash, desired to build a fitting temple for his god, NinGirsu, and, as was customary throughout the entire span of existence of the Mesopotamian civilization, the latter sent a dream..." These kinds of modern excavations reveal a lot more about ordinary daily life than the older translation of temple documents and royal inscriptions do, however.
- namaria 4y ago>These kinds of modern excavations reveal a lot more about ordinary daily life than the older translation of temple documents and royal inscriptions do, however. I don't think these are separate things. Excavating is a blind effort, there is no 'modern excavation', we just find more interesting things now because we excavate a hell lot more then we used to decades ago. And these boring translations of temple documents and royal inscriptions is how we get context for the objects and layers we find.
- nick123567 4y ago>there is no 'modern excavation' They describe the modern technique in the UPenn announcement... Rather than digging according to architectural construction phases, the Lagash Archaeological Project is using an approach championed by Pisa’s Pizzimenti, who excavates by microstratigraphic layers, thin lens by thin lens horizontally, across a wide swath, “like doing very careful surgery,” Pittman says. “Just 50 centimeters down, we were able to capture all of this. We were happily astounded.”
- namaria 4y agoThat's a refinement of practices that are decades old. Comment I responded to seemed to imply we got evidence of this tavern due to some recent breakthrough, while before we'd be doing mostly work on temples and translation. Which is false, we have slice of life findings since the beginning of archeology, and ongoing efforts on prominent buildings and bodies of text.
- staplung 4y agoNo word on whether any of the beers had coasters over their tops. I mean maybe they still plan to come back and boy are they going to be pissed if the archeologists have stolen their beers.
- tiffanyh 4y agoI don't know what I was expecting, but those photos weren't it.
- gwill 4y agoyea, i wanted to see this food.
- eternalban 4y ago> the tyranny of kings English had inns and pubs, when toiling under the "tyranny of kings", right? https://www.historic-uk.com/CultureUK/The-Great-British-Pub/ https://www.historic-uk.com/CultureUK/The-Great-British-Pub/
- londons_explore 4y agoFor those wondering why people were living in the middle of a desert 5k years ago... It seems the global temperature then was much the same as today: https://scitechdaily.com/images/Global-Average-Surface-Temperature-Curve-scaled.jpg https://scitechdaily.com/images/Global-Average-Surface-Tempe... Would there have perhaps been a locally different climate, for example because the african and middle eastern rainforests hadn't yet vanished after the global temperature rises 5k years earlier?
- senorsmile 4y agoThe Akkadians (Assyrians and Babylonians) as well as the Sumerians we're all attracted to the Mesopotamian area in general due to it being between the Tigris and Euphrates rivers. They flooded on regular intervals, thus creating fertile land despite the general desert like climate.
- dr_dshiv 4y agoA dog walks into a bar. “I can’t see anything!” He says. “I’ll take this one.” —oldest joke in the book
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- uhtred 4y agoI wonder why it was abandoned so rapidly that food was left in the fridge etc