19 ms·
Physically Demanding Work Tied to Male Fertility
- coding123 4y agothis is all explained in idiocracy
- noelwelsh 4y agoIt's been known for a long time that lifting leads to increased testosterone. This report seems to be mostly that, or did I miss something?
- delecti 4y ago> We already know that exercise is associated with multiple health benefits in humans, including those observed on reproductive health, but few studies have looked at how occupational factors can contribute to these benefits It seems like a fairly predictable confirmation. It wasn't a given though, exercise tends to improve long-term wellbeing, while lots of people with physically demanding jobs are pretty much destroyed by them.
- jjoonathan 4y agoThat checks out: with exercise, you have wide latitude to not do things that hurt (or otherwise suck). With a physically demanding job, you have much less latitude.
- hugozap 4y agoThere's been a lot of reporting on how testosterone and sperm count levels are decreasing without a clear explanation on why and lots of hypothesis so finding clear links between sedentary jobs and fertility is interesting.
- SamBam 4y agoThis study shows that occupational lifting (moving heavy things as part of a job) increases testosterone and sperm counts, while previous studies were looking at lifting weights in a gym. Yes, the earlier studies would certainly imply the later results were most likely true, but that's how science works. And this in turn lends higher credence to those earlier studies.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- noelwelsh 4y agoThat's fair.
- czbond 4y agoGood to see a study on it. Bodybuilders or powerlifters can feel the changes it creates in T levels almost intuitively. I still believe that as men age, with many (most?) becoming out of shape - their T level changes due to lack of vigorous exercise.
- AnimalMuppet 4y agoDoes this explain falling testosterone levels worldwide, as men become increasingly sedentary - desk jobs, video games for entertainment, etc?
- 4gotunameagain 4y agoOne factor out of many, such as xenoestrogens in diet and environmental pollution, sleep disorders, weight issues.. My unpopular opinion 5cents is that this is the cause of (skyrocketing rates of) transexualism in men, with social contagion being the cause of (skyrocketing rates of) transexualism in women
- kwhitefoot 4y ago> skyrocketing rates of You have some evidence for that? Or is it just that you see lots of stories in the popular press?
- DontchaKnowit 4y agohttps://www.ny1.com/nyc/all-boroughs/news/2022/06/10/study-estimates-transgender-youth-population-has-doubled-in-5-years https://www.ny1.com/nyc/all-boroughs/news/2022/06/10/study-e... Here ya go. And theres plenty of other studies out there. We only started keeping track of this kind of thing recently so its hard to gi very far back. But I mean come on, anecdotally, you can see how this is true right? I knew 1 transgender person over my whole life, until like 2016. Now I know 6. Half of those 6 are people I knew back when I only knew 1 transgender person. Its clear that at the very least, more peoppe are openly trans, but I think the rate in general has increased, open or not.
- Beaver117 4y ago[flagged]
- rootusrootus 4y agoYes, this is too obvious, what we really need is confirmation that fit people are morally superior as well.
- pc86 4y agoThat's also obvious.
- algoatecorn 4y agoAre you referring to being less of a burden on healthcare systems, more productive in physical jobs which maintain our critical infrastructures, and having more energy to take part in community building events?
- jmclnx 4y agoInteresting, I wonder if this correlates to falling birthrates in Advanced Economies ? And maybe how this worked in the old days when many kings blamed their wives with issues in producing children.
- throwaway1777 4y agoYes.
- kwhitefoot 4y agoBut it doesn't necessarily mean that the reduction in male fertility is the cause of a reduction in birth rates.
- GalenErso 4y agoBirth rates are falling all over the world. People aren't childless despite trying. They're just not trying, for the most part.
- hammock 4y ago>People aren't childless despite trying That's simply not true. Worldwide, sperm counts have dropped by 50-60% over the last 50 years (and the decline is accelerating). Sperm motility has been declining as well. These factors have a direct impact on fertility despite trying
- eastbound 4y agoDivisive politics, social media, many things have an impact on fertility which can individually have more impact than even dropping sperm count by 50%.
- Foobar8568 4y ago1/3 of one household for a 2bedroom flat would kill any fertility rates.
- GalenErso 4y agoI would be interested in knowing: - What is the magnitude of the change in testosterone? Are we talking 5-10% or more like 60-90%? - How long does it take to happen? Are we talking 2 weeks or 6 months? - How quickly do testosterone levels decline to baseline levels after someone stops performing physically demanding work?
- cullenking 4y agoOther unrelated studies on weight lifting and high intensity training put the differences at around 20%. I'd consider weight lifting and HIT/HIIT 3-5 times a week to probably be more effective at producing these results than a job, obviously depending on the job, so likely an upper bound of 20%. Obviously a big conjecture here. Other interesting results from various studies on improving testosterone also show around a 10-20% change in testosterone due to various stresses on the body: - higher carb diets (200+ grams carbs per day) produce ~20% more testosterone - vitamin D deficiency linked to ~20% reduction in testosterone - 5 hours sleep per night over 10 days linked to ~20% lower testosterone - excess cortisol due to stress linked to ~ 10% lower testosterone I got interested in this due to finding out I had pretty low testosterone levels. I am a chronically sleep deprived dad of 3 with a stressful job, so it wasn't a surprise. Working through that list myself and running some experiments to see if I can improve levels naturally, and if so, if the above list has any stacking effect, or if there's maybe just a 20% hit due to body stressors, regardless of the stressor.
- LeftHandPath 4y agoDang. That actually explains a lot about why I feel good when I feel good. It's amazing that just doing what feels good and ignoring all advice - whether from online / media / friends - often leads to a better end result than studying up on everything. Can certainly land you in trouble too, but largely, the body's built-in feedback systems are better at telling me what I should do than the words other people create to explain how their body's feedback systems have worked.
- cullenking 4y ago
- hammock 4y agoLots of "well this is obvious" comments here, but this finding strikes me as a new (haven't seen before) key driver of the global testosterone crisis to which no one has been able to tie a specific cause
- totemandtoken 4y agoI have a friend who puts the blame entirely on microplastics because its been shown microplastics upregulate estrogen (or something to that effect). Is this accurate? No idea, not a biologist.
- hammock 4y agoThat is not accurate. The book of science on the human harm caused by microplastics is thin and still new. There is lots of science on specific plastic chemicals and their estrogenic effects - phthalates is the largest category although there are several - but the classification of "microplastics" is orthogonal to the type of plastic involved Edit: downvotes why
- dsfyu404ed 4y ago>Edit: downvotes why People hate nuance because it doesn't wholly confirm their beliefs
- kelipso 4y agoHow are "specific plastic chemicals" or "phthalates" orthogonal to "microplastics". They are a subset of microplastics, so of course they cannot be orthogonal. Are you saying phthalates are not microplastics? It feel likes you are obfuscating the problem by using debate tricks or something and then calling it nuance.
- hammock 4y ago> They are a subset of microplastics Are they? Not trying to be difficult. Micro plastics are just tiny particles that break off of macroscopic plastic objects. They can be made of any kind of plastic. And phthalates are found in macroscopic plastic objects. Hence, orthogonal
- beedeebeedee 4y agoI wonder how much "physically demanding work" is just a surrogate for "not sitting". The article only mentions sitting once (and the press release, not at all) > Men also reported the level of physical exertion in their current job using the following categories: light (e.g. most time spent sitting, office work)... https://academic.oup.com/humrep/advance-article/doi/10.1093/humrep/dead027/7034534 https://academic.oup.com/humrep/advance-article/doi/10.1093/... Sitting inherently causes the nerves and blood vessels in the groin to be impinged, so it would not be surprising if that was enough to lower the production of sperm, testosterone, etc. It would be nice if they could control for sitting, so we could know if lifting heavy objects is causing the increase in sperm count, like the press release suggests.
- hammock 4y ago>Sitting inherently causes the nerves and blood vessels in the groin to be impinged Anyone have a good reco for a chair that doesn't do this? Does it have a hole in the middle or something?
- scottLobster 4y agoAlso sitting for long periods causes the testes to get warmer, which can damage sperm.
- algoatecorn 4y agoIn addition to stimulating higher Test, I would go ahead and guess that the cohort had more lean body mass and few overweight individuals. All together, these things make an large difference in male fertility. Body weight and activity level are enormously significant variables in practically all health outcomes. Easy to understand, but difficult to manage it seems.
- antonchekhov 4y agoObesity has become a pervasive problem in the U.S (and parts of the rest of the world). The average waistline of American adult males is now 40.5 inches![https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/fastats/body-measurements.htm https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/fastats/body-measurements.htm] That is jaw-dropping to me. I live in a U.S. state that is well-known for being one of the thinnest states in the country, and people don't seem particularly thin to me here - but when I visit other parts of the country, the obesity is pervasive and extreme. (No need to name states - there are numerous maps of obesity rates online.) There are strong indicators of several causes for this, but America really needs to get serious about health and overall wellness of the population.
- b112 4y agobut America really needs to get serious about health and overall wellness of the population. We don't need to fat shame, but also we don't need to accept. To say it is OK. To pretend that in 99.9% of circumstances, people have 0 control over it.
- PuppyTailWags 4y agoBased off the effectiveness of new anti-diabetes drugs that also help in losing weight I actually think people might have much less control over their obesity than we'd like to believe. Fat people might have some kind of hormonal difference happening that they have to manage in a way thin people don't, in the same way women have to manage their menstrual cycles but it would be weird to say they have control over them. Women who want to take control over their periods usually have to take medication to do so, and it seems fat people respond similarly to thin people once they take medication that adjusts their signaling to that of a thin person's.
- raincom 4y agoAll guys should start lifting weights now: 'Fertility crossfit' every corner.
- lm28469 4y ago> All guys should start lifting weights now Everyone should no matter their sex, literally no drawbacks and unlimited benefits
- maximus-decimus 4y agoOf course there are drawbacks : 1. It takes time 2. It costs money
- lm28469 4y ago> It takes time When the average social media usage per day is 2.5 hours this is no excuse, we have the time we just don't use it > It costs money Obesity is more expensive, my 24/7 gym is 15$ a month, in a major western capital
- maximus-decimus 4y agoI didn't say people don't have the time and money. I said it costs time and money. Just because you don't like people spending 2.5 hours on TikTok everyday, doesn't mean they're not using their time. They're using it on what they want : TikTok. I would also be surprised if most people walked to the gym. You have to pay for transport. That's car wear, gas expenses, possibly higher insurance cost. You're also using a false dichotomy : go to the gym or be obese. You can be obese while going to the gym and you can be a healthy weight while not going to the gym. Controlling what you eat is way more important for weight control than exercise. "You can't outrun your fork."
- sacnoradhq 4y ago3. It can lead to injuries. 4. Apparently now, it leads to babies too.
- frankus 4y agoThe natural (and probably correct) assumption is that physically demanding work causes higher fertility. While "having lots of children leads to physically demanding work" is super unlikely, it's worth considering whether there's some third factor that leads to both high fertility and a preference for physically demanding work.
- cperciva 4y agoMy first thought is that people with naturally higher testosterone -- and thus more muscle mass -- are more likely to end up in physically demanding jobs.
- rootusrootus 4y ago> While "having lots of children leads to physically demanding work" is super unlikely I don't think I'd toss that theory out entirely. Having lots of children is usually tightly correlated with having children early, and this absolutely makes gaining post-secondary education far more difficult. Which then correlates pretty nicely with being stuck with physically demanding jobs.
- unxdfa 4y agoAm I an outlier as I had three kids when I was a sedentary fatty? Got super fit and healthy now and have no desire or interest in that sort of stuff!
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- sam-s 4y agoIs it possible that the causality goes in the opposite direction - hormonal levels affect job selection?
- badcarbine 4y agoiFootball coming in 3…2…1…
- ewgoforth 4y agoCould this be a self-selecting group? Guys with higher testosterone can't stand the idea of sitting at a desk all day?