11 ms·
The most interesting thing about this article to me isn't the "spending too much on consultants" bit, it's the bit where the agencies in charge of budgets for t
by simonw 4y ago
The most interesting thing about this article to me isn't the "spending too much on consultants" bit, it's the bit where the agencies in charge of budgets for these enormous projects no longer have staff that are capable of managing them, having outsourced that institutional capacity to consulting companies for far too long.
This seems like a viciously difficult problem to solve to me. How do you hire someone for a city's transport agency who has the ability to manage a multi-billion dollar construction project? Anyone with those skills will surely be able to earn 10x more in the private sector.
But without that talent in-house, even the consultants are frustrated (or at least the ones that actually want to deliver projects) because they don't get the answers they need from their customers in order to move ahead with projects.
- Retric 4y agoDoes managing a 10 billion dollar construction project take dramatically different skills than a 100 million dollar construction project? The government doesn’t need the best of the best for this stuff they just need basic competence.
- jolux 4y agoA 10 billion dollar project is 100x larger. It's definitely more difficult to manage.
- Retric 4y agoSure it’s more difficult, but the difficulty doesn’t increase linearly with budget. A 100m dollar project isn’t 100x as difficult as a 1m dollar project. I am not saying anyone can make the jump, but promotions often mean handing an order of magnitude larger projects.
- mooseknees 4y ago[dead]
- kaspern 4y agoI'm not sure how you can conclude that for any infrastructure project, complexity scales sublinearly. This feels true in software, but not real world matters IMO. Think of all of the politics & hard choices involved, for instance, in displacing people vs. bending over backwards to accommodate them with the California high speed rail project.
- bobthepanda 4y agoIf anything, complexity probably increases exponentially as you have to consider ever more permutations of possible project.
- japaneseminisub 4y agoI agree, and think that this should be incorporated into the cost. Ie, a project twice as complex should be 5x the cost due to the additional management, comms overhead, permutations and potential risk. Said another way the curve is logarithmic and there's a theoretical upper bound on project complexity.
- Retric 4y agoTotal project complexity isn’t the relevant metric here, a project with 100x the budget has more people managing it any many decisions don’t make it to the top. Also, if a 2x as complex a thing takes 10x the budget then that scaling is already part of the budget figure.
- DoreenMichele 4y agoUrban planning is pretty complex. Basic competence is a higher bar than you may realize and anyone really good at planning this stuff can make more money in the private sector. Some people take staff jobs because they are good at the bureaucratic stuff. This does not necessarily mean they actually complete projects. It does mean they tend to keep their job and get viewed as competent, even if they may not be, really. A good reason to take a staff job is you are good at the planning part and not so good at being an entrepreneur and would like to actually get paid for your work. I have no idea how many people fit this profile versus how many people are good at playing the game without actually getting all that much done.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- maCDzP 4y agoIf you are unlucky the project you are managing doesn’t scale linearly. So a 10 billion projects is 99999999 time more difficult than a 100 million project. Then we have the problem of previous experience. How many 10 billion projects do we have in the whole country? And maybe they take 10-15 years to finish. You might get one chance at managing and then it’s time for retirement. When projects of this size start they often have “wicked problems” [0] which demand a lot of competence. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wicked_problem https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wicked_problem
- Retric 4y ago> How many 10 billion projects do we have in the whole country? Right now I would guess a few hundred, going back and adjusting for inflation it’s easily thousands. For scale a single aircraft carrier costs more than 10 billion. The US operates at a scale that’s hard to comprehend. Also,100 million dollar projects also run into Wicked problems.
- ricktdotorg 4y agohonest question: when the US Navy builds a new $10bn super-carrier, who is actually managing that project? is it US Navy staff, or is management of that project outsourced to a US company? i am genuinely curious.
- hackrnusr 4y agoFolks that graduate from schools like this: https://foundrycollege.org/about-us/team/ https://foundrycollege.org/about-us/team/
- Centigonal 4y agoOne of my relatives worked for the MTA for 20+ years until moving to a new role in 2022. He's mentioned consultants a lot, and has said the reason they relied heavily on consultants and contractors is because hiring or firing an MTA employee is a complicated and time-consuming process, and it's easier to hire consultants you can decide not to renew instead of risking a bad hire (that said, the way he's described the bidding process for new contracts also sounded extremely complex and time-consuming to me - I'm speculating that getting rid of a bad hire is somehow worse than that). He's also talked about a different kind of consultant, namely a cadre of management consultants that were brought in under Andrew Cuomo to restructure the agency. He didn't like those folks very much.
- elevaet 4y agoIt sounds like one of those situations where workers' rights backfire by making it so onerous to hire and fire them that it's safer not too, just in case you end up with a dud, or a role evaporates. It's a tricky balance and I don't claim to know where the sweet spot is in terms of worker's vs. employer's rights, but we may have overshot. Similarly, I see a problem wrt tenants' rights where it becomes so difficult to evict a tenant that no landlord will take a risk on someone who appears to be even slightly risky. It ends up with hordes of unhoused people at the bottom of the "desirable tenant" spectrum getting bumped onto the street in affluent cities, because no landlord will take a chance on the middle, let alone the bottom. Again, obviously tenants need rights, but it seems like many jurisdictions have overshot the sweet spot. These things are so complex and have so many facets. I'm not confident that excessive tenants' rights are truly a problem, but I it's possible.
- vineyardmike 4y ago> Again, obviously tenants need rights, but it seems like many jurisdictions have overshot the sweet spot Tenants need rights and landlords need tenants. In some cities (SF) the demand outstrips supply sufficiently that you won’t easily find housing but in other cities (NYC) there’s such a diversity in housing options that you’ll always be able to find a closet to rent somewhere. I think it’s hard to say that tenants have too much rights. There’s no reason to enter the business of land letting unless you are comfortable with the regulations. Laws and their purpose come before profits.
- majormajor 4y ago> The most interesting thing about this article to me isn't the "spending too much on consultants" bit, it's the bit where the agencies in charge of budgets for these enormous projects no longer have staff that are capable of managing them, having outsourced that institutional capacity to consulting companies for far too long. I don't see how you can avoid this problem without building far faster than the US currently wants to. (Largely because many argue that we don't need to build dozens and dozens of new projects simultaneously, whether subway or anything else infra-wise, all at once.) You won't get competence in managing the budgeting, planning, and execution of a subway line without doing it a lot. So how do you break the cycle of inefficiencies leading to people scared to start enough projects necessary to build expertise? There's a bit in here https://chrisgagne.com/1255/mary-poppendiecks-the-tyranny-of-the-plan/ https://chrisgagne.com/1255/mary-poppendiecks-the-tyranny-of... about how we haven't matched the construction speed of the Empire State Building since then, and a lot of it is because the depression + war that happened right after it was done cause all that knowledge to be forgotten.
- bobthepanda 4y agoThe trick would be to build lots of itty bitty extensions continuously and have a small constant staff rather than big bang projects where the knowledge poofs into thin air, although now the cost has gotten so out of hand that we can’t afford to do that either.
- bombcar 4y agoThis is the answer but small improvements aren’t “flashy” enough for the politicians (and voters) involved.
- TeMPOraL 4y ago> You won't get competence in managing the budgeting, planning, and execution of a subway line without doing it a lot. > So how do you break the cycle of inefficiencies leading to people scared to start enough projects necessary to build expertise? I wonder if this could be something that's only possible when you're riding on fast exponential growth - fast enough that you can afford starting more and larger projects faster than population growth (or at least faster than competent people entering management work), with confidence that this "spending spree" is self-sustaining. Once you lose that confidence, you start worrying, lose velocity, and then lose capability. This would explain why it seems that nations tend to rapidly industrialize and improve across the board, in a kind of push that lasts for couple decades, and then runs out of fuel, leaving the nation barely able to do any large project anymore. An analogy in my mind is to a scramjet: an engine that allows you to achieve extremely high velocities, but which itself needs you moving very fast to even start it - and conversely, if you let your airspeed drop past the threshold, it will stop working.
- niemandhier 4y agoI believe that would be quite a few people who would choose to work for public projects rather than as consultants, simply because doing something that is relevant to society can be quite fulfilling. The main problem in my opinion, is that it is impossible to have that on the local level. Multibillion-dollar project at rare events, even if you develop that talent locally, you will never need it again. I think the solution would be government employed large project professionals on the federal level.
- OkayPhysicist 4y agoIt should be doable at the state level, though. If a state isn't large enough to have consistent, large-scale projects, they probably shouldn't be an independent state. Heck, it can be even smaller than that. The Los Angeles Department of Water and Power is regularly working on extremely large scale projects, and maintaining the ones they built.
- hannob 4y ago> How do you hire someone for a city's transport agency who has the ability to manage a multi-billion dollar construction project? Anyone with those skills will surely be able to earn 10x more in the private sector. It seems you could hire them by paying them 10x more than you would usually do. And if it's a multi-billion dollar construction project, that's a rounding error.
- vineyardmike 4y agoPeople have a hard time grappling with the balance of government workers making good money vs being wasteful with tax money. No one seems happy with the government to having sub-par employees, but no one wants to pay for good talent.
- drfrisker 4y agoAlso possible the private sector simply pays too much, inflated payscale of CEO's blow everything else out of the water. The private sector can afford to pay double the current ceiling of essential government infrastructure workers when those figures are chump change compared to returns.
- ly3xqhl8g9 4y ago"viciously difficult problem to solve" It is very easy in fact: abolish public-private partnerships, they have been an abhorrent failure from the Smedley Butlers of the world [1] to the Norfolk Southerns of recent news. You want to have "a company in the free market", very well, do it, no state funds, no grants, "hustle", be innovative well within the regulations, whatever. You want to have a state, very well, do it, be interested in educating people as soon as they can talk, take care of the basic needs for all people (food, shelter, safety, healthcare, meaningfulness), make the state interface an absolute pleasure, perhaps develop even some status games, reward people for following the laws, for developing a community (invert the reinforcement curve, less punishments, more rewards), and so forth. What we have today is simply a criminal joke: some nameless suits (random pick, who is the COO of CVS Health? [2]) meet in various glass buildings and print trillions for their own benefit. No society will be able to withstand this kind of sociopathic behaviour for more than a few centuries, vide Senatus Populusque Romanus [3], not like that's any consolation for us living today. [1] "I feel I might have given Al Capone a few hints. The best he could do was to operate his racket in three city districts. We Marines operated on three continents." https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Smedley_Butler#:~:text=I%20feel%20I%20might%20have%20given%20Al%20Capone%20a%20few%20hints.%20The%20best%20he%20could%20do%20was%20to%20operate%20his%20racket%20in%20three%20city%20districts.%20We%20Marines%20operated%20on%20three%20continents https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Smedley_Butler#:~:text=I%20fee.... [2] CVS Health is the 4th company in US by Fortune 500 in 2022; Jonathan C. Roberts was the COO until 2022 apparently, now there is no COO, https://drugstorenews.com/cvs-health-coo-jonathan-roberts-retire https://drugstorenews.com/cvs-health-coo-jonathan-roberts-re... [3] An example would be the story of Marcus Licinius Crassus, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marcus_Licinius_Crassus#Rise_to_power_and_wealth https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marcus_Licinius_Crassus#Rise_t..., Crassus became wealthy, "the richest man in Rome", from real estate, among others: he would buy burned houses for nothing and use slave labor to rebuild; he also had his own fire brigade, the first ever in Rome: the firefighters would start fighting the fire only after Crassus finished the 'negotiation' with the owner for the price of the burning house.
- tsimionescu 4y ago> Anyone with those skills will surely be able to earn 10x more in the private sector. This seems extremely easy to solve then, if it weren't for weird hangups about government employee salaries vs government spending.
- bobthepanda 4y agoIt’s unfortunately not weird, or at least not uncommon. It’s the party platform of one of the two major parties and probably over half of the second one also doesn’t like the idea of paying competitive salaries.
- bradleyjg 4y agoHow do you hire someone for a city's transport agency who has the ability to manage a multi-billion dollar construction project? Anyone with those skills will surely be able to earn 10x more in the private sector. NY/C governments overpay low skilled workers (especially once benefits and work rules are factored in) and dramatically underpays highly skilled workers. Since there are a lot more unskilled roles, fixing the one problem would free up plenty of money to fix the other.
- nunez 4y agoA lot of that money feels like hazard pay, if you ask me.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- bradleyjg 4y agoA cop or a bus driver, sure. But why is the janitor at a city hospital making twice what one at a private hospital makes (inc benefits) while a doctor at a city hospital is making half what his private sector counterpart does?
- tbran 4y agoSome crane operators in NYC apparently make up to $500,000!! Kind of crazy that some skilled work pays so much. That may be fine, but makes me wonder if any planners/civil engineers/whatever are making anywhere close to that. From 2011: https://www.wsj.com/articles/SB10001424052702303936704576399563008284024 https://www.wsj.com/articles/SB10001424052702303936704576399...
- kube-system 4y agoThose are private sector jobs, no?
- bradleyjg 4y ago
- uonpopular_th 4y ago>This seems like a viciously difficult problem to solve to me. How do you hire someone for a city's transport agency who has the ability to manage a multi-billion dollar construction project? Anyone with those skills will surely be able to earn 10x more in the private sector. You pay them 5x as much as they would get in the private sector. In all my hiring trouble never have I been in a position where spending what I was told was unreasonable money on staff did not result in a better outcome. My only explanation why no one else does this is that CEO will never let anyone else in the company earn more than them.
- bombcar 4y agoIndustries exist where “workers” can make way more than the leadership - sports, movies, etc.
- nicoburns 4y ago> How do you hire someone for a city's transport agency who has the ability to manage a multi-billion dollar construction project? Anyone with those skills will surely be able to earn 10x more in the private sector. You pay them the market rate. That's certainly expensive. But as illustrated by the article, the alternative is more expensive.
- rapind 4y ago> This seems like a viciously difficult problem to solve to me. How do you hire someone for a city's transport agency who has the ability to manage a multi-billion dollar construction project? Anyone with those skills will surely be able to earn 10x more in the private sector. You recruit and reward just like any employer. The issue is that in government it looks bad to be paying market rate for talent, and yet the optics and blowing money on consultants with no results is practically ignored. Oh and there’s the plausible deniability when the consultant goes off the rails. Our federal government up here in Canada can’t tie its shoe’s without a consultant. Gutting government in favour of private consultants is a really really big problem that’s being actively pursued, marketed, and lobbied for by these firms. In fact a lot of politicians come from consultancies (like McKenzie) and the ties are blatent. So basically capture.
- light_hue_1 4y agoThe study even explains how to do this. Milan maintains in house experts by loaning them to other agencies. The US could do the same if there was more cooperation and less of an adversarial relationship between agencies.
- asimpletune 4y agoYeah, the USA should definitely study what they've done in Italy. In about 15 years Italy has massively improved its train systems.
- Spivak 4y agoAlso because working for a private company that provides services to governments is infinitely better than actually working for the government. So in some fields it’s effectively laundering a nicer place to work than government is willing/able to provide.
- h0l0cube 4y ago> In fact a lot of politicians come from consultancies (like McKenzie) and the ties are blatent. The phenomenon is so pervasive in governments it has a name: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Revolving_door_(politics) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Revolving_door_(politics)
- lr1970 4y ago> This seems like a viciously difficult problem to solve to me. How do you hire someone for a city's transport agency who has the ability to manage a multi-billion dollar construction project? Anyone with those skills will surely be able to earn 10x more in the private sector. The problem is exacerbated by the "revolving door" mechanisms between government and private consultancies. Work few years for the government, hire extensive consultants, then become expensive consultant yourself and milk the system. Nowadays this is common collusion among all levels of government and private industries feeding of governmental contracts or consulting fees.
- pandemicsoul 4y agoThe absurd part of this is that the solution is so clear and easy in the United States: Use the scale of the federal government. We got to where we are, in the U.S., because we've got massive inefficiency in state and local government. There's only a handful of cities that are massive enough to do projects that would require hiring highly paid specialists to manage these huge projects. Similarly, most states have very few opportunities for long-term career-building public project management. (There's like 3 west of the Mississippi.) But consolidating all of this expertise in a federal agency tasked with planning and executing massive public projects would allow us to hire career-oriented planners and keep them busy for ever. It's how we run the military, of course. And, ironically, the military is a leech on the U.S. taxpayer, massively bloated and throwing money at foreign problems in the most ham-fisted way just to justify itself – but if you shifted even 20% of the military's spending to a domestic public works department, all that money would not only be to the benefit of the U.S. taxpayer, but you could hire tens of thousands more American workers to do the jobs. It's a win-win for everyone. And it's probably something a lot of legislators could get behind. Not only that, but a federal public works department would quickly be able to aggregate learnings on improving efficiency – knowing what works and what doesn't – while also being able to wield the power of the federal government to negotiate lower prices.
- gersh 4y agoWe have the army corps of engineers, which maintains a lot of the dams. We could expand from there.
- larrik 4y agoI was thinking of them, too. We could utilize the military directly rather than siphoning off their funding.
- abduhl 4y agoTunneling and underground work is a uniquely localized specialty. A national organization that runs underground work is going to still need specialized knowledge for each region both because of local ground conditions and local contracting practices. It is very difficult to export know-how from one area to another. Site sampling/testing practices are not even consistent across regions. Beyond that, as someone with extensive experience with underground projects and the federal government, the federal government doesn’t pay nearly enough and its benefits lag private industry significantly at this point. It’s also worth noting that this agency already exists somewhat but spread across departments (FHWA, EPA, etc.). They still outsource to consultants.
- coastermug 4y agoIn the UK I’ve seen this called the “intelligent client” model. Basically a core group of PMs who outsource everything. In my narrow experience of being on the inside of this, it failed drastically as the internal PM team lacked the technical expertise to foresee and plan for challenges, and really understand what was going on. The sea of external consultants all had differing incentives (other than earning money) - and the contracts written weren’t watertight or ever enforced to stop runaway spending.
- red-iron-pine 4y agoMost PMs I've dealt with have no bloody idea what is happening most of the time, both in an actual day-to-day, but also in a technical sense. PMs are glorified secretaries.
- toldyouso2022 4y agoIt's not true that you need a superspecialkid to manage a billion dollar project. Just get a guy with a good reputation at the office. The problem is not giving normal people an opportunity and always going for these big companies where people that are normal but good at selling themselves steal taxpayers money with "consultancy". Just choose a guy with a good reputation in the office to lead the thing, don't bother him and it will be done well and at a fraction of the cost. Perfectionism is ruining society
- dzonga 4y agoyeah - a person capable of managing such complex infrastructure projects could earn more in a private sector environment. however - there's still plenty of "incentives" legal or not that the government can take to ensure those people work in civil service and are well taken care of. plenty of gvts including the 'US' have had such appointments that can't be turned down.