16 ms·
Does anyone notice the irony of it being partly repairable, while offering just three years of security updates, after which you basically have to throw the thi
by cubefox 4y ago
Does anyone notice the irony of it being partly repairable, while offering just three years of security updates, after which you basically have to throw the thing away? The repairability sounds nice, but it is very irrelevant compared to the limited software updates. Imagine buying a Windows laptop and only receiving three years of security updates. (I know, most other phones aren't better.)
It would have been better if they offered slightly longer security updates in exchange of only letting you change the battery. Other things probably won't break anyway before the security updates stop coming in.
- shams93 4y agoYeah this is why linux phones would be great, we have manjaro with rolling updates, a fully upgradable linux phone would go a really long way in getting control over the ewaste issues.
- bionade24 4y agoThe Jolla phone got 7 years of updates before being sorted out. You can buy plenty of "real Linux" phones just now and also LineageOS preinstalled phones which will probably be supported for a very long time. https://blog.jolla.com/jolla7/ https://blog.jolla.com/jolla7/
- lolinder 4y agoYes, I came here to say this. Swapping out the battery is a great improvement only if the device's lifetime is longer than the battery's, and my batteries tend to last more than three years. (Writing this on my 5 year old phone that still has the original battery.)
- kaetemi 4y agoThe only thing that's dead in all my old phones is the battery, and the outdated OS.
- adverbly 4y agoI've lost multiple phones to dead charging ports.
- jimnotgym 4y agoI think this varies a lot, especially for heavy commercial users who talk on their phone a lot. Only last week my sister was complaining that iphones need charging twice a day after 2 years. It doesn't affect me with my current phone, but I am a light user.
- scns 4y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34944079 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34944079
- lucakiebel 4y agoYes, though they can always make it easy to run a custom rom and rely on the community for (security) updates
- lolinder 4y agoCustom rom support would be helpful for a very niche audience, but it's not something that's going to make a dent in e-waste at all. I'm a pretty tech savvy user who runs Linux on my desktop and I'm too intimidated to try a custom ROM on my phone. The average Nokia customer isn't going to even know it's an option, much less be willing to take the plunge. If Nokia is serious about fighting e-waste they need to provide a longer lifecycle of updates.
- comte7092 4y agoPeople willing to repair their own device is a niche audience as well. If you’re willing to go through the effort of fixing your device, there’s a decent chance you’re willing to flash a custom rom.
- lolinder 4y agoScreens yes, battery no. Or at least changing batteries used to be mainstream. Anyone born before the year 2000 should not be at all intimidated by changing a battery. I can't speak for Gen Z, it's possible they've lost that skill.
- angry_octet 4y agoIt's just very expensive. If it becomes affordable they will do it. I remember having spare batteries for my Motorola, and an external battery charger, because charging via the built in would take ages.
- dlhavema 4y agoI remember my Old Samsung's and HTC thunderbolt all have replaceable batteries, as well as the Motorola Droid which was super cool.. Not going to these were the early ones. I think starting with the S8 or so they stopped letting you replace the battery. I'm on pixels now. And my Pixel 6 doesn't have a replaceable battery...
- moffkalast 4y agoWell it's not like desktop OSes are much better, your average LTS Linux distro gets like what, four or five years of updates before they pull the plug?
- RamRodification 4y agoWhat's your point? It's not like you are no longer able to update your computer's OS when that happens.
- lolinder 4y agoWhen I get to year 4 I install the next major version of my distro. My hardware doesn't go to the junkyard. Meanwhile, my mom was just reminding everyone in my family that Android security updates stopping means they have to replace their phone more often than they would otherwise like to.
- moffkalast 4y agoSo what's the actual technical hurdle of doing this on mobile devices too? I mean in practice it's because the manufacturer blocks it, but I don't really understand why (outside maliciously wanting you to buy their new stuff ofc). The architecture has been arm64 forever, memory and storage slowly increases but not in any way that really matters for an OS. There are specifically optimized apps to get the most out of the camera hardware and such, but if OpenCamera can handle all phone cameras on the market decently there's some level of API standardization and not that much to it. Some kernel drivers or wifi chipsets or something they can't be arsed to keep supporting? I really don't get why one couldn't theoretically just keep updating to the latest Android into perpetuity or why it's even an option not to do so.
- raron 4y ago> Some kernel drivers or wifi chipsets or something they can't be arsed to keep supporting? Yup, there is no documentation for these chips, you probably gets some SDK with an old version of heavily modified linux kernel in a big ZIP file (so no version control history, no diffs), sometimes you only got some random binary blob. Because every chip manufacturer thinks (maybe right?) that with a good mainline driver or at least with good documentation all their competition advantage would disappear. (Some gigabit Ethernet phy chip manufacturers do the same even if 1 GbE is more than 20 years old...) Imagine the same issue as the GPU card support as it was a few years ago, just multiply it by ten and apply for every insignificant peripheral device. (And nobody will start to reverse-engineer it, because you will not be able to buy the chip half a year later.) I do not think this will change without an open chip (do no think it is possible, it would have too much NRE cost, maybe if some government use it to spin up local semiconductor manufacturing?) or some heavy regulation (eg. force compatibility between vendors).
- userbinator 4y agowhile offering just three years of security updates, after which you basically have to throw the thing away? "security" is just used as an excuse, in practice there's very little in the way of remotely exploitable vulnerabilities. In fact the "security" of newer devices seems to be squarely aimed against the user, so make of that what you will...
- angry_octet 4y agoRemotely exploitable does not require it can be hacked without user action (although there have been many exploits which have achieved that too, e.g. Pegasus) but typically involves visiting a web page, opening an attachment, or installing an app with a vulnerability. Chrome updates and app scanning will protect against some problems, but advances are often tied to platform security features. So really, you've made an absurd comment. If the phone is to be usable past 3-4 years it must have security patches. Otherwise there will be a pool of devices which are still in use and easily targetted.
- userbinator 4y agoOtherwise there will be a pool of devices which are still in use and easily targetted. There already are, and the world hasn't ended yet... It's your paranoia that's absurd (and what these companies are relying on to keep the masses under their control, so keep drinking the kool-aid...) The fact that so many here are going on about updates and support, when in fact there's plenty of people who don't give a shit and the world works fine for them, just shows what a corporate-authoritarian shitshow this cursed industry has become.
- angry_octet 4y agoYou've obviously never dealt with people who've been hacked and had their life's savings extracted or the business made unviable. Just goes to show, you can lead a horse to security patches (or vaccination, or the effects of climate change) but you can't make him apply them.
- Timothycquinn 4y agoI would love for them to announce them to be Graphene OS ready out of the box by contributing a Graphene distro from the get-go. I know this is a vendor lock in nightmare but it would open up a huge market for the security conscious and those young ones interested in getting phones that are just for photos and texts.
- kristopolous 4y agoIn practice I've been cycling phones about every two years. I just checked and all resources I've seen puts the typical lifespan around this. I don't know what the distribution looks like though. I bet the distribution curves change if you bucket the pricing points. 3 years is ok. After you buy it, they've made 100% of the money they're going to make in the transaction. They need money to come in to support such an effort
- mikepurvis 4y agoI'm still rocking an iPhone 8, and it's just fine for me— came out in Sept 2017. At this point I consider Apple's commitment to long term support to be a key element of my loyalty to them.
- cubefox 4y agoYes, this I consider the key advantage of iOS over Android. Alas, Apple also supports some highly anticompetitive business practices (App Store exclusivity/tax, EMS/iMessage) which I do not want to support.
- cyanwave 4y agoIt’s true. They’re one of the best values if you can afford them all things considered. Store network, long term software. Quality of SOC, all components.
- mikepurvis 4y agoIf you can't afford one at new prices, you can always pick them up for a fraction of that 2-3yrs after release, and still get a solid few years of supported use out of them at that point.
- Baeocystin 4y agoI hear you about support being a big deal. I'm still happily using my S10+, and am pissed that it just received its last update. It's working absolutely fine, and I have less than zero desire to 'upgrade' to a phone that doesn't have an audio jack, SD card support, and the ability to use swipe-style card readers to pay, three features I use on a daily basis. And yet before the year is up, I'll need to move on for security reasons alone.
- nektro 4y agoa different OEM can buy these up with better OS support and ppl can install custom ROMs
- devy 4y agoI don't see a 3-year security update as an irony. In fact, I see that as a great gesture for the budget price point android phone has a 3-year software warranty. Nokia probably have done research on this pricing segment to know that the averaging budget android device lifecycle is about 2.x years and guarantee a 3 year security update to make the device more worthy, comparing to other brands at this price point. By the way, NO ONE offer unlimited years of security updates, even Apple iPhone as the gold standard only provide security updates up to 6-7 years but Apple charges at least 2 times of the price.
- cvalka 4y agoThe 3 year security update policy was the requirement for Android one.
- nilespotter 4y agoAt least 2 times the price... at least, indeed: > The Nokia G22 will cost from £149.99
- Angostura 4y agoThey should offer paid-for upgrades after 3 years
- IncRnd 4y agoThat would increase the cost of the phone, since they would have to support and test the phone long past the expected lifetime. But, this is marketed as a budget phone, so they aren't going to do that.
- thepangolino 4y agoThat’s why he said paid for.
- IncRnd 4y agoThis is a budget phone, so there are very few people who would purchase extended security support after three years. There certainly won't be enough to cover the business costs for keeping the support and testing of an old crufty phone used by few people. It's unsustainable to put the costs on the backend, so phone's price would have to be raised to cover those extended security updates. But, that won't happen for a budget phone. There just won't be enough people willing to pay after three years. That's the problem with purchasing a budget phone. You get what you pay for, a phone that will go away soon.
- firecall 4y agoCan you install your own Android versions? How does it work Android in this regard? I guess it’s not like Windows where if my hardware is supported I can install the latest supported version? I suppose it’s somewhat interesting in the industry difference between supporting hardware with updates as if it’s firmware, and supporting software with updates like an OS. (Not advocating for windows for anything at all BTW)
- netsharc 4y agoHomebrew ROMs often don't have Google's holywater blessing of being certified, so some things like banking apps might not run on them. So, say your phone has old Android version x. You're fine until a security hole shows up, or your banking app says "Our app needs Android version x+1. Please update your phone.". Oops, not offered by phone. Install a custom ROM. Banking app says "This device is not certified and for your own security, we refuse to run on this phone."...
- IntelMiner 4y agoDoesn't "Magisk" alleviate a lot of that? Except for I believe Netflix and its Widevine bullshit
- eastof 4y agoCommenting from CalyxOS, which usually receives Android security updates within a week of release https://calyxos.org/docs/guide/device-support/ https://calyxos.org/docs/guide/device-support/
- kernal 4y agoTo test this out I installed apps from 3 of the largest banks on a Nexus 5 running Lineage OS 20 (Android 13 - yes a 9 year old phone with 2GB of RAM running Android 13 very well) with a minimum install of Google Play Services. 1 app said I was running a modified version of Android, but let me proceed to log in. The other 2 let me log in immediately with no warning message.
- cleanchit 4y agoWhat APIs do the banking apps use to verify the holy water blessing?
- capableweb 4y agoSeems this new phone costs about 150 EUR, which for three years, would be 50 EUR per year, if you keep for as long as it gets security updates. A iPhone 14 costs ~1000 EUR where I am. If you expect to get 7 years of security updates out of it (I think that's what Apple says? Not sure, someone please correct me), then it'll be 142 EUR per year. Three times the price, if you calculate it per year. After three years of having this Nokia phone, you can buy the new model, have it for three years again, and repeat this in a total of 6 times (900 EURs, for security updates during 18 years), and you still didn't pay as much as you paid for the iPhone. So with all of this in mind, seems to be a pretty OK guarantee, timeline and price, at least compared to the "flagship" smartphone that Apple makes.
- sdf4j 4y agoA budget phone that is just less than three times cheaper than the most expensive flagship one?
- capableweb 4y agoThe most expensive flagship from Apple costs around 2000 EUR (more than 10 times cheaper), I meant "flagship" of smartphones in general, but one of the cheaper ones recently released from Apple. You still get the same amount of years of security updates though, if you buy the cheapest model from Apple or not.
- swatcoder 4y agoPeople will note that there are worse problems in the world, but tossing a sophisticated piece of electronics every three years by design sounds really wasteful, especially when practical capabilities change so much more slowly now. It’s a bummer that this is normalized.
- cubefox 4y agoI was comparing repairability to longer security updates, not cheap Android phones to expensive iPhones. For that matter, iPhones aren't especially repairable either: So if a cheap Nokia can be better than an iPhone in this regard, why couldn't it be at least as good in terms of updates?
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 4y agoHot take: security updates are overrated. People with fully updated iPhones and Pixels still get pwned. It seems like people's wants and needs change with whatever the hell Apple decides to do.
- palata 4y agoThat's a wrong look at security, I think. Everything is "pwnable", if you put enough resources into it. The question is how much resources do you need to put into it? If you have a 5 years-old never-patched Android, probably a student can go read disclosed security issues, pick one that they understand (or for which they found a tutorial online), and hack you. It's not the same thing as saying that your patched iPhone can be hacked by NSO, though.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 4y agoNo shit. It's important but I'm wondering if it's overrated. It's a phone. I've passed on lots of devices because they aren't supported for long. It makes me wonder if the security updates are a mere sales pitch that doesn't actually benefit the user a whole lot. Great, it's harder to hack me. Would I have been hacked if I stuck with my Pixel 3? Hard to say. Overrated
- palata 4y ago> security updates are a mere sales pitch that doesn't actually benefit the user a whole lot Whose sales pitch would that be? I haven't noticed that, I believe security is mostly seen a source of cost. Also we tend to change phone frequently, which is the same as a security update. But if you keep it for 5 years, it starts to matter more. > Would I have been hacked if I stuck with my Pixel 3? Hard to say. Everyone should fasten their seat belt when driving a car, but it does not mean at all that if you don't, then you will have an accident. But if you did, it is an established fact that the seat belt would probably help. People do get hurt by security issues. Remember NSO Pegasus? Would you want that to be out in the wild, such that a kid in your daughter's school could get access to her phone/social media/camera/pictures? I am pretty sure you do want some level of security.
- pentagrama 4y agoIs that risky have an unsupported Android version? My Nexus 5 still working ok, some problems started when apps started to drop support of the Android version, and that happens several years before it stopped receiving OS updates. Don't want to downplay that will be great that OS updates should be longer that the current standard, but sometimes tech minded people here in HN thinks that a day after stopped receiving updates the phone is a useless brick ais not the case.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- palata 4y agoI want updates mostly for security reasons. If your phone hasn't received a security update in a year, I can just go check security issues that were published online, pick one that I like, and write an app that will exploit it.
- HybridCurve 4y agoWhen the security updates stop, the phone should be wiped of personal data and isolated from both cellular and wireless networks. There should be no compromise on this, a phone has access to far too much personal information and local wifi networks to ever consider using it beyond is support lifetime. Additionally, we should all be more diligent ensuring our personal devices install security updates as soon as they are available especially before going to large events (conventions, sports games, F1, etc...) or areas which are high traffic (airports, etc..).
- Mistletoe 4y agoPoe's law is an adage of Internet culture saying that, without a clear indicator of the author's intent, any parody of extreme views can be mistaken by some readers for a sincere expression of the views being parodied.
- cleanchit 4y agoEvery single one of the thousands of packages you install with `npm i` has acces to your `~/.ssh`.
- atleta 4y agoThat's a fair point, but indeed a lot of people will kill their phone in less than 3 years. Either breaking the screen (which, IIUC, will be also replaceable/self servicable) or killing the battery. Most sources say that the battery will keep an acceptable capacity for around 500 cycles, i.e. 1.5 years if fully charged daily. (Now I don't know, because I'm very cautious not to fully charge and to discharge below 25-30%, so mine is pretty good after 1.5 years and the previous phone that I've used for 5+ years started draining the battery after a software update when it was less than 6 mo old...) Speaking about batteries, what would be nice if they added a setting that allows defining charging limits, e.g. like what we have on Lenovo Thinkpads. (You can specify both the upper threshold and also the lower one, so that charging doesn't start if the battery is above that level even if you connect the device. Which you may do to a phone even without wanting to charge, e.g. if you use it as a modem.)
- lolinder 4y ago> Most sources say that the battery will keep an acceptable capacity for around 500 cycles, i.e. 1.5 years if fully charged daily. This is what I see online, but this hasn't been my experience for any of my devices. My current phone is on year 5 with the same battery, and it's still very decent. I charge it every day to 100% and often plug it back in while it's still at 50%, so it's not like I'm being more careful than usual. There's a cynical part of me that thinks that these kinds of numbers are put forward by the industry to feed the narrative that these gadgets need to be replaced regularly.
- flippinburgers 4y agoI have a similar experience.
- josephg 4y agoYeah; and batteries can be replaced when they start losing their charge. New batteries are pretty cheap. I had an iPhone 6s that I used for about 5-6 years before upgrading and giving it to a friend to use. I replaced its battery at about the 4 year mark, and as far as I know it’s still going strong. I wanted to upgrade it earlier than that, and I could afford to - but why bother when my phone already did everything I needed it to do? 3 years of security updates is a joke. The hardware easily lasts over a decade if you want it to.
- YPPH 4y agoYou're absolutely right. If they wanted to make a truly repairable phone, they'd release the source code for all the binary blobs to enable the folks at LineageOS to continue to release fixes past the manufacturer's notional end of support period (which does not correlate with the possible lifespan of the device).
- hedora 4y agoIdeally, they would release the source code for the drivers, and the manuals for each IP block in the SoC, etc. For some reason, hardware manufacturers have decided that their manuals are secret. Of course, if you ban distribution of your product manuals, then only criminals that pirate your IP will be able to properly implement drivers for your product…
- gladiatr72 4y agoOh, cmon now. The N900 was the sweetest piece of pocketech since the palm 3! That has to be worth something. Man, if they put out a more modern piece of hardware that was designed on the same principle, I'd bye 5. (one backup and the others as gifts for skeptics.) And I'd promise to say at least one sycophanticlly positive thing about Nokia for a year! (sigh) PS I do realize that this in no way am actual response to the previous. I thought someone who might have an unbidden spasm of hope at the thought might have a better day if reminded of that one brief moment when an engineer's device made a brief appearance on the market's mass :)
- el_snark 4y agoPretty sure the Custom ROM crew will leap on this one, so flashing it with one of those seems like it will be an option.
- 45453836 4y agoTo be fair the mobile device iteration of the repairability movement has always been laden with irony. It's a user empowerment movement solving a problem users didn't care about or want to deal with, championed mainly by middle and upper income individuals in tandem with politicians looking for easy karma (bonus points if they're European because it makes them look tough against the big corporate Americans plus Samsung), all under the guise of helping users who want to save money (poor people) even though this category lacks the skills and the interest to repair their devices anyway outside of a rare few exceptions. At this point a model being easily repairable is like "GMO Free" labels on food, a thing you advertise because it'll bring in money from the activists while every other consumer ignores it and focuses on a combination of performamce and price. In short, as long as the device can be advertised based on its repairability I don't think the company cares much since the objective is already complete.
- britzkopf 4y ago> ...helping users who want to save money (poor people) even though this category lacks the skills and the interest to repair their devices anyway... Sorry, but can you explain this a little more. It's coming off as pretty offensive.
- quicklime 4y ago> even though this category lacks the skills and the interest to repair their devices anyway outside of a rare few exceptions Most poor people do have the skills to take their device into a repair shop to have it repaired? It makes a big difference to the price of the repair if the device is designed to be repairable. Even better if it’s something a user can do themselves, such as replace the battery in a Nokia 3310.
- hezag 4y ago> all under the guise of helping users who want to save money (poor people) even though this category lacks the skills and the interest to repair their devices anyway outside of a rare few exceptions This is simply not true. At least in my country, poor people generally have interest and the skills to repair their devices (or to pay someone to do so, as it's cheaper than buying a new one)
- dataflow 4y ago> while offering just three years of security updates, after which you basically have to throw the thing away Nope, you don't. It's just that somehow techies seem to have gotten this meme into their heads that an unpatched life isn't worth living. Can't update my phone within 1 microsecond of a patch being released? I guess I might as well just die. Much safer than risking the << 1% chance of getting malware on it, and everyone knows malware is worse than hell. > The repairability sounds nice, but it is very irrelevant compared to the limited software updates. I had an Android phone that didn't have OS updates for several years and... it was just fine. I was only forced to finally upgrade to get better reception on other bands it didn't support. If the hardware could keep pace I would've easily kept it with its current OS for another half decade, until apps just got so bloated that I couldn't use it anymore. > Imagine buying a Windows laptop and only receiving three years of security updates That's a bad analogy for so many reasons. Android's security is WAY more hardened than Windows's, your phone's apps (including your [likely] Chrome browser) would still get security updates, and even with Windows this isn't as horrifying as you're suggesting. (I've done much worse.)
- grishka 4y agoI build Android apps for a living. Let me tell you, the majority of users are on "outdated" OS versions. You have to support 5-7 years of Android releases to cover a substantial part of the Android user base. The app I'm currently working on requires a minimum version of 6.0 — this came out in 2015. I still test my apps on a Nexus 5. Many people would buy a phone that will never receive a single update. The software it came with is the only software it'll ever run. And they're fine with that. They see software updates as an annoyance and I fully understand them.
- Sammi 4y agoTell your management that usage of v6.0 is as good as gone, and you are wasting resources in doing any work to keep support for it: https://gs.statcounter.com/android-version-market-share/mobile-tablet/worldwide/#monthly-201706-202301 https://gs.statcounter.com/android-version-market-share/mobi... I you look at that data then you can see that the oldest version with any significant usage is v8.1. But even that is quite low, and you might do quite well in not supporting anything older than v9.0.
- kernal 4y agoThe phone costs $150 and you expect more than 3 years of updates? Here's a hack to get 12 years of updates - buy a new Nokia every 3 years x 4 and get 12 years of security updates for less than the cost of an iPhone 13.
- cubefox 4y agoThat argument would also count against repairability, therefore it doesn't show that longer updates are better than higher repairability.
- roryisok 4y agoStupid question, but what are security updates in a smartphone context? Surely Android updates are the security updates? Wouldn't keeping this thing up to date with the latest version of Android be enough to be secure? Or am I running a horribly insecure life right now?
- vagrantJin 4y ago> very irrelevant compared to the limited software updates That's the funny thing. Security? I don't want updates and my phone is over 6 years old. But the app developers usually threatens and holds my data ransom until I update. Some have the audacity to update upon any internet connection in direct contravention of my "no background data usage" policy on any connection. Funny that.
- Springtime 4y agoIt's why I've looked to LineageOS and which brands tend to get the longest support. There are apparently devotees to the Google Pixel line, with the Pixel 2 (2017) being one of the longest currently supported, receiving the latest Android 13. Granted, it probably wouldn't have hardware patches for say Qualcomm's 2020 vulnerability but I'm glad there are users who put in the effort to patch older devices. Support seems to vary even between models though, so there's no guarantee support for continue as long for any others.
- mayankkaizen 4y agoI am currently typing this on a 4 years old shitty Xiaomi budget mobile phone. I don't recall if I've ever updated mobile software (or if there was an update available) but my phone is working as good as it should. So far I haven't seen any problem in installing any app. I don't see myself replacing this phone in next 6 month at least. I guess tech people are way too much worried about security/software updates.
- usr1106 4y agoTo make things worse the 3 years seem to be counted from the release of the phone, not from when you buy it. So if you buy it a year after it came out, you get only 2 years. I am so sick of the whole smartphone crap. Google monopoly (well, there is Apple, but it's worse), unhandy sizes, electronic waste years too early.
- BeefWellington 4y agoThat's not exclusive to this Nokia; all manufacturers do the "from release" vs "from purchase" thing. This is one area I really wish more manufacturers would follow Apple's lead on.
- BeefWellington 4y agoAgreed, it would've been great to see a matching five year commitment to security updates. However, you can run alternate Android versions and get security updates even longer, outside of security updates for component firmware.
- cubefox 4y agoIt seems slightly unlikely there would be a custom ROM for such an unknown phone. In any case, custom ROMs are not an option for ordinary people.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]