14 ms·
U.S. corn-based ethanol worse for the climate than gasoline, study finds
- silverwasthere 4y agoI thought corn ethanol was for fuel diversity, not green energy.
- milsorgen 4y agoIt was positioned as both at one point. Really they just threw out every imagined or perceived benefit and ran with it irrespective of what the data was or is indicating.
- jonnycomputer 4y agoNot surprising; that's been the common wisdom for quite some time now.
- ok123456 4y agoSo that means we're going to start phasing it out?
- ch4s3 4y agoNo, it's an agricultural subsidy that is important to states that appear early in presidential primaries so its pretty well locked in for now.
- barathr 4y agoIowa is losing that status this coming cycle, so things may begin to shift.
- ch4s3 4y agoIt's Probably losing it's place in the DNC primary, but Michigan which plants 2 million acres of corn will be 5th and Iowa still might be on Super Tuesday. If the RNC keeps the early caucus it might turn into a more partisan issue which might be worse.
- dragonwriter 4y ago> It's Probably losing it's place in the DNC primary, The rule has already passed. It can defy the rule and keep its early date, but then it will lose half its delegates under the rule. > Michigan which plants 2 million acres of corn will be 5th Fifth isn't second, and two million acres of corn in a state with a $473B GDP is not the same significance as thirteen million acres in a state with a $180B GDP > Iowa still might be on Super Tuesday. Most of the country that isn’t on the early calendar is on Super Tuesday
- ch4s3 4y agoCertainly all true, but I think it's still to be seen what kind of influence the Corn Belt will have in the DNC primaries, and what will happen with the RNC.
- bluedino 4y agoThere are only a couple gas stations around that still sell it where I live. One grocery store chain and then Speedway.
- ch4s3 4y agoI think this has been well established for years. I remember seeing some studies circa 2008 showing that more energy in the form of diesel and fossil fuel derived fertilizer went into corn ethanol than you get out in usable fuel. It has always been an agricultural subsidy.
- chasil 4y agoThe ethanol is required as an anti-knock additive. The past alternative was tetraethyllead, which had catastrophic environmental impact. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tetraethyllead#Antiknock_agent https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tetraethyllead#Antiknock_agent
- TylerE 4y agoNot true. We went decades without lead or ethanol. You can still get ethanol-free gas if you look hard, and modern engines run quite happily on it.
- pengaru 4y agoIt's not like lead-free and eathanol-free gas is devoid of anti-knock agents... for much of those decades MTBE was used which was part of a groundwater contamination scandal. Wikipedia has an interesting article on the subject @ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Antiknock_agent https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Antiknock_agent
- kube-system 4y agoIt is used, but not required, as an anti-knock additive. Unleaded E0 is still available in some places in the US with octane numbers on par with E10 and E15 blends https://stillwaterassociates.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/11/E0.png https://stillwaterassociates.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/11/... https://www.pure-gas.org/ https://www.pure-gas.org/
- bluGill 4y agoThose are not the same gasoline. Ethanol is high octane and so you mix it with a much worse grade of gasoline and get the same octane. E0 advocates attribute to lack of ethanol what is really just the better grade of gas.
- strawhatguy 4y agoNot too surprising, almost inevitable: the government demanded it to help the corn lobby, the excuse was it was greener. Bet we can't get rid of those regulations for years to come too, especially since new regs seem to be heading in the direction of banning all new gas cars. So probably after that, if at all.
- fetus8 4y agoAnd it generally gets much worse MPG compared to regular gasoline!
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 4y agoI wonder if this doesn't need to be the case. With the higher octane rating couldn't you in theory run a much more efficient and higher compression engine?
- deeviant 4y agoIt's a simple case of it's energy density. The energy content of ethanol is about 33% less than pure gasoline. Higher octane doesn't even necessary equate to higher gas mileage. As soon as octane is high enough for your engine tuning, there's no mileage benefit.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 4y ago> As soon as octane is high enough for your engine tuning, there's no mileage benefit. That's exactly my point. Would it be possible to design an engine from the ground up for very high octane fuels?
- mywittyname 4y agoYeah, this is how most E85 engines generally work. They have a E15 engine map, and an E85 and map. And use sensors to figure out which fuel is in the tank and which map to use. Stock cars generally don't take full advantage of the octane benefits of E85 because they will blow up if someone fills the tank with E15. But in the aftermarket world, "corn powered" cars make substantially more power, especially turbocharged ones. They have the benefit of owners that understand to manually switch maps when changing fuels.
- UncleEntity 4y agoThey don’t have to manually switch maps, modern ECUs can figure out the blend and compensate.
- programmarchy 4y agoDoesn’t it also wear down engines more quickly?
- SteveGerencser 4y agoEthanol is hard on all the soft bits in an engine. Rubber seals, diaphrams and so on. This is most dramatically seen in small engines that still use carburetors vs fuel injection.
- bluGill 4y agoThat isn't the ethanol, that is the bad gasoline they mix in with the ethanol. When you buy E0 you get a better grade of gasoline that doesn't degrade the seals as much.
- ravenstine 4y agoNo, it does not. This myth will not die hard. It's not a total myth per se, because it once was and sometimes still can be true for engine components that are simply not designed to handle ethanol. Such is not the case for pretty much every car built after the year 2000, roughly speaking. Every soft component in modern cars is designed to handle at least 10% ethanol, and effectively handle 100% ethanol. Corrosion is not really an issue either. The E85 you get from a pump is anhydrous, and the only way you'll get things like phase separation is if water is added deliberately. Ethanol doesn't pull water into gasoline. That's a myth. It's not a dessicant. This topic has been studied and it's simply not worth worrying about. Most cars on the road today, including those that aren't Flex Fuel, can run somewhere between E30 and E50 with no problems whatsoever. They can even run on E85 or E100 with either a software update or a piggyback device between the ECU and the fuel injectors, everything else remaining OEM. A car running on ethanol won't rust, fall apart, or blow up. If anything, ethanol can be better for engines given that it burns cooler and leaves way less carbon deposits. If a small engine today has seal failures or other issues, it's more likely to be the BTX (benzene, toluene, xylene) in gasoline and not the ethanol component. By the way, I'm speaking from direct experience. Not only have I converted small engines to run on ethanol, but I converted my 2013 Hyundai to be a flex fuel vehicle.
- igravious 4y agoWe can't build out tried and tested nuclear reactors but we can and will continue to do this. I am so done with the "green" movement.
- droopyEyelids 4y agoAny movement will get partially coopted by entrenched business interests
- Avshalom 4y agoweird thing to call the iowa corn lobby.
- titaniumtown 4y agoYes, the corn lobby's pressure is totally comparable to the entire push for green energy /s
- bryanlarsen 4y agoCorn farmers are generally more Ducks Unlimited type environmentalists than Greenpeace type environmentalists.
- Laaas 4y agoIntuitively this seems wrong. The explanation in the article doesn't seem convincing. Any form of synthetic fuel that doesn't take more carbon out of the Earth should be better, no?
- hammock 4y agoMore energy in the form of diesel and fossil fuel derived fertilizer went into corn ethanol than you get out in usable fuel
- l33t233372 4y agoI think that the post was saying that it doesn’t require us to take carbon out from deep within earth and put it into the atmosphere.
- uoaei 4y agoIt's an irrelevant point. Carbon emissions include logistics and manufacturing operations.
- ttyprintk 4y agoMaybe not specifically addressed in this article, but those researchers also look at CO2 emissions from simply disturbing the land and converting grassland for farming. In Brazil, burning rainforest for ag use looks very bad abroad. Should be similar on the American prairie.
- sbradford26 4y agoThe issues is that it does. Using tractors to farm and harvest it all, all the industrial processes to create fertilizer all require carbon to be taken from within the earth. If you only look at the corn to fuel yes it doesn't produce as much additional carbon, but once you include all the externalities you have more carbon emitting processes.
- randomdata 4y ago
- cess11 4y ago"Corn is not a _food_. Corn is a _platform_." https://twunroll.com/article/1074810043495796736 https://twunroll.com/article/1074810043495796736
- Supermancho 4y agoThe silly way they connect corn to bananas annoys me, which you could do for literally anything, corn -> fuel -> lights -> you ate near a light ergo CORN! I don't see how this is anything but good. Having a single crop for so many things, makes the replicator go brrr. Yes it's a single point of failure, but it's efficient to use food production to scale everything else and it's not a dead-end if corn were to have problems (ie Interstellar)
- ch4s3 4y agoCorn has been the platform for civilization(s) in the Americas since agriculture was invented in Mesoamerica.
- cess11 4y agoArguably civilisation and market are orthogonal so the marketisation and commodification under capitalism means there's very little civilisation as well.
- ch4s3 4y agoI have know idea what this string of words means in context. Agricultural products, especially staple grains are all commodities, definitionally: "a raw material or primary agricultural product that can be bought and sold, such as copper or coffee." In the Inca store house system for example, potatoes were the central commodity, and all types of foods stuffs were made from the freeze dried potatoes. In MesoAmerica corn was used for food, drink, animal feed, and so on.
- mouse_ 4y agoGreat read. Starting a corn religion bbl.
- rr888 4y agoGasoline unlocks carbon that was buried underground. If we can avoid that surely its better?
- hammock 4y agoMore energy in the form of diesel and fossil fuel derived fertilizer went into corn ethanol than you get out in usable fuel
- kccqzy 4y agoOn a first approximation, food production (including corn) is just channeling natural gas into fertilizers through Haber–Bosch. If the produced food isn't actually being eaten, it's just a highly inefficient energy conversion Rube Goldberg machine. Now to answer your question, food production unlocks plenty of carbon underground through natural gas.
- ch4s3 4y agoNot to mention all of the fuel used to move around the fertilizer, tractors, finished corn, the energy used to grid/heat/ferment/distill into ethanol, and then to truck around the ethanol. It's actually almost hilariously indirect and inefficient when you think about it.
- mdp2021 4y agoWell all the final products (contextually, material fuels or just energy) have a production history: to call one of them inefficient you need to compare production processes. Diesel fuel does not come ready from "diesel springs".
- johncearls 4y agoA link to the study referenced if you are interested: https://www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.2101084119 https://www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.2101084119
- credit_guy 4y agoThanks for the link. As expected, the press distorted the study's conclusions to the point of actually lying: "we find that the production of corn-based ethanol in the United States has failed to meet the policy’s own greenhouse gas emissions targets and negatively affected water quality, the area of land used for conservation, and other ecosystem processes" It's one thing to "fail to meet" some emissions reductions and quite another to actually increase the emissions altogether.
- humaniania 4y agoWho paid for the study and have there been other studies on the topic?
- nerdo 4y agoStill better for the climate than burning the corn after harvesting it: https://www.farmcollector.com/farm-life/u-s-farmers-during-great-depression/ https://www.farmcollector.com/farm-life/u-s-farmers-during-g...
- ttyprintk 4y agoI wonder about that. Let’s take wood pellets, the largest market of which being converted coal-fired plants in Britain and Germany. Texas and North Carolina produce them for export. Under perfect conditions, waste sawdust becomes pellets but it’s understood in those states that old-growth timber is used. Shelled corn burns hotter than wood, and biomass pellet stoves make up a marginal part of the domestic heating market. For export, where heating and power generation are disrupted by war, shipping that corn seems a good transitional step without the harm associated with somehow discovering new sources of wood pellets.
- cashsterling 4y agoAs others mentioned, this is not a new finding. There is a lot of academic and industrial/economic analysis on this subject. Ethanol from corn was never a good idea economically for anyone other than corn farmers. It is also bad environmentally and places additional competitive demand on our food supply (choice and competition between corn going into food or fuel supply). Similar analysis has been done on other crop feed-stocks (switch grass, etc.) and none of the analysis has shown that crop derived ethanol is a good idea. I'm not a leading expert on this subject by any means, but I am a PhD chemical engineer and did a lot of research into alternative fuels science and economics about ten years ago. I'm not up on the latest research and analysis but the fundamental thermodynamics and carbon cycles of crop-based ethanol have not changed much in the past ten years or so.
- PaulHoule 4y agoEthanol from sugarcane in Brazil is not so bad.
- jfengel 4y agoCorn farmers from Iowa. Where they hold the first caucus of the interminable election season. No American politician or political party can afford to offend corn farmers. We should count ourselves lucky that our gasoline is only 10% corn.
- ch4s3 4y agoIt isn't just Iowa[1], the Corn Belt across the upper Mid West is the Saudi Arabia of Corn. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Corn_production_in_the_United_States#/media/File:Corn_belt.svg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Corn_production_in_the_United_...
- labrador 4y agowhich is why the Democratic Party changed it under cover of starting with "a more diverse state" Iowa no longer first; Democrats reorder the presidential primary calendar for 2024 https://www.desmoinesregister.com/story/news/politics/2022/12/02/dnc-democrats-primary-calendar-south-carolina-first-over-iowa-caucus/69695090007/ https://www.desmoinesregister.com/story/news/politics/2022/1...
- titaniumtown 4y agoIs there other crops that can be turned into ethanol that would be beneficial for the environment? Can't seem to find information on that.
- Sharlin 4y agoSure. As far as I know, corn is only used in the US, for fairly obvious reasons. Where I'm from it's made from carb-rich waste and sidestreams from various sources. Of course, the yields do pale in comparison to the corn megaindustry of the US, which produces more fuel ethanol than the rest of the world combined. Sugar cane is good, and used quite successfully in Brazil, but of course only grows in sub/tropical climates. Sugar beet is used in Europe to some extent, as well as staple crops like wheat and rye – not sure how they compare to corn. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ethanol_fuel https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ethanol_fuel
- trollerator23 4y agoThere is potatoes. In WW2 the potato production in Nazi Germany basically determined the launch rate of the V2 rocket, which used Ethanol derived from potatoes as fuel.
- ttyprintk 4y agoSome numbers: 26% of the worlds ethanol is grown in Brazil and becomes E22.
- ravenstine 4y agoYes, including sugar beets, sorghum, and even cattails. As far as whether we will or should use other crops, I doubt it. The whole thing with corn mostly came from the US having a large surplus of corn and needing something to do with it. Since we're operating on the false belief that the carbon cycle itself is a bad thing, and because we're trying to move to electric (theoretically), I don't think society is going to invest itself into more ethanol.
- bennysonething 4y agoI still don't understand why we're still doing bio fuels. We've known for decades that they are a disaster. Am I missing something, is there evidence to the contrary? For now I can't see how we can just stop fossil fuels without starving half the world (as we need them for fertilizer production). Never mind cement, plastics and steel.
- tstrimple 4y agoUnfortunately policy decisions seem to rarely be made based on evidence. It's a handout to farmers (and the entire ethanol industry) which politicians don't want to touch.
- HDThoreaun 4y agoWe're doing it to pump corn prices. Also energy independence from pre fracking days.
- Scoundreller 4y agoWhich pumps agricultural land values. Great news for retiring farmers. Cutting corn/food prices would bankrupt some overextended corporate/new entrant farmers (and their lenders), but it’s not like the fields would become unharvested.
- boomchinolo78 4y agoIt was never done for climate reasons. Purely economic and geopolitic
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- frankreyes 4y agoBecause farming equipment runs on gasoline.
- WaitWaitWha 4y agoDepends on the farm. My farm ran on all diesel.
- frankreyes 4y agoSorry not a native English speaker, when I said gasoline I meant petroleum derived liquid fuel such as gasoline or diesel or aviation fuel or kerosene.
- WaitWaitWha 4y agoNo worries; nor am I. I think in English speaking nations "petroleum" or "petroleum derivative" would work as an umbrella term.
- bluGill 4y agoNot since the mid 1960s at the latest. Sometimes hobby farms have gasoline tractors. Many farms still have a working tractor from the 1950s they use for small tasks. There is some random lawnmower sized equipment with a gas engine. Overall though diesel is much cheaper to run in the real world and so no "real farm" uses gasoline for much farming.
- frankreyes 4y agoSorry not a native English speaker, when I said gasoline I meant petroleum derived liquid fuel such as gasoline or diesel or aviation fuel or kerosene.
- mdp2021 4y agoGiven a perspective emerging from many posts, I would note: behind the search for alternative fuels, there is the notion that reserves for fossil fuels may deplete.
- ravenstine 4y ago> The research, which was funded in part by the National Wildlife Federation and U.S. Department of Energy Can't imagine there's any conflict of interest there. > ethanol is likely at least 24% more carbon-intensive than gasoline due to emissions resulting from land use changes to grow corn, along with processing and combustion. The nice thing about words like "likely" is that it leaves the door open for the other thing. Did the study find that ethanol is more carbon-intensive, or is it someone's opinion that it's more intensive? I don't see how this adds up. As the article mentions, the carbon atoms in ethanol came from the atmosphere to which it returns. Yet not all of the carbon even makes it back. But the mere tilling of the soil puts ethanol somewhere worse than fossil fuels? By that logic, we'd better stop farming crops all together. > Tilling fields releases carbon stored in soil, while other farming activities, like applying nitrogen fertilizers, also produce emissions. And we're to assume that, without the production of fuel ethanol, the same land wouldn't be tilled and used for other crops? What is the nature of the carbon in that soil? Is it carbon that is constantly making its way up through the soil and into the atmosphere? Does stable isotope testing corroborate that it's a meaningful contributor to the global increase in atmospheric CO2?
- bluGill 4y agoPlowing the soil is a terrible thing to do. Which is why no farmer has done it since around 1980. Modern tilling is much better for the soil, and doesn't release as much carbon form the soil (it needs more power from the tractor, and thus more CO2 from fuel, but still a lot less carbon total because the soil is saved. The above is also why GMO crops are so great for the environment: by using a little roundup (just a little - not only is it a mist sprayed, but that mist is mostly water) much less fuel is used vs cultivating (think mechanical hoe).
- RosanaAnaDana 4y ago>Plowing the soil is a terrible thing to do. Which is why no farmer has done it since around 1980. Thats just not true. Plenty of farmers still plough. There has been some movement to lower disturbance low-till/ minimum-till systems for commodity crops, but we're still seeing soil carbon losses in agricultural soils in general. Number isn't going up and to the right, its still going down and to the left. I appreciate the importance of these kinds of systems, but I also appreciate that its not nearly as well adopted as one would think based on a survey of youtube videos. There is a very real departure from the Internets vision of farming and real-life farming in terms of practice. I do agree however that carbon in the soils is the answer to most problems. The closest thing I came to witnessing a fist fight at work was between two 50+ yo scientists regarding aluminium/ alumina ions and their relationship with soil carbon. If geriatric scientsits are willing to raise fisticuffs over it, you should wonder why they care so much.
- thinkthink 4y ago[dead]
- Scoundreller 4y ago> There is more to Ethanol than just fuel. But mostly fuel. The amount of fuel burned by the average person directly and indirectly is wayyyyyyy more than their distilled beverage and hand sanitizer consumption.
- UncleEntity 4y agoIs this article based on the same paper as the retracted article? Timeline seems to match up.
- photochemsyn 4y agoI've seen a lot of these studies and the problem is always the same: the real-world spread on the inputs and outputs is always so much larger than what the report concludes. Since they're comparing ethanol and gasoline, you have two spreads to consider. As an example: Worst-case for standard gasoline vs Best-case for corn ethanol: A) Gasoline produced from Alberta tar sands syncrude (which has to be melted and partially hydrogenated using natural gas piped in from Northern Canada/Alaska) shipped by oil tanker (burning dirty bunker fuel) to California refineries for conversion to gasoline by distillation/cracking (with high CO2 emissions related to use of fuel to drive the require heating of the heavy crude oil); B) Ethanol produced from corn grown with ammonia fertilizer made by splitting water with sun/wind energy, planted and harvested with renewable-powered electric equipment, and fermented and distilled into 95% pure ethanol (the eutectic limit of distillation) using only solar and wind power and in facilities right next to the farmer's fields; And, conversely, the best case for gasoline and the worst case for ethanol: C) Gasoline produced from regionally-produced light sweet crude with a minimal need for transport, hydrogenation or extensive processing, meaning much lower emissions from transportation and refining (we could even have electrolytic hydrogenation from water using sunlight to produce the hydrogen); D) Corn produced in Kansas with large amounts of natural-gas-manufactured ammonia fertilizer, lots of natural-gas-derived synthetic pesticides and herbicides, planted and managed with diesel-powered equipment, then shipped overseas to China for fermentation and conversion to ethanol in a coal-fired ethanol distillery. So if you break those spreads down you get a ridiculously wide range of estimates. Hence any specific number presented ('at least 25%' in this case) doesn't really tell you that much, other than if you dig through the specific methods used (which are generally hard to find, sometimes they'll put the methods in another paper hidden behind a paywall) you can tell what interest was backing this particular study. Some will even include things like the carbon emissions needed to feed the workers who grow the crops, or who work in the refinery, and so on, which is just nonsense. (The emissions of the restaurant workers who feed the oil refinery workers and the field hands have to be accounted for...?) Personally, I think artificial photosynthesis is the vastly superior solution relative to either corn ethanol or crude oil gasoline, as you could plausibly run it anywhere with access to seawater and sunlight, saving agricultural land for food production (and conserving ever-scarcer potable water as well). It does however make sense to be able to convert excess agricultural production into useful products, although just composting it back into the soil might be wiser in the long run.
- jeffwask 4y agoThis is nothing more than a back door farming subsidy which is also why it's so hard to kill.
- Proven 4y ago[dead]
- xen2xen1 4y agoSo "oil and water don't mix", as is often said. Oil/ gas with corn based additives DO mix with water, so it cannot be piped through a pipeline, thus making it be carried totally by truck, and making it's carbon footprint even worse.
- bluGill 4y agoIt cannot be put in existing pipelines. You can build a whole new pipeline that will carry ethanol. Nobody wants to invest that much money.
- culopatin 4y agoFor 10% replacement? Not worth it.
- UncleEntity 4y agoI kind of doubt any of it is transported by truck but most likely by train.
- xen2xen1 4y agoI was told, while working at a Refinery, that is was mostly done by truck.
- megaman821 4y agoThis would be better positioned as a crop surplus and/or crop waste to fuel initiative. The government could still encourage overproduction of staple crops to guard against food shortages while being a reliable buyer of the the surplus to make ethanol out of.
- mcv 4y agoA big problem with agriculture-based bio-fuels, is that growing crops with modern technology uses a lot of fuel. Tractors and other machinery, fertilizer, and a million other things all take energy, which often comes in the form of fossil fuels. My brother-in-law has a farm, and claims that if you look at the amount of energy used and produced by farms, agriculture hasn't been economically viable for more than half a century. We pump fuel out of the ground, have farms turn it into food, and we eat that. It works because the energy from fossil fuels is already there, and eating is important. But if farms turn fuel into more fuel, those farms need to be a lot more efficient, or we're just burning fuel for nothing.
- bilsbie 4y agoIt’s unreal how much ethanol lowers your gas milage too! Experienced my local station switch to 10% and saw my milage go from 28 to 24. Pretty positive no other factors changed.
- tristan957 4y agoThis site might help you. https://www.pure-gas.org/ https://www.pure-gas.org/
- twiddling 4y agoBut great for votes in corn producing states
- r00fus 4y agoThe only way this gets resolved is when political parties stop pretending that Iowa is somehow representative of their voters and shift the primary schedule to put it farther behind other states. Democrats especially shouldn’t put up with Iowa considering how it hasn’t voted D anytime recently. Not to mention the completely FUBAR 2020 primary. Make GA or NH first contest. Then a lot less pressure for this losing ethanol boondoggle.
- dragonwriter 4y ago> Make GA or NH first contest. The DNC already voted to make SC first in 2024 (the early – pre-Super Tuesday – order in the new rule being SC => NH & NV => GA => MI)
- Mattasher 4y agoFWIW if you live in place with boating and you might be able to find REC-90 for sale, which is Ethanol free.
- dragontamer 4y agoOf course its Dr. Lark again. He's been contradicting USDA for years. There's something like 12+ PH.ds who are working in this field and create papers consistently. 11 of them agree, and then Dr. Lark comes out and disagrees. Every couple of years, Dr. Lark comes out with a new set of studies that contradicts everyone else. And then the news organizations / hacker news around here focuses on what Dr. Lark says rather than what the other 11 guys say. ---------- I don't necessarily want to demean Dr. Lark or his work. But people need to have context here. This guy is anti-Biofuel, and has been since the early 00s (maybe earlier). I'm not 100% sure what to do about this problem per se. Contrarian professors are important parts of the scientific process. Someone like Dr. Lark is very important to making sure that everyone's i's are dotted and t's are crossed. But the general "media" picks up on the contrarian, and uses that as "Entire field is wrong, everybody is wrong" and shouts it from the rooftops. Rather than... you know... rightfully pointing out that they're focused on the contrarian. -------------- We need contrarians like Dr. Lark. But we don't need media overly focusing upon contrarians and highlighting their specific research as if its the mainstream in the field. See yall in 2 years when Dr. Lark publishes another contradictory paper, like he always does.
- throw_away1525 4y agoHonest questions from a totally ignorant cynic: Who is funding who here? Is Dr. Lark being funded by the fossil fuel industry? Are the 11 other scientists being funded by 'big corn' or the USDA itself? Does the USDA/'big corn' have a revolving door situation where the USDA scientists have come from and maintain ties to industry?
- dragontamer 4y agoThat's just not the point of this at all. Dr. Lark's contribution, is that he has correctly identified holes in everyone else's research on a somewhat consistent basis. Sometimes you need an outsider to see the flaws in your methodology. Dr. Lark in particular brought up the issue of land use changes: how forests get cut down, release a lot of carbon, and then farmland is made over the forests. He has legitimate points, and releases calculations and research to show how it changes the biofuels numbers. Yes, its exaggerated at times and then the counter-points come out, but the push back-and-forth is necessary to advance the field. And we actually have technology that answers questions that Dr. Lark poses. IIRC, Argonne National Labs took satellite photos over the USA, measured how many forests got converted into farms using AIs, and ran the numbers. The discussion going on is very high level and sophisticated, modern, and high tech. This is a field (and discussion) to be proud of as an American. --------- What I'm cynical about is how the media treats these discussions. They want to invent problems where there are no problems. Instead of pointing out what most of the researchers agree on, today's media focuses on what the singular, most extreme member of a group disagrees with everyone else about.
- fIREpOK 4y agoI thought that corn-based ethanol exists solely for the purpose of taking advantages of government subversives and had nothing to do with climate or the environment...
- mattdanger 4y agoFor those interested in learning more about the Renewable Fuel Standard (RFS), check out this podcast series. https://aei.ag/corn-saves-america/ https://aei.ag/corn-saves-america/ Cliffs: - Farmers were over producing corn and needed new markets. - Americans, sick of importing oil from conflict zones, desired a US produced fuel - Americans desired a renewable fuel source. - Brewers grain, a by-product of ethanol process could be marketed to dairy & beef producers as a less expensive feed source.
- G_z9 4y agoThis argument is the same as people who said electric cars are worse for global warming because they are powered by coal plants and take more energy to produce. Completely invalid! If there is a cheaper and easier-to-scale system of converting carbon dioxide in the air into hydrocarbon fuel, then I’m all ears.
- RobKohr 4y agoTurns out that growing corn - which uses a huge amount of fuel, to then turn that into fuel produces more emissions. Perhaps if we stopped paying people to grow corn, they wouldn't find such stupid things to do with the corn that no one wants to buy. Would corn syrup be such common ingredient without corn being so heavily subsidized. Would animals be kept in feedlots and filled with corn if it wasn't subsidized. Govt subsidizes of corn hurt our bodies, out environment, and our tax returns.