11 ms·
Signal would 'walk' from UK if Online Safety Bill undermined encryption
- Arathorn 4y agoTo be clear, this is a really serious situation. The current Online Safety Bill wording from https://bills.parliament.uk/publications/49376/documents/2822 https://bills.parliament.uk/publications/49376/documents/282... (https://bills.parliament.uk/bills/3137 https://bills.parliament.uk/bills/3137) is as follows: clause 124(3) declares that OFCOM (the telco industry regulator) can impose "proactive technology" to comply with or remediate illegal content, child safety or fraudulent advertising(!): (3) A proactive technology requirement may be imposed in a confirmation decision only for the purpose of complying with, or remedying the failure to comply with, any of the duties set out in— (a) section 9(2) or (3) (illegal content), (b) section 11(2) or (3) (children’s online safety), (c) section 23(2) or (3) (illegal content), (d) section 25(2) or (3) (children’s online safety), or (e) section 33(1) or 34(1) (fraudulent advertising). and clause 202(1)(a) then defines "Proactive technology" to mean: 202 “Proactive technology” (1) In this Act “proactive technology” means— (a) content moderation technology, (b) user profiling technology, or (c) behaviour identification technology, In other words, the Bill gives the industry regulator the ability to impose a requirement that communication apps implement content moderation technology - which for an end-to-end encrypted system, obviously means the ability to scan and exfiltrate encrypted content to moderators (as how else can you moderate content). As a result, anything that whatever scanning technology deems illegal would have to end up in an unencrypted moderation queue (presumably provided by the app vendor?!), thus completely violating the encryption privacy guarantees. For instance, folks in Ukraine using Signal/Element/etc to discuss being bombed might end up with their messages exfiltrated by the scanning software to a moderation queue because they include the word 'bomb', which is then a sitting target which bad actors would use to gather intelligence and entirely sidestep encryption. The penalty for not complying is still being determined, but could mean jail time for those building the apps: https://www.telegraph.co.uk/politics/2023/01/16/rishi-sunak-forced-back-online-safety-bill-tory-rebellion/ https://www.telegraph.co.uk/politics/2023/01/16/rishi-sunak-... This is LITERALLY the online equivalent of putting a CCTV camera in everyone's bedroom, hooking it up to an machine learning classifier to detect 'illegal activity', and then sending unencrypted recordings to a moderation queue run by the CCTV vendor. It's terrifying, and we have to stop it, before it sets a precedent that the EU follows with ChatControl, or that the US follows (or uses it as an excuse to remove E2EE entirely). The way to stop it is to yell about it loud on social media, talk go the press, and if you're in the UK, write to your MP (they do actually read these letters). Signal & others, if you're reading this: we need to coordinate on an open letter to UK Parliament (probably the House of Lords Committee) to present a united front against this; please ping me at matthew[at]matrix.org to sync. The OSB is alarmingly advanced through the legislative process, and we are running out of time to stop it.
- cnity 4y agoI have a question: what does it mean for the _users_ of messaging applications? If the OSB passes am I still within my rights to PGP encrypt my messages before sending them?
- walterbell 4y agoThat may depend on whether operating systems (including app stores and package managers) are also regulated, e.g. via the EU Cyber-Resilience Act, https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34760173 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34760173
- hellojesus 4y agoWorst case you could always roll your own based on proven open source libraries, down to the metal.
- Arathorn 4y agoIn the current wording: yes, you can go encrypt your messages with PGP before sending them. However, the worst-case scenario is that Ofcom would then say to Apple and Google: "Hey, you are communication service providers (thanks to iMessage and Google Messages/Chat/etc). We believe you are failing to adequately block illegal content. Therefore we legally require you to perform content moderation. And given you also provide the operating system for your services, and given you've already demonstrated you are willing to do client-side scanning at the OS layer (https://www.siliconrepublic.com/enterprise/apple-csam-child-safety-sexual-abuse-material-uk-privacy https://www.siliconrepublic.com/enterprise/apple-csam-child-...) clearly we expect you to scan for illegal content in the OS. Therefore, please scan all content for illegal content, otherwise we'll send your UK-based staff to jail. By the way, have you considered putting scanning in the graphics pipeline? Then we can make sure that you do OCR and image-classification on all pixels that users see, to make sure that after users PGP-decrypt their messages we can spot words like 'bomb' or worse, and send evidence through Apple/Google's moderation teams, so they can be able to block the illegal content and uphold their obligations to report CSAM etc to the authorities." To be clear, this is a worst-case scenario, but it's the logical extrapolation of what the OSB allows. (That said, IANAL).
- brokenmachine 4y agoAs someone who doesn't have children, I am appalled that there is no mandatory government surveillance in every home that contains a child. We must protect those children! Anyone against such reasonable child safety measures must have something to hide.
- localplume 4y agoIsn't this situation the entire purpose of Signal..? Don't they already operate in the most authoritarian countries in the world? I don't understand why they would walk.
- notpushkin 4y agoThis. I believe the problem is, UK is extremely powerful in terms of asking “please ban this and that app from app stores”, so they can effectively block it (unlike say Russia, which tried to block Telegram and failed spectacularly).
- sshine 4y agoI suppose the difference is negotiation: You can use leaving as a point of leverage in a country that allows for open debate about end-to-end encryption. You can claim that being in the country is at odds with the country's principles and threaten to pull out, or actually pull out, to make the users in that country aware that their basic privacy is being pulled away from them. In a country with an authoritarian regime, being an option under the radar provides may be a better option.
- Raed667 4y agoThere is a difference between an APK being installable or downloadable from a store and your CEO getting into legal heat because they won't backdoor their encryption.
- fauigerzigerk 4y agoYou have to consider how this would happen. If the government bans E2EE, Apple and Google will have to ban E2EE from their UK stores. Apps like Signal will then have to make a choice. Either publish an app that does not use E2EE or get removed from the app stores. What Signal are saying is that they would accept the ban rather than publish an app with weakened encryption. Apple users will not be able to make their own choice. Android users will be able to make their own choice thanks to side-loading.
- nicce 4y ago
- favaq 4y agoBoris Johnson is shaking at the prospect of "signal" leaving the UK. Isn't that a toothpaste?
- ta1243 4y agoBoris Johnson is a backbench MP who rarely turns up for work
- ben_w 4y agoUnfortunately and remarkably — even when combined with "repeatedly lost jobs due to dishonesty" — that hasn't been sufficient for him to be rendered politically irrelevant.
- ndsipa_pomu 4y agoHe seems to be the only Tory politician that has any charisma and the party doesn't appear to have any workable ideas as their previous 12 years in power haven't shown them to be effective.
- ben_w 4y agoYeeeees. Rewatching HIGNFY recently, and Johnson somehow (to my introspective horror) managed to come across positively even when he was squirming at Ian Hislop asking about the audio recording of Johnson conspiring to assault a journalist. I half-remember a phrase, but not where from: "people don't remember what you said, just how you made them feel".
- ndsipa_pomu 4y agoI know at least one person that voted Conservative because Johnson made him laugh on HIGNFY. If only he could have been kept as a media personality and not been given power.
- nprateem 4y ago
- hunglee2 4y agoincredible if UK were to ban Signal, but I guess national sovereignty and security are always going to be higher priorities for the state than user sentiment
- trollied 4y agoI don't think the bill will pass in its current form. Can't see it happening.
- butterNaN 4y agoI don't know, man. After Brexit, it feels anything can happen.
- CommanderData 4y agoLots of bills people thought would never pass have. The recent legislation undermining of protests being one of them. I can see it happening too.
- katet 4y agoThat bill passed the Commons, but has been amended by the Lords (I know the Commons can override the Lords if it wants to, but it's not at that stage yet) https://bills.parliament.uk/bills/3153/stages https://bills.parliament.uk/bills/3153/stages
- blitzar 4y agoWhen the right wing, small state, less regulation party is obsessed with implementing this sort of policy - who exactly is going to stop them?
- mattmanser 4y agoThey're not really small state, and have never been. They're small state about certain things. They're small state about consumer protections to make it easier for their corrupting donors to pillage Britain and it's workers. They're small state about not letting public bodies solve big problems like forbidding councils from building houses. They're big state about controlling the population. They're big state about centralizing government control. They're big state about gerrymandering to impose a minority view on the population. Very much like the Republican party.
- notpushkin 4y agoTIL Element (the Matrix.org client) is based in UK. This is extremely worrying.
- fmajid 4y agoIt is dual French and British. That said, France's record on freedom of encryption is not that stellar either, even if it is not as bad an enemy of the Internet at the UK. Element should preemptively move its HQ to Iceland or similar.
- Arathorn 4y agoElement was founded as half French/British, but we also have German & US legal entities now, and we will shift our HQ out of the UK if forced to.
- walterbell 4y agoWhat do you think of the EU "Chat Control" proposals? https://www.patrick-breyer.de/en/posts/messaging-and-chat-control/ https://www.patrick-breyer.de/en/posts/messaging-and-chat-co... > The European Commission went a step further on the 11 May 2022 by presenting a proposal which would make chat control mandatory for all e-mail, chat and messenger providers and would even apply to so far securely end-to-end encrypted communication services ... All of your chat conversations and emails will be automatically searched for suspicious content. Nothing remains confidential or secret. There is no requirement of a court order or an initial suspicion for searching your messages. It occurs always and automatically. One way to increase awareness of these proposals would be for E2EE messengers to include an in-app notice and call to action, for customers in affected countries.
- spoiler 4y ago> One way to increase awareness of these proposals would be for E2EE messengers to include an in-app notice and call to action, for customers in affected countries. I think this is a really cool, low-cost/effort way to raise awareness. Makes me wonder if this could be used against those apps somehow. We all know some countries' governments are quite coerceful and scummy...
- jossclimb 4y ago> The government, and prominent child protection charities have long argued that encryption hinders efforts to combat online child abuse - which they say is a growing problem. So take using a sledgehammer to crack a nut. What they should be doing, is rather then increase the risk of for the majority who use encryption for valid reasons (privacy, not nefarious), is invest in services to allow individuals to gain help, in a manner where they won't be ostracised and at risk, all from trying to come forward and get help to amend their behavior. I am father myself, and like a majority (being a parent is a moot point really) am appalled and disgusted by CP, but me being that way won't stop individuals from succumbing to obtaining CP. Some of them do this even though they know it could trash their seemingly normal life (they often have their own families who are totally unaware). This to me suggests there is some sort of psychological disorder at play, and these people need professional help and intervention. Trying to snoop on everyone, to seek these people out won't achieve anything. They are willing to offend even with extreme risks already in place (being labelled as a pedophile for the rest of your life). Them being snooped on won't stop it all, the same vicious cycle will continue to play out, but now with all of us lacking a basic right to privacy.
- cnity 4y agoMake no mistake: the Online Safety Bill has absolutely nothing to do with protecting children. End-to-end encryption is the first line of defence against government approved mass surveillance. If it falls, the rest will follow. It will only be a short period until the operation is expanded under the guise of additional "protections" against the citizens.
- sph 4y agoThe "children" excuse + most of the population saying "I don't need privacy, I have nothing to hide" is a double whammy against any form of encryption and it's just a matter of time before our Internet privacy rights are completely stripped away. A huge educational campaign is necessary to convince people and the average politician that being pro-encryption doesn't mean being criminals or pedophiles. So it's a lost battle already, and the intelligence services everywhere know it's just a matter of time. Eventually a pro-privacy activist will be found with child pornography and everybody will cheer and applaud any form of privacy-stripping law. The children angle is insidious, and where the discussion keep devolving even in tech-savvy forums like this one, instead if seeing it's convenient and very effective marketing to hide anti-privacy goals.
- Mindwipe 4y agoThe NSPCC is one of the biggest risks to internet freedom globally, and it's time everyone started taking that seriously.
- autoexec 4y ago> "we would absolutely 100% walk rather than ever undermine the trust that people place in us to provide a truly private means of communication." This from the same signal that refuses to update its privacy policy to reflect the fact that they've started permanently storing sensitive user data in the cloud (https://community.signalusers.org/t/proper-secure-value-security-pins-are-too-easy-to-brute-force-sgx-is-not-reliable-enough/15096 https://community.signalusers.org/t/proper-secure-value-secu...). The same Signal that ignored the users who didn't want any of their data kept in the cloud in the first place (https://community.signalusers.org/t/dont-want-pin-dont-want-anything-stored-in-cloud/14057 https://community.signalusers.org/t/dont-want-pin-dont-want-...). That, combined with the way they were misleading in their communications (https://old.reddit.com/r/signal/comments/htmzrr/psa_disabling_pins_will_now_upload_nothing_to_the/fyjy7a5/ https://old.reddit.com/r/signal/comments/htmzrr/psa_disablin...) already undermined the trust I was placing in them. At this point I consider the fact that the very first sentence of their privacy policy has been a lie since 2020 to be a dead canary.
- j-bos 4y agoWhat alternatives are there to signal? Reasonable, for a lay person.
- amarant 4y agoTelegram I think is considered safe? But TBF signal is end to end encrypted which means at least the content if your chats are safe. This is in my opinion safe enough, but YMMV I guess
- piaste 4y agoTelegram is, I believe, generally worse than Signal for privacy. Both have FOSS clients and offer E2E chats (good), although Telegram doesn't make them the default. Both require the use of phone numbers for identification and store some of your metadata in their central servers (bad). Both dabbled with the idea of privacy-preserving monetization via cryptocurrencies, and both failed spectacularly (funny). Telegram is run by a swashbuckling Russian expat in Dubai; Signal is run by an American security nerd. You might prefer your metadata to be in Pavel Durov's hands than Moxie Marlinspike's, depending on your threat model, but probably not.
- SillyUsername 4y agoI suspect if they did, the funding for the project might see a cut. Russians (gov) would get annoyed since apparently they have broken or bypassed Signal's encryption. Brits would get annoyed because they can't use something they've funded.
- bryancoxwell 4y ago> Russians (gov) would get annoyed since apparently they have broken or bypassed Signal's encryption. Got a source for that?
- SillyUsername 4y agoPerhaps I was wrong - I've just seen this follow up article https://www.independent.co.uk/tech/signal-messaging-hacked-compromised-rumours-misinformation-b2025733.html https://www.independent.co.uk/tech/signal-messaging-hacked-c...
- ultim8k 4y agoThey should allow accounts without phone number or with an nft number, the way telegram does.
- crossroadsguy 4y agoSignal seems to have lost the plot, after everything that went down -- the exodus, sudden interest etc etc, right when they prioritised that crypto thing above everything else and actually released it. In my circle across 4 continents only one person knew about that damn crypto. Heard of it. That niche. But then maybe Signal is supposed to be “that niche”. I don’t know how they spin it (that is if at all they bother), or anyone else tries to explain it, it just doesn't make sense. It simply does not. I’d say it is worse or weirder than Firefox’s Pocket moment, but somehow on the same lines. I uninstalled Signal when that feature was released. I still install it now and then for an hour or so just to spin it, but earlier, whatever those few friends were on it, I used to try to use it. Now I don’t. Now for me Singal is just a useless relic. Maybe it still works for Snowden and people who are at risk and I hope it keeps working for them. But if they are the only target audience then Signal is already irrelevant and they CAN BE replaced by that small target audience and them “walking” from UK or anywhere else for that matter really doesn’t matter.
- Karellen 4y agoWhat are you talking about? Strong cryptography is Signal's entire point of existence.
- thallium205 4y agoI think he’s talking about a shitcoin Signal loaded into their app.
- Karellen 4y agoDoh. I often get confused when people use "crypto" to refer to cryptocurrencies rather than cryptography and encryption when the context isn't obvious. If you're talking about a product specifically built around cryptography, I'm definitely going to not think that the context is actually cryptocurrency without any other clues. Guess I just spent too long being interested in and reading up on crypto before bitcoin was invented.
- 4y ago
- skripp 4y ago> The government said its proposal was not "a ban on end-to-end encryption". > Critics say companies could be required by Ofcom to scan messages on encrypted apps for child sexual abuse material or terrorism content under the new law. So, what's going on here? Is it going to be E2EE between user and user and then also a copy E2EE between user and the government? What a time to be alive. Or is the law going to require them to scan encrypted messages for child abuse and terrorism content? Unless they are required to hand over the keys then... how is that going to work?
- spzb 4y agoGovernment policy on encryption (along with many other things including Brexit) relies on "magical thinking". They don't understand the problem so they assume there's an easy solution that's just being withheld from them by nefarious third parties.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- agd 4y agoIt's a classic misleading but true statement from the government. They can mandate apps scan messages client side before sending E2E.
- hellojesus 4y agoWhat stops a company from making a PWA that ignores the UK rule? UK can't block it, especially if they host on aws or gcp servers. So long as the company isn't headquartered in the UK, nothing can be done.
- polski-g 4y agoJust scan the encrypted data stream and call it a day. "Well, we tried and did not find anything"
- _8j50 4y agoI will say it again, something has got to give. You can't have humane treatment of child rapists and fear government overreach. It is in fact possible to backdoor communication systems for lawful intercept access. It is possible to also design public auditing of such systems so that a warrant or lawful order being used to intercept communications can be logged and audited by the public. Warrants are not forever secret, with that stipulation a check against abuse of lawful intercept can be incorporated into non-E2E encrypted protocols. However, what I have learned is that it isn't just privacy or government overreach technophiles like many on HN seem to use as a reason but also a desire to undermine legitimate lawful intercept in foreign countries. "What if the Chinese government intercepts dissident communication" they're the legit authority there, it will be publicly audited still but they have every right to do so and you have no say in what a foreign government does in their own jurisdiction. The internet itself should be eradicated if we can't do everything at all costs to prevent harm against the weakest.
- skripp 4y ago[flagged]
- _8j50 4y agoAn insult is not an argument.
- viridian 4y agoIsn't your argument essentially saying that a nation's sovereign body, no matter what their laws, are not only expected, but also justified and morally correct in enforcing those laws, without any regard to the nature of those laws? By this argument, one would believe that it is imperative for communications networks to assist Nazi Germany in the location and rounding up of undesired people as a part of Gleichschaltung, and that to not do this is to cede power to pedophiles.
- _8j50 4y agoYes that is my argument. Until Nazis try to invade your country. However, you are free to stop providing seevices entirely in that country if you disagree with their laws.
- nabla9 4y agoTextbook case https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Think_of_the_children https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Think_of_the_children This is part of Boris Johnson's Red Meat™ tactics. Red Meat tactics means pushing clickbait/culture war bullshit ideas that are idiotic, cruel, or non-working. The goal is to stir up fight over them. Boris has build his career on running across rivers on the backs of alligators. He avoids being caught by scandals, lying, fraud, infidelity, abuse by throwing Red Meat to distract.
- lotsofspots 4y agoYou do know Boris hasn't been in charge since last July, right?
- limbicsystem 4y agoNever mind signal, what would Apple do if the UK government forced them to compromise E2E crypt? Someone hasn't thought this thorough properly...
- sgjohnson 4y agoI'd like to think that the UK is small enough of a market for Apple to not give a single flying fuck about the govt forcing them to compromise E2E crypto.
- Gareth321 4y agoApple willingly handed over all iCloud data on Chinese citizens upon request. They don't care about privacy at all. They won't abandon the U.K. They'll comply with every single legal directive, as they have pledged to do on multiple occasions.
- sgjohnson 4y agoChina is a far more crucial market for them for a wide variety of reasons. They have virtually no operations in the UK. If the PR impact will cost them more than ditching the UK, they will ditch the UK.
- masterof0 4y agoWhat would they do with the people who has the Advanced Data Protection for iCloud on?
- pacifika 4y agoTry and stop an open source project built on standards
- danoni 4y ago> The government, and prominent child protection charities have long argued that encryption hinders efforts to combat online child abuse - which they say is a growing problem. Translation: can u give us a backdoor in Signal, plz? for the kidz, promiss.
- jarym 4y agoHonestly, this government has some balls. Signal won't be the only one leaving the UK - it's becoming a really poor place to live with high taxation, stalling economy, low consumer rights, environmental protections being stripped away and erosion of civil liberties and rights to privacy. Only when there's enough brain drain might they backtrack but politically we have a party in power that is susceptible to infighting and not at all focussed on actually serving its citizens.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- 10xDev 4y agoWith many reputable universities and large companies, brain drain isn't a realistic outcome.
- nequo 4y agoMany of the people who make those universities reputable are foreigners. If the UK goes down an extreme path, the ones who are there will start leaving and new ones will stop coming.
- jarym 4y agoThere was a story about researchers leaving because they wouldn't take part in European funded work anymore... that's that sort of bureaucratic stuff that researchers will not put up with when they feel like they're not able to keep up with their peers.
- sgjohnson 4y agoThankfully the internet is (almost) entirely decentralized, so it doesn't really matter. No matter what ban on Signal the UK puts in place, I'm relatively confident that everyone who already uses Signal will be able to find a way how to keep using it.
- seanhunter 4y agoSetting aside the question of whether signal are the good guys or not it's important for non-UK people to understand the political context here. The conservative party is eating itself. They have forced 2 leaders to resign in the last year and are trailing in the polls so are terrified of the next election. They won convincingly at the last election on the basis of a "red wall" strategy that involved an appeal to traditionally labour voters who were Euroskeptic and by throwing dog-whistles about immigration to appease people on the right wing of their own party who were thinking of defecting to the UK independence party. All that support is unravelling and they ended up having to do a humilitating deal with the Unionist party in Northern Ireland which is unravelling because their policies there (the so called "Northern Ireland protocol") threaten to undo the peace process and importance of preserving the peace process is just about the only thing the two sides in Northern Ireland agree on. There is also a cost of living crisis with strikes across multiple groups of public sector workers. So right now there is lots of "Performance politics" with policies designed to look tough and appeal to socially conservative right-wingers in an effort to shore up a weak government. Just this week we had the policy to insist that asylum seekers fill in a questionnaire in English no matter where they came from, and now this which they can spin as being tough on crime. I would highly doubt any of the people behind this bill have any interest in the technical pros and cons.
- fauigerzigerk 4y agoSo what is Labour's position on this? Aren't they demanding the exact same thing using slightly different rhetoric? The only principled parliamentary opposition to undermining encryption that I'm aware of has been coming from David Davis, conservative MP and arch-brexiteer [1]. Maybe there are others like him, but this is by no means a polarising issue in British politics. [1] https://hansard.parliament.uk/commons/2022-12-05/debates/E155684B-DEB0-43B4-BC76-BF53FEE8086A/OnlineSafetyBill https://hansard.parliament.uk/commons/2022-12-05/debates/E15...
- seanhunter 4y agoProbably. One of the problems of "tough on crime" framing in politics is no politician wants to be seen as "weak on crime" so it ends up being a race to the bottom on civil liberties.
- EVa5I7bHFq9mnYK 4y agoAnd this is from country where certain celebrities abused children for decades in plain site without any encryption. Where children of entire towns were mass-abused also in plain site and under the nose of police. Where members of Royal family are known kiddy fiddlers without anything serious happening to them.
- hackernewds 4y agoplain sight*
- EVa5I7bHFq9mnYK 4y agooops
- wonderwonder 4y agowell sure but those are the royals and minorities. Can't be arresting them. Its everyone else that has to be monitored, those are the real baddies. /S
- laylower 4y agoCan they force Apple and Google to add backdoors or monitoring at mobile device level? Is it even technically feasible if signal does not enable it?
- heavenlyblue 4y agoI like when commercial conservatives like to blame the government for always being too big, inefficient and useless, and then go around and sign off all of their rights to privacy of communication thinking that government is going to do a better job with their private messages (or otherwise using their private communications only for the specific reasons they state, such as child abuse) compared to everything else they do.
- jonplackett 4y agoI wish this older generation of politicians who grew up without the internet would hurry up and retire, and let some people who have at least a vague grasp of technology take over. It is painful to watch these people grapple incoherently with the basic idea of how encryption works and what is fundamentally possible or impossible to achieve.
- boppo1 4y agoWho are the faces of this bill? I'm picturing a webcomic where a ~25 year-old's boyfriend asks her for some nudes, she strips to take them and freaks out because [politician] is suddenly sitting there, leering and smiling. "Oh don't mind me, I'm just here to protect children and prevent terrorism." Any other ideas for a series?
- Kukumber 4y agoHow is that different from the CIA being able to sniff and access their servers thanks to the US patriot act? will they 'walk' from the US too? [1] Oh, my bad, i almost forgot! it's the tech that's being tested to power the digital online passport, we'll get to see it first with twitter [2], then meta, then it'll expand everywhere else Ahh, the joy of the bitcoin, who said china was evil with their social credit system? <:P (i did my best to picture a clown face) The existence of the patriot act makes everything obvious [1] - https://www.aquaray.com/en/blog/posts/cloud-act-patriot-act-rgpd-what-law-are-your-data-subject-to https://www.aquaray.com/en/blog/posts/cloud-act-patriot-act-... [2] - https://twitter.com/wongmjane/status/1596615573303357440 https://twitter.com/wongmjane/status/1596615573303357440
- Kukumber 4y agoFlashback, in case people don't have the reference: https://qz.com/1145669/googles-true-origin-partly-lies-in-cia-and-nsa-research-grants-for-mass-surveillance https://qz.com/1145669/googles-true-origin-partly-lies-in-ci...
- motohagiography 4y agoIf governments suddenly wanted to ban fire extinguishers, I think most people would be very concerned about what these authorities might be planning, but instead of fire, when they go to ban the tools we use to protect ourselves from crime and corruption, they get the benefit of the doubt? There is no principle for anti-encryption policy, it's not worth arguing with them, as these policymakers are not moved by reason. You can only organize and get them out.