11 ms·
Seattle becomes first U.S. city to ban caste discrimination
- merricksb 4y agoBig discussion a day ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34876082 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34876082 (258 points/1 day ago/462 comments)
- macintux 4y agoThis topic was heavily discussed just a day ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34876082 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34876082
- LewisVerstappen 4y agoIdk, I’m indian and I’ve absolutely never encountered anything close to caste based discrimination in the US. The thread seems to be a bunch of non-indian people (white dudes) talking about what they heard from “second hand” sources. But whatever. Hopefully I won't have to start filing TPS reports on my caste. I'm not saying discrimination doesn't happen. But there's literally dozens of factors that indians like to use to discriminate against each other (what language you speak - we don't all speak hindi, what state you're from, religion, gender, and a bunch others) Half the time it's impossible to tell what caste someone is from. (Not the case for me - my last name gives it away - but again, I've never had someone discriminate against me based on my caste)
- mixdup 4y agoDo you live in Seattle? Literally the top comment from the linked thread is by someone in Seattle who says it's a big problem Maybe it's only a problem in Seattle and not other cities in the US. Might be why Seattle is the first/only US city to implement such a policy Being Indian is only half of it, if you live in Birmingham, Alabama you probably have no idea what it's like in Seattle, Washington I am neither Indian nor live in Seattle so I can't and won't say in any direction, but it's important not to dismiss what others say they're experiencing out of hand just because you haven't experienced it
- roflyear 4y agoYeah my guess is maybe they don't live in an area with a big population of people from India? I dunno!
- LewisVerstappen 4y agoI do... One of the largest indian populations in the US. This might be a shocker to you, but indians aren't just in Seattle.
- roflyear 4y agoAh apologies. We maybe live in the same area (I am in #1 in the US I think by most accounts), so you might be my neighbor :) And yes, not Seattle. I don't live in Seattle. I didn't mean offense. I just worked at a lot of companies with very diverse cultures, and not picking on Indian people, but I have experienced this "problem" (it is a problem but it wasn't a problem for me, so I dunno) several times.
- LewisVerstappen 4y ago[flagged]
- tokai 4y agoHow do you know he's white?
- LewisVerstappen 4y agoHe literally said he's white.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- mixdup 4y agoNYC, NJ, and Dallas haven't passed laws around it, so maybe it's not an issue there. Maybe, like I said, it's a particular issue in Seattle and not as much elsewhere
- dilawar 4y agoMaybe you are from a higher caste!
- LewisVerstappen 4y agoI'm not... Also, my last name makes it extremely obvious what caste I'm from.
- 22SAS 4y agoNot all of us Indians are Hindus and have some caste assigned to us.
- ejstronge 4y agoAre you pro Lewis or pro Verstappen? More relevant, what is your caste identity? Wondering if your position in the hierarchy may insulate from the reported experiences in Seattle
- LewisVerstappen 4y ago> More relevant, what is your caste identity? Wondering if your position in the hierarchy may insulate from the reported experiences in Seattle I'm Vaishya
- roflyear 4y agoIt's weird because I'm white and I have seen it happen lol!
- cultureswitch 4y agoIt's refreshing to see a discrimination problem being addressed when it is in fact not imaginary.
- canadianfella 4y ago[dead]
- flangola7 4y agoWhich ones are imaginary?
- bigcloud1299 4y agoThis is a huge peorblem across the board. It goes unnoticed in corporate culture as everyone is focused on diversity based on color or origins. There is also a major discrimination issue between regions of India. North vs south. I have seen South Indian promote, hire etc other South Indians.
- cscurmudgeon 4y agoDo you have data on how big or small this problem is? (Not opinion pieces, but data). I am sure there must be some relatively objective data somewhere on this. Edit: Ah yes, here come the downvotes as we can’t ask for data on a source of easy virtue signaling :)
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- azzentys 4y agoMy guess would be that not a lot of people have done work to collect concrete data around it. Problems like these really go unnoticed, even most samples from urban-young crowd in India will say, "why do we need reservation?", "there's no caste discrimination".
- dilawar 4y agoLook for Prof. Andre Beteille work. His father was French and mother a Bengali Brahmin (French had a few colonies in India). M N Srinivas has done a lot of empirical work on caste. Every student of anthropology study caste . There is a quite a lot of data on both Indian villages and caste system but caste is the offices is not well studied, IMO. By the way, caste takes a lot of shapes. There have also been attempt to study racial divide in US South from caste perspective (a social category rather than a biological one). PS: I am a high caste Indian living in India who has more than interests in caste system. PPS: Mention of caste triggers most Indians, even those who are not living abroad. My wife (south Indian Brahmins) feels somewhat annoyed with my interest in caste. I won't ask my fellow Indians about caste, ever!! It triggers them more than saying bad thing about Modi.
- bobosha 4y agoI am Indian-American (born into a brahmin family if that matters) and personally haven't noticed casteism, barring the occasional idiot in our communities. Having said that, we (Indian-Americans) should be open to criticism and scrutiny. We are a very successful lot - arguably the richest immigrant group in America - surely we can be secure enough to confront some of these bad things. We need to stop being defensive and touchy about such charges.
- sampo 4y ago> I am Indian-American (born into a brahmin family if that matters) and personally haven't noticed casteism With a background in the highest-ranking caste, you would of course be the least able to notice those things.
- quadrifoliate 4y agoYou clearly know nothing about caste, because in cases where it happens, the "higher" or "middle" castes are most often the ones actively doing the discrimination. As a "higher" caste person, I have seen a great deal of this discrimination firsthand in India (both subtle and egregious [1]), and almost never among my fellow Indian immigrants in America [2]. The typical American response that I already see elsewhere in this thread is "lol this is like a white dude saying racism doesn't exist". This totally ignores the basic fact that it is not that easy to tell someone's caste, which makes it a totally different class of problem. It's kind of possible based on a combination of factors [3], but there are so many exceptions that basically unless you ask someone, you can never be sure. And therein lies the problem – the very existence of these sorts of conversations about "how you tell what caste X is?" is often the backbone of caste-based discrimination. I feel shitty even talking about how you'd tell someone's caste. And ultimately, I think that's why these kinds of measures will backfire. You are going to have a lot more Indian-Americans being curious about what caste they are when the problem could have faded into the background, with existing anti-discrimination statutes being applied to cases like the ones cited in the article. ---------------------------------------- [1] A typical subtle version is mentioning a person's caste in a conversation where's it's totally irrelevant; a US equivalent would be something like "Jim, the new software engineer started today. He's Latino." [2] A reasonable question here would be: "What changed? Why would Indian immigrants not discriminate after they come to America?" My answer is best guess is most Indians who come to the US are already likely predisposed to liberal and educated to a fairly high level. Unlike the US (where even Civil War history is still a touchy subject), specific lessons about the history of caste discrimination, statutes against it, and attempts at reparations are baked into all levels of the Indian education curriculum. Along with that, exposure to the staggeringly high diversity of America tends to dull any remaining biases that might exist. Like everything, I am sure there are exceptions. And I'm guessing that they are certainly more likely in Councilwoman Sawant's age group (she's almost 50). [3] There should be a Falsehoods American Media Perpetuates About Caste article. If I wrote it, the top two would be: a) It's always possible to tell a person's caste based on their last name, and b) It's always possible to tell a person's caste by whether or not they eat meat.
- piethrow29 4y agoMaking it illegal does not make it go away. Like racisim has not ended. They need to bring in reservations in education and govt jobs, a strong act like the sc/st act to ensure marginalized people get their due.
- rtkwe 4y agoIt does give you recourse if it does happen though and over time it at least gets quieter and more subtle. If we'd applied this same logic to the Civil Rights Act in the 60s we would be much further behind where we've made it to today.
- LewisVerstappen 4y ago> They need to bring in reservations in education and govt jobs No that would be idiotic because most of the time the discrimination has nothing to do with Caste. Different areas of india have completely different cultures (languages, foods, customs, etc.) Most of the discrimination is based on where you're from (do you speak tamil vs. hindi vs gujarati...) People want to hire people who are similar to them. Chasing caste is the wrong issue. India has thousands of years of cultural history & practices. America has...250 years? Applying your mental models from American politics to India (which is far more complicated) and then forming a strong opinion (without knowing anything about indian culture) is hilariously idiotic. There's far more things indian discriminate on other than caste. Location, language, family group, language-spoken, wealth, etc. And obviously political views. Half the time you have no idea what caste someone is.
- jmeister 4y agoSarcasm right? America has to import and litigate all of the world's problems? White Man's Burden?
- the_doctah 4y agoThat's just institutionalized racism, but literally.
- terminal_d 4y agoYup, because that works out really well in India...
- jdmtheNth 4y agoThis is why America was intended to be a melting pot: so that cultural baggage could be left behind. Complete waste of resources just to demonstrate how progressive the city is.
- PM_me_your_math 4y agoThey have to show they are doing something because they are not doing anything else.
- yeahbutiguess 4y agoSeattle is doing tons of stuff. They recently upzoned a huge amount of the city, approved ranked choice voting, approved social housing, expanded rail, fixed a major bridge failure before it failed, and plenty more. Crime rates are down, the city has grown astronomically, etc.
- the_doctah 4y agoI had a feeling your claim about crime rate was untrue so I googled it. It turned out to be wildly untrue. Crime rates are way up. https://www.seattletimes.com/seattle-news/law-justice/seattle-violent-crime-hits-15-year-high-other-takeaways-from-new-report/ https://www.seattletimes.com/seattle-news/law-justice/seattl... It's a "soft on crime" blue city. Crime doesn't go down.
- yeahbutiguess 4y agohttps://www.seattletimes.com/seattle-news/data/is-seattle-dying-not-if-you-look-crime-rates-from-the-80s-and-90s/ https://www.seattletimes.com/seattle-news/data/is-seattle-dy... Look at these graphs. Crime has consistently fallen. The article you linked is discussing a recent uptick after a stable period of low crime. They've cherry picked the statistics to not show the huge drop in crime over the past 40 years. Yes, crime is down in Seattle.
- 4y ago
- nindalf 4y agoDupe https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34876082 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34876082 (265 points, 463 comments) - 1 day ago
- TheMagicHorsey 4y agoAh yes, Kshama Sawant. Her favorite tack is to take policies that they are rolling back in India (because they failed) and roll them out in Seattle.
- screye 4y ago[1] As an Indian who does not come from an upper caste and has worked in Seattle, I have yet to experience any instance of caste even being mentioned in Indian circles, let alone experience any semblance of discrimination or see it happen near me. I'd believe it if someone told me IITians didn't eat with those from other universities. Or that 2nd gen Indian-Americans didn't eat with 1st gen immigrants. But this sort of thing is practically unheard of. Our Indian circle is pretty huge, and I haven't ever even so much as heard a whisper about this. I find that Americans have some bizarre views and opinions about India. Like they read some colonial era British report about the nation, watched slum dog millionaire and that's it. India has changed an insane amount since independence, and it has changed even more than that just in the last 20 years. I consistently find that HN threads about India are among the lowest quality of discourse on this forum. Highly opinionated while still being misinformed. The worst combination. ________ Hot take, but Americans have an internalized hubris about their civilizational understanding of anything past their own borders. They seem incapable of understanding social dynamics from a non-white-vs-black-American racialized lens. I am not just generalizing, I am actively calling this out as universal. You see it at even the highest level of intellectual discourse, and the so-called 'woke' might be the worst of them all. India is a civilizational nation with a population base & internal diversity that has matched or exceeded Europe over multiple millennia. (not just after our population explosion). Americans will demand a PhD before believing whether Mary Antoinette asked people to eat cake, but will readily accept any loud mouth's opinion on an entire subcontinent & parallel civilization. Take a seat. It's complicated, nuanced, and will take at least a few hours to even scratch the surface of. Yes, that's just how it is when you try to understand a nation as vast and alien from an outsider's lens. I'm feel like bickering today, so I will use some choice words. The worst of them all are the 'coconuts'. It is a derogatory term for those who are 'brown on the outside, white on the inside'. More specifically, people who have limited their interactions with India and Indians to merely their filter bubble, yet they feel entitled to an opinion about India, just by the virtue of the color of their skin. To each their own, but to then stand on a pedestal and claim to be the authoritative voice on 'what Indians are like' is preposterous. This is 1.5 billion people we are talking about here. I can find an anecdote to support anything I'd like. I specifically call out America (and Anglo-nations), because EU-Europeans have more humility. There is a certain rage that they too feel, when stereotypes bleed across national borders, and that's when both countries speak the same language, eat the same food and are genetically identical. They see the same distances on an Indian map and intuitively understand the implications for diversity & mutual differences. Even Mercator's best efforts can't hide how vast this land is. Americans seem to have no muscles for that kind of nuance. And yes, I am claiming this is a universal experience among Americans. [2] [1] Copying part of my comment from the other thread yesterday. [2] This is not to say that Americans are worse people. I have in fact repeatedly defended the US as the least racist country in the world. But cultural exchange is hard, and every culture has their own blind spot. 'The interweaving of identity, caste & class dynamics among Indian diaspora' is the perfect collision of these blind spots and the struggles of cultural exchange.
- exabrial 4y agoI applaud the action, but also, I don’t think this is the right way to enforce this. This should be enforced on grounds of racial background for max effect, since it is an established precedent.
- petilon 4y agoHere's the reality: https://www.nytimes.com/2013/06/16/opinion/sunday/caste-is-not-past.html?_r=0 https://www.nytimes.com/2013/06/16/opinion/sunday/caste-is-n...
- lashkhi 4y ago[dead]
- zero_night 4y agoWhat about discrimination against North Indians by South Indians? If you are from North India and a South Indian manager screwed you over, please comment here. I would like to know if its a trend. Counter examples are not helpful.
- terminal_d 4y agoNorth and South both screw each other over. And people of the same race / region / caste / creed screw over others belonging to the same group. This is universal and will never change. What this legislation does is line the pockets of the people putting their pens to paper for it while piggybacking on a divisive issue. And yeah, I've had good friends from almost every state in India. Some of them were weird about it, most don't really care. So-called "nationalists" will screw you over in any region if you're a migrant. Anyway, it's not a binary issue. It's just something that happens, and it's not possible to legislate.
- mlb893 4y agoI wonder if this happens in Canada and to what extent it is a problem...
- terminal_d 4y agoFunny how the United States is speedrunning ""sensible"" legislation without considering what it entails in the country the practice originates from. And yep, once enforced it's never going away. I guess people can now look forward to ever-convoluted steps for mitigating issues caused by this, and it'll fill the coffers of anyone that puts his stake into it. Better for the lawmakers, crap for literally everyone else. BTW, to anyone that hasn't lived in India: you don't understand how extensive """caste discrimination""" is or how it impacts society. You just don't.
- jagdish123 4y agoAs an Indian, coming from a lower caste family, this makes me happy. India already banned caste discrimination years ago and it had a positive impact on marginalized communities. The next step might be to follow something akin to caste-reservations that we have in India, to level the playing field for communities that have been marginalized for centuries. Advocating for more lower-caste Indian representation in private companies can be a good start. It can be a part of DEI initiatives that we have seen so many companies embrace. Overall, this is a positive development. But we still have a long way to go!
- tmmx 4y agoThat caste reservation system you mentioned is fundementally flawed. For example, it will favor children of low caste individual who already benefitted from the system and is at economically very priviledged position over children of a high caste individual who are economically disadvantaged.
- jagdish123 4y ago> That caste reservation system you mentioned is fundementally flawed. The caste reservation system has been pivotal in bringing social issues faced by the lower castes to mainstream politics. Only when some lower caste members made it up the social ladder through reservations, were they able to articulate their issues and lend a helping hand to others in their social groups. > For example, it will favor children of low caste individual who already benefitted from the system and is at economically very priviledged position over children of a high caste individual who are economically disadvantaged. Economics does play a certain part in social dynamics. But social advantages trump any economic disadvantages. Even though a lower-caste member might be in an economically advantageous situation, they are still subject to the social dynamics, put in place by the upper echelons of the hierarchy, that are antagonistic to their upliftment. This justifies caste-reservation so that we, as a humanitarian society, can lift up everybody.
- mdgrech23 4y agoSo if you are decsriminated against in another country you should get advantages here in the US? That seems wrong.
- Mystery-Machine 4y ago[flagged]
- amriksohata 4y agoWhat the people who introduced legislation don't realise is how they have been made to be used as useful tools, take all the focus on the number of hate attacks on Hindus away from attention and focus on some minor disagreements that are not really present in day to day society for most. I mean its pretty stupid when rather than trying to reduce racism against Hindus and Indians, some useful idiots have been used in the Indian community to shoot themselves in the foot.
- amriksohata 4y agoThere is a lot of casteism in Punjabi Sikh songs about Jatt caste being superior, just listen to the lyrics like "Jatt da muqabala". I hope this will now be used to identify casteist people of all castes who make remarks against other communities.
- dqpb 4y agoI understand, from a project management perspective, the need for a concerted, coordinated push to penalize widespread discrimination against a particular category of people. But I do not understand, from a legal perspective, why some groups are protected from discrimination while others are not.
- tonfreed 4y agoI have noticed with India born Indians that they have questions they'll ask to try and figure out each others' caste. Things like where they lived and grew up in India, what they're parents did, etc. It's completely alien for someone that's spent an overwhelming amount of time in western countries.
- known 4y ago[dead]