5 ms·
I irrationally want this to be true because I have an unreasonable amount of anger for how much a16z put into Adam Neumann's Flow. Neumann destroyed billions in
by hn_throwaway_99 4y ago
I irrationally want this to be true because I have an unreasonable amount of anger for how much a16z put into Adam Neumann's Flow. Neumann destroyed billions in value at WeWork, then used essentially hostage tactics to walk away with about a billion, and he still got a16z to invest $350 million in Flow.
I've been following Flow news fairly closely, and it always sounds like tons of fluffy BS to me, same as the new-agey BS that permeated WeWork. If the best example Neumann can come up with about building a sense of "community" is that you get to fix your own toilet, can't wait to see this, and a16z's $350 million, crash and burn. I think I might even be at the very least impressed if Neumann manages to destroy a ton of a16z's money and still pocket tens of millions or so.
- recuter 4y agoHow did he destroy billions in value? He created the company and spun it up very effectively before being done in by run away valuations -- thank Masayoshi Son who is also a bit of a cowboy. The hostage tactics went both ways.. > same as the new-agey BS that permeated WeWork. The thing is, this worked great for WeWork. Neumann successfully hyped it up into a global brand. The company still exists. People still enjoy using it. Some people like new-agey community vibes apparently, why is that bad? Apple wouldn't be Apple without some Steve Jobs mystique to capture the popular imagination either. These are lifestyle brands. You could just work from a crummy McDonalds or your bedroom, nobody really needs a coworking space. Vibes are actually worth something. > I think I might even be at the very least impressed if Neumann manages to destroy a ton of a16z's money and still pocket tens of millions or so. I like how there are lots of stories on HN about founders who assume disproportionate risk getting completely screwed by investors and end up with nothing -- yet a guy who is a little bit more savvy is so easily painted as a villain. Ha.
- benjaminwootton 4y agoIf it was Adam’s personality and approach that bought them down, it was the same thing that built a $multi-billion company in the first place. He deserved to be paid rather than it all falling into investors hands.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- bolanyo 4y ago> How did he destroy billions in value? He turned around $25bn in cash into a company worth about $4bn, how else would you describe this?
- recuter 4y agoSame way I would describe Uber. SoftBank trying to muscle their way into ownership stakes by playing games with valuations and squeezing out the founder. The greater fool theory seems to apply. Masayoshi knew all the numbers, he thought Neumann was a good hype man to unload WeWork unto less sophisticated investors -- when that didn't pan out he tried to make him the fall guy and ended up holding the hot potato. Uber and WeWork are real companies, still around, providing actual services to actual customers. Both of their founders walked away billionaires, so what? SoftBank might have to write down their imaginary valuations as the public markets didn't bite into their attempted flip. The companies might survive long into the future as viable businesses with more realistic market caps.
- SilverBirch 4y agoFirstly, it's not just a totally neutral act to hatch a plan to juice the numbers to a ridiculous extent and try and dump it onto public markets before it explodes. That's literally an attempt to scam you out of your pension fund. Secondly, you know that phrase "don't break the law while breaking the law", Adam wasn't just building this massive ponzi, he was self-dealing left and right, buying artificial surf beaches, selling his own trade mark back to himself, getting wework to rent offices that he owned, getting Softbanks other entities to rent huge amounts of Wework space to massively juice the numbers in Japan. The only reason WeWork was kind of acceptable is because he was mainly burning Saudi billionaire money, but make no mistake, the entire plan was that he'd become a billionaire whilst everyone else's pensions would take the hit, and even having failed he walks away a billionaire.
- recuter 4y ago> Firstly, it's not just a totally neutral act to hatch a plan to juice the numbers to a ridiculous extent and try and dump it onto public markets before it explodes. That's literally an attempt to scam you out of your pension fund. Sadly that is the entire premise of the Softbank Vision Fund and many others like it. Masayoshi Son is now personally on the hook for about $5.1 billion on side deals he set up at SoftBank Group Corp. ..As SoftBank grew into a global investor, Son argued the company couldn’t keep talent unless executives were allowed to cut side deals that tied compensation to the company’s performance. That’s exposed him further to the current market downturn. -- https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2023-02-08/masayoshi-son-now-owes-softbank-5-1-billion-on-side-deals https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2023-02-08/masayoshi... > the entire plan was that he'd become a billionaire whilst everyone else's pensions would take the hit, and even having failed he walks away a billionaire. Is that so? When do you imagine Adam Neumann hatched this scheme? At the very conception of WeWork in 2010 when nobody would invest? Truly a supervillain. Or perhaps four years later when WeWork was "the fastest-growing lessee of new office space in New York" and was on track to become "the fastest-growing lessee of new space in America." By which point everybody was calling him a genius visionary? I don't recall anybody complaining at that point that this company is doomed to fail or anything like that. It appeared to be on an upwards trajectory. Perhaps he turned to the dark side when SoftBank showed up and demanded they grow the company even faster by throwing money at them? And what was Masayoshi's plan when he invested? > and even having failed he walks away a billionaire. What did he fail at specifically? Masayoshi tried to squeeze him out of his own company and Adam called his bluff. So Masayoshi got the press to drag him through the mud and trashed the valuation further in the process. Then covid happened. Had Masayoshi succeeded nothing would change except SoftBank owning a larger percentage. I don't see why you favor one party over the other. My pension was never invested in any of this and neither was yours. This is as you noted, Saudis, Chinese, Koreans, and JPMorgan attempting to simply buy their way into what seemed at the time a very promising market with their overwhelming cash firepower. Why you should feel sorry for them is beyond my comprehension.
- LarsDu88 4y agoI think a lot of folks undervalue the power of "cult-like" behavior when it comes to successful companies. Steve Jobs learned directly from the Hare Krishna's how to get a bunch of people working hard and moving in the same direction for basically no money. We see the same thing in We work. The cult of crypto and even the cult of Elon are really not that far removed...
- breck 4y ago100% agree. WeWork is great. It does suck for anyone who overpaid for shares, but I was buying FitBit at $40 a share. Sometimes you overpay. Live and learn.
- weatherlite 4y agoIt is irrational. I don't like Neumann at all but if you work in tech, these VCs crashing can't really be good for our jobs and salaries.
- hnbad 4y agoIf your wealth and well-being is tied to the puppy crushing machine continuing to crush puppies, maybe it's time to reflect on that and reconsider the systems we take for granted.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- pcthrowaway 4y agoLet's not pretend there wouldn't be massive industry around puppy-crushing machines if it was profitable for corporations, and marginally legal. Decades of industry centered around killing other baby animals have shown this. If anything, it's likely that the lack of a profit motive for "puppy-crushing" has shaped society's general distaste for "companion animal" abuse, while accepting other types of animal abuse as just a way of life.
- banannaise 4y agoThere is a massive industry around puppy-crushing machines. We call them "puppy mills" and they're large commercial operations that overbreed puppies for sale and kill the undesirables.
- weatherlite 4y agoI wouldn't say my well-being but we all make a living in this industry, it's what pays the bills. Guess you don't care about that?
- Apocryphon 4y agoThis industry involves plenty more than VCs, particularly these VCs.
- theGnuMe 4y ago> I have an unreasonable amount of anger for how much a16z put into Adam Neumann's Flow. Why so angry? I'm interested in the idea behind flow because it is nontraditional in the American building sense. If I understand the idea, I think providing community is a really good one. There is a lot of loneliness and we know that when seniors move into senior housing they love it. Most young adults love college dorms. So why not have that for everyone else? You do have to contrast this with the "projects" which also tried to develop community but failed I guess, maybe because economic opportunities were not included. Is Flow based on the idea of a Kibbutz?
- ceejayoz 4y agoNo one seems to know what Flow actually is, which probably doesn't bode well. https://www.fastcompany.com/90847220/adam-neumann-a16z-flow-startup-real-estate-explained https://www.fastcompany.com/90847220/adam-neumann-a16z-flow-...
- oldgradstudent 4y ago> Is Flow based on the idea of a Kibbutz? Maybe based on the 1980s Kibbutz Crisis: > Investments made without economic justification: due to the ease of credit gain, the kibbutzim invested large sums of money in industry and agriculture, often when the investment did not have an economic justification, and often without sufficient examination of the investment in terms of financial risk management. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kibbutz_crisis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kibbutz_crisis
- breck 4y agoI love WeWork as a customer now. I joined in Poland and now use it when traveling around the USA. It's great. I used to work at Microsoft and I loved that I could travel around the world and work from offices all over. That was awesome for creativity. Now our startup can do that, thanks to WeWork. I don't know Adam Neumann's story. I do know my own though, and know that when you have success, watch your back, people will come with daggers. I wouldn't judge someone who built something great, for making a billion dollars. You never know what kind of daggers in the back he took. I for one look forward to seeing what he builds next.
- nemothekid 4y agoAny customer will love a company selling a dollar for 50 cents. Neumann made a billion dollars by extracting it from a company that is now worth less than that. I think most of the blame lies with Masayoshi but Neumann was the top conman
- hn_throwaway_99 4y ago> I don't know Adam Neumann's story. I do know my own though, and know that when you have success, watch your back, people will come with daggers. This is such a BS false equivalence. There are plenty of people who built really successful companies who are billionaires whom I greatly admire, e.g. Stripe's founders, Google's founders, etc. I was a huge fan of Musk before he went off the deep-end and became more interested in just being a grade A asshole, liar and bully. Neumann likes to wrap his bargain variety avarice and greed in "changing the world" bullshit, and not all founders do that. For example, Neumann's self-dealing with the "We" trademark took a special level of sociopathic hutzpah. I'm also a client of WeWork, and I like its services. That still doesn't mean it's particularly difficult to build a company with a market cap of $1.10 billion when you are given a total funding of over $22 billion to start with. Neumann literally destroyed $20 billion in value, and for that incredible feat was given a billion dollar payday. I agree most of that blame goes to Softbank, but doesn't mean I can't have incredible distain for Neumann for conning his way the whole time.
- stcroixx 4y agoI look forward to seeing him build some license plates.
- paxys 4y agoWhy be angry about rich people giving money to each other? You aren't involved in the equation at all. It has nothing to do with you.
- myroon5 4y agoVCs invest others' money, including endowments, pensions, etc. It's not their money to blow without scrutiny
- paxys 4y agoOthers' money, not yours. Fund LPs do exercise a good amount of scrutiny over where their money goes. Ultimately if you aren't happy with Andreessen Horowitz and their proposed investment strategy, don't give them your money. Or talk to your employer or pension fund manager if you are indirectly impacted by this (I'm guessing no one here actually is, and this is all just the usual pointless online outrage).
- lazzlazzlazz 4y agoWeWork is great. Hopefully Neumann builds something even better this time.