9 ms·
A step forward in understanding Fragile X syndrome, a cause of autism
- wpietri 4y agoI'm always a bit uncomfortable with articles that uncritically use the disease model for all of autism.
- nailer 4y agoExactly. Elon is open about ASD (he uses the word Asperger's because he’s older), Anthony Hopkins is open about autism too (he can memorise a 7 page script), I suspect Tarantino may have it, and half of the people who built the internet. Anyone that tries to ‘rectify’ me can fuck off. Edit: as a user of HN since it was Startup News, and as someone who is very much aware of the HN guidelines, 'fuck off' was chosen very carefully towards anyone who would erase my existence. Hopefully HN has a modicum of empathy for other people and can understand others not wanting to be destroyed.
- foolswisdom 4y agoSometimes I think I'd be quite happy to be "rectified" of ASD... Whether it is correct or not to see it _entirely_ in a disease model (which it's not clear to me, how should the study have been done with a hybrid model?), I have to disagree with the suggestion it shouldn't be seen as an issue.
- DoctorOW 4y agoBut what would "rectified" look like? Autism isn't entirely separable from the things that I think make me the person I am.
- foolswisdom 4y agoI agree it isn't entirely separable. I assume that personality / self develops differently due to the "issue" identified in the study, and if it were "rectified", then it would no longer be a factor. That doesn't mean that you'd wake up the next day as a completely different person. Everyone changes over time, and the prior "self" is still there and you can still choose how to integrate the new "changes". Of course, this is just my imagination, it may not actually be anything like that. But I will double down on the thrust of my original comment, which is that although autism is not simply a "disease" because the self has developed differently, doesn't necessarily mean that we want it to stay.
- goda90 4y agoDon't forget that the S in ASD is for "spectrum". There are parts of this spectrum with people for who ASD is debilitating to their happiness and participation in society. "Rectified" might not mean complete change, but enough to give someone the tools to handle things better.
- nailer 4y agoBut also removes the tools of autism. Neurotypical peopple often lie about things for social convenience, overly value fitting in, have trouble exploring the depths of their interests, and have a poor sense of smell and taste.
- marcellus23 4y agoFor people who are high-functioning, it may be that the benefits of autism you mentioned are worth the downsides. But I think most medium and low-functioning people would not agree with that.
- nailer 4y agoI’m technically level 2, which means there are periods where I cannot communicate. I have at least one level 3 friend that I’m sure would feel the same, I’ll ask her and find out for sure though.
- chasd00 4y agoI would be 100% ok with being cured of ADHD and off spectrum. If I don’t take my meds everything goes haywire for me and everyone around me. I don’t think people realize how “one hand tied behind your back” these things really are.
- cat_plus_plus 4y agoSo be a constant slave to judgement of strangers on how I talk, act and dress rather than tuning out all that useless noise and focusing on the few people and things I truly care about? That would be a hard pass for me. Maybe "ASD" umbrella is part of the problem, I don't have a "sensory integration disorder", I have emotions that tend to go from 0 to 65 with little in between and some other issues like poor facial memory (that would be nice to cure) and tendency to daydream. Maybe that's consistent with Aspergers as originally understood, maybe not. But just for starters, can we stop inventing nonsensical umbrella terms like "ASD" and "AAPI" that serve no purpose except shared victimhood and shaming everyone else for supposed microaggressions? Hawaii is not the same as India, and I don't need a service dog to tell me there is a fire alarm in my building. Maybe then it would be easier for me to work on my unique needs. Like you know how one in a several hundred people finds your responses 100% natural and preferable to superficial norms without necessarily sharing the same personality themselves? Would be great to be able to find them efficiently to maintain a decent social circle rather than stumbling upon one randomly every ten years.
- majikaja 4y agoI have a bit of difficulty trying to understand what ASD means for such individuals as adults. If one is highly intelligent one can just spend time studying people to determine how they respond to situations. I don't really grasp why understanding people is any different from analyzing any other kind of system. I wonder how many ASD diagnoses are made just because someone never learnt social skills properly due to circumstances or lack of effort/interest.
- 112233 4y agoHuh, have you experienced, or have been with a close person experiencing shutdown because environment is too loud, smelly, or there is someone acting in a provoking, humiliating manner? How analythical knowledge of social skills can be of help in that situation? Suppose three armed persons draw a weapon and give you contradicting orders while threatening you. How will deep understanding of those individual orders help you reconcile them and decide how to act?
- aleph_minus_one 4y ago> I have a bit of difficulty trying to understand what ASD means for such individuals as adults. If one is highly intelligent one can just spend time studying people to determine how they respond to situations. I don't really grasp why understanding people is any different from analyzing any other kind of system. I personally see three points: - People often expect that one reacts "intuitively" instead of analyzing the whole situation first - Humans don't behave in an "easy" way like physical systems. So extracting the "hidden laws" is in my opinion nigh impossible. - Even if one tries to find possible hypotheses, one has to run a huge amount of "experiments" to extract rules. What does "running experiments" here mean? Behaving in very weird ways all the time just to obtain data on the behavior of the people. And the required data volume is insane, so it means behaving consciously weirdly rather for decades.
- majikaja 4y agoI genuinely spend a lot of time studying people offline and online. I think someone who can't do this from first principles is probably going to struggle if they try living in a very foreign country or amongst a different subculture of their own nation. Most people can't cope outside their comfort zone.
- cma 4y agoHe said he was never diagnosed so take with a grain of salt.
- dsego 4y agoElon is probably as much ASD as he is an inventor. Going by his behavior (parts that are reported on in public), I can as a lay-person recognize him to have more narcissistic traits, so a personality disorder like NPD or ASPD is more descriptive of him in my mind. There is a good video on yt debunking his claims regarding his diagnosis. https://youtu.be/UCS0SuPsDH4 https://youtu.be/UCS0SuPsDH4
- nailer 4y ago> debunking his claims regarding his diagnosis. https://youtu.be/UCS0SuPsDH4 https://youtu.be/UCS0SuPsDH4 This video has logic like (all from the first 3 minutes): - "Elon wasn't public with his condition before SNL, nor did his mother reveal this deeply personal information, maybe he has it buy maybe he's a sociopath?". - Some people in our YouTube comments section have diagnoses and don't believe Elon. Here are their comments!
- andai 4y agoSo he's just plain weird then? ;)
- dsego 4y agoWhen you have money it's known as "eccentric", ie eccentric billionaire (similarly you have mad scientist, absent-minded professor, wise old man, etc).
- vjust 4y agoWhat did Elon invent? - just curious
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- krageon 4y agoCan you explain why? "Disease" doesn't mean that it is bad in all cases, it doesn't even mean that it needs to be cured. All it means it that it's not an optimal state in the eyes of most other people (i.e. it is normative). f.e. I don't think anyone has a problem with saying sickle cell is a disease, even though it has a large upside as well.
- wpietri 4y agoTrying to suggest that "disease" is a positive or even neural term is a giant stretch. And yes, my exact problem with it is that it is normative. Just because neurotypicals are in the majority does not make them better. Imagine if it were reversed, for example. In my view, the neurotypical fondness for drama is incredibly harmful. Ditto the way neurotypicals not only believe in all sorts of nonsense (UFOs, angels, gods, devils, etc.) but use that as justification for all sorts of dominance-driven behavior, up to and including genocide. And in practice the normative nature combined with the disease model leads to "medicalization of deviance". E.g., queer people's deviance was medicalized, seen as illness. ANd since they were sick, treatment was necessary, sometimes violently enforced treatment.
- hnbad 4y agoMany autistic people would disagree that being autistic is "not an optimal state". It's a different state. There are even some autistic people (on the extreme end: "aspie supremacists") who argue that being allistic (i.e. non-autistic) is actually more of an impairment. However most would at least say that autistic brains are not more or less "optimal", just different, and that normativity is more harmful than helpful. There are aspects of the kitchen sink that is Autistic Spectrum Disorder that can reasonably be argued to be an impairment (e.g. sensory overloads, situational mutism, etc) but autism is not in any way objectively suboptimal in itself, other than when it comes to interacting with allistics (but that goes both ways).
- causi 4y agobut autism is not in any way objectively suboptimal in itself For this to be true, autists would have to communicate and/or work with other autists as competently as neurotypicals mesh with each other. Strictly speaking, we should be able to work with other autists more easily than we work with neurotypicals who have a basic familiarity with autism, since we also have that advantage. In my experience we are not. Replacing your left hand with a sword also has measurable advantages but that doesn't make it not an overall impairment. Personally I find this cultural trend where "your deviation is your identity" to be illogical and offensive.
- scotty79 4y agoIsn't it a bit uncomfortable that term that described condition of non-verbal kids got so diluted that now there are adult people who self diagnose common human quirks with this term?
- senda 4y agoIt's a temporary catch all term that needs to go away once science illuminates this dark corner. We don't know why cockroaches turn left or right, psychologists need to be humbled.
- faeriechangling 4y agoIndeed, “spectrum” does mean “catch all” and autistics, where they do have medical issues (and they often do), don’t all have the same ones.
- beardedwizard 4y agoSelf diagnosis seems extremely popular in the last 2 years. Unrelated to autism, we also seem to be having an adhd epidemic based on the number of peole self diagnosing it.
- faeriechangling 4y agoSelf diagnosis is valid because the formal process is bullshit lol. The diagnostic process utterly lacks reliability in practice, there has been no two years in the last half a century where autism has been diagnosed at the same rate from year to year. Diagnosis has instead multiplied many times over. The biggest problem I have with self-diagnosis is the idea that self-diagnosis (along with formal diagnosis) is actually capable of diagnosing a neurodevelopment disorder. It just ain’t so and autism is a social construct that LARPs as a medical one.
- fluoridation 4y agoSelf-diagnosing was being mocked on the Internet at least as far back as 2006. It's definitely not just the last 2 years.
- jckahn 4y agoIMO the reclassification of Asperger’s Syndrome as a general Autism Spectrum disorder was massively unhelpful to all, and it only served to muddy conversations like this. Different ends of the spectrum affect people in wildly different ways. Different extremes need very different types of support. As a person with Asperger’s, I really wish it remained a distinct condition in terms of its classification.
- djaychela 4y agoHad this exact conversation with my 18-year-old daugther yesterday. She's fairly recently diagnosed and was happy with being described as Asperger's, but now it's much less clear when she's described as Autistic.
- adolph 4y agoHey, at least there is the pat on the head phrase of “high functioning” right?
- Loughla 4y agoI mean, I absolutely understand not wanting to use that, but what do I say instead? Autism is a spectrum, and some folks are less able to function than others on that spectrum. I legitimately want to know, because I don't know what to say here.
- mrguyorama 4y agoThe reality is that Autism as a whole IS NOT one single spectrum. It's a lot of different symptoms, needs, quirks, and crossover with a bunch of other mental illnesses as well, like social anxiety. Describing it as a singular variable "Spectrum" produces entirely wrong conclusions. It's more like a 10 dimensional space, at least, with each dimension being a symptom or needs category. For example, I don't think anyone would diagnose me with autism, or even old asbergers, but I have a lot of sensory issues and struggle to parse speech and faces. If you are aware of someone having some form of autism, and you want to know more about "where on the spectrum" they are, simply talk to them, ask what they struggle with, ask about their needs. If you didn't have to talk to a family member or nurse before talking to them, they probably don't need huge affordances.
- mikebonnell 4y agoAutism as a general topic should not be called a disease. As said so well in this article: https://novaramedia.com/2021/11/25/autism-is-not-a-disease/ https://novaramedia.com/2021/11/25/autism-is-not-a-disease/ "Treating autism as a ‘disease’, rather than a neurotype that exists as a result of natural biological variation, paves the way for a level of discrimination and stigmatisation that would not be acceptable if it were applied to other minority groups. At worst, it raises serious fears of eugenics. But the traditional understanding of autism as a deficit also plays a huge role in day-to-day discrimination against autistic people..." edit: removed a poorly worded section.
- jklinger410 4y ago> It is a disorder in that our norms of society are not aligned around Neurodiverse brains Reminder as always that over-simplifying autism to lean into the most high functioning description completely erases the existence of all of the severely autistic people out there who are barely able to function with their disorder. Given the context of how I understand autism, and my personal experience with it, as a severe inhibitor in a normal life for the people who suffer from it, I find the whole quote you shared as despicable. Further evidence that the autism you are talking about dismisses and denies the existence of many autistic individuals who are not as privileged to have such a high functioning variant. Your empathy for autistic people stops at a certain level of capability, because you refuse to even recognize that they exist within your argument. It makes my stomach churn.
- faeriechangling 4y agoI frankly don’t care if you feel the need to call me/a huge swathe or people disordered and have something medically wrong with them because you lack sufficient creativity to imagine how we could treat people with severe mental health issues if we failed to do this. Severely disabled autistic people don’t give two craps about autistic erasure, I knew some over a period of time, they never talked about ideas how “Asperger’s” was fundamentally problematic or any such hot takes, frankly they couldn’t hold a conversation and mostly wanted people to take care of them and be nice to them and for them to be more independent. This is about you, not them. All I hear is somebody calling me two insults, “disordered” and “privileged” who feels a sense of moral superiority for doing so. I never chose this label for myself, it was imposed upon me, I can’t choose to shed it, and I reject to being martyred for the sake of the severely disabled. I reject being labelled as having a neurological disorder without anybody looking at my Brain, taking my blood, doing any sort of objective testing, because some psychologist arbitrary deemed how I behave “deficits” through observation, an utterly subjective judgement. it’s some sort of moral obligation to believe I’m mentally disordered otherwise I’m hurting the severely disabled! You know maybe we could help the severely disabled by volunteering or donating to charity instead of this nonsense??
- sylware 4y agooooof! Now, is this very biological imbalance the real source of this autism? Could be only the result of a real underlaying set of causes. Now, how do we increase the neurons and synapses at those places? Intense, and maybe painful, mental training with brain imagery to check the right spots are being trained?
- BazookaMusic 4y ago"A protein called FMRP that is absent in the brains of people with FXS modulates the activity of a type of potassium channel in the brain. According to the research group's work, it is the absence of this protein that alters the way sensory inputs are combined, causing them to be underrepresented by the signals coming out of the cortical pyramidal neurons in the brain." Maybe adjusting the production of the protein they identified would be a reasonable thing to study before resorting to Clockwork Orange therapy.
- sylware 4y agoWow, the first part of the article does not mention the missing protein, and the "5 seconds" headline does not mention it neither. Then I though it was _only_ about this imbalance. Partial and fast reading, bad. And I am the first one to bash short term-ists in a hurry.
- pitched 4y agoIf the neurons that are weak are the ones for processing external signals and having them override internal signals is the goal, maybe it’s as simple as a cold shower every day.
- scotty79 4y agoYou can't train yourself to produce a missing protein you can't produce.
- raverbashing 4y ago(A step forward in) understanding "Fragile X syndrome" which is a type of autism. But I'm not sure how many of people with an autism diagnosis has FXS
- nailer 4y agoThe article says FXS is the most common cause. But that seems odd. Wikipedia has two references for; > Fragile X syndrome (FXS) is a genetic disorder characterized by mild-to-moderate intellectual disability. The average IQ in males with FXS is under 55. That doesn’t sound like most autistics I know.
- mnw21cam 4y agoFragile X is about 1.4 cases per 10,000 males. Autism is way more common than that, so I wouldn't say the Fragile X accounts for even a single percent of Autism cases. The article saying that it is the most common cause of Autism is definitely weasle-wording, and can only be claimed because most autism is not monogenic in nature. It's almost always a polygenic trait, and therefore doesn't have a single "identified" cause.
- kevviiinn 4y agoNot exactly, currently under the DSM there are a whole bunch of related behavioral phenotypes that are grouped under the ASD umbrella. This includes similar behavioral patterns and processing issues. Yes sometimes it can be polygenic but the reality is that there are a whole bunch of different things that can cause similar behaviors and sensory processing issues. The DSM (and psychology in general) is still pretty shitty in the way that it groups things based on phenotype rather than mechanism
- mnw21cam 4y agoYeah, sorry. s/polygenic/not monogenic/
- diydsp 4y agoYes def worth skimming about fxs.(1) Avg iq of fxs males is 55. This isn't "trains" autism. It's a full-disability. Still very important news! (1) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fragile_X_syndrome https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fragile_X_syndrome
- ilaksh 4y agoI'm sure everyone is going to dismiss this type of research now that most people think any intelligent, slightly shy and technically competent person must have autism.
- chasd00 4y agoIt does a disservice to those suffering. Mental illness and things like adhd and autism are very trendy for some reason.
- newaccount2021 4y ago[dead]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- xena 4y agoHonestly, the problem isn't autism. It's people not understanding that autism fundamentally changes how you view reality and then making people with autism have a harder time because of something they didn't ask for. It's like being able to see color and have everyone that only sees black and white get mad at you for it.
- mattigames 4y agoAnd here you are doing the exact same thing but with the people that don't have autism, they also didn't ask for their way if viewing reality, and that they communicate and interact with others based on a way that works most of the time so they stick to it.
- alasdair_ 4y agoThe problem is that (in school and the workplace, at least) it's almost always the individual with autism that is told to conform to others and never the case that the others are taught how to work with the autistic (or other neurodivergent) person instead. It would be better if the education about how others worked was two-way and included teaching others about autism as well. And yes, some schools now do this, but he majority don't.
- ImHereToVote 4y agoI wish you specified that you mean high functioning autistic people.
- danShumway 4y agoEven with low-functioning autistic people where "they're just different" isn't a good or respectful descriptor of their experiences, sometimes society makes dealing with those problems much more difficult than necessary. Again, not saying that low-functioning autistic people don't have a problem that they wish would go away, but it's sort of like having wheelchair ramps. Most people who are in wheelchairs wish they weren't in wheelchairs, but they still like having ramps into and out of buildings. It's still problematic to go to those people and say, "okay I get that you're disabled, but you need to learn how to walk up the library stairs, it's not our job to have ramps everywhere." There are a lot of autistic people who don't think of themselves as neurodivergent, they think of themselves as disabled. It is still often harmful to those people to force them to (on top of their other struggles) also figure out how to constantly conduct themselves so they don't inconvenience anyone else. Being more accommodating can mean allowing them to stim (if the stimming isn't self-destructive), it can mean giving them access to tools that help with sensory issues (headphones, for example), it can mean recognizing if they're panicking and responding to the situation, rather than just ignoring it until they completely break down. Mostly, it means teaching people to understand that person better and to try and set up systems in such a way that the individual can have a better life, rather than forcing the individual to conform -- especially in the case of people on extreme ends of the spectrum who very clearly can't conform. There is an element of accommodation for people who label themselves as neurodivergent that does deal with acceptance and celebration, and that's valid for them to bring up. I really don't think that neurodivergence/disability needs to be a contest, and it's fine for them to talk about autism in terms of social prejudice. But outside of of the neurodivergent movement, overall accommodation doesn't really have anything to do with whether someone is high functioning or low functioning as much as it has to do with not making their life more difficult than it needs to be. Especially in the case of someone who is on the extreme ends of the spectrum and needs help to take care of themselves, it's extremely important for the people around them to make some effort to learn about what they're going through and to learn to work with them and to treat them like a human being. I think that's the case for any mental disability (again, whether or not someone describes their own experiences with autism as a disability or as a difference is irrelevant to what I'm talking about). But if you want an extreme example from the "disability" side of things, you can't go to someone with alzheimers and get mad at them for not remembering what they ate yesterday. If you want to interact positively with someone in that position, you have to work with them. You have to be able to understand what's happening. A lot of social institutions (especially schools) for a long time never put in that work for autistic kids. And a lot of care for autistic people (including people who are best described as disabled) is still focused on making that person more convenient for society, not on caring specifically for that individual. One piece of advice I give when talking about autism care is "find someone who cares more about the autistic kid than they care about the parents." And I think that holds true both for neurodivergent and differently-abled people and for nonverbal kids who are extremely disabled and will require help to function in society for their entire lives. It doesn't matter, caring for that person should still be primarily focused on caring for that person, not the people around them.
- tgv 4y agoErrm ... about that headline. "The researchers found a difference in how sensory signals are processed in [pyramidal neurons of cortical layer 5]" in a mouse model of Fragile X Syndrome. That's it. The abstract of the paper ends with "These results challenge the traditional view that FXS and other ASD are characterized by sensory hypersensitivity, proposing instead a hyposensitivity of sensory inputs and hypersensitivity of predictive inputs onto cortical neurons." And that is under the assumption that any of these hypotheses are true(ish). While an interesting finding, it doesn't prove that it is a significantly contributing factor in (human) autism.
- tarokun-io 4y agoThanks. This is probably the most helpful comment. "Scientific" articles have such click-bait titles. I understand this is an evil necessity in capitalism, but these titles bias everyone...
- 908B64B197 4y agoUnlike most university press releases, this particular headline makes no claims other than "we have a better understanding of X".
- tgv 4y agoThe actual headline is "a giant step forward".
- epigwa 4y agoIt is interesting to learn about progress in understanding molecular deficiencies behind autism. However it seems to me that the prime root of autism is medicalization of natural life process which is pregnancy. Frequent advices for mothers-to-be to lay calm deprive a developing fetus of environmental stimulation necessary for brain development in critical first 9 months of life. Pregnancy is not ilness to be treated in a way which interferes with child's brain development!