11 ms·
IKEA made a smart air quality sensor to track indoor pollution
- progbits 4y agoThey are already selling the Vindriktning for a long time. It doesn't have a screen, just a traffic lights style indicator, and the thresholds are quite high. However it costs like $10 and if you buy a $3 esp module and spend few minutes soldering you can get it integrated into home assistant. This new device looks nice but due to the display I expect the price to be much higher.
- martin_a 4y agoThis was the first thing that came to my mind. I've got various IKEA lights integrated in Home Assistant which is no problem due to sticking to the ZigBee standard, so I can use my existing gateway + RPi 3. If those air quality monitors would support the ZigBee standard too, that would be very nice.
- progbits 4y agoDefinitely. These could be nice for locations where they can be seen as they actually look nice and provide useful display. But usually I prefer to hide something cheaper and uglier behind furniture and then get the data on my phone. I wish they put these into other objects like lamps, picture frames etc
- Jensson 4y agoYou can get a calculator for a few dollars, basic screens aren't that expensive. The screen shown looks like the same level as a calculator and a few printed symbols on top of it, so price shouldn't need to change much at all.
- unwind 4y agoCaptain Obvious checking in: the name (which Engadget classified as "tongue-twisting") literally means "wind strength", or "wind speed" as its called in actual English. It's two words: "vind" is (surprise) "wind" and "styrka" is "strength". The latter can be pronounced decently by pretending the "y" is perhaps a double "e", or something. It is, admittedly, is a bit weird of a name for a sensor that measures air quality but on the other hand it's Ikea and they name things after their own mind. Source: am Swedish.
- netrus 4y agoWhat does it take to produce cheap CO2 sensors? Ikea would be my best bet to provide a large enough market for good-enough sensors to bring prices down. A CO2 sensor should be in every classroom and every office, but it's not affordable enough yet.
- ikekkdcjkfke 4y agoWhy isn't my 1000$ smartphone loaded with sensors, infrared camera, decibel meter etc.
- davidy123 4y agoYou can add these things via USB (not sure about iPhone). If enough people find it helpful, it'll become part of the package eventually.
- happymellon 4y agoThere are a few lightning adaptors, I have an IR camera for example, however they are talking about the USB C port is going to be proprietary so it will only work for power unless you have Apple approved wiring and chips.
- aflag 4y agoProbably because it would make it cost more than $1000 while not being useful to most people.
- soderfoo 4y agoManufacturers believe consumer sentiment favors cramming more telephoto selfie cams and the like in to phones.
- literalAardvark 4y agoUnfortunately, word on the street agrees. I'd really love CO2, HRV and a physical keyboard, but it's just not gonna happen ever, because we'd end up with the Homermobile.
- chewmieser 4y agoThere’s plenty of air quality monitors out there already. Doesn’t seem like this does anything unique, but I’ll be interested in seeing the price when it’s available. I personally use an Atomotube Pro (https://store.atmotube.com/ https://store.atmotube.com/) which also has the added benefit of being portable.
- gizmodo59 4y agoIt looks good. But the reviews on Amazon says it’s not having a good battery life. How’s it for you? I don’t need to travel that much so I can keep it plugged in all the time?
- chewmieser 4y agoBattery life is fine, not amazing but fine. I can usually get around a week or so of battery life depending on what I'm using it for. I usually leave it near an outlet anyway so I can plug it in periodically. The portable nature of the device is a nice-to-have for me but I usually just use it in my home. One thing that it lacks is WiFi connectivity - all syncing needs to be done via bluetooth. Which makes sense since it's portable but WiFi would be nice when it's at home. But the device is open and their site gives you ways to make it WiFi compatible if you so desired. I originally found it through a report that showed it as effective as expensive air quality testing gear. It happened to be the only portable one as well that rated that well.
- joshvm 4y agoA big benefit would be ZigBee integration. Not particularly unique, but IKEA tend to do a reasonable job in terms of quality and price and their smart home bits are easy to connect to HomeAssistant. They claim it can talk to STARKVIND, so it should have that capability. They seem to be a bit more reliable than Aqara/Xiaomi (battery life seems to be variable for me).
- a_paddy 4y agoIKEA's marketing material say it's not compatible with the Tradfri Hub, so might be using Matter over Thread. Although the DIRIGERA does still also support ZigBee, they are moving away from it.
- input_sh 4y agoWorth pointing out that they already had a sensor, but it didn't have a screen, just LEDs that turned from green to red. For price reference, it's $16. https://www.ikea.com/us/en/p/vindriktning-air-quality-sensor-60515911/ https://www.ikea.com/us/en/p/vindriktning-air-quality-sensor...
- BossingAround 4y agoWhich is notoriously imprecise [1]. [1] https://www.airgradient.com/open-airgradient/blog/ikea-vindriktning-accuracy/ https://www.airgradient.com/open-airgradient/blog/ikea-vindr...
- wartijn_ 4y agoThat article is linked a few times in these comments, but I think it should be noted that that article is written by a competitor. Airgradient is a commercial company that sells air quality sensors. And it seems to be the only source that states the Ikea sensor is imprecise, so I wouldn't call it "notoriously imprecise"
- fbn79 4y agoIt's important to know that accuracy of this sensor are very low https://www.airgradient.com/open-airgradient/blog/ikea-vindriktning-accuracy/ https://www.airgradient.com/open-airgradient/blog/ikea-vindr...
- MaxPengwing 4y agonot the same device. Would be nice if they did a tear down of Vindstyrka as well.
- zihotki 4y agoWhile absolute accuracy is low, you still can use it to see the trend. Often the trend and approximate measurements are good enough. Edit: spelling
- danuker 4y agoLooks like the new device has a screen and is called Vindstyrka, and the one reviewed is an old one with LED indicators, Vindriktning.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- tecleandor 4y agoBe aware that review is not for this product, but for the previous one. I don't know if they're using the same sensors inside. Edit: to be clear, the new product is called VINDSTYRKA, the review you link is for Vindriktning, the previous "non smart" sensor.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- jeffreygoesto 4y agoWith a Bosch Bme680 you can detect farts. Take that, CO2 enthusiasts... =;-}
- BossingAround 4y agoLooks interesting; is there a blog somewhere detailing how to hook the sensor up to Raspberry Pi or something similar?
- hobo_mark 4y agoYou literally connect four wires and `pip install bme680`.
- rjsw 4y agoThe owner of the ISP that I use has been experimenting with making his own [1]. [1] https://www.revk.uk/2019/09/environmental-sensor.html https://www.revk.uk/2019/09/environmental-sensor.html
- hellweaver666 4y agoIf you're in the UK, Pimoroni have a bunch of awesome sensor boards with a PicoW attached to them which makes it super easy to put sensors on your network (they have sensors designed for indoor and outdoor use and even a full weather station!)
- londons_explore 4y agoCould an air quality sensor be made by using a spark gap and then a spectrometry on the light produced by the spark? You should be able to measure CO2, NOX, and various other pollutants this way, either via emission or absorption spectroscopy. For solid PM2.5 pollution, you could potentially identify the chemical make up of the particles, which should be good for identifying the iron metal dust from machines, the stone dust from building work, the organic skin dust, the rubber dust from tyres, the carbon dust from engines, etc. Seems like a single cheap sensor that might be able to provide a lot more info than other more complex sensor types.
- Doxin 4y agoI think the signal from regular air would swamp out any signal from higher CO2 counts or particulates or the like. Of course since you already know beforehand which spectral peaks you want to look at you can presumably use some really narrow color filters which might help.
- KaiserPro 4y agohas anyone found the price of these? I have some second hand awair sensors, which I got for about £50. They are brilliant, but cost £200 new.
- BossingAround 4y ago~40EUR on the Czech Ikea website that someone posted here.
- smhg 4y agoOn the Czech IKEA website it's listed with a price of 999 CZK [0]. This is about 42 EUR. [0] https://www.ikea.com/cz/cs/p/vindstyrka-senzor-kvality-vzduchu-chytre-40498234/ https://www.ikea.com/cz/cs/p/vindstyrka-senzor-kvality-vzduc...
- rishikeshs 4y agoIs it possible to build a similar one using Arduino?
- KerrickStaley 4y agoLook up AirGradient.
- folly237 4y agoMaybe I'm out of the loop since moving away from any IKEA store 6 years ago...but this feels a bit out of the ordinary for them, doesn't it? To me, IKEA = "build your own furniture". Not "smart home tech".
- jeromegv 4y agoThey have been selling TVs for many years.
- BossingAround 4y agoI'm sure people said that too when Amazon was launching AWS.
- Toutouxc 4y agoWay out of the loop. IKEA now sells loads of smart home tech: smart lightbulbs, LED drivers, motion sensors, light switches, power outlets, air purifiers, motorized window shades and even amazing smart speakers (designed by IKEA, but fully compatible Sonos internals with respectable sound quality).
- donutshop 4y agoUnpopular opinion - Airthings make very good air quality sensors, and detects radon levels as well.
- Toutouxc 4y agoThat’s not even an opinion, much less an unpopular one.
- KerrickStaley 4y agoI've been very happy with my AirGradient [1]. It measures PM2.5, CO2, temperature, and humidity. I got the $67 kit and assembled it; it was a fun soldering project. I like that I can reflash it and get it to send data to VictoriaMetrics on my Raspberry Pi over WiFi. The biggest thing that I dislike is that the CO2 sensor loses calibration over time and (from what I understand) needs to be re-exposed to fresh outdoor air every ~2 weeks. I might buy this IKEA sensor too to see how they compare; wouldn't hurt to be able to monitor a second room. [1] https://www.airgradient.com/ https://www.airgradient.com/
- vestrigi 4y agoIsn't the recalibration even a problem of all CO2 sensors, including the IKEA model?
- Toutouxc 4y agoIKEA doesn’t sell a CO2 sensor.
- thebruce87m 4y agoA well ventilated room should return to outside ppm levels during the day if unoccupied.
- slavoingilizov 4y agoHonest question - monitoring air quality accurately is great, but monitoring doesn't solve problems. Once you know it's bad, what do you do? I've been wondering what's the point of monitoring something if you can't do anything about it? Do people move house when it's consistently bad? Are the majority of issues caused by in-house pollutants so you open windows for ventilation more? Maybe I'm biased but in my neck of the woods, the bad air quality comes from _outside_. So unless I up sticks, not much else to do.
- blago 4y agoAir purifiers work pretty well for most kinds of pollution, and they are widely available.
- BelleOfTheBall 4y agoYou can use methods of cleaning the air in your house, I assume things like humidifiers and specialized air conditioning/cleaning units exist. The point of these sensors is to show the problem actually exists. If thousands of people suddenly find out their home air is compromised, that will then create a demand for air purification tools.
- karmelapple 4y agoDo you have a CO2 or other air monitor at your home? Do you have a gas oven? Every time I turned on my gas oven, the CO2 would spike from 600ppm to over 1200ppm almost immediately. I wouldn’t have known that without a meter, and wouldn’t have realized my air quality was bad inside.
- jabroni_salad 4y agoI'm bad with pollen and air filters have been good for me. It's just on a timer though, I don't use any fancy sensors.
- alias_neo 4y agoI built a PM2.5 and PM10 monitoring "box" for Home Assistant when we got our log-stove installed. The goal was to know how bad the air quality would be in our living room / home. Having used it for several weeks, now I've learned a couple of things; The air quality _in_ the house is usually _much_ better than it is outside, for example, I measure an average of 1-2ug/m3 inside, but if I take it outside or open the window it can rise to 20-30ug/m3, we live on a fairly busy road. I looked into the UK air quality guidelines and the advice is literally to "close your windows". Second, the log stove has no effect on the (PM) air quality in the living room when burning properly, however, opening the door to refuel, or not lighting it to a proper burn can cause the levels to shoot up to 70ug/m3 or as high as 200ug/m3 if you let a lot of smoke out while dicking around with the fire, this has a pretty slow fall-off and usually takes hours to drop back to "normal". I want a CO2 monitor next to check CO2 levels too.
- seltzered_ 4y agoWorth reminding of this blog post concerning cheap air quality monitoring systems: https://halestrom.net/darksleep/blog/048_indoorairsensing/ https://halestrom.net/darksleep/blog/048_indoorairsensing/
- blago 4y agoSo much irony considering that Ikea's furniture is probably the main source of formaldehyde pollution in most people's homes. I don't judge them too hard but ironic nevertheless.
- bklyn11201 4y agoHow much pre-1993 Ikea furniture still exists in USA homes?!
- blago 4y agoWhat happened in 1993?
- CharlesW 4y agoThat's when IKEA stopped adding formaldehyde to its products. https://www.ikea.com/us/en/customer-service/knowledge/articles/3d6091g2-bc89-4337-8489-2e7771f4g1fg.html https://www.ikea.com/us/en/customer-service/knowledge/articl...: "Trace amounts of formaldehyde can be found in our products as it is a naturally occurring substance, however, we do not add formaldehyde to our range. As a precautionary measure, IKEA has phased out several chemicals that could potentially be harmful, often ahead of legislation."
- blago 4y agoThis is not from 1993. "Trace amounts of formaldehyde can be found in our products" Trace amounts sounds great, but that's open to interpretation. There are MANY guidelines by different authorities and their levels differ by more than an order of magnitude. If you take OSHA PEL as baseline you can claim trace amounts and still be pretty harmful. "however, we do not add formaldehyde to our range." Range? This sounds so vague it feels deliberate. "As a precautionary measure, IKEA has phased out several chemicals that could potentially be harmful, often ahead of legislation." They didn't say formaldehyde was one of them :-) Also, did you ready the linked PDF? It says they don't use formaldehyde in their paint and lacquer. They didn't say anything about their glue and particle board. That's where formaldehyde is indispensable and used in large amounts.
- thimkerbell 4y agoTwo points: First, as noted by many below (above), IKEA really needs to put a CO2 monitor in this thing, to tell room occupants the most useful information. Second, one person being confidently wrong can use up a lot of other people's time. Maybe there's some way that forum design could reduce this problem. Maybe there isn't.
- idiotsecant 4y agoIs CO2 level useful, though? Our bodies are really exceptionally good at detecting harmful CO2 levels. There's very little effect to CO2 buildup in air up to levels that people are good at detecting. VOCs, PM2.5, and other contaminant classes are not so easily detected by human hardware, though.
- valenterry 4y agoThere's something between "perfectly fine" and "harmful" though. bad co2 levels can impact concentration without being harmful.
- skrebbel 4y ago> Second, one person being confidently wrong can use up a lot of other people's time. Maybe there's some way that forum design could reduce this problem. Maybe there isn't. Is this like an HN subtweet or am I just daft? I have absolutely no idea which comment you're referring to here.
- thimkerbell 4y ago(One thing that might aid reader skimming could be a 2nd step of offering the commenter something like 60 characters' worth of mild highlighting, to apply to their comment where they wish, to stress most important point(s), if they want to.)
- turtlebits 4y agoWhile I agree that CO2 sensors are useful, they'll significantly add to the price. High CO2 levels in a home aren't a health risk unlike PM2.5 or VOCs though.
- taeric 4y agoI welcome more information on air quality. I do not look forward to the emerging state of it. I fully expect it to be closer to back surgeries than otherwise.
- robg 4y agoLG has a purifier and sensor combo that I used to learn we were likely aerosolizing heavy metals in our humidifiers.
- dalyons 4y agoWhat did you do about this? I just noticed the same thing with my purpleair indoor (goes crazy on pm2.5 when I run the humidifier)
- somehnguy 4y agoMy air purifier's meter goes into the red whenever I use the shower down the hall from it - it did the same thing as my previous home as well. I've always just assumed it's a side-effect of the raised humidity.
- glitcher 4y agoOff topic: upon first opening this web page I was surprised to think that maybe I had already visited all the links in the article. Then I realized purple is one of the site's primary colors, and both visited and unvisited links look the same there.
- m3kw9 4y agoMakes sense, it would help sell their air purifier. Still could be useful by it self but if you are already concerned about air quality, this will push you to confirm your fears. The product development team there is rolling
- adolph 4y agoSo like: air sensor ($) -> air purifier ($) -> filters for previous ($$$ over time) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Razor_and_blades_model https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Razor_and_blades_model
- yalogin 4y agoThese sensors can only estimate based on what passes through them. So is it a good enough approximation for the whole room let alone the whole house? I get it that the very presence of some particles at some density will tell a story. Since we know where we are placing that device we have to extrapolate the numbers and get an overall sense of pollution in the house. Can folks that use something like this chime in with experience and how effective or useful this is?
- ahaucnx 4y agoI have extensively tested the previous model and it was a bit of a mixed result with the strongest selling point the price being really affordable. You can see my review and test result on our blog [1]. One of the biggest negative points that I found was that the traffic light cut off points are way off. So it shows a green light from 0-35 μg/m³ whereas the WHO defines the annual limit now at less than 5 μg/m³. Unfortunately in this new model this seems still to be the case and has not been improved (according to the manual [2]). So the VINDSTYRKA still gives misleading indications through the traffic light but at least you can now see the μg/m³ on the display and make a more informed judgement (compared to the old model without display). It is difficult to make a judgement on the accuracy without really running it through a test cycle but it is definitely missing a CO2 sensor. Measuring CO2 indoors is most likely the most important parameter, especially if you live outside strongly polluted areas e.g. in Asia. CO2 sensors that give good accuracy are relatively expensive and I believe it was probably shelved because of costs which is a pity. So this looks like a big missed opportunity but I will try and source one of these and write a review. If you are interested for a DIY kit with high quality sensors, check out our AirGradient kits [3]. [1] https://www.airgradient.com/open-airgradient/blog/ikea-vindriktning-accuracy https://www.airgradient.com/open-airgradient/blog/ikea-vindr... [2] https://www.ikea.com/cz/cs/manuals/vindstyrka-senzor-kvality-vzduchu-chytre__AA-2351596-1-2.pdf https://www.ikea.com/cz/cs/manuals/vindstyrka-senzor-kvality... [3] https://www.airgradient.com/open-airgradient/kits/ https://www.airgradient.com/open-airgradient/kits/
- berberous 4y agoHave you tested Awair? How does Airgradiant compare?
- ahaucnx 4y agoAwair uses much better sensors than the Ikea and the accuracy should be quite similar to the AirGradient.
- mcjiggerlog 4y agoAgreed - the lack of CO2 monitoring is a shame. I bought a relatively inexpensive CO2 monitor (~90 EUR) and it was really an eye opener. If you work in a small home office, the speed that you reach levels of CO2 that will have a noticeable impact on your mental faculties (eg 2000ppm) is incredible. Definitely makes you step up your ventilation game!
- bborud 4y agoLooks like it uses this particle sensor: https://www.environmental-expert.com/products/cubic-model-pm1006k-led-particle-sensor-752064 https://www.environmental-expert.com/products/cubic-model-pm...
- cptskippy 4y agoHey I made an IKEA smart air quality sensor too! https://imgur.com/a/UhL4OuD https://imgur.com/a/UhL4OuD
- Toutouxc 4y ago> IKEA already has a side table that doubles as an air purifier, but now it has a way to gauge just how clean that air really is Please note that the purifier/table combo and the standalone purifier, both called Starkvind, already have a PM2.5 sensor and are smart (Zigbee) devices.
- d1sxeyes 4y ago> It can tell a Starkvind purifier to ramp up the fan speed based on particulate levels, for instance Starkvinds already have an 'auto mode' which does exactly that. I love being able to see air quality and humidity, but in reality, pretty much every device you can control remotely which is capable of influencing air quality and humidity already has the capability built in, and I have fallen short of finding any actually useful automations that involve either humidity or air quality sensors.