14 ms·
Turkey’s earthquakes show the deadly extent of construction scams
- jmole 4y agohttps://archive.is/hHqal https://archive.is/hHqal
- mrlonglong 4y agoIf anything, the Turkiye government are dodging the finger of blame. The fault lies with the politicians for not stamping down hard on developers who flout building regulations and/or allowing them to construct buildings with a 'waiver' that lets them get away with substandard building.
- LarryMullins 4y ago"The fault" isn't some finite and indivisible thing that needs to be assigned to only one group of people. Politicians are at fault for not cracking down on scammers, and the scammer contractors are also at fault for being scammers. One does not diminish the other, stop thinking of fault as zero sum.
- ilyt 4y agoBut if it isn't politician's head on the line they won't do shit
- mrlonglong 4y agoI disagree. It is the Government's responsibility to its people to ensure buildings remain safe during earthquakes. If their building regulations are not being obeyed then it is their job to enforce it. It is their responsibility.
- raincom 4y agoIn the third world, building contractors collude with politicians and bureaucrats. This is a mutually reinforcing mechanism.
- dotancohen 4y agoNow I realize why it's called a fault line.
- Kinrany 4y agoWhile it's not zero sum, government policies create competitive pressure, potentially creating a situation where only scammers can compete. Heavily fining the whole industry and using the money to finance new companies being created would likely still be a better policy than letting them off the hook though.
- GalenErso 4y agoIn a twist of fate, the Chamber of Civil Engineers building is one of the few that withstood the quake. https://www.reddit.com/r/Damnthatsinteresting/comments/10yw25f/chamber_of_civil_engineers_building_is_one_of_the/ https://www.reddit.com/r/Damnthatsinteresting/comments/10yw2...
- 77pt77 4y agoThat will only result is in conspiracy theories about why that happened.
- wongarsu 4y agoI guess they had the forsight/experience to occasionally send one of their civil engineers to inspect the building site and make sure material and techniques were up to spec.
- jeroenhd 4y agoI think it's less about the foresight and more about being willing to spend the extra cash. Shoddy construction is often cheaper, easier, or faster, those are the driving forces behind ignoring code. I doubt many engineers would choose to avoid the catastrophes they've been taught to avoid in their work, because they know better than anyone what the impact of such catastrophes will be. There will always be bad people, but there are more constraints than just lack of skill or foresight that make these disasters unfold.
- eska 4y agoReminds me of the famous pictures of a tori arch in Japan that survived nukes and earthquakes while its surroundings were repeatedly destroyed. Real trooper.
- gruez 4y ago>is one of the few that withstood the quake. but in that picture, you can plainly see a bunch of other buildings in the background that also have "withstood" the quake?
- pearjuice 4y agoConstruction scams? More like government approved construction scams. In recent years, the Turkish government issued many exemptions for projects that were built or expanded in violation of the official buidling rules. For a small fine (which yielded the treasury almost three billion euros) they could do whatever they wanted, going against all requirements and obligations for safe building which is nature-disaster resistant.
- tremon 4y agoFor a small fine We have a word for those "fines": they're called indulgences.
- jl6 4y agoIt’s not surprising at all that the lack of accountability goes right to the top, and it’s tragic that it takes an earthquake to expose the corruption. But Turkey is far from the only country with a corrupt, ticking-time-bomb of construction and infrastructure quality issues. Pretty much every low-to-middle income country has taken the semi-rational approach of cutting corners in order to do more with less. And the high-income countries have arguably swung the pendulum too far in the opposite direction, with very high standards that lead to very high prices for construction of anything (and a few unfortunate places which enjoy the high price of high standards, and enough corruption to bypass these standards).
- mschuster91 4y ago> Pretty much every low-to-middle income country has taken the semi-rational approach of cutting corners in order to do more with less. For what it's worth, the "developed" Western countries have done just the same. Look at the fellow front page article about the train catastrophe in East Palestine or how virtually all companies got hit hard by supply chain interruptions - no matter if from Covid, the Ever Given or Ever Forward getting stuck, strikes, or whatever else tiny or small interruption, the key thing is that resilience aka stockpiles got out of fashion because they were seen as too expensive... Cutting corners is an universal problem.
- wazoox 4y agoYep. I've just seen an interview of a custom officer here in France. In the past 25 years the amount of foreign goods entering the country has more than doubled; in the meanwhile, the number of custom officers was slashed by 30% (in Germany it slightly increased in the same period). Illegal goods of all kinds (from toxic paints to non-conforming tools and drugs) are now everywhere. But the state saved money! In the short term at least...
- jl6 4y agoSo, it’s easy to be cynical here and point to examples of where high-income countries have had disasters, and from those data points conclude that everywhere is the same, but it really isn't the case that everywhere is the same. The fact we hear about failures, we see their political causes debated, and lawsuits filed, and root causes analyzed, and hands wrung in headlines… these are all symptoms of a system that is more or less working. These are the course-corrections and isolated incidents that serve to calibrate and revalidate that the accountability is there. This is nothing like countries where corruption is endemic. Witness Turkey’s recent arrests. What do we think is more likely: those contractors were the true root cause, and their arrests will prevent future building collapses during earthquakes? Or that they are merely the tip of a very large, very corrupt iceberg, and they will be made scapegoats to provide political cover that allows the rest of the system to quickly get back to business as usual?
- 77pt77 4y agoIt won't matter. Things will not change. Some empty gesture will take place to assuage the outrage but nothing will change. Bets are open on who will be scapegoated for this.
- INTPenis 4y agoOnly one person should ever take the blame for this. The guy who "lost" billions of dollars from the earthquake fund is the same guy who could have enforced stricter building codes. It's time for the people of Turkey to make their voices heard.
- mrlonglong 4y agoTurkiye, if you please. Turkeys are best enjoyed on the dinner table.
- commandlinefan 4y agoWhen she was little, my daughter was looking at a globe once and thought it was hilarious that Greece was on top of Turkey - "I don't like greasy turkey, but if that's your thing..."
- mabbo 4y agoMy wife has worked in the 'enforcing building codes' sector of engineering for her entire career. And it's so frustrating to watch. Everyone - everyone - is certain that the codes are all overzealous and their little thing needs an exception. Politicians get elected promising to 'get rid of the red tape'. And then an event occurs and we learn why these building codes exist. Like workplace safety rules, they are written in the blood of the dead. But given time, the events the preceded their writing gets forgotten. I've never seen any of these buildings fall down, so why do we need so many rules to prevent buildings from falling down? They just make it more expensive! Those greedy bureaucrats and building officials just want to prevent development!
- conanbatt 4y agoIt cuts both ways. What about the homeless person dying in the cold because he can't afford shelter due to sky high building requirements - is that included in the building code enforcement rules?
- biggieshellz 4y agoThat's more due to exclusionary zoning than building codes. There is no reason why we couldn't build, for instance, a boarding house under modern building codes, which would create more affordable housing on the low end. The reason that doesn't get built is that the zoning doesn't allow it.
- xxpor 4y agoThat's partially true, but it's really a combo of both. Things like dual staircase requirements, elevator size requirements, and sprinkler requirements make it extremely expensive to build any sort of housing. A recent affordable building in SF cost over $1 million per unit. That's completely unsustainable.
- mschuster91 4y ago> Things like dual staircase requirements, elevator size requirements, and sprinkler requirements make it extremely expensive to build any sort of housing. And you want and need precisely that in a house with fluctuating occupants of which a high percentage will have some sort of mental health issue. Cutting corners on boarding houses will lead to fire catastrophes.
- ChrisMarshallNY 4y agoIf I remember correctly, Turkiyé (did I spel it write?) has always had a bunch of rolling heads, after buildings fall down like dominoes, during their frequent quakes. Doesn't seem to have changed things. Japan, on the other hand, seems to have a really hard-core construction ethos. During quakes there, buildings rock around like they are at a rave, and don't fall down. If we ever have a big quake in New York, we're screwed.
- seizethecheese 4y agoI’m close with someone who does inspections in both US and third world contexts. Apparently, the US pretty much complies with safety related building codes compared to many other places.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- kerpotgh 4y agoWell New York isn’t on an active fault line. I think California would fare pretty well, as much as can be expected after the big one.
- ChrisMarshallNY 4y agoI have heard that the issue with New York, is that we have this solid rock substrate, and the buildings are anchored directly to it. In Japan, I have heard that the buildings actually have some kind of "shock absorber" structure, in their basements, and lots of counterweights.
- kerpotgh 4y agoYes they are anchored to the schist substrate. The point I’m trying to make is you generally don’t build to account for earthquakes if you’re not on a fault line.
- noir_lord 4y agoActive protection systems (big hydraulic dampers (passive and active)) and tuned mass dampers/diagonal dampers.
- andoma 4y ago> In nearby Erzin county, however, not a single building collapsed. The local mayor and his predecessor told local media that they did not allow any illegal construction. Both used the same phrase: “My conscience is clear.” That mayor, Ökkeş Elmasoğlu, should perhaps run for president.
- Oarch 4y agoTake a look at what happened to Ekrem Imamoglu recently.
- netsharc 4y agoI can't help but think that Erdogan's team is already looking for dirt on Ökkeş Elmasoğlu just because Ökkeş just made Erdogan look really bad.
- pizza234 4y agoVery interesting the sad contrast with reality, in particular, considering that there has been an occurrence of this event already, and then lesson hasn't been learned: > Construction amnesties, which allow owners to register unlicensed properties or ones that violate building codes in exchange for a fine, have made a bad situation much worse. Mr Erdogan’s government passed several such amnesties, the latest in 2018, ahead of general elections. The opposition backed the move, because it was popular with voters.
- ornornor 4y agoThe fact that this is the exception is so sad. I don’t know how our species made it so far in spite of its own nature. I can’t imagine how much pressure and intimidation this mayor suffered to refuse bribes from (probably very) well resourced and connected individuals/cartels.
- adventured 4y ago> I don’t know how our species made it so far in spite of its own nature. You're probably overestimating the representation of corruption among individuals. It's rare, not common; which is also why it upsets most everyone (if it were actually the common, it wouldn't upset so). Obviously it can also be more common in some places than others, depending on context. And it's a percentage tax - a friction - on progress, not an absolute stoppage.
- brucethemoose2 4y ago[flagged]
- berkle4455 4y agoIt’s a good thing the government of Turkey didn’t collect an Earthquake Tax on its citizens since 1999 and then do precisely nothing whatsoever regarding earthquake reinforcing or regulation or inspections.
- mrlonglong 4y agoJust out of interest for the layman, is there anything a non-expert like myself can examine on a building to assess its 'survivability' during an earthquake?
- ajross 4y agoThe examples in the linked article are reinforced concrete structure that were missing their steel reinforcement. So... no, not really, unless you have an xray setup or whatever. This is precisely why we have building codes and certified inspectors to sign off on construction projects.
- ansgri 4y agoWhile x-ray is not accessible, for this specific risk one could use some cheap induction-based metal detector to spot-check the presence of rebar within walls.
- myself248 4y agoIs it more than 1 story? Then run, don't walk, away. Don't do tall buildings in seismic zones without the benefit of an incredible amount of engineering practice, inspections, audits, and enforcement. If you suspect the locals are corrupt, your safest place during an earthquake is a straw hut or reasonable facsimile thereof.
- dotancohen 4y agoJapanese and Taiwanese buildings taller than a single story seem to fare fine.
- Loughla 4y agoI'm assuming that is answered mostly by the second paragraph OP wrote that you seemed to miss: >[. . .] without the benefit of an incredible amount of engineering practice, inspections, audits, and enforcement.
- lmpdev 4y agoIs there an independent international body which inspects and reports on building standards noncompliance? Even a stratified random sample of a few dozen buildings per country (based on location, size and cost of development) would likely reveal any evidence of systematic failures It would be a nightmare to establish something like this as every country's laws and building standards are different. I do feel like this is bordering on a human rights issue however (right to life, adequate - nonlife-threatening housing) This is tangental but a similar idea (somewhat) works for ensuring less developed Commonwealth nations conduct voting properly. Developed Commonwealth nations setup Commonwealth Observer Groups (COGs) who sample voting places and occasionally provide security such as the recent PNG elections
- nisegami 4y agoHow many benefitted from cheaper and more accessible housing as a result of the lax enforcement of building codes? I remain unconvinced that obscenely strict building codes are a net-positive.
- notch898a 4y agoThat doesn't matter because earthquake deaths are big and obvious and a bunch of homeless Turks/Kurds dying on the streets doesn't attract news. People see "house fall, housing bad" and then demand safer construction so the death will be hidden elsewhere.
- inglor_cz 4y ago"bunch of homeless Turks/Kurds dying on the streets" Is that common in Turkey? It rather sounds like an American extrapolating from the situation on the Tenderloin. In the Muslim world, extended families tend to stick together more than in the West and provide their members with some safety net. Your crazy uncle will have just a cot in a small side room, but won't be left alone in the street to fend for himself.
- notch898a 4y agoI am extrapolating from living in Rojava, which is as close as I can get to Turkey without getting executed.
- inglor_cz 4y agoIs non-war-related homelessness common in Rojava? As far as my knowledge of the Muslim world goes, families seem to stick together way more than in Europe and won't simply let one of their own in the street.
- notch898a 4y agoI don't think the war can reliably be separated from the issue anywhere in the Turkey/Syria/Iraq region, but I saw some desperate housing on the outskirts of Qamishlo. I don't see how requiring sturdy housing would make the situation any better, as many families simply cannot afford it. Also the Kurds, who are a big portion of inhabitants in South Turkey, tend to be less religious in general than residents of many of the ME countries. Plenty of non-muslims, orphans, etc.
- tablespoon 4y agoLibertarians: this is why we have building codes. We don't need builders cutting corners and harming people years down the road, because profit convinced them that was the right thing to do for their own interests.
- notch898a 4y agoWhy were the people living in that house so greedy that they cheeped out on buying/renting housing? There is soundly built housing in Turkey. If they were rich enough to buy sturdier housing then they could have done that. I'm not pointing this out to blame those people in any way, but it may be legitimately they can't afford better housing and this is the best they could do and the risk of dying in an earthquake was better than their alternatives. Maybe sturdier housing everywhere would mean some those people would have been dead long ago from exposure.
- tablespoon 4y agoYou're assuming the people affected did some kind of rational cost/benefit analysis, and just whatever choice they made was worth the chance of people dying. I very much doubt that was the case. You also seem to be falsely assuming there's only three options: be rich, live in a death trap, or be homeless on the street. That's not the case. People can be tricked, be stupid, just have bad ideas, or similar. Building codes are a check against all that. And if they make a certain class of housing more expensive, there are always alternatives of other classes of housing.
- ornornor 4y agoCorruption doesn’t make things cheaper. Shoddy housing most likely costs the same as up to code housing, especially since you can’t tell if it complies or not (hard to see the rebar embedded in the concrete or its absence) See the market for lemons.
- MisterTea 4y ago> Why were the people living in that house so greedy that they cheeped out on buying/renting housing? Can you please point out in the article where it states these occupants knowingly purchased/rented a structurally compromised home? Because the article I read does not state this. Don't say foolish things before reading the article.
- ak_111 4y agoThis is a global problem: construction red tape and regulations are one of the most annoying and expensive to adhere to, and with real estate prices sky rocketing around the world the most tempting to cut corners on to dodge costs (they are also very difficult and expensive to inspect, unlike in restaurant business for example where it is quite easy to inspect that the kitchen is clean). Take for example the Grenfell tower fire in London a few years ago, almost a 100 people burnt alive and it came down to the management company economising on external cladding (against regulation). https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grenfell_Tower_fire https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grenfell_Tower_fire
- Steve44 4y agoFrom what I've seen a major factor was the cladding manufacturer may have mislead architects regarding the validity of their testing and certification. https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-56101186 https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-56101186 and https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-56403431 https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-56403431 > The BBA decided the evidence from the more successful European tests carried out on the Arconic cladding meant it "may be regarded" as having met the British standard. > > But the Board was never shown the class E ratings for the cassette version of the cladding and knew nothing about them until a BBC investigation in 2018. > > Arconic's president in France, Claude Schmidt, was forced to admit at the inquiry this would have "misled" anyone reading the certificate, including British architects.
- dzonga 4y agoif you have visited turkey once, you already knew the buildings were built on wet sand. plenty of construction going on - but done badly. seen this everywhere from istanbul to antlaya. some countries in asia suffer the same problem as well.
- tagyro 4y agoI'm sure there's a whole chain of broken links and enough blame to share around, but as an engineer, I have to ask why we sometimes forget that we, as doctors, are also bound by a creed, which says (among other things, depending on the version), that we place service before profit, and the welfare of the public above all other considerations and that we'll "practice our profession conscientiously, with dignity, and in accordance with the highest ethical and professional standards". Am I too naive to still believe in this?
- jakub_g 4y ago> Construction amnesties, which allow owners to register unlicensed properties or ones that violate building codes in exchange for a fine, have made a bad situation much worse. Mr Erdogan’s government passed several such amnesties, the latest in 2018, ahead of general elections. The opposition backed the move, because it was popular with voters. The government reaped the political dividends, while millions of property owners ended up paying into state coffers and assuming the risk. A year after the 2018 amnesty, Mr Erdogan appeared in Kahramanmaras, proudly announcing that the programme “had solved the problems” of 144,000 of the city’s residents
- college_physics 4y ago> "The problems lie in implementation and oversight" This is a pattern that applies to every facet of human affairs: The declared "reality" differs from the implemented (real) reality. The key questions are only: by how much, and what happens when events force a comparison of these two "books": The one we choose to believe for expediency or profit versus the ground truth. We can be fatalists and accept that this is "how things are". But that is not what history shows. Civilisation is a process of reconciling arbitrary, emotional, low-information, "fake realities" with objective, verified, cool-headed, facts about the state of the world. The closer we get to reconciling these books, the less we will suffer. The only problem is that we can't emerge from our historical habits fast enough. Earthquakes, megafires, megafloods, virulent pandemics. How many wake up calls do we need? The game is over. We need to reboot to a better society.
- cm2012 4y agoTo be fair to Turkey's builders - 800 year old castles in the quake zone were completely destroyed. So this was a once in a thousand years event basically, otherwise the castles would have been destroyed long ago. Very very hard to plan for this kind of thing.
- emptyfile 4y ago[dead]
- kingofpandora 4y agoA lot of historical monuments have been significantly reconstructed or periodically reinforced so this doesn't necessarily follow.
- jimmySixDOF 4y agoTaking the other side of the scam coin there are construction projects that are over engineered out of all sense of proportion simply to increase the budget and associated flow throughs like skimming or powerbase increases etc. And that's operating under the assumption the project is useful at all in the first place which is by no means a forgone conclusion especially in contrast to other possible devotions of time and energy.
- thimkerbell 4y ago"There’s no reinforced steel here,” she says, “so the concrete lost its strength and the columns collapsed, along with the floors, as soon as the ground started to shake.”" "'The problem lies in implementation and oversight'" of building codes that are strict on paper.
- rsync 4y agoThat's unbelievable. I was expecting to learn that marginal corners had been cut ... best practices had not been followed, etc. But concrete high rise superstructure without steel reinforcement (like rebar) is beyond the pale. How could you even construct that and escape notice (and alarm!) from passersby ? How could you silence (every single worker at the site) ?
- danielodievich 4y agoI was just a teenager during 1988 Armenian earthquake that leveled entirety of city of Stepanakert (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1988_Armenian_earthquake https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1988_Armenian_earthquake) but I remember one of the most damning pictures on the TV and newspapers (even in USSR!) was a huge piece of load-bearing concrete from the collapsed panel building with "БРАК" (FAULTY or didn't pass QA) written on it in black marker/spray paint. Yet it was still used in the building. That earthquake was a significant part of political instability that contributed to USSR demise.
- selimthegrim 4y agoSpitak or Stepanakert?
- PicassoCTs 4y agoThe problem is that even with the codes properly, you can not escape past sins. In particular, illegal waste dumps from the 60s, 70s, who just have been bulldozed over and build upon. They lead to liquidification under stress (large buildings or small earth quakes. And even the best up to code building will not withstand stresses outside of the spec (tilt by 30 degrees + shake). https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Liquefaction https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Liquefaction Its very scary and in particular near old city borders in the 70s its acute. https://earthquake.usgs.gov/hazards/urban/sfbay/liquefaction/sfbay/ https://earthquake.usgs.gov/hazards/urban/sfbay/liquefaction... Preparations: Not alot you can do. Brainstorm and placebos.Lifeslides and ziplines. I dunno. I provide awareness and anlysis. No solutions.
- m0llusk 4y agoBack around 1982 I visited New Zealand. Traveling around Auckland it was surprising to me to encounter so many unreinforced masonry buildings. I tried several times to ask politely what was being done about this problem and each time received a stern response along the lines of "Shut up and mind your own business, damned Yankee." Then in 2011 nearly 200 people were killed, mostly by those buildings which had stood as an obvious risk for decades.
- c-smile 4y agoBuilding codes of course are written by blood and shall be followed. But looking on that photo... You see bunch of vertically standing "levers" around. With their own resonance frequencies. Dynamic of their vibrations is quite complex. They may amplify effect in some places. Effect of standing wave and the like. But that's also about building codes I believe.
- amai 4y agoThank god Turkey doesn’t have nuclear power plants: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Diablo_Canyon_earthquake_vulnerability https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Diablo_Canyon_earthquake_vulne...
- mikeponders 4y agoThey actually have the Akkuyu Nuclear Power Plant but I think it is not completed yet. However it was very close to the areas affected.
- amai 4y agoOMG! If something is a bad idea, Russia is not far away: "In May 2010, Russia and Turkey signed an agreement that a subsidiary of Rosatom would build, own, and operate a power plant at Akkuyu comprising four 1,200 MWe VVER1200 units." (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Akkuyu_Nuclear_Power_Plant https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Akkuyu_Nuclear_Power_Plant)
- kasabali 4y agoMetsamor plant checks that box since it's only 10 miles to the border: https://www.nationalgeographic.com/science/article/110412-most-dangerous-nuclear-plant-armenia https://www.nationalgeographic.com/science/article/110412-mo...