15 ms·
India’s government wants total control of the internet
- cleanchit 4y agoIt's available on odysee. https://odysee.com/@Archive:90/India-The-Modi-Question-S01E01:5 https://odysee.com/@Archive:90/India-The-Modi-Question-S01E0...
- daemoens 4y agoI think your comment may have given it the hug of death.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- 0xdeadbeef69 4y agoReminds me of 1984
- iamgopal 4y ago[flagged]
- jopsen 4y agoNo,
- msla 4y agoThis is the dark side of the same impulse that compels big tech companies to follow the GDPR even though they aren't headquartered in Europe: If a big enough market is run by an insane jackass, that insane jackassery will spread through the world on the wings of corporate policy. I really wonder what's going to happen when the India-China rivalry spreads to conflicting laws for tech companies that want to do business in both countries.
- shitlord 4y agoCompanies want to profit. They'll either be forced to follow different local laws in different locations, or they'll avoid the situation altogether. Microsoft chose the second approach and now Windows doesn't have flag emojis.
- smoldesu 4y agoCompanies do want to profit, but a lot of them (eg. Microsoft, Google, Amazon) draw the line somewhere. Many of those companies refuse to do business in China because their demands are too extreme. Other businesses that choose to operate in China are forced to lie to their customers and directly jeopardize their user's data. Look at iOS, which needs constant radical changes to comply with CCP demands. Be it changing the Taiwanese flag, moving domestic iCloud data into mainland China, or stopping protestors from using Aidrop effectively, Apple is is pretty much at their beck and call now. I think the better model is for companies to stand by their morals (even if they're weak) rather than bending to the unique tyrannical demands of each sovereign nation. Microsoft's choice here is honestly the most admirable to me, even though I despise them as a company.
- dctoedt 4y ago> Companies want to profit. Maybe tax the sh*t out of whatever profits they make in oppressive countries? "Go ahead and profit from dealing with Whateverstan, but we'll take most of it away from you."
- jaldhar 4y agoAnd then refund the taxes when the governments themselves make deals with the same oppressive countries?
- kneebonian 4y agoBased on what I've seen most tech companies are already pulling out of China or scaling back their presence so I don't think it will be a big deal.
- rushabh 4y agoYes there is increasing threat to freedom of speech, but India is not new to this. The left leaning Congress had even worse norms when they imposed martial law (Emergency). India has a robust sphere of public debate and draconian laws and acts of discrimination by the government are regularly criticised. In more cases than not the government embarrasses itself by its clumsy use of power to restrict opposition, like in the case of the BBC documentary which did not uncover anything new. Constant vigilance is required. I am not a BJP supporter, but I don't think the intent of the BJP is to suppress debate. They seek legitimacy. BJP is clearly toning down its more radical elements and is getting more mature judging by the way it allowed the Bharat Jodo Yatra (Join India Campaign) and understands that a robust opposition is in national interest. I am more hopeful than this article.
- supriyo-biswas 4y agoIt is useful to realize that either side is moved by the allure of power, and it's a fool's errand to justify the current situation with whataboutism - either instance was wrong.
- rushabh 4y agoI am not justifying the situation. I don't buy the overly negative prognosis.
- throwaway2056 4y ago> n't buy the overly negative prognosis. No one need to buy negative opinions or so but trying to suppress truly occurring issues is childish. One needs to be mature to accept criticism. Whether twitter or elsewhere... Again as a OCI, pointing out any issue is treated by this govt more as unpatriotic. (This strategy was successfully used by Bush/Trump to polarize the US). It is not good in the long term to do that. Again many of the complaints are not out of spite. It is truly from heart many have optimism and feel let down. This is even inside the Indian consulate - I once was told that visit us only if you want to give a positive vibe (when I politely asked them as they printed place of birth with typo). Note that US citizens complain about NSA spying, abortion rights etc. Given poor law/order people can disappear in India. Take citizens that are languishing in prison. Again US police are not perfect but there are due procedures in the DOJ-USA. And getting a driving license or registering a house in US/EU will not need bribes. Listening to complaints is the first step. One can politely disagree. By banning things they create a chilling effect. and please do not all the time compare to Congress govt. This is similar to blaming British. Yes, all that happened - just move on - NOW do good to current citizens. No point in having dirty beaches complaining about Congress or British.
- unpopularopp 4y agoWe already have "multiple Internets". See China, there is barely anything common ground between the services "we" use and China use.
- foverzar 4y agoTo be fair, it's not like people leave the western segment of the internet much, even when other national "internets" are not isolated from the rest of the network. Who has ever tried visiting any ru-net platforms, for example?
- somat 4y agoApplications of the internet are not the internet. However, more specifically, I don't think you can have more than one internet[1]. it is like the universe, by definition that is the whole thing[2]. The instant a network connects to the internet, it becomes part of the internet. 1. there are really two definitions of the internet. A. the set of networks that use the internet protocol. B. the sum of all interconnected networks. 2. But what about the multiverse? you loudly exclaim. Like I said by definition the universe is the whole thing. even once you expand your domain past it's original boundary the whole thing is still the universe. your original domain would now be considered a subverse.
- xyzelement 4y agoThis feels like a lot of effort to miss the point being made.
- gjsman-1000 4y agoThere's increasingly little ground between what the US uses and the EU uses, and will be even less ground over time as well. Is transferring EU Citizen Personally Identifiable Information to the US, in any capacity, even legal? Privacy Shield has been invalidated, the US passed the CLOUD Act, and GDPR is in force. Many experts say... it isn't, at all, it would just be chaotic if fully enforced. In 2 countries in Europe, Chromebooks have been ruled incompatible and schools have been prohibited from rolling them out under this rationale, with more countries likely to come with similar rulings. Just one example of the internet and tech splintering. EU also wants to do nonsense that would not fly in the US like Chat Control. What happens to US-based non-compliant services? Looks like some way of banning them needs to come next...
- CommanderData 4y agoThe documentary produced by the BBC "The Modi Question", was uploaded onto YouTube several times the week of release but taken down by request of the Indian Government. I was astonished a foreign entity can stop the world watching something if they don't like it, it wasn't just geo blocked it was removed off YouTube.
- garettmd 4y agoChina's done similar things, the most prominent I can think of being them bullying the NBA into policing what their players can say.
- dmix 4y agoAnd NBA franchise executives
- oaththrowaway 4y agoAnd reporters covering the situation (The Athletic)
- unpopularopp 4y agoBut it's on the iPlayer and works perfectly? So you can watch it in your own country https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/p0dkb144 https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/p0dkb144
- CommanderData 4y agoBBC iPlayer is restricted to UK residents only.
- iso1631 4y agoIt's quite sad, it's a generic "this video isn't allowed globally due to rights". That makes perfect sense when you're talking about last nights showing of Moanna, or even Eastenders (where background music in the pub might not be cleared for use outside the UK), but when it comes to a program like this you'd hope exceptions would be made.
- boh 4y agoThe main priority of "Big tech" is profitability not freedom. They're not "giving in" as much as they're following a business model to maximize revenue. Ultimately internet censorship will benefit the biggest companies who are able to keep up with the regulations. It will effectively grant them unofficial monopolies as smaller companies struggle to keep up.
- vijaybritto 4y agoIMO I dont think this is true. If that was the case then big tech wouldn't have closed shop in Russia for their crimes. Their morality is just conditional
- hef19898 4y agoOne word: sanctions. And breaking those is expensive in more than one way.
- supriyo-biswas 4y agoTheir morality is guided by the Overton window[1] of what most customers and employees find acceptable. Being based out of mostly western countries, corporations like Google and Microsoft found the belief system of quitting Russian business initiatives as most acceptable to the public, and hence executed that plan. A western worldview where it may have been more acceptable for Russia to initiate a war would have resulted in a different outcome. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Overton_window https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Overton_window
- foverzar 4y ago> big tech wouldn't have closed shop in Russia for their crimes Do you really believe big tech cared about some wArCrImEs, instead of getting a call from their lobbyist/investor/gov.account advising them to play along, or else? JFYI, YouTube (and the whole of Google) is still operational in Russia, I can still use my iPhone, pay for iCloud, and buy a new one as soon as I want. Business is business, I don't understand why people ever suppose it would be fighting for their political goals.
- 4y ago
- vijaybritto 4y agoI have learnt a very valuable lesson about my country's people at the face of the fascist govt. Caste affinity triumphs anything and everything. No matter how cruel the BJP is, their core vote bank which is the Upper caste population are not going to deviate away from them. The BJP has perfected formulas to win elections using hook or crook in every state now. Modi is going to do more fascist stuff and take away rights one after another. The supporters will keep inventing reasons every single time. It will always point to the caste order's interests
- rustedspoon 4y agoI’m not a bjp supporter by any chance, but this logic isn’t sound. if anything bjp wants to ignore the caste logic and combine all Hindu vote bank, I believe that’s how they won. Their religious arm even goes out and says this out loud that caste was only created after/during British colonization (true or not) and it didn’t exist in Vedas. They got 40 percent of the country’s vote in last election, do you mean 40 percent of the Country are upper caste Hindus and every single one of them voted for the bjp? Our current president from a scheduled tribe. Understanding bjp is the key to defeating them
- vijaybritto 4y agoI specifically mentioned that the upper castes are their 'core' vote bank and not their only vote bank. They have a large support from other castes now because Muslims are the enemies now. Until this narrative stays they will stay. This tribal president and the previous dalit president are exactly what I mean by their election winning formula. I'm not sure what's illogical in any of this because this is literally what they themselves speak about in every election meeting.
- gautamdivgi 4y agoUmmm - Modi is from one of the backward classes. Amit Shah is a Jain not Hindu upper caste. The president is a tribal woman. This whole upper caste bashing doesn’t reflect reality.
- 4y ago
- mc32 4y agoI don't think there is a way around this. Companies technologically focused or not have to comply with local regulations on a number of things: privacy, age restrictions, medical, gdpr, hipaa, etc. So you can't "just follow international norms" You have to follow local norms. In the West we had tech coordinate Covid, election and other information with government. But now the West is "uncomfortable" with others wanting to set their own narratives because we disagree with them for differing reasons. One is hard pressed to say one is right and the other is wrong. They are the same coin showing different sides.
- Hizonner 4y agoSure there is. Don't funnel everything through "companies". That was never how the Internet was supposed to work anyway.
- ushtaritk421 4y agoIf tyrannical localities want to enforce their norms, let them block it themselves.
- 2Gkashmiri 4y agoSomeone who has been on the receiving end of this, I can say that they are VERY persuasive. To a point they will lock you up for sedition,without trial for a decade and if you are really lucky, some stupid judge will be allowed to let you go on a planted technicality. I am not bragging but I've survived been charged with "waging war against India" whatever the hell that means and having my wits in the moment saved my sorry ass. Most are not so lucky. I am a dissenting voice that will keep dissenting. I've helped in various projects over the years in trying to "spread the voice" and its all I ever want to do. There is a war between me the person and the government and its just a matter of who wins. Let them try to control the internet, gfw is working but its not like its immune. I will find a way to make the voices heard. If it means someone Better than me has to chance the reins if I fall, well that's what we do.
- throawaw819 4y ago[flagged]
- oa335 4y agoWhat are your views on killing of Muslims in Kashmir? Gujarat? Randomly being lynched for eating hamburgers? Being expelled from their homes in Assam? Being barred from their schools in South India? Don’t post with a throwaway, at least have courage to voice your convictions like OP, who actually had to face down government oppression.
- 29athrowaway 4y agoWhy is that fuck still in power? It has been 9 years. We do not need another Putin or Xi.
- eunos 4y agoNon liberal populism is here to stay.
- throwaway2056 4y agoJust like conservatives/tory/UKIP from UK, the BJP have found way of blaming everyone else for issues. Of course, it works for a decade. Pretty sure once they have exhausted all cylinders, they will end up in same current UK situation. At the end if the majority (mostly boomers) that do not want change continue to do this it is saddening for the young. But of course, when it bites them it may be too late. Sad but democracy in function.
- 0xGod 4y agoNo it isn't.
- pasabagi 4y agoWildly popular, too. I'd love to hear somebody from India explain it: my guess is that religious politics and political religion have been India's problem from before the partition, and it's a fissure that Congress typically tried to ignore, while, rather awkwardly, it's been sticking its elephantine trunk in everybody's drinks while taking up eight tenths of the room. Modi drives straight at the problem, takes a position, then relies on the demographics to carry him through. There are more Hindus, so in a democracy, taking a Hindu-first perspective is sound electoral strategy.
- dartharva 4y agoIndian here. Simple answer is that there just isn't anyone left to stand against his behemoth of a party (BJP). The Congress/UPA's reputation was severely trampled out when BJP/NDA rose to power in 2014, and it hasn't recovered since. BJP has perfected the art of media manipulation and public politics, and is extremely competent in directing and subverting public sentiment; they are one of the biggest populist forces in the world right now with a formidable and highly-skilled marketing force backing its brand (enough to get featured on Harvard whitepapers). More importantly, they learn and adapt quickly to changing environments. For example, after the JNU fiasco they now seem to recognise the importance of moderation and avoid going gung-ho on dissent in practice (e.g. their prolonged tolerance to the Farm Law protests) while keeping a public image of firebrand rightism to maintain their brand. They are intelligent, very intelligent. Its opposition, meanwhile, has only gone downhill and keeps embarrassing itself. Opposition parties neither have a well-built plan or timeline, nor do they invoke any significant loyalty from voters. They keep infighting and bickering among themselves while retaining dynastic figureheads from an already disgraced family. They're all so in on themselves they still try to use the same half-baked strategies that used to work in the 2000s.
- tayistay 4y agoWell, in response, the US govt could (in theory) break up YouTube into YouTube and YouTube India, thus freeing the US version from foreign influence. Perhaps this is another reason why companies shouldn't be allowed to get so big.
- 542458 4y agoI appreciate the thought behind this, but I don’t see how it would work when India would not saddle their own social media with the same antitrust restrictions. Imagine the Indian equivalent to TikTok or whatever, which would be (by virtue of being huge and having better network effects) competing against a field of weaker American competitors. You could of course ban the foreign product, but that feels like we’d just be trading one type of censorship for another. Also, I suspect the US likes a monolithic YouTube from a “iPod diplomacy” perspective - being the cultural centre of the world is an advantage!
- tayistay 4y agoHistorically, breaking up large companies has been good for innovation (AT&T for example) so I wouldn't assume a field of weaker American competitors, but I'll grant that perhaps social media has network effects that make for a different dynamic.
- throawaw819 4y ago[flagged]
- yourapostasy 4y agoThis goes beyond "just" social content, other types of data are also involved. I don't understand this policy direction. In the cases I've been personally involved with, it added significant costs to comply to move processing and storage onto Indian territory data centers that are run by large US corporate cloud vendors anyways. If you're large enough, it doesn't matter. If your use case serves a small enough long tail where it ends up on the wrong side of that added cost burden cutoff, then it matters. And I think that is unfortunate, because I see lots of Indian innovation happening inside that long tail, and such restrictions disadvantage the smaller scale efforts where the novel propositions seem particularly rich. But perhaps I simply don't have sufficient data and perspective, so I'd welcome Indians closer to the action to help me understand why this is in India's interests. If I had to guess, I suspect the thinking is similar to China's: it is too strategic an area to give up, and India has enough population where it doesn't matter they are ring fenced into a walled garden as "only" the domestic market is big enough to stand within its own island market.
- heywherelogingo 4y agoI'd suggest governments generally want total control of everything, and in the digital age they see they might finally get it.
- klibertp 4y agoYes. The IT revolution that promised equal access to all of the world's information was first ignored and we - tech people - were left alone, to dream of our tech-crypto-quantum utopia. Then normal people joined, transforming the Internet into a loaded gun strapped to societies' collective heads. Efficient, personal channel of communication straight into people's brains (almost) - not weaponizing it was never an option. It didn't take long at all for someone to realize it and start pulling the trigger.
- relavir212 4y agoI think this government does not have problem with criticism, but opposition is doing very bad job of criticism itself. It fails to present proper solution/ better approach on things that matters to national security, policy and way forward for country and people dont appreciate such cynical thinking anymore. strawman arguments on high moral ground will not work after a while. As for BBC "The Modi Question", comes from wrong place itself. India has left that issue long ago, but internal and external forces who doesn't much on Modi in politics plays same card again and again. Few videos I found to their narrative - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bkVQ4RNxBB4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bkVQ4RNxBB4 Truth about Godhra 2002 riot https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Dcn4Yv-dR-Q https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Dcn4Yv-dR-Q https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eUI1Cc0gkcU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eUI1Cc0gkcU PS: Author AKASH BANERJEE is well know youtuber who extreme leftist. India's are not interested in people who cant represent them anymore. We lack centrist government / opposition.
- selfhoster69 4y ago> I think this government does not have problem with criticism > but internal and external forces who doesn't much on Modi in politics plays same card again and again. Is the BJP's "IT cell" spreading propaganda on HN now too? EDIT: totally wrote that without checking out parent's profile > user: relavir212 > created: 16 minutes ago
- throwawayxx123 4y agoI don't know why the parent is being down voted. Modi has not been found guilty. He was cleared of all charges by the Supreme Court of India after multiple scrutiny. As an Indian I have full faith in the Indian system of checks and balances. I am not even a huge Modi fan, and haven't voted for him, but I have to say these things.
- dddnzzz334 4y agoIf the government doesn't have problem with criticism, why do they censor people left and right and impose the draconian UAPA on any media which criticizes them? Your linked videos are quite literally propaganda pieces by a well-known propaganda channel. >Akash Banerjee is a leftist. He isn't.
- throwaway2056 4y agoI once saw a former Swiss president answer to question about US gun problem (especially schools). He just answered, well if the majority decide do that then... it is your problem. Not ours. Same here. If Indians, split from Internet - and if the majority (perhaps boomers etc), decide it is the right decision - may be OK - but likely they will lose in the long term - in terms of education, awareness, global participation etc. In some ways, top Indian MNC can benefit from talent not leaving India. Sure some will say, we have our own space program, etc - but lets be honest - it will take decades to even build a new operating system. Cooperation in science, tech benefits all humanity.
- dartharva 4y agoBoomers are in no way the majority in India. Its median age is 27.
- MPlus88 4y agoIndia has A LOT of skeletons in its closet that most people, not even Indians themselves know. Outsiders' image of India is through the narrative of the media, which has no connection to reality. The Indian government is also actively engaging in fake news dissemination. Here is a tweet from Michael Kugelman, South Asia Institute Director of The Wilson Center and writer of Foreign Policy's weekly South Asia Brief Michael Kugelman on Twitter: "The scale and duration of the EU/UN-centered Indian disinformation campaign exposed by @DisinfoEU is staggering. Imagine how the world would be reacting if this were, say, a Russian or Chinese operation." / Twitter
- throwawayxx123 4y agoWhat about the disinformation and misinformation campaigns by the USA?
- yutijke 4y agoThe Indian people want the government to have total control over the internet. You feel that's horrible? Sure, that's your right. But the moral universalism of the anglophone cultural sphere has long alienated a majority of Indians exposed to it, that at this point their opinions do not get any goodwill from Indians. Progressive media has published enough news that run absolutely opposite to the lived experience of a majority of the Indians that at this point they don't give a crap. I would even say that every report of far-right authoritarianism of Modu's India liberal media publishes, greater the support for Modi from Indians. I say this as someone who thinks of him as an absolutely mediocre administrator. It seems to be a common issue among liberal anglophones to confuse democracy with liberal democracy.
- hulitu 4y ago> The Indian people want the government to have total control over the internet. > You feel that's horrible? Sure, that's your right Of course it is horrible. Thanks to the free internet (Google, Apple, Microsoft, Facebook) we can further promote our interests. Sincerely, the NSA /s
- albertopv 4y agoAn illiberal democracy can't be a true democracy. If power can control what news and data you get, showing only positive ones, you won't really be able to judge their administration skills. If so, elections will be unjust and unfair. Countries like India and Turkey can't be really considered as true democracies at the moment, people have no more power over their governments.
- throwawayxx123 4y agoIndia is okay. We have better democracy than both UK and USA.
- davoneus 4y agoHell, India's democracy damn well should be; it had a chance to learn from the US and others mistakes. That said, Indian democracy is a pale imitation to post WW2 European democracies.
- Slava_Propanei 4y ago[dead]
- known 4y ago[dead]