7 ms·
The Toll of Layoff Anxiety
- haswell 4y agoI had just started working at a large financial services company shortly before the financial meltdown in '07-08. Leadership held an all-hands meeting letting people know that layoffs were coming, and the VP of each person's respective area would walk over to their desk to inform them personally. On the day of the layoffs, you could feel the stress in the air. Not much smiling, except the forced kind after someone tries to break the tension with a joke. And then, a door at the end of a row of cubes opens and your VP walks into the area. Everyone wonders if they're the one (they've been wondering since they learned of the layoff, but something changes when the agent of termination literally walks through the door). She walks down your row, nearing your desk, and your heart starts pounding. She keeps walking, and you breathe a sigh of relief. You peek over the edge of your cube to see her talking to Joe, and a few minutes later he is escorted from the premises. A few minutes later, she walks into the area again, and the cycle of stress repeats. I survived the cut, but the experience still sits with me. I don't remember much about any specific day during my next half-decade there, but I remember that day like it was yesterday. I know some of the recent layoffs have been handled terribly, but I never again want to be sitting in my cube, wondering if I'm next every time the door down the hallway opens.
- jobs_throwaway 4y agoJesus, what a terrible and needlessly stressful way to let people know
- lr4444lr 4y agoThe "escorting" strikes me as the worst part. I understand completely if the person is being fired under bad terms. But laid off? That just undermines everything: "Hey, Joe. You've done great work here, and you know that it's just the nature of the business that your unit simply can't be supported. It pains me so much to have to do this, and we hope you'll keep us in mind when things turn around: we'd hire you back in a second. Also, I don't entirely trust that you're decent enough to exit with dignity and not to go ape ** and destroy/vandalize/steal valuable company property. Good luck out there ... as soon as you leave the premises, that is."
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- cube00 4y agoBy the sounds of this they just wanted to be as needlessly cruel as possible to strike fear into those left behind to work even harder. There are so many other ways to handle this that will retain the employee's dignity but still mitigate any risk they might kick off.
- VagueMag 4y agoFor my recent layoff from a 100% remote role at a well known BigTech co, I was in the midst of a meeting and was abruptly signed out of my laptop and presented with a screen saying it had been frozen and prompting for a 6 digit passcode to unlock it. I had no idea what was going on and began calling IT support to get back in so I could let coworkers on my team know I was completely unable to do anything. They evidently hadn't been informed either as they actually gave me the passcode! I put two and two together when I got back in and was still locked out of everything, and a friend in a personal non-work Slack @'d me with the headline that my company was doing layoffs.
- techbozo 4y agothat is completely nuts and unsurprising
- ryandrake 4y agoThere are so many better ways to do layoffs, you have to assume they pick the cruel ways on purpose. It's not like these companies are inventing layoffs and figuring out on their own how to do it.
- xdfgh1112 4y agoSounds like you are better off not working for that company.
- bobosha 4y agoYour description couldn't help but remind me of this fantastic movie Margin Call https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zn2Xf9hAFcE&ab_channel=Weyland https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zn2Xf9hAFcE&ab_channel=Weyla...
- sircastor 4y agoI thought of that immediately. And of Spacey’s character congratulating the remaining folks because you need to somehow rebuild morale.
- nytesky 4y agoSo Stanley’s characters was walking out with a USB drive of d@mining evidence about the coming collapse of the company? It may not have been proprietary, but it does speak to why they walk people out under guard. Maybe he had good intent, as proven by how he handed it to his staff to look at in the elevator, but if that staff hadn’t stopped to thank him, that USB data would be in the wind.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- barbazoo 4y agoThat sounds so stressful. Not long ago the tech company I work at announced layoffs and for everyone to expect an email with whether they've been laid off or not. Most stressful 15 minutes of my whole career.
- xdfgh1112 4y agoHow is it that people are on insane salaries like $200-300k but are still terrified of being fired? Don't you have savings? In from the UK and earn about a quarter as much and I could be unemployed for several years before I had to start caring. I'm not trying to brag. My salary is shit compared to the US. Just genuinely curious.
- aaomidi 4y agoHealthcare. Mortgages.
- jedberg 4y ago> In from the UK and earn about a quarter as much and I could be unemployed for several years before I had to start caring. Luckily you live in a still mostly civilized society, where you don't lose your health care when you lose your job, and you have a decent welfare program so you don't lose your house and can still eat. We don't have that here. Also, in the Bay Area, $300K will barely get you by if you bought a house in the last five years.
- swatcoder 4y agoThose salaries are a new experience to a lot of people. In some cases, because they came out of school into them and have little experience with financial management in the first place, and in other cases because the prior benchmark for tech industry was like 30-50% of that until fairly recent (and remains that way at many US tech companies). And like with a lot of "new money" experiences, the answer to your question is: no. You get excited to taste a luxury lifestyle and get carried away buying an dangerously expensive house because it fits your Peleton and your bank says you're good for it. With this being your first time through a tech boom, you didn't believe the old cynics telling you there was a second act coming. But now you might get laid off and have $15,000 per month in bills to pay lest that house go back to the bank. It's an understandable story, and a tragic one. :(
- haswell 4y agoPeople come from a myriad of circumstances. In addition to the other responses, two major factors for me: 1. At the time, I wasn’t making anywhere close to that salary. The tech job market in my region at the time didn’t pay anywhere close to SV salaries, and even less as someone working tech at a non-tech company. 2. I only had a few years of decent earnings at that point, and was funneling most extra funds into debt. Having enough savings to quit for a few years is amazing, but a privilege that few people have.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- emodendroket 4y agoYou know, I wonder with a lot of these processes if it's not deliberately anxiety-provoking or cruel "pour encourager les autres."
- kodah 4y agoThere's a famous statistic from 2008 in the US that said something along the lines of, for every 1% of unemployment there were 40,000 suicides. That makes unemployment almost as deadly as coronavirus. I don't believe that statistic has changed.
- Waterluvian 4y agoI wonder how the quality of social support systems affects this statistic. That is: perhaps unemployment isn’t the cause, but financial peril is. And maybe half-decent social systems that mitigate financial peril in the face of unemployment could have an effect.
- barrkel 4y agoI would say it's less likely to be financial peril (though no doubt that plays a part, especially when e.g. health insurance is required for some expensive treatment), and more likely when a person identifies too much with their job. If you identify too much with your job, losing it is an attack on your ego and it damages your sense of who you are. It's like you died; the role you played in a whole network of social relations is gone. Your status and importance, if you mentally invested yourself in it, is diminished, possibly to irrelevance. You're a nobody. I think this kind of mindset can push someone over the edge.
- RA_Fisher 4y agoBoth are unfortunately very deadly and there’s a lot of societal value in preventing both (without inducing more costly trade offs). Covid appears to be killing at a rate of 138,000 per year in just the United States.
- Swizec 4y ago> for every 1% of unemployment there were 40,000 suicides I guess then it’s a good thing that USA is seeing some of the lowest unemployment rates in decades. Unemployment hasn’t been this low since 1969[1]. Even the tech sector where we’re seeing layoffs is doing pretty well. Tech unemployment rate is estimated at 1.8% for January 2023 [2] [1] https://tradingeconomics.com/united-states/unemployment-rate https://tradingeconomics.com/united-states/unemployment-rate [2] https://www.usatoday.com/story/money/economy/2023/02/07/tech-layoffs-2023-google-amazon/11135692002/ https://www.usatoday.com/story/money/economy/2023/02/07/tech...
- jobs_throwaway 4y agoI was at dinner with friends last night, and among the 6 of us, 5 of our employers had done layoffs in the last few weeks, and the 6th's employer has been talking about it. Certainly anecdotal but it was extremely jarring I don't feel particularly worried about my job, but multiple people at the table reported extreme anxiety over the layoffs, and I imagine that's more often than not the case
- osigurdson 4y agoSoftware has always been boom/bust. This is why people should not get into it unless they are really passionate about it.
- nradov 4y agoYou could say that about almost any industry except for government and healthcare. There's nothing special about software.
- ThalesX 4y agoI worked for a company heavily into government contracts and got into a tight squeeze. They had two rounds of layoffs in two years. Both on a Friday. The first one was crazy, no one knew anything, and suddenly you saw people crying in the hallways. By mid-day, the news spread that the company is doing layoffs. The team I was in went to lunch, and we all toasted a glass of whiskey, expecting to lose some folks. Luckily we didn't. The following year, the same thing happened; suddenly, people getting laid off. We called it Black Friday. We went for whiskey again. No one got laid off. We were lucky to be working on a strategic project. Still, the affected people in the hallways were definitely something I'll remember. The company is doing very bad now. What was once our manager is now scraping by, doing database administration and fixing some bugs, as he's the only one left from our former team, and there's a government obligation to keep the system running. He stayed because he has stocks in the company that have plummeted, but he's still hopeful. He sometimes asks for our help, even after a decade, and sometimes we hop on and help him with something for the sake of old times.
- xyzelement 4y agoIn my experience, anxiety is something you have. Layoffs give it a convenient focus but it doesn't have to be that way. I used to work at a hedge fund that basically screened for mental health during hiring. When we had layoffs, nobody freaked out. We knew we had a good run, we knew severance was good and we knew we'd be highly desirable in the market. So we metabolized the layoffs and went on with our lives. My job after that was at a scale up that leaned woke (a lot of employees were sold a tenuous connection between our work and a feel good mission). When layoffs happened, it was basically an all out mental health crisis, with everyone feeding into everyone else's anxiety. The facts weren't that different than at the hedge fund but the amount of angst and freaking out was through the roof. Now at a FAANG, obviously had layoffs recently. The emotional vibe is somewhere between the two above. Coworkers that came from tougher places (finance, Microsoft, Amazon) are holding it together fine. Others are not. I once heard the analogy of an orange. When you squeeze an orange, orange juice comes out because that's what an orange is made off. If extreme anxiety comes out when you are squeezed, it was there all along.
- swatcoder 4y agoOkay, but when you hire a few hundred thousand people into a booming industry and promise them unprecedented compensation, you’ll probably end up with at least a couple oranges in there. Maybe even a lot. Can we offer them some understanding and sympathy?
- renewiltord 4y agoIs it understanding or indulgence?
- DiggyJohnson 4y agoMust there be some token sympathy shown in any sort of analysis on this topic? Anyways > promise them unprecedented compensation They were promised and received uncompensated compensation. No promises of indefinite employment were ever given, and it’s a bit naive to assume boom times never end. I think it’s fair to make this point too, even if on an individual level I sympathize with pretty much anyone that loses their job.
- newaccount2021 4y ago[dead]
- RajT88 4y agoI've been waiting to discover whether or not I'm getting laid off (probably not, my M2 tells me). But anyways, yeah I'm at a big tech company going through rounds of layoffs. I'm at a good point where I'm wrapping a bunch of stuff up. So I've been trying to make sure I tie up all loose ends and make sure, if the axe lands on my neck, that my colleagues can pick up everything where I left off. After round one, it wasn't the anxiety (I'm in a good spot, companies are hungry to poach from tech companies like mine; I'll land on my feet), it was the lack of will to really work too terribly hard until I knew that I'd be sticking around. I still don't know. So I'm not working overly hard of late. I have started to see people I know get the axe though, and that has an effect on you. I'm only working hard on wrap-up activities, and turning down new big stuff. Congrats (Big Company), you played yourself. Want to keep morale up? Don't hire a shit ton of people, and then fire a shit ton of people a few months later.
- grioghar 4y agoSurvivor’s Guilt and a compulsive need to justify my continued existence in the role, coupled with sheer terror of losing my income, my home, and all the auxiliary benefits thereof have made me NEED to be seen by management. My code commits are up, my bug finds are significantly higher, and I’ve taken on educational and sales initiatives to drive adoption and revenue in much bigger ways. I was a poor Welfare kid who never had any idea about seeing the money I have in tech. Now, even though I’ve got 6 months of savings and skills that I’m sure will land me just fine, I’m pushing harder after watching a 25% layoff happen and seemingly more low-profile layoffs and reorganization. It weird the first time you get paid a SV compensation, but live in the Midwest, making your income stretch, saving, and getting a few nice things: there’s still that inner poor kid who isn’t sure where the next meal’s coming from, or if you’d be able to pay for vehicle repairs or get your kids’ braces taken care of; all things that seemed unimaginable just five years back working IT regionally. There’s the underlying fear that it’s all going to go away and you’ll be back to paycheck-to-paycheck after learning life doesn’t have to be that way. That’s what keeps me motivated; I cha fed my stars, and I’m looking to make sure I keep them changed and give my kids a life I couldn’t have fathomed. So, I push harder and work even more to make sure my place at the table is either secured, or a great portfolio to have on hand to show the next place. I can’t tell if this is noble or pathological, but I know I’m stretched thin emotionally and am not sleeping because of it. Here it is 3AM, the soul’s midnight, and I’m thinking about a few projects I still need to do initial commits on and start some regression testing… Bah. Tomorrow…er, later today, right? And on my weekend even. Definitely pathological.
- emodendroket 4y agoI got hit with the layoff hammer and then managed to just squeak in to a different assignment. Having it happen once made me a lot more zen about it.
- fsckboy 4y agolosing your job sucks, and anxiety sucks and is draining and deleterious. But the solution is building a society where the citizens are resilient against such strains, not a society where people are guaranteed not to lose their jobs or a society where certain jobs are coveted because they are sinecures as we see in all govt jobs everywhere but which particularly made a splash recently with the civil service exam cheating in India. All the effort that goes into clawing your way through that system would be much better spent on productive jobs. I'm not offering a solution, but trying to point at the problem and create awareness that pure job security in exchange for nothing is a pipedream like getting in shape without working out. Locking down a job so you can be secure discourages hiring in the first place and encourages economic sclerosis.
- brianjking 4y agoYes, yes, yes. All of this. My anxiety has been sky-high - nothing like being shocked out of sleep at 4:50 am when your alarm doesn't even go off till six most days.
- spike021 4y agoMy smaller company had a layoff and since I just joined back late last year plus am feeling slower than usual I feel more anxious about things if we do another wave of layoffs eventually. Doesn't help matters since I'm trying my best already and having that hanging over me is not helpful.