8 ms·
Copyright King: Why the "I Have a Dream" Speech Still Isn't Free
- ck2 15y agoI slightly corrected the title as Sony bought part of the EMI Group, not the other way around. Sorry if it makes less sense now but the article is a worthy read. In a nutshell, you won't be able to watch the video for free until 2038 in the USA
- scq 15y agoAnd that's if they don't keep extending the copyright term.
- brudgers 15y agoUnsurprisingly, my public library has a copy. For twenty bucks you can donate a copy to yours.
- ck2 15y agoIt's also on Netflix but not Instant Watch http://movies.netflix.com/Movie/Martin-Luther-King-Jr-I-Have-a-Dream/70031442 http://movies.netflix.com/Movie/Martin-Luther-King-Jr-I-Have...
- twodayslate 15y agoHow can you copyright that? If it is, it should be under creative commons.
- sp332 15y agoIn the USA (and most other jurisdictions, really) as soon as you write it down, you have the copyright on it. You also have some control over "derivative works" including any copies of the "performance" of the speech. In music, for example, you would need to pay royalties to the songwriter for publicly playing a recording of their song, no matter who actually sang the song.
- ck2 15y agoI'm kind of surprised congress didn't try to retroactively copyright the Declaration of Independence and Gettysburg Address and force textbook publishers to pay royalties.
- sp332 15y agoThose were works made by the government, so they're automatically in the public domain. I don't see why you're against Mr. King having the copyright on the speech he wrote and gave?
- ck2 15y agoMLK said those words to move governments and their people, to everyone and anyone that would listen. Some things are too important to lock down and copyright, at least not until 2038.
- anamax 15y agoWith copyright, he/his heirs get to decide how it can be used, such as selling Coke. (They didn't have to decide "sell Coke".) > Some things are too important to lock down and copyright, at least not until 2038. And the copyright law language embodying that principle is?
- henrikschroder 15y agoIt doesn't exist in copyright law, but may be it should? If enough people think it should be, we can write it down and make it law.
- anamax 15y agoI was unclear. I wasn't asking for an existing law that implements your idea. I was asking for language that does. > If enough people think it should be, we can write it down and make it law. Oh really? If enough people think that pi should be 3, can we pass a law and it will be so? There are lots of things that people want that can't be codified with the desired properties. This is something that looks (to me) to be on the edge. How about some other examples? (If it's just "I have a dream", we can pass specific legislation.)
- spacemanaki 15y agoWell, the article actually explains how it was copyrighted. Basically the King estate sued CBS and the court determined they had a claim. "Typically, a speech broadcast to a large audience on radio and television (and considered instrumental in historic political changes and ranked as the most important speech in 20th century American history) would seem to be a prime candidate for the public domain ..... the judge determined that the speech was a performance distributed to the news media and not the public, making it a “limited” as opposed to a “general” publication. That meant the speech, like other “performances” on CBS, was not in the public domain. That meant the King estate had the right to claim copyright" This is relatively readable: http://www.ca11.uscourts.gov/opinions/ops/19989079.MAN.pdf http://www.ca11.uscourts.gov/opinions/ops/19989079.MAN.pdf
- Maro 15y agoSo it really started with Martin Luther King's descendants disgracing his heritage.
- arethuza 15y agoNot really, according to the article: "But the copyright dilemma began in December 1963, when King sued Mister Maestro, Inc., and Twentieth Century Fox Records Company to stop the unauthorized sale of records of the 17-minute oration."
- ck2 15y agoThere is a difference in going to court to protect it from being misused and sold without his consent to trying to lock it away so it can be a profit making item.
- rdtsc 15y agoIt is a case of going overboard. Initially they didn't care probably. But then they saw someone making money off it. So they didn't just go and stop that particular instance but went further and made sure nobody would be able to do it. They saw how money could be made from it, and decided they should be the ones profiting from it.
- riffic 15y agoCreative Commons didn't exist in the 1960s
- godDLL 15y agoI think this is the first time I see YouTube embeds used this way. The article contains several of them -- non-functional and displaying a "removed due to third party copyright claim" message -- all to drive the article's point.
- VMG 15y agoI can still see the alcatel ad in germany
- burgerbrain 15y ago"Alcatel aired an ad with an excerpt of “I Have a Dream,” which it licensed from the King family for an undisclosed sum." They made money off of that one.
- Create 15y ago"I Have A Dream" is nothing compared to the Riverside speech, and its anniversary. https://www.democracynow.org/2008/1/21/dr_martin_luther_king_jr_1929 https://www.democracynow.org/2008/1/21/dr_martin_luther_king...
- ck2 15y agoTime magazine called the speech "demagogic slander that sounded like a script for Radio Hanoi," Yikes. He really was a progressive leader. Makes you wonder in perspective how we are going to someday see people for supporting Gitmo or giving gays "some rights" but not all rights.
- spodek 15y agoMedia today always talk about King's work on civil rights and equality work and show "I Have A Dream" footage and talk about his assassination. They don't show the five years between, despite his greater experience, awareness, and maturity. In those years he took on greater issues of a system that created so much poverty and created war. I think they don't cover those years because those issues remain and would force them to take on current issues they don't want to. Since his earlier work is better publicized, I find learning about his later work teach me more about him, his work, those issues, and leadership. The Riverside Church speech against the war in Vietnam was an incredibly courageous speech I consider right on, displaying mastery of the issues, his audience, oratory, ... basically every element of leadership.
- Chris_Newton 15y ago> Makes you wonder in perspective how we are going to someday see people for supporting Gitmo or giving gays "some rights" but not all rights. I think most of us know the answer to that question. Sadly, history will also record that the ruling class of our age often acted to benefit their own self-serving interests, just like the ruling class of every age before us. We call them politicians and corporate executives rather than royalty and nobility, and we call ourselves middle class or working class rather than serfs or slaves, but the balance of power isn't so very different when you get right down to it. The really insidious thing about our age, though, is that a significant fraction of the injustices are impersonal. People become victims of the The System, where no individual has ever personally chosen to harm them, yet harmed they are all the same. Even if the rich and powerful want to change The System for the better, it can be difficult for them to do so because of perceived consequences in terms of social norms or political fall-out. That in turn is partly because of the mistrust that has built up between the working classes and the ruling class, and the resulting apathy among (in a democratic set-up) the voters. The remarkable thing about people like Martin Luther King and Rosa Parks was that they stood up and followed their beliefs despite the risks. That is why they are remembered as heroes. It's a shame that The System today has evolved, probably inadvertently, so that it's almost impossible for such heroes ever to reach positions of real power now. Blame it on the political machine, the military-industrial complex, media empires, or whatever you like; they're just different sides of the same problem. Perhaps one day, history will record that a real leader did make it to the top against the odds, and they made statements of substance and honesty, and they adopted policies of justice and fairness, and they fought for causes worth fighting for, and that was when the damage of the past few years started to be undone. We can but hope.
- brudgers 15y agoDr. King was not a public official and was not giving testimony. His speech is no more a candidate for the public domain than the Beach Boys' Fourth of July, 1980 rendition of Barbara Ann on the National Mall is.
- ck2 15y agoA reasonable argument. But 2038? What about taking the artists original intentions and desires in mind? Would MLK want people to pay $20 to watch his speech?
- sp332 15y ago"Intentions" don't mean much if they're not in writing. MLK could have put the speech under a freer license if he wanted to.
- chadmalik 15y agoI think that comment just about sums up the absurdity of the entire "intellectual property" regime. A leftist crusader for equality and advancement of humanity who risked and gave his life in the service now has a bunch of corporate leeches jealously guarding access to and profiting from his most famous speech. I shudder to think what world culture would look like if the intellectual property regime as it now stands were in place from the beginning of recorded history.
- thesteamboat 15y agoWhat freer licenses existed in 1963?
- sp332 15y agoYou really don't need a pre-made license, like one of the Creative Commons licenses. Just grant the use of the speech and recordings of the speech for any purpose. Or make the text of the speech free for noncommercial use.
- 15y ago
- spodek 15y agoThe article mostly covers the relevant law and how the copyright ownership has evolved. I kept thinking about what we could do now. I doubt the copyright owner thinks about copyright laws like we do -- freedom, culture evolving, etc. Other posts on this thread say "Martin Luther King's descendants ... are disgracing the man's heritage," they probably don't know our perspective. They haven't read The Right to Read -- http://www.gnu.org/philosophy/right-to-read.html http://www.gnu.org/philosophy/right-to-read.html. They probably intend to keep others from messing it up. Instead of insulting them, we might try to educate them on our perspective and see if they might be persuaded to release it under the GPL or something similar. If Sony has it, they may be unwilling to change, but maybe the family? If an inflexible conglomerate already has it, what can we learn from them about getting the owners of rights to culturally important copyrighted works first? There are more of us. Why did they get there first? How can we do better next time? I want copyright law changed, but in the meantime, this work and many like it could be GPL'ed. Why don't we make that happen?
- JS_startup 15y agoMLK's descendants have turned his speech and legacy into a commodity, sued each other, stolen money from his estate and setup businesses solely for capitalizing on the speech. Something tells me they would not be interested in releasing the speech under the GPL.
- Newgy 15y agoYeah, MLK's family has been unusually greedy. They even used copyright to demand money during the building of the MLK Memorial! http://savannahnow.com/stories/102501/LOCmlkmemory.shtml http://savannahnow.com/stories/102501/LOCmlkmemory.shtml
- jonnathanson 15y agoFWIW, King's speech contains close to 40% repurposed or borrowed material (from the Declaration of Independence, the song "My Country 'Tis of Thee," cribs from previous speeches by Archibald Carey, etc.). I say this not to diminish the accomplishment, triumph, or historical significance of Dr. King's famous speech, but rather, to raise the point that it's a very nuanced copyright matter. Am I allowed to copyright a work derived from a collage of other people's works? If I incorporated one of your posts into a blog post of mine, could I copyright the entirety of the blog post? According to the letter of the law, King's estate should have been entitled only to copyright the portions of the "I Have a Dream" speech that contained 100% original material [1]. Yet these are not the most recognizable or famous portions of the speech, and they're not the portions King's estate has often licensed out to advertisers, etc. Almost all of the words most famously associated with the "I Have a Dream" speech are borrowed from other source material. And, unless I'm missing something -- I'm not a lawyer, so that's possible -- they should not have been granted to King's estate in the first place. Perhaps the current laws on the books took effect after that granting? [1]From 17 U.S.C. SS 103(b): "The copyright in a compilation or derivative work extends only to the material contributed by the author of such work, as distinguished from the preexisting material employed in the work, and does not imply any exclusive right in the preexisting material. The copyright in such work is independent of, and does not affect or enlarge the scope, duration, ownership, or subsistence of, any copyright protection in the preexisting material."
- brudgers 15y agoThe author's argument appears to be that Dr. King's speech is too important to be protected by copyright. The author provides very little to support this position other than an appeal to emotion. Lacking support with relevant facts, details, and rationales, the argument is, for me, entirely unpersuasive. Although I am certainly not an expert on the history of Civil Rights in the 1960's, I was curious as to who Bill Rutherford was and what he did. Before I found much I came across the source from which the author lifted: >“I think Martin Luther King must be spinning in his grave,” Bill Rutherford, who was executive director of the Southern Christian Leadership Conference when King was murdered, told 60 Minutes. “He gave his life for his ideas of justice, peace and love. He attempted his entire life to communicate ideas for free. To communicate, not to sell,” he says. http://www.cbsnews.com/2100-18560_162-319500.html http://www.cbsnews.com/2100-18560_162-319500.html
- brown9-2 15y agoI don't get it - what facts and details can someone supply to make the argument that this speech is very important to the public and to history? What about mentioning how often the speech is cited, how common place phrases from it are, etc.?
- monochromatic 15y agoNobody's disputing that it's important to the public and to history. The point of contention is whether that implies that it should be un-copyrightable. I'm with brudgers--nothing in this article gives any justification for that proposition.
- Silhouette 15y agoI think you're both begging the implied question: why should this work be protected? Regardless of the importance issue, we are discussing a speech given by one man nearly half a century ago to a huge audience in a public place. Today, that speech has somehow become the intellectual property of Sony. As the relevant jurisdiction here is the US, we can ask directly what the Constitution has to say about this: "To promote the Progress of Science and useful Arts, by securing for limited Times to Authors and Inventors the exclusive Right to their respective Writings and Discoveries." I fail to see how 1. the above situation promotes the progress of science or useful arts, 2. Sony is the author or inventor of this work, or 3. protection that lasts longer than the average human lifetime is limited in any meaningful way. After three strikes, I think you're supposed to be out.
- tpatke 15y agoMakes me wonder how may of Apple's Think Different personalities were paid for their "endorsement". [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Think_Different http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Think_Different
- snowwrestler 15y agoI would bet a lot of money that every single one of those photos and video clips was properly licensed by Apple. It's not even that complicated a commercial for that sort of thing--compare to the first iPhone ad, which probably had 2-3 times as many copyrighted clips: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8nyYloJyq9M http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8nyYloJyq9M
- e28eta 15y agoI just finished reading the Jobs biography, and I believe you're correct. Isaacson writes about Steve personally calling the editor in chief of Time Inc to get the famous picture of Gandhi which isn't available for commercial use, and meeting with Yoko Ono to get the pic of Lennon.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- bh42222 15y ago>It's amazing how the majority of our history is downright whitewashed. The more you look into something, the more you see a completly different story. No you don't. People are complicated. Everyone thinks and says things they would never say to lots of other people. That does not make you a different person. It just makes you normal. Like everyone he could be angry, emotional, etc. But as long as you act consistently, you are what you do. The stupid shit you occasionally say in private does not make you "different".
- powertower 15y agoI've deleted my post as it won't do anything except get downvotes, but I do agree with what you are saying. I'd imagine that all great man have had a private life that's colorful, to say the least. But at some point your personal and private conduct does being to reflect on your character, as true character is consistent (as you said), whether you're in front of a group of people or are in the bathroom by yourself. Otherwise, it's more of a persona than anything else.
- rthomas6 15y agoDoes this mean that one could be convicted of a felony under SOPA/PIPA if they posted a video of the speech online?
- billpatrianakos 15y agoThis is interesting on a number of levels. I'm part of the minority around here that is in favor of copyright but don't write me off as a knee-jerk reaction to my stance. An article like this could easily become a rallying cry for abolishing copyright but when you dig deeper it really doesn't lend itself to total copyright abolishment as much as you'd think. It's interesting when you bear in mind that Dr. Martin Luther King held copyright on this speech and used the copyright laws to control how his speech was used. The way he wielded the power afforded to him by copyright is a great argument for copyright, not against it! If we make some conservative assumptions based on his actions and what we know of the man then it's safe to say he would allow the speech to become part of PBS documentaries but not used in corporate advertisements. Isnt it fair to believe that most of us these days would agree that his Dream speech be used in historical documentaries and other works that promote his legacy but be upset if we saw that speech used in a Nike commercial? What I'm getting at here is that copyright itself isn't bad. It's how it is used that can be harmful but not always. Using copyright to keep MLK's legacy from being sullied is a legitimate and reasonable use for copyright. This particular case reminds us that copyright can be used for good too. If we fast forward to today and consider the King estate's attempt to make money from Dr. King's legacy we see what I'd call a gray area. Not everyone would want to see money being made in MLK's name. But far more people don't want to see the right to his words and likeness belonging to a corporation like EMI. I want to encourage all of us to take a less extreme, more balanced perspective on this. Laws like SOPA/PIPA have backed us into a corner where we're forced to take extreme positions against extreme laws but here amongst friends, why not discuss this in a balanced way and save the extremism for fighting those with equally extreme stances on the other side? I do support copyright but I don't support it in its entirety. This story is a prime example of why the length of copyright needs to be limited. But this isn't only about copyright. We forget that other US laws in combination with copyright are what cause some of the trouble. Corporations should not be considered people. I think taking a stance that promotes complete abolishment of copyright is like chopping off your head to cure a headache. The "I Have a Dream" speech should be in the public domain by now, there's no question about it. Copyright has hurt us in this case but while Dr. King was alive it had every opportunity to help us. It could have ensured that his speech wasn't taken advantage of. We seem to forget that copyright helps us promote freedom just as much as it can be used to restrict it. It can help ensure not just freedom as in liberty but freedom as in gratis, for free, free beer, pay zero moneys. We can't stop people from using copyright in ways we don't approve of without abolishing it but abolishing it opens another can of worms. So instead let's focus on trying to make copyright a little more sane, less biased, by scaling it back instead of ripping out our hearts to cure high cholesterol (I didn't want to use the chopping heads to cure headaches metaphor again, hopefully that wasn't too awkward a metaphor).
- Lagged2Death 15y agoI wonder what legal contortions were necessary to argue that "the speech was a performance distributed to the news media and not the public." That's some of the purest baloney I've ever heard. If giving a speech to a fifth of a million people on the steps of one of the most famous public monuments in the world, in one of the most famous public spaces in the world, doesn't count as "public," what possibly could? Maybe the "not the public" summation is a poor one. I've often thought it would be beneficial to the cause of history and governmental transparency to get more videos, recordings, and photographs of our important leaders (presidential candidates, et al) into the public domain. I had thought it was something a non-profit, a quasi-governmental corporation like PBS, or a governmental department could organize. But I don't know how copyright law interacts with public performances (obviously).
- giardini 15y agoThat's alright. No one wants to hear the whole speech anyway - too boring and dated. The great part ("I have a dream...") of the speech is available everywhere without paying. It's the truly memorable part of the speech. In fact, I'd bet that 99% who have heard of the speech have heard only that part of the speech.
- giardini 15y agoThat's alright. No one wants to hear the whole speech anyway - too boring and dated. The great part ("I have a dream...") of the speech is available everywhere without paying. It's the truly memorable part of the speech. In fact, I'd bet that 99% who have heard the speech know of only that part of the speech.