8 ms·
Up 17% in AH, on top of huge gains over the past 2 months. Nuts. It looks like it really wants to get back to $300+ It shows how all this talk about metaverse l
by paulpauper 4y ago
Up 17% in AH, on top of huge gains over the past 2 months. Nuts. It looks like it really wants to get back to $300+ It shows how all this talk about metaverse losses was overblown. This is why my best piece of financial advice is to tune out the media. By the time something is a narrative, it's too late. If the media is talking about how Facebook peaked or is the next myspace, this is time to buy. Same for Netflix.
Metaverse notwithstanding, Facebook and Instagram are still huge cash cows. Ad CPCs are really high, especially mobile ads. Companies, especially in financial services and healthcare, paying so much $ for clicks to target older people, retirees, etc. and also people with medical problems. Obesity epidemic means more healthcare spending, same for people living longer.
- MuffinFlavored 4y ago> Facebook and Instagram are still huge cash cows. I wonder what that makes TikTok then? Do we have any insight into how much ad cash Facebook + Instagram generate compared to TikTok?
- avrionov 4y ago$5B last year 2022. https://www.statista.com/statistics/1305708/tiktok-ad-revenue/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/1305708/tiktok-ad-revenu...
- toephu2 4y agoTikTok still losing money though Operating Loss At TikTok Parent ByteDance Topped $7 Billion Last Year, WSJ Reports [1] [1] https://www.wsj.com/articles/tiktok-parent-bytedance-sees-losses-swell-in-push-for-growth-11665071238 https://www.wsj.com/articles/tiktok-parent-bytedance-sees-lo...
- coffeebeqn 4y agoTheir infra is more expensive- all content is decent quality video instead of text and fairly low res images - and from what I can tell the ad network is not very robust. Not too surprising
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- melling 4y agoIt feels like only 3 months ago I was repeatedly trying to convince HN readers that Meta was a great investment opportunity at a P/E of 9. In fact, it was…: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33572187 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33572187 Markets aren’t efficient. People are biased and can’t look past them. There’s quite a bit of knowledge on HN. As a group, we could do much better understanding the markets.
- dangwhy 4y agomarkets are irrational except when it goes up 17% AH ?
- kibwen 4y agoRather, the market is irrational whenever it does anything that I disagree with, and rational otherwise. Trust me, I'm a rational human being.
- dd36 4y agoMarkets measure the tiny fraction of buyers and sellers on a given day and ignore the super majority of holders. It almost feels like length of ownership should be more determinative of price movements than anything else. If long-term holders start selling, it’s concerning.
- rcme 4y ago> Markets measure the tiny fraction of buyers and sellers on a given day and ignore the super majority of holders. Not really. The decision to not sell and to not buy is itself reflective of the price. If a stock is super cheap, people will buy. If the stock is priced fairly or overpriced, few people will buy. Same goes for selling.
- somethoughts 4y agoIt almost feels like length of ownership should be more determinative of price movements than anything else. >> Length of ownership AND relatedly original cost basis. I think a lot of stocks can seem to defy gravity (i.e. high PE and/or high P/FCF) when the founder and the early investors HODL stocks. At $0.0001 per share, HODLing (in say TSLA, META, MSFT, BTC) is easy since there is/was no upfront capital paid in and holding has essentially no cost basis - so there's no need to act like rationally like a later stage investor. >> Founders and early investors can easily own up to 30-50% of the company and really its only when the founder retires/starts diversifying and the founder and early investors start to unload - does price discovery occur on the entirety of the shares outstanding.[1][2][3] [1] Mark Zuckerberg Sold Facebook Stock Nearly Every Weekday Last Year For Almost 11 Months https://www.forbes.com/sites/rachelsandler/2022/01/06/mark-zuckerberg-sold-facebook-stock-nearly-every-weekday-last-year-for-almost-11-months/?sh=5570993f3f71 https://www.forbes.com/sites/rachelsandler/2022/01/06/mark-z... [2] https://techcrunch.com/2013/02/15/zuckerberg-now-owns-29-3-percent-of-facebook-representing-18-billion/ https://techcrunch.com/2013/02/15/zuckerberg-now-owns-29-3-p... [2] Amazon founder Jeff Bezos decreased his stake to 24% from 42% in the first nine years after IPO.
- matwood 4y agoI said months ago when they announced layoffs that Meta is fine. They are a literal cash volcano. Zucks foray into the metaverse to the tune of 10B/year is dumb, but it's a cash expense. Eventually he'll tone that investment down and that expense will flow right to the bottom line. Full disclosure, I am long Meta.
- baron816 4y agoI bought a small amount of META when the narrative of its downfall hit its peak. It’s the first individual stock I’ve bought in 12 years. I’m now going to be up about 60%.
- thunky 4y ago> I bought a small amount This is why it's really hard to win big buying individual stocks. You finally pulled the trigger, and you won, but you never even had a chance to make more than a small gain. Say you even bought $100k, which is probably much more than most mere mortals have the stomach to "place a bet" with. You'd be up 60k, which is great, but probably not life changing. And now you have to decide if you want to cash it out or let it ride and risk losing it. On the other hand, it doesn't take much intestinal fortitude to park 100k in VTSAX and sleep well every night.
- sicp-enjoyer 4y agoObviously one way to hedge risk is to use smaller amounts. His gains on that portion are still greater than if it was parked 100% in VTSAX.
- thunky 4y agoOnly if you care about percentage gains more than dollar amounts. Depending on how much meta he actually bought, he may have made more money today with the s&p's 0.22% gain that he's made with meta all time. But meta probably feels like the big winner.
- sicp-enjoyer 4y agoI don't see how that's the case. If he had 95% of portfolio in S&P and the FB he bought was 5%, he still did better in dollar terms than 100% S&P.
- thunky 4y ago
- rvz 4y ago> This is why my best piece of financial advice is to tune out the media. I'm trying very hard to not say 'I told them so'. In fact, I said this before here [0] [1] [2] too many times to stop listening to the nonsense from the media. Meta has lots of cash to last for another decade and they are still printing money. Such calls for the death of Meta Platforms on HN and in the media has once again always been greatly exaggerated. [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31832439 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31832439 [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33991718 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33991718 [2] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32256465 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32256465
- __derek__ 4y agoBuying back another $40 billion in stock also helps. The narrative around metaverse costs was largely that they should return cash to shareholders rather than dumping so much of it into that incinerator. It looks like the board took that advice.
- jlmorton 4y ago> rather than dumping so much of it into that incinerator. It's strange to me that people think Reality Labs is an incinerator. Truly, without exaggeration, I think this entire perception is based on the ridiculous early Horizon Worlds screenshots Mark Zuckerberg posted, which did a ton of damage to Meta. But Horizon Worlds is not The Metaverse, and it's not Reality Labs! It's one part of it. Reality Labs has game studios, the leading VR/AR hardware, all kinds of software packages to make working in the Metaverse possible, like Horizon Workrooms, Horizon Remote Desktop, and quite a bit more. They are quickly developing a fairly insurmountable moat. Meanwhile, Apple is also dumping billions into AR, but they don't break it out in earnings reports, so no one talks about it. There are lots of execution risks in Meta's VR strategy. Obviously, if no one ever wants their products for games, work, entertainment, or whatever else, then they will have incinerated an awful lot of money. But I think that's actually the unlikely scenario. The quarterly losses are very large, but it's an entirely new product line with a very large potential market.
- __derek__ 4y agoTo abuse the metaphor a bit, incinerators generate energy. It's entirely possible that Zuck and Co. have been capturing the energy produced by this one in order to help propel the company forward in the future. > But I think that's actually the unlikely scenario. Right, we take opposite sides of the probability here. My preference is just that they direct some of the output from that prodigious cash-generator towards shareholders in the meantime. You know, like Apple does.
- jjfoooo4 4y agoHorizon Worlds is what Meta chose to showcase, so it’s pretty reasonable to draw the conclusion that it’s the best they can do right now. The screenshots you’re talking about are of Zuckerberg trying to gin up enthusiasm for the product. The insurmountable most is surrounding a space that doesn’t make any money. Apple may be investing in AR but they didn’t signal that they are betting the company on it
- bboygravity 4y agoOr price discovery in US markets is completely broken. Could also explain it. Mumbles something about perpetual FTDs, naked shorting, the biggest market maker also being a hedge fund (who donates many millions to corrupt politcians), tokenized securities that can be used as short locates and so on...
- DiggyJohnson 4y agoWhat’s the biggest market maker? If you have any long form versions of this ranty comment, I’d be genuinely interested in reading it. Cheers
- bboygravity 4y agoCitadel securities (the largest retail market maker, this is the company front-running every single one of your trades through PFOF if you use a "free" broker like Robin Hood) Citadel LLC (the hedge fund) Both part of Citadel the mother ship. All owned by 1 man (who like Madoff owns a hedge fund and a market maker, but unlike Madoff actually seems to execute trades with his hedge fund). 1 man who also happens to be the top GOP donor (what could he possibly want in return?): https://www.cnbc.com/2022/10/07/citadels-ceo-ken-griffin-becomes-gop-100-million-midterm-megadonor.html https://www.cnbc.com/2022/10/07/citadels-ceo-ken-griffin-bec... If you want more info, this is an OK start: https://youtu.be/26_IcexvePA https://youtu.be/26_IcexvePA Kind of old, but still relevant (not much changed since then). The same documentary makers are working on a new one that I believe will come out this year. There's tons of info to find online if you Google any of those terms in my rant from the previous comment as well. PS: those are just tips of multiple icebergs, there's more.
- jcfrei 4y agoOn a yearly basis they are still down about 4% in revenue from advertising and apps and down 17% in the reality labs section. Their business is just shrinking less quickly than investors feared.
- ripvanwinkle 4y agoin constant currency they would be up about 4%. the biggest trend is revenue per ad was nearly offset by growth in number of ads - the latter is likely to hit its limit sooner than the former and that seems like the biggest risk to the business
- loeg 4y agoWhat does AH stand for? Thanks.
- MarcoZavala 4y ago[dead]
- HDThoreaun 4y agoMy only concern is that cost per ad was down 22% this quarter. They counteracted by showing 17% more ads on minimal user growth which seems likely to accelerate Facebook exodus.
- trieste92 4y ago> If the media is talking about how Facebook peaked or is the next myspace, this is time to buy Yeah same for FTX /s Better to just not see what the media is saying period than go full contrarian
- sicp-enjoyer 4y agoIn FTX case it had already happened when the media reported. In fact, prior to the scandal most of the media about FTX was positive.
- ulfw 4y agoThen why fire so many people?
- gnicholas 4y ago> Same for Netflix. I followed as NFLX dropped, and it was definitely a media narrative before the drop was over. We don't know where things will shake out, of course, but it's not the case that everything is priced in by the time the media starts talking about it.