16 ms·
How we plan to de-extinct the Dodo bird
- wayvey 4y agoThe site kind of looks impressive but due to the hype and extravagant design I have a hard time gauging the legitimacy of it.
- DrBazza 4y agoAlso on Bloomberg: https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2023-01-31/dodo-bird-dna-has-startup-valued-at-1-billion-to-bring-back-extinct-species https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2023-01-31/dodo-bird... and https://twitter.com/VictorVescovo/status/1620504852802699265?s=20 https://twitter.com/VictorVescovo/status/1620504852802699265...
- _Algernon_ 4y agoSeems sadistic to bring back a species to a world in which it can't survive in the wild. It's existence will be nothing more than a plaything for humans to look and gawk at.
- themitigating 4y agoIt died due to invasive animals brought by humans
- _Algernon_ 4y agoThat changes nothing about my statement
- once_inc 4y agoIf we can recreate the bird, we can recreate the environment for the bird too.
- BizarreByte 4y agoWe have barely been able to do that for animals which are still living, but lost their natural environment. Assuming we can recreate a maintain an accurate environment to ensure the bird’s long term success is way, way too optimistic.
- mathieuh 4y agoThey have an active mammal extermination programme in NZ trying to deal with the threat to the native birds. https://www.doc.govt.nz/news/media-releases/2016/predator-free-nz-2050-to-be-a-massive-team-effort/ https://www.doc.govt.nz/news/media-releases/2016/predator-fr...
- rippercushions 4y agoThe time-honored solution for this is to exterminate invasive species on a small nearby island, and make that a reserve. New Zealand has employed extensively with quite a bit of success, and there are numerous small, uninhabited islands in Mauritius that seem like plausible options.
- makeitdouble 4y agoWe can, but that assumes continued political will to do so. That's something we're definitely not good at.
- themitigating 4y agoI'm sorry. I took your statement as "if the bird couldn't survive on its own..."
- Wowfunhappy 4y agoHow is creating Dodo birds and putting them in a zoo inherently different than having other animals in a zoo?
- makeitdouble 4y agoHaving regular animals in zoos is also controversial. The question is different when it can be summed up as "to be or not to be", but I think it's still an ethical bag of hurts.
- psiops 4y agoGood question! I think it is related to knowing that zoo animals have wild counterparts and the ones in zoos are just (unlucky) specimens to be gawked at. You convince yourself this somehow helps the conservation of the wild ones through education etc. That's different from unextincting a species but there's no place for them anywhere in the wild world.
- JohnFen 4y agoIt's not. Zoos are depressing as hell.
- mschuster91 4y agoActually, bringing back extinct or near-extinct animals has a lot of side benefits to ecosystems as a whole - just look at the successes of wolf reintroduction programs. Wolves keep reindeer and similar animals in check, which is beneficial for plant life and subsequently species that depend on greenery [1]. But for that, you need quality breeding stock in zoos in the first place. [1] https://defenders.org/blog/2020/03/we-were-wrong-about-wolves-heres-why https://defenders.org/blog/2020/03/we-were-wrong-about-wolve...
- m000 4y agoI find it noble. It would only be sadistic if we bring them back just to see dodo meat farms in a couple of decades.
- Tepix 4y agoAre they tasty?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- helloworld11 4y agoApparently, based on contemporary accounts, opinion was varied, but they were meaty and easy to catch. A bit of selective breeding would probably make them ideal poultry farm animals.
- Beldin 4y agoI'm not a fan of trying to bring back extinct creatures from the grave without first addressing what's wrong with the world that led to their extinction. It really isn't ethical to start creating creatures just for our entertainment (i.e., keeping them in cages). But reintroduction into the wild is also problematic: either they're now an invasive species, or they're now (still) easy prey. TL;DR: "your scientists were so preoccupied with whether or not they could, they didn't stop to think if they should.”
- nend 4y agoIt went extinct due to human hunting and invasive species (rats, brought by humans) eating their eggs. While not exactly a solved problem, both of these things have been addressed for other species to help ensure they don't go extinct.
- hollowturtle 4y agoAppreciated the quote ;)
- JoeAltmaier 4y agoToo late by a century to worry about that. Extinction is so far advanced. Consider large animals: 50% on earth are the ones we raise to eat. Of the remaining, 46% are ... humans themselves! That leaves 4% of all earthly animals to be 'wild'. A negligible part of the 'ecology'. We're not going to put the genie of terraforming (reforming the earth to serve human needs) back in the bottle. The bottle is smashed; the earth is one large human park. Anyway, still we need to try not to destroy the atmosphere and water because they're critical to human needs and processes. That's reason enough.
- tbrownaw 4y ago> without first addressing what's wrong with the world that led to their extinction. Ecological niches shifting around doesn't necessarily require that something's wrong.
- worldofmatthew 4y ago> 38.14 MB transferred Including multiple photographs loaded as PNGs....... Nice design but someone forgot to optimize it.
- nickpeterson 4y agoI have a sneaking suspicion HN putting this on the front page will teach someone this lesson.
- worldofmatthew 4y agoLooks like Google Cloud CDN. Cache egress $0.02-$0.20 per GiB Getting on the front page of Hacker News might hurt their "pocket's" a bit.
- ly3xqhl8g9 4y agohttps://colossal.com/wp-content/themes/colossal/img/dodo/hero.jpg https://colossal.com/wp-content/themes/colossal/img/dodo/her... seems to be the main culprit: 10MB of JPEG at 2880x2400, absolutely unnecessary given that a simple re-export at 70% quality (imperceptible differences) takes it down to 385KB and a rescale to 1440x1200 takes it down even further to 72KB. Makes you wonder how many petabytes are pointlessly running between continents. Although in this case WordPress should have taken care by default to optimize the images.
- worldofmatthew 4y agoI managed 115KB with my normal AVIF settings at full size, maybe closer to 130KB if using artificial noise regeneration.
- asah 4y ago...or at least warn authors and provide a one-click button to optimize...
- account42 4y agoJPEG quality 70% absolutely wrecks the noise for me. This is quite perceptible at the size the image is used at. If the noise is really neccessary for the page is another question but surely there are better options than turning the JPEG quality down to 'ass'.
- nickpeterson 4y agoPerhaps I’ll write a utility called ‘sudodo’, which quickly kills an active running command…
- once_inc 4y agoIt should do so by spawning a number of different processes that each cut off resources of the targeted process, and which terminate any subprocesses started by the target process...
- nickdothutton 4y agoJust get on with it.
- denysonique 4y agoThis website breaks reader mode as well as the increase font size button on Safari iOS.
- _Algernon_ 4y agoPut it through Lighthouse with a score of 30/100. No wonder
- throwme_123 4y agoIs this from International Genetic Technologies, Inc.?
- nivertech 4y agoInternational Genetic Technologies, Inc. (InGen) was able to recreate all kinds of extinct animals with the goal of cloning these creatures and displaying them in a theme park on a tropical island. This company is only planning to recreate an extinct Dodo bird, and use it to terraform the planet Mars on Elon Musk's future expedition.
- tescocles 4y agoSince everyone is complaining about the site rather than the topic - I hate sites that hide the menu bar when you scroll downwards but then show it again when you scroll even slightly upwards. If you scroll up when you're trying to read something that happens to be placed at the top of the viewport, the menu swings down unceremoniously to obscure it. There are so many other options, have a button that pops out the menu or have it there permanently (if you're hiding it because it doesn't fit with the design of the page as you scroll, it's even worse that it just appears in front of the content). Having the trigger to view the menu as scrolling upwards a bit is bad UX anyway as it's not logical - there are very very few cases where scrolling should trigger a non-cosmetic interaction with the page. I like to align things (new paragraphs etc) at the top of my viewport during long reads, so this happens quite often.
- hendrikrassmann 4y agoIsn't this the premise of the Red Letter Media Star Trek Trivia Show plot? https://youtu.be/Ko0fKuy8z2U?t=72 https://youtu.be/Ko0fKuy8z2U?t=72
- frereubu 4y ago[flagged]
- nemo44x 4y ago“Your scientists were so preoccupied with whether or not they could, they didn’t stop to think if they should.“
- GrumpyNl 4y agoI was thinking the same thing. You made me smile.
- FooBarBizBazz 4y agoAt one level this delights me and gives me optimism. At a basic aesthetic level, a world that has dodos, and woolly mammoths, and sabre tooth tigers, is a more interesting one. "Bring back as many of these magnificent creatures as possible!", I think. Yet, to expand on points made by other posters, the very existence of this species requires a kind of ecological disequilibrium. Humans will need to maintain strict control over what other species are allowed into its habitat (the article mentions rats in particular). It seems like a fight against entropy, which requires ongoing work, like maintaining two thermal reservoirs at different temperatures. Or keeping COVID from becoming endemic in China (or any other country). I have always found the dodo to be a sympathetic animal, though. Tame, friendly, trusting. I suppose when you're hungry you eat anything, and once you've killed your first animal for meat, then the second and third become easier, so if I were not an insulated modern myself (indeed a bit like the dodo), then I would maybe have an easy time killing one. But as it stands, I find it hard to imagine, and my impulse is to try to befriend the creatures. "Yes, let's bring back the dodo", I think, "maybe we can be friends". Maybe that's not a horrible ecological niche. Dogs are not totally incapable creatures, but in America they live almost exclusively as domesticated pets. In a way, the same may be true of humans, who are all utterly dependent on the rest of society. Perhaps the dodo, who will live at the mercy of peoples' tastes, will not be so different from many of us.
- 542458 4y agoWhile your main point is philosophical, you mentioned the practical concern of rats - for what it’s worth, Alberta, a Canadian province the size of France, has completely eradicated rats despite being land-bordered on all sides by provinces with rats. Alberta produces a lot of grain, and it’s a big savings for them to not have to deal with rats. This is accomplished with a provincial task force that costs about half a million bucks a year, aggressive reporting action by the population, and enthusiastic cooperation from the local farms. So it can be done, and it’s not nearly as hard as it sounds!
- atlasunshrugged 4y agoThat's really interesting (I now live in an East Coast US city with a rat problem) -- do they have any good papers or anything on what tactics they used to eliminate the rats? 500K a year sounds like a bargain, I bet that's NYC's rat czar's basic salary
- Arch-TK 4y agoBut why, no really, I get that we're technically at fault, but the world changes, there are billions (about 5 billion to be exact) of extinct species, which ones do we pick to un-extinct? Do we have to prove that we or one of our ancestors was a direct cause for the extinction? And when we do un-extinct a species, what does that achieve, other than entertainment for some few people and maybe the feeling of having achieved something "good"? Surely the money spent researching this could be better spent making the world as it is a better place and improving ways in which humans interact with the world to reduce extinction rates and general harm to the environment.
- causi 4y agoDoing cool shit is good for the human spirit.
- astrojams 4y agoKeystone species can be important to the overall environment and other animals. Bring back the right ones and you could improve the environment. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Keystone_species https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Keystone_species
- Dig1t 4y agoI have to say that I generally agree with you, though that's unpopular. It's a cool project and it has scientific merit, it's cool to do just because they'll do something that's never been done before, and learn things that can be useful elsewhere. I do kind of agree that it seems pointless, and their justification seems more moral than it does practical. The moralistic side of this stuff sometimes seems to verge on nature worship with some people. It seems that we have somehow got it in our collective heads that we need to preserve the planet _exactly_ how it was right before the Industrial Revolution started, forever.
- Shinchy 4y agoLove it! Questions of ethics aside, I think it's a fascinating idea (one that may be completely unachievable) and would have a profound impact on history if achieved.
- londons_explore 4y agoWhat would the business model look like for doing this? I spend $20M on lab time and experts to clone a dodo... Then I lease that dodo to zoos for $2000/day... and in the dodo's lifespan I will never make a profit... Or I spend $30M to clone two dodo's - one male, and one female. I then breed 100 more dodo's from that initial pair. I then rent them to zoos around the world, at perhaps $200/day (lower price because there is no exclusivity anymore). Even this plan is dubiously profitable, considering my rental income will only slowly ramp up over 20 years as dodos are born...
- Joker_vD 4y ago> What would the business model look like for doing this? What would the business model look like for going fishing with your friends? Some people want to wear diamonds and dine at posh restaurants, some want to do gardening and write books on it, some want to revive extinct birds; it's not a means, it's an end.
- folio 4y agoI hope you are right, but this is a for-profit company that has just received a new round of funding. From an Austin American-Statesman article[1], "Colossal Biosciences, which this week announced a new $150 million funding round, is led by Austin-based entrepreneur Ben Lamm..." And from a Yahoo! Finance article[2], "Colossal’s use of various gene editing technologies will make waves across sectors – in agriculture...as well as in human health through improved gene therapy and vaccine development." I think it is reasonable to assume that there is a "business model" here. [1]: https://www.statesman.com/story/business/technology/2023/01/31/texas-company-colossal-biosciences-bring-back-extinct-dodo-bird-woolly-mammoth/69855986007/ https://www.statesman.com/story/business/technology/2023/01/... [2]: https://finance.yahoo.com/news/colossal-biosciences-secures-150m-series-140000458.html https://finance.yahoo.com/news/colossal-biosciences-secures-...
- UncleEntity 4y ago> I think it is reasonable to assume that there is a "business model" here. Maybe the plan is to make money off the technology they create to do this and let the dodos do whatever dodos do?
- bayesian_horse 4y agoThey should start with Harpagornis moorei, much more interesting species.
- helloworld11 4y agoBut nowhere near as captivating for media soundbites and news posts. The dodo is one very symbolic bird and just about everyone recognizes it right away.
- Tepix 4y agoSo, the website states that 6 species are going extinct per hour and continues to claim "the solution is de-extinction". Shouldn't we start by preventing further extinctions? Also it seems rather unlikely that they can scale their approach to 6 de-extinctions per hour...
- marmetio 4y agoNobody has figured out how to stop everyone else from extincting species. These people may be able to de-extinct some species themselves. Whichever thing you can actually do yourself is the solution [1]. [1] https://www.goodreads.com/quotes/1213773-wish-in-one-hand-shit-in-the-other-see-which https://www.goodreads.com/quotes/1213773-wish-in-one-hand-sh...
- credit_guy 4y agoNote that if this project succeeds, then dinosaurs are not far behind. For example, we have dinosaur bones, but very little actual dodo fossils (apparently only one foot and one piece of jaw [1]). The way this project is described, they will not need DNA of the dodo itself, only of its closest living relative (Nicobar pigeon) and closest extinct relative where we have DNA (Rodrigues solitaire). The genome of the dodo will be recreated by interpolation. Could that work for dinosaurs? Why not? There are lots of living relatives (all the birds, including the famous Cassowary, which some call a "living dinosaur"). We can do lots of genome interpolation, and we can identify the genes related to various morphological features. Not different at all from what they plan to do with the dodo. Would we ever get actual dinosaur DNA? Never say never. But even if we don't, it's quite likely we'll be able to deextinct the dinosaurs, if we can deextinct the Dodo. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dodo#Physical_remains https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dodo#Physical_remains
- idontwantthis 4y agoIsn’t that like an AI “restoring” an image? A guess based reasonable assumptions but in no way the original image.
- Keyframe 4y agoone minor snag in that narrative is half-life of DNA which is 521 years. Last dinosaurs (of ye olde) were when?
- credit_guy 4y agoJust one year after that paper claiming the DNA half life of 521 years[1], the DNA of horse from 700k years ago was sequenced [2]. That would be about 1344 half-lives. Then, in 2021 the DNA of a mammoth that lived 1.2 million years ago was sequenced. To answer your question, dinosaurs last lived 65 million years ago. [1] https://www.nature.com/articles/nature.2012.11555 https://www.nature.com/articles/nature.2012.11555 [2] https://www.nationalgeographic.com/science/article/130626-ancient-dna-oldest-sequenced-horse-paleontology-science https://www.nationalgeographic.com/science/article/130626-an... [3] https://www.science.org/content/article/mammoth-molars-yield-oldest-dna-ever-sequenced https://www.science.org/content/article/mammoth-molars-yield...
- duckqlz 4y agoPrimordial bird cells. Lol.
- deafpolygon 4y agoBigger chicken, yumm...
- freilanzer 4y agoAnd it's going extinct again.
- userbinator 4y agoNot if it gets bred.
- deafpolygon 4y agoOr bored.
- ChoGGi 4y agoCongrats Mike, you did it.
- Yaa101 4y agoWhy would we de-extinct an ugly, non tasty bird that cannot fly and who's ecosystem is gone for 100's of years and risk destabilize the current ecosystem that does not include it?
- modzu 4y agobecause god put dodos on earth for a reason
- Yaa101 4y agoSo far the reason seems to be to get extinct.
- micromacrofoot 4y agoWhy are we spending billions of dollars to blast harmful exhaust into our atmosphere to put humans on a barren planet constantly being bombarded with deadly radiation.
- cnj 4y agoReading the "Our Process: De-Extinction of the Dodo bird" section, I couldn't help but to think of https://xkcd.com/2501/ https://xkcd.com/2501/ ...
- joshuahedlund 4y agoI've been following Colossal and de-extinction efforts more generally with some interest (Beth Shapiro's books How to Clone a Mammoth and Life as We Made it are very eye-opening both to the weirdness of the advances of the last 10 years and how far we still have to go) However I'm getting a little cynical/skeptical when Colossal announces new species to their roster without announcing progress on the other ones, especially given my understanding that mammoths are supposed to be one of the easiest (relatively). I'm guessing the Nicobar pigeon to the dodo is much farther than the elephant to the mammoth, and I think Shapiro thought there was something fundamentally more difficult about working with eggs as well. This page is pretty heavy on pretty graphics and history and pretty light on recent technological breakthroughs that would make this more feasible.
- bmau5 4y agoNothing to add but also wanted to shoutout Life as We Made It and How to Clone a Mammoth. Had the pleasure of meeting Dr. Shapiro and she's as pleasant as she is brilliant.
- marmetio 4y agoIt seems like their tools and techniques might have value without achieving de-extinction [1]. If they can't find a way to profit off anything they've done, then I'd be worried. [1] https://theintercept.com/2022/09/28/cia-extinction-woolly-mammoth-dna/ https://theintercept.com/2022/09/28/cia-extinction-woolly-ma...
- JohnFen 4y agoI can't speak to the validity of their efforts, but that web page does them no favors at all.
- Mountain_Skies 4y agoLast I heard, they had already implanted embryos in Indian elephants and the pregnancies, which are twenty something months long, are in process. But it's just something I heard in passing recently so I wouldn't put a whole lot of faith in it. Still, it will be very interesting if we have a small heard of mammoths running around next year.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- gdsdfe 4y agothe website have that good old encyclopedia feel to it, which is kinda nice and a bit nostalgic
- mattanimation 4y agoI worked with the Co-Founder (Ben Lamm) at Chaotic Moon and Hypergiant. If I've learned anything from the past, it's that this is likely not the future. The pattern is: find a hot topic, hire Maven to make a nice website, raise on hype, find an exit or get booted. I don't doubt the team actually working on things is talented. I hope they can pull it off.
- culi 4y agoYeah like underground hyperloops or your self-driving car earning you passive income as a taxi. The game is to inspire and get heavy subsidization
- entropie 4y ago> hire Maven to make a nice website Well, that worked from me. I did not dig into the "how" (yet), but I immediately said to myself "wow, nice layout and general design"
- burner192837465 4y agoYeah, Ben is really good at riding the hype wave, not so much at executing for the long term, so the question is who’s running operations over there. I’d love to see “de-extinction” happen, but I’m going to need to be convinced that this will be any more practical or realistic than those Chaotic Moon SXSW tech demos.
- therufa 4y agothis is going to be jurassic park soft edition
- runako 4y agoI'm not a biologist and don't have any expertise in the field. But to my untrained eye, this looks more like creating a new species that has apparent traits similar to recorded traits of dodos than it is de-extincting the dodo. Is that an accurate assessment?
- api 4y agoDepends on how much actual dodo DNA they can get their hands on to be as authentic as possible. If we end up with something with a good chance of being very close to a dodo and it looks like a dodo and dodos like a dodo is it a dodo? At some point you get into philosophical debates about whether dodosity can be defined.
- runako 4y ago> dodos like a dodo This is the part that's sticky. We can't test against a reference implementation, so the only comparison we can make is to a relative handful of 16th- and 17th-century observations. This is a bird, for example, where there is apparently only a single written description of its nest. It would be difficult to make a convincing argument that we know enough about the dodo to assert the behaviors of the new animal aren't just coming from whatever animal they use to make the filler DNA (the pigeon?). > is it a dodo? I mean, it would seem like it is not, even with a fairly generous definition. I don't know that philosophy needs to enter the picture given that the process itself (as I understand it) can't (intentionally) produce an animal that could reasonably have been the offspring of any of the dodos that more recently lived. > how much actual dodo DNA I'm struck here by the comparison between human and chimp or bonobo DNA (edit: the comparison is that we share something like 98% of our DNA with those species). We need basically all of it to land on a specific species. (I'm assuming they don't have nearly 100% or they would presumably use a process more similar to cloning.)
- api 4y ago> I'm assuming they don't have nearly 100% or they would presumably use a process more similar to cloning. Cloning requires fully intact nuclear DNA with intact chromosomes. You aren’t getting that from old dodo feathers and skeletons but you might be able to get enough to assemble a full sequence. A full sequence isn’t intact chromosomes so the only way to get there would be to basically apply a diff against a living sample from the closest relative.
- CatWChainsaw 4y agoZoos are called mausoleums of the living dead for a reason.
- api 4y agoI love how the dodo is pitched like a tech product to a room full of VCs.
- restalis 4y agoThink about what it would mean to endeavor into project of reviving an extinct species. Not a bacteria or some worm, but one of the most complex organisms as target. This by all accounts is a monumental task, never-done-before kind of stuff, expect development of pioneering bio-engineering technology in there and billions worth of tried-and-true expertise gained in the process. Then open your eyes and look again how you are being told, with a straight face, "we're doing it for... Dodo", don't rise an eyebrow now. Well, this, more than anything, looks like a master piece of project's public image grooming to me. If I would ever plan to develop daring things that may scare people, and I'd also want to find ways to avoid the costs required for total secrecy, I'd remember Dodo, alright.
- taejavu 4y agoWell, I for one am interested in eating a dodo. I think the current lineup of poultry would benefit from an additional option.
- geuis 4y agoIf I remember correctly, this is partly why they went extinct. Combined with them not seeing humans as predators, they tasted pretty good.
- hypertele-Xii 4y agoSaving it from extinction for an eternity of torture and slaughter, nice.
- 4y ago
- rambojohnson 4y agowhy
- cellis 4y agoI can't speak to the biology claims, but the web design is gorgeous! Does anyone know what they used for this, or is it proprietary?
- chimineycricket 4y agoI thought it was horrendous. Makes it so hard to read. Sections are labeled but hard to determine immediately what each section is.
- Agraillo 4y agoGood point, I thought that this design belongs to the print media world, when the media is split by pages, not to the scrolling continuous world of the web.
- JohnFen 4y agoReally? I thought it was terrible on pretty much every level.
- whatanattitude 4y agoWe meant dodo bird nfts
- yawnxyz 4y agoJust having the name "George Church" slapped on there means you can raise $30M and never have a way to make that money back in any way (e.g. revenue, or a business model)
- nathanvanfleet 4y agoI hope they work on the Tasmanian Tiger too one day
- black_13 4y ago[dead]
- quickthrower2 4y agoIronically bringing back the dodo is about humans and nostalgia (plus a little touch of marketing for this c comoany). Dodos are another consumer product, essentially.
- Maursault 4y agoI think it seems kind of weird allocating resources to bring back an extinct species, because it seems like it would be vastly more difficult and expensive than saving a near extinct species, such as the vaquita, since there are a few still left alive rather than none for thousands of years. Also, it seems a bit cruel resurrecting something like mammoth, a creature of the ice ages, when the planet is warm and expected to keep getting warmer. Dodo extinction, any extinction, but especially human-caused extinction, is sad and maddening. I don't mean to be negative or cynical, but most extinctions from now on will ultimately be human-caused. We should exhaust all resources arresting the processes that cause these extinctions, and preserve the remaining diversity securely before building Jurassic Park.
- ipaddr 4y agoI'll comment on it being mean to bring back the mammoth because the planet is warmer and expecting to get warmer. There are plenty of places they would fit fine in. It getting warmer is 1 or 2 degrees at worst and on average. This carbon issue may get resolved with tech and social changes the future is unknown and a lifetime away.
- cmrdporcupine 4y agoMastodon makes more sense to bring back, maybe. They were in a wider variety of climates and they were smaller. I'd love to have a couple grazing in my back woods here on the farm :-)
- blisterpeanuts 4y agoI’m not so sure you would love that. Mastodons and mammoths are thought to have been rather ferocious, much more aggressive than modern elephants, and probably would not hesitate to attack you. If you are around one, you’d better hide fast.
- cmrdporcupine 4y agoDamn, but they look so cute. Furry elephant. I want a furry oliphaunt friend. They were hunted to extinction though, so clearly they weren't so terrifying and scary that we couldn't ... hunt and eat them. Some Mastodon blood was found on some stone tools not far from me recently. Right near my daughter's high school: https://www.thespec.com/news/hamilton-region/2022/12/31/discovery-of-mastodon-blood-on-ice-age-tools-first-of-its-kind-in-ontario.html https://www.thespec.com/news/hamilton-region/2022/12/31/disc...
- joshu 4y ago... why? are they especially tasty or something?
- LarsDu88 4y agoWhat's the business model? Well to engineer a dodo, another bird has to lay the egg. If that bird is a pigeon, the pigeon needs to modified to be bigger first. Do y'all see where I'm going with this? Engineering animals is a touchy subject in Congress, but these scientists have latched on a topic that almost no one is opposed to. The fact that they are attracting money in an area no one will touch should inspire hope. I have little doubt they will succeed with at least one species. Speaking as someone who created dozens of transgenic animals during a Bio PhD!
- lofaszvanitt 4y agoFinally, manipulators, sorry influencers, will have their new toy at hand, soon. Look, I have a dodo, and I fed it mcdonalds burgers. Look how cute it is!
- jaygray0919 4y agoJurassic Park redux
- iggldiggl 4y agoNobody here around who has read Jasper Fforde? (Plock, plock)
- SillyUsername 4y ago"LET’S BE CLEAR. THE ONLY ACTUALLY STUPID CREATURES IN THIS STORY ARE US, HUMANS" Like, yeah, what idiot would waste time and effort bringing back an extinct animal?