8 ms·
Why EVs Aren't a Climate Change Panacea
- PragmaticPulp 4y agoBetter headline: "EVs are decarbonizing transport, but we have more work to do. Here's what we should do next." From the article: > This is not to imply in any way that electric vehicles are worthless. Analysis by the International Council on Clean Transportation (ICCT) argues that EVs are the quickest means to decarbonize motorized transport. The headline feels like someone crafted it for maximum clickbait. The perpetual doomsday framing of everything, including the climate wins, only makes people tune out of the conversation.
- acdha 4y agoI think this concern has to be balanced against the billions of dollars promoting the status quo. A lot of people want to believe that all we need to do is buy electric cars, and there are multiple industries pushing that since it’s good for business while politicians like not having to tell people that lifestyle changes are necessary.
- CraigJPerry 4y ago>> A lot of people want to believe that all we need to do is buy electric cars The people i hear most vehemently arguing for ev adoption are quick to share a laundry list of all the other things we should be doing. I haven’t run across the EV-and-we’re-done brigade. I’m not dismissing that they exist but I haven’t met them.
- KennyBlanken 4y agoLiterally every time I see anything about "green transportation" from federal, state, or local government and non-profits the talk starts with and ends with electric vehicles. The feds talk some talk about alternative transit, and some cities are leaning heavily into alternate transit...but at my county and local level there's basically zero interest in public transit, walking, or biking infrastructure.
- BuyMyBitcoins 4y agoAdvocating for walkable cities and being anti-automobile is all the rage nowadays, but that doesn’t translate well to real world action. As much as we want to, and should, redesign cities, that is a monumental undertaking that will necessarily require several decades worth of effort and billions of dollars. Switching to electric vehicles, meanwhile, does not require eminent domain and does not ask citizens to change their mobility standards. It is also something local governments don’t have to pay for.
- paulryanrogers 4y ago> ...does not ask citizens to change their mobility standards. My how far we have come from "Ask not what your country can do for you, but what you can do for your country."
- sokoloff 4y agoThat challenge was to find ways to contribute in your own sphere. Converting one car to an EV (and accepting the resulting compromises) is more realistically in that spirit than something like “knock down your house and build a mid-rise on your lot” would be.
- paulryanrogers 4y agoCollective action and sacrifice will be necessary to change density. Still that doesn't prevent us from adapting to more sustainable transportation modes, both collectively and personally. I was addressing the fear that governments have of disrupting current mobility 'standards'.
- ajross 4y ago> A lot of people want to believe that all we need to do is buy electric cars, and there are multiple industries pushing that Um... who? I think it's rather the opposite: I see a "lot of people" in "multiple industries" making strawman arguments like this. Essentially, it's a deflection from "EVs are better than cars" (a clear truth that can't reasonably be argued with) to "EV proponents don't have all the answers either" (a winnable argument that feels like it's related even though it isn't). Buy the EV. Also move closer to the urban core, WFH, and otherwise reduce your dependence on the suburban road networks. But buy the EV if you need a car.
- mellosouls 4y agoEven leaving aside your dubious claim about what can and cannot be argued with, your conclusion about what choices people should make is pie in the sky for a significant part of even the developed world. Economic and logistic reasons mean that carbon fuel cars are still the best transport option for most (?) people outside of urban centres and well-paid jobs.
- ajross 4y agoThis seems like a dodge? You said lots of people were saying something, I asked for a cite.
- mellosouls 4y agoI'm not the poster you are referring to.
- b112 4y agoUpvoted, as I see you were downsmashed because you spoke of realities, not "where we want to be". What you say is true. I find "everyone EV now!" proponents, often just use handwavy platitudes when given "I can't" info. For example, for many, many people ... range is a vital, and sadly an electric EV preventive thing. When told this, EV absolutists often blather on about why a person is wrong, and do so while ignoring that person's reality. The same is valid for cost. If you are poor, and can barely afford a truck for work, telling someone to spend 2x or 3x for a EV variant is exceptionally unfeeling, unrealistic, and elitist. What we need to do, is be open to solutions to help people switch. One is H2, which has multiple cars with extensive range on the road, yet EV absolutists will start going on about green or not h2. While at the same time ignoring that all excess power in the US, currently comes from fossil fuel! Until the last fossil fuel shuts down, that is excess kept running by EV needs. But you see, the goal is not where the battery charge, or h2 comes from, it is where it can come from! We can 100% make green h2, just as we can eventually fully purge fossil fuels from our electric grid. And it takes decades to move cars and transport from fossil to alternative options. We are doing it in parallel. So that one day, when we are free of fossil use, all our cars will already be fossil free! Including poor people driving 20 year old cars!
- dheera 4y agoWhat I really don't understand is why don't Shell, Exxon, Chevron and their ilk get into the EV game and start setting up DC fast chargers at all of their gas stations? They profit, and EV range anxiety becomes a thing of the past by having chargers literally everywhere.
- pharmakom 4y agoLow profit. Accelerates decline of the cash cow.
- imtringued 4y agoBut the gas station cash cow is often the overpriced kiosk and not the gasoline.
- pharmakom 4y agoGas stations are usually franchised and the gas companies make good profit from that arrangement. The problem with supporting electric, is that most EV users don’t visit gas stations at all - they charge at home overnight.
- CharlesW 4y agoI'm guessing for the same reason innovation rarely happens within companies that are printing money by maintaining the status quo. The Innovator's Dilemma by Clayton Christensen is a good book on this, and the iPhone is another good example that had to come from outside the telecom industry. Plus, there's an impedance mismatch between EV charging times and the retail store model, in that retail stores want customers in and out ASAP.
- SECProto 4y ago> What I really don't understand is why don't Shell, Exxon, Chevron and their ilk get into the EV game and start setting up DC fast chargers at all of their gas stations? At least in Canada, there has definitely been a push in this direction. Both Petro-Can[1] and Irving[2] have set up fast charging networks at their stations. Many of the Tesla Superchargers in Canada[3] are also located at various gas stations and truck stops (that specifically benefit from more restaurant customers when they use the charger). [1] https://www.petro-canada.ca/en/personal/fuel/canadas-electric-highway https://www.petro-canada.ca/en/personal/fuel/canadas-electri... [2] https://www.irvingoil.com/en-US/on-the-road/electric-vehicle-charging https://www.irvingoil.com/en-US/on-the-road/electric-vehicle... [3] https://www.tesla.com/findus https://www.tesla.com/findus
- aqme28 4y agoI don’t fully agree. It argues that beyond the EV conversion, we also have to switch to cycling and public transit for transport.
- sfpotter 4y agoMaybe instead of criticizing the way in which the article was written you could comment on some if its actual contents. I feel like people on HN get incredibly hung up on minor things like the title of an article and can't move past that. Climate change is a big deal and HN is full of smart people. It would be nice if we could use it as a venue for discussion about interesting topics instead of whinging about things that annoy us.
- labrador 4y ago> The headline feels like someone crafted it for maximum clickbait It's written as a bait to people who have bought into the oil industry propaganda that EV's aren't a solution. "Where do you think the electricity comes from? Coal, gas and oil fueled power plants, that's where." If I had a dollar for every time I've heard this I could afford a Tesla.
- dheera 4y agoYeah I've heard this way too much too. Why are humans so bad at second-order thinking and understanding that it's possible and, barring politics, straightforward to change where electricity comes from but it's not really possible to change where gasoline comes from?
- toomuchtodo 4y ago130 million adults in the US have low literacy skills, meaning that more than half (54%) of Americans between the ages of 16 and 74 read below the equivalent of a sixth-grade level, according to a piece published in 2022 by APM Research Lab. https://www.apmresearchlab.org/10x-adult-literacy https://www.apmresearchlab.org/10x-adult-literacy My note: critical thinking is not as prevalent as one might think, and there are also folks at various levels of gov and corp acting maliciously about the topic (fossil fuel consumption, climate change) due to entrenched interests. “It is difficult to get a man to understand something when his salary depends on his not understanding it.”
- fbdab103 4y agoThat the article did not make a bigger reference to immigrants makes me suspect. What are the percentages for native English speakers vs ESL? The states with the largest rates of Level 1 are all in the southwest where I expect there to be larger numbers of native-Spanish speakers.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- andrepd 4y agoIndividual automobiles have 100 problems. EVs solve 1 of them (tailpipe emissions), leaving the other 99. Yes, I guess it's better than nothing, but... Meanwhile old boring things like trains, trams (frequent, comfortable, extensive), proper bike lanes, do more for climate change and general quality of life than replacing a petrol SUV with an electric SUV.
- PheonixPharts 4y ago> including the climate wins EVs aren't a climate win. It's just more consumption which ultimately means more energy which means more oil. Aside from that the issue has nothing to do with where the oil is consumed, but how much. The only way to stop climate change is to prevent oil from being extracted. We're currently in the process of escalating a war to extract more so I'm not optimistic about this. If EVs had an impact on US oil consumption you would expect that consumption to drop right? But 2022 was nearly a record year for US oil consumption [0]: > 20.40 million bpd in 2022 and 20.75 million bpd in 2023. That compares with a record 20.80 million bpd in 2005 EVs are just a way to keep you consuming while feeling okay about. It's not a climate win in the slightest. 0. https://www.reuters.com/markets/us/us-crude-output-petroleum-demand-rise-2022-eia-2022-09-07/ https://www.reuters.com/markets/us/us-crude-output-petroleum...
- codeulike 4y agoIf EVs had an impact on US oil consumption you would expect that consumption to drop right? Not yet, no. Barely expect it to make a dent yet. Straw man. It's not a climate win in the slightest. Why not? Why not in the slightest? You're saying its not even a teeny weeny little sliver of a climate win? We have to get away from fossil fueled transportation. Having transportation that can/can potentially be renewably powered has to be a step forward. What you're saying just seems like 'let the perfect be the enemy of the good' Please explain.
- PheonixPharts 4y ago> Straw man. Sorry but anything other than reduction in global fossil fuel consumption is that strawman. That is the only thing that matters. If everything we do is "green" and we still burn more oil than the year before that's all that matters.
- paulryanrogers 4y agoIn absolute terms more oil may be consumed, yet the cause could be growth elsewhere. Said another way EVs may have made that same growth less oil intense than the alternative.
- tppiotrowski 4y agoAnytime I see the word "assume" in an article it feels like a mechanism for subtly turning journalism into an op-ed.
- amanaplanacanal 4y agoThis article is explicitly an op-ed. Not sure what you were expecting here.
- MaysonL 4y agoMicromobility EVs may make a much bigger contribution to climate change amelioration.
- andrepd 4y agoExactly. A 3.5-ton electric SUV is marginally better than a petrol SUV. You what's better than both? An e-bike.
- zip1234 4y agoTruly, micromobility like E-bikes are cheap, require much less space, healthier and are more social. Governments do not know how to build for micromobility yet it seems.
- Tiktaalik 4y agoall it would require is building some protected bike lanes (which are very cheap to build), but that would gasp be taking space away from exclusive car use, and so is political anathema to many. This needs to change.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- mulcahey 4y ago> Perfect is the enemy of good! More at 11
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- pyrrhotech 4y agoEVs seem to not be a very well thought-out long term solution in general, unless radically different batteries with very high energy density can soon be developed. Earth has 88 million tons of lithium, of which only 1/4 is economically feasible to mine. Each Tesla battery uses about 50 kg of Li, which means only about 18 Tesla batteries can be produced per ton, or about 396 million total Tesla batteries. Current global automobile production is about 80 million per year. If society were to totally switch to EVs, we would run out within a decade or so even assuming most of these cars used far less lithium (and thus had much shorter range, limiting practicality). This back of the napkin analysis also ignores all the other competing uses of Li...
- triyambakam 4y agoAnd the mining itself is very polluting
- ravenstine 4y agoMaybe governments are helping to prop up EVs as a means of covertly hoarding lithium. Even if EVs don't work out, having an abundance of lithium could be of tremendous value. /conspiracy
- zopa 4y agoThis is in a timeline where governments are capable of long-term secret plans that move markets, but haven’t thought of strategic reserves?
- jhp123 4y agoEarth has many trillions of tons of lithium.
- mjrpes 4y agoMusk in 2022 said lithium makes up 5kg in a car battery: https://seekingalpha.com/article/4502519-tesla-inc-tsla-ceo-elon-musk-on-q1-2022-results-earnings-call-transcript https://seekingalpha.com/article/4502519-tesla-inc-tsla-ceo-...
- 4y ago
- giardia 4y agoThe Economist wrote a few months back that an EV in Japan actually produces more carbon per mile than an ICE because almost all of their energy comes from coal plants. I'm not sure if America has a radically different coal plant design which produces less carbon somehow, but ~60% of electricity in America comes from coal. [edit: 60% is fossil fuel generated, ~20% is coal] Additionally, it's going to be a massive effort to upgrade our grid (not just generation) to handle all these EVs, and America is not well situated for public transport since we built out instead of up. I don't want anyone to get the impression that EVs are bad, but people act like they're saving the world by buying a Tesla. It's not that simple. This is a very, very difficult problem and every solution has trade-offs.
- ezfe 4y agoI don't believe that it's true a fully coal powered EV produces more carbon per mile due to how inefficient combustion engines are
- giardia 4y agoI'll be honest, I haven't bothered to double check it, but it may be that coal is just that dirty.
- ezfe 4y agoI would certainly believe that the smog/pollutants from coal outweigh the benefits, but acording to this [1] Reuters article reviewing this question: > Even in the worst case scenario where an EV is charged only from a coal-fired grid, it would generate an extra 4.1 million grams of carbon a year while a comparable gasoline car would produce over 4.6 million grams, the Reuters analysis showed.
- com2kid 4y ago> The Economist wrote a few months back that an EV in Japan actually produces more carbon per mile than an ICE because almost all of their energy comes from coal plants. I'm not sure if America has a radically different coal plant design which produces less carbon somehow, but ~60% of electricity in America comes from coal. It is easier to upgrade a (comparative) small number of power plants than it is to make everyone's ICE engine more efficient. > Additionally, it's going to be a massive effort to upgrade our grid (not just generation) to handle all these EVs. The amount of work needed to upgrade our grid to handle the increased usage of air conditioning due to global warming is greater than the work needed to support EVs.
- Zigurd 4y agoThe article headline sets up a straw man. EVs do two important things: take a diffuse source of CO2 and other pollutants, and confine the problem to large-scale power plants. They also cut smog in cities where people are most exposed to pollution. Other commenters here have noted that small EVs like scooters are an important part of electrifying transport. A lot of cities would smell a lot better with electric scooters replacing gas scooters.
- sillywalk 4y agoI feel like I'm missing something fundamental about the whole EV thing. 1. Produce/transport a bunch of electric vehicles, producing massive emissions 2. ??? 3. Somehow billions of tonnes of carbon get removed from the atmosphere I fail to see how EVs do anything to actually do something about the problem i.e. REMOVE CO2 from the atmosphere.
- howtousethetime 4y agoThe idea, as I understand it, is that: A. Before the 2038 date the article suggests we must move to EV by, many/most cars will need to be replaced. So, the suggestion isn't necessarily to throw away good cars, as much as to replace them with an EV when they are replaced. B. Currently the electricity used to charge your EV may not be emission free, but someday it might be. Whereas gasoline will never be emission free. And if everyone has EV's already, then the benefit of cleaning the grid becomes greater and easier to justify to a decisionmaker. So while EVs wont solve the problem, it maybe could be said that the problem cannot be solved without first switching to EVs.
- kristopolous 4y agoIt's a giant decrease in aggregate emissions. Some people say we should go all in on mass transit. Alright cool. Suburbia doesn't work then. We're going to have to massively build our way out of this any way you slice it. EVs are an incremental improvement and that's how all goals are reached. Some people argue "What if you have a coal plant from the 1830s and that's powering the EV and we compare it with some sleek next gen hybrid" and we're all supposed to pretend that's not just some classic bullshit artist play. The stupidity gives me a headache. Why are we entertaining such transparent lies as if they're being given in good faith?
- sillywalk 4y agoThe point I'm trying to make (or get) is that EVs (or solar panels/wind turbines) don't actually do anything to actually fix the root problem - too much CO2 in the atmosphere. All of the emissions required to produce them in fact make the problem worse. Even if the world ICE vehicle fleet was magically converted to EVs powered by carbon-free fusion power tomorrow, I fail to see how this will actually lower the CO2 from 414ppm.
- jakewins 4y agoThe head of IEA they are referring to, Birol, wrote an op-ed on why the explosion of EVs is fundamental for the climate transition just a few months ago: https://edition.cnn.com/2022/09/23/perspectives/iea-electric-cars-clean-energy/index.html https://edition.cnn.com/2022/09/23/perspectives/iea-electric... Why would IEEE use a quote from 2017 from some Norwegian blog to make it seem IEAs position is the opposite of what it actually is?
- cat_plus_plus 4y agoWe are talking 2050 right? Why would most people keep a separate self-driving EV in the garage? Just hail one through an app and it will drive you on your trip, 1 mile or 500 miles. Some people just enjoy shaming others for living pleasant lives when technology is already available to preserve each activity while keeping carbon emissions down and is not standing still - in fact the rate of technological advancement of humanity is accelerating over time. Lab grown meat can be cheaper, tastier and healthier than one from a whole animal. See your less important travel destinations in high quality VR. Or if you still want organic meat or a non-VRable beach vacation, enjoy, we have carbon capture and biofuel tech to get you covered. Progress is about giving choices, not taking away choices.
- mrshadowgoose 4y ago> Some people just enjoy shaming others for living pleasant lives I've observed that most people have some instinctual need to hate on some other sub-group of society, and blame them for the world's problems. For a lot of people that subgroup seems to be "car users". We could collectively be focusing on decarbonizing all energy production, and building excess energy production capacity to offset any remaining carbon production, and even start winding back the damage we've done so far. And then it wouldn't matter one bit what mode of transportation you used, or what you used energy towards. But it's easier to divide ourselves and hate on each other.
- KennyBlanken 4y agoEVs absolutely help, but they don't address any of the myriad of problems inherent in low occupancy vehicle transportation. One person in a car requires more resources (energy, parking space, space on the road while in use, the cost of the vehicle and its maintenance, damage to roads, injuries/deaths from crashes, etc) If we spent even some money spent on self-driving vehicles on public transit infrastructure, we'd get immediate gains and it would in particular help those who are on the bottom rungs of the ladder economically - making it easier for them to contribute toward society, and causing fewer problems to boot (such as the enormous costs of trying to maintain a cheaper/older car, causing a crash because their vehicle is poorly maintained, or they fell asleep while driving from working 2-3 jobs, etc.)
- andrepd 4y agoAbsolutely nailed. EVs solve one problem about ICE cars. Not the other 99.
- imtringued 4y agoGovernments don't tax land so they have no incentive to invest in good public transport. Most transportation projects massively increase property values which is then captured by landlords instead of governments and then everyone complains that public transport doesn't work and can't fund itself and people wonder why politicians invest in boondoggles to immortalise themselves instead of acting more like a business that prioritizes useful investments because it increases future tax revenue. Land value taxes make way more sense than income taxes because they are location based. If a politician makes a mistake and you move away they will get your income tax regardless. So they have no reason to invest in any given location.
- dragonwriter 4y ago> Governments don’t tax land They…actually do.
- lnsru 4y agoI see on some days, that electricity generation in Germany is 45% coal and 20% gas. With all transmission and storage losses the EVs are almost coal powered then. I know, it’s very rough estimation. But with coal powered cars not much positive can be done against climate change.
- timbit42 4y agoAn EV running on coal-generated electricity is still cleaner than an ICEV.
- AstixAndBelix 4y agoDecrease need for private transportation. Heavily push for EVs. Allow combustion engines when actually necessary instead of banning everything like a bunch of blind ideologues. Clean up the air from carbon to compensate.
- api 4y agoNothing is a “panacea.”
- osigurdson 4y agoI think any solution that involves things getting worse for people is a non-starter. EVs will soon reach the point where it makes no sense to purchase an ICE vehicle. That is the model to shoot for - make the bad stuff obsolete. When the bad stuff is obsolete already (WFO is a good example), lets do our best to take advantage of it.
- college_physics 4y agoPeople are hoping for a quick sustainability fix but that is not on offer. Our current footprint on the global environment took at least a century of population growth and technological expansion to manifest. Car based cities are just one of the designs we are stuck with. EV's will play some role to keep that pattern workable, but it may well be that other ways of organising life and the economy will prove better adapted and more efficient in the midterm (~20 yrs) Keep in mind that co2 is just one of the many constraints we are increasingly bumping against. The age of innocence is gone. On the other hand there is nothing sacred about how we organized things since 1900 or so...
- nkingsy 4y agoDon’t know where to put this, but utility rates in northern California have gotten to the point where it’s cheaper to drive my prius than my EV from a fuel standpoint, and that’s using the special off peak EV rate. If you have net metering and solar, great, but at this point if you’re not a homeowner with grandfathered nem 2.0, Evs make no sense in northern ca.
- agilob 4y agoPretty much the same in most of Europe. Electric trams are stopped where I lived, council resigned from buying electric buses, some nearby cities even turn on only one side of street lights, charging EV is more expensive than diesel for the same range.
- jeffrogers 4y agoEven factoring in probable range increases and advances in charging tech, it will still be necessary to incrementally, if not fully, charge EVs in public. One thing that doesn’t seem to occur to our elected officials… there is nowhere near enough real estate to charge that many vehicles around town.
- timbit42 4y agoUse existing parking spaces.
- acdha 4y agoHow hard would it be to put plugs onto street lights? Most cities have wiring and the switch to LED bulbs means those circuits have a lot more spare capacity than they used to.
- longitudinal93 4y agoNew Westminster ( part of metro Vancouver) has been doing exactly that: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=KaBLOGakGfg https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=KaBLOGakGfg
- tzs 4y agoThe average amount driven per day by Americans is 39 miles, meaning that a heck of a lot of people will be able to do just fine with only charging at home.
- varelse 4y ago[dead]
- fwungy 4y ago1) Climate modeling is hard. There have been substantial shifts in the climate over time, including five ice ages. 2) Climate change predictions have been repeatedly wrong. In the 80's they said the Maldives would be submerged by 2000, for example. Maldives are still there. 3) if the models are good then things like the costs of coastal real estate should show it. Coastal real estate is still premium so either the models are wrong or the banks are ignoring the models and lend huge amounts on property thar will soon be reclaimed by the sea. 4) There are people and countries with trillions on pil reserve wealth who will be reduced to poverty in a fossil free world. Are they going to cooperate with their own impoverishment based on weak, poorly performing climate models produced by antagonistic western states? 5) There is a huge installed base of fossil fuels in the developing world. The energy density and portability of fossils is great for places with limited infrastructure. How do you convert them? 6) Nuclear is the only realistic approach to mass scale decarbonization. Why is this ignored. If you believe the climate models then we should accept the stochastic risks of nuclear over the absolute risk of climate in the near future. Is not the risk of an occasional Chernobyl better than planet wide destruction and degradation. 7) The past few years have demonstrated the danger of alarmists reacting to scary looking model data that they don't fully understand. 8) Addressing climate change directly at the source is intractable for the reasons I've listed. Mitigation approaches are going to pay much better dividends than multi moon shot green technology agendas.
- CJefferson 4y ago2) By "they said the Maldives would be submerged by 2000", this seems to be one report which was the basis for for a full study of the problem by the UN. Do you agree there have been notable, significant, temperature rises over the last 100 years, which appear to be a significantly faster change than in previous ice ages?
- fwungy 4y agoShow me the detailed climate data for the past 20 million years. Oh, you can't. Why? Because there is no data. It's all modeled. To be clear I'm not denying anthropogenic climate change, I'm questioning the strategies employed . A hundred years of data amongst millions is insignificant. We don't know what proportion is anthropogenic and which is the larger climate trend that is beyond our control. Regardless, the logical optimization is nuclear and mitigation, not a suicidal unilateral rush into zero GHG. Under that approach if the multiple technogical breakthroughs never come we are in worse shape than if we had not done anything.
- stevespang 4y ago[dead]
- Tiktaalik 4y ago> International Council on Clean Transportation (ICCT) argues that EVs are the quickest means to decarbonize motorized transport. However, EVs are not by themselves in any way going to achieve the goal of net zero by 2050. Yep. Technically correct, but an example of shooting for the wrong goal, and failing entirely. The goal is not making our motorized transport system low carbon. The goal is limiting the damage of climate change and keeping a lid on temperature rises. If we constrain our solution set to maintaining the same sort of motorized transport system we will fail. I would like to hope that software engineers on this site reading this would recognize such a problem. It is like when, fundamentally, the design of a program from the get go was wrong from the first foot forward and as a result it's simply too slow. No amount of fiddling around the edges, hacks and minor fixes will result in an adequate improvement. Only a new design is a real fix. Thankfully in many ways it's actually easier to fix cities than to fix a major software project. For one thing we at least know the solutions, and they're easily achievable given political will and with not a great deal of money. (not easily around on a software project!) Most of the issues come more from political restriction than anything else, and so much can be done by simply letting people do things that they're currently banned from doing (ie. let people build more housing). Couple that with some relatively affordable bike lanes and rapid bus lanes, and one can achieve remarkable improvements with relatively little capital expenditure and effort. > Even a few US cities it might be livable without a car. Musing that better things are maybe possible in "a few" US cities is dramatically low ambition and out of touch. Consider that 45% of Vancouver's West End commutes to work by walking. That's a neighbourhood of 45,000 in a major NA city. There's absolutely nothing going on remarkably here that accounts for this excepting the simple fact that it's a bunch of 1960s era residential apartments in a pleasant tree lined area within a 20 minute walking distance of Vancouver's Downtown. That's it. I'm pretty sure this concept is quite replicable in cities across America.
- longitudinal93 4y agoThey've also made it very unpleasant to own a car in the West End - parking is extremely limited or requires a special pass. There are very few thru- streets so all car journeys are convoluted, etc. And support for alternatives is plentiful - bus service is excellent, bike lanes and routes are abundant, there are numerous and frequent bike share stations, etc. It's definitely a great place to live.
- afrodon 4y ago[dead]
- xnx 4y agoEVs have the most effect on atmospheric carbon when they are saving money over an ICE vehicle. If the all-in cost (vehicle, fuel, parts, repair, etc.) per mile traveled isn't less, it's very unlikely there is lower carbon emitted.