13 ms·
This company is either run by someone who doesn't understand the tech or is willfully fraudulent. ChatGPT and company are far from good enough to be entrusted w
by lolinder 4y ago
This company is either run by someone who doesn't understand the tech or is willfully fraudulent. ChatGPT and company are far from good enough to be entrusted with law. Having interacted extensively with modern LLMs, I absolutely know something like this would happen:
> Defendant (as dictated by AI): The Supreme Court ruled in Johnson v. Smith in 1978...
> Judge: There was no case Johnson v. Smith in 1978.
LLMs hallucinate, and there is absolutely no space for hallucination in a court of law. The legal profession is perhaps the closest one to computer programming, and absolute precision is required, not a just-barely-good-enough statistical machine.
- intrasight 4y ago>absolute precision is required LOL - you gotta be kidding. In software, we strive for that - by running tests. In the law, there are no tests. Not saying that absolute precision isn't required. I know lots of cases were an extra comma, a wrong date, or a signature from the wrong person has cost someone tens of millions of dollars. I would argue that AI-based tools could prevent such HUMAN mistakes.
- geraneum 4y ago> I would argue that AI-based tools could prevent such HUMAN mistakes. Still you won’t find a useful/sober lawyer who would argue a case in front of a judge based on a made up precedent which never existed in reality. Making a mistake as you put it, in humans, is quite different than “hallucinations” of an LLM. The practical AI tool that is good for preventing such human mistakes (precisely) doesn’t exist _yet_.
- chrsig 4y ago> LLMs hallucinate, and there is absolutely no space for hallucination in a court of law. Well, _someone_ doesn't have enough schizophrenia in their life.
- Spooky23 4y agoI agree in many cases, except traffic court isn’t real court. It’s mostly procedural. Hell in my state, in many cases the judge is a person who wins an election and takes a 20 hour course, and prosecutions are conducted by police officers. Lawyers like to wax about the interests of justice. Reality is for crap like this, it’s a revenue funnel where there’s a pecking order of people who get breaks. Some small fraction have an actual legal dispute of facts. I’d argue that you could best serve the interests of justice by bringing the whole process online. You’d eliminate the “friends and family” discount and have a real tribunal process for cases that need it, instead of the cattle call and mockery that these courts are. NYC actually does a decent job with this by outsourcing the whole thing to DMV and administrative law judges on a tight leash. It’s mostly justice by flowchart. That pushes bullshit down to the police.
- ChrisRR 4y agoChatGPT Is currently very insistent that there is no letter T in Saturday. That alone should be proof enough that you can't blindly trust it Even then, before the December update it was sure that there was a T in Sunday
- gfodor 4y agoIf this is the case, the lawyers should have nothing to fear, and the plaintiff nothing to lose but a parking ticket. I say we stop arguing and run the experiment.
- lolinder 4y agoNon-lawyers aren't banned from giving legal advice because lawyers are trying to protect their jobs, they're banned from giving legal advice because they're likely to be bad at it, and the people who take their advice are likely to be hurt. Yes, in this case, it would just be a parking ticket, but the legal system runs on precedent and it's safer to hold a strict line than to create a fuzzy "well, it depends on how much is at stake" line. If we know that ChatGPT is not equipped to give legal advice in the general case, there's no reason to allow a company to sell it as a stand-in for a lawyer. (I would feel differently about a defendant deciding to use the free ChatGPT in this way, because they would be deliberately ignoring the warnings ChatGPT gives. It's the fact that someone decided to make selling AI legal advice into a business model that makes it troubling.)
- enraged_camel 4y ago>> Non-lawyers aren't banned from giving legal advice because lawyers are trying to protect their jobs, they're banned from giving legal advice because they're likely to be bad at it, and the people who take their advice are likely to be hurt. But why would the opposing side's lawyers care about this? They presumably want their client to win the lawsuit.
- greiskul 4y agoWell, it is supposed to be a Justice system, and not a game. While it is very easy to forget that, and many of the participants in it clearly don't behave as such, the outcome of it should be to be just.
- freejazz 4y agoWhen did the opposing side's lawyers say anything about this? Are you confused? Law is a regulated profession. The lawyers pointing out that this is illegal aren't on the other side of the case...
- ethanbond 4y agoDoNotPay seems to know very well what they’re doing. It really doesn’t strike me as true that law requires absolute precision. There are many adjacent (both near and far) arguments that can work in law for any given case, since the interpreter is a human. You just need no silly mistakes that shatter credibility, but that’s very different from “get one thing wrong and the system doesn’t work at all or works in wildly unexpected ways.” Low end law will be one of the first areas to go due to this tech. DoNotPay actually has already been doing this stuff successfully for a while (not in court proceedings themselves though).
- lolinder 4y agoThere are also many adjacent algorithms that could solve the same problem, but you still need to execute the algorithm correctly. LLMs are not ready for unsupervised use in any domain outside of curiosity, and what DoNotPay is proposing would be to let one roam free in a courtroom. I'm not at all opposed to using LLMs in the research and discovery phase. But having a naive defendant with no legal experience parroting an LLM in court is deeply problematic, even if the stakes are low in this particular category of law.
- ethanbond 4y agoThat’s nowhere near analogous because between every working algorithm are massive gulfs of syntactic and semantic failure zones. This is not the case with human language, which is the whole power of both language production and language interpretation. Is it more problematic than this person 1) not being represented, 2) having to pay exorbitant fees to be represented, or 3) having an extremely overworked and disinterested public defender? I’m not convinced. The idea that we need to wait to do this stuff until the people whose profession is under threat give “permission” is dismissible on its face and is exactly why we should be doing this is as quickly as possible. For what it’s worth, I mostly agree with you: I’m doubtful the technology is there yet. But that’s a call for each defendant to make in each new case and so long as they’re of sound mind, they should be free to pick whatever legal counsel they want.
- 4y ago
- criddell 4y agoIt would be kind of funny to hear an argument made by an LLM that has digested all the sovereign citizen bs.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- jonathanwallace 4y ago> there is absolutely no space for hallucination in a court of law I wish you were factually correct here. We've seen time and time again where courts are mockeries of the ideal because of the people in them and the faults they bring with them. E.g. see https://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/21pdf/21-418_i425.pdf https://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/21pdf/21-418_i425.pdf and the documented proof in the dissent contradicting the claims in the ruling.
- lolinder 4y agoThat there exist mockeries of justice is not proof that we should allow them.
- jonathanwallace 4y ago100% Agreed. Rhetorical question: Now what's the enforcement mechanism? (Also, what's with the downvotes?!?!)
- Miraste 4y agoThat case, to me, is indicative of a larger problem - it's 75 pages of arcane justifications, and yet I already knew how all of the justices had voted just from reading the premise, because like every Supreme Court case in a politicized area it was decided by personal conviction and the rest is post-hoc rationalization. There is no hallucination on the part of the humans involved, only intellectual dishonesty.
- eloff 4y agoI think you’re right here and it’s the same reason I see AI as a tool in the software profession. You can use it to speed up your work, but you have to have someone fully trained who can tell the difference between looks good but is wrong, versus is actually usable. I’ve been using copilot for half a year now and it’s helpful, but often wrong. I carefully verify anything it gives me before using it. I’ve had one bug that made it to production where I think copilot inserted code that I didn’t notice and which slipped past code review. I’ve had countless garbage suggestions I ignored, and a surprising amount of code that seemed reasonable but was subtly broken. This will still require a human lawyer (and/or intern, depending on the stakes) to check its output carefully. I am not now, nor have I ever been afraid that AI is coming after my job. When it does, we’re dangerously close to general AI and a paradigm shift of such magnitude and consequence that it’s called The Singularity. At which point we may have bigger worries than jobs.
- HeyZuess 4y ago> I’ve been using copilot for half a year now and it’s helpful, but often wrong. I wonder if that is because of the training set, us humans are often wrong or different. If given a room of programmers and asked to implement a Fibonacci algorithm would they all get it right, would they all do it via iteration, recursion, dynamic programming. Co-pilot might not replace you, but it just needs to replace some of those programmers. Then add tools like automated AI reviews or integration tests for example and now you removed another population of tech workers. I am not sure if that is cause for alarm or the fact that such improvements could be rather beneficial. Some tools will replace people, some will be assistive, and as they improve and other layers are added they will reduce the need for people in areas, improving efficiency and productivity. Robots in manufacturing for example, improve productivity and reduce human labor. And this leads on to this, these tools are narrow to general and have achieved this in a very short period of time. The cost factors have also massively reduced, if you could pay OpenAI $10 a month to make 1000 mistakes and still deliver code, or a human $120k a year to do the same then which one would you target. AI might not be coming for your job soon but it will be taking away your options to get a job. This is not unique to AI it is the basis for any technological improvement vs labor, yes new ideas and opportunities may come out of this but I don't think they will be equal in volume.
- ma2rten 4y agoYou could probably do much better than ChatGPT if you built a bot specifically for being a lawyer.
- lolinder 4y agoYes, you'd do better, but you'd still have a LLM that is designed to predict the most likely next words. It would still hallucinate and invent case law, it would just be even harder for a non-lawyer to recognize the hallucination.
- yubiox 4y agoLLM means Master of Law degree, kind of an advanced JD used in some specializations like tax. What do you mean here?
- pulisse 4y agoIn this context it means Large Language Model.
- appletrotter 4y agoLarge Language Model
- TheDudeMan 4y agoWhat would happen if a human lawyer did that?
- ruined 4y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Disbarment https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Disbarment
- winReInstall 4y agoEh, what if it was trained on all the previous cases ever to have existed? I think it could be pretty good, as long as it detects novelty as a to flag and confirm error case.
- bastawhiz 4y agoThat's not the point. LLMs work by predicting what text to generate next. It doesn't work by choosing facts, it works by saying the thing that sounds the most appropriate. That's why it's so confidently wrong. No amount of training will eliminate this problem: it's an issue with the architecture of LLMs today.
- lolinder 4y agoYou could layer another system on top of the LLM generations that attempts to look up cases referenced and discards the response if they don't exist, but that only solves that particular failure mode. There are other kinds of failures that will be much harder to detect: arguments that sound right but are logically flawed, lost context due to inability to read body language and tone of voice, and lack of a coherent strategy, to name a few. All of these things could theoretically be solved individually, but each would require new systems to be added which have their own new failure modes. At our current technological level the problem is intractable, even for seemingly simple cases like this one. A defendant is better off defending themselves with their own preparation than they are relying on modern AI in the heat of the moment.
- dinkumthinkum 4y agoIt’s bizarre that anyone that supposedly works in technology even thinks this is realistic. This betrays a large lack of knowledge of technology and a child like understanding of the legal system.
- dinkumthinkum 4y agoIt fails at determining if a number is prime and provides bogus arguments to such effect. You think it would make sense for this to argue complex legal cases with strategy? This isn’t Go or chess.
- gnicholas 4y agoExactly. I asked it for books on Hong Kong history and it spit out five complete fabrications. The titles were plausible and authors were real people, but none of them had written the books listed.
- LeifCarrotson 4y agoCan you follow up and ask it "Is [title] by [author] a published book?
- lolinder 4y agoI just tried, and it did issue a correction and gave me five new books, several of which were also fictitious. But the real question is, could you follow up with a question as it dictating to you live in a courtroom?
- weatherlite 4y agoThey will pretty soon be able to fact check everything they say when they gain real time internet connectivity. But for now yeah you're right. A year-two from now this won't be true anymore.
- Phlarp 4y agoAI hallucinations are going to be the new database query injection. Saying that real time internet connected fact checking will solve that is every bit as naive as thinking the invention of higher level database abstractions like an ORM will solve trivially injectable code. We can't even make live fact checking work with humans at the wheel. Legacy code bases are so prolific and terrible we're staring down the barrel of a second major industry crises for parsing dates past 2037, but sure LLM's are totally going to get implemented securely and updated regularly unlike all the other software in the world.
- sigmoid10 4y agoI'd also argue that "hallucination" is, at least in some form, pretty commonplace in courtrooms. Neither lawyers' nor judges' memories are foolproof and eyewitness studies show that humans don't even realise how much stuff their brain makes up on the spot to fill blanks. If nothing else, I expect AI to raise awareness for human flaws in the current system.
- lolinder 4y agoThat the legal system has flaws isn't a good argument for allowing those flaws to become automated. If we're going to automate a task, we should expect it to better, not worse or just as bad (at this stage it would definitely be worse).
- dinkumthinkum 4y agoNo shot. It is not commonplace there that lawyers and judges are making ridiculous arguments or citing fictional case law.
- aardvarkr 4y agoBeing connected to the internet may make their information more up to date but they won’t stop being confidently incorrect. These language models are amazing at token prediction but it’s a mistake to believe that they’re actually intelligent. Give it an inane prompt to better see the difference, like "write me an essay about camels and their value in cybersecurity" which gives us the answer "The camel is a valuable animal in the cybersecurity field due to its ability to store large amounts of data in its hump. Camels are able to cross vast distances with little water, which makes them ideal for carrying large amounts of data across networks. They are also very sturdy animals, able to withstand harsh conditions and even attacks from cyber criminals. In addition, their long eyelashes protect their eyes from sand and dust, making them perfect for working in dusty environments such as data centers." Having internet access wouldn’t fix this.
- phpisthebest 4y ago>>The legal profession is perhaps the closest one to computer programming There is a ton of people using ChatGPT for programming.... so much so that I wonder if we will have a crisis in skills as people forgo how to write code. sysadmin circles have tons people celebrating how they will not have to learn powershell now as an example
- godshatter 4y agoChatGPT has no concept of a model for code, no understanding of syntax or logic or even language keywords. It just pulls info out of it's backside that sounds believable like a lot of people do, it's just better at it. I suspect the immediate future will be resplendent with tales of AI-generated code causing catastrophes.
- gptgpp 4y agoI agree, but it doesn't have to be that way. I've been learning a couple new languages and frameworks lately and found it really accelerates my learning, increases enjoyment, and is good at explaining the silly mistakes that I make. So it can enhance skills just as much as it can atrophy them. And I'm okay with some skills atrophying... I hate writing regular expressions, but they're so useful for some situations. It's a shame chatGPT fails so hard at them, otherwise I would be content to never use a regex again.
- dinkumthinkum 4y agoThere’s a lot of people doing a big circle jerk over ChatGPT with wild ideas of singularity and oddly eagerly awaiting the end of white collar work. Whatever. I agree that programmers being obsessed with it can lead to skill atrophy. But, in reality, there are many people that are very technical and are not becoming reliant on these things for coding.
- mattwad 4y agoi use copilot every day, and it's never written more than one line at a time that didn't need adjusting. If you are letting an AI write code for you without knowing what it does, you should not be in programming. I would probably just fire someone if their response to me was ever "well the AI wrote that bit of code that deleted our DB, i didnt know what it did"
- AlexTWithBeard 4y agoI don't see the problem here. > Defendant (as dictated by AI): The Supreme Court ruled in Johnson v. Smith in 1978... > Judge: There was no case Johnson v. Smith in 1978. Case closed, here's your fine. Next time please be more careful picking the lawyer.
- barbazoo 4y agoDo judges know about all prior cases or do they check when they hear one referenced? It feels like this could easily slip through, no?
- dinkumthinkum 4y agoThat’s not how the legal system works. You aren’t slipping anything through. Either the judge knows the case, they don’t know all the cases, or the judge will research or clerks will research and you will be sanctioned if you try to do so thing unethical.
- AlexTWithBeard 4y agoIANAL, but I'd think in this case this is prosecutor's job. Also, the original post is about the traffic ticket. I'm pretty sure if the judge hears a reference to something he had never heard before, he'll be like "huh? wtf?"
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- torstenvl 4y ago"Counsel, I'm unfamiliar with the case you've cited. Have you brought a copy for the court? No? How about a bench brief? Very well. I am going to excuse the panel for lunch and place the court in recess. Members of the jury, please return at 1:00. Counsel, please arrive with bench briefs including printouts of major cases at 12:30. Court stands in recess." bang "All rise!"
- torstenvl 4y agoWell, the problem is that the defendant has a right to competent representation, and ineffective assistance of counsel fails to fulfill that right. (Your hypothetical includes a fine, so it isn't clear whether the offense in your hypothetical is one with, shall we say, enhanced sixth amendment protections under Gideon and progeny, or even one involving a criminal offense rather than a simple civil infraction, but...) in many cases lack of a competent attorney is considered structural error, meaning automatic reversal. In practice, that means that judges (who are trying to prevent their decisions from being overturned) will gently correct defense counsel and guide them toward competence, something that frustrated me when I was a prosecutor but which the system relies upon.
- barbazoo 4y agoMaybe that's where we're headed. It looks like it's becoming more and more okay to just make things up to please your tribe. Why shouldn't that seep into the courtroom. I hope this doesn't happen.
- mountainb 4y agoWhat's interesting is that sometimes it does a great job at something like telling you the holdings of a case, but then other times it gives you a completely incorrect response. If you ask it for things like "the X factor test from Johnson v. Smith" sometimes it will dutifully report the correct test in bullets, but other times will say the completely wrong thing. The issue I think is that it's pulling from too many sources. There are plenty of sources that are pretty machine readable that will give it good answers. There's a lot of training that can be eked out from the legal databases that already exist that could make it a lot better. If it takes in too much information from too many sources, it tends to get garbled. There are also a lot of areas where it will confuse concepts from different areas of law, like mixing up criminal battery with civil battery, but that's not the worst of the problems.
- lolinder 4y ago> The issue I think is that it's pulling from too many sources. There are plenty of sources that are pretty machine readable that will give it good answers. There's a lot of training that can be eked out from the legal databases that already exist that could make it a lot better. If it takes in too much information from too many sources, it tends to get garbled. No, this is a common misunderstanding about the way these things work. A LLM is not really pulling from any sources specifically. It has no concept of a source. It has a bunch of weights that were trained to predict the next likely word, and those weights were tuned by feeding in a large amount of text from the internet. Improving the quality of the sources used to train the weights would likely help, but would not solve the fundamental problem that this isn't actually a lossless knowledge compression algorithm. It's a statistical machine designed to guess the next word. That makes it fundamentally non-deterministic and unsuitable for any task where factual correctness matters (and there's no knowledgeable human in the loop to issue corrections).
- mountainb 4y agoIf that's true, then it'll never get to the point that it would need to, and its reliability would always be too low to use.
- humans2 4y agoHumans hallucinate too: https://youtu.be/lyu7v7nWzfo https://youtu.be/lyu7v7nWzfo We are unique in the universe but not important to its existence. Our automated inference technologies are accurately representing is; I read half a dozen STEM papers last year, even more during lockdown. Comma splices, grammatical errors everywhere. ChatGPT is us in the aggregate. Even the geniuses of our species are imperfect and hallucinate being better than they are given their accomplishments relative to the laymen. The court of law is itself an ephemeral hallucination which fails all the time; given the number of people proven innocent, it’s been suggested through analysis up to 25% or more may be incarcerated incorrectly. Drug laws are just one instance of humans hallucinating correct application of courts. YT broke a while back when it AI got hung up on circular logic in a debate about copyright (easily googled). The burden of proof of “correctness” is on humans to prove their society is not merely a titillating hallucination. We made computing machines before we had all the abstract semantics to describe it. Do those semantics mean anything to the production of computing machine or are they just a jargon bubble for a minority to memorize and capitalize on relative to those who have no idea wtf they’re talking about.
- jchw 4y agoPretty sure the whole reason why DoNotPay actually exists is because defending against parking tickets didn't actually require a strong defense. The tickets were flawed automation, and their formulaic nature justified and equally formulaic response, or something to that effect. Whether the LLM was actually going to output answers directly, or just be used to drive a behavior tree or something like that, is a question I don't see answered anywhere. That said, if it's such a catastrophically stupid idea, I'm not really sure why it had to be shot down so harshly: seems like that problem would elegantly solve itself. I assume the real reason it was shot down was out of fear that it would work well. Does anyone else have a better explanation for why there was such a visceral response?
- dragonwriter 4y ago> That said, if it's such a catastrophically stupid idea, I'm not really sure why it had to be shot down so harshly To avoid the catastrophy that makes it a catastrophically bad idea. > I assume the real reason it was shot down was out of fear that it would work well. Does anyone else have a better explanation for why there was such a visceral response? It had already worked badly (subpoenaeing the key adverse witness, who would provide a basically automatic defense win, and one of the most common wins for this kind of case, if they failed to show up.)
- rafaelero 4y agoA traffic ticket is hardly a catastrophy.
- WinstonSmith84 4y agoThis is the obvious point: they fear it would work well and they will have to slowly say good bye to their extremely well paid profession. We are so close from a new disruptive revolution where a lot of jobs (not just lawyers) will be made obsolete. Possibly similar to inventions like assembly lines, or cars. Such an exciting time to be alive!
- 2muchcoffeeman 4y ago>That said, if it's such a catastrophically stupid idea, I'm not really sure why it had to be shot down so harshly The title of the article seems misleading. A techbro who doesn't appear to be a lawyer or has any understanding of the law wants to use AI so people can defend themselves. It doesn't seem like any of this was done with input from any bar associations. Without seeing the emails and "threats", and ignoring the emotional language it sounds like these people were helping him out: >"In particular, Browder said one state bar official noted that the unauthorized practice of law is a misdemeanor in some states punishable up to six months in county jail." Were these emails "angry" or just stating very plainly and with forceful language, that if you do this without the AI having the appropriate qualifications, you are most probably going to jail? It even sounds like Browder didn't really widely publicise the fact that a case defended by an AI was about to happen. >As word got out, an uneasy buzz began to swirl among various state bar officials, according to Browder. He says angry letters began to pour in. Really sounds like these letter writers did him a favour.
- kjkjadksj 4y agoAt the same time, all these cases are on the internet somewhere. It wouldn’t be too tricky to make a lawyer gpt that is heavily trained on existing legal documents, and is only allowed to quote verbatim from real sources.
- dclowd9901 4y agoThis was never meant in good faith. The company did for the PR and got the PR.
- PostOnce 4y agoThe AI is also _deceptively_ "right". For example, it will cite precedent that has since been superseded. A non-lawyer representing themselves in a criminal case would overlook that, make a bad/wrong/misinformed argument, and go to jail. In other fields, it'll lie to you about the thickness of steel pipe required to transport water at a certain pressure, it'll refer to programming libraries that don't exist, and it'll claim something impossible in one breath and happily explain it as fact in the next.
- bostonsre 4y agoIn the court itself there would definitely be no way to trust them right now, but I could see AI being a useful research tool for cases. It could find patterns and suggest cases for someone that is qualified to look further into. No idea how hard it is for lawyers to find relevant cases now, but seems like it could be a tough problem.
- lolinder 4y agoYes, absolutely. As a senior software engineer, Copilot has been invaluable in helping me to do things faster. But having an expert human in the loop is key: someone has to know when the AI did it wrong. What's so bad about this experiment isn't that they tried to use AI in law, it's that they tried to use AI without a knowledgeable human in the loop.
- narrator 4y agoIf you make a ridiculous argument using confabulated case law as a lawyer, you can be subject to discipline by the state bar and even lose your law license. The legal system's time and attention is not free and unlimited and that's why you need a license to practice law. The judges and so forth don't want to deal with a bunch of people talking nonsense. Who is the lawyer who is putting their reputation on the line for the AI's argument? The people doing this want to say nobody is at fault for the obviously bogus arguments it's going to spout. That's why it's unacceptable.
- dragonwriter 4y agoIronically, I recently saw a convo on Twitter where someone was showing off a ChatGPT generated legal argument, and, it had done exactly that, hallucinated a case to cite.
- enoch2090 4y ago> Defendant (as dictated by AI): The Supreme Court ruled in Johnson v. Smith in 1978... > Judge: There was no case Johnson v. Smith in 1978. > Defendant (as dictated by AI): Yes, you are right, there was no case Johnson v. Smith in 1978.
- AnimalMuppet 4y agoAt which point you have seriously annoyed the judge, and made him/her/justice-of-other-gender scrutinize your points much more skeptically.
- computerex 4y agoYes it's true that LLMs hallucinate facts, but there are ways to control that. Despite the challenges they can spit out perfectly functional code to spec to boot. So for me it's not too much of a stretch to think that it'd do a reasonably good job at defending simple cases.
- dukeofdoom 4y agoThat's hilarious, watch some of the trails on courtTV on youtube. The trials are are as culturally biased as you can get. And these ones are the ones we get to see. Judges are not some logical Spock! Free of influence, politics, and current group think. But people who think about their careers, public opinion and know who pays their paycheck. And these are the the competent ones. I remember judge Judy proclaiming "If it doesn't make sense, it's not true!!!", while screaming at some goy. This is pretty much the level of logic you can expect from a judge.
- burkaman 4y agoCourt TV is not real court and is not anything like real court.
- dukeofdoom 4y agoThe TV one wasn't, but the youtube one actually it is, https://www.youtube.com/c/courttv https://www.youtube.com/c/courttv And judges as a group are some of the most deferential to authority people you can get.
- BlueTemplar 4y agoWell duh, law and justice are culturally biased by definition, that's why they are different in different jurisdictions.