5 ms·
Google has been slow because they can’t figure out how to release this without destroying their business model. It’s very hard to be commercially successful wi
by brookst 4y ago
Google has been slow because they can’t figure out how to release this without destroying their business model.
It’s very hard to be commercially successful with an innovation when it attacks the cash cow side of your business. It can be done, but it creates a lot of internal conflict and incentives to wait, to gimp the innovation, or to try to bolt it on to the cash cow to mitigate the damage.
I have no doubt Google could be a leader in the LLM space. . . But are they willing to destroy their own moat and take a serious revenue hit to do so?
- _visgean 4y ago> Google has been slow because they can’t figure out how to release this without destroying their business model. You can still display ads. My bet would be that they equally have not figured out how to make it reliable.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- xiphias2 4y agoEmbedding ads is much more natural than displaying them. I don't think Google will allow you to know what part is payed, just like how product search moved to ads-only.
- nradov 4y agoGoogle search isn't reliable either. Most of the results I get are either irrelevant or at least partly wrong (occasionally outright misinformation). But it's clear that the content comes from third parties without endorsement by Google so advertisers and users mostly accept it. When Google deploys a large language model to directly synthesize content it will carry a greater reputational risk for them and their advertisers. What happens when an ad appears next to an AI answer that could be construed as racist or promoting medical misinformation? The legacy media already hates big tech and will spin it as a "gotcha" moment.
- twelve40 4y agothere are a bunch of unclear questions about production readiness of this as-is. where does chatgpt get its data? Does it just hijack the data from websites without referencing them? might work for a limited dataset (commercial or loose licences), but musk already said he won't let it use the Twitter data, for example. Google search is for mutual benefit to publishers that provide the data because it drives traffic. This thing doesn't drive anything, so if I as a publisher found my data in it, I would be getting ready to sue them. there are other questions like, how to you continually retrain as you crawl the bigger web? on a really large number of sources, how do you rank and filter out crap spam from the actual useful, trainable content? so way too early to kill regular search imo.
- prepend 4y ago> Does it just hijack the data from websites without referencing them? How does one hijack data? Are you referring to scraping public websites that publish data for free? I wonder what the appropriate way to reference webscraping everything publicly available. I don’t think Google or other search engines do this, but I like the idea of listing out a massive set of trillions of URLs that have been included in the training along with a scrape date. I’m not sure Google is for mutual benefit as they summarize site content and prevent visits to that site. Would be interesting to measure the pros vs the cons there. I know there have been lawsuits over the years but don’t know the resolution.
- twelve40 4y agoyes, I'm talking about scraping. Google drives massive amounts of traffic to web publishers. It's carving out a bit for itself here and there with things like e.g. weather and answers to common questions, but they still drive a ton of traffic, and that's why (pretty much the only reason) the websites tolerate it. Just because a text on a website is "public", it doesn't mean you can copy it and plug it into your product. Nothing is "free" by default, many publishers have a deal with Google what can and cannot be used by Google, specified by robots.txt or in search console.
- 4y ago
- mike_hearn 4y agoThey also didn't release Imagen which doesn't seem to pose any particular threat to any of their existing businesses. And doing a ChatGPT style demo would also not have posed any threat to their business for the same reason ChatGPT itself doesn't: you can make it available for a while, get loads of attention and then paywall it until you figure out a better approach. The PR threat seems overblown. OpenAI isn't suffering any obvious reputational problems from making models available to play with, because people understand that AIs and their creators aren't the same thing. Also, though OpenAI is mostly a collection of really cool tech demos that may or may not turn into a business, not releasing demos like them is a major strategic blunder for Google. If you're an ambitious AI researcher where do you want to work now - the place where your work will get put out there in front of millions of people and become an overnight sensation, again and again? Or the place where your work will be put in front of, at best, a bunch of Googlers, and the only public knowledge of its existence comes from leaks and a web page saying "we can do that too"? Unless Google makes a vastly better offer than OpenAI can, it's going to be OpenAI. They've made this mistake before, with the cloud. Years ago, even before AWS existed at all, Borg and related tools were vastly superior to any publicly available cloud system. When I worked there we repeatedly asked management why that wasn't being turned into a business because it was so damn obvious that there was massive value in what had been built. The answer was always that Google could always make more money by keeping its tech private, because ads was such a great business model. That take ... didn't age well. They lost their chance to define what cloud meant and now GCP is lagging in third place. Unfortunately for Larry and Sergey I think the reason they aren't keeping up with OpenAI is actually not business model related, which is why they're going to have a hard time fixing it. They actually told us why they aren't releasing demos already and there's no reason not to take them at face value: they believe AI is literally dangerous and "unsafe" to release. It's been apparent for some time that there's some sort of weird internal purity spiral going on inside Google. Imagen is only available to employees yet, apparently, has been filtered so it refuses to draw people. If you want it to draw a person-like thing you have to ask it to draw robots. That's not a business model concern. The rationale appears to be some sort of DEI maximalism: if you asked it for people it might not draw the right kind of people, that would make Googlers/people racist, and so we have to block that. This reasoning seems largely unintelligible from the outside looking in, especially in parts of the world where these topics are less emotionally/historically charged. It comes from the kind of ultra-transitive worldview in which one person says something, or allows some words/images to appear somewhere, and someone else who may not even have been exposed to those words/images does something bad, and it's therefore the fault of the first person. Google's business model was once summed up by the mission of making the world's information "universally accessible and useful". I'm not sure they still believe in that, or at least not enough of them do. If Larry and Sergey want to get their AI products out there they're not only going to have to tackle thorny business model issues, but also try to reset the culture to the old one. The one that looked towards an optimistic future in which advanced technology could empower everyone, regardless of who they are.
- cybaz 4y agoThis is the same situation Kodak found themselves in years ago. Do you accept the business landscape has changed and accept a significantly smaller role in the market, or do you hope that somehow the alternative becomes unpalatable and you can keep your market position.
- bitL 4y agoThe business landscape has not changed yet, it's still early stages and there are no competitors utilizing the tech to displace Google. However, one can now clearly see the threat and what might transpire in the next few years.
- MacsHeadroom 4y ago27% of professionals use chatGPT for work already.[0] If you ask what it's replacing, most will say google. [0] https://thehill.com/policy/technology/3821400-nearly-30-percent-of-professionals-say-they-have-used-chatgpt-at-work/ https://thehill.com/policy/technology/3821400-nearly-30-perc...
- tuyiown 4y ago> 27% of professionals use chatGPT for work already.[0] > found that 27 percent of professionals have used the program to help them with work-related tasks. «Have used», as free test, at least once. Maybe twice. Tomorrow ? Until real value, habits and serious problems are established, my bracket of day to day for professional use is still opened between 26% - 1%.
- aatd86 4y agoHave to admit that I find ChatGPT's ability to provide customized code examples uncanny. It's often a good starting point. Sometimes there isn't much to change if at all. It can even design some custom algorithm. When you know what you're doing, it's a very nice helper.
- arthurcolle 4y ago
- kerpotgh 4y agoI mean can’t you still have ads based on the response?
- wkat4242 4y agoExactly. In fact you will have much more context to go on. The user will not only tell you what they're searching for but often also why or other pieces of context like what they want to use it for. This sounds like a marketeers paradise
- spankalee 4y agoI don't think this is true at all. First you'd have to show that the new thing is useful in the same ways that the old thing is, and that the new thing has a viable business model. I don't think ChatGPT has actually done that yet. Can they even charge enough to pay costs? If they do will enough people use it? And the questions about accuracy are material: if the LLM lies all the time, can it really replace a search engine? What do you do with a months old training set? Figuring out how to combine search + LLM is the problem and OpenAI doesn't have a search engine.
- EnergyAmy 4y agoEven if it sometimes lied, I would pay real money for a service that answered questions like "How do I cook basmati rice in an instant pot? Google has lost the plot on queries like this, and I don't have time to wade through the masses of bullshit it returns. I would guess that the average person would be in the same boat, preferring a simple answer that might be wrong to an endless stream of blog spam.
- wkat4242 4y agoThey're going to charge $42 a month which is a lot. That should cover the costs easily. It will put people off from using it for personal purposes though. Where I live in Spain that's a lot of money. About half my monthly energy bill (and I'm an IT enthusiast with 24/7 servers and a 3080Ti game PC)
- whatshisface 4y ago>Google has been slow because they can’t figure out how to release this without destroying their business model. I don't think that is the real explanation because even I can think of how to monetize it. Just have AdWords read your chat and advertise to you based on it. Far from a clever idea, it's exactly the way search already works!
- qikInNdOutReply 4y agoRemember microsoft putting win95 on the first tablets and making them pretty much unuseable. When its the cow keeping the lights on, everything grows teets.