8 ms·
Area 120, Google’s in-house incubator, severely impacted by Alphabet mass layoff
- kumarvvr 4y agoI remember a similar thing happened to Googles skunk works kinda division some years back. They had this division whose responsibility was to try pie in the sky ideas and see what sticks.
- 6figurelenins 4y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/X_Development https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/X_Development
- drblastoff 4y agohttps://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Google_ATAP https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Google_ATAP
- QuercusMax 4y agoX still exists and they haven't laid off everyone there yet.
- 0xcafefood 4y agoAt this point, Google just seems to be a conventional company. The writing has been on the wall for a long while now, but their first layoff seems to cement that fact.
- 762236 4y ago[flagged]
- bushbaba 4y agoThis isn’t googles first layoff. This is their first mass layoff
- xiphias2 4y agoI wouldn't write them down so easily. Even though they are not providing machine learning models, Google is still the biggest provider of high quality AI research papers in the world. As AI models are improving, at some point they will turn into business advantages, it's just not yet big enough business for Google to make a big difference compared to ads.
- theGnuMe 4y agoMaybe, I am more impressed with FAIR and Deep Mind. Yes I know Deep Mind is part of Alphabet... that being said TensorFlow and Attention is All you Need were amazing.
- xiphias2 4y agoWe can argue whether Deep Mind is part of Google or not (I think for many years it was officially a seperated entity inside Google, and recently moved out to be under Alphabet), but basically you agree with me :) Google is still one of the special companies that are prepared to take advantage of AI when it gets to the point of capturing trillions of dollars of value.
- primordialsoup 4y agoI can think of a list of works from Alphabet but can't think of much from FAIR (other than OPT). I will be happy to read something nice from FAIR as well, so please elaborate.
- zone411 4y agoThey do good work https://ai.facebook.com/blog/ https://ai.facebook.com/blog/ but Google/Deepmind are ahead.
- 0xcafefood 4y ago"Google is still the biggest provider of high quality AI research papers in the world." I agree that they have at least one of the top AI research groups among the corporate players. But is that going to translate into business advantage? IBM Research was (and is still to some extent) pretty solid, but did that actually translate into business advantage? The "Watson" that competed on Jeopardy was impressive for its time. But we can look back on how the attempt to commercialize that flopped pretty hard. Note: I'm not saying Google has IBM levels of sclerosis, at least not yet. But there's no ironclad law that a solid research division will always turn into something profitable.
- detaro 4y agoWhat else would it be?
- libraryatnight 4y agoWere you around when Google started to get big? And all the magazines were doing cover stories either about their engineers, their vision for the future, their offices, 'don't be evil,' for awhile it seemed like a real shining city on a hill. A shakeup of the established megacorps - overnight billionaires that gave their employees naps and a percentage of their day to experiment and work on other projects. Anyway, however obvious you mind find it, to many people watching Google become...this...is disappointing, or vindicating, or just interesting to see. I grew up with them and they're aging poorly.
- fidgewidge 4y agoAre they though. Not google's biggest fan for various reasons but most of that stuff you mentioned does still apply. The nice offices never went away and their impact on eng comp/perks has been astronomical. They didn't go evil either really, not like MS in the 90s which is what that referred to, not unless you're some sort of anti-capitalist who thinks all advertising is inherently wrong (prolly whilst collecting a nice faang paycheck). The most sinister/evil stuff they do is manipulate the public conversation around controversial topics.
- tpmx 4y agothe Google in-house incubator responsible for products such as Checks, Tables, Stack and ThreadBite Never heard of them. Looked at them each now - nope, no bells ringing. Separately, isn't an inhouse incubator a clear sign of a conglomerate that has gotten too big and slow? Makes me think of old telecom companies and their love of inhouse incubators, so that they can show they also do that innovative dotcom thing. Innovation needs to happen from within, at every level.
- MonkeyMalarky 4y agoOn one hand it's basically admitting that regular development teams and managers don't have the freedom or latitude to build experimental stuff. On the other, at somewhere like an aerospace company, experimental projects are just too big and complex to do without an incubator like skunk workshop so it can be a good thing.
- tpmx 4y agoGood points. Software obviously doesn't inherit the physical aspects involved with aerospace experimentation (e.g. Lockheed Martin Skunk Works). The limiting factor is typically only employee focus/time.
- bitL 4y agoIn-house incubators are pretty much normal these days (see ambidextrous organization). Even smaller companies like JetBrains are running them for ages. Nobody wants to miss the next big thing but you need to shield your existing business from anything that might disrupt it, so you make your incubator organizationally separate.
- theGnuMe 4y agoI really want the Stacks app for IOS.. I have this problem. I have so many scanned PDFs that need organizing...
- parkerhiggins 4y agoI hope these layoffs don’t impact the GA release of Google Tables. It’s marked for GA release but still under Area120 domain.
- esprehn 4y agoArea120, even with the previous cuts, was full of talented people with a background in building businesses and VC investments. It was a pretty unceremonious end to what was originally considered an important part of Google's innovation strategy. Separately it'll probably get less coverage than things like the incubator shutting down, but I suspect more external impact will be felt as a result of them firing the head of Open Source who's been there for 19 years. :/ Tech press hasn't picked that up yet though.
- bushbaba 4y agoA120 was never considered important to google innovation strategy. In fact what did it accomplish for the business. Google would have a better roi giving the money to Google Ventures or a16z. Or starting a private equity like firm adding notable startups to the alphabet portfolio. A120 was a sinking ship for a while
- KKKKkkkk1 4y ago> Google would have a better roi giving the money to Google Ventures or a16z. Is there any evidence that Google is better at managing money than its investors, say Warren Buffett? If not, they should raise their dividends instead.
- bushbaba 4y agoGoogle is likely not better at managing their money than investors. But once you issue dividends there is an expectation the dividend amount remains. Google did do share buybacks which is generally a more efficient way to return money back to shareholders. Alternatively if google is viewed as a growth tech stock. I think people would trust google to make investments into growth tech startups. Google ventures performance is pretty decent.
- seanhunter 4y agoVery little. In fact, in my interactions with them when Google Ventures were looking at a possible investment in a company I worked for I would say they stood out as by far the least technically-competent VCs we spoke to, and we spoke with everyone you might expect from the valley as well as several family offices and other investors. They definitely rated themselves highly though.
- michaelsmanley 4y agoI'd like to know which of the Area 120 projects did make it. I have been looking forward to Tables either becoming a Workspace product or getting rolled into Sheets (or AppSheet, worst case). It had just the right set of functions to replace some other tools for our team.
- monero-xmr 4y agoI don’t think huge companies should be creating brand new products. They should fund and acquire new businesses that are independently run. If you are just tweaking or improving existing products, or maybe copying a competitor’s offering, it’s possible. But trying to innovate inside of something like Google is just too hard to justify the expense. $5 million to a startup would be much better spent which is a drop in the bucket for Google employees’ salaries and benefits. Could $5 million even fund 5 people there?
- etrautmann 4y agoYep, Developing the iPhone as definitely a mistake
- kQq9oHeAz6wLLS 4y agoI saw a headline recently that suicides in girls have doubled since the smartphone was invented, so maybe? On the other hand, correlation is not necessarily causation.
- primordialsoup 4y agoThat's sad and hope something can be done about that. But that still doesn't mean we should go back and kill the iphone if we can do it. Because then we should go back to get rid of cars (so many accidents) and kill industrial revolution as well (so much pollution)...
- Ziomislaw 4y agoyes we should definitely get rid of cars, they don't add anything. you make your neighbourhood walkable and car looses to a bicycle on every metric except showing off who is rich.
- madiator 4y agoI will be typing this comment on my Nokia's keyboard.
- random314 4y agoSundar Pichai is just a bean counter. His innovations are a botched attempt to enter China, throttling promotions in engineering, low balling non FAANG experienced devs when hiring, lay offs, lowering benefits and plastering ads on anything and everything.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- altaltson 4y agoI really think things started heading south when Sundar became CEO and proceeded to exchange much of the leadership. He took over a company that was at the top of its game and fucking ran it into the ground in 4-5 years. He’ll be remembered as the worst tech CEO of a major company for years to come. I couldn’t believe how quickly and radically Google changed and after a while, many of us cut our loses and left. This layoff got rid of many other long-timers for what seems to be no good reason. We can only hope that all the solid engineers gravitate toward a company where the leadership is not completely incompetent.
- dougmwne 4y agoSundar is a hired gun. Ask who hired him.
- waiting4shoe2 4y agoSundar's job is to implement Ruth Porat's decisions.
- mardifoufs 4y agoWho?
- pjdemers 4y ago>> He’ll be remembered as the worst tech CEO of a major company He is up against stiff competition for this award. Even getting nominated is difficult.
- greatpostman 4y agoMore than anything, it’s surprising how well this company has maintained an illusion of competence and prestige. The general population really believes in the eliteness of their engineers. But when the rubber hits the road, the products leave much to be desired Edit: A hypothesis I have: Part of the success of search is in the belief of the elite ness of their engineers. “They are the smartest so why ever try another search product”. The aura of the company is part of the brand/product. It’s brilliant marketing
- 0xcafefood 4y agoGoogle does seem to have many solid engineers, as far as I can tell. (Though the bar must definitely be lower than back when it was a smaller company.) Their problems lie in management: executives, line managers, product, etc.
- bushbaba 4y agoGoogle builds well polished products that work well. The issue is that their product strategy is bad due to the company’s culture. For example stadia as a technology and product usage wise was great. However the product placement, market growth strategy, and pricing strategy was crap.
- luckylion 4y ago> Google builds well polished products that work well. The basic tech, I agree, like Youtube is great for watching videos, it barely buffers and you have billions of videos at your disposal and can watch each one and it just works. But polished? The search is atrociously bad. "Set your location" basically doesn't work. Comments under videos are a mess, half of them are deleted, but you can still see "10 replies", only nothing will load, creators will say "I didn't delete it, Youtube did". Shorts? Oh, the ability to upload TikTok clips and then get them presented in a way that's worse than random and actually makes you want to stop scrolling? I don't know Stadia, but I had a similar experience with a lot of Google services. It works, the fundamentals are solid, but the UX leaves much to be desired.
- 4y ago
- jwsteigerwalt 4y agoThis is reassuring. At the end of the day, google is a business. While innovation is key to their brand, they are not a nonprofit (like Apache) or an educational institution. The entire tightening of belts may be symbolic to investors across most companies, it would be jarring if the layoff were even across all businesses units.
- jl6 4y agoIs there somewhere that sunmarizes which teams/roles are being laid off in this round?
- nostrademons 4y agoRemember Yahoo!Brickhouse in the last downturn?
- drewda 4y agoAt least from the outside, Area120 looked like it existed mainly so that Google could have an option for retaining key staffers who might leave to do their own startup. Instead Google could offer the chance to be a founder -- at least in terms of creating a product and managing a team.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- thoughtpeddler 4y agoReally hoping that the Tables product survives this. They were supposed to "graduate it" out of Area 120 soon, with a full v1 joining the Workspace suite, but that hasn't happened yet. We were using it extensively at my company, becuase of its native Workspace integrations. There's so much product validation already from Airtable -- why hold this back?
- good_boy 4y agoWell, this makes Google less attractive for "could be" employees. They will have to lower the bar. Many with brains and ideas will choose startups. For Google this will backfire, former employees will be working for competitors soon.