14 ms·
Citizen scientists report global rapid reductions in the visibility of stars
- causi 4y agoParticipants were shown maps of the sky at different levels of light pollution and asked which most closely matched their view. This seems like a very lazy, inexact, and error-prone way of collecting data.
- elil17 4y agoHow so? They're looking for a change over time, so it would only really be an issue if we had some reason to think that people were changing how they responded to it in one year vs. the next.
- causi 4y agoso it would only really be an issue if we had some reason to think that people were changing how they responded to it in one year vs. the next. Such as, gee I dunno, a change in the nature of peoples' light exposure, like spending more time inside and more time staring at a screen every year? No way that could possibly throw off peoples' subjective feeling of how bright the sky is, right? I'm sure there definitely hasn't been any other types of changes to human vision over time, like an increase in myopia over time. There also definitely hasn't been an increase in photophobia over time due to, among other factors, changing demographics resulting in older people making up a larger percentage of respondents, no siree.
- ceejayoz 4y ago> No way that could possibly throw off peoples' subjective feeling of how bright the sky is, right? They're not being asked to evaluate the glow itself, but how many stars they can see in a particular region of the sky. https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2023/jan/19/light-pollution-rapidly-reducing-stars-visible-naked-eye-study-finds https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2023/jan/19/light-po... "Participants were asked to use a website to view a selection of star charts for their location – each showing an incrementally greater number of the stars that exist in that patch of sky – and pick the chart that best matched what they could see. The researchers then created a model that related the number of visible stars to the brightness of the night sky."
- elil17 4y agoWouldn't all of those changes also equally effect how the people see the reference photos? I suppose myopia might if it was not corrected, but the vast majority is corrected.
- anigbrowl 4y agoMaybe you're having a bad day, but expressing yourself in such sarcastic terms isn't going to win you any friends. These things are hard to control for, but perhaps you can suggest a better method, bearing in mind that respondents to this survey are self-selected and presumably care about managing their own light sensitivity to some degree.
- trompetenaccoun 4y agoWhich in itself is another flaw in ...whatever we even want to call this. It's not a proper study. Yes, many here vote and (dis)trust statements based on tone of voice but despite the user losing their cool - for whatever reason - their criticism is still valid. It's reasonable to assume at the least moderate if not extreme bias in this self-selected group of people who're concerned with a lack of dark skies. Yet they didn't address nor attempt to control for it.
- bee_rider 4y agoDue to light pollution - before anyone freaks out and starts worrying that the dome that the aliens put around us has gotten scratched up or something like that.
- blahblah1234567 4y ago[flagged]
- liftm 4y agoAstrophage.
- asdff 4y agoBack when street lights were all sodium vapor, you could use a filter and eliminate a lot of light pollution. These days sodium vapor streetlight are being replaced by LED lights, that emit a white light and also frequently turn bright blue when they begin failing before long, and filtering out this source of light is no longer so simple.
- actionfromafar 4y agoI fucking hate the blinding LED lights with a passion. Also, they fuck up the ecosystem in a major way. If we never get rid of them, they are visual DDT.
- icedistilled 4y agoit's particularly obnoxious because LED lights can easily be made to be about the same place on the spectrum as the sodium vapor lights - it's just costs a few pennies more and has a slightly lower light efficiency so typical cheap short termism type thinking gets us the blue cold tone LEDS
- actionfromafar 4y agoEspecially since at least the street lights are meant to light up the streets, not blind you. So the light efficiency is better, but the lighting efficiency is worse. It's not even short termism, it's wrong.
- adgjlsfhk1 4y agobluer lights actually do a way better job of being seen at night. if they're blinding that just means that they are too bright.
- nullc 4y agoThe large population of people who focus less clearly on blue light would beg to differ!
- chatterhead 4y agoI guarantee it's the HID headlights no one is regulating. It's blotting out the night sky!
- ceejayoz 4y agoThey're mostly turned off late at night. Street lights and outdoor building / landscaping lighting tends not to be.
- chatterhead 4y agoJesus Christ HN is filled with fucking retards.
- belter 4y agoSome places are fortunately seeing Dark Skies as a valid tourist asset to be protected Dark Sky Alqueva - The First Starlight Tourism Destination in the World: https://darkskyalqueva.com/en/ https://darkskyalqueva.com/en/
- igrekel 4y agoDark sky protection is definitely a thing and tourism worthy. I've known of this one I regularly visited for at least the last 15 years https://en.cieletoilemontmegantic.org https://en.cieletoilemontmegantic.org
- zokier 4y agoI find it funny that both your and parent comments destinations advertise as being "first", and probably Atacama stargazing tourists predate both of these initiatives
- trompetenaccoun 4y agoMy ancestors were stargazing in the Namib when your continent hadn't even been discovered yet.
- andrepd 4y agoBeen there, it's amazing.
- orobinson 4y ago"Overhead, without any fuss, the stars were going out."
- pjmorris 4y agoNow there's a line I've not heard in a very long time. Thanks for the callback. I'm fairly certain this is from Arthur C. Clarke's short story "The Nine Billion Names of God", partly used as inspiration for 2001: A Space Odyssey.
- leesec 4y agoGave me chills remembering this haha, what a great short story
- stavros 4y agoToo bad it spoils the entire story.
- yamtaddle 4y agoEh, in this case I don't think the story hinges on keeping that secret, and if you know what era of sci-fi the story was written in you'd be nearly certain you're getting the "shocking twist! (but not really a twist)" ending anyway. The alert, seasoned sci-fi reader would be more surprised by almost any other ending than that one, really, in a '50s story of this sort. Same thing Asimov usually did—a shower and/or stoned "what if...?" idea turned into a short story in a straightforward way—except Clarke took the extra step to, like, write actual characters and draw a setting and maybe even establish tone and mood beyond whatever the literal plot itself necessarily conveys.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- newaccount2021 4y agobefore: rural US has crappy broadband whaaaa everything sucks! now: starlink satellites are ruining astronomy for like sixty people whaaaa everything sucks! this is why I no longer give any credit to online bellyaching backyard astronomers: we don't care about you if only starlink satellites could be arranged in the shape of Trump's face directly above laid-off Twitter engineers, life would be perfect
- everdrive 4y agoA lot of people think the only way to be safe is to have multiple exterior lights on their property. It's a waste of energy and a blight.
- dheera 4y agoI mean, the other way to be safe is if the government would actually arrest the crooks and throw them in jail instead of releasing them back onto the streets of SF and Oakland.
- cptskippy 4y agoI mean, if that's the case then I'm ok with the residents of SF and Oakland running all the lights they want. But everyone else needs to turn them off and rest peacefully knowing their criminals are being shipped to SF and Oakland.
- it_citizen 4y agoAren’t the US waayyy ahead of other developed countries in term of incarcerating its population? How is that working so far? Mass incarceration doesn’t seem to be working well so far. Maybe it would be time to stop treating the symptoms and try a different approach?
- mrguyorama 4y agoOnly if your crime is smoking weed. There's a huge amount of "we won't do anything about it" for property crimes among police departments now. It's hard work, and not flashy, so cops don't do it. They have largely not been punished in any way for this.
- lliamander 4y agoMost people in prisons are there for violent crimes (partly because they tend to have longer sentences). Property crimes are definitely under-policed.
- Waterluvian 4y agoSpeaking of light pollution, months ago I experienced this phenomenon. This is taken hours after sunset. The moon is behind us. 403 westbound half hour out of Hamilton. It was both incredibly eerie and calming. One of the most liminal night drives I’ve had. https://youtu.be/7SKoaRBkGiQ https://youtu.be/7SKoaRBkGiQ
- terramex 4y agoPossibly a light pollution from industrial greenhouse. There is one near Wrocław (Poland) and tourists are constantly asking "what is that spooky light in the sky?". https://miejscawewroclawiu.pl/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/IMG_3240-scaled.jpg https://miejscawewroclawiu.pl/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/IMG...
- Waterluvian 4y agoIt might be! I’m also thinking an auto plant. There’s a cannabis greenhouse elsewhere in my region that creates a pillar of white light. It’s a completely surreal scene. Also pretty awful light pollution.
- wolverine876 4y agoThe LED lights also change the landscape of cities to something cooler. It's a massive aesthetic change that nobody talks about. LEDs for consumers come in various color temperatures. Why are the streetlights all so cold?
- mtalantikite 4y agoWhen my neighborhood here in Brooklyn switched over to LED streetlights I got very depressed. And angry. All of a sudden everything was drenched in this horrible white light. Plus there's a lamppost right outside our window, so my living room gets flooded in cold LED light. I complained multiple times to the city but they said it's just what it is now. A year ago our condos switched over to LEDs on all outside building lights and I no longer feel comfortable just sitting on our stoop enjoying the city at night anymore. It just feels so harsh. I have so many good memories from hanging out on Brooklyn stoops at night, either solo or with friends. I miss that soft, warm NYC lighting.
- rileyphone 4y agoStart a guerilla campaign to put tinted films on all the lights.
- mtalantikite 4y agoI actually bought a bunch of light gels from B&H to do this on the lights on my stoop. I wish I could do it to the street lights and the outdoor lights mounted on the sides of our building!
- icedistilled 4y agois there something actually stopping you?
- mtalantikite 4y agoThe lamppost is something like 27 feet and the ones on the outside of our condos are two stories up -- I don't have a ladder in my tiny NYC apartment is really the main reason.
- dsign 4y agoThis is a nice reminder that the atmosphere is such a pain for watching stars. If light pollution for sky-watching is a problem for you, citizen stargazer, please write to your local representative and ask them to quicken those space colonization plans.
- ballenf 4y agoMaybe we could send up a few dozen telescope micro- or mini-satellites and let citizen astronomers share time on them.
- nostromo 4y agoStreet lights are way too common. Let's phase them out entirely on non-pedestrian streets. This is one of my favorite things about Palm Springs, which has almost no street lights. The darkness at night is truly beautiful. And it saves money and electricity to boot. Maybe you could even get creative and have street lamps that dim up or down based on activity someday.
- college_physics 4y agoThe wonder of the true dark sky is that the numbers of perceived stars multiply significantly, giving an almost three dimensional impression. That indescribable feeling disappears with light pollution. It can be a street light nearby or an industrial estate hundreds of kilometers away. Nowadays one needs to go into extremes to experience such conditions.
- everybodyknows 4y agoI recall now that sense of wonder at seeing the Milky Way as a distinct band across the sky. Many years now since I've seen it, and yet perhaps some people reading this never have. Travel suggestion: Anywhere far from city lights where clear weather can be expected. The week of a predicted meteor shower might be ideal.
- teslabox 4y agoIn the beginning of the modern era, electric light was fantastically expensive. People used just enough light to get by. LEDs put out 7x as much light as an incandescent bulb, so people can use 3x as much light as they need and still save money on their power bill. I have a neighbor that has a string of bulbs along their driveway. These are left on all night every night. City code requires "fully shielded" lighting, but the city ignores its own code. What Is a Fully Shielded Light Fixture? http://we-watch.org/wp-content/uploads/2011/03/FullyShieldedLightFixture-1.pdf http://we-watch.org/wp-content/uploads/2011/03/FullyShielded... The tragedy of the increased amount of blue light in our nighttime environment is that there's a bunch of old research about the physiological mechanism behind high-energy blue photons causing inflammation in the eyes. This gradually results in people having reduced low-light visual acuity. Whoops. I think people need to be told that artificial light is most useful to humans when it bounces off of things. This is why streetlights are mounted high on poles, and are designed so all the light is directed down. Bulbs that can be seen are mostly emitting wasted light. A friend recently bought some light fixtures on the basis of looking nice when the lights are off. I think they're gradually realizing that staring directly into LEDs is not a pleasant experience. In the old days, people bought light fixtures to hide the bulbs, and to direct the light where it's needed.
- zxcvbn4038 4y agoMaybe it’s all a conspiracy so that we can’t see all the alien spacecraft flying around at night?
- NKosmatos 4y agoOne of the bad things of our modern lifestyle/civilization, most of the population hasn’t got access to a dark sky. I think of myself as privileged since I have the possibility to visit a Bortle 3 or 4 location in less than an hour of driving. Do yourself a favor, try to visit a really dark place, ideally with binoculars and a sky map and you’ll feel again connected with the Cosmos. Here is a very good map to find a dark place: https://www.lightpollutionmap.info https://www.lightpollutionmap.info Some extra info on the Bortle Scale: https://astrobackyard.com/the-bortle-scale/ https://astrobackyard.com/the-bortle-scale/
- hemloc_io 4y agoIt's honestly one of the coolest things I've ever done. It's not just about the brightness of the stars, the sky literally looks 3d, which I didn't expect
- NKosmatos 4y agoExactly this, you can almost feel the depth and get a broader look at the whole celestial dome. Be careful thought, since some people might get overwhelmed by this feeling of realizing your place in the universe. If I remember correctly there are a couple of related phobias, Astrophobia (fear of space) and Apeirophobia (fear of infinity). Something like the Total Perspective Vortex: https://hitchhikers.fandom.com/wiki/Total_Perspective_Vortex https://hitchhikers.fandom.com/wiki/Total_Perspective_Vortex
- BizarreByte 4y agoThis has actually occurred to people who have visited me (as I mentioned in another post I’m in a class 2, just barely off of a class 1). I find it comforting, but one family member was throughly freaked out/overwhelmed. It was a clear, moonless night and they’d never seen something like it in their entire life.
- dylan604 4y agoand they'll never forget it now. hopefully.
- herodotus 4y agoI belong to a local astronomy club, and was part of the "Light Pollution Abatement" group for a while. But I had to stop: persuading people that light pollution matters and that something should be done about it is almost impossible. Even some of the comments here indicate to me that few people really care. So why do I? It is not just to see more from my telescope. It is because this is part of a very broad problem. The problem? That humans on this planet have not even considered how we can live in a state of stasis with this planet. Weather catastrophes, insect decline, crop failures to pollination problems, shortages of seafood: these are all symptoms of the root problem, and light pollution is just one more symptom.
- hanniabu 4y agoI think the issue here is the same as recycling and carbon reduction. There's only so much us as individuals can do, our impact is extremely limited and negligible. You'd need to convince the governments to do something about it, but that's a large task given there's a lack of money for lobbying and a lack of profits to encourage them to do anything about it.
- mrelectric 4y agoGovernments are composed of individuals.
- themitigating 4y agoAnd people vote for them.
- hanniabu 4y agoAnd politicians barely listen to their voters
- switchbak 4y agoYou're right, but there are real system level dynamics and complex incentives at play, and you don't do the actual problem any justice with such a skin deep dismissal.
- chrisweekly 4y agoLast summer I visited Medawisla - a "National Dark Sky Park" on the edge of Maine's 100-mile wilderness, run by the AMC (Appalachian Mountain Club). It was a fantastic experience, highly recommended. I'm a life-long stargazer in my late 40's, and the only comparable night sky I've ever experienced has been on a sailboat.
- m348e912 4y agoWhy is the area around Punta de Mata in Venezuela off the charts with light pollution? It doesn't seem that populated.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- sammalloy 4y agoI’ve been complaining about this in my area for years. Where I live, the main problem right now is private property owners (mostly condos and commercial real estate, not so much private homes), refusing to put lids (or hats) on their security lights to point it down. We’ve lost half the night sky since 2011 in my area due to these lights going up. In various discussions, I’ve been informed that the insurance companies are behind this problem. If we could convince them to mandate night-protective lighting (with metal hats pointing the light down) this would return our night skies.
- isodev 4y agoOn a related note, even where people do get to access the dark sky, it’s severely restricted by other “modern” phenomena with dubious origins. cf. https://chaos.social/@phoenix/109630800743333177 https://chaos.social/@phoenix/109630800743333177
- TEP_Kim_Il_Sung 4y agoIt's just a System Containment Forcefield deployed by the Guvnuragnaguvendrugun. Jump beacons should still work fine.
- spacedcowboy 4y agoEmpty Night!
- giantg2 4y agoYes, but nobody cares. I'd like to reduce sky glow. I use motion sensitive downward lighting and close my blinds. I'd imagine that and redesigned street lights could cut sky glow in half or better. But there's not enough money involved to even create regulations/standards in building codes or for lighting manufacturers.
- wpietri 4y agoSome care. And discussions like this are how more people can come to care.
- cardamomo 4y agoA couple years ago, my parents, suburb dwellers in the Midwest, were spooked by a burglary in their neighborhood. A detective from the local police department suggested to them, and many neighbors, that they keep their outdoor lights on all night. Now, the lights at the front and back doors, which we once turned out every night, burn all night long. I feel so sad—the loss of darkness, the unnecessary electricity consumption—I don't know what could turn things around.
- destitude 4y agoIf you actually want to learn how to help address light pollution visit https://www.darksky.org https://www.darksky.org
- curling_grad 4y agoDid anyone recall the plot of Hail Mary by Andy Weir?
- bryanrasmussen 4y agoOverhead, without any fuss, the stars were going out.
- Self-Perfection 4y agoI suspect rapid reduction in the visibility of stars is one of the reasons why space travel seems to catch much less human imagination and excitement that it used to like 30 years ago.
- AtlasBarfed 4y agoCitizen zoologists report global loss of species. That's a headline I am far more concerned with.
- LinuxBender 4y agoI see a lot of discussion about types of lamps/lights, LED vs Gas, etc.. In my opinion the focus should instead be on two things: - BUG rating [1] Backlight (B) uplight (U) glare (G) - Legislating compliance of BUG ratings. Longer term there could be citations for violating BUG ratings first on city governments, then businesses then finally on residential. If a light manufacturer is found to have false BUG ratings then city and state governments must sue them into compliance or oblivion. [1] - https://www.firstlighttechnologies.com/solar-light-blog/lighting-fundamentals-bug-ratings/ https://www.firstlighttechnologies.com/solar-light-blog/ligh...