26 ms·
EV batteries alone could satisfy short-term grid storage demand as early as 2030
- lja 4y agoI think EV owners would need to find some level of compensation for the additional cycles they would incur. Electric vehicles are expensive because of the battery so deteriorating the life of one of the most costly parts of the car doesn't feel like a great solution.
- prottog 4y agoI agree. This further degrades the meaning of owning private property.
- wjnc 4y agoEnergy price volatility will probably increase because natural sources are more volatile and other sources have spin up / down cycles. A car battery is like 3-4 days of continuous house usage. The car battery being used to top off the top 10% in short term pricing for energy would give a very nice ROI I expect. The rest is software? Don’t overcharge, don’t go under the limit I set for continuous availability as a mode of transport. And that’s all within reach in front of the meter, thus under my ownership. Heck, without self driving becoming common a family might even have 2 EVs on the driveway, giving a week of off grid potential. Come to think of it - a harder part is how super local the grid is and energy pricing should become. In my somewhat affluent neighborhood in high summer the voltage rises too high and the supply of solar falls. And tragedy of the commons - we are still installing solar because it’s massively incentivized (2 years before investment returns itself). To solve this with EVs requires very granular prices. There might be clouds 50 km away. But again, those are software solvable issues. (I’m not holding my breath. It’s like IoT-superplus.)
- Ajedi32 4y agoUnless it's voluntary (which it darned well better be). I envision a future where individual appliances (including EVs) can opt in to spot pricing for the electricity they consume (or produce). That would naturally incentivize charging during off-peak hours and discharging during peak hours, all without requiring any government incentives or coercion. It could also be useful for other major appliances which could benefit from the lower prices afforded by load shifting, such as hot water heaters.
- NotYourLawyer 4y agoLots of now-compulsory things started out as voluntary.
- bryanlarsen 4y agoPretty hard to make it compulsory if you can avoid it by (at worst) unplugging your car.
- NotYourLawyer 4y ago>bryanlarsen, we noticed that your location is at home but your car isn’t plugged in. Please plug it in and drink a verification can within the next 10 minutes to avoid a noncompliance charge
- at-fates-hands 4y ago>> I envision a future where individual appliances (including EVs) can opt in to spot pricing for the electricity they consume (or produce). I remember when high speed internet was coming into being and there were a lot of pundits talking about how high speed bandwidth would be sold as a commodity on the NYSE. If someone needed say an hour of high bandwidth for a video conference, they could do what you're saying, buy an hour of high speed access. Of course, high speed internet eventually became so cheap and so readily available, those ideas faded pretty fast. I might be remembering this wrong, but wasn't Enron doing what you're talking about?
- tguvot 4y agoa bunch of appliances already can be aware of TOU pricing and run when it's atlowest. Many thermostats can be "auto-adjusted" based on grid load
- powerbroker 4y ago>> I envision a future where individual appliances (including EVs) can opt in to spot pricing for the electricity they consume When 1,000 devices jump on the grid the moment electricity hits $0.01/kWh, the demand spike will cause more generators to come back on line and increase the price back to $0.05/kWh -- thus causing the 1,000 devices to drop-off the grid. Rinse, lather, repeat. How do you compensate for the potential grid instability?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- nkingsy 4y agoThis makes much more sense with large lifepo4 chemistry batteries that are expected to outlive the car by a wide margin. Lifepo4 batteries > 50kwh should easily handle 500,000 miles. Higher performance lithium ion will degrade at a rate faster than any expected return from a scheme like this. At least in Northern California it’s now cheaper for me to run solar+battery off grid than to pay pge. Lifepo4 pushes it over the edge into profitability. If off-grid is competitive, selling at peak prices is a no brainer.
- toomuchtodo 4y agoI have 100k miles on my 2018 Model S having Supercharged it the majority of the time the last four years. It has only 6% battery degradation of the 100kw pack. Tesla warranties their powerwalls for 15 years when configured as part of their aggregated virtual power plants. The batteries are demonstrated to be durable. New LFP chemistries that are heavier but more stable are ideal for stationary storage and high cycle counts, but the evidence shows in general that these packs are built for longevity (with very occasional early failures). You could probably do well buying a salvage Tesla and shucking the pack for working modules and coming out ahead economically (safety warning, do at your own risk, etc) if you don’t want or can’t get dedicated stationary storage (although it comes with generous federal, state, and utility subsidies in California).
- danans 4y ago> if you don’t want or can’t get dedicated stationary storage (although it comes with generous federal, state, and utility subsidies in California). I installed stationary LFP batteries (from Enphase) on my house in CA 1.5 years ago, but I then discovered that the state and utility subsidies [1] only apply if you are in a very low income (for CA) bracket, have a health condition that requires backup power, or live in a high fire risk zone. I don't qualify for the first 2 categories, and my luck is that the high fire risk zone starts about a mile away from my house, so good from the fire risk perspective, but not for the subsidy. Still got the 26% federal tax credit (with IRA, it's now back up to 30%). 1. SGIP: https://www.cpuc.ca.gov/industries-and-topics/electrical-energy/demand-side-management/self-generation-incentive-program https://www.cpuc.ca.gov/industries-and-topics/electrical-ene...
- phkahler 4y agoDid you know that the standard DC chargers communicate with the vehicle using PLC (Powerline communication) chips even though that communication is not over the high power conductors? I've always had the feeling the grid operators got that included because they thought they were going to communicate directly with the battery management system to control it as they wish. It never happened and now the standard is stupidly complex and they're still trying to use cars as storage without much consideration for what vehicle owners want. Sure, offer variable rates. Offer interruptabke service. But stop wanting V2G, nobody actually wants it.
- jackinloadup 4y agoAssuming V2G means Vehicle to Ground, this is something I would like to see for the following use-case. I would like to use my car battery as a temporary home battery in the inevitable case of a grid outage. This opens the option to bring energy home from another location. Reduce or eliminates the need for a battery in a grid-tied house. Am I crazy? Edit: Granted that doesn't mean the energy company can use my car's battery at it's whim. I think compensation would be required and would actually make a lot of sense. It isn't like the electric company could build out a battery system for cheaper. It would need to be a higher compensation than to PV though. Batteries are more expensive and should be compensated as such.
- Reason077 4y agoV2G = vehicle to grid. It’s quite possible for this to operate as a backup battery, but like a Powerwall it requires extra “gateway” hardware to ensure that your house is isolated from the grid when the battery is discharging. V2L (vehicle to load) is a simpler form that lets you power 115/230V appliances directly from the vehicle. Quite a few EVs (Hyundai, Ford, etc) already support V2L.
- toast0 4y agoThat's not crazy, it's actually a publicized optional feature on the F-150 Lightning, and the F-150 hybrid has an optional 240V 30A output that can be used as a home backup as well (although that'd be a bit more manual).
- whazor 4y agoSelling electricity is compensation, like with solar panels. You only need hourly energy prices to make it profitable. Plus an app that does the profitability calculation and discharging.
- ThunderSizzle 4y agoSounds similar to Uber using a contractor vehicle's hidden depreciation and maintenance to shift the real cost of their service. I doubt the hourly price will ever truly be fair to individual car owners. Maybe we'll start to be asked whenever we plug in our phones to tip the owner of a car our electricity is coming from.
- cwkoss 4y agoIf there are consistent price cycles and a good API for reading price, it should be pretty easy for an EV owner to control how much they interact with the arbitrage opportunities with some simple rules. Ex. "only sell if it cost at least 15% less to charge", "always charge to X%", "charge to 70% if < $Y", charge to 100% if < $Z", "never sell below X%" The aesthetic vibe of having an autonomous energy trading bot in my garage is attractive to me.
- rtkwe 4y agoPart of the issue isn't the controls to do that it's that the prices to compensate wear on a battery are a) likely significantly higher than the base price and b) pretty hard to calculate.
- 0cVlTeIATBs 4y ago1. Core charge when recycling 2. Time-of-use electricity rates. Up to the customer to choose to install load shifting equipment
- _yb2s 4y agoWe also need EV designs where the batteries are modular and easy to swap out. I wouldn't be interested in a deal where I was compensated financially for quickly wearing my non-replaceable car battery out, because the battery wear alters the usability of the car, e.g. I might find I can only take my family on shorter trips than planned, if my battery is now 80% of what it would have been. I also wouldn't want the battery level timed around the grid vs my own transportation needs. What if there is suddenly a heavy demand on the grid, and now I can't take my sick family member to the hospital, because the charge was sold to the grid?
- tuatoru 4y ago> We also need EV designs where the batteries are modular and easy to swap out. Battery swapping is already a thing. In China. Nio[1] sells luxury cars and there are lots of more utilitarian vehicles that use battswap, but get no press outside China. In the west, Ample[2] is working with manufacturers to modularize batteries and make them swappable between vehicle brands, so a "gas station" business/industry model will work. Edit: I believe that EV manufacturers that don't offer battswap will confine themselves to the luxury niche of the market. The mass market wants low sticker prices on its vehicles. 1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nio_Inc https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nio_Inc. 2. https://ample.com/ https://ample.com/
- _yb2s 4y agoThis is really cool! Battery swap is the 'killer feature' for me that would allow an EV to replace an ICE vehicle.
- timidiceball 4y agoNIOs are very much for sale in Europe and Oslo, Norway has two battery changing stations (more coming supposedly). Very interesting what happens to car depreciation when decoupled from any particular battery pack.
- bryanlarsen 4y agoAssuming Tesla prices and full cycling of battery (aka from 100->0), draining a kWh puts about 2cents wear on your battery, so compensation would need to be above that price. In practice you'd never allow your operator to drain you to 0, so 2 cents is very much on the high side. In the California Tesla VPP trial, they pay 50 cents per kWh. (correction: 20cents wear, not 2cents)
- georgeg23 4y agoI calculate about $12 per Model Y full battery cycle, how did you get 2 cents? $12,000 (Model Y bat replace cost) * 300(miles for full drain)/300,000(total miles per pack) = $12 per cycle Edit: or 18 cents per kWh
- bryanlarsen 4y agoUsing your numbers: 300000 miles / 320 miles/cycle = 938 cycles. 938 cycles * 72kWh = 67500 kWh. $12000 / 67500 = 18 cents. Dunno where I got my 2 cents from, that calculation was done 2 months ago.
- georgeg23 4y agoI agree with your 18 cents/kWh. That's slightly more than the average cost of electricity in the US?.. That is interesting, that means for home-charging your electric cost (per mile) is about equal to the battery degradation cost. Thats 2x cost than most think.
- dtech 4y agothe "real" time-based prices have much more variability, if you have time-based prices you can buy for a lot less and sell for a lot more during peak. That difference can easily be double that 18 cents/kWh.
- rtkwe 4y agoFor you though that cost is just part of the normal depreciation of using the vehicle. Allowing the utility to discharge your battery isn't part of the normal utilization for yourself so the cost should get included. We also don't usually think or talk about how much depreciation using a particular gallon of gas costs you so it muddies comparisons.
- micromacrofoot 4y agoThe distributor should just pay the generation fee to the car owners just like they would a power plant.
- jackmott 4y agocycles hurt a lot less than just time does, but of course there would need to be some incentive!
- jvanderbot 4y agoDeferred cost is enough, just let the Tesla power the house once in a while, like the Ford Lightning can. The extra regulatory and technological stuff to make the Tesla power the neighbors house through the city grid is just overkill.
- cyanydeez 4y agoConsidering the market is moving towards pertual licensing, by the time this is a thing, you probably won't be an owner and it won't matter to anyone except some bean counters when they update lease rules.
- manmal 4y agoLFP batteries can do 3k-10k cycles. Assuming a range of 500km per cycle out of an 100 kWh pack, that's 1.5 million km of total range (assuming 3k cycles). Only a small number of people will ever get that much out of a car - maybe 40% that, if maintained very very well. But we're talking Prius/Mercedes level endurance here, most cars won't make it that long. So in most cases, 70+% of the usable cycles in an LFP pack won't be done by the EV it was first installed in. Knowing that, selling cycles is actually a great way to offset purchase costs.
- throwaway894345 4y agoYour range figures seem pretty crazy high. Pretty sure most EV batteries are smaller than 100k--my Model Y is only 75k for instance, and I'm not getting anywhere close to 500km per cycle because (1) my Model Y doesn't actually get 500km on a full charge and more importantly (2) like most EV owners, I don't charge to 100% and run my battery down to 0% but rather something closer to 80%/20%. So for my Model Y scenario, it's closer to half of your total range figure. Also, I'm not sure what components would wear out in an EV before the battery such that it would total the car out. If the EV batteries in totaled cars can be repurposed for grid use, then great, but I would expect them to get recycled and put back into cars unless strapping them to the grid is cheaper than recycling (seems maybe plausible?).
- coryrc 4y agoWhen speaking of battery cycles and lifetime, people almost always mean "full cycle equivalent". So when you say "I only go 80%->20%" then that would be considered 0.6 cycles counted against the lifetime.
- manmal 4y agoI don't, LFP batteries are quite resilient. 80% -> 20% is a usability nightmare nobody with a $50k vehicle should accept. My Ioniq (first gen) doesn't even have an LFP battery and is optimized for 100% -> 13%, maybe even 100% -> 10% (turtle mode starts at 5%). Still at 100% SOH after three years. Way more important for battery life is the charging rate (again, LFP are more resilient there too). Which wouldn't be an issue for grid use.
- zeristor 4y agoSurely just going between 80% to 20% would still be worthwhile, I understand this is for more amenable to a battery than a full fast discharge cycle. Indeed as this becomes more of an option I trust that car producers could look at engineering their batteries with this in mind.
- mozman 4y agoNot to mention a bug that could drain batteries overnight and put vehicle owners at risk!
- Teknoman117 4y agoAs a semi-related side question, does anyone have good numbers on how plug-in hybrid batteries deteriorate over time? I bought a (2022) last March and I do a full charge/discharge cycle on it nearly every other day. I've averaged half my miles on electric since buying it... I haven't noticed any range loss ... yet. I know on mine the physical capacity is 14.4 kWh but it'll only let me use a band in the middle (?) of ~11 kWh (it eats 12 kWh charging and I'm assuming a 90% charging efficiency) (I also don't know if the chargepoint chargers report delivered or stored energy). This is all what I'm presuming to be enforcing no full charge/discharge cycles to lengthen the battery life.
- abracadaniel 4y agoI've read that nearly all range reduction occurs in the first year. If you're seeing ~80% usable energy out of it, then it's probably keeping you between 10% to 90% which is probably fine. Another major factor is battery cooling. Some only air cool the batteries, and in a hot climate they will die much quicker that way. It would be nice if the details were made available as not all manufacturers will use the same limits. Even better would be if it were configurable to some degree.
- jungturk 4y agoNot a plug-in hybrid, and not data, but I'm down 5-10% total range after 80k miles over 6 years in a plug-in (full) electric vehicle.
- kbuck 4y ago
- bluefirebrand 4y agoLove subsidizing public infrastructure directly as well as paying taxes!
- glial 4y agoIMO the right answer is to make energy companies into cooperatives or not-for-profits.
- sp332 4y agoAs this gets more popular, I guess net metering will be offered less and less. But you should still get some credit for supplying electricity to the grid.
- function_seven 4y agoOn the contrary, I would expect to be paid higher rates for the energy I'm supplying to the grid than those I paid to charge it in the first place. Otherwise, what's the point? I'm not going to buy a kilowatt-hour high, then sell it low. Only way these grid balancing schemes work is if the pricing is real-time, and I have an opportunity to supply marginal peak demand at rates that are higher than what I paid to charge (while still being lower than what peaker plants would cost)
- jlmorton 4y agoIt's worth pointing out that Tesla's Virtual Power Plant in California -- which is used primarily in emergency events -- compensates owners $2/kWh. [1] Obviously, that rate is not going to be sustainable for routine energy storage, but PG&E is already compensating EV owners a substantial amount for peak electricity needs. [1] https://electrek.co/2022/09/02/tesla-virtual-power-plant-growing/ https://electrek.co/2022/09/02/tesla-virtual-power-plant-gro...
- gopalv 4y ago> I would expect to be paid higher rates for the energy I'm supplying to the grid than those I paid to charge it in the first place The Tesla VPP[1] model was 1$ KWH to send it back, better than Net Metering which should have paid only 42c. However, this was coordinated with PGE to match the lack of production (in advance, which is its own miracle) and unlike a car, the battery doesn't change locations or need to be unplugged at random. [1] - https://www.tesla.com/support/energy/powerwall/own/tesla-pge-virtual-power-plant-pilot https://www.tesla.com/support/energy/powerwall/own/tesla-pge...
- RetpolineDrama 4y agoI assumed this meant selling EoL EV batteries back to providers who convert them into grid storage. An EoL EV battery still has a decade or more of life as a grid-scale battery.
- sp332 4y agoIt includes both. But since EV manufacturing capacity is ramping up so fast, the amount of battery capacity in cars is going to be a lot larger than the amount in EoL car batteries for a while.
- Am4TIfIsER0ppos 4y agoImagine the government draining your tank at the gas station instead of filling it.
- iso1631 4y agoImagine the gas station selling you a tank of gas for $10 and buying it back for $15 later in the day, all while your car sits on your driveway
- ThunderSizzle 4y agoIt will never work that way, except for the lucky few. Have you ever tried selling books back to the school store? They'll buy it from you for $10 when you paid $100 for it. Same thing will happen for this.
- bryanlarsen 4y agoIt's trivial to prevent the power company from doing this -- just unplug your car. They can't force anybody to participate, so if they want participation they'll have to pay and pay well.
- olivermarks 4y agoBut then you won't be able to drive your electric car because it's not charged up...
- eddhead 4y agoHow did BritishVolt go bankrupt then?
- amalgamated_inc 4y agoSlowly, then suddenly.
- Reason077 4y agoManufacturing battery cells is very energy intensive, so I’m guessing that the recent sky-high UK energy prices spooked their investors and made UK battery manufacturing look unviable. Something like NorthVolt, on the other hand, works because they have access to reliable low-cost hydro in Northern Sweden.
- sandos 4y agoYes, Northvolt tried building their factory further south in Sweden (Västerås) but was denied due to limited grid capacity. Turns out they were somewhat lucky, since electricity prices are cheaper furter north, and the energy crisis happened!
- meltyness 4y agoThat this is still only an academic rumbling / home of the future[0] talk speaks volumes about how out-of-touch global finance remains. [0] https://www.wsj.com/podcasts/tech-news-briefing/tapping-electric-cars-to-power-the-electric-grid/2a81baba-e094-4d43-a49e-3818eac06c7e https://www.wsj.com/podcasts/tech-news-briefing/tapping-elec...
- throwawaaarrgh 4y agoWe're nowhere near close to home charging for the number of EVs estimated by 2030. Go ask around, very few organizations are working on it compared to public chargers. Apartment managers and condo associations aren't demanding them and only homeowners have a say, after they pay for the upgrade. Not to mention, the power companies hate the idea. They won't even let people with solar panels feed their excess power to the grid. We would need a federal mandate to get there, and I don't see it happening.
- martinflack 4y ago> They won't even let people with solar panels feed their excess power to the grid. Is that true? If so, TIL...
- chucksta 4y agoDepends on your state https://www.solarpowerworldonline.com/2020/03/which-states-offer-net-metering/ https://www.solarpowerworldonline.com/2020/03/which-states-o...
- burkaman 4y agoIt is not true, but they do make it very hard in some places and as a group utilities do kind of hate the idea. Almost all states require net metering, which what allows people to sell their solar to the grid, and there is some federal regulation too (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_Policy_Act_of_2005 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_Policy_Act_of_2005). Despite these requirements most utilities make it pretty hard to set up.
- PaulDavisThe1st 4y agoI opted NOT to sell my excess to PNM (New Mexico), because the agreement allowed them to claim my 6.7kW array as part of their own progress towards renewable conversion. What I didn't understand was that I ended up with an even better deal! I get back the excess kW/h on a 1:1 basis. This is much better "pricing" than I would have received if I had sold it for cash. Granted this model only works if there's a part of the year when you produce more than you need and another part of the year where you produce less. Since we heat more or less exclusively with electric air source heat pumps, but need no heat or a/c during summer, this works extremely well for us.
- bottlepalm 4y agoThis is already happening today in California, a couple gigawatts of batteries are charged during the day and released in the evening to offset peak demand. https://www.caiso.com/TodaysOutlook/Pages/supply.html https://www.caiso.com/TodaysOutlook/Pages/supply.html
- yodsanklai 4y agoThis seems high(?): for comparison, average power of French solar panels is 1.6GW (and a bit more for wind power).
- p1necone 4y agoThe population of California is ~ half that of France, and presumably California sells power to neighbouring states too, so it doesn't seem that out of whack.
- miahi 4y agoInsolation is higher in California, with the same solar panel surface you can probably get double the energy over a year, compared to France.
- fit2rule 4y ago[dead]
- martini333 4y agoI would not sell cycles from my EVs NMC battery.
- maliker 4y agoHmm, but how often and for how much? If you could get $500 to discharge 50% would that make it worth your while? If you only did it once a month? There are price situations like that on the grid already.
- oittaa 4y agoAs others have mentioned power companies in California pay a lot for virtual power plants when the demand is high. If power companies can avoid running an expensive peaker plant once a month, everybody wins.
- bryanlarsen 4y agoTexas was paying $9/kWh for electricity during their blackouts. If you had 72kWh of electricity in your Tesla that'd be a nice payout...
- vel0city 4y ago9 * 72 minus some losses, minus the delivery fees, maybe $600 for what would hopefully be an incredibly rare event. Meanwhile, after selling all the power in your Tesla in a house that's constantly getting colder with frozen pipes and no electricity you've now sold your best options of leaving with your family for a warming shelter. How many days was the power mostly out? Personally I'd keep the power in the car in an emergency like that. I'd much rather have the ability to flee if things get worse than sell my best way out in the first few hours of an emergency.
- microdrum 4y agoEVs with BrakeFlow resistive protection against thermal runaway also will have a big impact –– allowing for faster discharge into the grid. Increasing cRate for grid services can "bring forward" the point in time –– so 2030 could even happen a few years sooner if these high performance batteries from Enovix come to the EV market soon.
- cschmid 4y agoThe Taiwanese scooter company Gogoro recently announced something similar: Their scooters come with swappable batteries that you rent. The swapping station they have throughout the city are basically walls full of batteries. Since the company owns all the batteries, they can then use them to provide power to the grid during peak load.
- trompetenaccoun 4y agoThat makes more sense as it can be better planned based on projected demand. They also have more batteries than customers. With individual car owners, they often can't charge when it's convenient for the grid because they drive their car and need it when they need it.
- paraselene_ 4y agoThey also have solar panels at their batteryswap station when possible. The problem is battery rentals, I think only NIO right now is operating battery-swapable EVs. It's easy on a scooter, but not so much on cars IMO.
- dokem 4y agoIs the energy in these batteries for scooters or the grid? So you need to store more energy than the scooters need so that energy is not depleted from servicing the grid. Now you have excess batteries in the middle of urban area. Not what you want. The amount of energy needed for some scooters is peanuts when talking about the grid. Not to mention that scooter usage and grid power consumption surge will roughly correlate. Have scooters, sure. Have batteries of some form to handle the grid, sure. There is absolutely no need for this to be combined.
- joshe 4y agoIt feels like an iceberg has been slowly turning over for the past 10 years, and is now flipping quickly. Economic growth is now more correlated with carbon reduction than increase. The useful work of preventing coal plants is over and we need to switch gears to get home appliances, ev cars, solar, wind and transmission out as quickly as possible. Environmental groups and common knowledge haven't caught up yet, but the fastest route to a low carbon future is a lot of factories producing ev cars, appliances, and batteries. There are many zombie environmental groups that will continue to fight against anything humans try to change about the built environment, but over time the astonishingly good economics will move them to the side. One of the nice thing is they don't really have much power other than stopping solar farms and stopping clean energy transmission. For 80% of the things we need to do, it's just people going to home depot. And in many ways old school environmentalists are already losing the policy wars, the inflation reduction act is chock full of pro growth, pro abundance carbon reduction. If you are looking for startup inspiration... Super powerful battery augmented induction stove, hotter than gas: https://www.treehugger.com/impulse-electric-cooktop-gets-a-boost-from-batteries-6829666 https://www.treehugger.com/impulse-electric-cooktop-gets-a-b... In window heat pump 80% more efficient at heating and cooling. Helps with the big ticket/renter problem for heat pumps. https://www.gradientcomfort.com/ https://www.gradientcomfort.com/ The coming abundance of energy... Economic growth and solar: https://mobile.twitter.com/Noahpinion/status/1570688144449871872 https://mobile.twitter.com/Noahpinion/status/157068814444987... Solar economics: https://noahpinion.substack.com/p/why-im-so-excited-about-solar-and https://noahpinion.substack.com/p/why-im-so-excited-about-so...
- Timshel 4y agoMeh when I see that we are barely able to stop the growth of fossile fuel usage ( https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/World_energy_supply_and_consumption#/media/File%3AGlobal_Energy_Consumption.svg https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/World_energy_supply_and_cons... ), I'm not sure why peoples are so optimistic. And it's not like Enr and other suggestion you propose will not need insane amount of ressource extraction. Heat pump usually need a well insulated home, just isolating all the needed house in the next 25 years is probably a challenge itself between cost and having enough workers. And it's not like there was an article last week on electrician shortage ...
- pandama 4y agoPlease say a prayer for the people of the Congo who will have to mine the cobalt we want.
- rockinghigh 4y agoBattery makers are moving away from cobalt. Tesla already switched half of their batteries to a version based on lithium iron phosphate (LFP) which does not contain cobalt.
- eunos 4y agoAs other comment wrote batteries are moving to cobalt free LFP. Now can it be said that we just rob the future from Congo by preventing them capitals from their cobalt?
- pandama 4y agoWith "the future from the Congo", you are talking about the people with control over the artisinal miners using guns, right? There isn't enough cobalt supply despite these measures and so LFP is being used in lower range cars. No way I would buy one of those.
- PeterCorless 4y agoConsidering that most "EV batteries" are actually just smaller batteries glued together to bigger cells, modules and packs, I don't think this is as much of a win as people think it is. It's like saying "We can green the planet with Duracells." Ignoring what's in the batteries or what it takes to manufacture them. Or how they degrade over time. We may need to look at hybrid battery solutions with alternative energy storage systems, like graphene supercapacitors. https://www.laserax.com/blog/ev-battery-cell-types https://www.laserax.com/blog/ev-battery-cell-types
- karamanolev 4y agoIt's not as black and white. EV batteries are getting produced and will get produced quite a lot it seems. We'll be using them for transportation, but if we can also use them for short-term grid storage, that certainly improves the sustainability math. Using things better is a win, so let's do it. We can't green the planet with Duracells, but it's certainly better than producing and not fully using the Duracells.
- ericd 4y agoSorry, how is the size of the individual cells relevant? Big cells are just the same sorts of cathode/anode sheets, but in larger rolls, no? Duracells are typically single-use alkaline, so I’m also not sure why that comparison makes sense?
- ggm 4y ago"may need to" -Power Utilities worldwide have been looking at flow battery models for decades. What they lacked was supply chain committed to the longterm specific model, and a pricepoint which matched their needs. Lithium batteries were being made in volumes with a supply chain for multiple uses: cars, home storage, this industrial-scale purpose. It provided a pricepoint and a supply chain and logistics to match for BMS and demand management at scale. Flow batteries are good. They exist. They didn't get the capital required to drive them to ubiquity, in industrial scale deployment .. yet. Also, putting to one side "duracell" typically means a non rechargable, we actually can green the planet WITH canister sized individual battery instances ganged up into bigger units, because that's precisely what we are doing. The mistake is thinking batteries can do it alone. Not what format they come in and how we aggregate them. There are gigawatts and gigawatt-hours of Tesla batteries in deployment which provide frequency stability, and other load demand management services, and extend the duration that solar and wind power can be supplied without "firming" from Gas or other peaker plants, and they supplant traditional condenser spinning loads, and actually DO supply power. They have helped significantly alter the trajectory of change here. This is a bit like saying "great: we can't build skyscrapers out of something as small as gravel, this is stupid: we invented bricks for a reason" ignoring the structural role of gravel as aggregate in concrete. Individual cell technology is not the limiting factor here.
- mikaeluman 4y agoDid I read too sloppily or did they simply not discuss actual availability, that is supply, of metals needed?
- JakeAl 4y agoI wouldn't take that bet until solid state batteries get better. This is a disaster in the making.
- ratboy666 4y agoThe elephant in the room -- unfortunately, there cannot be enough batteries made to support this. That is why I invested in Tesla -- don't care about EVs, but the battery play is good! Backup power for personal/family use? I use a Firman generator - 20 litres of fuel per day of operation at load. (here, $30 Canadian). Since the generator was only $300 and load is 3000W, this is a much better deal for me. And... at the rates being bandied about here... if anyone EVERY offers, say, $1/KWh - That grosses me $70 per $30 of gas. I would take that incentive. Note that the generator would pay for itself every 10 days by my reckoning.. And the recycling of the motor is already a solved problem. So... $1/KWh is way too much. $0.50/KWh is also too much (and note that my gasoline pricing is around $1.50/litre at the pump -- $22.41 US for 20 liters ... So the actual amount should be around 32 cents per KW/h... 50 cents work fine because that factors in "wear and tear" -- do those numbers work for batteries? Of course, buying electricity is 7 to 15 cents/KWh here. I would want LiFePo4 for this application; at current rates, a 10KWh battery runs $10,000. From that, I determine that I can "just" buy much more effective gas/natural gas/propane burning generators. Something like the Generac 6551. Natural gas is .23/c3 or around $1 for one hour of 7000W operation... actually looking competitive with electricity grid rates (except wear&tear on the generator). Note that I do have a hybrid car. So, not "anti-electric" by any means. I just don't think that enough batteries can be made for this application. Certainly NOT be 2030 (6 years? Oh really?)
- tuatoru 4y ago> unfortunately, there cannot be enough batteries made to support this. Why do you say this? It contradicts what everyone in the industry thinks. There are no material shortages for the materials used in lithium batteries, and there are several alternative chemistries under active development, that are at least two of cheaper, more durable, or higher power-to-weight than lithium.
- reportingsjr 4y ago> I would want LiFePo4 for this application; at current rates, a 10KWh battery runs $10,000. Where in the heck did you get that number? 10kWh of LiFePO4 batteries is more like $3k at current prices: https://signaturesolar.com/eg4-lifepower4-lithium-battery-48v-100ah/?setCurrencyId=1&srsltid=AeTuncpTxPvKfrxGAtr46WGFibDBPB5vvrhgblCB3e6AZfqXy90r4Wc534Y https://signaturesolar.com/eg4-lifepower4-lithium-battery-48...
- claytongulick 4y agoMaybe before we get too excited about scaling production of EV batteries, we should solve the horrific abuses in the cobalt mines in the Congo [1] which provide 70%+ of all cobalt for all lithium ion batteries. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CIWvk3gJ_7E https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CIWvk3gJ_7E
- vardump 4y agoCobalt is becoming less and less important component of the batteries in the EV business. It's just not necessary, and can be replaced for example by nickel (and manganese) or iron (LFP batteries).
- elihu 4y agoCobalt is "needed" for luxury EVs. Everyone else could get by reasonably well with LFP cells.
- fwungy 4y ago1) This only works when the overlap peak electric demand and peak vehicle demand do not overlap. Night time, when the cars sit idle, is also a low demand time of day, and the afternoon energy demand peak coincides partially with the evening commute. 2) The loss of value to the owner based on cycles used needs to take into account that the failure of the battery in a vehicle can be what causes its final retirement, i.e. the condition of the vehicle itself does not justify a new battery expenditure. EVs are more like cell phones than ICE cars, which can have lifespans of over 30 years in the right climate. So losing 10% of your cycles to grid support could mean buying a car at nine years instead of ten years. Take a $40000 EV with half of the value being in the battery. Financed, say it's $600/month on a six year loan. With a ten year life span that's four years of no payments. With V2G say you lose 10% of your cycles, so you have three "free" years instead of four. Your real cost is 12 * $600 = $7200. You can't just calculate the pure cost of the battery with V2G, you need to take into account the depreciation on the entire vehicle as it relates to the battery. In fact, we know very little about how BEVs will depreciate.
- trompetenaccoun 4y agoAnd keep in mind it's to store energy from renewables (minus hydropower), i.e. mainly solar and wind. Solar is nonexistent at night. And although it varies, wind is generally strongest during the day and delivers less energy at night. But night-time is exactly when the vehicles are charged in people's homes, at least currently that's the situation and it would necessitate a ton of new infrastructure to change that. High voltage charging everywhere - ideally even DC charging and the necessary transformers, power cables etc. Even for street parking, because that's where a lot of cars are parked. So assuming there will be more EVs and we want to reach those net zero goals politicians always talk about we'd need charging stations everywhere. Meanwhile in the real world, here is the result when the green revolution doesn't go as imagined, due to failures in planning and mismanagement. Case study Germany: https://www.euractiv.com/section/energy-environment/news/growing-demand-puts-eu-electricity-grid-under-pressure/ https://www.euractiv.com/section/energy-environment/news/gro...
- themitigating 4y ago
- boringg 4y agoHypothetically sure - practically? Tough. Policy will be able to signal enough value for home owners to recoup the costs of degrading their asset (in this car care battery) and provide the margin for whoever is operating all the assets at the same time. I suspect that the players who aggregate across assets will provide a payout for the Tesla owners however that payout is less than the depreciation of their asset as a result. Most people won't be wise though. Energy arbitrage rarely make sense financially - you could operate an asset for awhile but the high cost of LiON batteries aren't made for energy arbitrage (typically financial differential between peak and off peak is not significant enough). Again unless there is a valuable pricing signal OR someone like OhmConnect makes significant in roads to market penetration / policy makers / execution of product.
- 535188B17C93743 4y agoIt'd sure be interesting for manufacturers to rent batteries to car-buyers and then have access to transmit energy to-and-from those batteries as a utility. If employers had hookups, during the day this could be done (set the time you'll be back for full charge) and this could also be done while cars are in garages at night.
- slavboj 4y agoWho's paying the capex on charging cycles for personal car batteries?
- zbrozek 4y agoI'd really like to use my car (Bolt) as a battery for the house, but this isn't actually achievable in the US right now. We're not going to be doing this in 2030 if the equipment doesn't support it.
- deostroll 4y agoThis paper covers only one aspect - estimating demand. But the cost of the EV batteries is another affair. Recently it has come to light several human rights violations involved with the lithium/cobalt mining industry. Both are necessary for making batteries and other electrical components that make up rechargeable batteries. But today, at least for the short-term, the only solution to stop those inhuman practices is to provide humanitarian aid. The proliferation of violations are at such a scale that even if some major tech players come together and decide that they should provide this humanitarian aid to the "miners", the profit margins drop drastically. Hence EV batteries may not become viable to the end-consumers.
- jillesvangurp 4y agoLithium is one of the more common elements on this planet. It's not a rare earth mineral. And there are ways to get lithium now that don't involve boohoo stories with small children breaking their backs under inhumane circumstances. E.g. Tesla is opening a lithium refining facility in Texas. And there are several battery chemistries that don't use cobalt at all now as well. And of course you can source cobalt from reputable mines as well these days if you do need it. And many companies make an effort to do just that. And of course batteries can be recycled and this is expected to be a big business pretty soon. Most EV manufacturers are already recycling their batteries. These things won't end up in landfills. So, it's not the case that all batteries must involve child labor and mass pollution. There are definitely some sustainability issues around battery production of course. Can we do better? Absolutely. But it's not that horrible to begin with. And it pales in comparison to the oil and gas industry. Lots of crocodile tears get expended on behalf of the children in the Congo. But nobody ever wonders where their petrol comes from. Double standards/hypocrisy.
- cryptonector 4y agoExcept that they won't because a) EV manufacturers won't allow it (Tesla doesn't), b) EV owners won't want to drain their EVs' batteries for others' benefit, c) even if EV owners wanted to allow it, they wouldn't necessarily all have their EVs plugged in when needed.
- cbmuser 4y agoOr, you know, we could just build more nuclear power plants instead of such an overengineered solution which requires millions of car owners to be cooperative citizens.