9 ms·
Despite everything you think you know, America is on the right track
- hersko 4y ago"Despite what the Main Stream Media is constantly trying to make you believe." What the headline should be.
- d35007 4y agoThat Atlantic is part of the "main stream media".
- jeffwask 4y agoA wealthy conservative Boomer raised by two college professors who had all the opportunity life could grant believes things aren't as bad as they seem. Shocking take, utterly shocking.
- yucky 4y agoAlso, this is the Atlantic. Them cheerleading neoliberal globalization is like Tesla saying we need to buy more electric vehicles.
- celtoid 4y agoDavid Brooks has a long history of being dead wrong but he still gets paid to be dead wrong. Great gig.
- leashless 4y agoI was curious about the piece until I saw Brooks.
- korroziya 4y agoThank you for proving my point.
- bnralt 4y agoThe job of talking heads is entertainment, not any practical value. I'd say the same is mostly true for the news media at large, as well as bloggers, commentators, humanities theorists, and other professional thinkers.
- guerrilla 4y agoNot just entertainment but often generating propaganda for their employers.
- korroziya 4y agoMost of the writers for the Atlanic are dead wrong (hell most op-eds are regardless of source) but David Brooks is a "conservative" by liberal standards so people on HN and Twitter love to call him out more than their progressive talking head darlings.
- celtoid 4y agoThe editor of The Atlantic has questionable ethics (he was a military prison guard while he served in a foreign army that's been accused of war crimes) so I always look at The Atlantic with a jaundiced eye. As for Brooks, he defended the invasion of Iraq for years.
- areyousure 4y agoIn case anyone is curious, this oblique description is of the editor-in-chief of Atlantic magazine: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jeffrey_Goldberg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jeffrey_Goldberg The "foreign army that's been accused of war crimes" is the Israel Defense Forces. Jeffrey Goldberg appears to have written a book about some aspects of his time as a prison guard at Ktzi'ot Prison: https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/139269.Prisoners https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/139269.Prisoners
- aeneasmackenzie 4y agoConservatives don't like David Brooks either.
- 77pt77 4y agoPeter Zeihan is another grifter along the same lines. His new grift is that merica is on the right track because religion and China is done for because heathens. Another hilarious one was Fukuyama and the whole the end of history grift of the 1990s.
- derbOac 4y agoI find these sorts of discussions unproductive in the absence of some specific focal points. Discussing how well the US is doing overall is sort of meaningless because it's so heterogeneous; you could have serious problems even while overall the country is doing well by historical standards. Saying things are fine by the standards of the 1940s isn't helpful either; I'm not sure that's ever really been an appropriate yardstick (I think public health and wellness opportunity costs are often more relevant). I also think you can take many of these same sorts of arguments, go back in time, and find out that many positive indicators preceded very horrific periods in world history. For instance, there were a lot of societal advancements that coincided with the emergence of the world wars, and they still happened despite (or maybe even because) of those advancements. I also have come to believe that many forms of societal collapse or crisis emerge fairly rapidly; things seem good by many objective indicators until they really don't. If you track some of these public indicators, they often seem to covary relatively weakly with the sorts of things you might expect, and no one really understands why. Seen from a distanced perspective those indicators don't seem to work as measures of what you'd like them to. I'm not trying to adopt a pessimistic position, as I tend to think a lot of that is equally poorly posed, and I think the article is correct that if you look to history simply for benchmarks of what to expect when something bad happens, things aren't as catastrophic as you'd think. But in the absence of some kind of rigorous understanding of what to look to for societal collapse or catastrophe, these kinds of discussions in either direction are kind of pointless. What seems more relevant are more focal discussions of specific issues, or how to predict what is important.
- Retric 4y agoHe directly mentions how things have been improved since 2007, so no the comparison isn’t just to the 1940’s. His point is people think American is much worse off than it actually is and he backs that up.
- zcw100 4y agoYou could make the argument that America is great because we think we suck and drive ourselves harder than might be necessary. It's when you think you're great that you become complacent.
- ShivShankaran 4y ago[dead]
- borissk 4y agoFully agree with article author. US has it's fair share of problems, but if it avoids a second Trump term I think it will have a bright future in the next few dozen years. China was a potential threat to the US global technological, industrial and military superiority, but since the 10 year change of leadership was abandoned I don't think they are a real threat anymore. Their dictator will concentrate on keeping his power and not on developing the country.
- brink 4y ago> but if it avoids a second Trump term I'm no Trump fanatic, but I still do not understand what people's real problem is with him either. Most of their problems seem to be made up. You can see it most clearly in the Jan 6th committee, who were committed by any means to suggesting that Trump incited violence even though he directly and plainly called for peaceful protest and spoke against violence that day, yet they showed none of that during the "trials".
- spywaregorilla 4y agoAnyone who denies the legitimacy of democratic elections is an enormous threat to the nature of democracy and should not be given large political power.
- brink 4y agoThe left did that in '16 and went on a sham witch hunt for meddling Russians for 3 years until they came up with pretty much nothing. So I'm not sure what you're trying to say. Maybe.. "It's only okay when we do it"?
- spywaregorilla 4y agoThe conclusion was that Russia was without a doubt meddling with the election. But the conclusion was not that the election itself was fraudulent or something that we should not abide by.
- 4y ago
- pastacacioepepe 4y agoWeird that it's always the elites to tell us that all is going well and we should stop complaining already.
- evan_ 4y agoI’d probably feel better about things if I was getting $120k vacations for free. https://www.nytimes.com/2015/11/09/t-magazine/vacation-four-seasons-around-the-world.html https://www.nytimes.com/2015/11/09/t-magazine/vacation-four-...
- frankfrankfrank 4y agoI find that phenomenon really weird, where things the ruling class promote or say is not immediately seen with immense suspicion if not outright immediate rejection and counter. There is simply no greater alienation and division than the difference between the ruling class and the people who do the work. An example; the ruling class promoting unfettered immigration and “Our Democracy” does not make people at least a bit suspicious of their motivations? Billionaires pushing immigration to import cheap labor? Billionaires pushing the populace having a supposed vote? But then again, this forum is very much a body representing ruling class agents at the very least, and it is immensely difficult for people to admit, let alone just contemplate that they are possibly not the good and great people they think themselves of. This YN forum isn’t all that different than a palace parlor where the aristocratic strata of the past who told themselves all kind of things about how they need to impose their ideas on the working class … for their own benefits, which magically happen to coincide with only advantaging the aristocracy. It’s really no differ than in the past; be it the feudal European aristocracy, the Southern aristocracy, or the technocratic modern aristocracy that is deceptive and secretive about what they need to impose on the commoners but not on themselves.
- dangond 4y ago> the people who are most pessimistic about the country are not the working class but highly educated and affluent people—the people, that is, who spend more time engaging with news media. I was surprised by this claim. I was always under the impression that poorer people spent more time consuming news media, and that the wealthier a person was, the less news they consumed. I don't know where I got such an impression, and I think I may have confused the statistics for television watching in general. Does anyone have a good source showing a correlation in either direction?
- JKCalhoun 4y agoConfused me as well. Perhaps David Brooks believes the working class get their news from Facebook memes. It's the only explanation that allows me to make his statement congruous.
- panzagl 4y agoDo you know any old people? My family is 24 hours Fox news, my wife's is 24 hour CNN, I can't say that either has a rosy view of where the country is going. Both would be considered well-off. Everyone else (especially the working poor) is too busy to listen to that noise.
- JKCalhoun 4y agoYou're only underscoring my same feeling of incongruity reading Brooks' statement. Yes, I know old people (ha ha, I'm old as well, but perhaps that's beside the point). My father has the TV on 24/7 with, I assume, FOX news playing (I wouldn't know since it's been over a decade since I chose to visit him, sadly). I haven't had cable for over two decades now. I only catch cable news in the early morning when I'm in a Best Western lobby trying to pull a waffle out of the waffle iron.
- JKCalhoun 4y ago> Many of them believe that radical action, even violence, may be necessary to save it. Too bad. I believe that change brought about through violence will only lead to a violent regime.
- guerrilla 4y agoSo you agree that every country that exists today is a violent regime except the handful that gained their independence peacefully because the rest were all formed through violence?
- JKCalhoun 4y agoI'm not a historian, perhaps you can enlighten me. France is one that came to mind. Violent regime? Of course not. But they did have to tread through a reign of terror after their Révolution française. Perhaps you eventually get to a peaceful regime. But it's hard to imagine power sweeping into control on a wave of violence suddenly shuttering that same violence.
- kelseyfrog 4y agoThis has been true at least for the US since the revolutionary war and in France since theirs.
- seanw444 4y agoCounterpoint: 1776.
- JKCalhoun 4y agoThe exception that proves the rule? That was the one that came to mind that, to my history-lacking-knowledge became peaceful right after the shooting stopped. I don't disagree.
- mensetmanusman 4y agoAn extremely rare event due to a leader actually stepping down when everyone around him was telling him to stay. Historians point to this behavior by George Washington as essentially one-of-a-kind in human history.
- nextstep 4y agoHahah! New this would be by Brooks before I clicked. Strongly disagree with this entire argument. Americans work more for less than their parents did, and much of the rest of the western world.
- Retric 4y agoOnly if you ignore the increases in quality over time. Yes people pay more for housing, however in 1975 the average American home was 560 Sq Ft/person in 2015 it hit 1058 Sq Ft/person. https://thefioneers.com/average-home-size/ https://thefioneers.com/average-home-size/ So people are paying more for housing, they are also getting a lot more of it. Similarly people keep moving to expensive cities which shockingly have expensive housing. It costs exponentially more, but cancer is killing fewer people today than a generation ago. https://www.cdc.gov/cancer/dcpc/research/update-on-cancer-deaths/index.htm https://www.cdc.gov/cancer/dcpc/research/update-on-cancer-de...
- scythe 4y agoHouses got bigger because they're not allowed to be small. Most cities have minimum lot sizes. Even Houston, the libertarian poster child, has a minimum lot size of, IIRC, 5000 square feet. People move to expensive cities because that's where the jobs are. Nobody moves to Fort Bragg, even though it has practically the same climate and coastline as San Francisco, because there's no money to be made. Handwaving these economic forces away as "quality increases" is misleading.
- sidewndr46 4y agoNot only are there minimum lot sizes, there are minimum square footage mandates in effect for much of America. Also as a home builder once you realize how expensive the permitting process can be you're suddenly motivated to build big. The permitting doesn't scale with structure size, it is fixed in most areas.
- sidewndr46 4y agoI don't really see how square feet per person is "more". Where I live for example it's an actually a detriment as I'm taxed based off the habitable square footage. This just further increases the cost of living.
- frankfrankfrank 4y agoThis reads just like how a con artist and manipulative person would frame things, essentially, don’t believe your own eyes and mind, let someone else with their own motivations tell you how it is instead. It is not possible for America to be on the right track when it is not no longer on the America track. Those are mutually excluding things, like a man abducting a child having the child’s best interest in mind. No matter what track we are on, we are clearly no longer on the American track when America is being denigrated and abused and destroyed in all aspects but the name. Is it the right track? That’s a different question altogether, but if the person making such a statement is being deceptive and manipulative in their language, it is reasonable to assume they are also not honest in their motivations and intent, hostile even.
- InitialLastName 4y ago> Those are mutually excluding things, like a man abducting a child having the child’s best interest in mind. This is possibly a bad example; the overwhelming majority of "kidnappings" of children are by one parent as a result of a dispute with the other parent. In that case, the "abducting" parent might well have (and almost certainly think they have) the best interests of the child in mind (never mind that the other parent and/or the state apparatus might disagree).
- pipeline_peak 4y agoThat's a lot of talk without mentioning mass shootings and health insurance
- rank0 4y agoAmerica is not “on the right track” We had a half baked coup attempt in 2020. People are polarizing in ways that weren't around only a few years ago. The congressional deficit has ballooned to unsustainable levels. Our annual interest payments are ~400B/yr. Social Security is projected to default next decade. We’re back to fighting proxy wars with the Russians, which the supposedly progressive author presents as a positive! We’ve destroyed South America and the Middle East in pursuit of our strategic goals. I hope we don’t provoke china into a war over Taiwan… I love my country but shit is seriously fucked up right now.
- agloeregrets 4y ago> People are polarizing in ways that weren't around only a few years ago. This one gets me the worst. America's political landscape is forever changed. 1. Political discourse between sides is so aggressive that morals, the truth, etc, are trumped by 'Who cares? My team is winning.' 2. Congressional cooperation has fallen to levels where the entirety of the government is incapable of making simple, easy decisions, and even when they do, it must help a talking point. 3. This divide has spread outwards into other branches of government in such a way that breaks the entire intent of checks and balances. At this point, the Supreme court is just doing a congressional party's bidding. This seems like 'balance' to other branches but it actually limits the ability for the supreme court to make impartial choices and means that a regime change in congress/ president will fully eliminate checks and balance. The government will answer to a party's bidding rather than the constitution or people. 4. A majority of people in one party no longer trust the electoral system while a majority in the other party see signs that the game is rigged against them (Gerrymandering). This causes a general feeling of 'We lost because of X, not because of us.' But finally, to me, the worst item... 5. Politics in America are now about feeling right and 'winning' rather than promises and goals. This was always in the background and any marketer will tell you this is how human minds work...but this change accelerates the rest. It doesn't matter what policy is passed or how it plays out, as long as 'I feel right.' Politics now realize that success is a 'sick burn' or a 'scary claim about "them"', not actual improvement of the country. Why? One of these is publicity and moves individual donations...it helps get you elected. It fires up your base because it is way easier to sell negative emotions ("I hate them", "They are going to kill america, we have to save it") rather than positive ("Our government is doing good things.") This means you need puppets, people in your party for their party to hate and people in their party for your party to hate. Alas, you get Trump, AOC, McConnell, Pelosi, Gatez. Each party knows this agreement is fantastic, or has learned it at least. Why? Because if, say, the GOP did not have a 'them' it would be impossible to sell.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- horsawlarway 4y agoI find it hard to take this seriously. The argument basically boils down to "America has survived turmoil by adapting before - so we should assume it will again". But that has nothing at all to do with "America is on the right track". If anything, I'd argue that the current pessimism is fairly warranted, and a crucial step in the process of adapting. The current format doesn't work for most people, in the same way that it didn't in the 1890s. The way we adapted was by tanking the financial industry (great depression) taxing the ever loving fuck out of the "robber baron" class (90%+ taxes) and creating an entirely new social contract (the "new deal"). We also lucked out with our industry remaining intact while the rest of the world dealt with the fallout of the world wars... Basically - If anything, we are decidedly NOT on the right track right now, but we arguably have the ability (and may be moderately well prepared) to change course. Optimism about the status quo is... not exactly warranted in my opinion - although pointing out our strengths is a good reminder that we have the ability to change. But it still requires... you know... actually changing.
- notch656c 4y agoChanging the course to local needs gets harder and harder every year, as consolidation of federal power hardens. Wickard v Filburn is case in point of the destruction caused by the New Deal. A man cannot even grow feed and feed it to his own animals without falling into "interstate commerce."
- zephyrthenoble 4y agoWhat does "changing the course to local" mean?
- golemotron 4y agoTo contextualize opinion pieces like this just consider that the writer gets paid regardless of whether he is ever wrong or right.
- altgeek 4y agoToo bad that writers and economists don't have concrete skin the game. Maybe some dosh should be put up, or their actual skin as Nasim Taleb wistfully notes (See the story of Sisamnes.)
- dangond 4y agoThis article makes a very good case for why the American economy is on the right track. However, I doubt this is what most respondents were thinking about when asked about "the direction of the country" (which to me already sounds like a question that biases people to answer in the negative). Brooks talks repeatedly about how the news media has influenced people's perceptions, but the news media he talks about has (from my perspective) spent more time on social issues rather than the economy, so of course there's a discrepancy there. He's tackling a fundamentally different question than the poll he mentioned. Just because America is on the right track economically does not mean that people are wrong to demand more from their country in other failing areas.
- nemo44x 4y agoWe need more progress. Everything has been getting worse and worse the last 80 years since the New Deal because we just haven't had enough government management to make things good. We should cede more power to the managerial class of academic experts, corporate leaders, and the elite journals (like the Atlantic) that vouch for their brilliance at managing us all, as their poorer and poorer performance is likely because they just haven't had enough control to make more progress.
- 77pt77 4y agoI still remember seeing a map from 2019 or shortly before showing countries preparedness for a pandemic. The USA and the UK were at the very top, being considered the best. It might have been this one: https://www.statista.com/chart/20629/ability-to-respond-to-an-epidemic-or-pandemic/ https://www.statista.com/chart/20629/ability-to-respond-to-a... Notice how Ireland is obviously worse than the UK. Portugal also worse than Spain. USA on the best tier. (No one is green I think) Another one even better: https://www.visualcapitalist.com/global-pandemic-preparedness-ranked/ https://www.visualcapitalist.com/global-pandemic-preparednes... USA at the very top followed obviously by all the anglosphere. Brazil, Belgium and Japan at the same level! Now contrast this with reality. If this pandemic showed anything is that the premise of this post is completely wrong. Look how that turned out. Must really suck having to spend so much energy ignoring reality. Then again, given the level of religiosity of the place I guess it really doesn't take that much extra energy.
- the_gastropod 4y agoYea, it's weird that a previous president's decision in 2018 to disband the National Security Council directorate for global health and security and bio-defense at the White House might've resulted in a lack of preparedness. His decision to completely politicize it and recommend quack-science solutions, from ingesting disinfectant, to "bringing light into the body", to taking random unrelated pharmaceuticals (ivermectin & hydroxychloroquine) might not have helped our response too much either.
- 77pt77 4y agoAnd this map was made after that. Although I'm pretty sure it wouldn't have made much of a difference.
- spookthesunset 4y agoTo be fair we completely ignored every single bit of that pandemic plan and instead decided to do almost the entire opposite of what was recommended…
- 4y ago
- jmyeet 4y agoI could spend hours taking this apart but this part (to borrow a meme) made me throw up a little in my mouth: > Take out a piece of paper. In one column, list all of the major problems this country faces—inequality, political polarization, social distrust, climate change, and so on. In another column, write seven words: “America has more talent than ever before.” Life isn't great because a pound of sugar has a lower labor-cost than it did 200 years ago. Here's another nugget: > From 1980 to 2018, the average amount of time a person had to work to afford the basket of commodities—energy, food, raw materials—that make up a typical middle-class lifestyle fell by 72 percent I notice housing isn't on that list. I mean this whole piece could be summed up as "Isn't capitalism, and by extension America, amazing?" Debt is built into your existence. Student debt, housing debt, medical debt. We have a system ibuilt on the exploitation of labor and the only way for profits to keep increasing is for labor to be squeezed ever more. Every part of your life is being financialized. A workforce living paycheck-to-paycheck is a compliant workforce. This is the road to neufeudalism.
- EasyTiger_ 4y agoA few articles from 'The Atlantic' on the front page suddenly?
- api 4y agoThere's a strong negativity bias in our system owing in part to the media and in part to the fact that both major political parties need to convince you the nation will collapse if the other party is elected.
- jccalhoun 4y agoIt is hard for me to be optimistic. I teach at a community college and in December I went out to a couple local high schools to observe the teachers teaching dual credit classes. Both of the schools were shabby and falling apart. One of the rooms had large areas of paint peeling off the wall. Last summer there was a ballot measure to fund building a new building for a 3rd school. It was overwhelmingly rejected even though there was a story in the newspaper about one of the classrooms being declared unsafe. In many measures of health, education, lifespan, and income my state ranks in the bottom half. Yet the state had a record surplus. What did they do with it? Fund things like education or roads? Cut the state gas tax that is one of the highest in the country? Nope. They gave people a $140 check. Sure that is nice but it would be better to invest in long term improvements. Yet in my state one political party has a supermajority in state politics with no sign of that changing any time soon.
- fallingknife 4y agoThe US is 5th in the world in education spending per student in elementary - HS and 2nd in college. They have the money they need. I would have voted it down too. If they can't afford repairs, they can fire some administrators. https://nces.ed.gov/programs/coe/indicator/cmd/education-expenditures-by-country https://nces.ed.gov/programs/coe/indicator/cmd/education-exp...
- jccalhoun 4y agoIn the above post I said my state ranks in the bottom half of most measures when compared to other states? Guess where my state ranks in spending per student? Below average by a few thousand...
- fallingknife 4y agoThen it's similar to France
- yamtaddle 4y agoAny good way to adjust that for the effects of other social spending that's not on the school's books?
- Zurrrrr 4y ago[flagged]
- brailsafe 4y agoMeh, as a non-american it seems like a specious list of aspirations that Americans themselves defined. Odd to pick out historical prices of sugar when... you know. They'd really have to have screwed something up for sugar of all commodities to be more expensive than in the middle ages. Deaths from Heart disease and smoking are down, but obesity has reached absurd levels. Productivity gains largely captured by so many other people and things, including hedonism. America has a lot of positive attributes as a visitor, but this is a deeply unconvincing article and it would take a monumental evolution for me to want to live there long-term. They do have a certain tenacity though, I'll give them that.
- motohagiography 4y agoI'm not American, but optimism that isn't framed as something to directly invest in is neutralizing. Even reports out of Davos show that crowd is worried about real turbulence and unrest (largely of their own creation). Their endgame is just beginning. The specific dynamic of the last decade has been that as GenX has taken the reins of institutions, the one thing standing in the way of their weilding government as a blunt and absolute instrument of social reinvention is the democratic cohort of working class and rural voters who don't recognize the legitimacy of their elite self-identity and could vote to keep them out of power. Margins in popular elections are in single digit percentage points, and so to remedy this, they realized that if they couldn't persuade voters to keep them in power with their policies at the voting booth, they could use immigration to mass import voters who would depend on their promised policies, and whose relative poverty would make those votes much cheaper to be bought with small promises like cash benefits. The logic goes that if you have an objection to this and think being born in a country entitles you to membership in a nation state whose government is accountable to said nation, you are a racist and beneath contempt - so much so that if you are killed by your prescriptions (opioids) or as a consequence of emergency policy, nothing of value is lost. This was not merely right or left either, as the neocons of the 90s and 00s, led by the same cast of characters we have today were also an anti-national movement that sought to make nations subject to international governance. Then, it was via the WTO and use international institutions to subordinate "emerging market" countries by offering their leaders bribes for resource policy concessions. This isn't their first rodeo. America is not on the right track. It has been purposely derailed by someone who, unlike 20th century demagogues whose ambitions were limited by their nation state orientations, understood that power is inversely proportional to its visibility. Its institutions have been compromised by networks he has been building over 35 years via WEF. He has subordinated entire countries (CAN/AU/NZ) by infiltrating their universities and political parties, and installing their leaders. This isn't a conspiracy theory, it's a real time critical observation with precedents of how the men we learn about, from Napoleon to Mao, as single political minds, shift history in the course their own lifetimes. The author of this piece is providing bromides to neutralize the uncomfortable sense of dissonance about the absurdities of official narrative, which are unavoidable without actively suppressing criticism of them. I have no doubt it's being passed around at Davos to as a talking points sheet.
- KryptoFashyHN 4y ago[flagged]
- popilewiz 4y ago[dead]
- 4b11b4 4y agoWhy is this article posted here? Serious question.
- UtopiaPunk 4y agoGetting unironic thisisfine.jpg energy from the article
- my_city 4y ago"If there is one lesson from the events of the past year, it is that open societies such as ours have an ability to adapt in a way that closed societies simply do not. Russia has turned violent and malevolent. China has grown more authoritarian and inept. Meanwhile, free democratic societies have united around the Ukrainians as they battle to preserve the liberal world order. " The free, liberal world order. A myth that doesn't exist but needs to be preserved as an ideological weapon. The "free, liberal" world is responsible for genocides, invasions, bombings of civilians, supporting far-right dictatorships and massacres around the world. Meanwhile, the "closed" world invests in Africa and Latin America as partners and not as a playground to invade and plunder. The "closed" world keeps their billionaires and mega-corporations in check instead of being governed by them. The "closed" world applies rent control and considers housing a human right not a market variable. The "closed" world develops vaccines and distribute them at no-cost to underdeveloped countries. The "free liberal" world order is a stomach-turning myth that needs to be put to sleep.
- drewda 4y ago> This is not rocket science: Evolution designed humans to pay special attention to threats. So, unsurprisingly [...] I know it's not the main point of this essay, but I am always turned off by this appeals to evolutionary psychology. They are "just so" stories: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Just-so_story https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Just-so_story
- mensetmanusman 4y agoInteresting thought, I had a similar response to the sentence, and this phrasing seems to be in vogue with all journalists. From a theology standpoint, evolution being a property of existence itself means one could read Evolution as ‘God’ and the two terms become interchangeable.
- RickJWagner 4y agoI truly believe America is a great place and it's long term prognosis is excellent. I also truly believe the Atlantic wants you think the same thing, as long as their preferred politicians are in office. When the other folks run things, the Atlantic screams that everything's horrible. The Atlantic is part of the problem.
- joshka 4y ago>Cowen’s point is that column B is more important than column A. Societies don’t decline when they are in the midst of disruption and mess; they decline when they lose energy. And creative energy is one thing America has in abundance. Decline is an interesting metric. Will America fail as a country? Probably not. Will America cause more suffering with the current trajectory than it would have if choices were made to better society rather than treating humanity as a zero-sum game? Certainly! It's easy to find evidence of that whichever side of politics you come from. > Productivity levels and living standards have increased so dramatically that it takes people less time to earn the money to buy the things they need. During the Middle Ages, an English laborer had to work 80 hours to pay for a pound of sugar. By 2021, an English laborer had to work only 1.89 minutes to do that. In 1800, it took 5.4 hours of work to buy 1,000 lumen-hours; in 1992, it took only 0.00012 hours of work for someone to light their home for six weeks. > From 1980 to 2018, the average amount of time a person had to work to afford the basket of commodities—energy, food, raw materials—that make up a typical middle-class lifestyle fell by 72 percent, according to the book Superabundance, by Marian L. Tupy and Gale L. Pooley. That, too, frees up a lot of time and resources that can be spent on other things. Healthcare spending from 1970 to 2020 has increased by 10x (394 billion to 4124 billion in 2020 dollars). Salaries have not increased by quite so much :D