9 ms·
Curtailment, like negative prices, seems like something that it is hard for people to have constructive conversations about. Probably the cheapest and best opt
by ZeroGravitas 4y ago
Curtailment, like negative prices, seems like something that it is hard for people to have constructive conversations about.
Probably the cheapest and best option is to build more wind and not care too much if it increases curtailment.
Yes, all the things mentioned should be looked into and done when it makes financial sense but "wasting wind" is much less a thing to worry about than "burning gas", and I'd rather waste wind than waste money.
- benj111 4y agoBut that presupposes we can actually supply enough electricity to where it's needed. We already hitting the limits, thus the curtailment and burning gas. Adding more capacity unless it's in the right place doesn't solve the issue.
- ZeroGravitas 4y agoThe example given was christmas day, when most industry stops, when the wind was blowing strongly. (UK heat is mostly gas, not electric). It's probably more typical for all available wind to be used and then gas burned on top of that. Building more wind, even in curtailed areas will probably help those cases, even if it leads to more curtailment on other days. It would be nice if their neat interactive graphs also clearly marked the "we burnt gas because we didn't have enough wind turbines" so we can balance the two costs correctly. Right now it's like a medical test that only reports false negatives and ignores false positives (or vice versa). Trying to reduce one to zero without reference to the opposing problem is probably making the other one worse.
- ta545 4y agoAt some point there will be more bang for buck to increase the north/south capacity. The price they're talking seems to be very low compared with other infrastructure. Sure it takes 6 years to build two 2GW links, so build 4 or 6 in parallel. What amazes me is the footnote that the total spending on net zero is just £50 billion. Lets assume it's more realistically £100b. That's less than the cost of HS2. It's less than the cost of decommissioning the existing civil nuclear plants when they reach their end of life. Its the cost of 12GW of nuclear power generation. It's 14 months energy subsidies.
- SamBam 4y agoI'm not sure I understand. Sure, letting turbines spin and not use the power, while burning extra gas, isn't worse for the environment than just burning gas in the first place (though it's significantly more expensive to triple-pay for the energy), but it's better is to turn that unused power into used power. The article wasn't decrying the existence of excess wind power, it was trying to describe the best solutions for using that power.
- ZeroGravitas 4y agoThe article says we pay three times, curtail wind and then burn gas. Which is bad. But all the solutions are aimed at reducing the curtailment of wind. Rather than reducing the gas burnt. If the money saved by building more wind (or solar) and not having to burn gas saves more money then who cares if more wind is "wasted"? It would be nice to use every last drop, but I dont want to actually spend money to achieve that goal when it could be used to e.g. build yet more wind, and burn even less gas.
- hedora 4y agoThe article is saying that more transmission lines were needed to avoid wasting 9b pounds of electricity last year. An already approved grid upgrade will cost 4b pounds, and would mostly be adequate. Something had to get built first, and I guess they picked the wind turbines. This seems like everything working as intended to me.
- stdbrouw 4y agoAgain, that's not what the article is about. If more wind power gets built in Scotland to serve needs in England, then increasingly more of that output will have to be curtailed because we simply can't move the energy to where it needs to be, to the point where the only thing adding more wind farms would do is to provide a tad bit more energy when there's hardly any wind to distribute. In all other scenarios, having more capacity will not translate into not burning gas! The article describes an entirely different problem than "oh no, it's very windy/sunny and we don't know how to use all of this energy" which is not solved with better distribution, but with storage and demand regulation. And actually, the article is in complete agreement with you that we needn't be overly worried: curtailment isn't the end of the world, but we can solve it and it turns out that some of those solutions are cheaper than just building more farms, or would incentivize building those farms closer to where the energy is needed.
- mattcoles 4y agoI understand that curtailment is needed to incentivise private businesses to invest in wind when the output and demand can’t be correlated, but if the government owned the wind farms then it wouldn’t matter if we wasted right? We could just always be overproducing and wouldn’t have to pay for it.
- jthirkle 4y agoThe UK government? Owning things? Surely you can't be serious...
- anotheraccount9 4y ago"wind power"...
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- alkjsdlkjasd 4y agoThey seem to be re-nationalising the railways: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_British_Railways https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_British_Railways Maybe not: "The Transport Secretary announced on 19 October 2022 that the Transport Bill which would have set up GBR would not go ahead in the current parliamentary session."
- Beltalowda 4y agoIt just got delayed AFAIK.
- blibble 4y agosince covid it has been essentially nationalised: the government took on the risk and any pnl the franchising sysem won't be coming back
- smcl 4y agoI'm sure TransPennine Express and Avanti West Coast passengers would love that but it's not quite true (yet?)
- jonatron 4y agoI like negative prices, I got paid to heat my hot water tank and have underfloor heating on last night for 1.5 hours.
- InCityDreams 4y agoPaid for 1.5 hours underfloor, or just on for 1.5? *also where you are would be interesting. There's a big difference say between Scotland and Croatia.
- jonatron 4y agoI'm in London, electric prices last night: https://nitter.nl/pic/orig/media%2FFmNAukVXgAEF6Ar.jpg https://nitter.nl/pic/orig/media%2FFmNAukVXgAEF6Ar.jpg
- KaiserPro 4y agowhich supplier are you with?
- jonatron 4y agoOctopus energy, on the agile octopus tariff: https://octopus.energy/agile/ https://octopus.energy/agile/
- archydeb 4y agoFor the brave! But seriously (author of article here) I think that agile tariffs and more demand flexibility are probably a big part of the solution
- KaiserPro 4y agoI have the luxury of a 13khw battery, so it might make sense. But I suspect that when I need to use the grid will be uber peak £1.04 per kwhr. Edit: for those who are curious, here is some data on prices over the last month: https://agileprices.co.uk/ https://agileprices.co.uk/
- redleader55 4y agoBalancing a nationwide power grid is very complex. Some energy sources can be started and stopped instantly, but are limited - water. Others are plentiful, but unpredictable - wind. Others are predictable, but take a long time to start and stop - gas, coal(several hours), nuclear(1 day to start, fast to stop, but very expensive). A balanced grid will need all of them, will need them in quantities which can cover faults in the big producers(a nuclear reactor makes 700-800 MW). They will need them built in the right place, because while more power cables can be built, you can't transfer a lot of power on very long distances, for cost and grid stability reasons.
- jamil7 4y agoI always thought gas was quite quick to start which made it a good complement to renewables.
- sbradford26 4y agoIt depends on the type of natural gas plant. Some of them are designed for efficiency which takes longer to spin up and down while some are peaker plants which can spin up in a matter of seconds/minutes.
- fundatus 4y agoYep, 15 minutes to full load is not uncommon with gas plants.
- tomatocracy 4y agoThe quickest gas generation (gas engines) can go from cold start to fully ramped up in 4-5 minutes. A typical OCGT/CCGT is a bit slower and has a higher start cost (and a CCGT won't reach peak efficiency for hours). Pumped storage hydro takes 20 seconds or so. However, turning generation on or off isn't the only way the grid is balanced in the short term - turning up/down tends to be a big part of it too and most conventional generation can do that faster (sometimes a lot faster) than startup/shutdown.
- tialaramex 4y ago> but take a long time to start and stop - gas Despite the insistence that Closed Cycle Gas Turbines can't react quickly, because they're by far the largest component that we could start and stop the UK does in fact very quickly increase and decrease output from the CCGTs. For example this morning 2.79GW at 0600 to 3.89 at 0700. There are much faster options, batteries, import, even the pumped storage is seconds instead of minutes - if available, but CCGT is just not that slow to change compared to the weather. In that same period the wind power went from 10.9GW to 11.4GW. 500MW is a lot of power but it's not more than 1.1GW
- debacle 4y agoI've worked in curtailment. It's a fraught shell game. I think it's a great idea, but the system needs better controls. Many companies sign up for curtailment for e.g. heat related reasons who have heat based energy needs. When they get the call, they eat the fine and still benefit because the fine is less than the benefit for enrolling in the program.
- mr_pinnen 4y agoWhat is the benefit for enrolling in the program? Is it just money? Sounds like a very bad system indeed if the fines are lower than the payout.
- debacle 4y agoYou get paid an up front amount for enrolling, and then you get paid a per-event amount for complying, as well as different amounts for e.g. testing, having smart monitoring, etc.
- cm2187 4y agoThe problem is that there was no wind in the coldest days of December when we needed electricity the most. Building more of something that goes to zero when you need it doesn't help. With huge storage capacity, maybe, but even the author of the article doesn't seem to think storage is particularly practical.
- esteth 4y agoI don't think the suggestion is to replace gas generation facilities with wind, but to concentrate new power generation on wind. The incremental cost of keeping a gas generator working is very close to zero compared to all the other expenses involved in building the plant and buying gas to burn in it. We can keep all our gas infrastructure around and simply use it less often if we have more wind.
- mikaeluman 4y agoStill does not help when the wind simply is not blowing. You can't have an energy system dominated by intermittent sources.
- ErikVandeWater 4y ago> I'd rather waste wind than waste money. How is paying wind farms hundreds of millions of pounds to turn off wind generation not wasting money?
- mjw1007 4y agoIn a sense: because all it does is move money from one place to another. That's very different to wasting money in a way that actually uses up physical resources or people's time.
- ZeroGravitas 4y agoBecause, overall the wind power is the cheapest energy source available, and has been for a decade (recently overtaken by solar in some markets). Something that is cheap can have some percent wasted and still be cheaper overall than more expensive options. Focussing only on the waste without that bigger context is at best a false economy, at worst fossil fuel promoting propaganda.
- avianlyric 4y agoWhat good is cheap if you can’t use it? Why would I want to pay for cheap wind energy I can’t use, and also pay for gas energy that I can use? Unless the cost of the wind is £0, paying for wind in addition to gas is just a waste of money.
- Dylan16807 4y agoThe wind is 94% used. Which reduces the gas use. What do you mean "can't use"?
- briffle 4y agoyou should see how much per MW/h it costs for power from a "Peaker" power plant. Looks like $150-$198/MWh https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peaking_power_plant https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peaking_power_plant
- mytailorisrich 4y agoThe solution is to upgrade the national grid. This is needed anyway because it is already maxed out and demand will dramatically increase with the transition to EVs.
- scrlk 4y agoTell that to Ofgem. The latest price settlement for electricity transmission and distribution networks (RIIO-T2 and RIIO-ED2) has cut the amount of investment the networks are allowed to carry out.
- mytailorisrich 4y agoI bought a petrol generator even before Covid.
- dahfizz 4y ago> I'd rather waste wind than waste money. But doesn't wasting wind waste money if we have to pay so much for curtailment?
- ajsnigrutin 4y agoYou have two problems: 1) a lot of wind means there's too much power... that has to be used somewhere, that's why you have negative prices, to get someone to take that power off the grid and use it for something, sometimes useless, and someone has to pay for that 2) no wind means you still need gas, hydro, nuclear etc. powerplants, because you need power even when there is no wind and sun, so you need all the power generating capacity covered even without wind
- louloulou 4y agothey should just mine bitcoin with it
- aembleton 4y agoI'm sure people do.
- jopsen 4y agoI know it's a joke, but the if you buy equipment to mine bitcoins, you don't let it sit idle waiting for those few times a year that electricity prices are low. You computer will be obsolete before you've made a return on investment. The same problem applies to H2, etc, if the process is rarely used and the setup to do the process is expensive, then it's cheaper not to. A plant that can produce H2 from electricity might be more expensive than the value of the power discarded.
- avianlyric 4y agoFrom the article > the National Grid pays the windfarms to turn off, and pays a (typically gas powered) alternative generator, closer to the demand, to turn on. Curtailing wind means paying someone else to generate that energy in the “right” location, which usually means burning gas. So all the extra wind being built isn’t reducing amount of gas being burned, it’s just increasing the total cost of electricity. > Probably the cheapest and best option is to build more wind and not care too much if it increases curtailment. We can build all the wind we want, but if connected to consumers by nothing more than a long extension lead that barely run a kettle, then it’s totally useless. The wind needs to be located so the energy generated can actually be transported to end users. Curtailment is basically a direct measure of the amount of wind we’ve built, that can’t actually be used. Building more isn’t helpful in the slightest. The article certainly doesn’t advocate for reducing the amount of wind built, quite the opposite, they just point out we need it built in the right places so we can actually use the energy produced. Rather than built bunch of wind turbines that will forever be pointed out of the wind.