12 ms·
Falling birth rate not due to less desire to have children
- sul_tasto 4y agoI’m sure the cost of daycare and the cost of college are huge factors on a couple’s decision. School schedules are also not built around dual working parent households. A lot more could be done to support parents.
- mhuffman 4y agoThe cost of daycare, in particular, is outrageous! And it has been that way for a while! I remember my ex wanted to get a job after our first child. We did the math and I would have had to pay and extra $200 a month for her to get a job!
- ovulator 4y agoA decade ago I paid $10,000 a year for one kid, and I was super lucky to even find anyone at all. That was the price for just some lady running a daycare out of her basement in the country. I don't want to know what it is now, in a city.
- 1auralynn 4y agoThat extra amount likely would have been more than cancelled out after your kid went to school, due to higher future wages (raises over time, plus your ex not having a huge gap in her work history).
- anon291 4y agoHow can daycare be anything but expensive? You are paying one subset of (mostly) women to take care of the children of another, while state laws mandate that the number of kids each daycare lady can watch is about the same as the number of kids she would have. There cannot possibly be enough women who are not mothers available to be daycare providers unless (1) lots of women are not becoming mothers, which contributes to low birth rates, (2) some subset of women have alternate arrangements for their own child's care (currently what's likely going on), or (3) daycare remains permanently expensive because there's simply more demand than supply. Thus, the total number of females willing to be daycare providers is going to be less than the total number of women with children. Thus, demand will always outstrip supply. Thus, the cost of daycare will rise to be the median wage of the highest-income cohort for which the supply meets demand. For example, if there are ten working women and two are day care carers who can look after four babies each, including their own, then they can look after six non-related babies all together. Assuming each woman has one baby, then of the eight non-carers, only six will have their babies cared for. The other two have to make alternate arrangements. Due to how the market works, the two who have to make other arrangements are going to be the lowest income. The cost of daycare will rise to be the median wage of the six working women, because the substitute for daycare (the women staying home) costs the same. Thus, perpetually, for the bottom twenty percent in this example, daycare will forever be out of reach. There is no getting around this. Note, I'm not saying anything about whether women should work or stay at home. I'm just pointing out that the whole system boils down to a Ponzi scheme of care, and withdrawals are constantly being demanded.
- jltsiren 4y agoAs some countries provide near-universal daycare, the numbers can be made to make sense. In Finland, the requirement is 1 carer for 4 children under 3, 1/7 for full-time care above 3, and 1/13 for part-time care above 3. Assuming 1 year of parental leave, 2 years at 1/4, 3 years at 1/7, and 1 year at 1/13, the average child requires 1 person-year of daycare. Assuming 40-year careers, an optimistic fertility rate 2.1, only women working in daycare, and some overhead, we would need 6-7% of women working in daycare.
- anon291 4y agoFinland has a fertility rate of 1.4 children / woman. That's a below-replacement rate, and thus I don't think Finland can be used as an example of a sustainable daycare system
- jltsiren 4y agoThe point was that even with a sustainable fertility rate of 2.1, the daycare system would only need to employ a few percent of the total workforce.
- ARandomerDude 4y agoOne of the fundamental problems is the mythology that paying the bloated tuition of some college is the most important duty of a parent. People are literally afraid to have children out of the fear that they won't be able to purchase multiple college educations 20 years from now. As a society, we need to recognize that college can be helpful in certain career fields but it is generally a huge waste of money compared to the actual education and ROI.
- bilsbie 4y agoWhat are some non-trade successful career paths without college?
- vidarh 4y agoIt may be huge factors in the decisions of individuals, but on a population basis if this was a major factor you'd expect to see a big difference between countries based on daycare costs and the like. Yet e.g. Norway's fertility rate has been under replacement, and currently around 1.7, despite measures like long fully paid parental leave, near full daycare coverage and low caps on daycare costs (at a fraction of e.g. what I paid for my son in the UK) as well as a monthly support payment per child (ca $105/month for kids over 6 and ~$168/month for kids under 6) until they turn 18, coupled with no college tuition (you pay living costs if not living with parents, and pay for books etc.) and stipends for students. Looking at graphs of fertility rates in Norway, they cratered when Norway started getting wealthy, and none of the subsequent expansions of welfare and support for parents appears to have been able to counter it.
- anon291 4y agoPeople, whether american or norwegian, claim to want things they do not want. For example, I 'want' a farm. When I think about owning a farm, I'm filled with happy thoughts of a pastoral life surrounded by nature, animals, etc. When people ask, I tell them 'yes, I would love to own a farm'. Of course, a few months ago, I had an opportunity to purchase one, and you know what I thought? Well, when I thought about the details... owning animals, caring for animals day in and day out, leaving my current home in the city, etc, I realized what I said I want and what I actually want are completely different things. Similarly, it's quite useless to ask people what they want. Most people have no idea. In particular, children are considered the default and there's plenty of marketing to show happy pictures of families with kids that make people biased to say they 'want' this, but for many, it's similar to my own idealistic view of what that desire actually entails. Many chicken out when it comes down to it. There's no way to measure this by self reports. If our ancestors were more desirous of children in reality than us or not, this study's methodology is unable to bear this out. Both generations may have said / may say they 'want' children, but there's many meanings of 'want.'
- vidarh 4y agoSure. Slightly restated, they may well "want" those things, but not want it badly enough to make the required changes to their life.
- spaceman_2020 4y agoA good daycare in my area costs half my rent. Bonkers!
- bell-cot 4y agotl;dr - "it's the economy, stupid"
- spacemadness 4y agoYes, it’s always been the simplest answer and breathtakingly obvious but older generations of policymakers continue to act incredulous regarding root cause.
- mensetmanusman 4y agoI wonder what number or set of numbers could describe this? The world has never been wealthier than it is at the moment, so clearly, there is a different metric to make this connection.
- tarboreus 4y agoKids used to be a backloaded financial asset, essentially low cost labor. Now they're a major financial liability. If you are middle class and have four kids, you're probably not really middle class anymore. Also, the stuff related to making kids expensive (school, housing, medical care) is working out of a completely different economy than the cheap TV economy that makes us the richest of all time. Medical care is far more an expensive by proportion of household income than it was in, say, 1955, as is school and housing. Add to that the breakdown in social structures that means you won't get family to take care of your kids and it just doesn't look that hot to have a kid these days, even if you want one.
- vidarh 4y agoIt's pretty clear that specific crises can have a short term impact in driving fertility rates down, but long term all the evidence also is very clear that increased wealth correlates pretty strongly with reduced fertility rates. That contradicts those who thinks dropping fertility rates is due to worsening economic strain, but it does not invalidate the claim in the article, though, which is not that falling rates are due to economic strain, beyond specific crises like the 2008 recession, but due to people feeling more worried. Part of that may well be that peoples expectations rise, both for what they want to be able to afford for themselves and what they'd expect to spend on a child. E.g. I've easily spent more money on my 13yo son so far than the total my parents spent - inflation adjusted - on me and my brother combined until we were 18.
- f154hfds 4y agoAfter having kids when young and spending my twenties as a parent watching my peers and siblings have so much freedom it's kind of obvious that the desire to have kids is a community/cultural phenomenon. When your friends start having kids you will start getting ready to have kids yourself even if the connection between your friends' situation and yours never enters your conscious mind. We're communal beings fundamentally. Couple this with the trend to get married and have kids later in life when you have less biological time it kind of seems obvious why the birthrate is low. What this means (and I've seen this in many people) - the number of kids they want is always >> than the number of kids they end up having by the time their time runs out in their 40's. Conclusion? Life. is. short. It's ok to wait somewhat but every year you postpone the plunge is a year you don't have on the other side.
- xenadu02 4y agoBut often the first couple to have kids delays doing so for reasons that come down to money or proxies for money. For example the career impact may be greater or childcare may be proportionally more of your income.
- hammock 4y agoWouldn’t the third or fourth kid have a proportionally smaller impact on your career or money? For example you have hand me downs, economies of scale in childcare, economies of scale in housing, etc
- cbhl 4y agoThird child has non-linear characteristics: most parents will need to buy a larger car to accommodate a third car seat. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32552994 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32552994 https://thezvi.substack.com/p/on-car-seats-as-contraception https://thezvi.substack.com/p/on-car-seats-as-contraception
- rayiner 4y agoIt's very much cultural. I got married and had a kid in my 20s because that's when my Bangladeshi mom said it was time. Like you we sat around for years while our friends remained single and childless, and it was alienating. If I hadn't had the strong influence from a non-American culture it might have turned out differently.
- torartc 4y agoIt feels pretty obvious that everyone is crunched financially by the ruling class.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- PathOfEclipse 4y agoWhat's even more amazing is that people keep voting for the ruling class that then continually turns around and takes more money and power from the people. People seem to do it because they think they are voting to have the money distributed more "equitably", and perhaps even redistributed into their own pockets, but the reality is that everyone is now poorer and worse off, and there is certainly no more justice in the world than there was before, arguably much less, in fact. I don't see a way out because it requires people to be wiser and morally better, and there's no quick solution to that.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- hammock 4y agoWe avoided the red wave in November so I would expect the birth rates to start reversing
- scottLobster 4y agoYou expect something as population-spanning as birth rates to hinge on the outcome of a single congressional midterm election? If anything they're going to decline further, Republicans are back to their "obstruct literally everything" agenda that they always have when they're the minority. Any potential pro-natalist government policies will almost certainly require government spending, which will now die in the house. So we're stick with the status quo, which is low birth rates.
- PathOfEclipse 4y ago
- llampx 4y agoI have had 1 kid and am having serious cold feet about having another even though I initially wanted to. Not only the sleepless nights, but thinking of all the vacations and iPhones I would have to buy, where almost every cost would be 2x just by default. Then comes the crowning glory or coup de grace, paying the college education. Cheaper by the dozen? Not by half!
- ishjoh 4y agoI have 3 and I remember the process you're going through. > thinking of all the vacations and iPhones I would have to buy You don't have to buy this stuff. I grew up lower middle class, the only vacation we took until I was 15 was driving 8h to stay with my grandma. I never had a gameboy or lots of other things. My childhood was still great. Looking back maybe I could have had those things if my brother didn't exist, but I'm much happier that my brother exists because 10/10 I had way more fun with him than having a gameboy or exotic vacations, even though we didn't always get along. College education is expensive, but it's possible to not spend a fortune using community college and transferring. Hopefully there will be even more low cost options in the future. If you can have a roof over their head, feed them, have a stable home life and bring a positive attitude to every day then the rest doesn't matter.
- llampx 4y agoThanks for the chat. I have seen enough families where the siblings don't get along, although I do get along with mine and have many fond memories together. I have to balance the potential for good memories as a bigger family with wanting to have the best for the kid(s) we do have.
- psychphysic 4y agoI think this kinds of research is just pants. When you ask people these kind of vague aspiration goals. The answers don't change. Same reason everyone rates Schindler's list 5/5 on Netflix and never watches it. (Paraquoting Reed Hastings). The biggest factor imo is that these days people have better things to do than have kids. Mostly work at jobs they hate. Similarly everyone prefers to watch an Adam Sandler movie they say they hate and not Schindler's list.
- Am4TIfIsER0ppos 4y agoI don't particularly like Adam Sandler but I might laugh more than once at the same "joke" however I don't recall laughing at anything in Schindler's List.
- brianmckenzie 4y agoSchindler's List is a fantastic film, but it's also the kind of film most people only want to watch once. That might explain it.
- deafpiano 4y ago> The data in the study can’t explain why, but the results fit evidence indicating that young people today don’t think now is a good time for them to have children. > "For those who are concerned about America’s dropping birth rates, this study suggests that there is no need to pressure young people into wanting more kids, Hayford said." This article (and most quoting "low birth rate") are incredibly out of touch. How can you be shocked that in a world where a shooting might not make the news, our politicians don't hide their corruption, and you know, the climate crisis that we've seen coming and still choose to do nothing. No I can't think of a single reason why "young people don't feel like it's the right time".
- goalieca 4y ago> This article (and most quoting "low birth rate") are incredibly out of touch. How can you be shocked that in a world where a shooting might not make the news, our politicians don't hide their corruption, and you know, the climate crisis that we've seen coming and still choose to do nothing. And yet, the world has never been safer in a long time and the statistics show it. The ever rising cost of living and challenges to careers for caregivers are a real concern though.
- Super_Jambo 4y agoPast performance may not be indicative of future results. Especially when you're predicting 80 odd years into the future.
- toyg 4y agoWorld =/= US, which is what the article is about.
- dahart 4y ago> I can’t think of a single reason This is depressing, because there is good news out there! I’m sure you’re not alone, that you’re reflecting what the article is talking about. But I feel like this might say more about how we are sharing news and framing the world than about whether this is a good time to raise kids or not. Shootings in the Wild West were a dime a dozen. Politicians have always been shitty. In the mean time, amazing things are going on everywhere in the world. Being unable to think of a single one is a bit frustrating.
- anonporridge 4y agoI believe Peter Zeihan said something to the effect of... Kids on a farm were free labor. You had as many of them as you could. They improved your quality of life. Kids in a city condo are a destructive house pet that drains your time and money for at least 18 years usually with zero financial payoff. People aren't dumb, so they had fewer of them.
- hammock 4y agoYes, Zeihan’s point is that increasing urbanization- 50%+ worldwide now- has decreased the utility of children (if we can use that term) and increased their costs
- anonporridge 4y agoChildren are a luxury item, like a Gucci handbag, or a non working pet. A liability, not an asset. You only have them if you have money to burn and either intrinsically value the luxury or want to signal your social status to your peers.
- disambiguation 4y ago> You only have them if you have money to burn this is quite cynical and disingenuous, given birth rates are highest among low income demographics.
- hammock 4y agoIt's a bathtub shaped curve. Even in low-birth-rate countries, birth rates have not depressed among the rich.
- spaceman_2020 4y agoDoesn't explain why birth rates are falling in countries with largely rural populations as well. India's fertility rate is now below replacement level. 65% of the country's population still lives in rural areas.
- __MatrixMan__ 4y agoHaving kids sounds like a lot of fun, but if you look at a graph of population over time we sorta look like a species that's in for a rude awakening about the limits of our ecosystem. Introducing more people at this time just doesn't seem like the humane thing to do. Maybe next time.
- fasteddie31003 4y agoI think birthrates are one of the most important statistics to keep an eye on regarding the future success of a country. There are a number of reasons for the falling birthrate. IMO one of the most overlooked reasons is endocrine disrupting chemicals in our environment. I hope future historians don't regard BPA and phthalates in the same light as how the romans used lead to sweeten wine.
- polski-g 4y agoThat's probably true. They stimulate the effects of estrogen which makes the men less likely to follow their evolutionary imperative: to breed as much as possible.
- nine_zeros 4y agoAs a millennial with a spouse and with similar discussions everyday, let me clearly express my problems. * I had to work extremely hard to get to the current income level. It took 16 years of schooling with good grades, outside school activities and recommendations , all just to get into a top state school for college. A failure in any step in those 16 years could have derailed my path. * After gaining that admission, I had to take an exorbitant debt for the privilege of studying in that university. A failure/low grades/lack of internships at any time could have derailed my path. In fact, a lot of my peers suffered because we graduated around 2008 recession. * I had to relocate to a new city after graduation for a new job. The relocation could have been an expensive mistake for someone graduating with an enormous debt - see rescinded offers. * I had to work hard at my job to avoid PIPs and unreasonable management. Any one performance review was enough to derail my life. I absolutely needed the job until I paid off my student loans. * A few years in, I got laid off because the department was shut down. Which means that I needed to find a new job asap to continue my healthcare and student loan repayments. I got a new job but the experience of a sudden layoff severely affected my understanding of what it means to be a worker. * More years later, I realized that promotions are impossible. The system is set up to suck your labor for limited rewards. So start looking for a new job. This was also the time when leetcode started booming. So, all my education was kind of worthless because I needed leetcode university education to get a new job that paid me enough. And I prepared for months/years. I failed over 20 times to get the next job. * At the next job, I had to start from scratch again because the tools of the trade keep changing. Tools in 2022 are enormously different from 2012. Keeping up with tools, systems, bugs, performance reviews just to keep the job. * Dating was hard and I struggled to find a compatible partner for so many years because I was so focused at work for such a long time. I genuinely did not have enough time/experience to grow mature relationships with the opposite sex. But luckily I stumbled upon someone who was very compatible with me and my lifestyle. Only problem, she was in a different state. * Repeat the job searching process, leetcode and interview process, tools learning process and performance review process in a new state. * Finally, my partner and I felt stable until the pandemic hit and we got cut off from our families and friends. We struggled with healthcare and fertility issues. It was clear that pregnancy was going to be difficult. * Then comes inflation raising the prices of everything. * Then comes recession causing layoffs, meaning we lose the healthcare system needed to treat our fertility issues. * Now we are sitting precariously wondering when one of us will lose our jobs and hoping we can continue to get ahead. But here's the thing - at any point in our lives, things could have been derailed easily. Systems in America are too precarious. We had it good so far. We don't have any more student debt. We have good healthcare so far. We have financial stability. We have everything a person could reasonably hope for. Not everyone has this kind of luck. Not everyone works in tech to reap the high salaries. Not everyone goes through life without medical issues. Not everyone has good health insurance. How are you expecting them to think about bringing children and raising them for years? If lucky millennials struggle, how would unlucky ones even do it? Nobody is happily looking forward to having children. Life is far too uncertain, far to flakey. Systems break far too much for people to safely start a family.
- bsenftner 4y agoI'm gen-x, and chose not to have children simply because our entire culture is a giant lie, capitalism is slavery with extra steps, Governments are simply the mafia that won each entire nation, corporations are legally projected slave operations, and the vast majority of people are constructed lemmings marching off a cliff designed for them to march off. And public discourse is the rants of immature babies. Sure, bring more young innocents into this farce.
- rafaelero 4y agoI can't help but think that economics is not the most important bit; at least not the money part. Urban life is simply much more entertaining nowadays. So many things to do, so many places to go... Of course people would be postponing being attached for years with the huge responsibility of taking care of a child.
- fxtentacle 4y agoEveryone I know who could financially afford to have kids, did decide to have kids. And those that were struggling financially delayed their kids. I can't believe the simple reality of how bad the job market can be for regular young people has not yet reached politicians and they actually needed a study to tell them? Just try to buy a family home with an average salary ... and you know why people don't create the situation that requires a family home.
- lordnacho 4y agoIt's all money. Houses weren't allowed to collapse when they were overinflated, and here we are with the highest house-to-income ratio in ages and ages. If you can't have a house, you can't have kids. Then there's daycare and college savings. Also at the highest ever. Post agrarian kids already can't make any money for years and years, so we make fewer of them. But maybe the biggest problems is the precariousness of it. When you have kids, you need to not lose your job. Even more so when stuff costs loads. Want more kids? Subsidize kids. The US has the world's biggest and baddest military. If you want lots of kids pay for that as well.
- JustSomeNobody 4y agoThe US spends 3X as much as the next highest spending nation (China) on military. 3 TIMES as much. We have got to get that under control.
- scottLobster 4y agoNo we don't. Especially given China is a potential military adversary, and they're on the opposite side of a giant ocean from us. Also the US military budget is not standing in the way of increased domestic spending. We just need to treat other areas of government with the same reverence as the military, and we partially do (look how badly every attempt to cut Social Security fails).
- thatfrenchguy 4y ago> If you can't have a house, you can't have kids. I mean, yes, you can have kids without a house in a condo/apartment, people do it every day in cities around the world and the US. The American obsession with single family detached housing where you think you need a big house that you use 20% of and a yard that your kids spend almost no time in is what got us in this mess in the first place.
- lordnacho 4y agoIt's not just an American thing. Just about everyone who doesn't have kids needs a bigger place when they have kids, whether that's a bigger apartment, palace or mud hut.
- spaceman_2020 4y agoCurrently watching my wife throw up for the 6th time this week with morning sickness (except hers happens after 6pm). She is in academia and has enough flexibility that she's been able to arrange her classes in the morning when she feels better. I work from home in my own company so I can eke out free time. But man, there is no way we would have been able to make this work if we had traditional jobs. Pregnancy is hard, and it's much, much harder for some people. My wife has been constantly nauseaous for a month now. The medication that does help somewhat - Zofran - has some iffy results and most doctors are afraid to prescribe it. I don't regret it, but I absolutely do not have the will or the time or the money to have another.
- Eleison23 4y ago[dead]
- Someone1234 4y agoCollege for my kids is projected to be $110K each in today's money ($240K each at the time). A home for a family of four costs $550K+. Plus me AND my wife had to pay off OUR college loans for years to even get to $0 of wealth. Each kid's birth was $10K and more for all the appointments before/after that. Food is incredibly expensive, vehicles have gone through the stratosphere, and wage increases haven't kept up with inflation let alone gone up in real terms. We're also told we're meant to save for retirement and my question is: With what leftover money? I'm in the top 20% of income earners, and we're barely getting by. You want to know why people aren't having kids? That's a start of why. But we have a record number of billionaires and millionaires, so I guess that makes up for it...
- rayiner 4y agoI find this reasoning incredibly hard to believe. My moderate income neighborhood with lots of people who don’t have college degrees has tons of kids. By contrast many of the people I know who have very high incomes don’t have kids. I think the truth is that being a dual income no kids professional couple is a pretty fun life and lots of people don’t want to sacrifice that by raising kids.
- rafaelero 4y agoI agree. GDP per capita is inversely correlated with fertility rate, so it looks like the richer people are the less likely they are to have children.
- scottLobster 4y agoAs a single income family, he's more right than wrong. My wife and I have one infant, and want another. I make around 117k/year pre-tax. Rent for a 3 bedroom townhome is 2500/month, that's roughly half my monthly take-home pay. Everything else comes out of the other half. I contribute enough to my 401k to get my employer match, but no more. I'm putting $250/month into my daughter's 529 based on similar calculations for what a decent 4 year degree will cost (a little north of a 100k). I max out our HSA to make the high deductible health plan worth it. We don't eat out that much. I drive a 23 year old hand-me-down Toyota. Things still add up fast if we don't keep track. There's not much left over at the end of the month. And there's going to be another $250+/month when the other kid comes along. We're not living in poverty by any stretch, have no debt, and can afford some minor luxuries. But it's a lot tighter than it was for my dad working essentially the same job at the same age. I'm curious as to the levels of credit card debt in your moderate income neighborhood, and how prepared they're going to be for retirement at their current savings rates. Or perhaps they just don't expect to pay for their kids' college at all, and are just hoping they don't get sick. We've already sacrificed the vacations and expensive restaurants. Should we sacrifice our HSA and kids' college funds as well so we can have 3 instead of 2?
- gampleman 4y agoI think it's mostly cultural. a) The age when one starts gives a pretty hard limit on the maximum number of children one can achieve; this age has been going up in most places, sometimes significantly so. b) Female employment rate has also been going up and it also doesn't help. Mixing parenting with full time work outside of the house isn't easy and it's mostly women who tend to feel guilty about the tradeoffs involved. My hypothesis is that this guilt can tamper down the desire to accumulate more of it. c) Relatedly, it's also far more likely that relatives are also in full time employment and generally very busy, so the amount of practical help parents can get from family is likely less. While professional daycare can compensate for this, it is both expensive (in some countries at least) but also potentially less trustworthy, so parents feel more guilt relying on it. d) Having even 4 kids one feels like an outlier in our society (heck one even needs a different kind of car). It seems like large parts of society have adapted to a mostly childless lifestyle and fitting in with a larger family can be challenging. There are also plenty of misanthropes running around who have some sick idea that you ruining the world by daring to have so many offspring and are happy to let you know about it. I can't imagine what having 7 children must be like. This is strange, since even talking to older living people, having 4+ siblings seemed very common back then. So yes, while there are a number of unpleasant economic realities, I personally doubt that they are trump the socio-cultural factors.
- mensetmanusman 4y agoI have 7, it’s great. Is like having 3, but with an army of additional support (our 7 year old for fun likes to get up at 6:30 am and make buttermilk pancakes). It’s surprising how helpful kids are with a Montessori framework.
- cudgy 4y ago> heck one even needs a different kind of car Why? Most couples have 2 cars anyway. Drive separately with 2-3 kids in each car or get an older, cheaper bigger car. First world problems.
- gampleman 4y agoNot around here they don't. 1 small car is the norm for families around here (and for good reason, car ownership is rather expensive). Also needing two cars is impractical for a lot of activities. It means you need 2 parents for everywhere you want to take all your kids to. Also road trip (which is BTW a lot more economical way of traveling when you have a large-ish family) is much more complicated/expensive/exhausting if you need to drive 2 cars.
- thefz 4y agoWhile birthrates were rising, how many did not heave the desire but were forced into it?
- angmarsbane 4y agoWe all get a later start on establishing ourselves due to the 4 yr degree. Switching to a 3 yr degree system gives everyone one more year of post-college fertility, as would pushing less people into college. For my female peers, another hold up is a lack of suitable male partners. Men who aren’t financially supported by parents and who want kids.
- hackrnusr 4y agoI always thought the answer to this question depended on whether you asked a woman before she gets married if she wants to have children, or afterward.