9 ms·
How many AMD RX 7900 XTX's are defective?
- wzy 4y agoDoes this problem extend to the 7900 XT?
- snarfy 4y agoApparently not. "... The reference model for the step-down Radeon RX 7900 XT appear to be fine as well." [1] [1] - https://www.pcworld.com/article/1446335/amd-confirms-radeon-rx-7900-xtx-overheating-what-you-need-to-know.html https://www.pcworld.com/article/1446335/amd-confirms-radeon-...
- causality0 4y agoAMD originally stated that 110°C junction temps were normal, but seemed to back off that statement as more evidence Letting the marketing assholes control how you respond to a crisis is a great way to destroy your credibility forever.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- crote 4y agoI think part of the issue is that silicon is intentionally being run increasingly hotter over the last few years. The temperature sensors have gotten good enough that the hardware can auto-boost right up to the physical limits. The card will essentially "overclock" itself until it either 1) hits a temperature limit, or 2) hits a power draw limit. A high temperature is indeed normal, and customer support / marketing is aware of this. You have to look at the power drawn to reach that temperature to determine if there is a cooling issue, but such technical details are probably lost on most low-level CS folks.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- paulmd 4y agoyes, at 7nm and below you pretty much have to have runtime monitoring of the voltage/temperature microclimate across each core (CU or SMX) because it simply is not possible to validate that a given core will always be stable under a given operating regime. it is not possible to guarantee that the worst-case scenario of a very hot transistor (needs more power) that is in an area where voltage is drooping low and all the nearby transistors fire at once in a worst-case neighbor load will not result in switching times that are too slow and an incorrect output. the operating margin at 7nm and below is extremely slim and you just cannot get competitive clocks while guaranteeing that transistors will never be pushed out of their stability regime. And in computing, one in a million chance happens 1000 times a second. instead you actually design the chips to detect this and slow themselves down... that was the whole thing with "clock stretching" showing up on zen2. everyone has had to implement something similar, the chip watches itself and will either delay instructions or slow down clocks or something similar if the voltage/temperature is not going to allow the timing hotpath to converge inside the clock window. side effect is that now everyone is looking at "hotspots", but hotspots generally are significantly higher than the average, that's why you have to watch them. there is a much stronger "microclimate" where voltage can droop and temperatures can increase significantly between different regions of the chip. https://semiengineering.com/power-delivery-affecting-performance-at-7nm/ https://semiengineering.com/power-delivery-affecting-perform... also just very simply the density has been increasing faster than the power consumption has been decreasing (no more Dennard scaling) so overall the power (and thermal) density has been getting higher every time you shrink.
- dhruvdh 4y ago110-degree junction temperatures are indeed nothing to worry about, it's just the card shouldn't be throttling and reach these temperatures at these frequencies and power draw. When a new product is released, it is common for there to be a learning curve for support in terms of what is normal and what is not. They are not engineers. This is just an unfortunate coincidence - batches were tested in vertical orientation, which is normal for test benches, but most users use the card in horizontal orientation. Orientation affecting temperatures is unexpected and unintuitive, so this was missed. Cause is rumoured to be insufficient coolant in vapor chamber for affected batches. Please don't read too much into this low-effort rant. I don't blame the author, it's okay to be frustrated when a big purchase doesn't go their way, but if you have a large following you should be more mindful of your words.
- Sweepi 4y agoThe cause is no longer a Rumor, there has been an official statement by AMD: “It all comes down to a small batch of our vapor chamber acually have an issue - not enough water.”
- jjulius 4y ago>This is just an unfortunate coincidence - batches were tested in vertical orientation, which is normal for test benches, but most users use the card in horizontal orientation. Why would you choose to test your product in a manner that is completely opposite from how most people would use it? Granted, I'm asking from a place of ignorance, but that just seems... dumb. I'd be curious to learn why my perspective might be wrong.
- geerlingguy 4y agoPractically all the reviewers test these cards on test benches too, which masks the problem with the horizontal card orientation (thus nobody uncovered the issue in the initial reviews). Test benches are way more convenient than minitowers when you need to regularly swap components.
- dhruvdh 4y agoTest benches are used for convenience. A proper case is too much effort to work with. Vapor chambers also rarely show up on GPUs, until recently.
- pifm_guy 4y agoHeat pipes - the large copper tubes between hot chips and heatsinks - are actually hollow and usually filled with some liquid/gas mixture. That's often butane or something with a lowish boiling temperature at lowish pressures. They work by having the liquid boil at the hot end, the gas flow along the pipe, condense back to a liquid at the cold end, and then the liquid flow back. That last step, the liquid flowing back, is the critical one. With gravity, the liquid can gush back really fast, and loads of heat can be transferred. But if the card is the wrong way up, then it relies on the liquid wicking back along some clothlike material coating the inside of the pipe. That's a far slower process. Therefore the heat that can be dissipated this way is much lower. That's why heat pipe performance is dramatically affected by orientation. The designers of this card will have been aware of that, but likely decided a small performance hit for sustained workloads was probably worth it.
- onli 4y agoIt's not a small performance hit. The card is throttling a lot and ramping up the fans up to 1000RPM more than usual because cooling fails completely. There were report about cards failing while testing this (e.g. in the der8auer video), but ofc it's not possible to be sure that the card broke because of this. It's possible though. This is not an expected failure mode the engineers would have been okay with even if it did not kill cards. No one would be okay with the heatpipe drying up like this.
- formerly_proven 4y agoThe card der8auer had which failed was very clearly a VRM failure.
- onli 4y agoThat's not very re-assuring when the cooler is not working as expected. VRM gets killed by heat (I don't actually think it's likely that this is what happens here, but I do think AMD is making a mistake by letting customers run into this issue and by giving me reason to speculate like this).
- formerly_proven 4y agoAs per der8auer and GamersNexus, AMD claims to know which batches of cards have underfilled vapor chambers yet at the same time refuses to recall them and wants customers to RMA instead.
- twblalock 4y agoIs this really that unreasonable? From the point of view of a customer who has one of these cards, a recall or RMA is basically the same: they have to mail in their card to get fixed or replaced. Customers could also return them to the retailers they bought them from. The hyperventilating about this on tech YouTube is getting a bit ridiculous. The same thing happened with the controversy over the power connector on the 4090. Yes, it's bad -- but it's not like AMD ran over your dog. When a new product has bugs (and many do), it takes some time to figure out who is impacted and what the fix is -- and when an issue becomes high profile, a lot of people who are not impacted manage to convince themselves that they are. Given that, and the general hyperventilating about this, I am not surprised AMD wants to be careful.
- paulryanrogers 4y agoWhy ship them if one knows they're defective? Why even package them at all?
- wmf 4y agoAMD didn't realize these cards were defective until after they shipped.
- jimmydorry 4y agoThis is not at all the same kind of "controversy" as having a component fail catastrophically and catch fire. Comparing it to such is minimising how reckless and callous nvidia was.
- arcticbull 4y agoGamersNexus paid a bunch of money and had a failure analysis lab go over the Nvidia issue with a fine-tooth comb. I think their conclusion was that the connecters weren't fundamentally problematic - the melting issue overwhelmingly occurred when people didn't actually seat the connector properly. Further, it had to be off by a lot and the cable had to simultaneously be at a significant angle. [1] I don't disagree there could have been a better design, and I think the design is fundamentally a risk when misused. When seated properly there shouldn't be any risk. That said we should ask for better than that from hardware makers. This feels like a job for a warning sticker this generation and something a little different next generation. The Nvidia issue is not like the NZXT H1 riser fire issue, for instance. [1] https://www.reddit.com/r/nvidia/comments/yx0m1g/gamers_nexus_the_truth_about_nvidias_rtx_4090/ https://www.reddit.com/r/nvidia/comments/yx0m1g/gamers_nexus...
- pifm_guy 4y ago[flagged]
- sbierwagen 4y ago>just get a 90 degree pcie adapter And also buy a second PC case that actually has the slots for a 90 degree mount? Otherwise you'll need to take a hacksaw to the back of your computer.
- omegote 4y agoThe standard position for graphics card has been horizontal, for many, many years. I don't think the standard position for a cigarrete lighter is upside down, to begin with. Next, for your "solution" to work you need a special case that allows for the card to be installed vertically, which is not common.
- mardifoufs 4y agoIt severely impacts performance. Also, once the junction reaches 110°, the fans also start spinning at max speed with no hope of actually cooling down the card enough. So yes, if you don't mind the noise from 100% fans always being on, your card being constantly unable to cool itself, and a 20-30% hit on performance on your 1200$ card... sure I guess?
- hot_gril 4y ago> Just get a 90 degree pcie adapter That's not trivial. How about I just buy a different card?
- shmerl 4y agoBetter to use custom models anyway.
- seanw444 4y agoAs much as I like AMD, this is unfortunately true. I never get reference models. The 5700 XT's cooling system was terrible.
- shmerl 4y agoI usually use Sapphire Pulse ones.
- seanw444 4y agoThose seem to be pretty good. So far XFX has done well for me, so I'm hoping that streak remains.
- DiabloD3 4y agoPulse and Red Devil are the two major series that have hit the tops of the charts among miners; they overclock easier, they survive at overclocked longer, and they run at overclocked cooler, and their fans survive higher RPM longer. They are also the two launch day non-refs for the 7900 XTX, and due to the vapor chamber issue, vanish from stock as soon as they come in.
- shmerl 4y agoNow that GPU mining is in decline, it's not hindering the rest of GPU users at least. But new Pulse models are still not readily available. Newegg and Amazon didn't even start selling them yet.
- morjom 4y agoa decently known PC hardware overclocking channel, der8auer, did a few hands on investigative videos on these kind of cards that I found interesting. maybe you will too. they do content in both english and german. https://youtube.com/@der8auer-en https://youtube.com/@der8auer-en
- urbandw311er 4y agoIf you read the article der8auer is referenced
- jackmott42 4y agoWhat does price gouging mean to Jeff? What does it mean to you? gaming cards are a market with competition (AMD, Nvidia). It is also a luxury. So how do you price gouge? Surely at almost all moments in time both of these public companies have sought to maximize profit, as they are now.
- amerine 4y agoThey recently changed their agreements with card makers and forced very high pricing. They are charging more because they can, it’s the definition of price gouging.
- twblalock 4y agoEvery company charges as much as it thinks it can for a product. If that counts as price gouging, almost 100% of all the companies that exist must be guilty of it!
- Buttons840 4y agoThat's the logic of the free market, yes. But do two companies which probably swap employees and executives constitute a market? If I went to a classical market, and two people were selling, is that a healthy market?
- twblalock 4y agoIf those two people in your example tried as hard to compete with each other as AMD and Nvidia do, then yes, it's a market and it's more healthy than many others. An unhealthy, uncompetitive market would not have such a notable rate of improvement of the products as we see in the GPU market. Plus, if it's competition you are concerned about, the situation is improving! Intel is getting into the discrete GPU market too.
- tormeh 4y ago> such a notable rate of improvement of the products To be fair, frames per dollar have been roughly stagnant for a couple of years. It's just that now you have the additional option of paying more dollars to get more frames. This is an unusual situation, but it is what it is. The AMD 7000 series is (so far) not better value than the AMD 6000 series. Same with Nvidia. That's odd.
- tgtweak 4y agoIt's a basically 100% (of reference models) at this point given it's a design flaw on the reference card design that many OEMs used.
- xbar 4y agoPerhaps. Or perhaps it's 1% of reference models. But it is, according to AMD, a knowable, countable, and therefore recallable number that AMD is electing not to issue a recall for. If they did, the both the consumer market and the investor market would know how big a problem this is. Which AMD is very clearly shying away from. As a cynic, it makes me suspect that the number is on the larger end of the spectrum.
- CoastalCoder 4y agoIn recent years I've been a big fan of AMD's products. But I agree, there evasiveness on this topic is eroding some of my trust. I'd like to see AMD get sued (without settling out of court) so that hopefully the number of affected cards becomes public via discovery. Poor form, AMD, poor form indeed.
- tgtweak 4y agoSeveral youtubers have bought multiple cards to test and nearly all of them experienced this issue when installed horizontally (vast majority of gpu installs are this way - motherboard vertical, card horizontal). AMD claiming that it's due to some vapor chambers not being filled fully is pretty bunk since it is across all vendors and there is supposedly a revised cooler design going out to OEM partners for recall/refitting.
- spuz 4y agoAccording to AMD, it's not a design issue but a manufacturing issue. Some of the coolers were not filled with enough water. Many cards with reference cools do not suffer from this issue.
- Night_Thastus 4y agoIf this is anything like that power connector debacle, it's actually a pretty small % of all users, they're just obviously very loud about it. (Which they should be, obv) Manufacturing mistakes happen. The important thing is AMD is doing the right thing on the repair side for them, paying for cards to be sent back and fixed. This whole situation is a bit of a nothing burger.
- geerlingguy 4y agoIn my case they aren't paying for cards to be sent back and fixed, and so far there's no concrete evidence it's a small/limited batch of cards affected. Honestly, outside of those who actually benchmark their cards, most people would probably just live with slightly reduced performance and very noisy fans (none the wiser), so it's hard to tell how widespread the problem actually is.
- paulmd 4y agothere are system integrators (places like Puget Systems) who build boutique gaming rigs and workstations and those kinds of places perform additional testing to make sure everything is working as expected, and they've measured around 10% of MBA cards as having faulty coolers. https://www.igorslab.de/en/single-case-or-vapor-gate-samt-failure-of-quality-management-behind-the-rx-7900-xtx-cooler-problem-total-qm-qa-and-qc/ https://www.igorslab.de/en/single-case-or-vapor-gate-samt-fa... (note that this site does google translate for its english copy, so there are some textual oddities, if you speak german you might want to read the DE version) the thing with the connector problem was that nobody could reproduce it in a lab, so the rational assumption was that it was a very very rare failure case at best. NVIDIA has a lot of marketshare and the law of large numbers says that if even 0.04% of people experience a failure mode, that works out to at least a couple dozen people or whatever. in contrast this one is easily measurable by SIs, and it very much should have been caught by QC at multiple levels - 10% is not exactly a rare failure, if you can't catch a failure rate of 1 in 10 units then you are probably are missing a bunch of other QC issues too. As Igor notes in his analysis - there actually are a lot of people who fucked up on this one. Further, we are at the very earliest stage when MBA cards are most prominent in the market. Custom card designs (PCB and cooling) generally launch later in the lifecycle, this is a relatively large amount of the entire market of cards that have a problem. Once again, should have been obvious - if 200k cards launched and half of them are MBA (perhaps an underestimate) that means there's around 10k defective cards. Not everybody would (or will) notice the defect, and that's understandable to some degree because it's not emitting smoke and flames, but contrast maybe a couple dozen people plugging in their NVIDIA cards wrong with 10k AMD users with defective coolers here. or perhaps a more dramatic comparison would be the recent spike in 6000-series chip failures reported by a well-known electronics repairman in germany... a relatively uncommon failure has now made up around 2/3rds of his repairs in the past month and the common factor seems to be they were all using the same driver version. the New Worlds thing was a huge scandal (despite basically tracing back to EVGA fucking up their soldering yet again) and people have perpetually murmured about "bad NVIDIA drivers causing chip failures back in the day" despite that really not being supported in any significant way, and here's actually the same thing seeming to occur on AMD 6000 series cards. again, if this was NVIDIA I can only imagine the social-media shitstorm and the murmur campaign that would be in progress right now, despite only being one repairman with a sample size of under 100 cards. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pQDnwpc_k4E https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pQDnwpc_k4E there is a major major attitude difference in the enthusiast community, people are ready to pounce at the first sign of a weakness or a problem from NVIDIA, and constantly assume the most pessimistic and nefarious possible scenarios, while downplaying AMD problems and giving them the most optimistic and altruistic benefit of the doubt at all times. like, if this were NVIDIA, does anybody think the community's reaction to a bunch of cards seemingly failing with an usual and specific failure mode would be "now calm down and be rational, let's wait and let NVIDIA investigate and see what they say"? After the connector "scandal", after New Worlds, after POSCAP-gate, after the EVGA 1080 fires, etc? pretty sure everyone whose card died in the last month for any reason would be coming out of the woodwork and posting on reddit, and tech media would be running breaking coverage about it, demanding statements from the manufacturer, etc. or consider the 5700XT - if NVIDIA had shipped (what at this point appears to be) defective silicon, ignored widespread reports of crashes and blackscreening for months, and then after being called out by tech media finally released a couple halfhearted patches that didn't really fix the issue for most people, would the public have just shrugged and moved on like they did with AMD? There would be lawsuits and angry videos and widespread demands for refunds etc etc. And they did the same thing with early Zen2 silicon which was far below advertised clocks and never really improved after the patches/etc. Later silicon was fine, just a batch of poorly-binned silicon at launch that they decided to ship anyway as higher-tier SKUs, but they never recalled it or made anyone whole. The social media community just buried it, did a bunch of "well it comes close if you just run loops of NOPs" damage control bullshit to argue that it wasn't technically false advertising. Once again everyone shrugged and moved on, later silicon got better and the people stuck with defective chips got screwed. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=M3sNUFjV7p4&t=254s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=M3sNUFjV7p4&t=254s https://old.reddit.com/r/hardware/comments/cy7omt/der8auers_zen_2_boost_clock_investigation/ https://old.reddit.com/r/hardware/comments/cy7omt/der8auers_... https://old.reddit.com/r/Amd/comments/cfli2n/i_discovered_how_to_get_my_3900x_to_boost_to/ https://old.reddit.com/r/Amd/comments/cfli2n/i_discovered_ho... Everyone says AMD doesn't have mindshare but they clearly do have a massive amount of mindshare with loyalists that help them move past these sorts of issues very fluidly and without any accusations or recriminations or even controversy really. Everything is just "they're doing the best they can, practically a small family-owned business, you can't expect them to ship working products every time". The tyranny of low expectations. And that's what leads to these larger problems. The recall costs, lawsuits, and popular blowback are supposed to be the corrective mechanism for companies being sketchy as fuck or taking needless technical risks, and that has been short-circuited for AMD by popular assent.
- tgtweak 4y agoThere are also some concerning reports of rx6000 series GPU chips "cracking" but it's less covered. Source: https://wccftech.com/amd-radeon-rx-6000-gpus-mysteriously-start-dying-german-repair-shop-receives-48-cards-with-cracked-chips/amp/ https://wccftech.com/amd-radeon-rx-6000-gpus-mysteriously-st...
- mjevans 4y agoI'm going to be charitable and make a wild guess. There's probably some software section that checks a memory mapped region for a value from thermometers and throttles as necessary. It doesn't sound too difficult to make a mistake related to testing that region. If I were an evil overlord / dictator trying to follow one or more of the lists of things to do / not do... a dedicated hardware circuit for thermal overprotection would be among the must have items for any non-trivial device. Trivial devices being things that could fail with no risks, even from their worst failure mode. http://www.eviloverlord.com/lists/overlord.html http://www.eviloverlord.com/lists/overlord.html // https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/EvilOverlordList https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/EvilOverlordList
- DiabloD3 4y agoThe way that is worded makes it sound like a certain German retailer is frequented by miners, and this is what the failure mode of RDNA2 cards look like when overclocked and overvolted until dead. The article says the users claimed they weren't mining, but, obviously, a miner wouldn't say they were mining with it, even though the strict EU consumer protection laws would probably protect them anyways.
- yourusername 4y agoMiners almost never overclocked but tended to underclock and undervolt. Especially in a place like Germany where power is very expensive miners would be even more incentivized to find the optimum power/performance spot.
- tgtweak 4y agoUsually miners undervolt and also clock down the gpu. The memory is what gets clocked up. Majority of those deaths happen due to heat-up and cool-down cycle of the gpu between gaming sessions. Not implying that mining is light on the cards vs occasional gaming but if you game daily on it you'll have higher gpu temps during gaming. Source: had an rx6800 that mined for over a year and no such issue.
- Krisjohn 4y agoWhy walk away from AMD for one design/manufacturering fault? It's easy to avoid, just buy a card that doesn't use the reference cooler.
- dylan604 4y agoWhile this may be the first for you, it may just be another example on a list over time. Apple walked away from Nvidia to solely use AMD after enough instances, but I was only personally affected by one model. It was apparently the one (2011 MBP) that broke the camel's back though, so there's that.
- tverbeure 4y agoThe bump crack issue with MacBooks was in the open in 2008. Apple used AMD GPUs for the MacBook Pro 2011. 4 years after bump crack, they switched back to using Nvidia GPUs for the trusty old mid-2012 MacBook Pro that's still my daily driver, with excellent keyboard, and for the late-2013 MacBook Pro too. If there's anything that, I don't know what it is.
- dylan604 4y agoAre you telling me the laptop that I have isn't what it is? Really? That's what you want to do? It was repaired twice by Apple, but the third time it happened, they wanted me to pay for it which was going to be a good chunk of the cost of a new MBP.
- tverbeure 4y agoAre you telling me that my 2012 MBP isn’t using an Nvidia GPU? As for the early-2011 17” MBP: it used AMD. https://support.apple.com/kb/sp621?locale=en_US https://support.apple.com/kb/sp621?locale=en_US So there’s that.
- dylan604 4y agoI dont' know what you're trying to say, but I never said that the 2011 model that I had was the last version to ever have an Nvidia GPU or that AMD was never used before then. You're really trying to start something just because...what, you're bored? I specifically chose the Nvidia GPU over the AMD option because of wanting to use CUDA. Most of us are aware that Apple's hardware designs and manufacturing pipelines are planned so that if they decide something today, it won't become available to consumers for at least a year if not two. So I guess, I'm really asking WTF is the point of you arguing?
- andrewstuart 4y agoAMD confirm the issue and commit to fixing any affected cards: https://www.tomshardware.com/news/amd-vows-to-replace-overheating-radeon-rx-7900-xtx-boards https://www.tomshardware.com/news/amd-vows-to-replace-overhe... "We have the fix we are ready to send it to you. Just call our tech support line if you bought it from amd.com or if you bought it from one of our AIB partners call them, they have [replacement] units, Geerling says: AMD said "customers experiencing this unexpected limitation should contact AMD support", but if you head to the support page, and call the US support phone number, it directs you to the warranty claims page on the website. On that page, it guides you through a wizard and determines if you didn't buy the AMD card from AMD.com itself, you have to contact the partner manufacturer (even though in this case it's the reference design, just packaged by Sapphire).
- notjes 4y agoOT but got me thinking: I member my old Voodoo graphics card had like 10 to 15 Watts. Then was surprised how much power the 6800Ultra consumed: whooping 70Watts. Those numbers are peanuts today. 350W for the AMD and 450W for the nVidia card. AMD is predicting 0.7kW in 2025. I imagine in 2030 people will be having some some fancy CPU and RAM, but that GPU will be sitting on top of a 2kg block of copper to keep up with the heat generation. 1.2kW Cards here we go! Next up: that power cable coming out of that wall is going straight into the GPU. https://sundries.com.ua/en/the-power-consumption-of-video-cards-will-reach-600-700-w-by-2025-amd-forecast/ https://sundries.com.ua/en/the-power-consumption-of-video-ca...
- icelancer 4y ago>> Next up: that power cable coming out of that wall is going straight into the GPU. This is already a thing in some servers, and of course, crypto miners that use server power supplies + adapter boards + 8-pin plugs to power the GPUs separately. You chain the server PSU with your ATX PSU using a jumper and they start simultaneously. No doubt that some form of that is coming to gaming and machine learning PCs soon. (It's already here for ML builds actually, but not that widespread I guess)
- dTal 4y ago>Next up: that power cable coming out of that wall is going straight into the GPU. It kind of seems like we're evolving towards the GPU being the "main computer". We need to keep an extra close eye on things like open standards and free drivers. nVidia's closed-source stack only feels like a minor hassle right now, but if you think of the GPU as the heart of the system it puts us right back to the bad old days of computing where cross-platform was impossible, compilers were vendored, and operating systems were closed source. We got into the current cushy situation of PC compatibility by sheer luck, and the "mobile revolution" is a warning sign that we can't take any of it for granted when the computing substrate evolves.
- runnerup 4y agoEverything will have to move to water-cooling. Reliably air-cooling more than 1kW in uncontrolled end-user environments starts to get fairly absurd.
- CoastalCoder 4y agoMaybe Gamer's Nexus should post a video about how AMD refuses to confirm that less than 90% of their boards have this defect.
- atlgator 4y agoAnyone run benchmarks on a Red Devil or other XTX with a custom cooler? Any issues?
- geerlingguy 4y agoSo far this problem seems exclusive to the AMD reference design for the XTX only.
- DiabloD3 4y agoIt has already been confirmed by major people in the community that designs, ref or not, that use a conventional cooler do not exhibit the issue, and will reach about 85c (ie, normal) at 100% load. The dead giveaway isn't that the chip reaches 110c, it's that the entire card gets so hot (due to manufacturing error of the vapor chamber, independently verified by the community and AMD both), that RAM starts throttling too (ie, identical to the 3090 issue with the special Micron GDDR6, and glad to see AMD also adopt RAM temp throttling), and that has not been observed on any non-vapor chamber card and also any vapor chamber that doesn't have the issue.
- johnwalkr 4y agoWhat is up with the first image? At first I thought it was a picture of a screen inception, but maybe it's a picture of a screen, with a slightly larger screen behind it, and a yet slightly larger screen behind that?
- renewiltord 4y agoThe first image shows exactly one screen and two boxes, one per top end GPU bought by the author.
- johnwalkr 4y agoSorry, second image.