13 ms·
Guerrilla guide to CNC machining, mold making, and resin casting (2015)
- georgeecollins 4y agoI sent this right away to my son that does FIRST robotics. It's amazing the tools that he has available to him.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- takk309 4y agoCool guide to get started with! I gave it a quick glance and noticed two things I struggled with when I started with CNC work, work holding and feed/speed calculations. Both of these topics are relatively machine dependent, so I understand the omission.
- dragontamer 4y agoNotes vs 3d printers. 1. This guide is about making the mold-of-the-mold, the mold, and finally the final product. Its at least 3 steps before you get the final piece of plastic, rather than a single step process like 3d printing. 2. I hear that expensive software can help automate this process ("Design Product" -> "Auto build mold" -> "Auto build mold-of-mold"), but software is surprisingly expensive for hobbyists. Expect to be manually designing these molds and mold-of-molds unless you're willing to pay for some rather expensive software. That being said: "Rectangle -> Difference (product-shape)" is a good start. 3. The chief advantage of resin casting is the huge variety of paints and resins available. If you want a flexible material, get ShoreA 40 Urethanes. If you want a silvery material, buy silver pigments. If you want Red, you can buy red pigment. Compared to 3d printing, you have far more material selection (ShoreA soft materials, from grades 20 to 80, ShoreD harder materials from grades 20 to 80, etc. etc.). 4. There's also a "mass production" advantage. You can build multiple molds and "parallelize" the resin casting relatively cheaply. Once you have the "mold-of-the-mold", building 5 molds, and then using those 5x molds 10x each will be faster than waiting 50x iterations of your 3D Printer. Assuming your object is small enough to fit multiple molds inside your pressure chamber, of course. 5. If you are aiming at extruded ABS (aka: professional legos plastic), the mold-of-the-mold methodology is very similar (though made out of Aluminum and/or Steel, rather than Silicone like in this guide). There's still subtle differences between Aluminum molds vs Silicone Molds, but the similarities mean that you have a better idea of the final-final product with a silicone mold prototype. 6. EDIT: 3D printing is also compatible. If you wanted to make the molds or mold-of-molds out of 3d printers, you probably can do that. Its all just "shapes" after all. However, CNC Mills have far better accuracy than 3d Printers, so CNC Mills are just a better tool for this methodology. But if you don't wanna buy a CNC Mill to go through this process, feel free to play with the techniques listed here with a 3D Printer instead. -------- The biggest issue with #5 are the "shapes" that molds can make. Its much more restrictive than the "shapes" a 3d printer can make. If you design your shape to be 3d printed, it might be impossible to make a mold out of it that builds that shape. In contrast, if you actually go through the mold-of-a-mold / mold process as listed here, you innately are thinking about the final Aluminum/Steel die that Injection Molders will do. You have much lower chance of erroneously building a product that's impossible to die cast. IIRC, the main mistake is that silicone molds are flexible. If a corner gets stuck or something, you can just yank it harder and the plastic will come out. Aluminum/steel dies are very rigid. You can't just do that. So if you're "aiming to prototype an ABS Injection Mold / Steel die", you wanna design your mold to "cleanly lift" off a piece without anything getting stuck.
- toss1 4y ago>> you wanna design your mold to "cleanly lift" off a piece without anything getting stuck. THIS!! Make sure you have a good draft angle and reliable release agent coating, or a multi-part mold that can come apart at the seams (which does 99.9% mean a flash cleanup step in your mfg process) With those, it will work great. Overlook it, and you'll have a very tedius cleanup job before your next part, or worst case, an expensive doorstop or coffee table piece.
- legitster 4y agoSemi-related: As an average consumer I'm disappointed that nearly a decade of the "makerspace" has seemingly failed to produce any sort of meaningful Renaissance in small-scale US manufacturing. I've purchased the odd 3D printed or resin cast tchotchke from small operations a few times at this point. But it's still disappointing that if you need professional quality products, you still either need to pay out the nose to have it fabbed or ship it in from China. It seems to me the industry is very good at serving hobbyists and prototypers. But I think there is a huge market being missed out on easy-to-use, introductory products for mold tooling, plastic injection, and general manufacturing automation. As cool as 3d printers can be, I don't think owning one scales up into a professional endeavour very well. However, developing a pretty good mold for a phone case would.
- thepasswordis 4y agoYou're wrong. There are massive 3D printing farms that are producing consumer products at scale in the united states now, and that is a direct result of the work that the maker community (both here and especially in China) has done on 3D printing.
- legitster 4y agoSure. But the vast majority of products are not ever going to be 3D printed. Most of the things you are going to touch today are going to be injection-molded. Keyboards, keychains, car parts, cups, computer cases, etc. There's a 3d print shop that sells at my local farmer's market. But they only sell tchotchkes. I am imagining a world where the same size business could also phone cases or mugs or even supply a local manufacturer.
- dicknuckle 4y agoWe're not at farmers markets, because our niches are too focused. One guy I follow on YouTube pretty much only sells tool trays for cannabis products and I only sell replacement brake cable guides for 1980's powersport machines. We've been at the very beginning of what you're describing for about 3-4 years now. I only started selling by request of the communities I'm part of because none of them knew anyone to print it.
- dekhn 4y agoI followed this guide (mostly) and ended up making a reese's peanut butter cup mold out of silicone (from a 3d printed template; I'm not doing anything ultra-precise) and then used my 3d printer to melt chocolate to make the entire confection. It was fun.
- throwaway4aday 4y agoI think CNC machining is primed for developments that make it much easier to use for the home hobbyist. The tech is very close to what's needed for 3D printing but it has a few added requirements like the need for a sturdier frame and accommodations for a fairly large and powerful motor. Both are solvable with the right materials and the motor can be anything from a DC spindle to a repurposed wood router. The biggest hurdle to overcome would be the software. Right now, Fusion360 is the defacto standard for hobbyists but it leaves a lot to be desired for ease of use and handling complex models that a lot of people would like to mill. Having software that is as easy to use as a slicer for 3D prints would be a huge win. The ability to make metal parts and carvings is a game changer even if you are somewhat more limited in the features that you can carve with a CNC vs 3D printing. The other small fab tool that I think would be great to streamline would be a small foundry for casting aluminum, brass, and bronze but that one is much more difficult to automate beyond having a furnace with good presets. An ideal machine would be something similar to an injection molding machine for plastic but capable of melting metal, perhaps using induction heating with a graphite crucible and spigot for depositing the metal into a mold. I'm also somewhat convinced that there may be a way to do aluminum extrusion with a much smaller setup than is normally used but the pressures and temperatures involved may make that uneconomical for an individual.
- datpiff 4y ago> The tech is very close to what's needed for 3D printing but it has a few added requirements like the need for a sturdier frame and accommodations for a fairly large and powerful motor. This is a huge understatement. You also need large investments in consumable tooling plus metrology tools to do anything useful with metal. The entire operation is really loud, slow, dangerous and throws chips everywhere. The whole point of the linked article is that CNC machining is a pretty awful fit for a hobbyist! It literally recommends finding alternatives with stuff that's easier to have in a home.
- throwaway4aday 4y agoI don't think it's that much of an understatement looking at the table top CNC machine that I got off Aliexpress and upgraded so that it could mill aluminum. Same stepper motors, same Arduino type board, moderately fancier bearings. The main things I had to do were just beef up the frame with some plate and replace the dinky spindle that came with it. I'm not making precision parts with it, just fun hobby things and artsy stuff.
- prova_modena 4y agoI skipped right to the section on CNC machining because that's what I have some expertise in. A couple pieces of feedback: - In section 2.1.1 there is a note that states "CAM applications are designed to fail safely; that is, if any of the features of the model cannot be reached without plowing through another essential section of the geometry, the problematic region simply won't be machined at all." This is really, really bad advice for someone learning CNC, because it's the kind of statement that may be true 90% of the time but the remaining 10% where it is false can have serious consequences (ruined workpieces, broken tools, crashed machines, injuries etc). Every one of the 6 CAM programs I have used has both intended behaviors and bugs/edge cases that will violate this assumption. A CNC learner should instead be instructed to have a step-by-step verification checklist to determine the correctness and safety of a new program. This includes steps utilizing both the simulation functions within their CAM program and dry running on the machine. In addition to behaviors within CAM, there is a whole additional class of unintended (unsafe) behavior that can emerge once the program is actually run on the machine and will not be caught in CAM simulation. The exact composition of this verification process will vary depending on what you are doing, but the main idea is to never assume your CAM programming will fail safely like this article suggests. - In regards to Total Indicated Runout in section 2.1.3. The article has a good discussion here, however I would add that the smaller tool you use, the greater effect TIR has on tool longevity and surface finish. As overall tool diameter get smaller, allowable chip load generally decreases. TIR effectively changes the chip load on each tooth as the tool rotates. If TIR is large enough relative to chip load, this imbalance will destroy the tool in short order. Why is this important to a new CNC user? Lots of new CNC operators assume that since smaller tools reduce cutting forces, they can use very small endmills on their benchtop end mills and not worry about rigidity. However, due to the TIR + chipload issue described above, demands on spindle precision actually increase if you want to use smaller end mills. There is a sweet spot where the end mill is cutting, has decent life and does not exert overly high cutting forces, which will depend on the machine and tool holding setup. But this does not necessarily coincide with using the smallest end mill possible. - In section 2.1.7, jaw chucks (like a drill chuck) should not even be mentioned, except to caution users away from them. The article describes them as if they are just a non-optimal choice, but they are outright dangerous to use for milling. They are not designed to deal with the lateral forces created by end mills. They also are often mounted on tapers that can't deal with those forces either. Please do not reply and tell me you have had success milling with an X-Y table on your drill press. You may have, but you won't be doing it in my shop. It's not safe. - Section 2.1.8 is overall good info, but misses mentioning what is one of the most important keywords to understanding how CNC machines interface with CAM software: the postprocessor. All G-code is interpreted and comes in many different dialects, with varying degrees of compatibility across CNC controller manufacturers. Which dialect your CAM system outputs is controlled by the postprocessor, which is a build script that can be interchanged to support different CNC controllers. Of special interest to the HN audience is the fact that these postprocessors can be written and (usually) modified, which may be advantageous to support unusual machines or customize your production process. IIRC fusion360 postprocessors are javascript. Professional machine shops without in-house software dev expertise pay big money for custom postprocessors. If anyone is interested in getting deeper into this subject, I have been curating a list of resources for learning machining on my website here: https://www.r-c-y.net/posts/machining/ https://www.r-c-y.net/posts/machining/ I began compiling these because I was mostly self-taught when I started machining and at the time found it pretty tough to find good learning resources that weren't primarily focused on hobbyist-scale machining. These should provide a good introduction to industrial scale, professional quality machining rather than small scale benchtop milling like this article. However, the fundamentals apply to both, so even if your ambitions are small it's good to learn from the pros.
- DalekBaldwin 4y agoAs somebody trying to get into mechanical engineering while living in a small urban apartment, this has been an incredible resource... not that I've made much progress along the lines it describes though. It's tough to plan a path toward growth in these skills without sustaining inordinate expenses at each step. I can't afford to become afflicted with Gear Acquisition Syndrome. I've come close to dropping huge sums of cash on tools before discovering, at the last minute, critical reasons that they could not do what I need for the designs I have in mind. Maybe I'll visit a makerspace? Ah, but every one in my area appears to have gone defunct since Covid year zero. So the journey up to this point has been: - A lot of reading: not just faffing around with hobbyist blogspam -- full-on MechE textbooks, learning what really goes into engineering schematic diagrams, all that good stuff - Getting back up to speed with the pencil-on-paper geometry and math skills I've lost after years of doing all my intellectual work in digital form (at least I can still draw a freehand circle) - Proto-proto-prototyping: just making some physical objects roughly of the same geometry as what I've designed -- whittling them out of wood, sculpting them out of polymer clay - Hacking together janky tools: trying to make a crappy mini lathe out of Meccano-clone parts, trying to make a crappy mini lathe out of an electric drill, just to get a basic feel for what's involved - Apologizing to my wife for all this weird scary stuff in the corner of the apartment I was a CS major. The only hands-on physical engineering I did in college was cooking a single-transistor chip in a freshman applied physics lab. Basically I feel like someone who has studied everything about the physics of bicycles but has never ridden one. I'm really struggling on how to proceed.
- dragontamer 4y agoTake a woodworking class at your community college. Focus on the serious fundamentals first. I mean like how to hammer a nail into a thing, how to screw things together. Learn the difference between nut+bolt, Truss Head screws, and pan-head screws. Learn when to use each of these things. Visit Home Depot. Build a damn coffee table. Focus on the fundamentals. CNC Mill comes after all this IMO on the hierarchy of knowledge. You really should be extremely familiar with fasteners (Glue vs Nuts+Bolts vs Screws vs Nails) before you start designing things that get glued/screwed/snapped together. -------------- Most things are left unsaid because just building a damn coffee table (or similarly simple / small object) is everything you need to know about beginner level mechanical engineering. Finding a class (community college) with this basic level of skills really is the bulk of it. Once you've accomplished the basics, it becomes obvious how to use a CNC Mill or 3d printer or whatever these electronic tools are.
- 12311231231 4y ago[dead]
- pugworthy 4y agoSomething I'd add to this list is the use of heat set threaded inserts when combined with 3D printing. Rather than create nut-shaped indentations or threading into plastic, you take a threaded insert, and heat it up with a soldering iron and push it down into the plastic.
- jacquesm 4y agoThis is a great guide. One word of warning: it's not the shop tools that will cost you real money over the longer term, it is the tooling. It isn't rare at all to spend double or more on tooling than you did on your CNC machine, especially if you bought it second hand. So keep a sharp eye out for local machine shops going out of business and ebay to score tooling in quantity, sort out what you think you'll need and sell the remainder. That's going to cost a very small fraction of what you would spend otherwise. To give you just one example, a pretty common 1/2" dia 3" long quality endmill will easily set you back $40 or more. And you never have enough clamps and hold down gear.
- F35Machinist 4y agoI wouldn't recommend buying anything other than brand new cutters. People overpay for used junk. New cutters can be pricey, but you only buy what you need anyway.
- HWR_14 4y agoThe information there seems to dismiss a lot of the dust considerations with regard to cncing standard (aluminum, wood, plastic) materials. Other sources online have been pretty scary. Does anyone have any experience or knowledge?
- mmaunder 4y agoMost CNC machines come with a vacuum attachment which I recommend using. If your feeds and speeds are correct your making chips, not dust.
- HWR_14 4y agoThanks. If the CNC machine does not have a vacuum attachment (if it's just a small hobbyist machine) are there best practices? And if it does, is a simple shopvac sufficient or should I be looking at HEPA filters?
- mmaunder 4y agoI'm sure googling this will help you out. Mine only have vacuum attachments and filters.
- thealch3m1st 4y agoThis website is great! His advice about resin casting, tolerances, machining/runout is invaluable.
- at_a_remove 4y agoOnce again the brief period of excitement I had shortly before the closure of TechShop is roused. They very foolishly offered me three months free, and all of the classes I could take during that time, free! I did every class but the CNC embroidery. Completely hog wild. In my defense, I was primed for it: extensive drafting courses, some engineering courses, the ability to do math with a parametric mindset, woodworking in high school, some focus on material when I was still on an engineering path before switching to physics, and so on. I just lit up and ran about the place like a crazed monkey churning out personalized knickknacks for friends, throwing together little projects, doing a spot of weird art. All of the spaces are now faaaar away and I miss just banging out strange things on a whim.
- mmaunder 4y agoI use a Shapeoko XXL 3 and 4 and I have a HDM on the way. The 5 Pro and migration to ballscrews for X and Y instead of belts for their more affordable machines looks great. Wanted to first say this is a great resource and I’ll be constantly referring to it. It doesn’t mention Fusion 360 and Vectric Aspire much so I just wanted to add that Fusion is great for engineering designs and CAM but is terrible at machining shapes derived from STL or other high resolution 3D data. Fusion likes you to create the source data in Fusion. It can’t handle creating CAM tool paths for scans with more than 50,000 triangles and even more than 10,000 is asking a lot. Aspire absolutely eats STL tool paths for breakfast and asks for seconds. So for machining topography I’ve moved entirely over to Aspire. I like it so much I’m using it for other non topo projects too because it’s just so fast. It is significantly slower on a Windows VM but absolutely screams along on a modest gaming PC. There’s a free tier for Aspire so try it out. To buy Fusion or Aspire is expensive which is why the guide probably doesn’t mention them much. Also total tangent but I just installed a Fireboy automatic fire extinguisher above my CNC machine that I use for overnight unattended jobs along with cameras and remote shut off. I’d strongly recommend this for longer jobs. CNC fires are common and seem to be most often caused by insufficient work holding where the part comes loose and is dragged by the bit creating friction and heat.
- takk309 4y agoI watched a good video on the subject of adaptive clearing taking too long to calculate and it helped me to improve the processing and machining time of complex geometry. https://youtu.be/osNPQr5-EpM https://youtu.be/osNPQr5-EpM Another thing I found with topographic stuff is to simplify the mesh after importing it. It makes very little difference to the final project depending on your scale.
- mmaunder 4y agoMakes a big difference in quality in my experience and the conversions generally run overnight. Same applies to M1 architecture and high end gaming PCs. I am for example carving the entire state of Colorado on 24” X 24” oak 2.5 inches deep. But I’ve see the same loss on quality on eg a VW beetle relief that I carved that was 24x12”. Aspire has blown me away with the end result and speed of computation.