22 ms·
Antidepressants are over-prescribed, but genuinely help some patients
- WeylandYutani 4y agoIf your healthcare system is private patients become customers and the customer is always right. If they want pills the doctor will give them. Antibiotics, sleeping pills, painkillers, antidepressants.
- kwhitefoot 4y agoThere is significant over-prescription of ant-depressants in the UK NHS as well. As far as I can tell at least partly because the health and social security system doesn't have the capacity to treat underlying causes. Some of the underlying causes are of course poverty and insecure employment neither of which is amenable to a medical intervention. Waiting times for any kind of talking therapy are huge and even when a place is available it will often require the patient to travel long, expensive, and awkward distances which alone makes it impossible for people on low incomes.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- thehappypm 4y agoI had anxiety attacks constantly (chest tightness followed by passing out) in any sort of stressful environment. I tried for years to conquer it with mental toughening, but recently my doctor prescribed me Zoloft and it has completely solved that for me. It’s like a miracle drug. A side effect? Noticeably improved moods. I was certainly not substantially depressed, but my balance of moods is definitely shifted towards positivity and I’m just less moody. So I definitely believe they can be a tool in the fight.
- yuck39 4y agoAs someone taking Lexapro for similar reasons, do you have any plans to taper off of Zoloft? I tried to stop taking it cold turkey once and had wild side effects ranging from fatigue to the inability to keep my balance standing up. My psych seems to be okay with keeping me on it indefinitely but I'm not sure how long I _should_ be taking this stuff.
- seunosewa 4y agoTake it as long as it helps you.
- mtlmtlmtlmtl 4y agoStrange, Lexapro is typically one of the easier SSRIs to stop taking; it has a long enough half life that it tends to be self-tapering. It's certainly possible to do a slow taper off it, though. In general there should be no super long term side effects to worry about though. If you absolutely insist, your psychiatrist would probably help set up a tapering schedule.
- phphphphp 4y agoDo whatever feels right for you. There are some people for whom there is a psychological cost to being on medication and medication for them is a step towards being "normal" but for many other people (like myself) medication is a tool I'll continue to use for as long as it feels helpful. That said, if you do wish to stop taking medication like Lexapro or Zoloft, try to frame it as an experiment in finding the ideal dose for yourself: you hope it'll be 0 but it may not be. Stopping cold turkey is a very bad idea for the obvious side effects you experienced, but you're also missing out on the opportunity to understand whether you can live well without the medication (i.e: your entire quitting Lexapro experience becomes consumed by the horrible side effects, rather than the change in your mental health, which is difficult to measure when you're suffering an inability to stand up right). I am not a doctor or the parent commentor, just a Zoloft consumer, so take this with a spoonful of salt, but... the standard dose of Zoloft is anywhere from 50mg to 200mg: if you're on 200mg and feel that maybe now is the time to come off Zoloft, then gradually reducing down from 200 to 150 to 100 to 75 to 50 to 25 to 0 will give you many helpful checkpoints to determine whether the medication is required, e.g: if you get down to 100mg from 200mg and start to struggle, you know that 100mg isn't enough, but 200mg is more than you need, so maybe a good new dose for you is 150mg. Repeat every time you feel like quitting. Swap those numbers for whatever Lexapro's dosage range is.
- taeric 4y agoHoly crap, this general headline probably captures the vast majority of all interventions and strategies for everything. Replace "microservices" for "Anti-depressants" and you could probably get the same for companies. This is not to say the research is bad. Quite the contrary. The research is to find the nuance and most patients/companies can't wait for that before they need something.
- mensetmanusman 4y agoSo it’s like antibiotics. Sure they’re devastating for many people’s long term gastrointestinal health, but it does save some of them, so we make the trade off.
- omgmajk 4y agoADs have helped my friends but didn't help me. Other medication did help however and for that I am thankful. It gave me breathing room, enough to reboot my career and focus on important things.
- carlgreene 4y agoIt's pretty obvious that antidepressants help people, but I pretty firmly believe they are unnecessary. Vigorous exercise (morning is better) and time outdoors should be the first thing prescribed to these patients. The former being probably the most important. I was on and off SSRI's for awhile. Pretty chronically "depressed" through my late teens up to about mid 20's (shocker!). Exercise, talking to someone, and realizing that I am the one who's in control of this has helped me more than any anti-depressant. Similar story with several of my good friends. The jump to medication in my case was a result of laziness and impatience. Once I got past those two nasty traits, "depression" was a just a bout of sadness that comes when I should feel sad.
- butlerm 4y agoAs they say, the plural of anecdote is not data, and here we don't even have a plural.
- carlgreene 4y agoYes but as a famous man once said, "when the anecdotes and the data disagree, the anecdotes are usually right". Not sure how accurate that is, but it points to the possibility data is being measured incorrectly. Whether it's factually right or wrong, it's still important to use your intuition and question science and research.
- mariodiana 4y agoThere is something else that points to. Not everything is measurable.
- cedilla 4y ago"Just exercise vigorously" isn't actionable advise for many people struggling with depression. Telling people with a disorder that often goes along with sleep disorder to "just exercise vigorously in the morning", and linking it with "laziness and impatience" is either a misunderstanding of the disease or simply mean.
- partiallypro 4y agoI had taken Paxil for the past decade and stopped late last summer. It had some effects I enjoyed, but it also had so many bad side effects that frankly the doctor that prescribed it to me never even mentioned. Lower libido, lower testosterone, weight gain, sometimes making me more apt to make a rash choice etc. It was also literal hell to taper off of, and I don't say that lightly. Brain zaps, restless legs, insomnia, flu like symptoms, minor sexual disfunction etc. It took 2 months for RLS to go away with some help from some supplements like Ashwaganda and Magnesium. However now that I'm fully tapered, I still don't feel depressed, I've lost 10lbs and my testosterone and libido are starting to come back. I like to think Paxil helped me in the past but I'm not entirely sure. My main problem is the lack of transparency upon it being prescribed. I don't think my instance is unusual.
- trashface 4y agoTried a couple (citalopram, sertraline) that didn't work for me. The first did make me gain a bunch of weight though, took years to work that off. Also had buproprion, which was useful & stimulating at first (as expected) but I seemed to build a tolerance really fast. So I gave up. Actually my primary doc just refused to renew my Rx and so I went cold turkey, then got rebound depression, that was fun. I know there are 8+ more SSRIs I could try, but my ADD (undiagnosed) is probably a bigger problem anyway. Its on my TODO list to go to a psychiatrist to get that all sorted out, for about 4 years now. Will need something to get a job again though.
- stillbourne 4y agoI probably would have killed myself if not for antidepressants. I cared for my elderly grandparents through the end of their life. During that time I saw a therapist to talk about my depression that kept getting worse as I slowly watched them die. I kept asking her to prescribe something for me but she said she didn't have the ability to write a prescription. What she didn't tell me and what I didn't learn until my third call to the suicide hotline is I could just ask my primary care physician. I thought I needed a therapist to sign off on it but it wasn't needed at all. I ended up quitting her practice for not bothering to tell me I could just ask my doctor for a prescription we ended up having a fight because she argued that I didn't need them. Meanwhile 3 weeks after I got them I was no longer suicidal. Anecdotally, people say antidepressants are over-prescribed but I've been on that prescription now for 8 years, the last of my grandparents passed two years ago. It is my personal opinion that talk therapy is what is over-prescribed because it didn't do a fucking thing for me while a $7 dollar a month prescription solved in a month. Don't let people tell you what you should do to stay sane, that's between you and your doctor.
- temptemptemp111 4y ago[dead]
- peepee1982 4y agoI've only read the headline, but isn't this the consensus already? Full disclosure: I'm on antidepressants and probably don't really need them.
- MichaelApproved 4y agoIf you care enough to wonder and comment, why not read the article?
- willcipriano 4y agoNot really. I haven't heard a explanation that is all that credible about why mental illness rates are skyrocketing like they have been (quick Google pulls up this chart, you can find many others[0]). The idea that a large percentage of children are mentally ill is taken at face value but if rates of say asthma were rising at the same pace we would probably be restructuring society to prevent it. [0]https://www.whitehouse.gov/cea/written-materials/2022/05/31/reducing-the-economic-burden-of-unmet-mental-health-needs/ https://www.whitehouse.gov/cea/written-materials/2022/05/31/...
- api 4y agoThere seems to still be this notion that mental health is froofroo stuff and if it’s all in your head you need to just toughen up. So either it’s chemically based mental illness in which case you take a pill or it’s nonsense. Antidepressants can help some people with chemical issues but will do little to nothing for people without them.
- garganzol 4y agoThose graphs in the article look too close to placebo. So I wonder why antidepressants are still prescribed to treat any kind of disorder and not only, well, genuine psychogenic depression. The thing is psychogenic aspect is overrated. In reality, there are multitudes of other pathologies that may cause a condition. For instance, metabolic dysfunction, poisoning, Lyme disease. And if one treats only the consequence and not the cause then the probability of a successful recovery becomes negligible.
- kzrdude 4y agoShould we do more comparisons to no treatment? (Placebo is not "no treatment", that's why we have placebo effect.) Three cohorts, medication, placebo medication, no treatment. There must have been studies like this? This metastudy seems to say they have no evidence of a placebo effect, though. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/12535498/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/12535498/
- gruez 4y ago> Those graphs in the article look too close to placebo. So I wonder why antidepressants are still prescribed to treat any kind of disorder and not only, well, genuine psychogenic depression. Another article goes deeper into this issue (ie. why do meta-studies show a statistically significant difference, but the difference is so small?) https://awaisaftab.substack.com/p/the-case-for-antidepressants-in-2022 https://awaisaftab.substack.com/p/the-case-for-antidepressan...
- coldcode 4y agoI was briefly suicidal about 20 years ago, took anti-depressants for a couple of years, never needed them since. I can't say if they "worked" in a biochemical sense — perhaps the only affect was placebo — but they did keep me sane until my life circumstances improved. The brain is a very complex organ we still only vaguely understand, so "fixing" it is still very much a primitive response.
- maweaver 4y agoI just want to plus one this anecdote. I had a traumatic experience that led to my getting stuck in a very bad mental state. It became a cycle, where I didn't have the energy or willpower to do the things that could possibly have pulled me out of the pit. Antidepressants gave me the mental space to break the cycle and get things back on track. Placebo or not, my mental health steadily improved once I started taking them, and soon I found myself able to get back to exercising, eating healthy, and doing the other things that led me back to a healthy life. Edit to add: I am glad they were available when I needed the help, but I hope to God I am never in that bad of a mental state where I feel like I need them again.
- martopix 4y agoYes, the problem is in the "until my life circumstances improved". In your case they either improved on their own, or you don't talk about the possibly large amount of work you did to improve them. In my understanding (but it's not my field) the criticism is precisely of when antidepressants are used without a proper plan on that side.
- AlanSE 4y agoI'm picking up a theme about the US health care system - that doctors respond to conditions caused by environment with a drug. Our lifestyle (activity) is unhealthy, our food is unhealthy, our houses are nice but we don't get out of them, our relationships are unhealthy, even our culture creates anxiety. I speak for myself, but also everyone I know.
- jesuscript 4y agoThis sounds like the correct way for these things to be utilized. In your case, you were approaching a bottom so in so many words, you were at the end of the line and the only way to go was up (if you wanted out of the predicament). Where the prescriptions fail imho is with people that are nowhere close to bottoming out. They are in the murky middle and then get a bunch of scripts. They are not near destitution, so their prescriptions end up being perpetual. Taking antidepressants and other medication, and then going to therapy for years constantly talking about how much it sucks to be depressed about this and that means you are on a pathological treadmill. In sports, a “treadmill” team is good enough for the playoffs, not good enough to win a championship, not bad enough to get a top 5 draft pick that could change the whole team. They are stuck in the middle. Eventually treadmill teams realize they need to bottom out and trade most of their team so they can suck for a few years and rebuild with great draft picks (the crappier you are the, the better draft picks you get). Bottoming out is, for better or worse, one of the most effective methods of snapping people out of an addiction. I think it is underutilized when it comes to other issues. If you say your life sucks, then lose the job, lose the money, lose the friends, get homeless, and sleep out in the cold. Then if the natural will to live a better life doesn’t kick in, we’ll hospitalize you in a mental institution. Then we’ll try the medication. I’m pretty sure for most people, especially this demo of privileged tech workers, will at some point realize “hey my life ain’t that bad”. In Tech we call this “fail fast”. Test your theory on how much you think your life sucks by making it suck even more, and test it quickly. Then you’ll get your perspective.
- ergonaught 4y agoThe research has shown unequivocally that the benefits, such as they are, for the majority of people derive from the placebo effect. It's only in the very extreme cases where the effects genuinely exceed placebo. Irving Kirsch alone has hammered this for many years... I don't know when the lawsuits will finally begin, but they're going to be epic.
- chiefalchemist 4y agoUltimately, they'll pay a relatively small fee. Their insurance will cover some. In the end consumers will pay the rest. It's a great business model. Shady but effective.
- nostrebored 4y agoIt's shocking to me how few people realize that anti depressants very rarely outperform placebo. I've been arguing with people about this for years, because the evidence from RCTs really has been convincingly bad for a while now. I'm starting to feel like psychopharmacology is a lot like academia, where the real force of change is a generation taught X dying off.
- gruez 4y ago>It's shocking to me how few people realize that anti depressants very rarely outperform placebo very rarely? >Findings >We identified 28 552 citations and of these included 522 trials comprising 116 477 participants. In terms of efficacy, all antidepressants were more effective than placebo ... https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lancet/article/PIIS0140-6736(17)32802-7/fulltext https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lancet/article/PIIS0140-6...
- engineeringwoke 4y ago> All antidepressants were more efficacious than placebo in adults with major depressive disorder 1 in 4 American adult women take anti-depressant drugs. Do they all have major depressive disorder?
- LatteLazy 4y agoDespite the the title itself not being news, there is an insight in this (short) article and it IS worth actually reading IMHO. https://archive.ph/vmmFi https://archive.ph/vmmFi I wonder if anyone is doing a study into the particulars on the three groups to try and find common characteristics to guide future prescription? The cynic in me assumes not as that would reduce demand so why would a manufacturer fund such a study? But perhaps I am over cynical. Speculating wildly for a moment, think that misdiagnosis is one likely reason. Maybe anti-depressants work on depression (the disease), but do not work on (say) CPD (where depression is just a symptom). Of course actually correctly diagnosing people will be time consuming and expensive. And I personally am not convinced we actually have a good grip on what diseases exist in mental health but that is another whole discussion...
- notRobot 4y ago> And I personally am not convinced we actually have a good grip on what diseases exist in mental health but that is another whole discussion... If possible, can you go into it a bit more and/or link some further reading?
- Tangurena2 4y agoPart of the reason for the disparity is that people's genetics can drastically influence what effect particular drugs have. Switching drugs is a pain as one is supposed to taper off the old one, then switch to the new one and wait 4-12 weeks for the new one to take effect. If one drug works "good enough" then you're unlikely to want to even try a different one. I finally took a DNA test last year after reading about it (a "pharmacodynamics" one that your doctor has to order). Reading the results showed that all of the antidepressants that I had tried in the past were ones that I either had a gene to metabolize too fast or another gene that said they'd be ineffective for me.
- _the_king_ 4y agoAntidepressants can be wonder drugs for some people but in my case they made me manic as hell and ruined my life for a few months. Make sure you get screened for bipolar before you go on them.
- Zak 4y agoThe core finding in the article is: for 15% of people antidepressants provided large benefits independent of the placebo effect. What this suggests to me is the syndrome we call "depression" has multiple root causes, and current antidepressant medication treats at least one of them, but not all of them. Identifying those causes and finding ways to test for them could bring huge benefits, both in identifying people who would benefit from drugs, and avoiding unnecessary treatments for those who would not.
- lm28469 4y ago> What this suggests to me is the syndrome we call "depression" has multiple root causes Pretty sure in 50 years we'll see "depression" the same way we now see "hysteria" in 1800s/early 1900s, aka mostly whack diagnosis that grouped a lot of completely unrelated things under the same term
- tsoukase 4y agoI am a doctor. ALL conversations in HN about mental health go overboard due to two reasons: either generalisation of a N=1 case or trying to apply in practice large scale statistics. Reality lies somewhere in the middle, that is ADs are neither garbage nor life saving for all. It is absolutely personalized
- n8henrie 4y agoI would broaden this to "conversations about health" in general on HN. (Does HN support ~strikethrough~? On mobile or I'd try to find the official documentation.)
- nmarinov 4y agoI don't think so, it's not listed in the docs: https://news.ycombinator.com/formatdoc https://news.ycombinator.com/formatdoc
- bilsbie 4y agoI think every person is in charge of their own health. We can’t blindly follow advice based on credentials of others.
- jstx1 4y agoSure, you're responsible for your health but don't use that as an excuse to ignore or dismiss scientific evidence. I guess you could ignore it, as long as you aren't harming anyone else, but it still seems like a bad idea.
- anikom15 4y agoI think that’s part of the problem. We have very little understanding of the mechanisms of depression and how ADs can help or harm that.
- mellosouls 4y agoNo, of course not - by definition, advice is advisory only. But we can and should default to trusting advice from reputable people over hearsay; credentials inform our assessment of how reputable they are.
- Tangurena2 4y agoMy theory is that most people are taking the wrong antidepressants. I've been depressed for most of my life. It took decades before doctors would prescribe anti-depressants and I struggled trying to find one that worked. It wasn't until I took a DNA test that was specifically developed to help determine if/how one's genes were biased towards/against specific drugs. In my case, all of the ones I had tried so far were listed under "consider alternates" because I have a gene CYP2C19 that metabolizes them faster than other people. What I & my doctors did, was switch drugs until I found one that worked "good enough". I should have taken this DNA test years ago. It cost me $150 out of pocket.
- cjbgkagh 4y ago1000% get sequenced! Should be step number one for everyone. It’s now $200 for a high quality whole genome sequence where you can do all DNA tests simultaneously as well as future tests being developed. We’re walking bags of pathogenic rare conditions.
- kar5pt 4y agoWhat DNA test did you take?
- DaftDank 4y agoOut of curiosity, which test/company did you go with? A quick search reveals a lot of options, and I'm hoping you may have done some of the legwork already to determine if one is better than others for privacy reasons etc.?
- sandos 4y agoI don't know the answer, but as far as I know, 23andme seems to be the most focused on medical conditions?
- mtlmtlmtlmtl 4y ago23andme is little more than a grift to steal your genetic data, providing some vaguely interesting, possibly untrue information in return.
- swayvil 4y agoEvery evening, owners (who were on antidepressants) would put dog in solitary for the night. They had a special room for this. Dog found it very stressful. Eventually dog, knowing what horror was coming, would get upset as evening approached. Owners, on the advice of a dog-psychiatrist, put dog on antidepressants to cure the upsettedness. It's emblematic of something.
- alocasia-1 4y agoSo on the level of the dog, everything else being equal, is it better to have the medication or to suffer?
- randerson 4y agoOr option 3: let dog sleep in owner's bed.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- mariodiana 4y agoMy understand is that a dog's psychology is that of a pack animal, and that the stress of being put alone in a room every night is the stress of being separated from "the pack." Being separated from the pack equals the looming threat of death—to a greater or lesser extent—for a pack animal. What this whole scenario illustrates is that the dog's suffering depression was due not to any chemical imbalance but to it being in an environment radically unsuited to its deep-seated psychology. So, the dog's case, I would argue, is a case of anti-depressants being over-prescribed. The people were being cruel to the dog. They should have stopped being cruel. I'm writing all this because the dog's owners were on anti-depressants too, presumably to ameliorate their suffering. Perhaps they've created just as bad an environment for themselves as they have for the dog. Is it better for them to have the medication or to suffer? I say, that may be a false alternative.
- alocasia-1 4y agoI was treating the dog as an analogy for us, or maybe for children - in environments that aren't particularly suited for us having good mental health, etc. And the giving the dog antidepressants as an analogy for a prescription. If it's a literal dog then yeah.
- reality_inspctr 4y agoso it goes: consciousness emerges from stardust in infinite permutations one class of mutation becomes homo sapiens and that class can have a bug in the code called depression other homo sapiens manufacture biology modifiers that fix those other experiments and that is good?
- goldenchrome 4y agoDepression is a feature not a bug. It’s like saying hunger is a bug.
- chayesfss 4y agoDon’t forget, they’re a simple way to make your spirit sleep, ask yourself who is it that really didn’t like you enough to suggest you get diagnosed?
- varispeed 4y agoAnother problem is that some drugs are artificially illegal to prescribe like medical cannabis. Doctors run out of options and prescribe anti-depressants off label for chronic pain rather than safer cannabis. I know someone suffering from chronic pain who tried to commit suicide multiple times after being on anti-depressants. Fortunately medical cannabis has been legalised and that person now thrives. Caveat is that here it is only available on private prescription and costs a fortune. I wonder what happens if that person gets made redundant and won't be able to afford it anymore.
- mschuster91 4y agoThe key problem is that even in 2023, we barely have an understanding how the human brain works. We know from trial and error that some stuff works pretty well, e.g. areas where the natural water supply is high in lithium have lower depression rates [1], herbs and plants with psychotropic effects (LSD, mushrooms, cannabis, ...) - but we barely know why these work or why some people with the same ethnic background, symptoms etc. respond completely different to the same amount and type of anti-depressant (or other mental health impacting) drugs. The reality for a lot of people with mental health issues is that they struggle for years until they finally manage to find something that works for them. And obviously it didn't help either that research on whole classes of drugs was pretty much outlawed and non-existing for the last decades "thanks" to the war on drugs. The time lost to that crap is seriously holding us back. [1] https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/32716281/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/32716281/
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- ftyers 4y agohttps://archive.ph/vmmFi https://archive.ph/vmmFi