9 ms·
A Lecturer Showed a Painting of the Prophet Muhammad. She Lost Her Job
- stonecharioteer 4y agoThey should have instead shown the audience Jesus and Mo [0] [0] - https://www.jesusandmo.net/ https://www.jesusandmo.net/
- noisy_boy 4y ago> So last semester for a global art history class, she took many precautions before showing a 14th-century painting of Islam’s founder. In the syllabus, she warned that images of holy figures, including the Prophet Muhammad and the Buddha, would be shown in the course. She asked students to contact her with any concerns, and she said no one did. In class, she prepped students, telling them that in a few minutes, the painting would be displayed, in case anyone wanted to leave. > After Dr. López Prater showed the image, a senior in the class complained to the administration. Other Muslim students, not in the course, supported the student, saying the class was an attack on their religion. They demanded that officials take action. Why is she complaining if she chose to stay in the class despite all the warnings? Islam doesn't allow much nudity either: --- [0]Tell the believing men to reduce [some] of their vision and guard their private parts. That is purer for them. Indeed, Allah is Acquainted with what they do. [1]And tell the believing women to lower their gaze and guard their chastity, and not to reveal their adornments1 except what normally appears.2 Let them draw their veils over their chests, and not reveal their ˹hidden˺ adornments3 except to their husbands, their fathers, their fathers-in-law, their sons, their stepsons, their brothers, their brothers’ sons or sisters’ sons, their fellow women, those ˹bondwomen˺ in their possession, male attendants with no desire, or children who are still unaware of women’s nakedness. --- I'm pretty sure art history is full of pictures of men and women in various state of nudity - should all that also be purged from the classroom? What is the standard to decide whether a painting can be shown? Or should the universities start allowing random art students from various religions to make decisions on whether The Dancing Girl[2] or Michelangelo's David[3] is fit to be displayed in the class? Observing Hindus worship cow but beef is routinely consumed in Europe/America. So in accordance with their beliefs, they don't consume beef. Strict observers do not even go to places that serve beef (as is their right). What they don't do is complain to McDonald's that they are offended by other people consuming beef (and even if they did, I'm pretty sure the answer won't be to ban beef in McDonald's). > At the Dec. 8 forum, which was attended by several dozen students, faculty and administrators, Ms. Wedatalla described, often through tears, how she felt seeing the image.“Who do I call at 8 a.m.,” she asked, when “you see someone disrespecting and offending your religion?” What you do is, you question whether what happened was non-malicious, whether there was legitimate reason behind it and whether the offended person had the chance to avoid the experience altogether. In this scenario the answer to all those questions is, yes. > The lecture was so disturbing, she said, that she could no longer see herself in that course. Absolutely correct thinking and beneficial to all parties because clearly she doesn't have the mindset necessary for an art history class. [0]: https://quran.com/24?startingVerse=30 https://quran.com/24?startingVerse=30 [1]: https://quran.com/24?startingVerse=31 https://quran.com/24?startingVerse=31 [2]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dancing_Girl_(sculpture) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dancing_Girl_(sculpture) [3]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/David_(Michelangelo) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/David_(Michelangelo)
- bitlax 4y agohttps://archive.ph/SVhFH https://archive.ph/SVhFH
- fancybouncy 4y ago[flagged]
- morby 4y agoIslam isn’t a country. It’s an ideology that can be practiced by anyone.
- NicoJuicy 4y agoWe have separation of religion for a lot of things. Schools should be too ( only partial now)
- morby 4y agoThis isn’t about separating religion from school. It’s about having sensitivities for peoples way of life. There are a lot of things you wouldn’t be able to get away with outside of depicting Muhammad in art. And none of them related to Muslims.
- mruniverse 4y agoHow sensitive are Muslims to other peoples way of life?
- DoctorOW 4y agoIt depends from person to person. Anyone I've met who is Muslim seem incredibly tolerant to me.
- mruniverse 4y agoTolerant enough to support an art history professor who showed an image depicting Muhammad?
- morby 4y ago
- benj111 4y agoIsn't it prohibited to depict any of god's creations in some/many/all Islamic sects? Thus all the interesting geometric patterns. Does that mean that virtually all Western art is islamaphobic? At what point does the demand that Western art doesn't do something that offend Islam itself become westernphobic.
- thaumasiotes 4y ago> At what point does the demand that Western art doesn't do something that offend Islam itself become westernphobic. The standard response is that there can be no such thing as Westernphobia because the West is powerful and Islam is weak, just as there can be no such thing as anti-white racism because whites are powerful and nonwhites are weak.
- benj111 4y agoYes and I take issue with that, $phobia isn't wrong just because of the power imbalance. Further these aren't monolithic entities, the power distributed between people is unequal. I've been denied a job because they were looking for a manageress (by a woman), who has the power in that situation? If you want me to treat you equally, you need to hold us both as equals, anything less is hypocrisy.
- fancybouncy 4y agotell that to white people in Kenya or South Africa... I don't have the link handy right now, but I read they are routinely in danger of rape/murder because of anti-white hate.
- lakomen 4y agoThus apparently extends to gender or rather sexuality as well recently. I've been banned for asking why my sexuality - heterosexual, is excluded, actually not even asked why but if a flag representing my sexuality existed, since there were a bunch of flags that represented every possible spectrum, even asexuality. I am not at all racist, my best friend has dark skin, but I also can't help but notice that on social networks there's always that black* group/tag/community never do you see white,red, yellow, only ever black. I do find that quite racist and exclusive. If we're all the same, why does such distinction exist?
- tyho 4y agoIn Europe she would be likely be dead or in protective custody. https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-10655679/Teacher-30-hiding-fleeing-showing-pupils-cartoon-Prophet-Mohammed.html https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-10655679/Teacher-30... https://www.france24.com/en/france/20211015-the-violence-shook-me-profoundly-teachers-students-remember-samuel-paty-s-murder https://www.france24.com/en/france/20211015-the-violence-sho...
- thuridas 4y agoThe response from a caricature vs a respectful historical depiction may be very different. Remember that in US this happened not a long time ago: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stabbing_of_Salman_Rushdie https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stabbing_of_Salman_Rushdie
- joenot443 4y agoIt's incredibly sad seeing Shia extremism making its way to North America. This was only a few months ago too. What's even scarier about this case was that the Iranian government issued a fatwa on the victim in 1989, and then Iranian state media celebrated the attack 30 years later.
- rippercushions 4y agoOddly enough, Shias are much more tolerant of depictions of Muhammed, it's the hardline Sunni who really have a problem with it. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Depictions_of_Muhammad#Contemporary_Iran https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Depictions_of_Muhammad#Conte...
- toxik 4y ago[flagged]
- viraptor 4y agoThis contradicts the more nuanced explanation from the article. Did you mean to disagree with it?
- kspacewalk2 4y agoThe painting in question: https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/2/20/Mohammed_receiving_revelation_from_the_angel_Gabriel.jpg https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/2/20/Mohammed...
- dekhn 4y agoIt's a gorgeous piece of art and I am truly surprised that even the faithful would see this as blasphemous. Islamic art is really underappreciated in the west.
- atlintots 4y agoThat's definitely not Islamic art, though. Islamic art quite notably does not depict humans or animals, and instead combines calligraphy and geometric patterns (and floral, maybe? I'm not entirely sure). You should definitely check that out too, though, it's beautiful! As for this art piece, I think it would certainly cause some controversy. I'm a Muslim myself, and afaik depictions of living beings are discouraged, and depictions of the Prophet (PBUH) are a no-no (though perhaps I should mention that I do believe firing that teacher was absolutely the wrong decision, and what she did was not at all an instance of Islamophobia).
- tptacek 4y agoSunni Islamic art doesn't depict humans or animals, but my understanding is that's actually not a universal characteristic of Islam. You'd know better than I do, but Ken White (who is not a Muslim) pretty stridently takes the university to task for universalizing the anti-art stance to all of Islam, as opposed to the specific sects involved. Is he wrong?
- atlintots 4y agoNo, he's not wrong. It's definitely not a universal stance. My own belief (based on my sect) is that the depictions that the Prophet (PBUH) banned were done so to discourage idolatry among muslims (much more relevant at that time than now). Beyond that, there is little to suggest that Islam explicitly forbids art depicting humans. In the case of prophets though, I think it is discouraged (by muslims) largely to prevent misattributing features or misrepresenting them (and of course, mockery as well). I should add, there is probably a bit of miscommunication when people use the term "Islamic art". Some may mean art that does not violate Islamic principles (whatever those may be to them), others may take it to refer specifically to the typical aniconistic style of art that has now become synonymous with "Islamic art" (at least that's what I, admittedly, thought of in my previous comment), or perhaps art originating from muslim territories / made by muslims, etc.
- hericium 4y ago[flagged]
- dec0dedab0de 4y agoIf south park gets censored for it, then what chance does anyone else have?
- hutzlibu 4y agoThat's a reference to South Parks great 200/201 episode, which are all about that topic and in which Kyles speech at the end got censored. Despite there is no single frame, where Muhammad is shown. But the speech probably contained too much uncomfortable truth : https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8TMHIYDHMSE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8TMHIYDHMSE "If there's anything we have learned, is that terrorizing works" "If you don't want people to make fun of you anymore, all you need are guns and bombs"
- raverbashing 4y agoProselitizing to religions (and I'm not talking about only one) is one of our moral failures of this past years
- rdxm 4y ago[dead]
- umarniz 4y agoEdit as this is flagged by many people already: My opinion is all art and historical text should be discussed and talked about. Apparently an attempt to share the context is not very appreciated here. No horse in the race but I find it important to try to understand the perspective from all sides. Apparently its similar to showing a swastika or hail hitler. People have been punished for that as well: https://www.thefire.org/cases/george-washington-university-jewish-student-suspended-displaying-souvenir-indian-swastika https://www.thefire.org/cases/george-washington-university-j...
- Y_Y 4y agoAt least that swastika thing was on a bulletin board in a dorm, I think it would be much harder to object to one being shown in context in a history class, for example.
- wazoox 4y agoThis is classical Persian Muslim art they're complaining about. Not Charlie Hebdo caricatures... Figure that, then weep.
- sgjohnson 4y agoSo we shouldn’t be showing swastikas or Hitler in a history class, for they might offend someone?
- bonbonbonj 4y agoOr on anti-Nazi media like the Wolfenstein series of computer games. For Wolfenstein 3D at least, Germany made them replace all the swastikas with neutral imagery before the game could be released there.
- sgjohnson 4y ago> For Wolfenstein 3D at least Not just Wolfenstein 3D, the same thing happened even with the Wolfenstein: The New Order and Wolfenstein: The New Colossus But that law was retarded and they recently repealed it. It's now okay to depict fictional nazis and nazi iconography even in Germany.
- bonbonbonj 4y agoPerhaps the bigger question is, should purportedly liberal institutions feel obliged to implement their own version of Islamic apostasy law, as is the case here?
- rg111 4y agoThat was my second thought here. This would not have caused problem in Malayasia, Maldives, Indonesia, Bahrain, among many other countries.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- janalsncm 4y ago> Dr. López Prater’s situation was especially precarious. She is an adjunct, one of higher education’s underclass of teachers, working for little pay and receiving few of the workplace protections enjoyed by tenured faculty members. I hope this bit doesn’t get lost in the conversation. Tenure seems to be extremely hard to get, even for very smart people who (in my opinion) fully deserved it.
- pnf 4y agoAbsent a radical retrenchment of reactionary-style teaching institutions, I don't see how "getting tenure" is a viable strategy going forward. The institutions have radically shifted their construction to be administration/student-centered rather than professor-centered. It may be that tenure as an institution could not survive the massive growth of the university system. Like any guild, membership growth must be limited. Tenure is a kind of life membership that simply cannot be conferred willy-nilly. Modern university economics simply will not support it. The trend is to disempower labor. Meanwhile, existing tenures are precious resources inspiring perverse behavior. In some ways, the tenure system has badly back-fired for professors, hastening their proletarianization (like doctors in the hospital system). It hasn't helped that most professors have been complicit in their own disenfranchisement, refusing to fight for their non-ideologically-aligned cohort, supporting the administrators in their anti-professor actions on behalf of student-customers. The whole thing is a mess but tenure is done. We may as well lament the loss of the guilds at this point. The barn is open, the cow is gone.
- ModernMech 4y ago> I don't see how "getting tenure" is a viable strategy going forward. It's not, which is why many schools are moving away from tenured faculty and more toward contract instructors. They're paid like regular faculty (not pennies like adjuncts) but aren't on a tenure track. 3-5 year contracts give better job security than a typical job, but not a guaranteed job for life.
- pnf 4y ago3-5 year contracts are maybe better than employment at will for faculty but they are of a kind with deleveraging the profession vis a vis the institution. The institutional character has shifted to big-E Education. Like big-H Health it is a rationalization of the industry that disempowers the "productive" professionals in favor of the "managerial" professionals (administrators) who manage the economic relationships (means of production/distribution) of the whole shebang. Maybe the death of tenure will augur a new age of unionization for faculty (I have my doubts).
- jonstewart 4y agoThis is as much about the relative lack of power held by adjuncts. It’s easy for a college to fire an adjunct, as there are so many more ready to grab the spot.
- wazoox 4y ago[flagged]
- morby 4y agoIt was one student complaining.
- wazoox 4y agoImagine the harm a group of those fanatics can achieve if one student can make a whole University comply to his intolerant whims. Karl Popper famously said that an open and tolerant society must manage carefully the intolerant... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paradox_of_tolerance https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paradox_of_tolerance
- morby 4y agoYou realize there are 2 million Muslims living in America without any problem right? Take your bigotry elsewhere, HN is typically more elevated than that.
- Multicomp 4y agoI read the GP comment more charitably than that in the context of the thread in general terms. More like "if one arbitrary student (of no particular description) can cause this much damage, how much damage can multiple like-minded students (of any particular alliance) cause?" And that question would apply to secularists Muslims Christians etc. equally. Not necessarily "if one Muslim can do this, how much damage can lots of Muslims do?" But maybe I'm wrong? I could see how you got that impression upon rereading the comment.
- wazoox 4y agoThat's not targeting Muslims, that's targeting fanatics of all ideologies.
- 4y ago
- wonderwonder 4y agoThis was the wrong decision. Liberal institutions in the west have begun to increasingly yield to the demands of extremist minority views and doing so only emboldens them. You are free to insult white people, Christianity, and non transexual heterosexual men in this country but everyone else is a protected class. Even speaking positively or respectfully discussing the protected classes in a vaguely defined wrong way spurs outrage and likely costs you your job. Its interesting watching institutions act outraged over Florida's "don't say gay" bill while instituting their own version of it that just targets everything else.
- jnovek 4y ago> This was the wrong decision. It seems like it. It seems like the university didn’t even clearly understand that Muslims are divided on this topic before taking action. > Liberal institutions in the west have begun to increasingly yield to the demands of extremist minority views and doing so only emboldens them. You are free to insult white people, Christianity, and non transexual heterosexual men in this country but everyone else is a protected class. This, however, is just straight up alt-right talking points.
- laserdancepony 4y ago> This, however, is just straight up alt-right talking points. I beg to differ, this is exactly my impression, too.
- wonderwonder 4y agoReally? If you speak ill of "white people, Christianity, and non transexual heterosexual men" will you lose your job? Will you lose your job in liberal universities if you speak ill of Jews, Muslims, homosexuals, African Americans? In case of perceived bias, I'm a swing voting (95% Dem) Jew.
- ModernMech 4y agoYes, depending on what you say, absolutely. If I stood in my classroom and made blanket disparaging statements about cis men or Christians or white people, I guarantee students in those groups would go to the admin and complain. If what I said was bad enough, I’d likely be fired.
- kergonath 4y agoThe fact that people describing themselves as progressive are fighting to forbid blasphemy has got to be the worst “freedom is slavery” newspeak in the last decade. When did it become acceptable for one sect to dictate what we are allowed to talk about? They are the enthusiastic useful idiots for dark age theocrats, the exact translation of our despicable white nationalists and Christian supremacists.
- bonbonbonj 4y agoThat is unfortunately a feature of modern-day progressivism. There are a number of other 'blasphemies' that it condemns (that are actually often censored on HN too, in the name of civility) as well. I miss the progressivism of old, where there was more of an emphasis on tolerance even when one disagrees.
- ModernMech 4y ago> That is unfortunately a feature of modern-day progressivism. You'll find this is a feature of all isms. Even the free speech absolutists ban the blasphemers when given the chance.
- draw_down 4y ago[dead]
- spacephysics 4y agoYeah the more I learn about history in my spare time, the more corollaries I see with medieval papal censorship and suppression of freedom of thought, and some movements today going in that direction. I yearn for the, looking back, somewhat balanced days where not everyone was head deep in politics, and we could have useful debates about maybe health care or national budget, without degenerating into blanket character attacks. Then after the debate, everyone is at least cordial. Just finished the first season of white lotus. Did not expect to see some good dichotomies of two generations interacting with one another (re: the scuba family)
- hairofadog 4y ago
- afroisalreadyin 4y agoIf Muslims are not OK with their religion and its figures being talked about in ways that are not within the rules of their religion, they shouldn't bring it up, and we should act as if it doesn't exist. You think your prophet was righteous? I don't care, I can't talk about him anyway, so it won't be part of my world of ideas. This has been my position on this topic since I got scolded by a Muslim for not referring to Islam's prophet with the obligatory "s.a.s."
- jdthedisciple 4y agoIf LGBTQ are not OK with their gender and the movement's figureheads being talked about in ways that are not within the rules of their safe spaces, they shouldn't be shoving it down everyone's throats constantly, and we should act as if they don't exist. You think being LGBTQ is important? I don't care, I can't talk about them anyway, so it won't be part of my world of ideas. This has been my position on this topic since I got scolded by some transgender person for not referring to them by their preferred pronouns.
- teppn 4y agoThis is unironically a very good point. The intolerance that many trans-rights activists show to those who don't accept that a man with a 'female gender identity' is a woman is similar to the intolerance that many followers of Islam show to non-believers. No-one on the gender critical side has been beheaded yet, but there is a surprisingly large "kill the terfs" movement that parallels the extremism of Islamists.
- gnull 4y agoThey aren't committing atrocities because they don't have the resources for that, not because they are ethical and chose not to. Weakness is not a virtue, we shouldn't give them credit for it.
- afroisalreadyin 4y agoWhat makes you come to the conclusion that they would "commit atrocities"? On the one hand there is constant and widespread violence perpetrated against the LGBTQ, on the other there are vague threats by a couple of anonymous accounts, and your conclusion is that "they aren't committing atrocities because they don't have the resources"? I find this comment really insensitive, to say the least.
- gnull 4y agoIs Islam at all compatible with secular values in the same country? In the end, you will have one of the two encompass the other. Either you have a secular country living by democratic, progressive law which allows people to be Muslims modulo this. Or you have a Muslim country living by Shariah law, but tolerating secular non-believers in it. First won't work because Muslims (in the traditional sense) won't tolerate some other framework encompassing their worldview. They have taboo topics nobody should ever question, and secular ideology based on science will question things. And second won't work because Shariah law gives very concrete directions on dealing with non-believers.
- morby 4y ago[flagged]
- laserdancepony 4y agoGodwin's law never seems to fail.
- morby 4y agoI find reactionary, conservative, and bigoted opinions come up more often that Hitler, but with obvious connections.
- pepperonipizza 4y agoI have notice your comments in this thread where you are making wild assumptions of the users commenting. Your reply here could fall under defamation.
- morby 4y agoPlease point out every comment I made in this thread and then point out which of those comments made “wild assumptions” and how they are “wild” based on the content of the comment being replied to. Also, defamation does not mean what you think it means.
- 4y ago
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- recuter 4y agoI swear I've seen this before in a musical. Edit: found it! https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pDx3vnvSbm8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pDx3vnvSbm8
- laxmin 4y agoUnfortunately, the world is such that losing a job is the least pain and torture. In India, a Lady, Nupur Sharma merely quote the Hadith about Mohammad's marriage to Aisha and she had to go underground. Many people lost their lives. The Islamists call for 'San Tan se Juda' - Separation of the Head from the Body. The Islamic world needs a renaissance.
- anthk 4y ago[flagged]
- noisy_boy 4y ago> In India, a Lady, Nupur Sharma merely quote the Hadith about Mohammad's marriage to Aisha and she had to go underground. This is not equivalent to the case in question (to be clear about my stand, I think the firing of the lecturer was completely wrong). However, there are few things to consider in Nupur Sharma case: 1. Nupur Sharma is not a random Lady, she was the spokesperson of the ruling party BJP. As part of the ruling party, she had the responsibility of acting as is appropriate for a national-level party member. More so as being the spokesperson, her views could be seen as the views of the party. See point #3 on why this is relevant. 2. Her comments were not part of some art history or philosophical discussion. By her own admittance, she couldn't accept the insulting of Hindu god Shiva and retaliated by making comments about prophet Mohammad. 3. Her comments were not made within the confines of a classroom where free academic discussion is paramount; she went on three national TV channels and basically tried to make the same comments deliberately knowing well that in a deeply religious country like India, such actions have far reaching consequences. My personal view is that one should be free to insult any god, Hindu or Muslim or any other religion; however, practicality demands that care should be exercised by members of political parties on such public platforms (if she was a Muslim leader who insulted a Hindu god, the point would still stand i.e. her behavior was irresponsible).
- boruto 4y agoI guess the focus of OP comment was the death threats she received, the beheading that followed of a tailor. But it seems your comment sort of justifies all that because nupur is a spokesperson of a party.
- cykros 4y agoJe suis Charlie.
- nmoadev 4y agoI don't think this belongs on Hacker News. It's an issue worth discussion, but it's an a category of general controversial news that gets plenty of discussion elsewhere. Also there is no technical, scientific, or engineering context to it.
- dang 4y agoHN threads don't need to be technical, scientific, or engineering. They just need to be intellectually interesting (https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html). Anything as prominent in humanity and history as religion is certainly that. However, flamewars destroy intellectual interest (put bluntly, they're predictable, nasty and dumb), and it's nearly impossible for a large community to discuss religion without religious flamewar (the most predictable, nastiest, and dumbest of all flamewar). That's unfortunately the other issue with stories like this, besides the run-of-the-mill controversy that you correctly point out.
- fancybouncy 4y agoi believe that flagging my comment was not an attempt to avoid flamewars, but plain censorship of a honest intellectual question that any society taking a stance, against or in favor of multiculturalism (that is, hosting non-integrated completely different cultures within its borders), must confront sooner of later when things like this lecturer's ordeal start happening. The article was a concrete instance of the abstract dilemma i posed in my comment, so it was on-topic and necessary imho.
- dang 4y agoYou can call it censorship if you want—people mostly use that word nowadays to express a feeling—but the moderation point is that you plainly broke HN's rules with https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34298516 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34298516, and doing that will get you banned here.
- fancybouncy 4y ago
- whatyesaid 4y agoNot sure why it's a fireable offence since precautions were taken. Give a strike or whatever and debate it's relevance to the course of "art history". I don't think the painting itself is significant, it could just be referenced. The context of why the painting is banned inside of Islam is relevant as previously there was a lot of idol worship and even nowadays figureheads like Jesus are now claimed to be God, stuff like "Jesus is Lord". But this moves more into theology than art history now. Reminds me a bit of Kanye being banned on the new free speech platform Twitter and people saying it wasn't an actual Swastika, it was an UFO cult symbol, it being tied to the older peace symbol of Hinduism etc.
- hutzlibu 4y ago"the context of why the painting is banned inside of Islam is relevant" How is that relevant to anyone not muslim? Because this is what this is about - (some) muslims wanting other people to follow their religious rules.
- whatyesaid 4y agoWell, when I said relevant or not relevant, significant or whatever, I mean in terms of the class "art history". It's not like any of the painting depictions had any notable art styles nor new techniques, from what I can tell. So I think it crosses moreso into the intersection of religion and art, that's why historical context becomes relevant. If you deem context irrelevant then why include any of it unless the art has some different quality about it? I think there was art novelty with the decorations of churches and mosques though.
- aorth 4y agoIt's crazy that this happened at all, let alone in an art history context. For the record, there are at least two academic sources attesting that the prohibition on depiction of the prophet Muhammad are recent. 1. Wijdan Ali's From the Literal to the Spiritual: The Development of the Prophet Muhammad's Portrayal from 13th Century Ilkhanid Miniatures to 17th Century Ottoman Art. 1999. Open Access, available here: https://webspace.science.uu.nl/~gent0113/islam/downloads/ejos_4_7.pdf https://webspace.science.uu.nl/~gent0113/islam/downloads/ejo... 2. Christiane Gruber's The Praiseworthy One: The Prophet Muhammad in Islamic Texts and Images. 2019. https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/37702531-the-praiseworthy-one https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/37702531-the-praiseworth...
- draw_down 4y ago[dead]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- nickdothutton 4y agoDifferent civilisations have different views, values, and “red lines” to borrow a term from elsewhere. Some of these may make the civilisations incompatible. How anyone is surprised by this I do not know.
- mruniverse 4y agoHere's what the professor had to say: “I am showing you this image for a reason. And that is that there is this common thinking that Islam completely forbids, outright, any figurative depictions or any depictions of holy personages. While many Islamic cultures do strongly frown on this practice, I would like to remind you there is no one, monothetic Islamic culture,” https://hamlineoracle.com/10750/news/who-belongs/ https://hamlineoracle.com/10750/news/who-belongs/
- NickC25 4y agoI really don't like pandering to the religious beliefs of a minority, especially when said group was given tons of precautions from the professor. The student in question still made the choice to show up to class, made the choice to complain, and made the choice to cry in front of other students saying that she felt deeply offended. The girl was given every chance to avoid this altogether, but instead chose to put herself in the situation so she could be the victim. I feel absolutely terrible for the professor, they did absolutely nothing wrong. I took an religious art history class in college too...and yeah, we had Muslims in the class. One of them just didn't show up that day, and others just continued on as if it was just another piece of art. No complains, no grandstanding. Just mature people with the mindset of "I'm not in any position to complain, I'm not special, the professor isn't targeting me, nor anyone else. My religious beliefs are not and will never be part of the law system here and I don't expect them to be." That's it. We are a secular country. We have separation of religious institutions from our government (in theory). If someone of any faith wants to whine about being offended because of a picture they saw at school, they need to grow the fuck up.
- prox 4y agoEven if it was a religious majority it should stand. She was trying give an example of art history , how it was. The fact that some believe it is outlawed in their beliefsystem (which is a result of the Wahhabism movement as I understand it) is exactly the point of learning and knowing the context of which an image was made in. It’s indeed a form of maturity. Or learning or aspiring to be exposed to other viewpoints and ways of seeing.
- pvaldes 4y ago> The girl was given every chance to avoid this altogether, but instead chose to put herself in the situation so she could be the victim. The problem is that this doesn't matter. In the case of the beheaded french teacher the girl just lied about being in that class (he was not her teacher, and she didn't even come to school that day) and tell everybody later that she was forced to see pictures of the prophet naked. I wonder where is she now.
- pvaldes 4y agoI wonder. Why are this classes still opened to muslim students? Seriously. Why?. What's the point of all this drama? Teachers risk entire careers. Risk decades of hard study and even their lives, to show students concepts like free speech and different points of view. Students don't seem to appreciate the effort. Each single time, somebody will feel justified to use this situation to feel outraged and punish the teacher. Their families will use it politically and ask for public lynching. Is always the same history. Wouldn't be more wise for the university to apply a self-defence stance and made muslim students to pick a different class. Period. No exceptions? Save yourself all the bullying, and the undesirable publicity. Why to be forced to burn valuable human resources in a war that is not your war?. Why universities still accept the role of the dummy punching bag in this history? They should know better. Wouldn't be better also for muslim students not to force them to choose between the university and their families?
- ModernMech 4y ago> I wonder. Why are this classes still opened to muslim students? Because this is an exaggeration: > Students don't seem to appreciate the effort. Each single time, somebody will feel justified to use this situation to feel outraged and punish the teacher. I don't know what causes you to feel this way, but it's just not true. That some students cause outrage at one small school, that doesn't mean students or Muslims writ large feel the same, or that "every single time" Muhammad is depicted something like this happens. Frankly it seems like the opposite it true; the last time this was controversy in the news that I can remember were the terrorist attacks a decade ago. If it's true that Muslim students will use this to punish teachers and feel outraged, why doesn't it happen more often? Really all that seems to be happening here is that a student got more upset than they should have, the school overreacted more than they should have, and now the anti-woke internet mobs (because the reactionaries are just as bad as the activists at this point) are overacting as well.
- pvaldes 4y ago> Because this is an exaggeration Not. Is a risk, and risks should be addressed. > the last time this was controversy in the news that I can remember were the terrorist attacks a decade ago 2020: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Murder_of_Samuel_Paty https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Murder_of_Samuel_Paty Universities and schools should meet over a common protocol for damage control and stop the problem for good. This lectures are like throwing blood in a shark pool; any extremist in a radius of a thousand miles around will be invoked in holy duty mode to "save the students souls". And the risk/benefits ratio is just mew. Is a losing situation for everybody.
- penguin_booze 4y agoNot long ago in the UK: https://www.thesun.co.uk/news/14462046/school-teacher-prophet-mohammed-cartoons-shut-angry-protest/ https://www.thesun.co.uk/news/14462046/school-teacher-prophe.... Separately but on the same theme, there was an outrage against sex education in schools, because Muslims were offended, saying it was against their way of life. The irony was that the protest was lead by a dude who didn't even have children.
- locococo 4y agoSomeone showed a picture in an educational context with no intent of harming but to educate and lost their job because of it. People seem to be losing all sense of being reasonable in their response to things they or someone else find "offensive". The fake outrage is really disgusting back to the dark ages.
- yodsanklai 4y agoCould the lecturer sue the school? this doesn't seem like a legitimate reason to fire someone.
- Gnob 4y agoHi, a "fundamentalist Muslim" here, bite me Why is it so hard to accept that some people have redlines, once violated you leave no place for respect anymore? Is it a hard concept or is it entitlement that makes you feel you have the upper moral ground? What do you all think about the UN forcing LGBTQ+ rights on Muslims in their own countries? Do you consider that "freedoms" too? or is it proxy colonization? I wonder. My heart goes for this teacher I am sure if someone depicted her or anyone, she cares about in a derogatory manner she'd be so happy and grateful and quite tolerant, she'd joke about it I guess especially if the picture was shown to a wide audience. I'd have loved to see people making derogatory cartoons of someone she loves and sharing them on the internet and seeing how much of a tolerant and freedom advocate she is. Must be so hard for the atheists to understand that we care about our prophet and to stop mocking him and just be decent people. You have to mock religious people or otherwise you're not the cool kid I guess, because disbelieving gives you extra brain points, who gives them? nvm, they just pop up out of nowhere.
- ikt 4y agoWhy do you consider a painting of someone which is not mocking them to be mocking them?
- Gnob 4y agoBecause she knew it's prohibited and it's not what we do and everyone seems to be taking their free speech dig at our prophet and I would assume this is no different, because there is literally no reason to bring that image. However, I think they should have left the class and contacted her regarding this subject and firing her probably was an overkill and done to make the problem go away, though not sure why the student complained to the administration before contacting her despite her giving warnings to the students.
- pvaldes 4y ago> Because she knew it's prohibited Not it isn't. Teaching art is totally legal in Minnesota.
- 4y ago
- dang 4y agoRecent and related: College that fired prof for showing image of Muhammad could lose accreditation - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34293131 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34293131 - Jan 2023 (85 comments)
- tptacek 4y agoKen White did a pretty useful breakdown on this whole story: https://popehat.substack.com/p/hamline-university-and-cancel-culture https://popehat.substack.com/p/hamline-university-and-cancel...