19 ms·
Rising rent, not poverty, is the real driver of homelessness
- zzz345345 4y ago[flagged]
- selectodude 4y agoI get it. I know a lot of people who cover their rent but losing their jobs would be an immediate severe issue. Housing insecurity is really scary.
- jimbob45 4y agoThe real issue is that apartment managers can come after you for the remainder of your lease. You can suddenly be in 10-20k of debt if you need to break your lease early. That's both more accessible and worse than many medical debt horror stories.
- t-writescode 4y agoEven without that, you're still easily $2k in the hole and that all on its own is scary - the long-term repercussions of "evil by bureaucracy" are, of course, even worse; but the very beginning is plenty terrible, enough that there doesn't need to be a "real issue" here for it to be bad.
- twblalock 4y agoIf you signed an agreement to pay a certain amount, for a certain number of months, and then you don't do it, the counterparty should be able to come after you. I understand that some of the people who break leases are experiencing hardship, but others are just breaking their leases because they can -- and a lot more people would do that if it was easier. That would put landlords on the defensive and result in more restrictive lease agreements and/or higher rents to reduce the risk, which would ultimately make things worse for all the renters who really do intend to honor their agreements to the best of their ability. Also, in many places, landlords are legally obligated to make a good-faith attempt to find replacement tenants before they sue lease-breakers for the remaining rent.
- deathanatos 4y agoThere's "covering risk", and there's tenant lock-in. I have no problem with requiring a tenant to rent for a year, to prevent quick turnover and the risk and costs associated with that. But multiple landlords now have all had the same policy: the lease will never go month-to-month, basically. You can, but e.g., for my current lease, it costs ~60% more to go month to month. This creates bizarre pay-off points, and greatly raises the costs of trying to move. When it's "+$2k/mo to go month-to-month", that's not risk-reduction, that's just greed, trying to make sure I can't move. IME, it used to be that after you rented for a while (e.g., a year), the lease went month-to-month. You were a long-term stable renter, and you'd paid enough rent at that point to cover the overheads of finding a new tenant and making the necessary touch-ups to the apartment. (Beyond what was covered by security deposit.) (I recently had this conversation with my parents recently. The previous generation has no idea about some of the provisions that renters of my generation are having to put up with.) An average price of $18,000 to break lease on a 3+ year old lease is absurd. We need more housing, to drive competition in the rental & housing markets. If I ever get to buy a house (… if my landlord doesn't first capture any gains I might get…) the first thing I'll have to do is not get to live in it: the most logical course of action would be to rent it short term, until I can get out of my own lease.
- twblalock 4y agoI was renting until just a few years ago and I never had a lease longer than 12 months, and it was actually difficult to find one longer than that. I'm not sure where you live, but in a lot of places, a landlord refusing to allow a lease to go month-to-month is illegal.
- dinosaurdynasty 4y agoMaking month-to-month 60% more expensive is effectively refusing to allow it to go month-to-month
- SoftTalker 4y agoYes it probably varies by location. And if housing supply were more plentiful then landlords could compete on more flexible lease terms as well as actual monthly rent. When housing is scarce they can demand whatever price and terms they want. When I've lived in areas where housing was not scarce, it was reasonably easy to find apartments that would do month-to-month leases right from the start.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- thamer 4y agoThe current link points to the website of a radio station that only posted a brief summary of a much longer article from The Atlantic. Maybe the URL in this post should be changed to the original? https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2023/01/homelessness-affordable-housing-crisis-democrats-causes/672224/ https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2023/01/homeles... edit: actually the original link already has a submission on HN: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33961543 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33961543
- nickradford 4y agoTwo sides of the same coin really
- t-writescode 4y ago"It's not that we don't pay people enough, it's that living costs too much"
- TSiege 4y agoNot exactly since the largest cause of housing insecurity is the fact that there simply isn't enough homes (at least where we need them). Paying everyone more wouldn't solve that issue, it'd just make rents rise further
- atdrummond 4y agoI’ve lived on the streets and worked with homeless charities for years and years. I am extremely skeptical this is case and for those whom it is true, I expect them to fall into the class of “transient homeless” who experience it for a short period.
- droopyEyelids 4y agoTransient homeless (those who have fallen upon hard times, and may still have a job, but no longer have a place for their family to live) make up around 80% of the homeless population. Solving that would be a huge win for society.
- andrewla 4y agoSure, but not really the policy outcome that people are thinking of when they talk about solving the "homeless problem". The guy passed on in the subway car next to his own feces is not going to be helped in any way by these policies. There are no good solutions here that respect the rights of the individual and also our collective right to live in a civil society. Involuntarily detention through the criminal justice system (horrifying) or the mental health system (completely dehumanizing) are the best tools we have, other than having compassionate people who will devote time and effort and individual attention to the victims of mental health or pathological substance abuse problems.
- cjwilliams 4y agoNo reason why mental institutions cant be compassionate and devote time and effort to individuals. Much better than letting these people live in their own excrement in the subway.
- andrewla 4y agoWell, maybe "no reason" is a bit strong. Organizations cannot be engineered to be compassionate; compassionate individuals can make an organization more compassionate, but the bottleneck will always be finding people who are compassionate, have subject matter expertise, and are willing to work for the wages offered. And even with compassion there are still problematic situations. Involuntary confinement of any sort requires a careful application of principles -- when is it okay to confine someone; when and how do you decide when they can or must be released; who can make the judgment calls and what checks are in place to prevent abuse. These are questions that seem to have no good answers.
- TSiege 4y agoBefore the pandemic this problem really seemed intractable for a lot of metro areas, but now with WFH taking hold we've been given a potential life raft if we jump on it. Office space cannot get converted into homes overnight. There's a lot of remodeling and rethinking of how to fit an apartment into one, but it's a chance nonetheless. The biggest burden is likely to be the cause of the problem in the first place, zoning. Hopefully we learn from the past and correct this while we can
- SketchySeaBeast 4y agoFor some reason I doubt that developers will be looking to convert that office space into affordable housing.
- anonuser123456 4y agoWhy? They don’t like money?
- jrockway 4y agoWhat is the path to profitability you see? They pretty much have to gut rehab the building to add kitchens and bathrooms, in an economy where loans are pretty expensive. Is that competitive with people selling existing move-in ready housing stock in a down market? Do you want to be the first person to sign a contract in one of these conversions? (Not to mention the usual "new construction" taxes that are seller-paid on existing housing, but buyer-paid on new construction.) I think everyone is incentivized to sit on what they have now and offer cheap leases. I also think that cities are incentivized to bring workers back to the office. Like in NYC, we spent billions of dollars on a new commuter railroad terminal that opens this year, and upgrades to run more trains per hour during rush hour. I don't think the state is going to step in and offer free money to make more housing. All in all I love the idea of converting offices to housing. Working from home is great, and affording your own home is even better. But, I don't think the economy wants either of them :/
- 4y ago
- jankyxenon 4y agoIs street homelessness really driven by people who couldn't pay their rent? You would think they'd stay away from drug-addled violent tent cities - and sleep in a car or at a friend's house. Too many ideas seem to be conflated with the umbrella term "homeless"
- jrockway 4y agoI see where you're coming from, but if you go to the extreme and anyone could have a private room for $1 a month, would anyone be living on the streets?
- jankyxenon 4y agoAbsolutely yes they would. I know someone in my extended family on the streets - his problem is addiction. Lot's of people are willing to offer a roof. I know that's anecdata - but you asked about the extreme case.
- jrockway 4y agoIs it because buildings refuse to house people with addiction problems, or that the extra $1/month is better used in their mind to get the next dose of the substance?
- jankyxenon 4y agoThe roof typically comes with the stipulation of no drugs (or even rehab). That’s untenable to the addict.
- fnimick 4y agoThe roof also comes with a loss of any sense of personal autonomy and the threat of violence from other people in the shelter. There's a reason people treat them as a last resort, and it's not drugs. It's that being in a shelter opens you up to abuse.
- jlmorton 4y agoImagine you're a municipality like San Francisco. You control all of the zoning regulations, and many of the permitting requirements. You have a AA+ credit rating, and even in today's higher rate environment, you can borrow billions of dollars at 6%. You already own oodles of land. You can build to whatever height you want within reason, because you control the zoning, and you even control many of the ordinances that allow citizens to block development (though certainly not all, like CEQA and NEPA). So you have lots of lands to build on, and what you build is largely in your control. Construction costs in San Francisco are sky-high, at $440 sq ft. But people will happily pay you $40/sq foot per year for housing, probably for 75 years. How is this not the easiest decision in the world? Create a housing development agency, become a permanent developer, and landlord. Never stop building. Put proper incentives in place, so that employees at the agency can partake in the profits, incentivizing them to be efficient. Never stop doing this. You might not be great at this at first, but fifty years later you will be.
- samman 4y agoAnother factor to consider is that there may also be significant infrastructure upgrades required to support the increase in population, and costs might increase dramatically when you consider increased water usage in an already drought stricken region.
- Tiktaalik 4y ago> How is this not the easiest decision in the world? Unfortunately wealthy established homeowners don't want more people to near to them so they vote against any and all change. Welp! This is why higher orders of government need to step in to "force" municipalities to enact some of these sorts of policy changes you describe. This gives the local municipalities cover to enact the good policies that the selfish rich would kill at the ballot box.
- orangecat 4y agoUnfortunately wealthy established homeowners don't want more people to near to them so they vote against any and all change. Yes, combined with useful idiot "anti-gentrification" activists who have convinced themselves that the concept of supply and demand is a capitalist myth.
- e_commerce 4y ago[dead]
- exabrial 4y agoNo it is not. Raising rent is a correlated effect, not a causation. All cases of homelessness are highly individualized. They usually follow a pattern such as this: 1. The setup: Some sort of condition or pattern of life choices that isn't intrinsically harmful, but combined with other things, will become overwhelming once the bottom drops out. The lack of community and isolation from a support network are key indicators that a person is at risk. 2. An Event: divorce, disease, severe mental illness, tragedy, etc that causes their steady state to change significantly. 3. An Aftermath: Poor coping mechanisms such as hard drug usage, alcoholism, and other short sighted choices, combined with the inability to bounce back from things in step 1, lead to the bottom falling out. With no support network, the individual falls out of normal society and ends up on the street. Addictions can develop and the person becomes trapped. ^ These three things aren't mine, It's something a social worker pointed out to me.
- jeffbee 4y agoThis theory is wrong and it is easy to see why. Rates of homelessness are not correlated with "life choices" or "events" at all. Mental illness rates don't vary much geographically and they don't correlate with homelessness. Same with drug abuse and disease. However housing costs are very strongly correlated with homelessness. Great book on the subject: https://homelessnesshousingproblem.com/ https://homelessnesshousingproblem.com/ Edit: prospective reply guys need to explain why W. Virginia, the place with by far the biggest drug abuse problem, also has the least homelessness.
- anm89 4y ago> Rates of homelessness are not correlated with "life choices" What could this possibly even mean? Someone roles a dice and then somebody materializes on the side of the road with a tent and a shopping cart and a fentanyl addiction? This person just existed in a choiceless state up until the exact moment where the gained agency and simultaneously became homeless?
- janalsncm 4y agoIt means that poor choices and addiction can’t explain why San Francisco has so much higher homelessness than other places like West Virginia, which has much higher addiction rates.
- exolymph 4y agoThe non-visible homeless (people down on their luck, to an approximation) get mentally sorted into the vast category of "that's unfortunate but it doesn't affect me directly," which might influence people's votes or charitable donations, but doesn't arouse much passion for most of us. By contrast, the visible homeless are a visceral inconvenience, even a danger, so people feel strongly about how that problem is addressed. As a smallish woman, I am on high alert in certain areas of San Francisco, Oakland, etc. I'm not all that likely to be accosted, but if I ever am, it will be a big deal, so navigating those places is nerve-wracking because my threat-detection is constantly dialed up. I would compare it to, like, road planning versus traffic enforcement. The former has far-reaching, long-term impact (like housing policy) but the latter is what gets people heated, due to the immediate impact in their day-to-day lives. --- Full disclosure, reposting a comment from a similar thread: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33961731 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33961731
- themitigating 4y ago"visceral inconvenience" The problem with the homeless isn't how it offends your senses. "I'm not all that likely to be accosted, but if I ever am, it will be a big deal, so navigating those places is nerve-wracking because my threat-detection is constantly dialed up." Have you ever thought that being this worried about threats is something you're partially responsible for?
- novok 4y agoAre you a large tall white man by any chance?
- themitigating 4y agoI'm a white man but I don't see how that matters. If I was Black would be more likely to be assaulted for some reason? Do homeless people avoid assaulting white people? I get that you implying that I would feel safer because I'm less likely to be sexually assaulted and that I have a greater chance to defend myself. However, that doesn't prevent me from criticizing other's feelings. It's like a someone who is racist saying "well you don't live with them so you don't understand"
- joh6nn 4y agoIf rents rise to a level that you can't find a home, aren't you by definition impoverished? Is there some aspect of this distinction that I'm not grasping?
- jeffbee 4y agoBut the other thing is not necessarily true. Lots of places have high poverty and little homelessness.
- toofy 4y agoi’m confident that someday in the future we’ll look back at our insistence on profiting off housing as a huge miscalculation.
- janalsncm 4y agoIt should be seen as a blight on leadership, a catastrophic failure of the free market due to seeing homes as a commodity rather than a necessity.
- slibhb 4y agoWhen people talk about "homelessness," they're often referring to street people. Most technically homeless people aren't street people, they're between jobs or living in their car or something like that. It seems clear that lower rent/housing prices would help with homelessness but I don't think it would help street people.
- germinalphrase 4y agoTo further your point, the U of Chicago recently released a report that around 50 percent of homeless individuals are employed.
- mindover 4y agoIn the US or in Chicago? I doubt 50% of homeless people in CA are employed… but I could be wrong.
- gremlinsinc 4y agoI think if we could just help the out of sorts, hardship cases that are 'newer' homeless, or maybe classified as 'under-housed', which may include couch-surfers, car/van-lifers, etc. I mean there's levels to homelessness some of which is mental health related and such, some people actually maybe could prefer that life for reasons. There's a lot who are forced into it, and are just down on their luck. These should be a much easier subsection to target for at least fixing things a bit.
- throwaway742 4y agoIt doesn't help that we are basically doing the opposite. In my experience you pretty much have to already be homeless to get any help. It would be nice if you didn't have to lose everything before you get assistance.
- paxys 4y agoHow long do these temporary displaced people stay in that state before eventually becoming "street people" themselves?
- robotnikman 4y agoThe scariest part imho is the huge housing and apartment owning conglomerates, not the small guy who happens to be renting out a house. Its the large housing corporations which don't care about difficulties paying rent, and unlike the small guy they have an army of lawyers ready to crush anyone in their way. They also have the money and power to influence local politics in a way that favors them.
- readthenotes1 4y agoNeeds a [in overpriced cities] tag, like [in mice]
- nickpinkston 4y agoThere's also a good argument that rent/housing affects more of our broader lives than anything else - often called "The Housing Theory of Everything". https://www.worksinprogress.co/issue/the-housing-theory-of-everything/ https://www.worksinprogress.co/issue/the-housing-theory-of-e... If you're interested in helping the housing problem across the US, I encourage you to check out: YIMBY Action who does local activism across the US, and particularly active in SF Bay Area and CA. https://yimbyaction.org/ https://yimbyaction.org/ Full disclosure, I'm on the board, but I joined because the ROI / growth are both crazy. We have a tiny budget / staff but have a huge impact on the discourse, passing various laws and pushing cities to follow the law to approve housing. We're now at an inflection point and need to scale our model out.
- HDThoreaun 4y agoLVT now. Truly the solution to all our economic problems.
- nickpinkston 4y agoIf only! If you like LVT, you'll love this Twitter account haha: https://twitter.com/yhdistyminen https://twitter.com/yhdistyminen
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- dsfyu404ed 4y agoIf it was that simple someone would have done it recently. LVT would cure places like SF where there's huge land values and pent up demand, sure. But it also creates a huge incentive to block development on a town level to keep taxes low.
- HDThoreaun 4y agoYes, LVT needs to implemented along with Japan style national zoning to halt the progress of nimbys. It’s certainly not easy, but that’s because of politics, not the economic reality.
- whiddershins 4y agoI don't understand this thesis. In terms of visible homelessness a huge percentage are untreated mentally ill and/or drug addicted to such an extent that they won't be able to afford housing at any price level. The article offers no data to support the claim, just some anecdotal observations.
- janalsncm 4y agoCities like Milwaukee have very low homelessness. Is it because the people there are just less mentally ill? Less prone to drug addiction? Of course not. (In fact in a state with cold, dark winters and where there is a bar on every corner, you’d expect the opposite.) No, it’s because of the low cost of housing and because of their Housing First initiative. Housing First works and it’s only because of a lack of political will that it’s not being used in more places.
- ejb999 4y agoIts also possible that it is very hard to be truly homeless in the winter in many places in the USA, and being someplace warm year-round, makes being homeless easier. Just like being someplace that is less likely to arrest you for openly doing drugs in public. If you make it easy to do drugs without consequences, easy to live on the streets year round, you are pretty much guaranteed of getting more of those things. I live someplace where it routinely gets well below 0F in the winter, for weeks on end - if you live someplace like that, you do your best to make different life choices if you do not have a death wish.
- shanty 4y agoYou're neglecting to address enforcement issues such as Criminal Vagrancy which is strictly enforced in some locales and lax in others.
- andrewla 4y agoThe homeless debate, especially around housing, has become a nightmare of semantic creep and rising metricism [1]. Metricism is the tendency to focus on measurable things; in principle a noble goal, but more often than not you can't actually measure the thing you're interested in, so you measure something similar and then pretend you're measuring the thing you want, and when you're done, you've implemented solutions which reduce your metric but have no effect on the underlying problem. What is the problem of "homelessness"? Is it transient homelessness, where people, through a run of bad luck or circumstance, find themselves unable to afford housing, but otherwise are functional in society? Or is the problem the much more visible problem of mentally ill and otherwise unstable individuals wandering the streets and pushing kids on to subway tracks? The latter is the homeless problem that people care about (I mean, we are human, we care about both, but if I had to choose which one I'd rather fix, as a New Yorker, the latter takes priority). Fixing this problem, though, is incredibly hard -- there's the intersection of human rights, involuntary confinement, and the otherwise incredible complexity of managing mental health in a free society. But this is SOOOOOOO hard to measure! It's much easier to just measure the people who are "unhoused", pretend you're solving the "homeless problem", and show that you can make the numbers go down. The problem being solved by increasing housing and lowering rents is not the problem of people walking down the subway screaming about electricity and knocking cell phones out of people's hands -- he is more than a couple of rent payments away from being okay. [1] metricism is my own neologism; closest analogy is James C. Scott's "legibility" or Goodhart's "observed statistical regularity" or even the drunk "looking for the keys where the light is good" but I'm more specifically concerned about fetishizing around metrics specifically.
- dudeinjapan 4y agoIt's far easier to point at imaginary causes for imaginary problems than it is to talk about the real causes of real problems.
- johnpublic 4y agoA friend of mine who recently moved to the US from the UK put it to me like this: "imagine one state says they will pay out benefits without a permanent address. Where do you think the homeless are going to move to?"
- shoo 4y agoThe "The Obvious Answer to Homelessness" by Jerusalem Demsas, published by The Atlantic (linked in another comment by thamer) argues that this hypothesis is falsified, and can cite research: > Few Republican-dominated states have had to deal with severe homelessness crises, mainly because superstar cities are concentrated in Democratic states. Some blame profligate welfare programs for blue-city homelessness, claiming that people are moving from other states to take advantage of coastal largesse. But the available evidence points in the opposite direction—in 2022, just 4 percent of homeless people in San Francisco reported having become homeless outside of California. Gregg Colburn and Clayton Aldern found essentially no relationship between places with more generous welfare programs and rates of homelessness. And abundant other research indicates that social-welfare programs reduce homelessness.
- cjwilliams 4y agoThese self reported studies are not good measures. They need to find out where these people were last employed or attending school.
- throwaway742 4y agoIs there any state where you can't get benefits without a permanent address or am I missing something here?
- Lendal 4y agoMore theorizing. Why don't they just ask the homeless, on an individual level, why they're homeless? They know better than we do. It's not like they're animals, such that we can't ask them a simple set of questions. My personal theory? The reason there's more homeless in LA and NYC is because LA and NYC are huge. There's more of everything in those cities. Why shouldn't there be more homelessness as well?
- 1024core 4y ago> There are a lot of poor people in Utah, there are a lot of poor people in Detroit and Philadelphia, but we don't see the kinds of homelessness that we do in Los Angeles, San Francisco,... Because where would you rather be if you're poor and homeless? Detroit or San Francisco? Philly or La? I know where I'd rather be in such a situation! Add to poverty drug addiction and poor life choices and you have basically nixed any chances of renting a place.
- janalsncm 4y agoI have heard this line a lot, and it shouldn’t go unchallenged. Most homeless people don’t plan to be homeless anywhere, and certainly don’t plan to move from Detroit to LA to be homeless. Many poor but non-homeless people have never left their state, so it’s pretty hard for me to imagine a homeless person gathering enough money for a cross-country trip to supposedly homeless Mecca. And most homeless people are only temporarily homeless. Many people also aren’t aware of the fact that a sizable percentage of homeless people have jobs. So “poor life choices” can prevent a person from having a roof over their head, but apparently not from working. No, what is clear is that there is a direct relationship between an influx of people, lack of new housing, and an increase in homeless people. Did people suddenly become more predisposed to mental illness and drug addition when housing demand went up? Of course not. Most of the homeless people in a city are from that city. In places with Housing First, there is a huge decrease in homelessness of course, but also in other associated problems like mental illness and drug addiction.
- 1024core 4y ago> it shouldn’t go unchallenged. Well, you should talk to the homeless people then. I live in SF and am on first-name terms with close to 20 homeless people. All but one of them came from outside SF. You'll often hear of "point in time" surveys which claim that 70% of homeless people lived in SF when the became homeless. But this is a self-reported survey, without any proof, and the definition of "lived" is very loose: even if you were living in a homeless shelter and got evicted, you'd be classified as having "lived in SF when you became homeless". I read an interview of a homeless woman from Minnesota, who explicitly said: I had a choice: would I rather be homeless in Minnesota, or homeless in San Francisco; so I hopped on a bus and came to SF. SF has a very permissive culture, and an open drug scene, so it is attractive to anybody who's homeless.
- jklinger410 4y agoHigh rent is due to lack of space to house people as inflation is due to too much liquidity in the market. "Everything is made up and the points don't matter!"
- jmyeet 4y agoThere are levels of homelessness. The first level is one where you don't have permanent shelter. Maybe you're staying on a friend's couch or in your sibling's basemenet. But not long term. You may have several such situations and bounce between them. These arrangemenets tend to be temporary and are triggered by the loss of a job or rising rent or divorce or a number of other factors. These people are larely invisible. The next level of homelessness is when you're exhausted your temporary options and you end up living in your car. You are likely still employed and need your car to get to and from work (because America). This too is a temporary situation. Towns and cities don't like people living in cars. You may get harassed by police. You may get towed. Your car may just stop working and you can't affrod to repair it. On top of that, you may have a bunch of parking violations you can't afford. You may have to deal with crime (eg people breaking into your car and stealing your stuff). These people are a little more visible but are still mostly invisible. Like I've seen cars people are clearly living in but my guess is that 95% of people don't see it. The third level is where you've lost your car and now you're living on the streets. This is the first truly visible level of homelessness. This experience is traumatic and dangerous. This is where you may start self-medicating (eg drugs, alcohol). It's more difficult to hold down a job so you may lose that too. Crime will affect your daily life. You will be harassed by the police who will randomly move you somewhere else to get you temporarily out of sight. Such people will tend to find some form of community for self-protection, which is why you have encampments. The last level is where you've been on the street so long that you have serious medical and mental health issues. You may well have substance abuse issues too. You likely will have suffered or at least witnessed serious violent crime. The self-medicating continues. At this point it is incredibly hard to come back from this. My point here is that when people talk about homelessness they only talk about visible homelessness (ie the last 2 levels). But the problems begin way before then. It starts with a lack of housing security. The most important thing to do for homeless people is to find them somewhere to live. It's not a shelter. Those have their own dangers and issues. This is what people mean when they talk about a "housing first" policy towards homelessness. We, in the US, live in the richest country on Earth. There is absolutely no reason why we can't feed and house and provide medical care for every man, woman and child in this country. But we don't because some people don't want to give anything to other people. Some think it'll somehow "encourage" homeless people and stop them from being "lazy". Instead we pour billions of dollars into an incredibly ineffective and highly militarized police force. Homelessness and poverty breeds crime. The only way to address that is to address the underlying cause. A lot of places simply ship their homeless to coastal blue states. Just this week, NYC agreed to pay a man $135,000 in settlement after an NYPD officer decided to drag him out of a mostly empty subway car for having a bag on the seat and then lie about what happened [1]. That officer faced no disciplinary action and still works for the NYPD. The worst thing to happen in the West is the financialization of the housing market. Everybody treats housing as an investment. We've created an incentive to make housing more expensive for the less fortunate. We create policies to make housing unaffordable. This is by design at this point. [1]: https://pix11.com/news/local-news/man-dragged-from-train-by-nypd-officer-to-get-135000-from-nyc/ https://pix11.com/news/local-news/man-dragged-from-train-by-...
- WalterBright 4y agoShould check the drug addiction rate among the street dwellers before drawing such conclusions. In Seattle, 90% are addicted to drugs or alcohol, or are mentally ill. https://komonews.com/news/local/komo-news-special-seattle-is-dying https://komonews.com/news/local/komo-news-special-seattle-is...
- throwaway742 4y agoThat number seems unbelievably high. LAHSA for example found that only 15% of homeless individuals have a substance abuse disorder. https://www.lahsa.org/documents?id=3422-2019-greater-los-angeles-homeless-count-los-angeles-continuum-of-care.pdf https://www.lahsa.org/documents?id=3422-2019-greater-los-ang...
- garbagecoder 4y agoYou just missed the distinction. Talk to people who work with “street people” and they will tell you almost all either suffer from mental illness or addiction. This is not the same as people who are housing insecure.
- throwaway742 4y agoGood point I did miss that. They also included mentally ill with substance abuse disorders.
- g_sch 4y agoAs other commenters have mentioned, people living on the street don't comprise the majority of unhoused people. It does seem like California has a higher overall percentage of "unsheltered unhoused" people among the unhoused. But e.g. here in NYC the vast majority of unhoused people move in and out of the (largely corrupt, poorly maintained, highly restrictive) shelter system, and a only small percentage live on the street or in the subway.
- dano 4y agoBuilding more housing is tossed out as if this is a single dimension economics problem, like widgets in Freshman econ. Perform a capacity utilization study of all available housing, where Capacity is the number of room days of housing available and utilization is the amount it is actually occupied. Then tag each of these housing units (room) across multiple dimensions including cost, location, house, apartment, condo, etc.. Find out how existing housing is actually being used and how much it is being used. Then adjust the financial incentives to change the usage to what you think it ought to be. I live in an medium to high cost of living location and the number of underutilized properties due to second homes, opportunistic rentals, and basic investment properties (downtown condos) is substantial. If someone can point me to a city that has performed a Housing Capacity Utilization study, I'd like to read it.
- woah 4y agoWhat a bizarrely complicated argument to try to refute the most basic law of supply and demand. Many economists have proven over and over that building more housing means that there are more places for people to live. The burden of proof is on you, since you are the one making outlandish claims. The number of "underutilized properties" is likely a few percent in your area. "Most condos are empty and owned by foreigners" is a myth perpetuated by NIMBYs and conspiracy theorists. Even if it was true, the best way to screw over these shadowy foreign empty-building-owning figures would simply be to build more housing so that it's not an artificially scarce investment asset. The value of their investment would plummet and they would have to sell it or take on tenants.
- shanty 4y agoFrom a supply and demand side, Real Estate Developers would gravitate to high value developments due to potential for making higher returns as well as the prestige in building "fancier" developments.
- prottog 4y agoA glut in the supply of high value developments would lower the market price of existing lower value stock, as well. Plus, in a lot of places developers are forced to focus on "luxury" housing because their margins are hamstrung by affordable unit requirements; so instead of putting up a building that's 100% medium rate, they build something with 70% luxury units to offset the 30% affordable units.
- braingenious 4y agoThe wording for this is hilariously bad. “Poverty” isn’t the real driver of homelessness so long as you define poverty in a way that it’s unrelated to your ability to shelter yourself! This sort of tired, pointless game of “if you define words differently, sentences have different meanings!” is so oddly popular on here, especially when it comes to housing. I personally go by the dictionary definition of poverty: 1 a : the state of one who lacks a usual or socially acceptable amount of money or material possessions If the landlords in your city use some scummy software (1) to provide cover for them deciding that they should help themselves to 110% of your paycheck and that results in your inability to live indoors, you’re functionally impoverished. 1. https://www.theverge.com/2022/11/26/23479034/doj-investigating-rent-setting-software-company-realpage https://www.theverge.com/2022/11/26/23479034/doj-investigati...
- kderbyma 4y agoobviously. rent seeking corporations have infected every major city and speculators and local greedy developers are half the problem, city councils raising property taxes and doing nothing to fill vacancies in their cities....usually foreign owned....
- kodyo 4y agoWhere do drug addiction and lunacy rank in the drivers of homelessness?