8 ms·
Tesla finally breaks and offers round steering wheel on Model S/X
- zzz345345 4y agolol.... who would have thought that a circular shape would be better for a steering wheel in a consumer car...
- mkraft 4y agoIf you set out to reinvent many of aspects that are conventional of a complex machine like a car, I’ll forgive you for not getting 100% of them right.
- jrm4 4y agoWhich is why you shouldn't "set out to reinvent" just for the sake of looking cool, and why Tesla is starting to be valued at what it's actually worth, aka not a whole lot.
- jdminhbg 4y ago> aka not a whole lot Lord grant me a business worth $400B, aka not a whole lot.
- heavyset_go 4y agoIt's still got a way to go until it reaches a sane valuation, and the stock is still falling.
- nverno 4y agoI'd love for it to drop to a 'sane' valuation so I could get in. Already itching to pull the trigger, but I think it could shave off another $20-30.
- cwalv 4y agoYou could sell secured put options and end up making a decent return even if it doesn't drop http://opcalc.com/PJM http://opcalc.com/PJM
- taylodl 4y agoTesla's average transaction was $65K in 2022. There were 1.3 million transactions. That's $84.5B in transactions. Companies are typically valued at 7x their transactions which would be $591.5B - which we'll just call $600B. If Tesla is currently valued at $400B then they're undervalued by 33% and that would put Tesla at a BUY. These are all back-of-the-napkin calculations and assumes Tesla will sell as many cars in 2023 as they did in 2022 and in fact will continue to do so for the foreseeable future. I'm not an automotive industry expert but I don't see any reason why Tesla wouldn't. I think part of the reason Tesla's stock pulled back so much in 2022 is the realization that Tesla may not have that much GROWTH left.
- svnpenn 4y agoA single u-turn should have been all Tesla needed to understand how terrible an idea yoke is. You try arm over arm, then crash the car.
- themitigating 4y agoThere are other hand methods when using a yoke that work just as well. I think they assumed people would adapt. Considering it's already an EV maybe they thought people would be more willing to try new things.
- brandonagr2 4y agoI have over 25k miles in an S with a yoke, there was one day where I was exiting a parking lot and the yoke was upside down and the turn signals buttons were backwards that was a slight annoyance. Other than that I have never had an issue turning with the yoke and wouldn't want to go back to a wheel that blocks the instrument cluster constantly.
- zzz345345 4y ago> that blocks the instrument cluster constantly. they also could move the instruments (but besides the speedometer... most of them are somewhat useless anyways... and with a FSD car, even the speedometer should be useless)
- collegeburner 4y agonever driven a tesla, but also steer by palming rather than hand over hand so can't people just do that?
- happytoexplain 4y agoThis is a pretty generous framing. The use case differences between round and rectangular steering wheels are well understood. There was something else motivating this, not "reinventing the conventional", as it would be phrased in a TV spot.
- zzz345345 4y agoI won't forgive Elon Musk for trying to put a transmission in an electric car... luckily it didn't work.
- photonbeam 4y agoThe yoke only makes sense if you use FSD beta 24/7
- modeless 4y agoActually isn't it more annoying? FSD will be turning the wheel a lot more than regular autopilot, but you still have to keep hands on the wheel frequently or it will disengage. It will only be better when hands on wheel is no longer required.
- themitigating 4y agoSome new FSD systems only require that you look forward. There is a camera that monitors your eyes
- timdorr 4y agoYou don't have to keep your hands on the yoke during hard turns with the FSD beta. Even with a wheel, it would be hard to signal the right amount of pressure without disengaging when their is a lot of movement going on.
- modeless 4y ago
- xiphias2 4y agoAs Fred mentions the main problem with the steering wheel is that the car doesn't change the steering ratio depending on the speed.
- georgewfraser 4y agoI have an S with a yoke and prefer it to a round steering wheel. 95% of the time it’s better: you can see the entire dashboard and your body can feel the angle of the wheel instinctively. 5% of the time it’s worse, during low speed maneuvers.
- svnpenn 4y ago> low speed maneuvers AKA maneuvers. Driving on the highway in a straight line is not a maneuver.
- asdff 4y agoYou should be able to see the entire dash board with any steering wheel
- _9omd 4y agoIt really depends on your height and preferred wheel height setting. I'm tall and in some cars the wheel obscures a good portion of the insturments.
- Hellion 4y agoThere are significant and effective federal regulations around this. If you are telling the truth, your steering wheel is way too high, and you need to lower it
- aidenn0 4y agoNot who you are responding to, but I have a tall sitting height and I suspect that the steering wheel is too low. Consider this diagram of a properly adjusted steering wheel (instrumentation is where the "II" is): /----\ / II \ |------| \ / \----/ If you are tall what can happen is: /-II-\ / \ |------| \ / \----/ A telescoping steering wheel helps quite a bit because you can adjust your seat back/forth more to get a good angle, but in cars without telescoping steering wheels, I have the second sight-picture at any position in which it is comfortable to hold the steering wheel. If you are suggesting: II /----\ / \ |------| \ / \----/ then this will render the airbags ineffective.
- pnw 4y agoMy S was wrecked in a crash (I was unhurt luckily) and instead of replacing it with a new S I bought a Y instead, solely because of the yoke with the touch controls instead of a round wheel with stalks. I can't be the only person who reacted like that, because Tesla wouldn't even let you test drive a car with the yoke last I checked.
- darknavi 4y agoHow do you like the Y coming from the S? We had a 3 and added a Y and now we barely drive the 3. Strictly a commuter.
- toomuchtodo 4y agoNot OP but I own an S and a Y. The S has a generous air suspension while the Y feels like driving a deuce and a half; very rough suspension (although I’ve heard new Ys since a few months ago are getting something more fancy now). Higher ride height is also nice. Pros and cons. Still love the S even though she’s a chonk and rides low. Interior in both is spartan. Towing with the Y is a treat for trailers within its rating. If you have to pick, I’d recommend a Y almost always over the others. It’s the optimal intersection of price and value across all models.
- maxerickson 4y agoIf you have to pick, There's literally no one that is forced to choose from $50,000+ electric cars.
- toomuchtodo 4y agoIf one has chosen to buy a Tesla, one must choose which to purchase...? It’s pretty clearly an expensive luxury good with robust demand, sooooo what’s the argument? Don’t buy one if you’re not of the means to afford one. If you’ve decided to buy a Tesla, I’m sharing which you’ll get the most value out of. Average price of a new car is $45k-48k btw. 17 million new auto sales per year in the US. $50k-$60k isn’t egregious considering total cost of ownership savings. One could buy an equally expensive combustion vehicle I suppose. Prices for a new Toyota Highlander currently range from $37k to $67k, for example.
- ilrwbwrkhv 4y agoAbsolutely horrible design was the yoke. Almost crashed into neighbours' car due to it. Had to dump the car itself since I hated the steering so much. Who came up with such a dumb idea. This is as dumb as the touchbar on the mac pros.
- vkou 4y agoIt was probably a cost-saving measure, just like the touchpad in lieu of a physical console.
- int_19h 4y agoI suspect that a lot of Tesla design decisions boil down to positioning it as "innovative" and "disrupting" compared to normal cars.
- SilverBirch 4y agoWell, we've watched this at Twitter right - Musk will come in with a really strong dumb opinion on some weirdly specific issue, and then insist on a specific solution and only relent after the decision has been implemented and shown to be wrong. The yoke is the Tesla version of the Twitter Blue Tick. The rumours are that the guys at SpaceX are just much better at managing Elon and avoiding this, but it makes you wonder what weird decisions have been made there too.
- Lendal 4y agoIt wasn't the shape of the wheel that was the problem. It was the unasked-for capacitive-touch turn signal buttons located on the left side of the wheel, instead of a turn-signal lever. The round wheel keeps those useless buttons, so is not a solution to the problem. You still have to use your left thumb to pick between these two buttons. They don't push in, have no feedback and they are often unresponsive, especially when you attempt to push one while turning the wheel at the same time with your left thumb at an odd angle. It just doesn't work. Bring back the turn signal lever.
- Hellion 4y agoMercedes put a bunch of these in the $100k plus EQS. Car companies: we are begging you, please stop with controls without pressure sensitivity and haptic feedback. Copy apple if you need to, just cut it out!
- actuator 4y agoApple is not the only or the first manufacturer that did this, they wouldn't be copying Apple if they do this.
- rgmerk 4y agoApparently, VW are going to bring back buttons after lots of feedback like yours: https://www.edmunds.com/car-news/volkswagen-relents-and-brings-us-our-buttons.html https://www.edmunds.com/car-news/volkswagen-relents-and-brin...
- illumin8 4y agoI have a Model S Plaid and they do have haptic feedback when you press them, but the problem is they require muscle memory to know the exact place to press to get left/right turn signal or horn. I'm 6'1" and the horn is particularly problematic because it requires stretching your right thumb an uncomfortable amount to hit it. It reminds me of using a very large smartphone and trying to use your thumb to reach a tap point at the top of the screen. Terrible UX. There have been several times I've needed to honk at someone quickly and been unable to hit the right button. The other issue with the yoke is that it still requires the same amount of turns as a normal wheel, so 3 point turns and U turns become more challenging. I've adapted, but you also have to use the touchscreen to select forward/reverse, so 3 point turns are like this: - Turn the wheel hard left (hand over hand but you have to grab only the sides) - Brake, then slide reverse on the touchscreen (taking your eyes off the road) - Turn the wheel hard right (hand over hand again) - Brake, then slide forward on the touchscreen (taking your eyes off the road again) - accelerate out of the turn while straightening the wheel I"m a pretty capable driver but this is way harder than it should be and I can't imagine my wife or many "normal" drivers being able to manage all of this, while taking their eyes off the road, and not causing an accident. Tesla makes great cars, but it's amazing that NHTSA hasn't recalled the yoke yet...
- devnulll 4y agoI have 20k miles driving a Model S with a Yoke. While I'm not a huge fan, the yoke itself is only part of the problem. The bigger problems are: 1. The capacitive buttons for turn signals. They are dangerous. They require taking eyes from the road, offer no feedback, and are honestly dangerous. 2. The horn. It's not in the middle. It's off to the side as a no-feedback capacitive button. Every time I've needed to use the horn, I've been unable to find the button. I think recent S/X Updates have moved it back, but it's so dumb. It's a feature set designed to look cool on Twitter. Not really for driving.
- porphyra 4y agoThe horn is in the middle now. Besides, if you cover multiple buttons on the right with your palm, the horn will sound.
- dieselgate 4y agoYikes, buttons for turn signals? I can barely get a "legacy" horn to honk sometimes even
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- culi 4y agophysical buttons are reliable, easily repairable, more accessible to people with a variety of conditions, allow you to memorize location with feel, etc. I've never met anyone who's preferred capacitive buttons over physical ones yet more and more every "smart" technology seems to be opting for them. Some have even added haptic touch-like software to them... just to regain the feeling of the thing that everyone misses but without actually giving them the thing they want...
- alexvoda 4y agoApart from regulation mandating that safety features work, are reliable and are easy to use (physical buttons), I think we need some new economic theory. Why is it that for products with complex spec sheets, the free market (the auto industry is arguably not a free market) does not work to provide the desired diversity? Automakers clearly have the incentive to make any control a capacitive touch surface for many many reasons. Many people hate touch controls for important features in cars. Yet most automakers are switching to touch controls. Free market theory says that other manufacturers should appear and satisfy that desire for consumers. This isn't happening. I do not know of a economic theoretical model that accurately explains the behaviour of complex (many orthogonal characteristics) goods.
- JoshTko 4y agoLiterally tried to reinvent the wheel and is now paying the consequences.
- electriclove 4y agoYeah but I'm glad they are trying new things. If it isn't better, then revert.
- Gonzalez07 4y ago[dead]
- int_19h 4y agoWith cars especially, I'd rather they don't do it "in prod" - meaning on the roads where I also drive.
- SilverBirch 4y agoThe problem isn't trying new things, it's trying new things in stupid ways. The car industry has a whole structure for this - the concept car. And you can see, most of the time, they show the concept people go "But that's dumb because of <x>, and then they don't try and sell it to customers! They're constantly putting out new concept cars to explore new ideas, and the good ones they then incorporate into production cars - like Lexus did, producing a car that has a yoke that actually has a technology solution to the obvious problems of a yoke. Instead, Tesla goes "We're going to do this cool new thing!" people quite rightly respond "Ok, how did you solve <obvious problem>" and then Tesla sells the car with the obvious flaw anyway. You don't actually need to sell a shitty steering wheel for several years. People aren't asking them to be less creative, they're asking them to be competent.
- taylodl 4y agoThis isn't how you do things when there's the possibility of injuring people. Even worse, those being injured aren't necessarily those who made the decision to buy the vehicle - it's everybody else on the road. I don't think I'm being unreasonable in saying I don't want my life dependent on the whims of Tesla.
- saurik 4y agoThe yoke was just gratuitous. In addition to being a stupid and atypical design even for a yoke--where the grip is under the center of rotation and (as mentioned) it has a constant ratio (making low-speed turns ridiculous)--the mechanism was never designed for use in cars where you need to make complex parking maneuvers: the concept comes from racecars. When I saw they were going in that direction, I nearly considered not wanting to even try a Tesla, as "worse case" I'd actually like the car and then one day I'd need a new one and I wouldn't be able to get one anymore without a yoke. I finally decided they were probably going to cave, and "lo and behold" they did ;P. One thing I did was watched a ton of videos of Tesla fanbois defending it on YouTube with videos claiming "if you don't like the yoke you clearly don't know how to drive, let me show you how easy it is to use" and then confidently driving around a parking lot while constantly fumbling with the wheel which they clearly weren't good at using and they were so self-absorbed into their narrative that they somehow failed to even realize their video was proving the opposite of what they wanted to anyone who actually cares about driving feeling natural rather than being something you have to concentrate hard to pull off. But like, if you try to analyze the wheel just from a business perspective, it feels like an unforced error: I can't imagine many people at all--possibly not even anyone--were making the decision to buy a Tesla because of the yoke steering wheel. They aren't on the fence about this car that is already so unlike every other car on the market and then suddenly they see the wheel and think "wow... that's it: that's the detail that is selling me on it". Here's the scenario which feels much more likely: people are already trying to decide whether a Tesla is right for them, trying to get over the "range anxiety" that plagues electric vehicles and having to be convinced that they were going to be able to find convenient opportunities to charge (in my case, I rent an apartment, like a lot of people, and virtually everyone I know; I thereby simply can't charge at home) and then they do a test drive and now realize they have another problem: they need to decide if they can tolerate the yoke steering wheel. And, maybe they can! But now the sales person is having to defend multiple things at once, and this one is frankly a doozy as you are dealing with someone who has been driving a car so far their entire life and has potentially decades of motor memory--many tens of thousands of hours--working with round steering wheels and are suddenly feeling a bit relieved that these electric cars are some kind of joke because of the yoke. Even if the yoke were a good thing (and I'm pretty confident it isn't) in the long term, it seems absolutely daft to try to introduce it in a car that is already--by its very nature--having to be extremely different from every other car on the market on another critical axis unless it is a clear and obvious win where almost everyone who tries it thinks "omg I didn't even realize I was missing this until I tried it and now I can't go back" (which, btw, I'd claim Tesla actually pulls off surprisingly often): if the feature is even slightly controversial it is almost certainly going to cost you too many idiosyncrasy credits. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Idiosyncrasy_credit https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Idiosyncrasy_credit
- skellington 4y agoThank God! Maybe this means they'll offer a round wheel (as an option or whatever) on the CyberTruck!!!!!!!! I despise the yolk with a fiery passion, but have zero problems with other people having one. Just give us the option! I won't even consider a car with a yolk (maybe if there is an easy modification). Blocking the dash screen is a non-argument. Never had a problem in many cars with seeing the display through the wheel. With a yolk, you are forced to hold it in a certain way. In an emergency, grabbing the yolk is less certain than grabbing a wheel. It's easier to put way too much torque in the yolk causing more steering than desired. The capacitive buttons are dumb (yolk or not). The stalk for PRND and a separate stalk for signals is better, and put back the wiper controls while you're at it!
- bitexploder 4y agoWhat did eggs ever do to you? I will see myself out :) I drove a friends plaid. I would buy one on the spot if it had more physical controls and a round steering wheel. The performance of them is just so fun for daily driving and the range is amazing too. Ahh well, Elon gonna Elon.
- gneray 4y agoany indication on whether people with yokes can get a normal steering wheel replacement? i don't mind the turn signal buttons but the driving experience is not ideal for quick reactions, and the horn...has got to go
- redox99 4y agoYes, there will be a $700 retrofit.
- xeromal 4y agoThe yoke would work if a full turn was at 90 degrees. This yoke is just a steering wheel cut funny
- tedk-42 4y agoArticle is a bit of a joke. Honestly we should be able to control a car with that degree of freedom. I'm a big for of smaller steering wheels that are out of the way. They use to make sense when you needed to apply lots of torque manually (aka no power steering) but gone are those days. > For example, if you lose control on an icy road, it could be harder to do some quick maneuvers to regain control. No F1 driver is winning a world championship with a wheel and not a yoke. The statement in the article is incorrect. The yoke actually makes it easier to do quick moves but in icy conditions that's not what you want.
- nixgeek 4y agoNo F1 driver is doing a 3-point turn using a 14:1 steering ratio either.
- JohnBooty 4y ago> No F1 driver is winning a world championship with a wheel and not a yoke. The statement in the article is incorrect. The yoke actually makes it easier to do quick moves but in icy conditions that's not what you want. This is a misunderstanding. The steering ratios on F1 cars are way, way tighter. They never have to turn the wheel more than a few degrees during a race and aren't turning the yoke more than a few degrees during a race. F1 drivers are also high-performance athletes and aren't tasked with driving their cars in the snow, maneuvering into tight parking spaces, etc. Lots of design decisions on F1 cars don't make sense for road cars, and vice-versa.
- viburnum 4y agoAn F1 wheel only goes slightly more than 180 in either direction. Regular cars typically go 540 degrees in each direction.
- miika 4y agoSo now they can call it steering wheel. Before it was steering rounded rectangle.
- disillusioned 4y agoI literally cancelled my Plaid S order and switched to a Model Y over the stupidity of the yoke. I simply could not square that circle, so to speak. They emailed me telling me it was going to be ready for delivery and I said, "you know what, I can tell I'm going to hate it." I'm really glad I did that. I simply cannot understand how the yoke ever made sense, aside from being a 13-year-old's idea of what a cool car would look like. I'm not changing 25 years of functional muscle memory for... literally no practical improvements at all. And the removal of the stalks is goddamn criminal. To save, what, a couple hundred dollars on a $150k car? That coupled with the rumored removal of ultrasonic sensors is some very stupid forest-for-trees regressions in "if it ain't broke, don't break it" world.
- porphyra 4y agoThe yoke is very comfortable to rest your hand on while FSD is enabled, doesn't obscure the instrument cluster display, and you get used to it immediately. Like the old saying goes, don't knock it till you've tried it.
- kj34kj 4y agoBut the Y has no instrument cluster. Which is one of my favorite features! Because in any other car, I always find part of the instrument cluster occluded by the wheel. I do agree that the yoke partially solves this problem, but it introduces many others (so I've heard; I admit I haven't tried it). Regardless, I'd just rather have no cluster.
- Mawr 4y ago> The yoke is very comfortable to rest your hand on while FSD is enabled Seems like the opposite is true: https://youtu.be/-QBWfw_nkr0?t=152 https://youtu.be/-QBWfw_nkr0?t=152
- porphyra 4y agoLetting the wheel slide through your hand like that doesn't apply a torque, so you will get nagged and you will have to jiggle the wheel once in a while. By resting your hand on the corner of the yoke, it has just enough torque to keep the system happy indefinitely.
- powerbroker 4y agoI've driven the Model S for 13 months. Initially I was very apprehensive. But here is how my thinking has progressed: 1. 30 days prior to acquiring the car, I solely drove with hands on 3-and-9 in my conventional car; 2. First 30 days of driving, I practiced the turn signals and and horn at random parts of my drive to develop muscle memory; 3. First 6 months, I fully adapted to the 3-and-9 handling. I had 'button mishaps' maybe 2-5% of the time; 4. Final 7 months, button-errors diminished to sub-1%. Some maneuvers are actually easier in the yoke than with a regular wheel. A U-turn is reminiscent of using the old rotary-dial telephones. You just dial the wheel counter-clockwise by hooking your left pointer-finger in the small valley on the upper left of the yoke. I drive with some quirks that remove certain issues others have with the yoke. I never park next to a car -- and benefit from longer walks to stores, etc. Consequently, I rarely have any surprises as I pull in and out, and don't need to make sudden maneuvers. Moreover, even in the telephone-dial turn technique, my turning hand knows exactly where the 3 O'clock or 9 O'clock position is, and can adjust from 'dialing' to grasping. Now I've had experience piloting various aircraft -- so, its remotely possible I have slightly more brain plasticity than your average bear. So your mileage may vary. I also benefit from the advantage of driving through icy conditions once every 3 years or so. TL;DR: By six months of driving, my early apprehensions were allayed, and all phases of driving are no worse while driving the yoke. Oh, and in case you think I have any weird biases: Elon Musk sucks in managing Tesla for the last 12 months, at least.
- dawdaway 4y agoSo for six months you were driving less safely, even while benefitting from your extra "brain plasticity"? Extrapolate that to a wide variety of consumers who dont have any experience piloting aircraft and what do you get? Less safe roads for no reason other than style points. No one remotely capable of driving a car thinks doing a u-turn needs to be "easier".
- ryanwaggoner 4y agoThat’s a new selling point: if you’re an experienced pilot, you can probably learn to drive our car in a mere six months!
- tablespoon 4y ago> There are even some driving scenarios where the butterfly not only becomes impractical but potentially dangerous.... > As for the lack of stalks, Tesla replaced all of their functions with force touch buttons on the wheel, even for things like turn signals and the horn. Musk’s logic is that “all input is an error,” and that the car should automatically perform all the functions that were on the stalks (now on the force touch buttons). Was Musk's New Year's resolution to shatter, one and for all, the world's belief in his competence? All of these choices were really, really stupid.
- helf 4y agoDoes Tesla do any real usability testing? Or is it strictly yes-man grab ass and fanboys? /capacitive/ turn signals without even haptic feedback? How the fuck did that get through initial design? How is that even legal? With the fiasco that is the objectively stupid cabin design of the Semi on top of bullshit like this it really makes you wonder what the hell they do over there.