6 ms·
As the curmudgeons say: pride goeth before the fall. I'm not saying that Matt is wrong, or that the WSJ is right, but this essay was just a bit too...precious.
by timr 18y ago
As the curmudgeons say: pride goeth before the fall.
I'm not saying that Matt is wrong, or that the WSJ is right, but this essay was just a bit too...precious...for my tastes.
I don't have the answers, and I don't have much confidence in anything, outside of myself. That said, if I know one fact about the world, it's that very few of the self-confident 22-year-olds that I meet are going to get rich from their big brains and hard work. If history teaches us anything, it's that most smart people will fail -- repeatedly and painfully. So, while it's not the right time for the adults to shake their walkers at the children for running on the lawn, perhaps it would be prudent for the kids to hold back on the self-congratulatory essays, in anticipation of the day when it all goes pear-shaped?
I'm not much older than Matt, but even I can detect a distinct generational shift in attitude toward work; I know where the WSJ editorial is coming from, even if I don't agree with its conclusions. And while I'm sure that the brash 20-somethings that I know believe that self-investment and autonomy are the keys to avoiding their parents' fate, that probably has more to do with the abject failure of all previous models of work, than the proven success of this one.
In ten years, some of you will be rich, successful and powerful. Most of you -- despite all of your hard work and independence -- won't be. Which brings me to another thing that the curmudgeons say: the more things change, the more they stay the same. Youth and arrogance are eternal companions.
- ph0rque 18y ago> In ten years, some of you will be rich, successful and powerful. Most of you -- despite all of your hard work and independence -- won't be. So why spend 60 hours a week in a suit under fluorescent lights in an 8' x 8' cube either way?
- mattmaroon 18y agoRight, we'll all be happier. It's not about being rich, it's about being the primary beneficiaries of our labor and striking a proper work-life balance.
- timr 18y agoPerhaps. Just try to remember that yours is not the first generation to pursue these goals.
- davidw 18y agoI think there used to be a different balance between various things. You could expect to find a 'good company', dedicate a lot of your live to it, and be more or less reciprocated. These days, it's "every man for himself". In Europe, they have, in some places, attempted to legislate this relationship, which I don't agree with, but sometimes I feel there may be something we are missing out on in terms of long term, loyal employer/employee relationships. I'm not sure I'd want that myself, having pretty much grown up with the hopping around + brutal layoffs style common in tech, but still... it makes you think.
- run4yourlives 18y agoI think that's exactly it. It's just taken a couple of generations to adapt to this new reality. My parents (well, my mom at least, my dad was an entrepreneur) would never quit their jobs. This was something that was unheard of. Xer's would be happy with whatever job came their way. Now, the millenials are fully understanding that their jobs are about as secure as their car parked in the bad part of town. Honestly, corporations have changed how they treat their employees, and so the employees are adapting.
- davidw 18y agoRight... it's a problem with solutions at different equilibriums (I'm not sure of the exact way to phrase that), and I'm not sure that what we are moving towards is necessarily the best for all people/jobs/companies: sure, there's more flexibility and responsiveness, but as an employee, I have figured out at this point that I don't really have any more loyalty to an employer than they are likely to have for me, and perhaps we both lose out because of it in some ways, at least for certain combinations of people/jobs/companies.
- deleted 18y ago[deleted]
- run4yourlives 18y agoOne word: Security. When you get married and have kids, you'll see how much more important that word becomes.
- ph0rque 18y agoWhat makes you think that I'm not married and without kids? In fact, I value my free time more knowing I can spend it with my wife and daughter.
- run4yourlives 18y agoFair enough, but many people value their next paycheck more than the free time. You asked why we should toil away as an employee for someone else, and that's the answer. Being an entrepreneur is risky business.
- vlad 18y agoIn the long term, working on your own projects using the latest technologies and latest editions of popular languages, and having projects to show for it, will give you much more experience and credibility than working at a company for the same amount of time. Over the years, I'm sure early adapters of Java, .Net, Ajax, Rails, Django, and Objective C did not have a hard time finding jobs. Companies typically try to convert existing developers to use new languages, and an employee hired for this knowledge will be an expert. A startup using the latest technologies will want to hire employees who already possess this knowledge. Finally, a user experimenting with new technologies might decide that he or she is so far ahead of companies who are still using old technology that he or she should start a business.
- run4yourlives 18y ago>In the long term, it's less risky than working Bullshit. For every single Paul Graham there are hundreds of entrepreneurs living in abject poverty, wondering how they'll feed their kids or where they get the money to pay the mortgage. You're taking a very small subset of extremely bright, assertive go getters and insinuating that this is the norm. It is not, and statistics show this.
- sant0sk1 18y agoWell said. Wishing you wouldn't have censored yourself. I read your comment before you removed the last line. It hit home very well, imo.
- timr 18y agoAdded it back. Thanks.
- aneesh 18y agoWell said. The funny thing is, there's nothing about this argument unique to our generation. Both the WSJ article & Matt's response could've been written at any time in the past, and perhaps at any time in the future. Indeed, the more things change, the more they stay the same.
- mattmaroon 18y agoI don't think that's true. There's been a fundamental shift away from working one job all of your life (as our grandparents did) and being more of a free-agent that could never have been said before.
- Retric 18y agoOur grandparents are just one example I don't think most people started and ended the Great Depression working for the same company. I think today's world is much closer to the historical norm of lot's of small to mid sized companies fighting it out.
- kingkongrevenge 18y ago> working one job all of your life (as our grandparents did) You know, you hear this all the time that people used to work one job all their lives. But I keep my 88 year old grandmother company often and she doesn't shut up, relating extensive biographies of the family tree going way back. If anything it sounds like major career changes were more common in the past. You definitely get that impression reading about colonial America circa the revolution. I think maybe there was a brief post-war period where it was true? William Whyte's "The Organization Man" talks about the era.
- silentbicycle 18y agoI wouldn't be surprised - there are numerous assumptions in American culture about how things have "always been" that are only really accurate from the post-WW2 era on. The GI bill led to substantially higher college enrollment, which in turn had a tremendous influence on pretty much all white-collar jobs.
- Prrometheus 18y ago>If history teaches us anything, If history teaches us anything, it's that economic reality changes. In the 18th century, the optimal size of the firm was small. There were many independent artisans. In the 19th and most of the 20th, industrialization occurred and firms faced increasing returns to scale. Soon, the mega-corporate-conglomerate ruled the world. Now, information technology means that even small teams can be highly productive. Billions dollar investment funds are run by 20 people. It is not unreasonable for young people to wish for or strive for the return of the artisan age.
- bootload 18y ago"... I don't have the answers, and I don't have much confidence in anything, outside of myself. That said, if I know one fact about the world, it's that very few of the self-confident 22-year-olds that I meet are going to get rich from their big brains and hard work ..." You will gain answers with time. Your confidence will grow. But chances are if your average "self-confident 22yo" lives in a first world country they are already rich surviving the ardor an diseases of childhood, being feed enough to grow. To have the opportunity to be educated enough to read and write. All that time living in a relatively stable environment. "... In ten years, some of you will be rich, successful and powerful. Most of you -- despite all of your hard work and independence -- won't be ... the more things change, the more they stay the same. Youth and arrogance are eternal companions ..." I'll take that back. Probably one of the most astute things I've read this week.
- sabat 18y agoPrecious essay or not, his larger point stands: we are more on our own than our parents or grandparents. The Republican party and the ultra-conservative movement of the past 25 years has created a new wild west; it's every man for himself. BTW this is not just for Matt's "Nintendo" generation (Y, I presume). It goes for aging generation X, as well.
- babul 18y agoYou speak so much sense I wish I could give you more than +1 points.
- pg 18y agoYou'd have to know Matt to know this, but he's about as unentitled as you get. His brash confidence is the deliberate brash confidence of the WC Fields variety, not the naive sort that comes from inexperience.