13 ms·
The infrastructure behind ATMs
- ilaksh 4y agoMy take on this is that it's absolutely obsolete. There is a type of technology that can bring this stuff up to date but I can't write it on Hacker News without being buried.
- veb 4y agoThis was a fun read, never knew so much about ATMs until now.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- charcircuit 4y agoInstead of selling magic paper why not use reloadable prepaid cards so you wouldn't have to keep magic paper in the machine?
- toast0 4y agoKind of silly to use a magic rectangle to buy a different magic rectangle. Better to buy magic paper.
- martyvis 4y agoI've actually recently got a "travel" card (Wise) even though I don't have a plan to travel. But it allows me to top it up with say $200 and present it locally and online (with attractive exchange rates) and limit risk and potential lockouts on my regular bank issued card. I can use the physical card as well as via Google Pay on my phone. (In Australia contactless payments are pretty much ubiquitous and have low fees if any)
- jhugo 4y agoNot sure about Australia but in many countries (at least UK, SEPA countries, Singapore), Wise is a registered bank now and the card is just a Visa debit identical to those issued by any other bank. When you "top it up" you are just transferring money into another bank account of yours. Not to say Wise isn't great (it is), just dispelling the idea that it's somehow different from a bank account + debit card.
- martyvis 4y agoI guess I am just impressed by the features compared to my regular bank. While I don't earn interest in Wise, having things like the way you can categorise and annotate transactions, instantly freeze and thaw the card, quickly create purposeful accounts for putting aside funds in whatever currency, quick transfers
- jhugo 4y agoYeah, they are fantastic. I am forever hopeful that their feature set will inspire other banks. So far I have seen that happening in UK/Europe, but not so much elsewhere. Wise does offer the ability to switch your balance from Cash (safeguarded, no interest) to Interest (government-backed assets) or Stocks (index fund) while still having access to spend it. This might be gated by currency or by the country of your verified address.
- lyall 4y agoFunnily enough, this is very common in Japan via so called "e-money" stored value cards such as Suica[1], Pasmo, Waon, Nanaco. Those four you can even provision right now into Apple Wallet and load with money via a card if you've got an iPhone made in the last few years. Accepting them in a sane payment system is a bit of a nightmare however. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Suica https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Suica
- astrange 4y agoLoading Suica with a foreign credit card was unfairly good because there was no fee and it’s coded as travel, so that’s maybe 5% back with the right card. I say was because it’s currently broken apparently, as they switched payment providers to one that requires 3D Secure in an way Apple Pay can’t do.
- asdff 4y agoCertain businesses only take the magic paper. Namely dispensaries and roadside taco stands.
- lunchbreak 4y agoI was under the impression that selecting debit when paying at the cashier means a direct debit of your account happens (as this article seems to imply). Which isn't subject to laws protecting consumers which apply to credit cards. However selecting credit by the cashier - while using eg a MasterCard branded debit card still gives you the consumer protections (eg when disputing charges the onus is on the bank etc) Am I completely wrong about this? Is the only difference the payment rail that gets used - and that has no affect on whick consumer protection laws you fall under?
- lyall 4y agoYes, the rails used should not affect the consumer protections you do or do not receive. If it's a debit card, it's a debit card regardless of if it's processed over a credit network. Exactly how long the transaction takes to _clear_ your account may vary depending on the semantics of the network and integration used, but processing a debit card over a credit network doesn't mean you get to hold onto your money for any longer than you would otherwise. The auth will put a hold on the funds in your account instantly and you will effectively have that much less money in your account.
- cobertos 4y agoThe terminology makes this so much harder to distinguish. My bank does have different consumer protections for different cards issued through them (debit cards require you to report fraud within 7 days, credit cards require you to report within 30). I didn't realize that the payment network used was not coupled to these mechanisms. I wonder if financial marketing understands this? Associating credit with less risk, less requirements, in naming of the networks themselves? Even though settlement can occur on each network
- lyall 4y agoThe payment processing space, like basically anything when you look close enough, has a fractal-like complexity to it. And in my opinion the industry as a whole does a pretty poor job of abstracting away that complexity, often leaking it through, such as with the "debit or credit?" question. But turns out it's pretty difficult to hide the complexity, and many businesses are built around hiding it as a service. It usually involves taking on risks others aren't willing to or having an Apple-like resolve to piss off some customers by deciding what's best for them without asking or, rarely, the power and/or innovation to actually change how things are done.
- tossaway0 4y agoTwo observations: 1. My bank ditched physical locations (for the most part) and now just covers the cost of using other banks' ATMs. 2. The overhead these banks have for just talking to eachother is understandable when you read about the intricacies of why it exists, but something that really shouldn't exist today.
- patio11 4y agoI think the costs involved in financial services are often more nuanced than given credit for. The nature of the services provided aren't simply a communications protocol, not that banks treat communication protocols as rounding to free. (Chase can call up Bank of America at any time and frequently will do so, up and down the banks' operations, every banking day of the year. Those calls aren't free, even if the direct cost of the call time rounds to zero. There is a substantial human and technological overhead to permit the calls to go through and be useful to both sides.) With ATMs as a concrete example, you don't just need a rest API connecting the ATM to the issuing bank. The transaction also involves multiple risk transfers, mandated-by-regulation accountability if something goes wrong (including SLAs for resolution with effectively mechanical penalties for breach, in many cases), 24/7 staffed customer support that answers questions like "I am in New Orleans and a machine just ate my card heeeeeeeeelp!", etc. Now we, as a society, could decide "You know I like a US- or Japan-style penetration of ATMs in society placed by a combination of banks and independent entrepreneurs, but I hate that they actually cost money to end consumers. We should shift the cost of them to... OK I care about the specific payer far less, actually. Let's write a law to do that." Some societies have chosen that.
- mike_d 4y agoIt was a bit buried, but calls out an interesting fact I wish more people knew about business: cash has processing fees too. If you deal with commercially relevant quantities of cash, in addition to your own labor costs associated with it, your bank will assess a fee for depositing it. Larger retailers will negotiate their own bespoke rates, but the right ballpark for small businesses above a nominal amount is 3 bps, or $3 per $10,000 transacted.
- swyx 4y agodamn, they get you coming and going. cant even deposit your own money in your own account without paying something
- mattclarkdotnet 4y agoYou don’t have to deposit it, you can just keep it under your mattress for no fee
- paranoidrobot 4y agoThe context is commercially relevant. As a regular consumer you can deposit cash without additional fees. If you're running even a modest business, keeping large amounts of cash on-hand for any length of time is a business risk. Some vendors may not want to be paid in cash, particularly for larger payments. Depositing it is the only way to deal with a lot of things.
- TedDoesntTalk 4y agoWalmart, Target, McDonalds branches deal with so much cash that they would need at least two mattresses.
- inopinatus 4y agoWalmart & Target also sell mattresses, making them a vertically integrated financial services provider.
- 4y ago
- timeimp 4y agoI find it amusing that in the US its "cash back" when getting money out at a retailer using debit cards but here in Australia its "cash out."
- solarmist 4y agoI'm American, and I still find it confusing because I use it so rarely.
- flemhans 4y agoIn Denmark, you'd say something like "Can I get 50 on top"? Or "on the amount", if you didn't want cash. This was many years back, I wonder if it's still possible.
- noisy_boy 4y agoIts "cash out" in most of South/Southeast Asia too.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- simondotau 4y agoAlso an Aussie; first heard it called “cash back” while in London UK. Found it very confusing. Cash back from where?
- bigbluedots 4y agoAgree, "cash back" sounds like bonus money
- s0sa 4y ago“Cash back” from the amount they just charged your account?
- simondotau 4y agoThat would make sense if, per your reply, the question is posed after the money has been taken from my account. But that's not how it works.
- zinekeller 4y ago> Although many readers may not remember this, bank ATMs used to be free as a matter of policy, through approximately the 1990s. This isn't clear to me. Is it for interbank transactions or is this includes intrabank transactions? It's confusing for me since that nearly all banks here have free intra- and interbank withdrawal*. Are US banks really that greedy? * It may be indirectly charged by lower interest rates, I'm not sure, but there's no direct fees collected. Edit: wow, US banks are greedy. This is the first time that I've heard about domestic own-bank fees (separate from ATM operators' fees) for inquiring (not even withdrawing) your account. Silver lining is that intrabank transactions are still free, which is okay I guess but but definitely weird for me.
- patio11 4y agoIn Japan same-bank transactions routinely have ATM fees outside of banking hours, though this is finally starting to change. Banks will also routinely charge you for same-bank bank transfers, often at a discount to interbank account transfers, including when they’re made at the same bank’s ATMs during banking hours. (For added fun, sometimes the price is different if it is same-bank same-branch versus same-bank different-branch, largely to lessen impact of fees on interfamily transfers and entrepreneurs moving money into and out of closely held companies.) In the U.S. withdrawing at another bank will frequently incur a few twice, once from your institution and once from the disbursing one, unless you are on a product which specifically makes a selling point out of reimbursing you for ATM fees. This is not simply a matter of “greed”; it is also a policy choice made by society as to who pays for bank services and where. Different equilibria prevail in different places, partly anchored on historical practice and partly in response to the usual factors which shape public policy.
- fomine3 4y agoIt's really weird that same-branch vs different-branch fee difference still exists. It's on the same central system for a long time.
- quartesixte 4y agoAnd don’t forget sometimes the price changes depending on time of day! Definitely biggest culture shock of my time living there.
- conductr 4y agoI feel like a few things were skipped in between network and operators (for US at least.) There are a lot of middlemen in the distribution of off-premise ATMs. The banks, networks, processors, sponsor banks, ISO's, distributors, operators, merchants, etc. It's actually much more complicated because it gets kind of like an MLM scheme when distributors can have infinitely nested "sub"-distributors so, as an operator, you may be many more steps away from things than you realize. Generally, ISO have bank sponsors. They can operate ATMs. More often, they service distributors. Distributors are typically local businesses serving a market; they may operate ATMs. They also can just sell the ATM and the merchant can operate it. The ISO and sponsor banks typically is where the processing agreement/negotiations is actually happening. The ISO is typically the highest level anyone will ever interact with on the downstream side (it's the top of the pyramid in the MLM example). Everyone down stream gets a payment portal specific to their function. An operator can be anyone, they service the machine and keep it stocked with inventory (cash) and typically keep the surcharge (less than 100% is a bad deal, renegotiate.) What's interesting is the ISO gets its hands on some interchange. Then it gets passed around as negotiated. Most people in the industry don't talk about this, but it's usually their revenue since the operator is getting the surcharge. But, even as an operator of a single ATM, you can ask for a cut of the interchange pie. Like all things, it varies but with volume you have leverage to negotiate a bigger slice. It's similar to how as a consumer there are no line items for you to see, but there is interchange when you make a credit transactions. You bank is being paid by the merchant's bank to facilitate the transaction. If your card/bank chooses, they can share that interchange with you. It's purely marketing as to whether they will or not (it's a product feature). It's possible as a merchant operator your transaction economics would look like: Cash Reimbursement + 100% Surcharge + Cut of Interchange (amount varies, but I was averaging ~$0.50 per transaction) > Note that the settlement of these deals is necessarily much slower than the transaction itself is. The ATM network will often be paid the following business day by your bank, but the ATM operator will probably be paid several days later by the ATM network, using an ACH transfer (in the US) or similar frequently slow rails. ATM operators should be getting the money quickly. It works next-day on the schedule of the ACH system. IIRC the cutoff is 4pm ET and it's next business day. Any operator not getting this is probably stuck on some 25+ year old agreement and probably should switch providers; renegotiate at a minimum if it's even worth the hassle.
- disordinary 4y agoInteresting that they say the number of tellers is up because the amount of branches is up, because where I live (New Zealand) it's practically impossible to find a bank branch now days, they've all been shut and replaced with internet banking and ATMs. I can't remember the last time I used a cheque, for instance, probably 20 years, so the requirement to physically go into banks is low, but when you do need one they're not around.
- baud147258 4y ago> I can't remember the last time I used a cheque Here in France I'm still using cheques to pay for my electricity bills (which not the usual way, I'd wager most people just pay by internet), but I never have to go to the bank for the checkbook, I order it online and receive it by mail within a fortnight.
- isolli 4y agoA friend (in France) recently had to walk into a branch to declare a stolen check book (couldn't do it online). While the branch was open, it was physically closed and you could only get in with an appointment. He had to negotiate and explain his situation before they let him in and processed his case.
- Semaphor 4y agoHere in Germany, most traditional banks still have branches (assuming you are in a city). Not many, but still quite some (and it depends on the bank, some have more than others). FinTech banks like N26 never had any.
- flemhans 4y agoIn Denmark, the traditional banks closed the branches. My bank (Danske Bank) has two branches left in the whole country.
- carstenhag 4y agoFunnily enough some german banks are experimenting with something called a "banking bus". It has an integrated ATM and 1-2 bank employees. Each half day it is at another village/small town.
- wsh 4y agoFor an interesting look at one of the early ATM networks, see Gifford and Spector’s article, “Case Study: The CIRRUS Banking Network,” Communications of the ACM, August 1985. It’s posted here as an exhibit in a patent case: https://ptabdata.blob.core.windows.net/files/2017/CBM2017-00041/v10_Exh%201009%20-%20Cirrus%20p798-gifford%20Communications%20of%20the%20ACM%20August,%201985.pdf https://ptabdata.blob.core.windows.net/files/2017/CBM2017-00...
- ggm 4y agoAnyone recall the story of data in X25 connection declined message and the invention of the "mini call" as a response? Or ISA buss triple width 3DES cards with a funky fully potted encased circuit to do SuPeR SeKrEt CrYpTo over the wire
- jimmySixDOF 4y agoI definitely expected to see X25 mentioned somewhere in the article
- amaccuish 4y agoCould you elaborate? This sounds interesting.
- ggm 4y agoIt's more rumour than proof. But, it's said a bank worked out that an X25 call reject response had enough data space to pass a transaction payload and coded their ATM to use incomplete calls to pass the higher protocol messages. Because X25 was modelling phone networks it only charged for completed connections: it was a free call. The protocol got a new minimal, mini-call model which didn't expect more than one packet each way to take account of it.
- jsmeaton 4y agoDo the fees imposed for “credit” or “debit” differ for the consumer? The article seemed to imply that it did, otherwise, regulations being the same, why would it matter? It’s fun to know what the actual difference is though. I had always just assumed that if I select credit when using a debit card the transaction would just fail “silly customer we know, you told us to check the wrong vault”.
- RC_ITR 4y agoYou can think of payments networks as secure messaging infrastructure where the operator says “you can trust us that this payment is legit” to varying degrees of certainty and with varying degrees of fraud protection. Debit networks (oversimplification) are basically ATM networks where your bank gets a note saying “user” supplied their card and pin to authorize a withdrawal of $X. This is why you can also pull out extra cash on these transactions. Banks ofc want to be reimbursed for the onerous task of giving you your own money, so they usually charge a consumer-facing fee for these transactions. Credit (really Visa/Mastercard) transactions tell the bank “user” gave us their card and a signature, our fraud algorithms tell us this is probably fine, and we’ll settle this payment in bulk with the rest of your users’ purchases in 1-3 days. Banks, again wanting their cut, are paid via merchant-facing fees (interchange and merchant discount rate). Stores keep the debit option up because some people like to draw extra cash and they get the benefit of not paying the fee even though their prices already incorporate the cost of credit card processing. That is also why all the “financial advice” sites say to run things as credit, but honestly I’m not sure how current the above is given recent regulations.
- jsmeaton 4y agoIn Australia quite a lot of stores place an additional fee for using any kind of card (but they must be capped to actual fee, though some smaller vendors will add a minimum 50c fee).
- kuschku 4y ago> even though their prices already incorporate the cost of credit card processing. That's not yet the case everywhere. In Germany, girocard (a federated debit system, run by merchants and banks together, with basically no fees) is so common that prices do not include credit card fees. Now MasterCard is forcing banks to stop issuing girocards or MasterCard will stop working with those banks, in turn trying to destroy girocard. But this means prices for everything will jump another 1-2% to account for the new fees which are added by switching to the MasterCard network.
- kylehotchkiss 4y agoI want this level of detail about the SWIFT system now!
- patio11 4y agoI've written about it previously; let me know if there is anything you'd want more detail on. https://www.bitsaboutmoney.com/archive/moving-money-internationally/ https://www.bitsaboutmoney.com/archive/moving-money-internat...
- gonzo41 4y agoATM's are the OG distributed system. If you ever get a online banking notice about your bank doing maintenance over the weekend usually they ATM's will go into standby mode. When this happens it is really interesting, and a fun source of chaos. The ATM's in standby mode allow you to withdraw on credit, the limit of your card. Even if you have no money. It all starts to get reconciled over the next week and you have to pay it all back. But it's a 2am bear trap for drunk people at casinos.
- imwillofficial 4y agoI came for the article, stayed for the wonderful writing on what I thought would be a boring subject. I was wrong, I just spent three hours reading this blog and learned so much about so many things.
- ElevenLathe 4y agoFair warning: The "infrastructure" here is a metaphor, and this is all about how the business of operating ATMs works. There is no talk at all about the physical infrastructure of the machines themselves, how they are installed securely, the network they use, how cash is physically stocked in the machines, etc.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- berniedurfee 4y agoYeah, I was ready to be terrified learning the intricacies of our surely antiquated ATM physical infrastructure.
- metacritic12 4y agoFwiw, here's a bullet point summary by ChatGPT: -ATMs were originally introduced to banks as a cost-saving device, allowing for routine transactions such as cash withdrawals and balance inquiries to be handled by machines rather than tellers, freeing up tellers to handle more complex transactions. -The basic transaction at an ATM can be seen as not a withdrawal, but rather a sale of paper with mystical properties (cash) in exchange for money, often with a convenience fee. -Transactions at ATMs require real-time confirmation of availability of funds and cannot use the same "rails" as other transactions in the economy, making them vulnerable to fraud. -Using an ATM owned by the same bank as the account being accessed is straightforward, but using a different bank's ATM requires more infrastructure and relationships to ensure smooth and secure transactions. -"Off-premise" ATMs, owned and operated by non-bank entities, became popular in the 1990s, charging a fixed convenience fee for cash withdrawals. -Interbank networks, such as Cirrus, were created to streamline relationships between ATM operators and multiple banks, increasing the reach of any ATM bearing the network's logo and allowing for smooth transactions between different banks. -ATM transactions involve a series of offsetting deals between the customer's bank, the ATM operator, and the interbank network, with settlement occurring later. -The expansion of interbank networks and increased use of off-premise ATMs led to the creation of independent ATM deployers (IADs), who manage the placement and maintenance of ATMs for a fee, rather than owning and operating the machines themselves. -Offering cash back when using a debit card at a store allows the store to save on banking fees for depositing cash and potentially earn float. -Big Data has been used to optimize ATM demand for cash and minimize servicing trips. -The use of cashless transactions is on the rise, but there are still challenges to overcome such as lack of internet connectivity and cultural differences in adoption of new technology. -The future of ATMs is uncertain, with potential competition from mobile banking and the rise of digital currencies.
- cesarb 4y ago> If you’ve ever used a debit card to purchase something in the U.S. you may have been asked “Debit or credit?” and wondered “Hmm, can’t they tell from looking at it that it is a debit card? Or isn’t it, I don’t know, in the card number or the magnetic stripe or somewhere?” I don't know if it's a cultural difference, but at least here in Brazil, it's common to have the same physical card work as debit, credit, and as an ATM card. AFAIK, they are different applications running in the same chip on the card, selected by a command from the terminal. So they really have to ask "debit or credit", since the same card can be used for both.
- albertopv 4y ago>at least here in Brazil, it's common to have the same physical card work as debit, credit, and as an ATM card Same in Italy, at least recently, a few years.
- electroly 4y agoIt's the same in the US. I have a card that is both, and that's the only card where the ATM asks me to choose.
- somedude895 4y agoI'm from Europe and I have separate cards for credit and debit, but the ATMs in the US still ask me. I've always wanted to try pressing debit on the credit card but then never could be bothered. Would it just do credit because that's the only thing the card can do, or reject it altogether?
- 0xffff2 4y ago>I'm from Europe and I have separate cards for credit and debit, but the ATMs in the US still ask me. This is true in the US as well, but most US debit cards have a Visa/Mastercard logo on them. Those cards can run the transaction either through the debit system or the credit system. It's not actually a combined credit/debit card (at least I've never heard of such a thing), just that your debit card can pretend to be a credit card.
- stuff4ben 4y agoCame in expecting a tale about the actual infrastructure, i.e. hardware and software and probably something about OS/2. Came out with a lot more info about payment "rails" and fees and stuff that makes me glad I'm in software development and not finance.