11 ms·
Silicon Valley offices less empty than other regions
- sylens 4y agoI wonder how much of this might be due to every member of a team being more likely to work out of the same office in a SV located company than in other companies. The reason I’ve been so bullish on remote work coming out of the pandemic is because multiple jobs I had before the pandemic were very much remote jobs, with the added requirement of having to perform them from an office building 45-60 minutes away from me. My team was distributed across New York, Florida, Texas, and California, so all of our meetings were using Teams or Zoom anyway. The fact that I had to ride a train twice a day just to take those zoom calls from a local office was always an annoyance.
- NikolaNovak 4y agoSame here. My teams are primarily in Ottawa and Halifax, as well as Toronto, Calgary, Edmonton, and few stragglers all over the place. Going to office will allow you to talk in person to some of the people but ends up creating massive insulated islands. Remote has put us all on same page and made us communicate, resulting in pervasive awareness. Operationally we are distinctly more effective remote and I shudder for the inevitable return to office where it'll be "you guys in Halifax can't see this on the 1993 broken polycom speaker phone, but Claus is drawing an updated architecture. Sorry you can't hear him he's also far from phone, we'll catch you up later " (they never do)
- Tade0 4y agoI'll do you one better: I've been in a project where our PM was in South Carolina, the bulk of the team in Poland and our single Indian teammate phoned in from Hyderabad. We were all working remotely at the time, but before the pandemic the Polish team would commute to the office.
- scruple 4y agoI ran a team where myself and the TPM were local in SoCal, QA was remote in NorCal, and developers were in Texas, Chicago, Argentina, and the Netherlands. It worked surprisingly well but that boiled down to 80% having the right set of personalities.
- nerdponx 4y ago> The fact that I had to ride a train twice a day just to take those zoom calls from a local office was always an annoyance. This exactly. I was already working more or less remotely before the pandemic, but from an office 1 hour from my apartment. I often worked from home anyway and nobody noticed other than my manager, who usually was also working in a different office from me (1 hour drive away) but who insisted that I come into the office whenever possible. Covid gave me the chance to stop wasting my time and energy on the train just to keep up appearances for the person who did my annual performance reviews. My current job is a bit different. Our team is "global", but several of my coworkers actually work in the office near where I live, so going into the office is actually a nice experience. Also my commute is 1/3 what it used to be, which helps.
- gumby 4y ago> The fact that I had to ride a train twice a day just to take those zoom calls from a local office was always an annoyance. This. My gf's company mandated back to the office in mid January 2022 so she went in on the first day...and was the only member of her group to do so. In fact most of the group was in other locations anyway, so she just zoomed from work that day. I remember even before that, working for FAANG the office complexes were so big that most of her meetings ended up on Zoom anyway even if the participants were elsewhere on the same campus.
- huntsman 4y agoThe vacancy rate of offices looks low because the big tech companies are still "occupying" them, but if go into many of them and they still look like ghost towns. Much more that offices in other locations. This feels unsustainable.
- lazide 4y agoIt definitely is unsustainable. A lot of wil-e-coyote running off the cliff type of stuff going on. And hey, maybe some places will connect with a cliff on the other side. But I wouldn’t want to be in the commercial real estate space right now. About 90% of every office and co-working space is empty now, all day, every day here. It’s only slightly busier than during Covid when it was 99%. Light industrial and retail (strip mall type stuff) is doing well and super busy however.
- toomuchtodo 4y agoColloquially this was known as “extend and pretend” during the GFC.
- macNchz 4y agoHere in NYC I've been to a couple of coworking spaces in the past 6 months and was surprised to find them downright bustling, I had trouble finding a quiet space to work. There are definitely serious problems in commercial real estate here, but the coworking situation was unexpected to me.
- blevin 4y agoOne succesful mode of applying coworking spaces seems to be less for heads-down focus time and more for periodic get-together time for teams. These spaces seem not very good as a full-time micro-office due to the noise issues you mention... but as a place to go whiteboard or empathize they seem quite useful. Bonus if there are nearby interesting excursion options, food courts, recreation, etc. and multiple easy-ish commute options. Part of economic development seems to be exploring options for how to dis- and re-aggregate services like this, providing more and smaller transitions across the tradeoff landscape.
- outside1234 4y agoI technically work from my Silicon Valley office - but haven't been there in two years.
- ghaff 4y agoYou have to actually look at person-days in an office. How many people are technically assigned to that office is pretty much meaningless. I haven't been been into my official office in 3 years (although I've very occasionally gone into another couple company offices).
- jayzalowitz 4y agoLonger term leases. Its gonna hit hard before 2030.
- randomopining 4y agoYou mean they aren't gonna renew en masse?
- bushbaba 4y agoDisagree Silicon Valley is home to many hardware, medical, and other industries which require labs or equipment that requires in person work.
- banach 4y agoI am still waiting for companies to realize that offices in the pre-pandemic sense are a completely unnecessary expense, a drag on productivity and a competitive disadvantage for the organizations that keep clinging on to this idea. It's easy to talk about the importance of meeting face-to-face, when you ignore the opportunity cost of enabling this versus scaling down to more up-to-date spaces that make things like workshops, larger meetings and pair programming truly comfortable, and reinvesting the savings into higher salaries and other benefits. Are the management teams in our industry just waiting for someone to pull the trigger, or are they hoping that no-one will do so, and that everyone will just forget that the pandemic taught us how meaningless commuting to work is?
- dragonwriter 4y ago> I am still waiting for companies to realize that offices in the pre-pandemic sense are a completely unnecessary expense, a drag on productivity and a competitive disadvantage for the organizations that keep clinging on to this idea. When their top investors and board members are often also top investors and board members of the firms that own the commercial real estate, it may be hard for them to come to that realization.
- kcplate 4y agoI am waiting for the exact opposite. I love WFH, my team loves WFH. All of us will tell you how much more productive we are and Individually we might be. As a team…we are definitely not more productive and no one wants to say that uncomfortable part out loud. Sooner or later that truth will trickle upwards and we will all be back to a commute and cubicles.
- bitcharmer 4y agoSo you're saying everyone is more productive when WFH individually, but somehow the team as a whole isn't. Could you please explain how that works?
- HDThoreaun 4y ago
- yardie 4y agoAhem, “the average amount of space per lease is decreasing across all types of commercial property.” Fewer, new commercial projects going up, and smaller office sizes. Vacancy is down if you count the number of leases signed and not the size of the property. So still going down.
- gumby 4y agoThe actual linked report does the calculation by area, not lease count.
- icapybara 4y agoMuch of Silicon Valley is hardware work that literally can’t be done from home.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- KerrAvon 4y agoIn 2023? Do you have statistics? I want to believe, but isn’t it mostly web shops of one type or another, like everywhere else on the planet?
- icapybara 4y agoI don’t have statistics. It’s in the name though, “silicon” valley. The South Bay is home to the semiconductor industry and its ecosystem. My own company has about 15k employees in San Jose, and we’re all back to the office full time. Many of us can’t do our jobs from home, it’s hardware work.
- gumby 4y agoThe Valley is mostly tech, while SF is more the web shops. SF didn't even have much tech exposure at all until the dotcom boom; in 2000 it was still mostly old line industries (a stock exchange!) and music and other art. People in tech lived up there and commuted to work in the Valley.
- iron2disulfide 4y agoThe "Silicon" part of Silicon Valley is still very much relevant. Intel, AMD, nVidia, etc. all have major presences down there. There's also a multi-billion dollar industry supporting silicon design shops in various ways, and they're all in SV too.
- Tempest1981 4y agoThat's also my perception. Just by looking at buildings and job offerings, there seems to be more hardware in the South Bay, vs. the peninsula or SF. Not sure about the Oakland area. The article defines Silicon Valley as "Santa Clara and San Mateo counties, along with the cities of Fremont and Newark." I would have split out the first two.
- photonbeam 4y agoIf they provided a private room with a closable door, then I might be tempted to commute. Open office means the home office instead
- amalgamated_inc 4y agoCorrect answer
- JoshTko 4y agoCould this be partially explained by longer leases in SV on avg prior to Covid? Meaning that actual utilization of office in SF is much lower, but some tenants were locked in longer contracts which have yet to expire.
- nashashmi 4y agoSeems like a spin from Silicon Valley Real Estate companies and Mayors
- repeekad 4y agoPeople who love remote work seem to be senior, well established employees who were already fully ramped up and had a social foundation in SV before the pandemic. I left my entire life behind after college to relocate to SV; I loved working with talented engineers and gained so much experience and mentorship in 2019. But remote work was isolating and lonely, mentorship went to zero, and it has caused me a lot of stress realizing that remote work is never going away. It was very sad, but I had to leave SV behind to find a career with people who cared about my success again, rather than preferring remote work for themselves at the expense of less experience engineers having to ping and zoom for every question, with less authentic relationships being formed. Remote work might seem like employees vs the boss, but there are people like me who actually loved their jobs, and now can only do them through a screen alone in a bedroom.
- pcurve 4y agoI'm in my 40s, unattached. Strong introvert. I didn't realize how much I missed going into the office until a few of us had half day in person meeting at office. I wanted to do more of it. Sadly, the office was still mostly empty, so there was no point going in. I left the job. There were other reasons of course, but I want my next job to be at least in-person 3 days a week.
- amalgamated_inc 4y agoTry just going to a coffee shop every day as a routine, just to see some actual faces. Works for me.
- yodsanklai 4y agoI'm a bit in the same boat. I recently switched to full remote work. In retrospect, I think it was a bad decision. I don't feel I'm a part of the company anymore, and staying home feels lonely. Ironically, I liked to go to the office when my team actually wasn't there! I like to socialise with people from different teams but seeing my teammates is sometimes stressful. Also, I'm a slow thinker and I often prefer to work on problems asynchronously.
- softwaredoug 4y agoThis is what makes modern Nimbyism even more destructive. We’re heading to a new urban death spiral. With no commuters and empty office building. Residential density could salve some of the issues that creates for cities. But nimbyism will of course prevent that, and leave cities the decaying while stodgy citizens delay any solution and argue against density.
- ViViDboarder 4y agoNo commuters? What city are you referring to? In SF, Muni is packed along my commute to the city. Probably there’s not as much commuting, but there’s certainly quite a bit. Also, more dense housing actually usually means less commuting. That’s one of the reasons I generally support it. People living closer to work means less commute time resulting in less carbon as well.
- gumby 4y agoI think we could easily go back to the days (not so long ago) when SF was a bedroom community for SV and working in SF was the reverse commute. SF could become a fun place to live and play again.
- ghaff 4y agoMy observation in Boston is that driving in by car at rush hour is as bad as it has ever been. Commuter rail ridership seems to be significantly down relative to pre-pandemic so some of the traffic probably comes from that, but it's still very heavy so a lot of people are obviously still commuting in.
- dehrmann 4y agoI don't think nimbyism is why office buildings aren't getting converted to residential. It's just expensive.
- unity1001 4y ago> We’re heading to a new urban death spiral. ALL the dense urban areas on the planet sorely needed that though - they have become literal messes of skyrocketing real estate costs, traffic jams and infrastructure problems along with other problems. A bit of easing could not do harm.
- AntiRemoteWork 4y ago[dead]
- hnburnsy 4y agoJust saw on CNBC that San Francisco office vancancy was 3.7% in Q4 2019 and just hit a record 27.2% for Q4 2022.
- gumby 4y agoSan Francisco is the worst performer in this report. Unsurprisingly, Silicon Valley is doing much better than SF.
- cadence- 4y agoMost office leases are for 5 to 10 years periods. I’m not surprised they are not seeing huge changes yet. It would be more interesting to find out how much of that space is actually occupied by meatbags. Most offices I went to this year were basically empty chairs.
- goldenchrome 4y agoTruly challenging work approached with a deep passion is best done in direct collaboration with others. There’s no replacement for the energy that you find from a desperately hard working team that’s working together in person. I’d estimate that 90% of people aren’t interested in working that hard so remote works just fine. SV has been pumping out money for the last decade so they’ve had to offer cushier environments to attract talent, but now that the free money is drying up I hope that more companies will return to what made SV great in the first place: obsessive work. We’re already seeing the more committed business owners enforcing in-person work, but there’s been strong push back from employees. Only the companies that are truly creating value will be able to entice enough talent to work there, and many companies will falter in the process, but I think it’s good for us all. It’s like a forest fire that creates space for new growth.
- horns4lyfe 4y agoAgreed, but I’d add: 90% of people aren’t interested in working that hard to make a founder life changing money while they’re collecting a salary and adding a bullet point to their resume. And reasonably so.
- amalgamated_inc 4y ago> Truly challenging work approached with a deep passion is best done in direct collaboration with others. It is also best done in a quiet, comfortable place and not in a mosh pit with a dozen sales and HR people yelling on the phone all day. I've never worked in an office that was better for deep work than my home.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- black_13 4y ago[dead]
- zephrx1111 4y agoI feel someday, going to office will become a privilege.
- api 4y agoWasn’t it a supply constrained market before? So now there is just a bit of slack but less than other markets they were previously less crazy.
- spritefs 4y agoWhat's this? An SV newspaper posting copium about office space in SV?
- rconti 4y agoSo, official vacancy rates from a leasing perspective. This doesn't cover leased space that nobody's using or that's partially occupied. My understanding is that office leasing tends to be longer term than residential, though I'm not sure what kind of early termination provisions might be typical that would add signal back to the noise. Some reasons I can think these stats might be misleading: * Long term leases signed recently (pre-pandemic) that are still in effect (though now that I realize we're almost at the 3 year mark, I suppose this is wearing off). So younger companies that just got started in SV might disproportionately skew our stats. * Companies prioritizing some cost saving measures (layoffs) over others (real estate). "Legitimate" reasons I can think of that SV offices might be more in-demand than other places: * Younger average workforce (?). Anecdotally, younger workers prefer the office, and it feels like younger talent flock to SV early in their career (and/or tech companies discriminate against older workers). Younger workers might prefer the office for all sorts of reasons; social life, fewer fears about illness, etc. Which brings us to... * Real estate costs mean that fewer people can afford a home office / more of these younger workers share apartments or small homes, so the office is a necessary space to spread out. (plus someone else pays for the A/C and snacks!) * More need for dual-income / more dual-income "professional" workers, combined with small housing, means more need for space just as in point #2 above.
- xchip 4y agoSales people always claim their product is in high demand. Same here.
- qqtt 4y agoSeems like the entire WFH/RTO conversation is based around feelings, anecdotes, and personal opinions. For every person saying WFH has been a game changer, you have a person saying RTO is essential for some reason or other. This is one of the few times I've seen the entire tech sector basically collectively raise their hands and give up on any form of data driven analysis, and go whole turkey into personal conviction as the only guiding factor. This seems like an area ripe for assessing with metrics. FANG companies onboarded hundreds of thousands of employees over the past 2 years, in addition to their existing workforce. And yet, I haven't seen any CEO anywhere give a compelling case one way or the other with data backed conclusions. This entire conversation just devolves into "trust me bro" anecdotes and personal opinion, even at the CEO level. It is downright bizarre to me.
- nickfromseattle 4y agoThis is a good point. What kind of metrics do you think could be used to evaluate WFH versus in-office productivity? Any initial ideas on the pros & cons of the metrics you would use?
- benatkin 4y agoProbably a good thing to ask ChatGPT.
- nitwit005 4y agoGeneral strategies for how to manage employees have always been driven more by gut feeling and emotion than anything else. People rarely asked for data before adopting "agile" practices, for example. Often they tweaked those practices in ways that would have invalidated any data anyways. They just hopped on a trend.
- notfromhere 4y agoBecause there's no objective way to measure employee productivity in the vast majority of white collar work, and anyone saying otherwise is lying. Most metrics measure indirect proxies to productivity (emails logged, activity, revenue, etc) but its not something you can set a KPI against.
- kilotaras 4y agoPer TFA: *Vacancy rate is lower* than in other region. At least for MANGA I work at SV office is way emptier than London one. Which is not surprising if you take commute time difference into account.
- guiambros 4y agoWhat a terrible article. Of course there's little "commercial vacancies"; most established companies in the Valley are still keeping their offices open. But just because the office space hasn't been returned (yet), it doesn't mean there are actual human beings inside. For a different take, check this other article shared earlier today [1], which paints a stark difference (apparently using mobile phone data, which would be a better proxy for "human beings"). [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34173996 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34173996
- runamok 4y agoAt least Google plans to add houses but to me that is the key to getting people to return to the office. A home within a 20 minute commute that doesn't cost 1.2 million for a tear down. > Google is proceeding with its massive multi-billion-dollar Downtown West development that will span roughly 80 acres near Diridon Station and could take about a decade to complete. Google anticipates up to 25,000 people working in its downtown offices, across 7.3 million square feet of office space. The project plans also call for adding *4,000 homes*, 15 acres of parks, a large community center and its own microgrid.