4 ms·
Well, yeah. That should have been required years ago. In general, you're not allowed to run an anonymous business. Arguably, it already was in the EU, under the
by Animats 4y ago
Well, yeah. That should have been required years ago. In general, you're not allowed to run an anonymous business. Arguably, it already was in the EU, under the European Electronic Commerce Act.
If Amazon doesn't like this, they can be the seller themselves, and take responsibility for product liability. They've fought that in court. They lost in Pennsylvania, appealed, and then paid off the plaintiff to avoid an adverse decision on the record.[1]
[1] https://news.bloomberglaw.com/product-liability-and-toxics-law/amazon-seller-liability-issue-dropped-at-pennsylvania-high-court https://news.bloomberglaw.com/product-liability-and-toxics-l...
- ChuckMcM 4y agoThis was what I was thinking as well, the whole freight forwarded "fulfilled by amazon" thing where a "company" is none existent so that liability is not a problem (if anyone gets serious in their complaints the company goes "poof" and a new version shows up).
- crote 4y agoHow could the company be nonexistent? Does Amazon not check that the company you claim to be actually exists?
- Animats 4y agoNo, they don't. In the Pennsylvania case, Amazon claimed they were unable to find the seller. That's why they couldn't pass the buck to the seller.
- ChuckMcM 4y agoAnimats is correct, ask yourself the other question "Do I need to be an 'official' company to do business as one on Amazon?" The answer is no, very little data has traditionally been required to be presented as a business on Amazon and that practice has been copied to Walmart, Newegg, and elsewhere. All Amazon needed was for you to ship product to their warehouses, and a place for them to send payments. In the US there is something called a "DBA" which are initials for "Doing Business As" and you can register it with the county and then use that name to create a bank account. There were a number of tutorials out there about how to create a "company" where you wired money to some factory in China that would then drop ship your "product" to Amazon, set up a DBA and a checking account, and then create a bunch of ads for AdWords/Twitter/Facebook etc to sell your gizmo for 5 - 10x what you paid for it. Amazon handled all the logistics, you collected cash, and when your stock ran low you wired some more cash to the factory to send more product. Instant side hustle that brought in revenue. There are literally thousands of these companies out there. Because Amazon wasn't required legally to validate you were officially a business, they don't. This tries to plug some of that loophole with the trick that when you buy your product they have to tell you to whom the money is going. With that, a private investigator, and $10K you can often get to the individual involved. Now whether you can recover any money from them? That isn't really answered. It just ups the risk for the "fly by night" vendors.
- Animats 4y agoDo these vendors file a proper D/B/A name? A D/B/A name is not anonymous. I have "Animats" as a D/B/A name. Filed the notarized statement with the county, published the required notices in a local newspaper, and paid the fee. The county publishes my name and address. Online lookup is available. That's California, though. Some states let you use a D/B/A name without registering it.[1] [1] https://dbafilingonline.com/dba-by-state/ https://dbafilingonline.com/dba-by-state/
- nonethewiser 4y agoAnd FB marketplace and craigslist?
- NullPrefix 4y agoFb marketplace and cl only list ads, the transaction itself happens offsite
- rootusrootus 4y agoCL yes, FB Marketplace no. FB handles the payment for things you sell on Marketplace.
- NullPrefix 4y agoThanks, wasn't aware of that
- colinsane 4y agoand so does the seller here act as the “anonymous business” (OP’s words)? cash transactions w/o asking for ID or anything isn’t uncommon on CL. and there are CL users out there making a living from it (admittedly, they’re usually multi-platform sellers). at what point are such sellers breaking the law?
- charlieyu1 4y agoAnd why are we trying to invade the privacy of the sellers? They are as much as ordinary people as you and me
- Animats 4y agoCraigslist doesn't act as an intermediary. They never handle the money. They just put you in direct contact with the other party. Amazon doesn't want customers and sellers to communicate directly.
- rootusrootus 4y ago
- notjoemama 4y agoI just want country of origin listed somewhere. There's a big difference between shipping from Michigan to California versus Hong Kong and California. Shipping estimates have been really wrong since before the pandemic. Maybe put flags next to brand nanes in filters? I don't recognize 90% of the brands on Amazon and that filter is useless to me, unless I could tell is was a domestic or foreign brand. Again, just trying to determine if I can wait 2 weeks or 2 months for things like birthday gifts.
- charlieyu1 4y agoNot sure why you are bringing up Hong Kong on this, most unknown brand names on Amazon are Chinese companies selling Chinese products marked up by 300% to Western customers who are unable to notice the red flags. Then again, it is not so different for Chinese companies to register in US and continue their scam anyway.
- wyre 4y agoI assume you’re talking about shipping origin? eBay lists shipping country and city of origin on the product page. You can even search by closest distance.
- fgsgfsdgfdg 4y ago[flagged]
- nexus7556 4y agoThat is not at all what this law does unless you're selling more than $20k of goods via Craigslist.
- fgsgfsdgfdg 4y ago[flagged]
- borski 4y ago“ Also, the language in the bill continually refers to High-Volume Sellers. The bill defines such sellers as having at least 200 or more discrete transactions, totaling $5,000 or more in gross revenues over any continuous 12-month period during the previous 24 months.” “Individuals that are high-volume sellers will only need to provide their name. However, sellers that are not individuals (businesses) must provide a valid personal government ID on behalf of the seller (business) or provide a valid government-issued record or tax document that includes the business name and physical address.” “ There are exceptions to the contact disclosure requirement if the seller does not have a dedicated business address. That means sellers that only operate out of their residential home address or have a shared residential/business address will only have their country and state (if applicable) disclosed. However, shoppers will be informed that no business address exists for this seller and the only communication available between the two parties will be through phone (personal numbers exempted from disclosure – again shoppers will be told), email, or the platform’s messaging system.” Literally all of the concerns you keep bringing up are addressed in the bill.