8 ms·
Glass Onion: A Knives Out Mystery – Bad Writing
- jcpst 4y agoUgh- I thought that when it said spoilers ahead, it would be just the movie being reviewed in the article, which I don’t plan on seeing. Then there were spoilers for other movies (Get Out) that I intend to watch sometime.
- zach_garwood 4y agoGet Out was released 5 years ago. I think if you haven't seen it by now that's on you. Also, Darth Vader is Luke's father, Snape kills Dumbledore, and Bruce Willis is dead the whole movie.
- tleilaxu 4y agoFortunately Dobby lived to be a grandfather, right?
- jcpst 4y agoYep, got it, lesson learned. “Spoilers” can mean spoilers for anything. Back to my cave I go.
- savanaly 4y agoThat wasn't his point. His point was that spoilers for a movie that's 5+ years old don't need to be alerted. I agree, because it would make movie discussion somewhat exhausting if it were otherwise.
- throw0101c 4y ago> “Spoilers” can mean spoilers for anything. Honestly, if you're reading an article about movie X, then IMHO it is reasonable to assume that any spoiler warnings would be specific to movie X. If an article is going to spoil movies A, B, and C as well, then the spoiler warning text should make note of that.
- zach_garwood 4y agoI think that it's fair to be upset that a newly released movie was spoiled for you. I think it's silly to expect that nobody will ever talk about the details of a movie that hasn't been in theaters for half a decade.
- jcpst 4y agoI don’t think it upset me really- more so surprised. Still feels like it was just released recently, but I suppose time perception is funny that way. Interesting discussion on movie discussion etiquette though. I never really considered how much time is “long enough” to get into a movie’s plot details.
- carapace 4y agohttps://xkcd.com/1053/ https://xkcd.com/1053/
- etchalon 4y agoReading the piece it seems like the author is upset they weren’t able to guess the suspect, and blamed the movie for it. I watched it twice over the weekend, and the second viewing showed how many details were in plain view the whole time. Which was the central gag of the movie. Up front, I’ve liked every Johnson film, except for Looper. Not that Looper was poorly crafted, just that I didn’t connect with it. I thought Last Jedi was the best SW movie since Empire, especially among the sequels, since it had actual things to say. The other two seemed to be more about fan service. Andor is the only other SW media I’ve seen that I’ve enjoyed as much as LJ. So I’m clearly in Johnson’s audience.
- modernerd 4y agoI found Glass Onion's writing far from “lazy”. > Instead, he used the most basic and lazy trick in the book: withholding information for no good reason whatsoever … With Glass Onion, our main perspective character was performing. And we didn’t know because the movie refused to let us know. No, the movie is playing with your expectations around genre-typical knowledge gaps. In classical murder mysteries like the original Knives Out, our knowledge gap is loosely aligned with the protagonist: they arrive at the scene knowing roughly what we know (“there's been a murder”), they outpace us to see through the unreliable witnesses and extend their knowledge gap through brilliant detective work, until the denouement where they explain what was in plain sight all along. In Glass Onion the knowledge gaps are numerous and they're sliced, layered and reordered: - There's a large initial knowledge gap between us and Benoit. He is not just ahead of us: he has a 50% head start. This gap slams shut halfway through the movie by backfilling information on how Benoit really came to receive his invitation to the island. — A new gap opens: the knowledge we now share with Benoit is not yet known to the guests on the island, and we get to enjoy this with him as a reward for the initial “deceit”. From this point we have caught up with the protagonist, at the small cost of our poor reviewer feeling cheated at having interpreted simple unreliable narration as the movie _refusing_ to present the facts to him in tired chronological order. — Yet another gap opens because for the first time in the film — only halfway through our murder mystery! — we know who was murdered but we don't yet know who murdered them. This presents us with the classical murder mystery knowledge gap that the reviewer wanted to exist from the film's start. — The writers pepper extra knowledge gaps that provide more unknowns, some of which are new (who “killed” Miles in his murder mystery game?) and others that exist to provide coherence with the original Knives Out. (Who invited Benoit? Is the murderer of all victims the same person?) > This gets back to something Hitchock [sic] talked about regarding tension. If you watch a scene where two people talk at a restaurant for five minutes then a bomb goes off, it’s boring for 5 minutes and shocking for an instant. If you watch a scene where someone plants a bomb under a table, then two characters show up and talk for five minutes, you’re wondering the entire time if the bomb will go off. It makes the conversation much more dynamic. Glass Onion achieves far more dynamism than this! The murder-mystery format itself provides the “bomb under the table”: we start from the first minute knowing that a murder will be committed. When halfway through that “bomb” has not gone off yet the dynamic tension is unbearable. It's released with the first bomb's detonation (someone is murdered), only to be replaced immediately by more fizzing fuses (we learn that another is dead, and that the murderer must know there's an imposter).
- GaryNumanVevo 4y agoI wish this movie got a wider release! We saw it in theatres and it's a great film to watch with an audience to react to the plot twists and jokes. My wife and I have loved the series so far. We're glad to see the murder mystery genre get revived.
- TheChrisLambert 4y agoHey, y’all. Article author here. I know this is a divisive one. But just wanted to say whether you agree or not that I appreciate you taking the time to read and discuss. If you have any direct questions, let me know and I’ll do my best to answer. Have a great end of 2022 and start of 2023!
- devaler 4y agoI enjoyed your take. I didn’t agree with every point you made, but I was sympathetic enough to appreciate them.
- rvillanueva 4y agoThe joy of a whodunit is being given just enough clues to feel like we could have solved it ourselves by the end. If the Cassandra/Helen twist had been the reveal, I would agree it felt like cheating. But because it's halfway through, it just becomes another layer of clues given to us so that we can figure out, along with Leblanc, that the real twist is that this entire film is about how stupid and simple everything has been all along.
- SilverBirch 4y agoTo be honest, once I saw the direct allusions to Elon Musk in the build up of the film I thought... oh this is going to be annoying. When the conclusion of the film was "Hey! You know that guy! You know how he seems really stupid but everyone asserts he's a genius? Well guess what! He's a fucking idiot!"... well, I had a strong suspicion how a certain segment of people would react to this movie. > Thematically, Glass Onion is showing how terrible people gain power. I don't think that assertion is even close to correct. In fact, I think you have to work pretty hard to avoid seeing the actual theme. It's called Glass Onion for gods' sakes. It's not about terrible people. It's about appearances! It's about seeing people for what they are! It's called Glass Onion. What happens when you peel back the layers of a glass onion? It looks exactly the same. I don't know how to explain how much more obvious the theme was meant to be other than continually repeating the name of the movie... Look, read the name of the movie, that's the theme. I think trying to get ou the rule book for this movie and scoring it is an unsatisfying prospect, because it doesn't play by those rules, so it doesn't care.
- psychphysic 4y agoI'm so tired of critics being sewers of hyperbolic hate. I didn't like it, turns into THE WORSE WRITING EVAH!! It hits a lot of tropes but in an entertaining way which is surprising. Who'd have thought the audience has time for a met mask wearing antivaxxer. All the characters looks simple and deplorable but end up being complex and more hateworthy for it! Who'd have thought audiences even had time for another whodunit? But it proved they did. That makes it a great movie, and I can't think what I'd recommend anyone as an alternative. Maybe Bodies, bodies, bodies? But then I truly suggest most should watch both!
- Krisjohn 4y agoI’m sorry, but if you start your complaint by saying Looper is some brilliant thing that sets the bar, or whatever, I’m not going to be taking you very seriously. The plot for that was so full of holes they literally had to invent a gun that only works if the target is about two feet away for the movie to not end in the first 15 minutes.
- isaacsweeney 4y agoIdentical twins seem cheap and "cheating" in detective stories. This one does it a little differently, but still, it's kind of cheap. There's also a point where someone who's "dead" really isn't. Luckily, the movie is funny enough and interesting enough otherwise.
- bkishan 4y ago‘Bad’ doesn’t even come close to describing it imo.
- dpatterbee 4y agoAgreed, it was really very good.
- rimher 4y agoI found it rather enjoyable, but a click bait title will definitely get you further in this age of the internet
- marcellus23 4y agoWhat’s clickbait about it? If anything it’s anti-clickbait — it just says Knives Out has bad writing, and then the article goes on to explain why.
- brookst 4y agoIt’s clickbait because it asserts something surprising and extreme about a movie that is generally considered to be very good, and then the article can’t really back the title up, let alone its even more extreme yet wishy-washy claim that the movie “might be” one of the worst movies the author has ever seen (talk about bad writing — that should be either “is one of the worst” or “might be the worst”). The article maaaybe identifies one or two minor flaws, but mostly demonstrates that the author didn’t understand the movie. The word “fugue” is not mentioned in the review, for one of the many big misses. It reads to me like garden variety clickbait of the “Beatles didn’t have a single good song” or “the internet has done no good” variety.
- marcellus23 4y ago> It’s clickbait because it asserts something surprising and extreme about a movie that is generally considered to be very good "Bad writing" is not suprising or extreme, just an opinion. And "very good" is subjective — we're talking about movies here, i.e. art. This isn't a review of programming languages where there's an objective reality of pros and cons to consider. I haven't seen Glass Onion, but I saw Knives Out and while it was a decent film, I think comparing it to the Beatles or the Internet is a bit silly. It sounds like you really enjoyed the film and are just annoyed that someone else didn't.
- version_five 4y agoI'll just chime in to say I liked it. I see the author's point about a somewhat lazy plot device, but I didn't really think about that until now. Maybe I'm lacking context - to me it's a Netflix movie and in the top 5% easily of what's on there. It was an entertaining movie that had lots of funny parts. What else do you want? The critics long winded explanations, often requiring analogies, of what was inconsistent, seem like he had to think too hard to find something to criticize
- barnabee 4y agoYeah, the author mostly just makes it seem like being a movie critic is a great way to ruin your ability to enjoy movies.
- guerrilla 4y agoIs this here because Miles Bron is an anagram for Elon is Mr B? "It’s practically a hit piece on Elon Musk" yeah duh, author must be a real smart one. Don't usually see movie reviews here otherwise. I thought it was pretty good, quite funny at times, fun mystery. I liked first one better but by no means was it bad.
- HWR_14 4y agoThe character has an obsession with repeating a single letter in his company names/products and big sources of changing the world are rockets, cars, and a news site. He also is clearly into crypto (if you look at the background). It's not a far leap.
- adrian_b 4y agoI admit that I have also wondered whether there is any allusion to Elon, mainly because he is a notorious eccentric CEO. Nevertheless, I have been amused by this movie much more than I assume that most of its viewers have been, because Miles Bron, more than resembling what I know about Elon, had an uncanny resemblance to the CEO of a startup where I have worked some years ago. The resemblance was complete, in behavior, in speech, in the dyslexic words invented continuously, in the content of the fax messages with product feature suggestions (though my CEO used e-mail, not fax). So I wonder how many such CEOs exist and whether the script writer has completely made up the Miles Bron character or he has indeed used a real-life CEO as inspiration.
- josephpmay 4y agoThe show is a far better sendoff of the mid-2010’s tech bro than anything on HBO’s Silicon Valley
- morelisp 4y agoIt's absolutely wild to see people on this forum of all places saying they can't relate to the characters' social interactions. Thanks for a laugh even after the film is over, Rian.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- LordN00b 4y agoStill reading it, but to the first point about the starting hour. Yo-Yo ma sets up the flashbacks, and the structure of the movie as a fugue. A melody thats played upon and expanded. The first reveal that the writer says 'renders the movies first hour pointless..' is an example of that. Benoits seeming fawning of Miles, 'inadvertant' needling of his intelligence (childish puzzles) are shown to be part of Blancs own deceit. And in fact all, the flashbacks extend information you already knew, Duke, Whisky and, Miles, for example. That's the smart thing about these dumb murders, its in the composition itself, and not the characters, or the plot driving it. I had a whale of time watching it, and loved the mundanity of the crimes and the fact it was just dumb people in this rich persons playworld.
- ageitgey 4y agoGlass Onion takes the well-worn detective genre and creates some genuinely surprising moments by "cheating" a little with what it shows the audience. This article says it should have played it straight. I think that would have made for a more standard, boring movie. But whatever, that's just opinion. But I think it is silly to call it bad writing. Bad implies that the writer didn't have command of their craft. It is clearly all very deliberate and designed to create something surprising in a genre where that is very difficult. Like it or hate it, at least it tried something instead of just being another remake of Agatha Christie's "And Then There Was One".
- sliken 4y agoDunno, I felt let down. Mysteries reward those paying close attention, everyone builds their pet theory on what happened "The butler did it!" and plays along being a detective. But instead the movie shows you what didn't happen, like grabbing a poisoned drink, and only later shows what really happened, being handed a poisoned drink. Seems just lazy and lame.
- cantaloupe 4y agoThe original scene showed what did happen: the drink being handed rather than picked up. You can see it right before the 59’ mark. The drink being picked up was only shown in the later “memory” and was immediately pointed out to be a false memory.
- brookst 4y agoWell said. The author is basically complaining that their steak dinner was the worst pizza they’ve ever had.
- swivelmaster 4y agoIncredible analogy! I love it!
- ivan_gammel 4y agoExcept that this was not a steak dinner, not even close. It was a microwave pizza with ananas served in “Italian” restaurant.
- clarkdale 4y agoIt would be interesting to watch an edit played in chronological order. A similar response was made to Passengers[1], where if it is NOT made chronologically, the director could have an opportunity to push the theme entirely close to a horror genre. 1. https://youtu.be/Gksxu-yeWcU https://youtu.be/Gksxu-yeWcU
- ghaff 4y agoInteresting. Passengers also had at least one fairly nonsensical effect scene and some plot points that just didn't make sense. But, yeah, with some fairly modest changes it could IMO have been a notably better film. For me, it's definitely in the category of films that are frustratingly close to having all of the ingredients but doesn't pull them together properly. The Circle is another one. If ever a film called out for a satirical take on its source material, it was that one.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Hamuko 4y ago>It would be interesting to watch an edit played in chronological order. Don't know about that. I've heard that if you watch Memento in chronological order, it is very uninteresting.
- jccalhoun 4y agoThe film wasn't perfect but these complaints are not very compelling to me. The cheat of "what you thought you saw wasn't what you saw" is kind of a lazy cheat but it is very common in detective and heist films. The point about whether the sister who journaled everything wouldn't have journaled about creating the software is a good one and the conceit of the twin being able to fool the friends is also a good point but is also a tried and true cliche.
- musingsole 4y ago> The point about whether the sister who journaled everything wouldn't have journaled about creating the software Where does it say she didn't journal about the software? And - imagining said entry - even if you could prove the date the entry was written, it's still just hearsay against the testimony of 4 others.
- browningstreet 4y agoWhen JM showed up in the island, Miles should’ve had a reaction to her presence. The cheat is worsened when the movie doesn’t ever tell us how he reacted, even after the fact. IMO it qualifies as a giant plot hole.
- morelisp 4y ago> When JM showed up in the island, Miles should’ve had a reaction to her presence. The shot lingers on literally the same facial expression when she arrives on the island as when he first sees her again after he shoots her.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- browningstreet 4y agoI should’ve been more clear. He may have reacted in his face, but it’s never addressed, even in a private moment. Given the potential realm of implications to her presence, he just… carried on. Same as he planned. And I’d argue her presence, plus the addition of an investigator… can’t reasonably be ignored, or dismissed. Which, in the story, it seems to have been.
- rendall 4y ago> Glass Onion: A Knives Out Mystery might be one of the worst written movies I’ve ever seen. Then this person has not seen very many movies. > And now Glass Onion will haunt me for the rest of my days. I don't care too much for this superlative, unduly passionate style of pop culture critique even if it is a joke. I enjoy reading negative critique of movies I like, as long as it shows understanding that reasonable people can disagree. This is not that.
- automatoney 4y agoThe author also "absolutely loathed Star Wars: The Last Jedi" which to me feels like an overreaction to a movie.
- lostgame 4y agoOh; wow, worst example ever. Ten minutes into that movie when Leia somehow comes back to in deep space I was ready to walk out of the theatre. It’s not an ‘overreaction’ to see The Last Jedi as a fundamentally awful film, it’s just the knee-jerk reaction most people I know who have seen it have gotten. Whether you’re a Star Wars fan or not; ‘The Last Jedi’ is just a clear-as-day not-good film. But when you do actually take the time to analyze it and compare it to the original trilogy; it’s borderline unbelievable just how God-awful it really is. I also never understood the idea that they hadn’t just kept the same director for the three films. 7/8/9 feels less like a trilogy than a disjointed mess of films imitating far better films.
- kevingadd 4y agoSounds like the director's style just doesn't work for them at all.
- snickerbockers 4y agoit's not an overreaction to that movie.
- paulryanrogers 4y agoWhy?
- mypastself 4y agoI’m geniunely wondering what the audience is supposed to get from all the 2020 references (Covid, Among Us, Zoom, Twitch), and the barrage of celebrity name-drops. I feel like the film was written for some specific Twitter subculture Rian Johnson is a part of, and maybe they find all the references hilarious. The mystery is dull, the dialogue obnoxious, the jokes unfunny, and the camera has that patented ugly digital Netflix look. By the time the movie picks up about an hour in, I had long stopped caring. It’s a shame because I enjoyed the first one. It’s a shocking drop in quality.
- drewcoo 4y ago> all the 2020 references (Covid, Among Us, Zoom, Twitch), and the barrage of celebrity name-drops Today's mystery, tomorrow's "beach blanket?" Haven't seen it, but if it's campy enough, it could have staying power.
- mypastself 4y agoThat’s actually a good point. I suppose the film might have some nostalgia appeal for specific groups of people decades from now. I suspect I’m going to dislike it even more, though.
- GaryNumanVevo 4y agoHuh, sorry you had a bad time watching it at home. It looked great in theatres!
- cramjabsyn 4y agoIs it shocking? Sequels are notorious for being this way. It’s rare that a sequel can capture lightning in a bottle in the same way as the original.
- mypastself 4y agoI don’t know if you’ve seen the movie, but it’s almost a completely different style and tone. Sequels tend to play it safe and try to redo the original, but Johnson instead tried to make a completely different film. I’m wondering if Netflix gave him much greater creative freedom, and if the original movie would have been much worse without studio notes.
- vander_elst 4y ago[spoiler warning] Just watched the movie yesterday evening and I was also quite disappointed, some of the choices did seem cheap, the twin, the book stopping the bullet, the "punishment" of Miles by the destruction of the Mona Lisa. I think that the movie had some potential, but after the twin reveal everything started going south. Edit: added warning
- fxtentacle 4y agoMaybe you should add a spoiler warning. BTW I thought the punishment was very good writing. As long as he's rich, all will lie to protect him. Once the source of his money - which is he reputation of Klear - is destroyed, all of them stop lieing to cover for him. I thought it highlighted their hypocrisy exceptionally well.
- vander_elst 4y agoImo if you destroy the Mona Lisa to punish a person, you don't punish a person, you destroy the Mona Lisa.
- devaler 4y agoI agree, and this plot point unsuspends my disbelief more than any others.
- lukas099 4y agoWhen the twin destroyed that painting, she became the villain of the movie.
- paulryanrogers 4y agoNot the one who paid off a government to take a national treasure, then recklessly bypassed the security controls for their own amusement? Or launch an unsafe product for the general public?
- 4y ago
- vletal 4y agoI'd not mind the structure and flashbacks if - the first act was not so slow and boring, failing to actually introduce the characters - the finale was not so dumb... At first I felt a little bored. At the end I was disappointed. Only the middle of the movie was kinda fun.
- DoneWithAllThat 4y agoWe are seriously in the dark ages of writing right now. It’s not that good books, movies and tv shows aren’t being made, but most of the top tier a list stuff is just astoundingly awful and amateurish. It’s like these industries are trying to make hot garbage now and only occasionally goof up and accidentally end up with a good story.
- snickerbockers 4y agoThe problem's that all these big franchise movies can be terrible but still set new ticket sales records. Audiences aren't showing up to watch the new JJ Abrams or Rian Johnson movie, they're showing up to see the new Star Wars movie. Even if it gets bad reviews everybody still wants to see what happens next with Luke and the gang. Then movie pulls in record ticket sales and the studio execs think that means it's a success so they reward the same writers and directors with more movie contracts.
- csours 4y agoSpoilers-ish (this happens pretty early in the movie) Janelle Monae smashes open a mystery box with a hammer, which is direct commentary on JJ Abrams Mystery Box writing. This movie is very very well written. Nearly every detail is paid off.
- erwinh 4y agojohnson seems to be hyper self aware of what he is doing and i’m here for it! In a way its a similar debate to the one on SW VIII where he was going too meta on the nature of the force which caught a whole bunch of fans off guard.
- csours 4y agoI'd really really love to know what happened on the inside with this movie and the 7/8/9 trilogy. Rian Johnson is extremely detail oriented and the movie we got was mostly soup.
- HWR_14 4y agoHow did JJ Abrams come into it?
- morelisp 4y agoWhen you pillory a lot of dumb people's idea of a smart person, it's not unsurprising you piss off a lot of dumb people.
- 4y ago
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- etempleton 4y agoI too was disappointed with "Glass Onion: A Knives Out Mystery." My first struggle with the movie is that it breaks the first rule of a good mystery story in that you need the audience to have enough information that they can plausibly solve the crime themselves. Glass Onion only provides information when it becomes relevant to move the plot along. You could have never known certain things, you could have never even guessed at them because the information did not exist right up until it was needed in the story.This happens repeatedly. Midway through there is a plot twist that you could have never guessed or seen coming and that pretty much ends any sense of suspense or intrigue. I also don't care about any of the people in the story as people or characters nor do I find any of their relationships convincing. It seems implausible that any of them would have ever been friends. Close your eyes and imagine these people hanging out at a bar together and you can't. How did they interact? What was their friendship like? You never see it and so the weight of the strain of the existing relationship isn't ever fully felt. The characters in a "Knives Out" were caricatures too, but they were family, not friends. Everyone knows that strain. Everyone can relate to that relationship dynamic. You don't get to choose family. Friends tend to match each other to some extent. Give them some kind of connection. They are all trivia nerds and were a trivia team. Anything. With all that said, I want to rewatch "Glass Onion: A Knives Out Mystery." I want to see how much was visible in scene. How much could I have technically figured out. It is an interesting movie, I am just not sure it is a very good one.
- ghaff 4y agoThat's a good description. I didn't like it as much as the original but, like you, I actually want to rewatch it now to better appreciate the whole thing. Certainly it's not a bad movie. I'm just not sure it really hangs together at the end of the day.
- dctoedt 4y agoI thought it was more a send-up of mysteries, in roughly the same vein as 1980's Airplane! (including the celebrity cameos).
- ghaff 4y ago
- gilbetron 4y agoWe really enjoyed it, loved the twists and turns. Without spoiling it, the seen with Benoit and the iPad and crossbow was amazing on many different levels. Someone else mentioned Star Wars The Last Jedi, and that was my favorite of the sequel trilogy (although not without flaws!), so I think I just really enjoy the director. Some people don't, which is fair, whereas I find JJ Abrams to be dull and uninspired and utterly lacking in depth, the complete opposite of Rian's work. The film missed a couple of beats for me, so it isn't perfect by any means (neither was Last Jedi!), but it was really entertaining and clever.
- k2xl 4y agoAlso disliked the movie for similar but also different reasons. The first is the political layer on top of the film. Miles is obviously supposed to be Elon - "everyone thinks is genius but is an idiot" and the Twitch guy is supposed to be Joe Rogan who "got banned on Twitch for touting Rhino pills" (referencing the ivermectin that CNN [in which Jake Tapper has a cameo in the film] called a horse dewormer). Kind of ruined the movie for me because it felt a bit of a collection of character hit pieces. Another issue is the whole ending seemed poorly written. As the OP mentions it seems weird that Helen/Andi would be left alone with Miles. Also why wouldn't Miles, with all his wealth and resources not be able to hide how the Mona Lisa was destroyed?
- matthewdgreen 4y agoIt’s pretty amusing because “Elon Musk is kind of dim-witted” is a much more popular characterization after his Twitter takeover saga, but this was made before.
- Havoc 4y agoI liked it. Though went in with no major expectations of a cerebral murder mystery
- smcl 4y agoThe film was released a little while back, why are there suddenly a bunch of exaggerated opinions like this being published right now? Ben Shapiro was also complaining about it on Twitter, and there have been a handful of others. I personally enjoyed it, not quite as much as I enjoyed the original and I imagine there are people who didn't particularly like it. That's totally fine, everyone has different tastes, but I find it hard to believe these people truly hated the movie as much as they claim. It feels a bit performative.
- gnutrino 4y agoI think the only thing missing from the movie is that they should have established that Andi had a sister, and maybe allude to the fact she has a twin or very similar looking sister. I think the twist was good actually, and you see why Miles was so shocked that Andi shows up to the party. That would have made the first hour of the movie more interesting.
- morelisp 4y agoI think there are a few hints - for example, the mythical Cassandra and Helen were also (non-mutual) twins, and putting a "Cassandra" and "Helen" on a Greek island (and maybe also in some sense "Paris") you're definitely being primed to think in that direction. I would need to watch it again to see if there's something more blatant as she shows up. My nitpick is that Peg felt mostly extraneous - the main plot beat conversation with Peg could've been a conversation with Birdie directly. (And Derol is already present as the extraneous-for-the-sake-of-it element.)
- balsam 4y agoRian Johnson based the central character on Elon (amongst other billionaires), but admits that the portrayal turned out to be closer to Musk than he intended: https://www.forbes.com/sites/paultassi/2022/12/26/glass-onion-both-is-and-isnt-about-elon-musk-says-rian-johnson/?sh=68e57bd31eb5 https://www.forbes.com/sites/paultassi/2022/12/26/glass-onio...
- Hamuko 4y agoI feel bad for Rian Johnson, since before the whole Twitter fiasco, it was more plausible for idiot tech billionaire to not be a Musk wearing a mask. But with how badly the Twitter purchase went down after the Glass Onion was written, it's hard to watch it without thinking of Musk.
- prepend 4y agoIt makes more sense if you view it through a political lens where everything is justified based on the evil of Brons. So anything bad flows from him so mistakes of others could be forgiven. Destroying the Mona Lisa is worth it because it punishes Brons. The movie had some high points and I thought it was fun, but the story had many flaws. I think it’s best not to overthink it too much.
- popilewiz 4y agoI liked this movie quite a bit. It didn't have as much charm as the first one and slightly less mystery, but it made up for it in comedy and cultural commentary. Really glad that this is a franchise now