7 ms·
Toyota chief says ‘silent majority’ has doubts about pursuing only EVs
- MBCook 4y agoAmazing how the “silent majority” can never actually be found but always agrees with person invoking them.
- asddubs 4y agoI guess if i thought the silent majority disagreed with me, i would just shut up about it
- LudwigNagasena 4y ago99% of cars sold by Toyota in fiscal year 2022 were either ICE (72%) or hybrid (27%).
- dagmx 4y agoHow many Toyota EV's are actually available though? There's basically only the Prius Prime that was available, and it's at a price point where there are better EV's to get. There's the bZ4X as well but I've never seen one available anywhere. They have a bunch of stuff announced for 2023 though. Using Toyota as the barometer is only really useful for Toyota. It's not a great reflection of the rest of the market.
- dragonwriter 4y ago> How many Toyota EV’s are actually available though? Model year 2022 in the US, if you exclude non-plugin hybrids, then Prius Prime (PHEV) and Mirai (FCEV) seem to be the only two; 2023 adds RAV4 Prime (PHEV), and bZ4X (BEV).
- dagmx 4y agoAh yeah I always forget about the RAV4 Prime since it arrived so much later. Though looking at the price, similar to the Prius Prime, there are so many better EVs, and it's hard finding a dealer with them in stock to begin with. I personally wouldn't count the Mirai, since it's a weird lame duck. Limited availability (only california and hawaii iirc??) and IMHO nobody sane was buying one unless they got it on the often crazy deals you could find (I think you could get one brand new for <20k, and last years model at 11k at one point)
- nicoburns 4y agoI'd be willing to bet a lot of money people would jump at the chance to buy Toyota EVs if they actually put effort into making them for the mainstream market.
- moonchrome 4y agoI got a Toyota CHR with the intention of it being a second car long term and was counting on going electric for the upgrade - but looking at the prices if I go electric I might as well jump up in class - cost of batteries seems to make price jumps between classes a much smaller % than ICE. Basically there are no cheap electric cars, if I'm paying a lot might as well pay for the premium brand.
- KerrAvon 4y agoI’ve looked for a Toyota EV for sale in the near future that I would actually want to buy and could not find one. Meanwhile, at other automakers: Chevrolet Bolt, Tesla {S,X}, Hyundai Ioniq 5 and 6, VW ID.4, Ford Mach-E. Jaguar, Mercedes, BMW, Lucid all have theoretical contenders. And I’m probably missing a few from other manufacturers. Toyota is behind. edit: formatting
- MBCook 4y agoHow many Toyota BEVs were available to buy? From searching Toyota only planned to make 7,000 for the US this year. And then ended up with a stop sale due to a safety issue. Toyota sold about 1.8 million cars in the US last year. So it would have been 0.388% of their production for the US. That’s not a failure to sell. That’s a failure to try. Every other manufacturer can’t keep BEVs in stock. (Still ahead of Honda who currently has ZERO full EVs models for sale in the US)
- kirykl 4y agoLate to market, early to market. Business strategies that play out in the marketplace. Not everything needs to follow lockstep with headlines
- jqpabc123 4y agoAnd the "silent manority" really means Toyota. Toyota has lots of jobs and industry and know-how built around the internal combustion engine --- and therein lies their concern.
- nonethewiser 4y agoWell if the market wants EVs and they don't have them, then they're fucked. They have every incentive to come to an accurate conclusion.
- givemeethekeys 4y agoThey can also come up with the right conclusion but publicly promote the opposite conclusion. They wouldn't say, "Oh yeah, EV's are awesome! Go get EVs" when they don't have one that people want to buy.
- epolanski 4y agoThey are launching multiple EVs in the future with the bZ4X being the first. Toyota is also the biggest car maker in the world with one of the best reputations, any EV they would make would sell great.
- kjksf 4y agoThat's the theory. Here's the sad, sad, extremely sad reality: bZ4X sales in US in 2022: 05: 199 06: 33 07, 08, 09: zero (they recalled every car and stopped production and sales) 10: 351 (resumed production) Those numbers are not in thousands. That's 351 cars in November. https://carsalesbase.com/us-toyota-bz4x/ https://carsalesbase.com/us-toyota-bz4x/
- epolanski 4y agoMeaningless numbers. Current production is of 1'000 vehicles per month. It's still not produced in high volumes, they need to ramp up production. I can assure you this is going to sell like hotcakes (especially as Toyota offers a 1 million kilometers warranty, good luck driving a tesla even for a third without having to change the battery) and there's no shortage of demand (it's Toyota afterall).
- etchasketch 4y agoI mean...He's not wrong. I'm going to get crucified for saying this, but I suspect hybrids will likely be the future, with EV use picking up slowly (if at all) over the next 20-30 years. Not saying EVs are like 3D TVs, but as it stands right now, EVs are far too expensive for the vast majority of the US population. I'm going to focus on the US for now. The readership for hacker news skews wealthier, but I would like you all to pretend to be broke, for just one second. The cost of a battery pack replacement for EVs are exorbitant, and that battery pack replacement cost all but eliminates whatever potential monetary benefit an individual would derive from driving an EV in the first place. Yes, I know blah blah blah the environment, blah blah blah lower maintenance, but look - broke people already take their car the cheapest mechanic or have uncle joe take a look at it, or just don't maintain it at all. The vast majority of people are going to look and see if its cheaper to buy, own and insure than a regular gas car. The price of a new battery pack for an EV is exorbitant. A chevy bolt battery pack is 8 grand. A tesla pack costs 15k. Other electric vehicles are in the same ballpark. There is no way to get these battery packs new, other than going to a dealer, because "refurbished" packs just keep failing every 2-3 years and you keep replacing cell by cell playing whack a mole until the next cell fails. Ain't nobody paying 10-15k for a battery. You can buy a whole ass car for that amount of money. The readership for hacker news skews wealthier, I know, but truly, there are a lot of people who buy cars for 5-10k and drive them for the next 8-10 years, with rarely an incident. There are a whole lot of people who have never bought a brand "new" car from a dealership in their life. And until EVs get cheap enough to percolate down to the masses, adoption is going to be at a standstill. As an aside - The reputation of car brands is made and destroyed in the used car market. the Prius has an excellent reputation because (despite battery pack woes) there are people who drive those things for 300k miles plus, regularly. I guarantee that if an automaker rushes and builds shitty EVs that ultimately end up being pieces of unreliable shit 5-10 years later on the used car market, that is by far the easiest and fastest way to ruin their their company and drive themselves to insolvency. Tesla is on the cusp of learning this, unfortunately.
- LinuxBender 4y agoI've rented a Prius a couple of times. It's a little small for me but that car was much more zippy than I expected. I know a few people that own one and they've been happy with it for many years. I don't think it would work well here in the snow but if Toyota built a plug-in hybrid AWD Tacoma Crew Cab I would seriously consider it, especially if there is no telemetry junk in it.
- epolanski 4y agoFor sure most europe doesn't and won't have enough electricity to keep up with EVs, I think EVs should be limited in places like central italy where 90 % of electricity is made from natural gas anyway. It's so inefficient. Hybrids are the least polluting option out there, unless most energy in your region comes from renewables or nuclear. Also don't forget producing an ev is insanely polluting too.
- elgenie 4y agoEven the most efficient ICE engines are dramatically less efficient than the worst natural gas plants (like, on the scale of 25% versus 60%), the economies of scale at utilities allow for future improvements and pollution capture, and that's without accounting for the inefficiencies involved in transporting and refining marginal oil and then transporting and distributing the marginal gasoline (and the constant gas station trips for fill-ups). If your local electricity generation mix is 100% made up of the dirtiest possible coal being shoveled into the least efficient possible power plant, then sure, maybe, it'd be comparable over the lifetime of the car… except for the obvious possibility that said plant could be retired, upgraded, or the car moved elsewhere. Battery manufacture does produce pollution, but it's also a process that can be improved over time, and the break-even point for an EV battery is at something tiny like 5K miles driven. https://www.epa.gov/greenvehicles/electric-vehicle-myths https://www.epa.gov/greenvehicles/electric-vehicle-myths
- akmarinov 4y agoItaly, one of the sunniest countries in Europe, should do ok.
- derekp7 4y agoI really think PHEV would be idea, if only they had just a bit more electric-only range. Many of them only get you 25 miles or so on electric only, so you would still end up using the gas engine quite a bit. Bring that up to 40 - 60 miles, then you can do 95% of your driving on electric only. So I've heard the argument about "why haul around a gas engine you are only going to use 5% of the time". The same thing can be said about all electric -- in that case you really need a 300 mile or so battery instead of the 50 mile battery, but most days you will be hauling around 250+ miles of extra battery you will only be using 5% of the time. Also, on a PHEV, I'd like to see the gas engine be just barely enough horse power to drive the car (and keep some minimal charge on the battery). And have it use that in conjunction with the electric motors for acceleration. That way the gas engine can be kept even more light weight.
- sethgrisham 4y agoNot sure about other car manufacturers, but I know Toyota is having trouble building up their battery infrastructure, which is why their PHEV range is lacking as of yet.
- greenonions 4y agoI'm naive about this topic, but I think other factors to consider are the manufacturing and maintenance. A PHEV just can't be as efficient to manufacture as a BEV. This is particularly true as investment dollars follow the money into batteries and the ICE supplier chain grows tighter. Then, once you've got it, you still need to maintain it like an ICE, even though you'd rather just use the battery. That being said, I think PHEVs are great, but I think consumers and producers both see greater benefits moving to full BEV. Edit: grammar
- davewritescode 4y agoThis is precisely the road Mazda appears to be taking. When they introduced the CX-30 electric lots of folks were disappointed with range. If the rumors are to be believed, Mazda will be introducing a rotary engine range extender with some interesting technology. In my opinion, this is probably the best option for now. I'd much rather 4x as many range extended hybrids with 50 mile-ish range than 200 mile range electric cars.
- unwise-exe 4y agoMy car is a decade and a half old, and still works well enough. Not having to visit a gas station ever, would be kinda nice. Having to get a rental for longer trips once or twice a year would be mildly annoying. A hybrid with enough battery range for daily use would probably be fine. An EV that can be hybridified with a generator on a trailer would probably also be fine.
- dsfyu404ed 4y agoExactly. Most people just aren't that vested in this so long as they aren't facing a cost increase or substantial convienince downgrade.
- JumpinJack_Cash 4y agoThat is absolutely right. People will always swear by something when asked in polls but pollsters will never explain the tradeoffs. The tradeoffs for electrification are too complex and the downside too big. All for the benefit of people who will be alive 150 years from now. It doesnt make sense from a gametheory perspective. The E in ESG will either drop or will have to be transformed in “Ecology” At the end of the day when you dig deep enough it’s clear that this is all about the need that the elites have of having a shot at being the person who gets remembered as having solved the biggest problem ever in the history of humanity . A leap that would put the moon landing to shame, but the non-elites have much more stringent , less grandiose needs and although they can be convinced of all sorts of BS , I dont think they can go against their interests in such a big way
- stuven 4y agoWell put. I'm glad we're making them.
- balderdash 4y ago“…the legacy auto makers have a much broader base of customers, including many living in rural areas and developing economies with unreliable electricity supplies.” Seems pretty uncontroversial
- olliej 4y agoI don't get this "everyone must be EV only" mentality - utility companies in the US are already complaining about the strain EV cars put on the grid, and again that's in the US, there are huge swathes of the world that need cars and trucks, but do not necessarily have any grid at all, not even an unreliable one. If every manufacturer goes EV only, then you'll just get new manufacturers popping up to serve the fairly giant "EV is not viable" option.
- jnsaff2 4y agoThe funny part is that Toyota has a very long experience with EV technology. Everyone I have talked to in the EV conversion communities are really impressed by how good the Toyota hybrid inverters are. Their petulance does not make sense to me unless you account the musk factor of big personalities in. They could easily dominate the EV market but they just don't want to. Yet. Their marketing is also borderline criminal, Lexus still has billboards at my local airport talking about "self-charging hybrids", carefully omitting that you charge your self-charging hybrid at the petrol pump.
- metadat 4y agoArchive link: https://archive.today/ITuv6 https://archive.today/ITuv6
- kjksf 4y agoTo put this in context: this is not the first time Toyota advocates anti-EV point of view. In the beginning of this year the same guy (Akio Toyoda) was spreading all the EV FUD there is: electrification will tank the (Japanese) economy, the electric grid will collapse, no-one needs electric cars etc. He just might be right about tanking the Japanese economy but not because "EV bad" but because Toyota and Honda and their suppliers are big parts of the economy and they are laggards among laggards on EV adoption front. And it's not just words but money and lobbying: Toyota joined Trump's lawsuit against EPA (now dropped) and is among the largest anti-EV lobbyists, in the great company of oil giants. Anti-EV lobbying means: lobbying against increased fuel efficiency standards and ICE bans. Given that China is already 30% EV, Europe ~25% their position doesn't seem rational but purely talking their book and trying to not get killed by mistakes they made in the last 5-10 years. Until mid-2022 they were selling more hydrogen cars (1) than EV cars (0). Hence their bizarre "we're pro EV but ALSO pro hydrogen" stance. Hydrogen lost and there's no path to hydrogen becoming a thing for passenger cars. They are also waiting their time working on manual transmission for electric cars. It's peak stupid. But most importantly they only have 1 EV on sale (with a genius name of bz4x) and it doesn't sells well. Rumor has it that they just decided that their e-TNGA platform used in bZ4X is not cost-competitive with Tesla and started working on a new EV platform that won't be ready in 4 years. https://www.reuters.com/business/autos-transportation/exclusive-toyota-scrambles-ev-reboot-with-eye-tesla-2022-10-24/ https://www.reuters.com/business/autos-transportation/exclus...
- VintageCool 4y agoJapan as a whole bet heavily on hydrogen. The rest of the world is going to battery electric vehicles, and the Japanese auto manufacturers are way behind the curve.
- happyjack 4y agoIf can replace my 2001 Toyota Tacoma with 300k miles in 10 years with another Tacoma, I don't care what Toyota does with the rest of the line up.
- kkfx 4y agoA simple observation: EV are a tech evolutionary need because we have peaked the possible evolution of current ICEs, we have tried some other ICEs in the past but with no success on scale so to evolve we need something else. Electrical motors are known to be effective (far more than ICE) and keep evolving so are a natural replacement candidate. Than arrive the issue: electrical motors are fantastic compared, more power, constant torque, far wider rotation range, far less thermal issues, far lighter, cheaper, ... BUT we damn need electricity. Electricity is the problem since it's a hard form of energy for us. Drill a hole to milk some oil is not simple as it sound, but it's also not that hard in tech terms, oil hold much energy in a compact volume and mass, we can move around and store for very long with very little issue. Electricity is far more complex. Lithium tech just reach the level of BARE MINIMUM on-scale usability, since suffice from small pocket torch to cars, it does not last enough but still enough IF we will been able to recycle batteries (so far many experiments exists BUT none usable on scale because scale IS the issue) so it's promising. I do not know and I pretend to be arrogantly pretty sure NOBODY really know if such move will be successful or a disaster BUT we need to try to see. The sore reality is that the sole way to try without much risks is the public. We need public research so to have a damn standard that allow interoperability, for instance is DAMN STUPID to being unable to couple a car's battery BMS to a p.v. MPPT simply because no such standard exists so far and competing vendors try to push their own, it's equally a pity we need to charge from p.v. (DC) to an AC inverter to another AC inverter in car to DC again because those who crafted actual tech need to mach different layers of crap from different vendors. It's a pity we do not have a build standard for batteries to allow a bit less complex recycling and so on. These are still SMALL POTATOES issues, but are costly issue due to the current development model. Bigger issues lie in uncertain about how much lithium we can harvest and when we will been able to recycle batteries effectively, IF we can. The typical public research is: we try in a lab, we start experimenting with some public body, let's say a PUBLIC postal service cars, some army services etc, we correct issues emerged from such experiments and keep going experimenting for a while until we think tech is mature enough to try the big scale. We go to the public with some incentives crafted to allow a proper development like "the government subsidies buying an EV only in certain areas where the electricity grid it's ready, if the Citizen have a private parking place to recharge etc" something no private company can do. The again few iterations to correct new emerging issues and a wider cohort of public testers. The the first opening to commerce and so to anyone. This was essentially the classic way of evolution even the USA have done WHEN they innovate for real, like pharma research by universities and NIH, like public funded labs from PARC to NASA. Now with the WEF corporatocracy model such effective system got dismantled and research costs got offloaded to the people, pushing them with crappy advantages if they accept to pay or forcing them to pay. Personally I have an EV and a classic European diesel, I like the EV but it's designed by some who do not drive them, do not have p.v., do not have any damn clue about cars. It's just a crapload of crapware on a classic car, with a nice visual. We need to mandate FLOSS in cars, mandate NO proprietary services allowed to send OTA, mandate some standards like the aforementioned DC bi-directional coupling (who exists now, but just since few months [1]) and mandatory policies on batteries imposing an EV at the same price of the equivalent ICE. We need to KILL the PSP market for public charging: those who install charging stations also sell the energy directly paid with any classic payment means just like gas/diesel ones and so on. [1] https://www.iso.org/fr/standard/77845.html https://www.iso.org/fr/standard/77845.html
- dsfyu404ed 4y agoI don't really care much about the actual substance here. I'm sure they'll figure out EVs. I'm sure EVs will get better over time. On a more meta note, nobody degrades online automotive discourse to a very low common denominator quite as reliably as Toyota fanboys and the vast majority of those people are secondarily EV fans so it really brings a tear of joy to my eye seeing this topic sow division among a group of mild-grade trolls.