10 ms·
AI breakthrough ChatGPT raises alarm over student cheating
- jgalt212 4y agoI think the model to handle this is similar to how Computer Algebra Systems have been handled. Or one could write a good ChatGPT detector.
- pyinstallwoes 4y agoBut then you could train ChatGPT on the detector
- jupp0r 4y agoThen students will become proficient in training AI models. Disaster!
- danuker 4y agoReminds me of stories where people get fired for automating their job away
- jhbadger 4y agoOr that could be how they learn. It reminds me of professors that let you create a exam "cheat sheet" (a single page in which you were allowed to include any facts or equations you thought might help you on the exam). So we spent hours scouring the textbook and assignments for good stuff to put on the cheat sheet. When it came time for the test, we often found out we rarely had to consult our sheet -- the act of creating it made us absorb the material.
- bestcoder69 4y agoMake the word problems problematic so ChatGPT refuses to answer them. Bing-bong simple.
- bestcoder69 4y agoHow is chatgpt, in particular, the breakthrough? Seems like you can get similar results in other models, right?
- amanj41 4y agoIt's an accessible interface that has gone viral enough for non-technical students to catch wind of & use it.
- makestuff 4y agoIMO searching on stack overflow/googling requires some level of technical understanding. Ex: You can't just paste your homework problem into google and get an answer. However, ChatGPT is just a better/high level of abstraction of google search. You can 100% paste in a full leetcode question and get an answer. Obviously it is wrong sometimes, but in the next few years it will become more accurate. This is no different than the people I was in CS with who would just copy other people's projects/homework though. If you want to use ChatGPT for 4 years in college and then are able to get a job and do the job somehow I don't really care. I would be surprised if you could do the job well, but I am sure some people will be able to.
- shagie 4y agoIts the ease at which it can properly handle plain English to access its knowledge. I am a highly intelligent question answering bot. I will determine the truthfulness of a statement. If the statement is true, I will respond with {true}. If the statement is false, I will respond with {false}. If I am unable to determine the correct answer, I will respond with {unknown}. Q: The country to the north of the United States is Mexico. Other settings include "stop sequence" as carriage return, inject start text: "\nA:" and "Inject restart text: \n\nQ:" Q: The Spanish-American war was fought in 1898. Just quizzing it on T/F questions that one would expect of a 9th grade level homework that is "did you read the assigned text?" level of cursory knowledge, it gets a better than guessing, not perfect, likely passing grade. So, here's $0.04 worth of compute, I type in all the homework and I get all the answers. I am a highly intelligent question answering bot. For a given prompt, I will write two to four sentences about the subject based on historical truth. Q: What was the cause of the Spanish American War? A: The Spanish American War was a conflict between the United States and Spain that began in April 1898. The immediate cause of the war was the explosion of the USS Maine in Havana harbor in February 1898. The US blamed Spain for the explosion, and used it as a pretext to declare war. The US also sought to gain control of Cuba, which had been under Spanish rule since the 16th century. The war ended in August 1898 with a US victory, resulting in Spain ceding control of Cuba, Puerto I didn't give it enough tokens for an answer range... lets double that and append on "Write at a 9th grade level of vocabulary." And I get back this time: A: The Spanish American War was a conflict between the United States and Spain that began in 1898. It was caused by the growing tensions between the two countries over the issue of Cuban independence. The US had been supporting the Cuban rebels in their fight for independence from Spain, and when the Spanish government refused to negotiate, the US declared war. The war lasted just over three months and resulted in a US victory, with Spain ceding control of Cuba, Puerto Rico, and the Philippines to the US. Getting that level of response, and yes, it is correct, so that someone could in plain English write out the homework assignment and hand in the results and get a passing grade on that assignment. The breakthrough is the ability to get ask the information in simple text combined with the ability to get back the answer in simple text. When asked questions correctly, GPT could probably get a passing grade for most classes that involve writing (foreign languages, social studies, and English literature) in high school and likely even in college (though there the short form answers are less common) with only minor effort (and arguably, even less effort than it takes to cheat/get answers other ways that would produce comparable results).
- nickelcitymario 4y agoI've heard this concern a lot lately. It's understandable. But I think it's shortsighted. Does using a calculator make you a cheater at math? No, you still needed to understand the concepts. Does using ChatGPT make you a cheater at school? While ultimately that's up to the schools to decide, I would argue it shouldn't. Because you need to have enough understanding to ask the right question as well as to be able to spot what's wrong in the answer. For example, I was helping my kid out with their Java homework and we we're both stuck for a good hour. Finally I loaded the question into ChatGPT. The answer that came back helped us solve the problem. But we didn't just cut and paste. We looked at that solution and compared it to our own to find the problem. I don't consider that cheating. Others may feel differently. Ultimately, I think of this as augmented thinking. In the real world, we all use whatever tools we have at our disposal. If in the real world we have access to Google and calculators and now AI chatbots, why should we train and educate ourselves as if those don't exist? I'd rather my kids learn to use every tool at their disposal to be as fast, efficient, and effective as possible. And unlike paying someone to do your homework, this is something everyone can do, not just those with discretionary income. So I really have no problem with this at all.
- verdenti 4y agoDon’t be silly. There’s no way to do a writing course without extensively writing about a prompt. With chatGPT just plug it in and out pops your finished essay. You have learnt nothing besides some minor comprehension skills. Same with programming courses. It will answer all basic coding prompts. You cannot learn by just reading through a solved solution no matter how much you want to make the case for it.
- jupp0r 4y ago"I'd rather my kids learn to use every tool at their disposal to be as fast, efficient, and effective as possible." But that's not how (pre college) education works for the most part, unfortunately. It's lots of fact learning and essay busywork, not a lot of actual problem solving and critical thinking.
- sc2862 4y ago
- jerrygenser 4y agoIdea: Not exactly sure how it would be implemented, but some sort of virtual proctoring for writing essays that prevents usage of chatgpt or similar tools?
- jupp0r 4y agoWhat happened to preparing kids for life?
- jrumbut 4y agoYou're always preparing kids for life, the question is what kind of life are you preparing them for.
- cptcobalt 4y agoThings like this already exist, like Lockdown browser. This doesn't mean they're good for students or effectively measuring learning.
- throwaway23597 4y agoThese tools aren't going away. And I still think ChatGPT is incapable of writing a full essay with parenthetical citations and such that schools require. Perhaps the best solution would be to teach students to use ChatGPT to help improve their sentence structures and grammar, which I think would raise essay and writing quality across the board without explicitly crossing the line into blatant cheating.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- bearjaws 4y agoI had to "AI" proof my technical screening questions for engineers. I was alarmed that about 1/3rd of my questions were easily answered by ChatGPT. Thankfully I've always made about 1/3 my questions from their resume so hopefully they can answer that without GPT... Most of the ones that it did not answer you could tweak the question into ChatGPT to get a correct answer, but would lead to a pretty noticeable delay in answering.
- localhost 4y agoAfter reading your reply here, I did the same with a question that I've calibrated over 100s of in-person interviews with college candidates at Microsoft. This is for both intern and full-time candidates. The goal of the question was to probe for technical competence (my role in the loop). The assumption was that anyone who can remember their data structures and algorithms class can make it through maybe 50% of the question. The question got progressively more challenging so that I could see what happens when the candidate reaches the edges of their knowledge. It starts very fizz-buzzy and if the candidate makes it to the end, there's a deeper discussion of caching impacts on performance and optimizing algorithms. ChatGPT nailed it. Even when I said things like: "can you optimize this program further to maximize the utilization of L2 caches in modern CPUs?" And it did it in <10 minutes. The best candidate I ever saw took 25 minutes and the rest of the candidates took the full allotment of time 45 minutes and none of them got to the discussion of L2 cache optimization. These are candidates from the best schools in the country. This was really impressive.
- periheli0n 4y agoThe bottom line being, you don't need to hire engineers anymore, just ChatGPT operators?
- Workaccount2 4y agoWe are fucked way sooner than we anticipate. Either transformers level out somewhere right around here to give humans a few years (really a decade would be nice) to prepare, or we are going to slam into an event horizon that's impossible to see the other side of. It's unknowable how humanity will react to be pounced on by commoditized intelligence. ChatGPT feels like something that is ahead of schedule. Years ahead of schedule.
- hiidrew 4y agoI successfully used a GPT-2 output identification tool to see whether something was generated using ChatGPT. I think it only works if the text has a minimum number of characters. I imagine it's only a matter of time until Turnitin integrates something like this, or some other start-up comes along in edtech. Either way, the continuous arms race on generative media / identification of it will be fascinating to watch as it unfolds!
- hiidrew 4y agoI think this was the tool I tested it out- https://huggingface.co/openai-detector https://huggingface.co/openai-detector
- ivegotnoaccount 4y agoWell, as explained in some of my other comments, it doesn't seem that effective. Most GPT-generated garbage will probably be GPT-3 based, which doesn't seem to too often trigger as "fake" (got more "human" results when I tested it with ChatGPT), while on the other hand, it says that several of my comments are fake with >99% certainty.
- hiidrew 4y agoI see, that's obviously an issue. I only tested it with something I generated and someone's long form blog post.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- drdaeman 4y agohttps://archive.is/BesJA https://archive.is/BesJA
- dougSF70 4y agoIf the students were studying loquaciousness then ChatGPT would give them an advantage, otherwise while the output is good is probably a 'C' grade rather than an 'A' grade.
- gptadmirer 4y agoThe more you practice, the less you bleed in battle. The more you prepare for interview and study, the less you compete in the job market. People who study Leetcode have virtually eliminated a lot of competition in the interview market alone. Now what's left is the competition between Leetcode practicioners. Leetcode is the best investment I've made in my career so far. I've outearned most of my peers (and people more senior than me), easily. Just by doing Leetcode I can eliminate 90% of the competition? Sign me up! Why not just let the problems sort itself out? If the students want to cheat, let them cheat. The students who really want to learn will learn. This makes the competition between them better. The bottom of the barrel will continue to be the bottom of the barrel, and the successful ones still become successful. We really should stop ascribing to "no child left behind" thinking, and instead encouraging competition between them. Who's gonna work the low paying dirty jobs after all if everyone is smart and capable? It is called "economic ladder" for a reason.
- nynx 4y agoI’m not entirely sure what point you’re making. Is leatcode not akin to cheating in this context? If doing it pushes you to the top, how would this sort out correctly?
- gptadmirer 4y agoYes, Leetcode pushes you to the top. SWE often divided into two camps, those who really refuse to do leetcode and those who do it because they know it will give them advantage. Leetcode actually does make you a better engineer, provided you study deeply for it. Ofc it has diminishing returns, but you are already ahead of the game 99% of the time if you are doing Leetcode. ChatGPT will make some students lazier, and will make some students better. Those students who can use ChatGPT correctly, by taking and observing the output and synthesizing it with their own understanding, will be ahead of the game. Students who are lazy and just copy pasting ChatGPT answers won't, but McDonald's employment is still open for them.
- alfalfasprout 4y ago
- kypro 4y agoI guess I have a fairly cynical take on this. I think this just exposes that AI is fundamentally going to undermine the value of education in certain fields. The fact some tests can be "cheated" by AI really just suggests that some skills have little to no value in our future AI-prevalent world. Stopping people cheating is going to change that. In the same way that in the past being able to do fast, accurate calculations in your head or on paper might have landed you job as a "computer", today technology makes the idea of hiring someone to be a computer absurd. And therefore any tests that test someone's ability to multiply and divide large numbers is basically a worthless test in today's world. Fields where there's value humans can add won't be cheatable by AI (at least today's generations). Tests in these fields will hold value. In some cases it will mean the education and tests will evolve to educate and test areas where humans can still add value - arguably this has already happened in maths. But many fields could be replaced entirely. I don't mean to sound unsympathetic to those who's jobs and professions will replaced by AI in the coming years and decades. It makes me sad that someone could spend years obtaining and perfecting skills which might soon become redundant, but for better or worse AI systems like ChatGPT will fundamentally change the value of some skills and educational fields. The sooner we accept this the better we can adapt society for it.
- visarga 4y agoI give you another anti-cheating solution: test all exams on chatGPT, by giving it first the tasks, then the answers for self grading. If the model fails, use the problem, if not, change it until chatGPT fails. The task should always require human intervention to pass.
- oceanplexian 4y agoI think the purpose of exams is deeply misunderstood. They are supposed to be a feedback system for the teacher and the student so the student can improve. They’re not a competition or an intelligence measuring stick. ChatGPT is kind of the perfect tool for that; if a student doesn’t understand maybe AI can help then get to the right answer and give them personalized attention. Something that IMO teachers fail at due to the nature of large class sizes where teachers can’t help tutor each student.
- phonescreen_man 4y agoMy son came to me the other day asking about some properties of material question for his engineering BTEC, it just happened the night before I had been playing around with chatGPT for ffmpeg commands and stable diffusion prompts. I told him about it and he got right on it. It answered the question for him with plenty of extra info he had not considered. He tried to add it as a reference ,the instructor said it was not allowed. However the instructor who had never heard of chatGPT was so impressed he started using it on all the questions to see how good it is. Also so he can detect others using it. It’s a game changer and a really great tool. If it helps people learn then surely that must be a positive.
- DeWilde 4y agoIf a technology can make an educational method obsolete maybe it is time to rethink the educational method? And if students can use a technology like ChatGPT to complete their education, are they not then prepared for real life tasks and situations that they can also complete using ChatGPT?
- cptcobalt 4y agoChatGPT is just like a calculator. We should allow it, but you should be able to prove you still know the material. This is where things like written exams still win (but not everything has to be a written exam). My takeaway from this is: good riddance, just fix the way we teach students instead. The most painful part of school for me was the real awareness that not every question is valid, and most often the throwaway work given to you (vs. that of, say, exams) was most often the most junk & inane work you could do. (NB: I've got ADHD, and for me that worked out to always underperforming and missing homework but doing great on exams.) How can the state of education reinvent itself to embrace ChatGPT, computer science, and yes, even calculators—teachers need to stop plugging their ears and pretending these good tools don't exist.
- andrewallbright 4y agoSomething I've realized after using chatGPT since the preview released is that I am still responsible for knowing what the possibility space is for what I want to do. This helps in two ways. First, it helps me formulate my requests of ChatGPT. Second, it helps me discover incorrect output which I can then either fix myself or make a subsequent request of chatGPT. I consider ChatGPT an extremely eager junior dev who makes mistakes by moving too quick in this slice of time. (Im sure it'll get much better very, very soon).
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- photochemsyn 4y agoThe cheating cycle in academics is kind of interesting. A few years ago when getting into programming I took an assembly language course, basically a feeder program at a community college for students transferring to 4-year CS programs. The final project was some ridiculously complicated program written in MIPS assembly with lots of functions and custom system calls, that you were supposed to debug and add to. Hand-editing saved registers on the stack and so on. I didn't care at all about the grade, as I was just there to learn the material (and was irritated about learning MIPS instead of something useful like RISC-V), but I tried working through it for a while, an incredibly tedious exercise. Then I talked to a few other students, and literally every single one got the code off some online site. It was auto-graded via online submission, so they got their good grade and moved on. Imagine a few iterations of this: the teachers are thinking "yup, the students all get it, we can even make the problems harder to get a better distribution of grades", and the students keep finding better ways to avoid having to spend 20 hours working through a complicated tangled mess of code. Are the students learning anything of value? Sure, they're learning how to play the system for their own benefit. They're learning that the appearance of being intelligent and successful is more important than the reality (see Sam Bankman-Fried, for example) when you're stuck inside a corrupt system. This of course explains the coding interview in the software industry: everyone knows this is how the current educational system works, so looking at grades, recommendations, accolades etc. is a waste of time. Instead they say, "Here's a problem, solve it in real-time using just the skills you've actually learned and the knowledge you've actually memorized." ChatGPT might make it a little worse than it already is, when it comes to ranking students from excellent to mediocre - but it's just a cheaper version of the private tutors that so many students utilize. It might even level the playing field somewhat, as tutors are expensive. Ultimately, the only real solution, assuming grading is important, is to proctor the students during real-time tests, with all their devices locked away. This makes work much harder for the teachers, particularly with large class sizes, as auto-grading based on online submission of work is so much easier.
- anonymousDan 4y agoTo be honest I think it will make my life a lot easier. Online tests during covid were a joke, cheating was rampant. I will completely dispense with basic coursework that contributes to the final grade (probably converting it to formative assessments), and then rely on some combination of the in person exam and more complex coursework.
- easylogin 4y agoMy take is that it's another tool such as a search engine. Usually we have things such as citations pointing to where data came from as data sourcing is part of the activities included in homework. Additionally, we often test "offline" with constraints such as no calculator, open book, or closed book with notes, etc. So more regular knowledge checks seem to be a must if we're looking to verify foundational understandings.
- out_of_protocol 4y ago> cheating Check this gallery out: https://www.reddit.com/gallery/zju817 https://www.reddit.com/gallery/zju817 "Solve x = x ^ 2" and a lot of different answers, most of them looks valid (with explanation!) but not correct
- beej71 4y agoI've always felt the real trick was to make students not want to cheat. Or, put another way, convince them to want to learn. You can't convince them all, but the honest students HATE the heavy-handed anti-cheating mechanisms schools are putting in place. They interfere with learning. Cater to the honest ones, and try, though various means, to convince everyone to not want to cheat. That $80,000 piece of paper isn't worth jack if you can't pass an interview. There are plenty of ways to cheat your way through school--and being able to get answers off the Internet is nothing new. Frankly, preventing plagiarism in CS has been pretty much a lost battle for years.
- jabthedang 4y ago[dead]
- knaik94 4y agoHaving to push the entire class to learn instead of just the self motivated is a bureaucratic decision. Everyone is paying 80,000$ to be there, it would be problematic for many reasons to ignore those that seem uninterested. For pre-college education, minimum student performance is usually the strongest metric tied to funding. I don't think the current schooling system is set to let everyone find things they will care about learning and not cheating in. It's not realistic to expect no one to want to cheat. Even the brightest student can feel insecure enough in their ability, feel pressured to cheat if they believe those around them will cheat, or just want to get that little bit more ahead of the competition. Cheating is not strictly tied to honesty.
- beej71 4y agoI could have worded that better--I'm not proposing to ignore anyone. The goal should be to make the disinterested/cheaters want to learn instead.
- jabthedang 4y ago
- fab13n 4y agoif your test can't tell a smart student apart from a dumb algorithm, the broken part is your test.
- ddmma 4y agoI could post my assignments in 5 minutes solving my math homework but I didn’t so is always a choice. If you could learn the way you can solve it might be an asset then it’s dependent on the final exam and also your understanding of the problems. Sorry but you will not be able to compensate the personal critical thinking with external knowledge systems whatsoever
- paulpauper 4y agoIt's always students who are blamed for cheating or laziness, but never the administrators, teachers, etc. for failing to create sufficiently engaging work or curriculum that students do not feel compelled to cheat in the first place. Yes, some cheating is always inevitable ,and it's unfair to kids who do not cheat, but why it the framing always one-way. It's like productivity, automation, and collaboration is valued in corporate America, but it's the opposite in school.
- knaik94 4y agoI don't know how many teachers or administrators will say it outright, but LLMs and ChatGPT assisted essays are a lot more difficult to detect. ChatGPT is accurate enough to answer many typical reading comprehension questions at a high school+ level. Students will always feel some incentive to cheat, even if they wouldn't in isolation, they could feel pressured based on their peers. A strong curriculum isn't enough to encourage every single student not to take shortcuts. Despite all external circumstances, it's still an active choice to cheat. Cheating is framed one-way because it's generally discussed imagining the laziest and most adversarial student possible, similar to how you'd red team for security testing. I think the concern is things like ChatGPT will lead to a lot more students cheating. I think it's human nature to want to take shortcuts. I agree with you that the way in which cheating is demonized in a school environment is counterproductive in the long run. I think admin and teachers have hid behind students' fear of academic integrity violations being reported on a college application to not have to admit that most are terrible at catching cheaters. It's from the perspective of imagining ignorant teachers and adversarial students. Most minor cases of cheating aren't caught, even at a college level.
- neatze 4y agoWonder if it is possible to use fiverr to cheat ? (seems like it, I would be very surprised if it is not used for many years, already)
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- ipsum2 4y agoBut chatGPT can't connect to the internet, it said so itself. Sorry, couldn't resist pointing out this garden path title.
- spike021 4y agoI mentioned this on twitter a week or two ago, but in a lot of ways ChatGPT really reminds me of being in college about 10-15 years ago and using Wolfram Alpha a lot. It wasn't difficult back then to put in some challenging math problems or historical questions and get back results I could reference in notes for things. It's a concern but I feel like it's also just inevitable. There will always be resources that can be used for cheating. Hopefully students just learn to use these things as a resource rather than a shortcut.
- jeffrallen 4y agoI asked ChatGPT to tell me of examples were more likely from a large language model or for a student. It failed miserably on the job. Like I asked it to write a short paragraph on Shakespeare and then asked it to determine if the paragraph came from it. It said that the paragraph (that it generated 3 prompts before) was written by a student!
- rlt 4y agoBetween the COVID learning gap and this transitory period when education has to adapt to AI cheating, there's going to be a few rough years of kids falling behind.
- Julesman 4y ago100% not worried. There are some real short-term issues. Teachers who don't know anything about it. Students who think the teacher won't notice that their illiterate self got smart over the weekend. Legislators using it as a political football. But ultimately before long text AI will be good enough to fool anyone. And you will be able to feed it your style and it will spit out text appropriate for your grade level, just good enough for the A. And cheating will happen. Pandora's box is not going to be closed. Does that spell universal illiteracy and the end of higher learning? lol. Nah. Testing will certainly have to be creative. Just off the top of my head. Have every student write one paragraph during a whole period and make it as good as they can. That creates a baseline. And, you could actually use an AI (or not) to measure future results against it and map growth. We will figure this out and AI, at least for a time, will be a good thing. Quantum Computer AI that can predict the future... not quite as excited about that one. heh.
- russdill 4y agoI remember the hard part of the GREs for me was the essay section. Especially since in all my education, writing something short and concise being graded primarily on the prose and not the content was something that really didn't come up much in my education. Essays were something you did at home. It does seem like take home essays will be less and less of a thing going forward.
- ulrashida 4y agoWhat happens when those students are then called upon to apply that knowledge? Are they locked into AI-assisted answers forevermore, or do they succumb to a hint of "well I got an A in school on this" and start believing they actually understand the material?
- periheli0n 4y agoComputer science, and academia in general, has always adapted to technical progress, although slowly. In the case of ChatGPT and similar LLMs, these should become part of the toolbox that students are being taught. I.e., how does it work, what can it do, what are its limits, how can it be used to help solve a problem or complete a task. An exam question could then be e.g. to ask ChatGPT for an essay on a topic, critically discuss its shortcomings, and improve the essay e.g. by adding references and deeper discussion, which will be graded. Alternatively, use ChatGPT to iteratively discuss and improve the essay. The whole chat transcript should be included and will be graded.
- ckemere 4y agoPlus one to this. The reason we make students read and write is to teach them what good communication is. ChatGPT currently produces (and likely will continue to produce for a while) mediocre prose. How do I know that? Because I've read good prose and I've attempted to write it and understand the editing process. At some level it represents a huge pedagogical opportunity. (Grading IS moderately harder, but not that much.)
- russdill 4y agoChatGPT is just another mile marker that we are whizzing past.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- 908B64B197 4y agoThe slide rule didn't render arithmetic obsolete. Neither did the calculator. Being able to do math on paper is a side effect of understanding the base 10 representation of number most of the world has settled on. And the first thing someone in college for EE does is re-learn this arithmetic in base 2. The calculator is just an extra tool to get to numerical results faster. ChatGPT is an extra tool as well. Smart students will realize they have an extra tool to get an upper edge when competing in the zero-sum game they've been thrown in. They'll have ChatGPT generate the essay from an outline they wrote and will then trim and re-formulate as needed, spending most time fact checking and reading from source material to make sure ChatGPT isn't making stuff up (what will get some of their classmates caught).
- imdsm 4y agoThe problem is education, not ChatGPT. Education needs to evolve, and so far, ChatGPT has been fantastic as an educational device. Compare to my experience studying for a year at Open University where the tutors were unresponsive, unhelpful, and often, unavailable, ChatGPT will (and should) replace them.
- ModernMech 4y agoIt’s much harder to fake the provenance of an assignment than just the final result. This is why I now put all assignments under version control, and ask my students to commit their work as they go. I’m thinking if these AI assistants get much more popular, I might even ask my students to do their assignments in a keylogging editor.
- anonymousDan 4y agoNice idea regarding version control.
- vans554 4y agoPeople still go to traditional-school?
- ukFxqnLa2sBSBf6 4y agowhat do you think?
- codeproject 4y agoI don't know if anyone noticed this; the name of chief product officer of TurnItIn is Annie Chechitells. If i were in her position, I would change my name to Check-it-All. that would sound more professional.
- softwaredoug 4y agoI’m the late 90s it was common to write programs to help you cheat at Physics exams. Might be horribly counter productive to actually learning the content. Well anyone who is a software engineer would probably see it wasn’t. By writing and endlessly debugging a program to solve physics problems, you ended up mastering the material. I’m not sure whether physics teachers turned a blind eye to this “cheating” I’m imagining a similar “lengthy” chat interaction with ChatGPT to craft the perfect essay. Reading it, asking for edits, and tweaking it and so on. Maybe this is the optimistic take, but it could be students actually use it to produce, study, create, and “internalize” deeper arguments.
- yrgulation 4y ago
- shagie 4y agoBy itself, the essay that is written isn't the goal. One doesn't make students write essays just for the sake of writing essays. Instead, essays are intended as a measure of three other skills - the ability to write, the ability to synthesize knowledge, and lastly, the general structure of the knowledge. The ability to write - and write clearly - is an important skill that if one reads Reddit posts or Stack Overflow questions enough you can see where it is lacking. It is important to write in a way that provides the information to other humans. Using correct grammar, complete sentences, and proper vocabulary. Likewise, writing up a bug report isn't something that you can ask GPT to do for you. I will rail about poorly written Jira titles and descriptions that fail to have the necessary information presented clearly... and comments that aren't helpful either. I've been given a set of products and instructed to write up a comparison grid for how well I expect the product to be able to fulfill a certain requirement. This is done by going out and reading the product specifications and features, and a few customer issues to see what problems people have with them. The difference between that and the world history question back in high school on "compare and contrast the political structure of two countries on opposite sides of WWII" and needing to go into the library and look up information beyond what the history book had in it is not that significant; rather its the same set of skills. And finally, the general structure of the knowledge from high school. Understanding the international political tensions that are in the news is something that has its foundations in world history class. What was the Great Game? When did India get its independence? What happened with the collapse of the Soviet Union (that was actually current events rather than history at the time)? How did yellow journalism impact the Spanish American war, and what parallels does that have in today's media? Being ignorant of the past 200 years of American (or whatever nation you are reading this from ... and for that matter, the history of civilization going back another few thousand years) leads to a myopic and self centered view of the world today. The lack of this understanding is in turn leading to an increase in nationalism and the increased strife that that brings. So yes, cheating on high school world history with GPT is a problem. Beyond not learning how to put one's own thoughts to text it is also missing out on all of the practice of the process of learning and the background information for the world that we live in.