11 ms·
Apple changed how reading books works in iOS 16
- anonymous344 4y agothis is how it works and what matters to apple is huge $ nothing else. 1. people like apple 2. they use it 3. they become part of an apple cult 4. apple makes products worse and worse yet more expensive 5. the zombies still uses and pays, small% will complain, rest not even that ...for example, apple mouse is the worst product on the market. But nooo.. apple zombies won't even think of using anything else ....does the iphone video/cam recorder even in the 2022 have a pause button? i remember it did not have it in 2020 yet in all other phones had it 10 years because you need it
- vr46 4y agoApple devices are nowhere near as playful and fun as they used to be. Source, just had to drag out and tidy my accidental collection of Macs and iPhones including my Mac classic and Powerbook 180 from the 1990s, a Titanium G4, a Powermac 8100, and there's definitely real fun, not just nostalgia, missing from the modern era.
- quitit 4y agoiOS 6 on iPad is charming to use. I get that people were tired of skeuomorphism and the bright candy colours sell, but I think the muted colours and texture helped with long term use - making it functionally better.
- crazygringo 4y agoTrue, but honestly I don't really miss it either. Yes, interfaces used to be whiz-bang, lickable-glossy, mega-3D, skeumorphism etc. But after the initial "wow" wears off, it's all just kind of... busy and distracting. It took me a while to warm up to "flat design", but now I can't ever see myself (or the industry) going back. By allowing the interface to recede, you allow the content to shine. Generally you want to focus on the document, the photo, the text, the movie -- not the controls around it.
- a4isms 4y agoI have mixed feelings about this, I definitely miss some of the playfulness of years long gone. But a simile comes to mind: The whizz-bang interfaces were like illuminated manuscripts. Beautiful. Works of art. Literal human artistic treasures. But when I’m reading an email, I do not need dragons curled around drop caps.
- thrill 4y ago"But when I’m reading an email, I do not need dragons curled around drop caps." I might actually bother to read such an email.
- a4isms 4y agoNow all we need is a Markdown dialect supporting illumination.
- JasonFruit 4y agoI would pay for that feature. With AI scanning the paragraph text, we might even be able to get relevant illumination images generated on the fly. I want this now, whereas five minutes ago I had never thought of it.
- vbezhenar 4y agoThat's not how human works. We love non-functional things around us. I doubt that you live in a white cube. Our minds are pretty good at focusing on important stuff. We don't need white margins for that. We can focus on important stuff even with non-white margins. And those non-white margins might actually bring some joy when you can't focus anymore, because brain focus is finite. There's no way for industry not going back. It'll go back. It always did. We move in spiral. We just need to completely forget how good skeuomorphic interfaces were, so companies will sell those again. Probably executed much better.
- surfpel 4y ago> That's not how human works. Then I must be GPT model because those non-functional things are way too distracting. Jokes aside, I hated the page animation. It was amusing for the first minute but it felt weird to interact with it. Sticky is the only word that comes to mind, but not quite that. Glad it's gone.
- draw_down 4y agoFor better or worse, whimsy and playfulness are majorly out in terms of design these days. I thought the page curl was a nicely done bit of frippery in an app that is really a pain to use. for me I’m afraid are many worse things about the app than removing that animation. Search is bad, no way to open more than one book at once, the list goes on.
- wkdneidbwf 4y agoreading books on something without an e-ink display is goofy in the first place.
- pasc1878 4y agoNo I read on my iPhone which I keep in my pocket - I have that with me and don't need to carry a larger thing in a bag. But I don't use Apple's Books it just feels wrong - I used Stanza and when Amazon broke it I switched to Marvin I do use ereaders and if I travel for some time I'll use it..
- drclau 4y agoI remember the time when it was "reading books on something without paper and ink is goofy in the first place". :) I gave up on e-ink readers a few years ago and donated a couple of them. I am reading books in eletronic format on iPhones. It's just more practical, I don't need to carry a second and usually larger device with me, and ... I don't need an external light when it's too dark to read. Plus, the newer iPhones with OLED displays are pretty good for reading.
- rootusrootus 4y agoTotally agree. The ability to read on my phone has been such a boon. My close up vision has degraded to the point where I need readers for a paperback, but readers make me ill. The OLED screen on the phone means I can read in the dark without lighting up the room, which is handy since I often read in the middle of the night if insomnia wakes me up.
- yamtaddle 4y agoDisagree specifically for the case of pre-16 Apple Books. The ability to fiddle with page corners, half-flip pages then flip them back, that kind of thing, made it much more like reading a real book, and it was my favorite way to read ebooks, followed at a distance by e-ink readers, and then, very distantly, by every other non-e-ink way to read ebooks that wasn't Apple Books. Not joking that the page flip animation was the thing that made the Apple version far and away my favorite way to read ebooks. The new animation doesn't just lose that quality, it's also notably bad even among the all-some-degree-of-bad animations of reader apps in general (not counting pre-16 Apple Books).
- voisin 4y agoGetting rid of the ability to export highlights has been insanely frustrating and has meant I can only use this app for reading fiction that I don’t generally highlight.
- mercacona 4y agoI replaced Books with Yomu to keep my annotations and highlights.
- quitit 4y agoWith Apple: complain loudly and make a case, there are countless examples of that working, including on massive initiatives. Despite their shortcomings they do indeed read everything sent to /feedback
- dmitriid 4y agoWhy do you need loud complaints and writing feedback when this doesn't even pass common sense? See https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34030839 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34030839
- goosedragons 4y agoIt was kinda fun in 2010 for a few minutes I guess. But it certainly isn't something worth chaining your book purchases to Apple products for. If you REALLY want this though at least Moon+ Reader on Android has it, both one mimicking Google's and Apple's!
- astkaasa 4y agoOr koreader, both of them have much better formatting than Apple's and can be tweaked freely.
- xenonite 4y agoSo why is the page flipping animation missing in iOS16? My blind guess: due to the rewrite of the iBooks app in Swift, they did not find a swift way to take over the performance critical code in Objective C for the page flipping animation.
- nicoburns 4y agoYeah, it may well be they're using SwiftUI, which doesn't give them that control at all.
- pixel_tracing 4y agoNot really you can port or bridge that code over.
- cellularmitosis 4y agoYou may already be aware of this, but it is very easy to mix Swift and ObjC in the same codebase. There’s nothing technical stopping them from plucking the ObjC page-turning transition into the Swift app.
- admax88qqq 4y agoSwift and Objc? Sure. Swiftui and uikit? Not as easy. Is it technically possible? Yes. is it easy? Maybe not.
- sebastien_b 4y agoWhich seems to imply that Apple, which counts 1000+ engineers[1], and spent $5B+ on a “spaceship” campus[2], is just “lazy”. 1 https://www.apple.com/newsroom/2020/06/apple-reveals-lineup-for-its-biggest-ever-worldwide-developers-conference/ https://www.apple.com/newsroom/2020/06/apple-reveals-lineup-... 2 https://www.weetas.com/article/apple-spaceship/ https://www.weetas.com/article/apple-spaceship/
- admax88qqq 4y ago
- Archipelagia 4y ago> E-reader fans might say that I should be doing my reading on a dedicated device that’s not as subject to ever-changing software Oh boy, if you think dedicated devices don't have the same problem of frustrating updates, then I got some bad news for you. I still remember how annoyed I was when Kindle update added recommendations (=ads) on my home menu.
- torben-friis 4y agoDoes that also show up in the ads free version? I’m looking at getting a kindle and that might be a deal breaker to me, I’ll have to look at alternatives
- mrweasel 4y agoThis might be a result of my Kindle being old, it's the 2012 model. It doesn't have ads. I am concerned that it might break, because none of the newer Kindle work like the old one. It has button, a non-touch display and isn't backlit, all things I consider must have feature, or non-features. Personally I don't understand why they didn't just stop development at that point and just lowered prices as the components became less and less expensive.
- 43920 4y agoNot defending the first two (physical page turn buttons are great!) but on my 2018 paperwhite, the backlight will turn off entirely at the lowest brightness setting.
- WalterBright 4y agoSounds like the Kindle Keyboard. I bought an extra one just because the Kindles all went downhill after that one.
- urtrs 4y agoYes. The home menu is filled with "recommendations". Most read, trending, new releases...
- rchaud 4y agoTLDR: new iOS Books app removes the "page turn" animation from older generations. It is now a simple "slide" transition.
- pimlottc 4y agoIt's not a simple slide transition, it is some sort of odd slide-out-and-reveal-slide-in-underneath animation that has no analogue to any existing reading experience. A plain sliding transition (like reading a physical scroll) would be an improvement over what they did.
- viburnum 4y agoI can't figure out how to get the controls to recede so that the app only shows the book text.
- BadThink6655321 4y agoThey also "broke" the ability to set/remove a bookmark by double-tapping the page. The more Books degrades to become like Kindle, the less incentive I have to buy books from the Apple store.
- xemoka 4y agoThat’s weird, I have the exact opposite issue, I’m constantly triggering the bookmark via double-tap where in iOS 15 it was never an issue.
- rootusrootus 4y agoAgreed, this is my problem too. By the time I'm finished with a novel I have hundreds of pointless bookmarks.
- g42gregory 4y agoI highly recommend not to tie your personal happiness to a particular UI/UX choice, in a single App, from a technology provider who does not know you and does not care about you as a person, on a device that you probably shouldn’t spend much time on anyway. Instead, I think it’s more productive to diligently look for alternatives.
- markeibes 4y agoHow are you supposed to actively tie your happiness to something?
- pimlottc 4y agoThat's... bizarre. They didn't make the animation non-skeuomorphic, they just switched to a different and very weird skeuomorphism that has nothing to do with how actual books work. It's worse than if they had just made it completely flat.
- ksec 4y ago> They didn't make the animation non-skeuomorphic,.......that has nothing to do with how actual books work. Then it is non-skeuomorphic. And they have been removing it bit by bit since they kicked out Scott Forstall.
- Apocryphon 4y agoOne wonders if Forstall would be the Jobs type figure to return to on the back of a white horse aquihire should Apple ever fall into dire straits again. I don’t think he’s actually working anywhere that could be bought, though.
- pimlottc 4y agoIt’s not skeuomorphic to books but it does replicate (sort of) what it might look like if a book were printed out a stack on index cards. The shading and the motion is definitely meant to make it feel like a physical object moving.
- itake 4y agoIsn’t that exactly how most modern websites are designed? Like look at Google’s Material design. UIs are basically cards sliding around the screen.
- masklinn 4y ago> it does replicate (sort of) what it might look like if a book were printed out a stack on index cards. Except with a stack of cards (or pages) the bottom page would not be moving. The visual is more reminiscent of some sort of assembly / processing line.
- 4y ago
- _aavaa_ 4y agoAm I crazy for thinking that the scroll view is significantly better than the paginated view, regardless of the animation used?
- n42 4y agoI find I switch depending on the type of book. Technical books I prefer scrolling and fiction I prefer page flip
- _aavaa_ 4y agoI actually prefer it the other way around myself. I find pdf that technical books to be better since the equation typesetting, and any other similar things, can be done with a single page size and font in mind. I find that really suffers from trying to reflow when you change the eBooks font size.
- odysseus 4y agoScroll view is way better, it’s how you do most of your other reading on the phone. The old page flip animation was always distracting to me. I haven’t used the new one.
- filoeleven 4y agoI was surprised to see how many people are using the paged view too! Scrolling with dark mode is the only way I read ebooks. Works well in any indoor lighting, and it’s great for reading in bed too.
- rootusrootus 4y agoI didn't even realize they had a paginated view, I haven't used that (on Apple Books or Kindle either one) in forever. Scroll view is much better. My only complaint with the iOS 16 version of Books is that it's way, way too easy to double tap a bookmark into existence. I've gotten good at ignoring it. Kinda like it's too easy to create a section of highlighted text on the Kindle app. Both of these are probably just a case of 'holding it wrong' but whatever.
- Tempest1981 4y ago
- ricardobeat 4y agoHoly. The way the title remains “suspended” over the animation is horrendous. How does something like this come out of Apple’s design team?
- xattt 4y ago“Customer research shows that digital natives have low attention spans, so we introduced a persistent reminder of the title of the book they are reading in between page slides.” - Internal Apple design presentation /s
- yamtaddle 4y agoI will say, I'll read entire ebooks and by the end still have trouble recalling the title and author. Never a problem I've had with physical books.
- elliekelly 4y agoThis happens to me, too! If I read a physical book I can easily recall the author and the title months and even years later. But when I read digital books I often struggle to remember a book’s name and have to look it up if I want to recommend it to someone.
- yamtaddle 4y agoMy guess is it's mostly because the physical book's cover's always visible in your environment, even when you're not reading, so you see the title and author's name a lot more. Some e-readers put the cover on when in sleep mode, but that's small, black-n-white, only on one side (no spine) so it's easily covered up, et c. Books also often put some or all of that info at the top of every page or every other page, while many reader apps hide it most of the time, I suppose to save space for body text.
- rrrrrrrrrrrryan 4y agoOneAd free Kindles (can) display the cover of the book you're currently reading during idle mode. I love it because I used to leave a book on a coffee table or my desk as a kind of physical invitation to read (instead of watching TV or playing video games or derping on my phone). Such a tiny feature, but since I've turned it on it has nudged me to read hours more each week.
- donkeyboy 4y agoThis was my exact reaction when I upgraded to ios16. I spent 20 mins looking how to get the page turn animation back. Sad
- Twisell 4y agoI never got accustomed to reading book on my iPhone It never felt quite right despite (or maybe because of) the skeuomorphism attempt. Am I the only one thinking the new animation actually looks better? The page seem to quickly fade away with less distractions and might enable to focus more on the text flow. If anything knowing the interface evolved is actually encouraging me to give it another go.
- yamtaddle 4y agoThe old animation was a must-have for those of us who fiddle with edges of pages when reading physical books. Only method of ebook reading I've seen that satisfied that particular I-suspect-uncommon-but-not-rare book-reading behavior. Not the same as running a finger over the corner of the whole block of pages, but close enough.
- Twisell 4y agoHowever during the transition the text is sometimes obfuscated by a huge white space that doesn't exist on a real book that is indeed recto/verso printed. It's fun for fidgeting but I personally find it way more visually distracting than the new behavior.
- teeray 4y agoKindle added this animation style to their app, and I love using the app more because of it. It was one thing I lived about Apple’s eBooks that I didn’t get on Kindle (but the catalogue and other features made up for it).
- amelius 4y ago> and I may never be happy again This is what a monoculture gets us. We need more competition, and hardware to be open so we can get even more competition (also free competition).
- 33955985 4y agoI suspect we’ll see a return of the page turn animation before the next full release. It doesn’t make sense for them to leave such a basic feature behind, especially since iBooks is a front end to a revenue stream.
- dmitriid 4y ago> It doesn’t make sense for them to leave such a basic feature behind, especially since iBooks is a front end to a revenue stream. The basic features they butchered/implemented for the "front end to revenue stream": - jarring animation that cannot be turned off - scrolling is now relegated to a weird small control in settings that has no relation to the actual book you're reading - "lock orientation" locks orientation in portrait mode - accessing table of contents is now three taps - accessing font settings is now three taps - table of contents + scrolling + searchig + themes + scroll lock + bookmarks ... all of that is accessed through a tiny gray icon that is nearly indistinguishable from surrounding text. Also, this icon is unique, and has never been used anywhere in iOS or MacOS - closing a book is now a tiny gray x that is almost indistinguishable from the text All this passed design -> design approval -> engineering managers -> programmers -> qa -> launch check lists. By the way, when it launched in iOS 16, the close icon and the "kitchen sink" icon would always pe present, they only fixed it a month or two later. Yup. This is the state of a "frontend to the revenue stream". Done and approved by people who have never read a single book on iOS (and MacOS where it was also butchered), or perhaps have never read a single book in their life, period. Edit: their animation is also "least effort" attempt: they hide page numbers when animation, then it takes up to two seconds for them to reappear.
- gnicholas 4y ago> But it genuinely was a feature that made me choose to buy e-books on Apple’s platform instead of anyone else’s — and given how same-y most book stores and reading apps are in the broad strokes, it really is the details that get you locked into an ecosystem. Although I've used Macs for decades and iPhones since day one, I typically purchase ebooks on third-party platforms. If I buy an Android tablet, a non-Apple computer, or some other device that hasn't been invented yet, I don't want to be locked out of my prior purchases.
- passwordoops 4y agoOld man shakes fist at cloud rant Lord I wish we could go back to the days of pay a flat one time fee and own the dang software so I don't get "improvements" shoved down my throat Old man rant over
- vbezhenar 4y agoYou can stay on iOS 15. Nobody shoves iOS 16 down your throat. Apple even backports fixes for most dangerous vulnerabilities for quite some time. What you can't do is downgrade once you've found that you're not happy with upgrade. That's the most bizarre Apple thing. Unless you can jailbreak. Not sure if it works nowadays, back in days I was very happy to downgrade to iOS 6 with jailbreak on my iPhone 4S.
- dataflow 4y agoHow long do you think people will be able to stay on old versions of software like iOS 15? 5 years? 10 years? 30 years? Their lifetime?
- fsflover 4y agoThis is exactly why I avoid iPhones and prefer to support GNU/Linux on the phones. Such phones will have a lifetime support without anti-features.
- egb 4y agoNo, they forced iOS16 by only backporting security fixes for devices that can't run iOS16 https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2022/12/apple-releases-ios-15-security-updates-for-devices-that-cant-upgrade-to-16/ https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2022/12/apple-releases-ios-1...
- yftsui 4y agoNo, i think they are just messing up the devices force using iOS16 they think they can get away with. iPad Pro (2021) get iOS 15.7.2 update.
- marstall 4y agoyeah. this was disappointing. I hope to get used to it, but for the moment it really detracts from my very enjoyable little stolen dad moments here and there reading Ian McKuen on my phone at a bar. feels like I'm reading a xeroxed copy of a book.
- aSithLord 4y agoAs good as apple hardware devs are its software devs are the same in the other direction.
- sieabahlpark 4y ago
- c-fe 4y agoIn general I feel the books app got so much worse with the iOS 16 update that it is partly responsible for me selling my iPad to get a dedicated e-reader
- yftsui 4y agohonestly, i don’t think books app get better since iOS 12, it is always getting worse. Either starting in iOS14 or 15, if you have multiple devices and all use sort by most recent read, one or few device will lost that order once in a while and sort the library with a bizarre order and lots of old books with wrong reading progress.
- robin_reala 4y agoThe biggest problem with Apple Books (from a producer point of view) is that they removed the ability to connect dev tools to it. Up until the Catalyst rebuild you could open Safari dev tools, connect it to the Books instance, and use it to inspect CSS, highlight particular elements, and basically do anything you can in a browser. This might not sound like much, but Books is unfortunately laden with weird bugs that don’t exist in normal Safari. They managed to fix the one I reported about srcset not working for images (it just didn’t display anything) but flex / grid display with 100vh is completely broken, and there’s a bunch more minor things like broken page-break functionality. And the debugging cycle currently is to make changes, repackage the book, reload the book in Books, and hope for the best.
- gcanyon 4y agoOverall there are many more practical settings that are available in the new UI. I don't remember everything that wasn't in the previous version, but I don't remember things like line spacing, character spacing, and word spacing. Of course, new features don't have to come at the expense of existing features, especially not when we're comparing page turn animations to text rendering, but as people say, this could be part of a transition to swift, so it's expected that there would be trade-offs in re-implementing features. I'm thinking more people are positively impacted by things like text rendering than page turning.
- jasamer 4y agoThe page turn animation was truly excellent. I have seen a few other apps/sites try to copy it, some of them did it pretty well. But one detail I’ve never seen anyone else do: the text of the curled page is “distorted” in 3D, as one would expect of a real page. The closer the letters are to the part of the page that’s orthogonal to the screen, the more the are squished. It’s an effect that’s quite complicated to do. You need to put the page on a 3D cone and render that. I have quite a bit of experience with UI kit animations, but I don’t know how I would do that one.
- baxuz 4y agoThis was one of my favourite features of iBooks. :(
- Sunspark 4y agoI have one app that does it, it doesn't do the corner curl, but it does do the side curl with the reverse text showing on the other side. It uses OpenGL to do it and that is how you can do it.
- minusf 4y agomaybe i'm just unsophisticated but what exactly is the point of it? all this work for basically nothing. and we wonder why our apps are bloated and need ridiculously overpowered hw.
- Tempest1981 4y agoIt brings joy to many users. Not all, granted. The HW is already needed for games.
- Grustaf 4y agoIt's probably done on the GPU, requiring almost no power at all. As far as 3d graphics goes, it's very very simple.
- Groxx 4y agoYeah. Essentially no power and essentially no space was spent on that. It's barely more computationally complicated than sliding the page. There are lots of things to dislike about feature and size bloat, but this is among the worst possible examples.
- armatav 4y agoTerrible choice by Apple - o m g; you’re not kidding on the weird asymptote towards ugly-low-effort-minimal.
- nbzso 4y agoI am amazed at the progressive downfall of Apple over UX and UI in their products. Recently, I moved to downgrade my Mac Mini 2018 to Monterey over the horrible performance hit and overheating that I've got with Ventura. I don't understand how is this possible. Don't let me start about red colored "text" over dark background button. Grrrr.... Someone in Apple HQ must find the old HIG and make it mandatory.
- astrange 4y agoIf you're going to downgrade, file feedback first.
- rpastuszak 4y agoHa, selling this animation (implemented using ActionScript) more than once covered my rent during uni:)
- jlarocco 4y agoI'm not an Apple books user, but I find almost every skeuomorphic animation annoying and useless. Does the app have a way to turn those off? I strongly prefer the continuous scrolling mode from the Kindle. On further thought, any kind of UI animation bothers me. I don't need the computer to waste my time, I just want it to do what I told it.
- _xnmw 4y agoHuh, good to know I wasn't the only one that really enjoyed that animation. It made Apple Books so much more pleasant compare to any other ereader.
- ClassyJacket 4y agoThat's so sad. I used to play with that page turning animation back on my iPhone 4 just because it was so cool. I hate the era we're in now of changing software to be worse just so they can say they changed it. It's gotten to the point where any announcement of a software update gets an initial reflexive negative reaction from me, as these days they're more often steps backwards than improvements.
- kmfrk 4y agoI know no one at Apple uses iTunes on Windows, but surely these people read books? And yet the iBooks experience has been a disaster for years with little to no improvement.
- iggldiggl 4y ago> I know no one at Apple uses iTunes on Windows In some way currently I actually regard that as an advantage – iTunes might have its foibles, but the hard split between e.g. Music and Podcasts that happened on Mac definitively isn't something I'm looking forward to. That's because I've found the Podcasts section of iTunes actually quite useful for also managing my collection of radio comedy, e.g. to get the nice at-a-glance listened/unlistened episode display. With unified iTunes it's simply a matter of adding those files (which are only rarely native podcasts and usually have been scrounged together from all sorts of various sources) to my music library and then manually setting the media type to "Podcast", but on a Mac post-split-up that no longer works, and the successor Podcasts app apparently allows no manual file management. So I'd either have to manually hack the database, or more likely set up a fake local podcasts server, or just give up entirely and switch to something else (which might still mean having to set up a fake podcasts server anyway in order to sync the episodes to my phone). At least on Windows iTunes update and general compatibility aren't as directly tied to the OS itself as on Mac, so if push came to shove, I could just keep on using iTunes – the only slight annoyance would be if compatibility with the iTunes store would eventually break…
- muhehe 4y ago> But even if I were to buy a Kobo or Boox or something, that wouldn’t help me with the dozens of books I’ve already purchased on Apple’s platform THIS is the real problem. Books (or music, movie, whatever) tied to one specific platform, without any chance to migrate somewhere else - somewhere where is more comfortable/convenient for you.
- ArjenM 4y ago> "One thing that we have learned is that piracy is not a pricing issue. It's a service issue," Ownership of data should be included in service, but rarely is.
- maronato 4y agoYou can export a purchased book from Books on your Mac by dragging it out of the app https://discussions.apple.com/thread/7967098 https://discussions.apple.com/thread/7967098
- Kye 4y agoDoesn't work if you don't have a Mac.
- mwint 4y agoGo to an Apple Store and do it, or buy an old MacBook Air / Mac mini for ~nothing off eBay.
- ChuckNorris89 4y ago[Edited due to misunderstanding. Apologies.] Still, signing into public devices with your private credentials and data is a bad idea. What if they kick you out of the store or take away the device your were toying with before you manage to wipe/reset it?
- akerl_ 4y ago
- dmd 4y agoFYI, the animation can be turned off with the global "Reduce Motion" setting, which really makes iOS much more livable in general.
- mcculley 4y agoWhat annoys me is that there is more lag in the app. When opening the app just to get in some reading when I have some free time, there is a 1-2 second lag just to open a book that I have been reading. I am on an iPhone 11 Pro. Opening a book should be instantaneous. But it gets slower with each update.
- mensetmanusman 4y agoI still laugh when I use my toddlers iPad 1 which is now over a decade old. That iPad has a more responsive keyboard than my iPad Pro.
- MutableLambda 4y agoI agree. One of the reasons I chose iOS over Android around 2012 was because it worked really smooth, no stutters, everything is responsive. They are gradually removing it since iOS 7, the contact list was the first victim (you click on it, it displays, half a second after it updates, but you could have clicked a contact already and now you're calling the wrong person).
- WalterBright 4y agoOne reason I still use my old DOS editor (recompiled for modern machines) is it loads instantly. And I mean instantly.
- rickreynoldssf 4y agoDidn't the person who thought that was a good idea have something better to do? Is it time for a good old fashion layoff in Apple's design team?
- 4qz 4y agoThis is a good change but it doesn’t go far enough. Infinite scroll is obviously the best way to read long form content. Unfortunately, most book sales are by people who like the idea of reading books more than actually reading
- zerocrates 4y agoYou think? I tend to find I get "lost" more easily in a big scrolling document, particularly if I'm coming back to it several times before finishing, as would usually be the case with a book. In the case of e-ink e-readers you also face the issue that their screen updating tech is really better suited to full page replacements then line- or pixel-level scroll, though of course that doesn't apply to Apple's devices.
- rootusrootus 4y ago"Obviously the best way" is probably too strong, though for me I do much prefer scroll mode for reading novels. And I like reading on my phone, because then I can read a few pages anywhere I want.
- ilyt 4y agoSeems like designers at Apple need to find excuse for their employment again and started fucking with perfectly functional things...
- meindnoch 4y agoI still remember when the Music app had a landscape mode with Cover Flow... :'(
- ncann 4y agoSome comparisons with other apps: - Google Play Books: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gOJ15ysPsRo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gOJ15ysPsRo - eReader Prestigio: https://youtu.be/YdNCElSHJbE?t=79 https://youtu.be/YdNCElSHJbE?t=79
- ChadNauseam 4y agoPlay Books is Google’s most underrated product. I live in fear that they’ll sunset it.
- samirsd 4y agoYea I felt the same way and cried internally for a bit and then forgot about it. I appreciate someone writing about it. I really hope they bring it back. I don't think the redesign really brought about any improvements... just change for the sake of change.
- theferalrobot 4y agoWeird, I am on iOS 16 on both my iphone and ipad and i still have the swipe animation for books. Apple doesn't really do much A/B testing so this really kinda surprises me. Edit: Think I figured it out - looks like PDFs still have the page turn animation on iOS but epubs are using the new animation
- null_object 4y agoAw come on. I get the HN thirst to knock Apple about absolutely everything, but the page turn animation is utter bullshit. When I’m reading a real book I don’t see some absurd ‘scrolling over page turn’ - I just turn the page. It’s over in the blink of an eye, and isn’t some “joyful” imaginative experience, at all.
- waboremo 4y agoVast majority of animations are done in the blink of an eye. When done well, you barely notice them, it just feels good. When done poorly (most new page turning animations), it becomes noticeably odd and that's one of the worst qualities for an animation to have.
- masklinn 4y agoNope, sorry, you're wrong. The page turning animation was delightful. If you didn't care for it, you could ignore it, it was fast. But it showed that the designers of iBooks had cared about it being an experience of reading books. The new animation is just... weird. It's not an actual thing and makes no sense. It doesn't even look like you're yeeting the top page out of the pile since the bottom one moves.
- aeturnum 4y agoLike you, I could not care less about the page turning animation. As long as I see the next page it's fine with me. The thing that prompts me to comment is that this feels like yet another place where the "artfulness" of software is getting optimized out of things. Whatever any of us thinks of the animation, it was clearly the result of clever work by the team putting out the app. The two ways of turning the page give a different feel and have a different character. I think how apps feel - and the engineering behind making them feel a certain way - often does not get its due. I think we, as an industry, should do more to celebrate people doing things "the hard way" because it's nice - and not dismiss it as "absurd."
- fearthetelomere 4y agoIt may seem trivial, but I assure you it's valid criticism. FWIW, I've stopped using the Books app on my Ipad in favor of emailing my ebooks to my Kindle account and reading it through the Kindle app. Why couldn't they have an option to keep the old animation? In 2022, it should be that simple, but of course... It's not that I loved the old animation, but rather that I can't stand the current one. It's like I'm rotating a deck of cards, taking one off the top of the pile and putting it underneath. Not very pleasant to me, and also not an animation style I've seen used in any other book apps to my knowledge. I wonder why that is?
- joeman1000 4y agoI’m normally sentimental about things, but I couldn’t care less about this one. They’ve updated other features in the app (after about ten years…) and this kitschy little bastard had to go. It was cool when I first saw it on my iPhone 4…
- hilyen 4y agoRather them work on natural reading of the books with Text To Speech. People with disabilities such as Dyslexia, ADHD, partial or total Blindness have to hobble on with the terrible TTS available. You have to select the text to get it to read, which means you will have to do that each page. A simple play & stop button for "read aloud" would solve this. They love to think about use cases to make things easier for their users, but have they hired disabled people to give comment? This has been a glaring issue to me, and I've told Apple, but nothing ever comes of it. Cool animation though .
- evan_ 4y agoI wonder if that’s a compromise with the publishing house, who would prefer people buy audiobooks if they want to listen to the book being read.
- bentley 4y agoIn the past the Authors Guild threatened to sue Amazon over providing text to speech in the Kindle. https://www.theguardian.com/technology/blog/2009/mar/01/authors-guild-blocks-kindle-voice https://www.theguardian.com/technology/blog/2009/mar/01/auth... Not to be confused with the time the publishers sued Amazon over providing speech to text in Audible. https://www.theguardian.com/books/2020/jan/15/audible-settles-copyright-lawsuit-publishers-captions https://www.theguardian.com/books/2020/jan/15/audible-settle...
- hilyen 4y agoOh Crazy. It is so frustrating, for people with ADHD, in order to have our brains stimulated enough to keep focus, we have to read and hear it at the same time, so our option is to buy it twice.
- comex 4y agoHuh. I always _hated_ that page turning animation, because it obscured the content and made it difficult to quickly swipe back and forth. It was also slow, interrupting my reading flow. When I'm reading something exciting, I always start reading at a fast pace, and the interruption in reading while I turn each page feels like a video constantly stopping to buffer. Both of these factors apply to physical books to some extent, but much less so – mainly because you can fit much more text on a book page than on a phone screen, and also because you can turn a physical page quite fast. Slow page turns are also the reason I don't like ePaper readers. In that case it's not an animation slowing things down, but the ePaper refresh time. Anyway, this is why I used to use the iOS Kindle app instead of Apple Books (née iBooks) – because the Kindle app uses a simple horizontal sliding animation (similar to Libby in the article) that is faster and doesn't obscure content. However, Apple Books eventually added a mode that removes pages altogether in favor of a continuous vertical scroll, which I now use. I just briefly tried Apple Books' new page turning animation, and I definitely prefer it, though it's still a bit slow and I still prefer the vertical scroll. Perhaps the change was made with users like me in mind. Which is not to say I'm happy with the old animation being taken away from users who liked it! I appreciate that my sensitivity to interruptions is idiosyncratic, and the old animation certainly had superior aesthetics. Ideally it would be a setting.
- __david__ 4y agoI also hate page turning animations. Maybe it's my dumb brain but it's super distracting and I never could learn to ignore it. I finally found an e-reader app that let me disable all animations and just immediately cuts to the new page. When I'm reading and I hit the end of the page, by the time my eye has moved back to the top of the screen the new page is there and if I time my tap correctly I don't even see the page change. It's the only way for me to read now.
- gigglesupstairs 4y agoYou can also use “Reduce Motion” setting in iOS to reduce motion and excessive animations across iOS including reader app.
- 4y ago
- the-printer 4y agoAs a vertical scroller I am indifferent to this decision. What matters to be is what Yomu and GoodLinks offer: changing the line height and exporting highlights. The default leading in Apple Books is decent, but I switch fonts at a whim and many require adjustments. And nothing is more irritating than copying an excerpt from a book and having to remove the extra text about the title of the book, the book’s author and the copyright information. Plus the way Yomu exports highlights is really interesting.
- hitgeek 4y agothe page turn animation was probably the main reason i bought the original ipad. it was just so delightful. like some others, i miss the skeuomorphism of the original ios.
- indiantinker 4y agoApple is literally breaking all the things that work in the name of innovation and upgrade :(
- rgj 4y ago“I still feel like Apple’s destroyed one of the last ways that my phone brought joy into my life” Please tell me you were being sarcastic. I’m really afraid you’re not.
- Dylan16807 4y agoLots of people get no joy at all from their phones. And it's not bad to appreciate a small thing. So I think that sentiment is fine. It's not one of the last things the author liked, it's one of the last things they liked about their phone. It's very minor, but minor nice things were all the phone had going for it...
- sph 4y agoExactly. Optimising care and attention to detail out of product design because it's too expensive is one of the reason technology today is absolute crap anywhere you look. A decade ago I used to view Steve Jobs as an a designer that was a little too full of himself, today I see him as an extinct breed of people that had a vision and didn't compromise in the name of revenue and cutting corners. Many engineers and managers nowadays think good, opinionated and well-crafted product are a waste of time and money. Shipping early is the only metric that matters, and the various Tim Cooks in charge are a sign of the times.
- wackget 4y agoWhat's wrong with that sentence? Phones are generally pretty horrific in my experience. Dog-shit usability compared to a desktop computer, massive brain-draining time-sinking cheap dopamine-spiking apps which add virtually zero value to the world, 99% of which have no real reason of being an "app" in the first place. Phones are horrific.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- dylandesrosier 4y agoEven worse is the dark mode page turning brightens the display in the new animation. Reading before bed has been destroyed.
- mlindner 4y agoWow that new animation is horrendous.
- ambrose2 4y agoI loved Books ever since I first got an iPhone. Since the iOS 16 update, I’ve been unsatisfied, the UI isn’t as slick. I just started giving Yomu a try, here goes.
- extantproject 4y agohttps://archive.ph/4E43X https://archive.ph/4E43X
- 1shooner 4y agoI don't understand what kind of masochist wants to read books on an active display in the first place.
- twobitshifter 4y agoIt’s great on the iPad mini. I haven’t noticed any eye strain at all with it, is that what you think would be so bad? It seems overblown to me since most tech workers spend 8 hours behind an active display each day.
- 1shooner 4y ago>since most tech workers spend 8 hours behind an active display each day. Exactly. I try to get off active displays at least 2 hours before going to sleep, which is also when I like to read.
- masswerk 4y agoTurns out, skeuomorphism is fun. However, this totally ignores the fundamental principle of serious software being joyless.
- adolph 4y agoAmazing: 1. This is the person who buys books from iTunes. 2. Despite deploying their own words to a scroll, the last person buying books on iTunes laments losing a pointless* animation. * the animation doesn’t semantically enrich the reading experience since it lacks the feeling of the rest of the pages. It merely imitates the paper book experience that might be technically satisfying to see performed once, but is otherwise a perfect example of kitsch. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kitsch https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kitsch
- harerazer 4y agoAs someone who does most reading on an IPad, and was already somewhat reluctant to update: I'm never updating to iOS 16. This along with some other changes have convinced me totally (see, for example, some of the changes listed by dmitriid)
- rgovostes 4y agoIn continuous scroll mode, they removed a subtle progress indicator in the margin with a chunky slider control (exactly the same style as used for the volume in Control Center or a smart lightbulb in Home). It's almost comical. My only complaint with the previous version was that it was too easy for an errant swipe to create a highlight. This has been replaced by every other swipe being interpreted as a double tap, creating a bookmark on every single page.
- forgotpwd16 4y agoI'll have disabled this animation from the first moment. I find animations as this more of a distraction than something to enjoy let alone be useful.